Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging proposes a physically intuitive method called layered gauging to systematically generate (k + 1)-dimensional topological orders from k-dimensional generalized symmetries This method is significant because it provides a versatile approach to investigating quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries by relating k-dimensional symmetries to (k + 1)-dimensional bulk topological orders Core Methodology The layered gauging construction involves stacking many layers of k-dimensional quantum systems with certain symmetries into a (k + 1)-dimensional pile and then sequentially gauging a diagonal symmetry acting on each nearest-neighbor pair of layers Roughly speaking, the prescription is to stack many layers of k-dimensional quantum systems with certain symmetries into a (k + 1)-dimensional pile, and then sequentially gauge a diagonal symmetry acting on each nearest-neighbor pair of layers The detailed procedure depends on the specific symmetry types The method overcomes limitations of previous constructions by being able to apply to conventional, higher-form, subsystem, anomalous, nonabelian, or noninvertible symmetries Elementary Constructions The paper demonstrates the method with several elementary examples across different dimensions and symmetry types 1.
Kai: 2d Toric Code from 1d Z2 Ferromagnets is constructed by stacking many copies of a 1d qubit chain into a 2d lattice and gauging the bilayer symmetry generated by UnUn+1 2.
Mira: A 3d Toric Code is constructed from a 2d square lattice of qubits using iterated gauging where the bulk model realizes the Z2 topological order 3.
Kai: The X-Cube Fracton Topological Order is derived from the subsystem symmetry of the 2d plaquette Ising model through two different ways of gauging, leading to distinct bulk orders 4.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today called "Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging." It sounds like they're proposing a new way to build up higher dimensional topological orders from lower dimensional symmetries that we already understand.
Mira: Exactly, it’s about taking these existing k-dimensional symmetries and systematically generating (k plus one)-dimensional bulk topological orders. It’s presented as a more physically intuitive method than some of the other mathematical formalisms out there.
Lev: I wonder how practical this is for actual hardware. If we're stacking layers, that implies a lot of control over the coupling between these layers, and we need to make sure that sequential gauging process doesn't introduce too much decoherence or complexity.
Kai: Right, so they stack many layers of k-dimensional systems with certain symmetries into a pile, and then they sequentially gauge a diagonal symmetry between each nearest neighbor pair of those layers. It’s this stacking and sequential gauging that’s the core idea here.
Mira: The authors show how this works for several examples, starting with the 2d Toric Code coming from 1d Z2 ferromagnets, which they build by stacking a chain of qubits into a 2d lattice and then gauging that bilayer symmetry <ref:2604.27363#pg2>.
Lev: That’s interesting because the standard way we get a three dee toric code is often through different iterative processes, so seeing this layered approach for the three dee case is something to keep an eye on <ref:2604.27363#pg3>.
Kai: Then they also construct a 3d Toric Code from a 2d square lattice of qubits using iterated gauging where the bulk model realizes the Z2 topological order <ref:2604.27363#pg3>. It shows how you can use this stacking method to get different results depending on the symmetry you start with.
Mira: And they even derive an anisotropic fracton topological order from the subsystem symmetry of a 2d plaquette Ising model through two different ways of gauging, which leads to ground state degeneracy that only depends on system sizes along x and y directions, not z direction <ref:2604.27363#pg2>.
Lev: Anisotropic orders are tricky because the structure of the ground state degeneracy changes depending on which dimension you look at, so having a method that produces those specific dimensional dependencies is valuable for understanding complex phases.
Title and authors: Kai: Then they generalize this construction to much more complicated things, including symmetries with 't Hooft anomalies, nonabelian groups, and even noninvertible fusion category symmetries. It shows the method can handle a lot of different kinds of symmetries beyond the simple invertible abelian ones.
Mira: For example, for a symmetry with an 't Hooft anomaly, they show that the bilayer symmetry stays anomaly-free if you couple the second layer's operators to a gauge field in a way that respects Gauss's law. That means it manages to keep things consistent even when there are these extra anomalies present.
Lev: Keeping things consistent with Gauss's law is always the main hurdle in any gauge theory, so showing they can handle that suggests the method has some underlying mathematical robustness.
Kai: For nonabelian symmetries, the construction requires each layer to have both a left symmetry and a right symmetry that mutually commute, and then they gauge the bilayer G symmetry generated by rho n left g rho n plus one right g. That’s a specific prescription for how to handle those nonabelian groups.
Mira: And for noninvertible symmetries, which are fusion category symmetries, they describe a natural gauging procedure where the bilayer global symmetry operators N n mu N bar n plus one mu become local 'gauge' symmetry generators that produce a representation of the group G.
Lev: If you're dealing with noninvertible categories, that pushes the mathematical machinery quite far, so I’m curious if they have concrete examples showing how this maps onto something we could actually simulate on a real quantum device.
Kai: The resulting bulk theories exhibit rich topological properties like gapped phases and topological degeneracy. Specifically, the model derived from the anomalous Z2 symmetry in one dimension realizes the double semion topological order, which has anyons with semion statistics.
Mira: That double semion order is a specific type of exotic state because it has its own unique line operators that create these anyons, which is different from what we see in simpler systems like the toric code.
Lev: Semions are interesting because their statistics are distinct from conventional anyons, so understanding how this construction produces them tells us a lot about the underlying structure of the bulk theory.
Kai: Finally, they show that for the nonabelian example, it recovers the quantum double model when considering both G and Rep G symmetries in one dimension, which results in a two dimensional bulk topological order.
Title and authors: Mira: So to summarize, this paper suggests layered gauging is a versatile tool that lets us systematically build up complex topological orders from simpler k-dimensional symmetries while handling some of the trickier symmetry types we encounter.
Lev: It sounds like it provides a bridge between the known low-dimensional physics and higher dimensional bulk theories, which is exactly what error correction researchers need to connect to physical realizations.
Kai: The authors also suggest future work should focus on testing this method with anomalous, nonabelian, and noninvertible symmetries more rigorously. They also propose exploring how efficient this construction is for preparing new quantum states in actual experimental platforms.
Mira: And they mention that the bulk construction might be seen as a generalization of hypergraph products, suggesting potential for creating new quantum error correcting codes beyond the standard ones based on all-Z and all-X stabilizers.
Lev: If it can generalize hypergraph products to produce new QEC codes, that’s a significant implication for building more robust quantum computation protocols on actual hardware.
Kai: So, in the end, "Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging" gives us a systematic way to generate these bulk orders from k-dimensional symmetries and shows it works across a wide range of symmetry types.
Mira: It’s about showing that even for complex symmetries like nonabelian groups or noninvertible categories, we have a structured way to generate the corresponding topological order description.
Lev: For me, the most important part is seeing how this method translates into tangible constraints on what kind of bulk phases we can actually realize in a physical setting with limited resources.
Kai: The paper shows concrete examples like the 2d Toric Code and anisotropic fracton orders, which gives us a good starting point for seeing how these constructions look in practice <ref:2604.27363#pg2>.
Mira: It’s about showing that the mathematical structure isn't just abstract; it connects directly to physical phases we can observe in condensed matter systems.
Lev: I hope future work focuses on testing those noninvertible symmetries with experimental platforms, because that’s where the real challenge lies for realizing these states.
Kai: We'll keep an eye on how this layered gauging construction helps us push the boundaries of what topological orders we can describe and potentially build.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, what we’re looking at now is the summary of this paper about "Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging." Basically, they’re showing how you can take a lower dimensional symmetry, say something in one dimension, and stack it up to build a higher dimensional topological order.
Mira: Right. It’s presenting layered gauging as this systematic way to generate those higher dimensional orders from symmetries we already know about, whether they are conventional ones or these more complicated things like nonabelian groups or even symmetries that have anomalies.
Lev: That systematic part is key for me. If the method is predictable, it means we can maybe design a specific sequence of layers and gaugings to *produce* a target topological phase rather than just hoping it shows up in some random material we synthesize.
Kai: Exactly. They’re demonstrating this with a few examples, like building a two dimensional Toric Code from one dimensional Z2 ferromagnets by stacking qubit chains and then gauging that bilayer symmetry.
Mira: And they show how this technique works for things like the three dimensional Toric Code using iterated gauging on a two dimensional square lattice of qubits. It links the stacking process to the bulk model realizing that specific Z2 topological order.
Lev: I’m paying attention to those specific Hamiltonians they get, like H equals minus J times X times f B f, because if we want this to run on real hardware, we need a clear picture of the energy scale and how much noise gets injected during those stacking steps.
Kai: They also handle more complex stuff. For example, when you have a symmetry with an 't Hooft anomaly, they show that the bilayer symmetry stays anomaly-free if you couple those operators to a gauge field in a specific way that respects Gauss’s law.
Mira: That coupling part is the crucial assumption there. It shows that even when there are these extra anomalies present, you can still perform the gauging procedure correctly by respecting those constraints.
Lev: If the method can handle anomalies this way, it means the construction isn't just limited to perfectly clean, anomaly-free systems like simple Z2 codes. That opens up possibilities for studying more realistic physical settings where imperfections are inevitable.
Kai: For nonabelian symmetries, they require each layer to have both a left symmetry and a right symmetry that commute, and then they gauge the bilayer G symmetry by using rho n left g rho n plus one right g operators.
Mira: And for those noninvertible symmetries, which are fusion category symmetries, the procedure is even more direct: the bilayer global symmetry operators become local gauge generators that generate a representation of the group G.
Lev: That mapping from global operators to local gauge generators sounds like it could be translated into specific gate sequences on a quantum computer. It suggests we might be able to program these complex topological states directly using those gate operations.
Kai: The results show that this process leads to rich topological properties, including gapped phases and topological degeneracy. For instance, the model from the anomalous Z2 symmetry in one dimension realizes a double semion order with anyons having semion statistics.
Mira: The double semion order is interesting because it means the anyons behave differently than what you see in simpler systems like the standard toric code, with specific line operators creating these new types of particles.
Lev: Semions are complex, so understanding how this layered gauging produces them tells us a lot about the underlying structure of that bulk theory. Is that statistics measurable on current platforms?
Kai: And finally, for the nonabelian case in one dimension, they recover the quantum double model when you consider both G and Rep G symmetries together, resulting in a two dimensional bulk topological order.
Mira: So what this paper really tells us is that layered gauging is a versatile tool. It gives us a structured way to build up these complex topological orders from simpler lower dimensional symmetries while managing those tricky symmetry types we run into in physics.
Lev: For me, the real implication is that this construction might be a generalization of hypergraph products for quantum error correcting codes, potentially leading to new error correcting codes beyond the standard ones based on all-Z and all-X stabilizers.
Kai: That would mean we could design better QEC protocols using these stacked structures instead of just relying on the repetition code idea.
Mira: It’s about showing that the mathematical structure connects directly to physical phases we can observe in condensed matter systems, providing a concrete blueprint for building these exotic states.
Lev: I think if they can show how this translates into controllable gate operations for state preparation, that would be the most useful part for real hardware applications.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So we’re moving on to what the authors suggest as improvements for this layered gauging method. Basically, they’re saying there are ways to push this construction further, especially when dealing with more challenging types of symmetries.
Kai: They propose focusing future work on anomalous, nonabelian, and noninvertible symmetries because those are the ones that really test how robust this method is.
Mira: Right. That’s a big one. They want to see if this technique can handle the full spectrum of complex symmetries we encounter in condensed matter systems, not just the basic invertible ones.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means testing it against those difficult constraints—anomalies and nonabelian structures—because if it works there, we might be able to build better error correction protocols that are more resilient to real-world noise.
Kai: They also suggest exploring how efficient this construction is for new quantum state preparation protocols in actual experimental platforms.
Mira: That’s interesting because the whole point of these topological orders isn't just describing a phase, it's about using them as resources. If we can use this method to actually prepare those states efficiently, that changes how we think about state synthesis.
Lev: If they can show a protocol for preparation that works on superconducting qubits, that’s huge. We need methods to create these resource states reliably before we can even talk about error correction overhead landing somewhere useful.
Kai: They also suggest viewing the bulk construction method as a generalization of hypergraph products for quantum error correcting codes.
Mira: That connects it back to the resource theory stuff we’ve been reading. It suggests this framework could lead to new QEC codes that go beyond just using standard all-Z or all-X stabilizer types.
Lev: If they can replace those standard structures with something derived from this layered gauging, that could mean a fundamentally different approach to building robust quantum hardware architectures.
Kai: So the main idea here is moving from showing it works for simple things to proving it can handle the truly messy symmetries we see in nature and theoretical physics.
Mira: It’s about taking this systematic generation technique and applying it to the most complicated physical systems, which is where a lot of the real physics lies.
Lev: We need to see how they address those limitations when you move into those noninvertible categories, because that’s where the math gets really heavy.
Tom: So, what we’re looking at now is what the authors suggest as improvements for this layered gauging method. Basically, they’re saying there are ways to push this construction further, especially when dealing with more challenging types of symmetries.
Kai: They propose focusing future work on anomalous, nonabelian, and noninvertible symmetries because those are the ones that really test how robust this method is.
Mira: Right. That’s a big one. They want to see if this technique can handle the full spectrum of complex symmetries we encounter in condensed matter systems, not just the basic invertible ones.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means testing it against those difficult constraints—anomalies and nonabelian structures—because if it works there, we might be able to build better error correction protocols that are more resilient to real-world noise.
Kai: They also suggest exploring how efficient this construction is for new quantum state preparation protocols in actual experimental platforms.
Mira: That’s interesting because the whole point of these topological orders isn't just describing a phase, it's about using them as resources. If we can use this method to actually prepare those states efficiently, that changes how we think about state synthesis.
Lev: If they can show a protocol for preparation that works on superconducting qubits, that’s huge. We need methods to create these resource states reliably before we can even talk about error correction overhead landing somewhere useful.
Kai: They also suggest viewing the bulk construction method as a generalization of hypergraph products for quantum error correcting codes.
Mira: That connects it back to the resource theory stuff we’ve been reading. It suggests this framework could lead to new QEC codes that go beyond just using standard all-Z or all-X stabilizer types.
Lev: If they can replace those standard structures with something derived from this layered gauging, that could mean a fundamentally different approach to building robust quantum hardware architectures.
Kai: So the main idea here is moving from showing it works for simple things to proving it can handle the truly messy symmetries we see in nature and theoretical physics.
Mira: It’s about taking this systematic generation technique and applying it to the most complicated physical systems, which is where a lot of the real physics lies.
Lev: We need to see how they address those limitations when you move into those noninvertible categories, because that’s where the math gets really heavy.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging" shows how we can systematically generate higher dimensional topological orders from lower dimensional symmetries through sequential gauging steps.
Mira: It really demonstrates that layered gauging is a versatile approach, allowing us to build things like the 2d Toric Code or even anisotropic fracton orders, while handling some of the trickier symmetry types we run into <ref:2604.27363#pg2>.
Lev: From an engineering view, this suggests a way to design complex topological phases using specific gate sequences on quantum hardware rather than just relying on random material synthesis.
Kai: The main implication is that this method gives us a clear blueprint for building those bulk states, connecting the math directly to physical phases we can observe in condensed matter systems.
Mira: It moves the discussion from purely abstract mathematical models to something that has direct relevance for designing new quantum error correcting codes beyond the standard ones.
Lev: I think if they can show how this translates into controllable gate operations for state preparation, that’s the most useful part for real hardware applications.
Kai: So, we’re leaving here with a solid methodology for generating bulk orders from k dimensional symmetries across many different symmetry types.
Mira: It’s a strong paper because it shows the structure underneath these phases is quite robust, even when things get messy with anomalies or nonabelian groups involved.
Lev: I just think we need to see those experimental results soon to know if this overhead lands somewhere useful in terms of qubit count and fidelity.
Shang Liu
Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences
cond-mat.str-el, hep-th, quant-ph
Submitted: 2026-04-30
Updated: 2026-10-31
Comments: Published version. Added a new example with an SPT initial Hamiltonian. 20+6 pages, 11 captioned figures
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 114, 245130 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/lmf2-27g1
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 85/100
The gist: Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging proposes a physically intuitive method called layered gauging to systematically generate (k + 1)-dimensional topological orders from…
Key concepts
- Layered Gauging
- This is the core method where many layers of k-dimensional quantum systems are stacked into a (k+1)-dimensional pile. A diagonal symmetry is then sequentially gauged between nearest-neighbor layers, effectively mapping the lower-dimensional symmetries onto a higher-dimensional bulk topological order.
- Topological Order
- This refers to a special type of quantum phase characterized by gapped ground states and topological degeneracy that depends on the system's topology rather than local details. The resulting bulk theories exhibit these properties, such as those found in the Toric Code or double semion orders.
- Generalized Symmetries
- The method is powerful because it works with many types of symmetries, including conventional ones, higher-form symmetries, anomalous symmetries (like 't Hooft anomalies), nonabelian groups, and noninvertible fusion category symmetries. This broad applicability allows for the construction of diverse topological orders.
- Bulk Topological Orders
- These are the resulting theories in a higher dimension (k+1) that emerge from gauging lower-dimensional symmetries. The paper shows this method can yield specific orders, such as the double semion order or quantum double models, which are characterized by unique anyon statistics.
Terminology
Summary
Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging proposes a physically intuitive method called layered gauging to systematically generate (k + 1)-dimensional topological orders from k-dimensional generalized symmetries This method is significant because it provides a versatile approach to investigating quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries by relating k-dimensional symmetries to (k + 1)-dimensional bulk topological orders
Core Methodology
The layered gauging construction involves stacking many layers of k-dimensional quantum systems with certain symmetries into a (k + 1)-dimensional pile and then sequentially gauging a diagonal symmetry acting on each nearest-neighbor pair of layers Roughly speaking, the prescription is to stack many layers of k-dimensional quantum systems with certain symmetries into a (k + 1)-dimensional pile, and then sequentially gauge a diagonal symmetry acting on each nearest-neighbor pair of layers The detailed procedure depends on the specific symmetry types The method overcomes limitations of previous constructions by being able to apply to conventional, higher-form, subsystem, anomalous, nonabelian, or noninvertible symmetries
Elementary Constructions
The paper demonstrates the method with several elementary examples across different dimensions and symmetry types
-
2d Toric Code from 1d Z2 Ferromagnets is constructed by stacking many copies of a 1d qubit chain into a 2d lattice and gauging the bilayer symmetry generated by UnUn+1
-
A 3d Toric Code is constructed from a 2d square lattice of qubits using iterated gauging where the bulk model realizes the Z2 topological order
-
The X-Cube Fracton Topological Order is derived from the subsystem symmetry of the 2d plaquette Ising model through two different ways of gauging, leading to distinct bulk orders
-
An anisotropic fracton model is constructed by taking a second way of gauging the subsystem symmetry, resulting in a model where ground state degeneracy depends on system sizes along x and y directions but not z direction
Generalizations and Complex Symmetries
The layered gauging construction is generalized to more complex symmetries including those with anomalies, nonabelian groups, and noninvertible fusion category symmetries
-
For a symmetry with an 't Hooft anomaly, the bilayer symmetry remains anomaly-free and can still be gauged by coupling the second-layer symmetry operators to the gauge field in a way that respects Gauss's law
-
For nonabelian symmetries, the construction requires each layer to have both a
left
symmetry GL and aright
symmetry GR that mutually commute, and the generalized construction gauges the bilayer G symmetry generated by rho n,L(g)rho n+1,R(g) -
For noninvertible symmetries (fusion category symmetries), a natural gauging-like procedure promotes the bilayer global symmetry operators Nn,µN¯n+1,µ to local
gauge
symmetry generators which generate a Rep(G) symmetry
Topological Order Characterization
The resulting bulk theories exhibit rich topological properties, including gapped phases and topological degeneracy The model derived from the anomalous Z2 symmetry in 1d realizes the double semion topological order, characterized by specific line operators that create anyons with semion statistics Finally, the nonabelian example recovers the quantum double model [21], which generalizes both G and Rep(G) symmetries in 1d to a 2d bulk topological order
Future Directions
The authors suggest that future work should focus on anomalous, nonabelian, and noninvertible symmetries to further test the method They also propose exploring the efficiency of this construction in quantum experiment platforms for new state preparation protocols The bulk construction method may be regarded as a generalization of the hypergraph product, suggesting potential for producing new quantum error correcting codes beyond those based on all-Z and all-X stabilizers
Appendix Summary
Appendix A reviews the procedure for gauging an onsite finite group symmetry by introducing gauge field degrees of freedom on the edges and restricting the Hilbert space to satisfy Gauss's law constraints It details the gauging map GΓ acting on operators, which ensures that gauged operators commute with all gauge symmetry generators and reduce to the original operator on trivial gauge field configurations Appendix B provides an explicit form of the semion loop operator derived from the product of S ER stabilizers in a rectangular region It also shows how to obtain line operators that create dual pairs of anyons, which are semions The final bulk Hamiltonian is recovered as H = −λ X v − J X f B f (67) The ground state degeneracy is shown to be four-fold on torus geometries, confirming the existence of a nontrivial topological order It also proves that any local operator commuting with all stabilizers can be generated by those stabilizers, suggesting robustness against local perturbations The model realizes the double semion topological order with anyon statistics distinct from the toric code The final result recovers the quantum double model when considering both G and Rep(G) symmetries in 1d, corresponding to a 2d bulk topological order
References
[1] X. Chen, Essay: Generalized Landau Paradigm for Quantum Phases and Phase Transitions, Phys. p. 0 Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging
Shang Liu∗
Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100910, China
Understanding quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries is a central
objective of quantum many-body physics. A powerful modern paradigm for investigating this problem is topological holography, which relates symmetries in k dimensions to “bulk” topological orders
in (k + 1) dimensions.Where the paper says it
[2] G. Moore and N. Seiberg, Classical and quantum conformal field theory, Communications in Mathematical Physics 123, 177 (1989)
[3] E. Witten, Quantum field theory and the jones polynomial, Communications in Mathematical Physics 121, 351 (1989)
[4] L. Kong, X.-G. Wen, and H. p. 1 2
ity are already well-established. For instance, any fusion
category symmetry in one spatial dimension (1d) corresponds to a 2d bulk topological order described by the
Turaev-Viro topological quantum field theory (TQFT)
[17, 18], which admits a Hamiltonian realization through
the Levin-Wen string-net models [19]. We note that topological holography in the case
of subsystem symmetry is still an underexplored subject. Nonetheless, previous works have found that in this context, the same boundary theory may correspond to distinct bulk fracton topological orders [23, 32].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[5] L. Kong and H. Zheng, Gapless edges of 2d topological orders and enriched monoidal categories, Nuclear Physics B 927, 140 (2018), arXiv:1705. p. 0 Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging
Shang Liu∗
Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100910, China
Understanding quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries is a central
objective of quantum many-body physics. A powerful modern paradigm for investigating this problem is topological holography, which relates symmetries in k dimensions to “bulk” topological orders
in (k + 1) dimensions. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[6] L. Kong and H. Zheng, A mathematical theory of gapless edges of 2d topological orders. p. 0 A powerful modern paradigm for investigating this problem is topological holography, which relates symmetries in k dimensions to “bulk” topological orders
in (k + 1) dimensions. While conceptually profound, most existing bulk construction methods rely
on sophisticated mathematical formalisms and can be difficult to apply to certain symmetry types. (12)
Such an operator can be regarded as the analog of e
iΦ
in electromagnetism where Φ ∈ {0, π} is the magnetic
flux. As a customary step of the gauging procedure, we
also add the flux operators to the Hamiltonian with a
negative coefficient, in analogy with the magnetic part
of Maxwell term.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[7] J. Pulmann, P. Severa, and F. Valach, A nonabelian duality for (higher) gauge theories, Advances in Theoretical and Mathematical Physics 25, 241 (2021), arXiv:1909. p. 1 Hamiltonian realizations of these
theories have been constructed for arbitrary anomalies at
least in 2d [21, 22]. As a common feature of most existing constructions, sophisticated mathematical tools, such
as (higher) category theory, that describe the infrared
properties of the systems are involved.Where the paper says it
[8] W. Ji and X.-G. Wen, Categorical symmetry and noninvertible anomaly in symmetry-breaking and topological phase transitions, Phys. p. 0 INTRODUCTION
Understanding quantum phases and phase transitions
in the presence of symmetries is a central objective of
quantum many-body physics. In recent years, the framework of topological holography – alternatively referred to
as symmetry topological field theory or symmetry topological order – has emerged as a powerful method for this
purpose.Where the paper says it
[9] L. Kong and H. Zheng, A mathematical theory of gapless edges of 2d topological orders part ii, Nuclear Physics B 966, 115384 (2021)
[10] T. Lichtman, R. Thorngren, N. H. Lindner, A. Stern, and E. Berg, Bulk anyons as edge symmetries: Boundary phase diagrams of topologically ordered states, Phys. p. 4 (9)
The topological phase of the system at J > 0, h = 0
is unaffected by this change as long as λ > 0, since
the Hamiltonian is frustration free. Nonetheless, softening the Gauss’s law will allow for richer excitations:
At h = 0, the above Hamiltonian H allows for both eanyon and m-anyon excitations of the toric code topological order, while the previous H˜ allows for only one type
of anyons, although both Hamiltonians share the same
ground states.Where the paper says it
[11] L. Kong and T. Lan, X.-G. Wen, Z.-H. Zhang, and H. Zheng, Classification of topological phases with finite internal symmetries in all dimensions, Journal of High Energy Physics 2020, 93 (2020)
[12] L. Kong and T. Lan, X.-G. Wen, Z.-H. Zhang, and H. Zheng, Algebraic higher symmetry and categorical symmetry: A holographic and entanglement view of symmetry, Physical Review Research 2, 043086 (2020)
[13] D. Gaiotto and J. Kulp, Orbifold groupoids, Journal of High Energy Physics 2021, 132 (2021)
[14] L. Bhardwaj, Y. Lee, and Y. Tachikawa, SL(2,Z) action on QFTs with Z2 symmetry and the Brown-Kervaire invariants, Journal of High Energy Physics 2020, 141 (2020)
[15] L. Bhardwaj, L. E. Bottini, D. Pajer, and S. Sch¨aferNameki, Gapped phases with non-invertible symmetries: (1+1)d, SciPost Physics 18, 032 (2025), arXiv:2310. p. 0 Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging
Shang Liu∗
Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100910, China
Understanding quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries is a central
objective of quantum many-body physics. A powerful modern paradigm for investigating this problem is topological holography, which relates symmetries in k dimensions to “bulk” topological orders
in (k + 1) dimensions.Where the paper says it
[16] M. Cheng and D. J. Williamson, Relative anomaly in (1 +1)d rational conformal field theory, Physical Review Research 2, 043044 (2020)
[17] V. G. Turaev and O. p. 1 2
ity are already well-established. For instance, any fusion
category symmetry in one spatial dimension (1d) corresponds to a 2d bulk topological order described by the
Turaev-Viro topological quantum field theory (TQFT)
[17, 18], which admits a Hamiltonian realization through
the Levin-Wen string-net models [19].Where the paper says it
[18] J. Barrett and B. Westbury, Invariants of piecewise-linear 3-manifolds, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 348, 3997 (1996)
[19] M. A. Levin and X. p. 1 2
ity are already well-established. For instance, any fusion
category symmetry in one spatial dimension (1d) corresponds to a 2d bulk topological order described by the
Turaev-Viro topological quantum field theory (TQFT)
[17, 18], which admits a Hamiltonian realization through
the Levin-Wen string-net models [19]. 2
ity are already well-established. For instance, any fusion
category symmetry in one spatial dimension (1d) corresponds to a 2d bulk topological order described by the
Turaev-Viro topological quantum field theory (TQFT)
[17, 18], which admits a Hamiltonian realization through
the Levin-Wen string-net models [19]. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[23] S. Liu and W. Ji, Towards non-invertible anomalies from generalized Ising models, SciPost Physics 15, 150 (2023), arXiv:2208.09101 [cond-mat. p. 0 Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
[24] J. Garre-Rubio, Emergent (2+1)D topological orders from iterative (1+1)D gauging, Nature Communications 15, 7986 (2024), arXiv:2403. p. 1 The first method [23] takes as input a pair of
k-dimensional qubit lattice models related by a generalized Kramers-Wannier duality, and produces a (k + 1)-
dimensional topological order by a specific rule of constructing stabilizers. The second method [24, 25], named
iterative gauging, starts by gauging a symmetry of a kdimensional lattice model, followed by iteratively gauging
the dual symmetry acting on the new gauge field degrees
of freedom, until a (k + 1)-dimensional lattice model is
generated.Where the paper says it
[25] D. Blanik and J. Garre-Rubio, Non-abelian quantum double models from iterated gauging, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2512. p. 1 From the anomalous Z2 symmetry in
1d, we constructed a new square lattice model realizing
the double semion topological order. We hope our bulk construction method provides a
new perspective on topological holography or the bulkboundary correspondence of topological orders, and can
produce more interesting lattice models in the future.Where the paper says it
[26] M. Barkeshli, Y.-A. Chen, S.-J. Huang, R. Kobayashi, N. Tantivasadakarn, and G. Zhu, Codimension-2 defects and higher symmetries in (3+1)D topological phases, SciPost Physics 14, 065 (2023), arXiv:2208. p. 0 Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging
Shang Liu∗
Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100910, China
Understanding quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries is a central
objective of quantum many-body physics. A powerful modern paradigm for investigating this problem is topological holography, which relates symmetries in k dimensions to “bulk” topological orders
in (k + 1) dimensions. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[27] However, this property can not be directly generalized to the case of a nonabelian symmetry.
[28] W. Ji and X.-G. Wen, Noninvertible anomalies and mapping-class-group transformation of anomalous partition functions, Physical Review Research 1, 033054 (2019)
[29] An explicit way of achieving this is to apply CNOT gates to every pair (v, e), where v is a site, e is a link adjacent to v, and the site qubit is the controlling qubit. As a result, the Gauss’s law becomes Xv = 1 for every site v
[30] This will be more evident if we first apply CNOT gates to every site-link pair (v, e)
[31] T. Rakovszky and V. Khemani, The Physics of (good) LDPC Codes I. p. 2 Depending on
our initial choice, the bulk may be a nontrivial topological order, but may also be trivially gapped (with a trivial boundary Hilbert space), or even be gapless. From
the examples we examined, we conjecture that the good
choice is to let the k-dimensional layers spontaneously
break their A symmetries completely.Where the paper says it
[32] T. Schuster, N. Tantivasadakarn, A. Vishwanath, and N. Y. Yao, A holographic view of topological stabilizer codes, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2312. p. 0 As another example, in
Ref. 16, from the topological holographic viewpoint, the
authors are able to prove that all unitary minimal conformal field theories in one spatial dimension have no ’t
Hooft anomaly, thereby imposing a strong constraint on
gapless states with anomalous symmetries.Where the paper says it
[33] S. Vijay, J. Haah, and L. Fu, Fracton topological order, generalized lattice gauge theory, and duality, Phys. p. 1 The first method [23] takes as input a pair of
k-dimensional qubit lattice models related by a generalized Kramers-Wannier duality, and produces a (k + 1)-
dimensional topological order by a specific rule of constructing stabilizers. The second method [24, 25], named
iterative gauging, starts by gauging a symmetry of a kdimensional lattice model, followed by iteratively gauging
the dual symmetry acting on the new gauge field degrees
of freedom, until a (k + 1)-dimensional lattice model is
generated. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[34] W. Shirley, K. Slagle, and X. Chen, Foliated fracton order from gauging subsystem symmetries, SciPost Physics 6, 041 (2019), arXiv:1806. p. 7 It might be interesting to note that H
(2)
dual-PI can be
mapped to H
(1)
dual-PI by a standard Kramers-Wannier duality, which is equivalent to gauging the Z2 symmetry
generated by the product of all Z, removing matter sites
by the Gauss’s law, and finally setting the flux term coefficient to +∞. X-Cube Fracton Topological Order
Both ways of gauging the subsystem Z2 symmetries
can be generalized to the bilayer case and hence can be
adopted for our layered gauging construction. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[35] Y. Fuji, Anisotropic layer construction of anisotropic fracton models, Phys. p. 0 We hence conjecture
the method to be very general. For example, from the subsystem symmetry of the 2d plaquette Ising
model, we derive the X-cube model and also an anisotropic fracton topological order. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[36] Y.-A. Chen and S. Tata, Higher cup products on hypercubic lattices: Application to lattice models of topological phases, Journal of Mathematical Physics 64, 091902 (2023)
[37] Indeed, in the case of an abelian invertible symmetry, under group redefinitions (automorphisms) on half of the layers, we may also state our construction as gauging the bilayer symmetries generated by Un,αUn+1,α
[38] M. Levin and Z. p. 1 2
ity are already well-established. For instance, any fusion
category symmetry in one spatial dimension (1d) corresponds to a 2d bulk topological order described by the
Turaev-Viro topological quantum field theory (TQFT)
[17, 18], which admits a Hamiltonian realization through
the Levin-Wen string-net models [19]. This
anomalous Z2 symmetry was first derived in Ref. 38 as
the boundary symmetry of a symmetry protected topological state.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[39] D. V. Else and C. p. 9 One may also directly compute its anomaly
data using, e. the Else-Nayak approach [39]. This
anomalous Z2 symmetry was first derived in Ref. 38 as
the boundary symmetry of a symmetry protected topological state.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[40] It was realized very recently that there exist lattice symmetries which are free of field-theoretic ’t Hooft anomaly but are still not onsiteable [53–55]
[41] This is actually a consequence of our gauging procedure. See the proposition at the end of Appendix A
[42] See the proposition at the end of Appendix A
[43] S. Bravyi, M. B. Hastings, and S. Michalakis, Topological quantum order: Stability under local perturbations, Journal of Mathematical Physics 51, 093512 (2010)
[44] T. D. Ellison, Y.-A. Chen, A. Dua, W. Shirley, N. Tantivasadakarn, and D. J. Williamson, Pauli Stabilizer Models of Twisted Quantum Doubles, PRX Quantum 3, 010353 (2022)
[45] Y.-A. Chen and S. Tata, Higher cup products on hypercubic lattices: Application to lattice models of topological phases, Journal of Mathematical Physics 64, 091902 (2023)
[46] We use the term “vacuum states” for ground states satisfying the cluster decomposition property, i.e. “non-cat” states
[47] One can verify the cluster decomposition property of these states using a matrix product state representation and the orthogonality relation (80)
[48] N. Tantivasadakarn, R. Thorngren, A. Vishwanath, and R. Verresen, Long-range entanglement from measuring symmetry-protected topological phases, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2112. p. 9 This
anomalous Z2 symmetry was first derived in Ref. 38 as
the boundary symmetry of a symmetry protected topological state.Where the paper says it
[49] S. Ashkenazi and E. Zohar, Duality as a feasible physical transformation for quantum simulation, Phys. p. 0 Many topological properties of k-dimensional quantum systems with the symmetry, such as the classification of gapped phases and the modular transformation
rules of partition functions, can be captured by the algebraic properties of the anyon excitations in the bulk topological order. As a concrete example, by analyzing the
anyon condensation patterns of the doubled-Ising topological order, one can show that in one spatial dimension and with the Kramers-Wannier duality as a symmetry, there is only one gapped phase with three-fold
degenerate ground states [15].Where the paper says it
[50] S. Bravyi, I. Kim, A. Kliesch, and R. Koenig, Adaptive constant-depth circuits for manipulating nonabelian anyons, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2205.01933 (2022)
[51] J.-P. Tillich and G. Zemor, Quantum LDPC codes with positive rate and minimum distance proportional to n ˆote 1/2, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:0903.0566 (2009), arXiv:0903.0566 [cs.IT]
[52] J. Haegeman, K. Van Acoleyen, N. Schuch, J. I. Cirac, and F. Verstraete, Gauging Quantum States: From Global to Local Symmetries in Many-Body Systems, Physical Review X 5, 011024 (2015), arXiv:1407. p. 0 Constructing Bulk Topological Orders via Layered Gauging
Shang Liu∗
Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100910, China
Understanding quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries is a central
objective of quantum many-body physics. A powerful modern paradigm for investigating this problem is topological holography, which relates symmetries in k dimensions to “bulk” topological orders
in (k + 1) dimensions.Where the paper says it
[53] W. Shirley, C. Zhang, W. Ji, and M. Levin, Anomalyfree symmetries with obstructions to gauging and onsiteability, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2507. p. 1 2
ity are already well-established. For instance, any fusion
category symmetry in one spatial dimension (1d) corresponds to a 2d bulk topological order described by the
Turaev-Viro topological quantum field theory (TQFT)
[17, 18], which admits a Hamiltonian realization through
the Levin-Wen string-net models [19]. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[54] Y.-T. Tu, D. M. Long, and D. p. 4 − J
− λ
. (9)
The topological phase of the system at J > 0, h = 0
is unaffected by this change as long as λ > 0, since
the Hamiltonian is frustration free. We
then demand local gauge symmetries generated by the
following operators:
. (11)
Note that the product of all such operators is equal to the
global symmetry generator U.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[55] A. M. Czajka, R. Geiko, and R. Thorngren, Anomalies on the Lattice, Homotopy of Quantum Cellular Automata, and a Spectrum of Invertible States, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2512. p. 1 For instance, any fusion
category symmetry in one spatial dimension (1d) corresponds to a 2d bulk topological order described by the
Turaev-Viro topological quantum field theory (TQFT)
[17, 18], which admits a Hamiltonian realization through
the Levin-Wen string-net models [19]. As another example, a 0-form finite group symmetry G in arbitrary k spatial dimensions, including those with ’t Hooft anomalies,
is associated with a Dijkgraaf-Witten TQFT in (k + 1)
spatial dimensions [20]. Several concrete realizations of this holographic dualarXiv:2604. 27363v1 [cond-mat.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved ability to construct (k+1)-dimensional bulk topological orders from k-dimensional generalized symmetries using layered gauging, allowing for systematic generation of liquid or fracton orders from conventional, higher-form, subsystem, anomalous, nonabelian, or noninvertible symmetries.
-
Ability to model and simulate specific topological phases such as the 2d Toric Code and 3d Toric Code by stacking k-dimensional Z2 ferromagnets using the layered gauging method to generate corresponding bulk lattice Hamiltonians like H = -J X f B f.
-
Capability to realize anisotropic fracton topological orders, characterized by ground state degeneracy depending on system sizes along specific dimensions (x and y) but not z, by employing a second way of gauging the subsystem symmetry from the 2d plaquette Ising model.
-
Functionality to construct nonabelian topological orders characterizing onsite finite group symmetries in 1d by stacking models with left and right regular representations, resulting in the quantum double topological order H = -eta X v Av - lambda X f Bf.
-
Development of new quantum state preparation protocols by leveraging the layered gauging construction, which may be realized in experimental platforms by combining unitary gates, measurements, and feedforward to produce topological orders.
-
Application of the layered gauging construction as a generalization of hypergraph products for quantum error correcting codes, potentially leading to new QEC codes beyond Calderbank-Shor-Steane types by replacing the repetition code with other classical error correcting codes.
Abstract
Understanding quantum phases and phase transitions in the presence of symmetries is a central objective of quantum many-body physics. A powerful modern paradigm for investigating this problem is topological holography, which relates symmetries in k dimensions to "bulk" topological orders in (k+1) dimensions. While conceptually profound, most existing bulk construction methods rely on sophisticated mathematical formalisms and can be difficult to apply to certain symmetry types. In this work, we propose a physically intuitive and versatile method, termed the layered gauging construction, to systematically generate (k+1) -dimensional (liquid or fracton) topological orders from k-dimensional generalized symmetries. Roughly speaking, the prescription is to stack many layers of k-dimensional quantum systems with certain symmetries into a (k+1) -dimensional pile, and then sequentially gauge a diagonal symmetry acting on each nearest-neighbor pair of layers. The detailed procedure depends on the specific symmetry types. We have successfully implemented the method in a number of examples in different spatial dimensions, with symmetries that are conventional, higher-form, subsystem, anomalous, nonabelian, or noninvertible. We hence conjecture the method to be very general. For example, from the subsystem symmetry of the 2d plaquette Ising model, we derive the X-cube model and also an anisotropic fracton topological order. Additionally, starting from an anomalous Z 2 symmetry in 1d, we construct a new square lattice model realizing the double semion topological order. From a quantum-error-correction perspective, our layered gauging construction may be viewed as a generalization of the hypergraph-product construction beyond the standard Calderbank-Shor-Steane setting.
Sources
- Generalized Landau Paradigm for quantum phases and phase transitions
- Boundary-bulk relation for topological orders as the functor mapping higher categories to their centers
- Gapless edges of 2d topological orders and enriched monoidal categories
- A mathematical theory of gapless edges of 2d topological orders. Part I
- A non-abelian duality for (higher) gauge theories
- Bulk Anyons as Edge Symmetries: Boundary Phase Diagrams of Topologically Ordered States
- Classification of topological phases with finite internal symmetries in all dimensions
- Algebraic higher symmetry and categorical symmetry -- a holographic and entanglement view of symmetry
- Orbifold groupoids
- $SL(2,\mathbb{Z})$ action on QFTs with $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry and the Brown-Kervaire invariants
- Gapped Phases with Non-Invertible Symmetries: (1+1)d
- Relative Anomaly in (1+1)d Rational Conformal Field Theory
- String-net condensation: A physical mechanism for topological phases
- Fault-tolerant quantum computation by anyons
- Twisted Quantum Double Model of Topological Phases in Two--Dimension
- Towards Non-Invertible Anomalies from Generalized Ising Models
- Emergent (2+1)D topological orders from iterative (1+1)D gauging
- Non-abelian quantum double models from iterated gauging
- Codimension-2 defects and higher symmetries in (3+1)D topological phases
- Non-invertible anomalies and mapping-class-group transformation of anomalous partition functions
Related papers
- Coupled Magnetic and Lattice Excitations in Multiferroic Ba3HoRu2O9: Insights from Neutron Scattering, Raman Spectroscopy, and Machine-Learned Phonon Calculations
- Gossamer Superconductivity in Moir'e WSe 2 Bilayer
- Spin-density wave of ferrimagnetic building blocks masking the ferromagnetic quantum-critical point in NbFe2
- Raman Circular Dichroism and spinon Quantum Geometry of Chiral Quantum Spin Liquids
- Twin Algebras: Condensable Algebras beyond Anyons
- Spin supersolid in triangular lattice easy-axis spin-1/2 antiferromagnet: a fermionic parton perspective