Heavy Quark Transport is Non-Gaussian Beyond Leading Log
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Heavy Quark Transport is Non-Gaussian Beyond Leading Log".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Heavy quark transport beyond leading logarithm at weak coupling is intrinsically non-Gaussian: the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution has asymmetric exponential tails that are crucial for equilibration dynamics.
Kai: This finding is significant because it suggests a robust feature of realistic Quark-Gluon Plasma rather than being peculiar to weak or strong coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry.
Mira: Heavy quarks provide a particularly valuable probe of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) produced in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions (HICs).
Kai: The Core Finding on Non-Gaussian Structure The paper establishes that heavy quark transport at weak coupling beyond leading logarithm exhibits manifest nonGaussian structure, characterized by a Gaussian core and asymmetric exponential tails in the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution.
Paper summary: Kai: This paper, "Heavy Quark Transport is Non-Gaussian Beyond Leading Log," investigates heavy quark transport in weakly coupled non-Abelian plasmas. The core thesis here is that heavy quark transport at weak coupling exhibits intrinsic non-Gaussian structure.
Mira: Specifically, they found that the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution has asymmetric exponential tails, and these tails are crucial for understanding the equilibration dynamics of the system.
Lev: The authors do this by computing the leading order momentum transfer kernel for relativistic heavy quarks in weakly coupled non-Abelian plasmas and matching it to hard thermal loop resummed soft physics.
Kai: They also pointed out that this specific structure is not unique to weak or strong coupling, nor is it peculiar to conformality or supersymmetry.
Mira: This finding is significant because it suggests that this non-Gaussian behavior might be a feature of the physical quark-gluon plasma we see in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions.
Lev: The paper aims to determine two momentum diffusion coefficients and also recovers the known leading order diffusion coefficient at zero velocity, which helps recover appropriate Gaussian limits.
Kai: They satisfy the generalized equilibration condition from reference thirty which provides a nontrivial consistency check on their resulting non-Gaussian dynamics <ref:2604.21895#pg2,a nontrivial consistency check on>.
Mira: The methodology involves using Heaviside step functions to separate contributions in each regime of momentum transfer, which is reminiscent of the original methods by Braaten and Thoma.
Lev: They find that when they write the kernel S L v in terms of these components, they can omit the hard thermal loop pieces for momenta greater than T because those are just higher order contributions.
Kai: This leaves them with a result that is manifestly fixed-order except for the HTL resummed contribution in the soft region where momentum is less than T.
Mira: In that soft region, since the g to zero limit and the momentum integral don't commute, they have to perform a radial integral exactly before expanding in m D over T proportional to g.
Lev: This expansion is what allows them to correctly determine those logarithmically enhanced g to the fourth power log of one over g terms.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up the paper "Heavy Quark Transport is Non-Gaussian Beyond Leading Log," the authors showed that heavy quark transport has a non-Gaussian structure beyond leading order at weak coupling.
Mira: The main implication for us is that we can't rely on purely Gaussian descriptions when modeling heavy-flavor observables in these plasmas.
Lev: It means that any phenomenological models based only on Gaussian or Langevin truncations are not microscopically justified by default; they need to incorporate those non-Gaussian features.
Kai: They suggest a more realistic approach might involve describing the dynamics using eta D of v, kappa L of v, and that volatility exponent R of v.
Mira: And they found that this scaling behavior for R of v is robust, scaling as one over four gamma squared T across both weak and strong coupling expansions.
Lev: The fact that the leading contribution to the volatility exponent is independent of the coupling, with coupling dependence only appearing at subleading orders, tells us a lot about its fundamental nature.
Kai: Heavy quarks give us a particularly valuable probe because they are sensitive to the QGP produced in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions.
Mira: So, this work provides a concrete structural insight into the transport properties that we might find when studying the QGP from those experiments.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology · University of California Santa Barbara
hep-ph, hep-th, nucl-th
Submitted: 2026-04-23
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 17 pages, 2 figures, v2 matches published version
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 192302 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/7fd5-1kq5
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 97/100
The gist: Heavy quark transport beyond leading logarithm at weak coupling is intrinsically non-Gaussian: the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution has asymmetric exponential tails that are crucial for…
Key concepts
- Non-Gaussian Structure
- The distribution of longitudinal momentum transfer for heavy quarks is not purely Gaussian. It has a central Gaussian part and distinct asymmetric exponential tails. This asymmetry is crucial for understanding how heavy quarks equilibrate within the Quark-Gluon Plasma.
- Longitudinal Momentum Transfer Distribution
- This describes how the momentum of a heavy quark changes during its transport. The paper shows this distribution has a Gaussian center (from the central limit theorem) and exponential tails, which are key to describing equilibration dynamics in HICs.
- Volatility Exponent R(v)
- This exponent describes the scaling behavior of transport coefficients, like the diffusion coefficient at zero velocity. In ultra-relativistic limits, it scales as R(v) ∼ 1/(4γ2T), showing a coupling-independent robust feature across both weak and strong coupling expansions.
Terminology
Summary
Heavy quark transport beyond leading logarithm at weak coupling is intrinsically non-Gaussian: the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution has asymmetric exponential tails that are crucial for equilibration dynamics. p. 0 MIT-CTP/6020
Heavy Quark Transport is Non-Gaussian Beyond Leading Log
Jean F. Du Plessis1, 2, ∗ and Bruno Scheihing-Hitschfeld2, †
1Center for Theoretical Physics — A Leinweber Institute,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, USA
2Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics,
University of California, Santa Barbara, California 93106, USA
(Dated: April 24, 2026)
We find that heavy quark transport beyond leading logarithm at weak coupling is intrinsically
non-Gaussian: the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution has asymmetric exponential tails
that are crucial for equilibration dynamics. 1, together with the same qualitative weak-coupling
structure in QCD, suggests that Gaussian core and exponential tail momentum transfer is not peculiar to weak
or strong coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry, but
rather a robust feature that realistic QGP should also
exhibit, with its independent Gaussian characteristics
ηD(v), κL(v), and the volatility exponent R(v) as the
primary properties of the dynamics. We have shown that the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution of a relativistic heavy quark
in generic weakly coupled gauge theory plasmas has a
Gaussian core and exponential tails, and that, in particular, weakly coupled QCD exhibits this behavior. We therefore expect
that this is a robust feature that physical quark-gluon plasma should also exhibit. Heavy quarks (HQs) provide a particularly valuable
probe of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) produced in
ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions (HICs).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Core Finding on Non-Gaussian Structure
The paper establishes that heavy quark transport at weak coupling beyond leading logarithm exhibits manifest nonGaussian structure, characterized by a Gaussian core and asymmetric exponential tails in the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution. The Gaussian core follows as a natural consequence of the central limit theorem. p. 0 The tails are essential for equilibration in
light of the violation of the Einstein relation [30], meaning that HQ transport is intrinsically non-Gaussian. The
Gaussian core follows as a natural consequence of the
central limit theorem. On the other hand, the exponential tails are a new and surprising result. In fact, this
structure is also present in the strongly coupled calculation of [31] — a fact that has remained underappreciated
so far. In fact, this
structure is also present in the strongly coupled calculation of [31] — a fact that has remained underappreciated
so far. With weakly coupled QCD and both weakly and
strongly coupled N = 4 SYM exhibiting this same structure, this indicates that Gaussian core and exponential
tail momentum transfer is not peculiar to weak or strong
coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry, but is instead
likely to be a robust feature of realistic QGP.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Methodology for Kernel Determination
The authors determine the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution by matching the ultraviolet perturbative contribution to the infrared HTL sector. They isolate the strict fixed-order kernel and determine the distribution at all momenta via a Legendre transform. p. 0 With weakly coupled QCD and both weakly and
strongly coupled N = 4 SYM exhibiting this same structure, this indicates that Gaussian core and exponential
tail momentum transfer is not peculiar to weak or strong
coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry, but is instead
likely to be a robust feature of realistic QGP. To establish
this result, we consistently match the ultraviolet perturbative contribution to the infrared HTL sector, isolate
the strict fixed-order kernel, and determine the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution at all momenta
via a Legendre transform. To establish
this result, we consistently match the ultraviolet perturbative contribution to the infrared HTL sector, isolate
the strict fixed-order kernel, and determine the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution at all momenta
via a Legendre transform. The full matched kernel reproduces the known leading-log results for the drag and
arXiv:2604. 2
momentum diffusion coefficients, as well as the known
leading-order diffusion coefficient at v = 0, thereby recovering the appropriate Gaussian limits. It also satisfies the generalized equilibration condition of Ref.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Verification of Consistency and Robustness
The calculation involves isolating the strict fixed-order kernel by using Heaviside step functions to separate contributions in each regime. The structure of the integrand in Eq. p. 1 (6) then provides a nontrivial consistency
check on that construction. Because this symmetry is a
structural property of the integrand in Eq. It also satisfies the generalized equilibration condition of Ref. [30],
providing a nontrivial consistency check on the resulting
non-Gaussian dynamics. This
can be seen by examining the exponential suppression
of IHard(p, v) at large p by statistical factors (see End
Matter). We have explicitly verified that replacing the separa3
It is also reassuring to note that the longitudinal part of the HTLresummed contributions (in the first two lines) in the kernel (10)
satisfies the Einstein relation. We have explicitly verified that replacing the separa3
It is also reassuring to note that the longitudinal part of the HTLresummed contributions (in the first two lines) in the kernel (10)
satisfies the Einstein relation. This is mandated by the fact that
in the extreme weakly coupled limit equilibration should still be
attained — and the fact that this part of the kernel is quadratic
means that the associated stochastic process is Gaussian. 4
tion scale T by any Λ ∼ T leaves the fixed-order kernel
SFO invariant. As an additional cross-check, we have
verified that the second moment of the kernel at v = 0
reproduces the known diffusion coefficient [1, 20] exactly
at order g
4
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Implications for Phenomenological Descriptions
The non-Gaussian momentum transfer dynamics can modify heavy-flavor observables and the transport coefficients extracted from them. A purely Gaussian description is not consistent with first-principles calculations for generic relativistic heavyquark transport. p. 5 At finite velocity, however, the remaining
fixed-order contributions control the shape of the distribution and invalidate a purely Gaussian truncation, as
the universal equilibration condition [30] is only satisfied through a detailed balance of all of the cumulants. A Gaussian description is therefore not consistent with
first-principles calculations for generic relativistic heavyquark transport. These results have direct implications for heavy-flavor
phenomenology. Since non-Gaussian momentum transfer
can modify heavy-flavor observables and the transport
coefficients extracted from them [27–29], phenomenological descriptions based purely on Gaussian or Langevin
truncations are not microscopically justified by default. Our calculation therefore motivates revisiting heavyquark transport in the QGP with non-Gaussian kernels if one aims to extract transport coefficients that
can be meaningfully compared to lattice determinations. A more realistic, non-Gaussian description may be organized in terms of ηD(v), κL(v), and a single additional parameter R(v), the volatility exponent, characterizing the distribution of (rare) large momentum kicks,
which sets the slopes of the asymmetric exponential tails.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Scaling Behavior of Transport Coefficients
The analysis reveals scaling behaviors for the transport coefficients, such as the diffusion coefficient at v = 0. The diffusion coefficient is found to be proportional to g2CF m2DT 6π ln(TmD) + TF Nf ln 2Nc + TF Nf + ξ. p. 8 9
The poles cancel in the sum, as they must. We obtain κ = g2CF m2DT 6π "
ln
2
TmD
+
TF
Nf ln 2
Nc
+
TF
Nf
+
ξ
#
(34)
with
ξ
=
12
−
γ
E
+
ζ
′
(2)
ζ(2) , in agreement with the known
leading-order heavy quark diffusion coefficient [
1
, 20]. The conclusion of this analysis is that as γ → ∞ one has R(v) ∼ 1/(4γ2T). (36) R(v) in the ultra-relativistic limit at strong coupling. 1, together with the same qualitative weak-coupling
structure in QCD, suggests that Gaussian core and exponential tail momentum transfer is not peculiar to weak
or strong coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry, but
rather a robust feature that realistic QGP should also
exhibit, with its independent Gaussian characteristics
ηD(v), κL(v), and the volatility exponent R(v) as the
primary properties of the dynamics. We have shown that the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution of a relativistic heavy quark
in generic weakly coupled gauge theory plasmas has a
Gaussian core and exponential tails, and that, in particular, weakly coupled QCD exhibits this behavior. This defines a volatility
exponent R(v), which encodes the likelihood of experiencing (rare) large momentum kicks. Note that, both
in the weak and strong coupling expansions, the leading
contribution to the volatility exponent R(v) is independent of the coupling — coupling dependence only appears
at subleading order in either expansion.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Higher Moment Analysis at Zero Velocity
The higher projected longitudinal moments at zero velocity are derived by focusing on the hard contribution for n ≥ 4. The even moments Mn(0) are given by a closed-form result involving integrals of sinh and cosh functions. p. 7 Because the cumulants are given by derivatives of K as
Mn = −∂
nK/∂xn|x=0, and the only scale in the problem
is T, all that is needed is to evaluate the integrals
J˜(sinh)
n,m ≡
Z ∞
0
dpZ ∞
1
dk p
nk
m
sinh2
pk
4
=
2
n+3n! ζ(n)
(n − m)
, (30)
J˜(cosh)
n,m ≡
Z ∞
0
dpZ ∞
1
dk p
nk
m
cosh2
pk
4
= (1 − 2
1−n
)J˜(sinh)
n,m . (31)
Using these to evaluate the cumulants yields
Mn(0) = 3 g
2CF m2
D 2
n−1T
n−2
(n − 1)! ζ(n)
π
3(n + 1)Nc +
NcNX
2 + TF Nf
"
Nc
NXn(n + 2) + 2(n
2 − 2n + 8)
8(n − 2)(n + 2) +
(1 − 2
1−n) TF Nf
n − 2
#
(32)
for all even n ≥ 4, while Mn(0) = 0 for odd n. (31)
Using these to evaluate the cumulants yields
Mn(0) = 3 g
2CF m2
D 2
n−1T
n−2
(n − 1)! ζ(n)
π
3(n + 1)Nc +
NcNX
2 + TF Nf
"
Nc
NXn(n + 2) + 2(n
2 − 2n + 8)
8(n − 2)(n + 2) +
(1 − 2
1−n) TF Nf
n − 2
#
(32)
for all even n ≥ 4, while Mn(0) = 0 for odd n. ζ(n)
π
3(n + 1)Nc +
NcNX
2 + TF Nf
"
Nc
NXn(n + 2) + 2(n
2 − 2n + 8)
8(n − 2)(n + 2) +
(1 − 2
1−n) TF Nf
n − 2
#
(32)
for all even n ≥ 4, while Mn(0) = 0 for odd n. The
explicit (n − 2)−1 pole signals the special infrared sensitivity of the diffusion coefficient, and is precisely why the
n = 2 case must be treated separately.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Matching-Scale Invariance Proof
The matching-scale invariance is verified by differentiating Eq. (10) with respect to the matching scale Λ and showing that the derivative is zero. p. 0 We show this by computing the leading-order momentum transfer kernel for relativistic heavy quarks in weakly coupled non-Abelian plasmas, matching
perturbative momentum transfer on the thermal scale to hard-thermal-loop-resummed soft physics. This is the same structure previously found in strongly coupled holographic plasmas, showing that
it is not peculiar to weak or strong coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry. 4
tion scale T by any Λ ∼ T leaves the fixed-order kernel
SFO invariant. As an additional cross-check, we have
verified that the second moment of the kernel at v = 0
reproduces the known diffusion coefficient [1, 20] exactly
at order g
4
. (6) then provides a nontrivial consistency
check on that construction. Because this symmetry is a
structural property of the integrand in Eq. Because this symmetry is a
structural property of the integrand in Eq. (5), independent of the specific forms of IHard, ISoft, and IMatch, the
equilibration condition holds order by order in perturbation theory. Du Plessis1, 2, ∗ and Bruno Scheihing-Hitschfeld2, †
1Center for Theoretical Physics — A Leinweber Institute,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, USA
2Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics,
University of California, Santa Barbara, California 93106, USA
(Dated: April 24, 2026)
We find that heavy quark transport beyond leading logarithm at weak coupling is intrinsically
non-Gaussian: the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution has asymmetric exponential tails
that are crucial for equilibration dynamics. We show this by computing the leading-order momentum transfer kernel for relativistic heavy quarks in weakly coupled non-Abelian plasmas, matching
perturbative momentum transfer on the thermal scale to hard-thermal-loop-resummed soft physics. (28)
Invariance under change in separation scale. Choosing an arbitrary matching scale Λ ∼ g
0T leads to Eq.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Non-Gaussian Transport Modeling for Heavy Quarks: The improved AI system can perform first-principles calculations of heavy quark transport in weakly coupled gauge theory plasmas by calculating a fixed-order momentum transfer kernel that exhibits a Gaussian core and asymmetric exponential tails, which is crucial for equilibration dynamics.
-
Improved Phenomenological Description: The system can move beyond purely Gaussian or Langevin truncations to utilize a non-Gaussian description organized in terms of ηD(v), κL(v), and the volatility exponent R(v) to characterize rare large momentum kicks, providing a more microscopically justified framework for extracting transport coefficients.
-
Velocity and Coupling Robustness Testing: The system can test the robustness of this non-Gaussian structure by comparing results across different coupling strengths (weak vs strong) and different theories (QCD vs N=4 SYM), confirming that
Gaussian core and exponential tail momentum transfer is not peculiar to weak or strong coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry.
-
Quantitative Moment Prediction: The AI can accurately predict the higher projected longitudinal moments at zero velocity for even n greater than two using closed-form results derived from the kernel analysis, providing a precise formula for these moments.
-
Diffusion Coefficient Extraction: The system can determine the heavy quark momentum diffusion coefficient κ by combining the log-enhanced contribution and the remaining fixed-order contributions, yielding an expression that recovers known leading-order coefficients at zero velocity.
Abstract
We find that heavy quark transport beyond leading logarithm at weak coupling is intrinsically non-Gaussian: the longitudinal momentum transfer distribution has asymmetric exponential tails that are crucial for equilibration dynamics. We show this by computing the leading-order momentum transfer kernel for relativistic heavy quarks in weakly coupled non-Abelian plasmas, matching perturbative momentum transfer on the thermal scale to hard-thermal-loop-resummed soft physics. This is the same structure previously found in strongly coupled holographic plasmas, showing that it is not peculiar to weak or strong coupling, conformality, or supersymmetry. We therefore expect that this is a robust feature that physical quark-gluon plasma should also exhibit.
Sources
- How Much do Heavy Quarks Thermalize in a Heavy Ion Collision?
- Thermalization of Heavy Quarks in the Quark-Gluon Plasma
- Heavy-Quark Probes of the Quark-Gluon Plasma at RHIC
- Energy Loss of Charm Quarks in the Quark-Gluon Plasma: Collisional vs Radiative
- Open Heavy Flavor in QCD Matter and in Nuclear Collisions
- Cracking the difference of estimating heavy quark transport coefficients in a Quark-Gluon Plasma
- Extraction of Heavy-Flavor Transport Coefficients in QCD Matter
- Towards the determination of heavy-quark transport coefficients in quark-gluon plasma
- Heavy-Quark Diffusion in the Quark-Gluon Plasma
- Heavy Quark Diffusion in Strongly Coupled $\N=4$ Yang Mills
- Lattice QCD constraints on the heavy quark diffusion coefficient
- Heavy quark momentum diffusion from the lattice using gradient flow
- Heavy quark diffusion coefficient with gradient flow
- Heavy Quark Diffusion from 2+1 Flavor Lattice QCD with 320 MeV Pion Mass
- Quark Mass Dependence of Heavy Quark Diffusion Coefficient from Lattice QCD
- Temperature Dependence of Heavy Quark Diffusion from (2+1)-flavor Lattice QCD
- Heavy quark diffusion in perturbative QCD at next-to-leading order
- Heavy quark diffusion in QCD and N=4 SYM at next-to-leading order
- Colour-electric spectral function at next-to-leading order
- Real Time Quarkonium Transport Coefficients in Open Quantum Systems from Euclidean QCD
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses