Tunneling from an oscillating state in quantum mechanics
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Tunneling from an oscillating state in quantum mechanics".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We study the decay of general initial states out of a metastable potential well in quantum mechanics This paper provides a closed-form expression for the probability current that tunnels through the barrier in terms of the resonant states into which the initial state can be decomposed Specializing to a coherently-oscillating initial state, we derive an approximation to the time-dependent decay rate and demonstrate its accuracy by comparing it to a numerical solution of the Schr¨odinger equation.
Kai: Tunneling Mechanism and Resonant States The study focuses on tunneling from a metastable well separated from a true vacuum by a barrier The initial state is expanded in a basis of resonant states, which are defined by imposing outgoing boundary conditions to the right of the barrier, leading to complex energies where the Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian.
Mira: These resonant states satisfy Hψe n(x) = εnψn(x), where εn = En − iħΓn/2, and they are localized in the well with a lifetime of order 1/Γn.
Kai: The initial state is approximated as ψ(x) = X n cnψ n(x), where the coefficients cn are obtained by inverting the overlap matrix Smn ≡⟨ψmψn⟩.
Paper summary: Kai: To recap what we just covered, the paper by Janssen and Kleban and Norton sets out to find a way to calculate the tunneling probability current for any general initial state leaving a metastable well.
Mira: They claim they provide a closed-form expression for that probability current by using the resonant states into which the initial state can be decomposed.
Lev: The key step they take is defining those resonant states by imposing specific outgoing boundary conditions on the right side of the barrier, leading to complex energies where the Hamiltonian isn't Hermitian.
Kai: They then approximate the initial state itself by mixing it with these resonant states using coefficients obtained from inverting an overlap matrix Smn.
Mira: And for their focus, they specialize this to a coherently oscillating initial state, which lets them derive an approximation for the time-dependent decay rate.
Lev: Their verification involves comparing this derived rate approximation against a numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation to check its accuracy.
Kai: The paper confirms that when you use this method for a coherent initial state, the result is actually very accurate when compared to the simulation.
Mira: It’s really about showing how the ingredients in that closed-form formula are computed semiclassically, which they do by using WKB approximations.
Lev: They also discuss how tunneling happens in narrow bursts near the classical turning point when you look at a coherent initial state approximation for the current.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this discussion on "Tunneling from an oscillating state in quantum mechanics," it's about taking a general initial state and translating it into something we can calculate using those resonant states.
Mira: The authors provide that closed-form expression for the probability current that tunnels through the barrier, which is built entirely out of those resonant states.
Lev: What this means for us is that they've shown how to approximate the time-dependent decay rate specifically when you start with a coherently oscillating initial state.
Kai: It confirms the intuition that tunneling happens in narrow bursts near the classical turning point, which is something you see when you look at their numerical verification against the Schrödinger equation.
Mira: The authors also point out a limitation: this resonant-state expansion isn't complete because it leaves out contributions from a non-resonant continuum, especially for times smaller than one divided by omega.
Lev: Also, the WKB approximation for decay widths gets less accurate when the energy of the relevant resonances is close to the top of that barrier.
Kai: Overall, this work gives us a precise quantum-mechanical realization of how a particle in a well attempts to tunnel once per bounce off the barrier when it's oscillating.
Laboratory for Theoretical Fundamental Physics, EPFL · Center for Cosmology and Particle Physics, New York University
quant-ph, hep-th
Submitted: 2026-05-05
Updated: 2026-10-29
Comments: 29 pages + 3 appendices. v2: major revisions, including a generalization of the main result to oscillations of arbitrary amplitude in the well, a path integral derivation of the main result, and the discussion of small oscillations where a simple closed-form expression is found
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 95/100
The gist: We study the decay of general initial states out of a metastable potential well in quantum mechanics This paper provides a closed-form expression for the probability current that tunnels through the…
Key concepts
- Resonant States
- These are specific quantum states localized in the well that satisfy certain outgoing boundary conditions beyond a barrier. They have complex energies, $\epsilon_n = E_n - i\hbar\Gamma_n/2$, which indicate they have a finite lifetime of about $1/\Gamma_n$. The initial state is decomposed into these states to describe the tunneling process.
- Probability Current
- This quantity measures the flow of probability through space over time, calculated using the complex time-dependent wavefunction. For resonant states beyond the barrier, it shows how much probability current is carried by each state at a specific point $x_T$ to the right of the barrier.
- Semiclassical Approximations
- In this limit, complex energies are simplified using WKB approximations. The average leakage rate ($\Delta P$) is approximated as $\Gamma$, and for coherent states, the tunneling current near maximal tunneling can be approximated by an expression involving the second derivative of a function at the turning point.
- Coherent Dynamics
- This refers to the behavior of a state that is in a superposition of many resonant states. The paper shows that the step structure observed in tunneling probability arises entirely from phase coherence among these resonant states, meaning they tunnel together rather than independently.
Terminology
Summary
We study the decay of general initial states out of a metastable potential well in quantum mechanics This paper provides a closed-form expression for the probability current that tunnels through the barrier in terms of the resonant states into which the initial state can be decomposed Specializing to a coherently-oscillating initial state, we derive an approximation to the time-dependent decay rate and demonstrate its accuracy by comparing it to a numerical solution of the Schr¨odinger equation. p. 0 All ingredients in the equation are computed analytically to
first subleading order in the semiclassical limit. Specializing to a coherently-oscillating
initial state, we derive an approximation to the time-dependent decay rate and demonstrate its accuracy by comparing it to a numerical solution of the Schr¨odinger equation.Where the paper says it
Tunneling Mechanism and Resonant States
The study focuses on tunneling from a metastable well separated from a true vacuum by a barrier The initial state is expanded in a basis of resonant states, which are defined by imposing outgoing boundary conditions to the right of the barrier, leading to complex energies where the Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian. These resonant states satisfy Hψe n(x) = εnψn(x), where εn = En − iħΓn/2, and they are localized in the well with a lifetime of order 1/Γn. p. 3 The continuum of scattering states is replaced with a discrete spectrum of
resonant states with complex energies localized in the well. These states satisfy
Hψe n(x) = εnψn(x), εn = En − i
ℏΓn
2
, (1)
where He is the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian and Γn > 0. Since ⟨ψm|ψn⟩ ̸= 0 in
general for m ̸= n, the sum does not collapse and we instead define the overlap matrix
Smn ≡ ⟨ψm|ψn⟩. (5)
The coefficients are obtained by inverting this matrix,
cn =
X
m
(S
−1
)nm ⟨ψm|ψ⟩.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Time Evolution and Probability Current
The time evolution of the initial state under the complex Hamiltonian is given by ψ(x, t) = X n cnψ n(x) e−iEnt/ħ e−Γnt/2. The probability current associated with ψ(x, t) is j(x, t) = ħ m Im[ψ∗(x, t) ∂xψ(x, t)]. p. 5 2 Probability current
We now turn to the time dependence of the tunneling process. This can be obtained by computing
the probability current associated with ψ(x, t),
j(x, t) = ℏ
m
Im[ψ
∗
(x, t) ∂xψ(x, t)] . We can take the An
to be real by “normalizing” the ψn to be real at x = xT . With this convention, the probability
current carried by the nth resonant state at xT is
jn(xT , t) = A2
n
m
Re kn e
−Γnt
. Coherent state We now specialize to a coherent initial state and seek an approximation to
both the total probability that leaks out during one oscillation period and the time window over
which this leakage effectively occurs. In the semiclassical limit, Re kn ≈ |kn| and δn ∼ ℏΓn/En is
exponentially small, so we set
Re kn →
p
2mEn , δn → 0 , (23)
and neglect exponential decay factors for times |t| ≪ 1/Γ, with ¯ Γ the average decay rate given in ¯
(21).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Semiclassical Approximations and Coherent Dynamics
In the semiclassical limit, the complex energies are approximated by En = En − iħΓn/2, where Γn = 1/(gntn e−2Sn/ħ). The average probability that leaks out of the well per unit time is approximated as ∆P ≈ Γ = X n cn 2Γn. p. 6 (20)
These results are then used to approximate the probability current in Eq. At this stage, we can give a rather general expression for the average probability that leaks
out of the well per unit time:
∆P ≡
1
T
Z T
0
dt j(xT , t) ≈ Γ , Γ = X
n
|cn|
2Γn .Where the paper says it
Numerical Verification and Physical Interpretation
Numerical studies using a Complex Absorbing Potential (CAP) Hamiltonian confirm the validity of the resonant-state decomposition, showing that the formula in Eq. (18) can be approximated analytically in the semiclassical limit using WKB. p. 9 The main result we would like to verify numerically is Eq. (18), in particular that it can be
approximated analytically in the semiclassical limit using WKB as in §2. (42)
If we are able to neglect the S
′′
0
terms, we have
ω
p
2|f
′′
0
|
3
(n0)
3
|n1|
2
→ 1 . (43)
To summarize, in this regime the tunneling rate is exponentially enhanced when the coherent state
is near the classical turning point of the barrier, and the tunneling is localized in a time window
much shorter than the oscillation period in the well. Third, for a coherent initial state, we derive a saddle-point approximation for the
current showing that tunneling occurs in narrow bursts near the classical turning point, and we
verify the result numerically. 2 Tunneling from resonant states
Consider a potential with a false vacuum (a well) separated from a true vacuum (an asymptotically
free region) by a barrier, shown in Fig. Tunneling from an oscillating initial state
in quantum mechanics
Oliver Janssen1
, Matthew Kleban2 and Cameron Norton2
1Laboratory for Theoretical Fundamental Physics, EPFL, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
2Center for Cosmology and Particle Physics, New York University, New York, NY 10003, USA
Abstract
We study the decay of general initial states out of a metastable potential well in
quantum mechanics. We provide a closed-form expression for the probability current
that tunnels through the barrier in terms of the resonant states into which the initial
state can be decomposed.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Limitations and Extensions
The resonant-state expansion is not complete because it neglects contributions from a non-resonant continuum, which becomes important at early times t ≲ ω−1. Furthermore, the WKB approximation for decay widths Γn becomes less accurate as the energy of the relevant resonances approaches the top of the barrier. p. 4 In these cases, decomposing the initial state as a sum of
resonant states is a useful approximation. This approximation becomes less accurate for states
with significant support at higher energies, where contributions from the non-resonant continuum
are no longer negligible (and at very early and very late times, as we discuss later). In superconducting circuits, a current-biased Josephson junction can tunnel out of a zero-voltage
metastable state via macroscopic quantum tunneling. It has been verified experimentally that the
decay rate depends sensitively on whether the system begins in the ground state or an excited
state of the tilted washboard potential [3, 4]. In this work we focus on quantum mechanics, leaving the extension to quantum field theory
to the future. We first express the outgoing probability current for a general localized initial state
in terms of resonant states.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
WKB for Excited States
For excited energy eigenstates with energies V0 ≪ E ≪ Vb, one can use linear WKB turning point formulae to transition between the classically allowed and forbidden regions. The normalization NE of the energy eigenstates can be fixed by requiring⟨E'E⟩ = Z ∞−∞ dx ψE'(x)ψE(x) = δ(E' − E). For highly excited states with n ≫ 1, the normalization Nn is found to be Nn = 1/p d √π 2 n! p. 6 Interference can have dramatic effects on the
current, as we will see. All we have assumed so far is that the resonant states in (1) have been found, and we have
written the current in terms of {(En, Γn)}.Where the paper says it
Time Evolution of Excited Resonant States
A generalization of the time evolution formula is derived for all the resonant energy eigenstates with energy well below the top of the barrier, given by ψn(x, t) = r m gntn (−1)n p kn(x) exp iħ Z x bn kn + iπ 4 e−Sn/ħ e−iEnt/ħ e−Γnt/2. This form is accurate for x > bn in the free region and is normalized by multiplying by a constant phase to make them real at x = xT. p. 4 We therefore fix their overall normalization by
requiring
Z xT
−∞
dx |ψn(x)|
2 = 1 , (2)
where xT lies to the right of the barrier where the free region starts. There is also no guarantee that the ψn form a complete basis of the Hilbert space. We therefore fix their overall normalization by
requiring
Z xT
−∞
dx |ψn(x)|
2 = 1 , (2)
where xT lies to the right of the barrier where the free region starts. There is also no guarantee that the ψn form a complete basis of the Hilbert space. (42)
If we are able to neglect the S
′′
0
terms, we have
ω
p
2|f
′′
0
|
3
(n0)
3
|n1|
2
→ 1 . (43)
To summarize, in this regime the tunneling rate is exponentially enhanced when the coherent state
is near the classical turning point of the barrier, and the tunneling is localized in a time window
much shorter than the oscillation period in the well. (42)
If we are able to neglect the S
′′
0
terms, we have
ω
p
2|f
′′
0
|
3
(n0)
3
|n1|
2
→ 1 . (43)
To summarize, in this regime the tunneling rate is exponentially enhanced when the coherent state
is near the classical turning point of the barrier, and the tunneling is localized in a time window
much shorter than the oscillation period in the well.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Low-Lying States and Quadratic Approximation
Low-lying energy eigenstates are those with E ≳ V0 for which the linear connection formulae cannot be applied, and approximating the potential as quadratic near the bottom leads to E = O(ħω). In this case, one can use quadratic turning point formulae to find an energy eigenstate satisfying −∂2yψE + y2ψE = (1 + 2n)ψE. The resulting energy eigenstates are found to be ψ n(x) = N n e−(x/d) 2/2H n(-x/d), with N n = 1/(p d √π 2 n! p. 6 Interference can have dramatic effects on the
current, as we will see. All we have assumed so far is that the resonant states in (1) have been found, and we have
written the current in terms of {(En, Γn)}. (20), with tn = 2π/ω. We will approximate the sum in (24) by an integral, which assumes the dominant contributions
come from n ≫ 1, and replace all functions defined for integer n by smooth extensions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Time Evolution Form
The time evolution of the low-lying resonant energy eigenstates is given by ψ n(x, t) = r m gntn (−1)n p kn(x) exp iħ Z x bn kn + iπ 4 e−Sn/ħ e−iEnt/ħ e−Γnt/2. This form is accurate for x > bn in the free region and is normalized by multiplying by a constant phase to make them real at x = xT. The normalization is exponentially enhanced when n is close to an integer.
WKB for Low-Lying States
In the region far inside the barrier but still within the quadratic approximation, the usual WKB approximation becomes valid where κ'/κ squared ≪ 1.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Quantum Tunneling Rate Prediction for Metastable Systems: The improved system can calculate a closed-form expression for probability current tunneling through a barrier from general initial states, capturing both exponential decay of individual resonances and interference between different resonant states.
-
Coherent State Time Evolution Simulation: The system can approximate the time-dependent decay rate of coherent initial states by deriving an approximation to the time-dependent decay rate, demonstrating accuracy against numerical solutions of the Schrodinger equation.
-
Semiclassical Tunneling Regime Analysis: The improved system can derive a saddle point approximation for tunneling current, showing that
tunneling occurs in narrow bursts near the classical turning point,
and determine thetime window of effective tunneling
based on this approximation. -
Phase Coherence Detection: The system can distinguish between coherent and random-phase initial states by analyzing how interference terms in the probability current scale with phase randomization, which is key to understanding time-structured escape rates.
-
High Energy State Tunneling Assessment: The system can assess the reliability of approximations by comparing results for different energy regimes, noting where the WKB approximation becomes less reliable as resonance energies approach the top of the barrier.
Abstract
We study the decay of general initial states out of a metastable potential well in quantum mechanics. We provide a closed-form expression for the probability current that tunnels through the barrier in terms of the resonant states into which the initial state can be decomposed. All ingredients are computed analytically to first subleading order in the semiclassical limit. Specializing to a coherently-oscillating state, we derive an equivalent semiclassical approximation to the current via the path integral, which circumvents the decomposition into resonant states. We test the accuracy of the approximation by comparing it to a numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation.
Sources
- Black holes and the multiverse
- Generalised escape paths for dynamical tunneling in QFT
- Quantum tunneling from excited states in the steadyon picture
- Path integral predictions for pre-asymptotic false vacuum decay
- An ode to instantons
- Survival amplitude, instantaneous energy and decay rate of an unstable system: Analytical results
Related papers
- Computational regimes in matrix-product-state-based quantum trajectory simulations
- Toward chemically accurate quantum simulations on quantum hardware: A quantum-HPC hybrid approach
- Transversal surface-code game with reconfigurable qubits
- Fulqrum: a generalized framework for quantum subspace diagonalization
- Flux-Activated Resonant Control of a Bosonic Quantum Memory
- Machine learning the effects of many quantum measurements