The two-level systems in cryogenic solids, or how to avoid stressful memories
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The two-level systems in cryogenic solids, or how to avoid stressful memories".
Paper summary: Mira: To follow up on that idea of enthalpy vs. TLS depletion, the paper examines how this relates to ergodicity breaking and memory effects in glasses >
Kai: They bring in the concept that making a memory one or two has a free energy cost, which is positive for both of them, but it's quantified in a history-independent way >
Lev: How does that free energy cost translate into things we can actually measure on hardware? Because for us, that overhead really lands on the coherence and the fidelity of what we build >
Mira: The paper connects this to residual stress per particle, which they describe as being proportional to temperature times the ratio of number of particles over some characteristic number >
Kai: And they link lower configurational entropy at freezing to more ergodicity breaking, less residual stress, and fewer TLSs >
Lev: That makes sense if the lack of entropy is what drives the TLS count down, but it doesn't fully explain why amber keeps its TLS population despite being very stable >
Mira: The authors suggest that less configurational entropy at freezing leads to fewer TLSs in conventional glasses made by bulk quenching a melt >
Kai: But when you look at experimental data, they find that the density of states for these TLSs varies by about an order of magnitude even within the range of quench rates possible >
Lev: That variation is significant, because it means there isn't one single number for how many TLS we should expect just by knowing the quench rate >
Mira: And computationally, they found that searching for candidate TLS modes has a lower success rate when you look at more stable structures >
Kai: They also have this prediction from RFOT theory that in a glass made by quenching near the critical temperature, say Tcr, a single TLS should encompass twenty to thirty beads >
Lev: That number sounds like it’s for a specific model, not necessarily for the real complexity of what we're trying to engineer >
Mira: Right. So the paper is mapping out this puzzle between thermal quenching, enthalpic stability, and these persistent low-energy excitations known as TLSs >
Conclusion: Kai: So what does this whole thing mean when we look at the title of "The two-level systems in cryogenic solids, or how to avoid stressful memories"? It sounds like it’s about managing the structural memory of a material >
Mira: It seems to be focused on how different ways we stabilize a solid—like quenching versus long-term aging—affect these TLS excitations >
Lev: For someone building real hardware, this means if you're trying to design a very stable system, you need to consider not just the final enthalpy but also the path taken to get there >
Kai: If we can understand how these TLS modes behave, it informs how we might try to engineer materials that have fewer of these troublesome low-energy states >
Mira: The authors are pointing toward a link between enthalpic stability and the presence of non-phononic degrees of freedom in disordered solids, which is a key connection they're making >
Lev: So the big picture is that it’s not just about getting a material to be stable; it’s about controlling the structural landscape so you don't end up with too many these excitations >
University of Houston · Texas Center for Superconductivity
cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.soft
Submitted: 2026-04-22
Updated: 2026-11-18
Journal ref: published in Adv. Phys. (2026)
DOI: 10.1080/00018732.2026.2750696
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: Structural glasses prepared by bulk quenching a liquid melt universally exhibit puzzling low-energy excitations commonly known as the “two-level systems” (TLSs) <ref:2604.211095…
Key concepts
- Two-Level Systems (TLS)
- These are puzzling, low-energy excitations found in structural glasses. They behave like two-level systems at very low temperatures and represent strongly anharmonic, resonant degrees of freedom beyond normal vibrations.
- Enthalpic Stability vs. TLS Depletion
- The paper examines the conflict between making a glass enthalpically stable and having fewer TLSs. While ultrastable films show fewer TLSs, amber does not age similarly, suggesting stabilization might come from increased bonding rather than just aging.
- Ergodicity Breaking
- This is a fundamental property of glasses where the system's average value cannot be replaced by a typical value. The free energy cost associated with creating different memories quantifies probabilities in this history-independent manner.
- Configurational Entropy
- The amount of configurational entropy in the glass relates to ergodicity breaking. Less configurational entropy at freezing is linked to less residual stress and fewer TLSs, implying a more broken ergodic state.
Terminology
Summary
Structural glasses prepared by bulk quenching a liquid melt universally exhibit puzzling low-energy excitations commonly known as the “two-level systems” (TLSs) <ref:2604. p. 0211095, Structural glasses prepared by bulk quenching a liquid melt universally exhibit puzzling low-energy excitations commonly known as the “two-level systems” (TLSs) <ref:2604. p. 021109#pg4>.
The Nature of Two-Level Systems
Structural glasses made by thermal quenching universally exhibit structural degrees of freedom in excess of ordinary vibrations, behaving like two-level systems at sufficiently low temperatures according to bulk measurements <ref:2604.21109#pg4>. These strongly anharmonic, resonant degrees of freedom behave like two-level systems at sufficiently low temperatures according to bulk measurements <ref:2604. p. 121109#pg4>. Early treatments assumed these excitations come about because glasses can host strongly anharmonic, non-phononic modes owing to the lack of strict periodicity <ref:2604. p. 121109#pg4>. The TLS density of states turned out to be rigidly correlated with how strongly the TLS couple to the acoustic modes <ref:2604. p. 121109#pg4>.
Enthalpic Stability vs. p. 2 TLS Depletion
The paper addresses a seeming conflict where enthalpically stabilizing a glass may or may not lead to a decrease in the TLS density of states <ref:2604.21109#pg4>. Ultrastable glassy films and deeply supercooled model liquids alike show a substantial decrease in the number of TLSs, whereas amber matured over geological times does not <ref:2604. p. 221109#pg4>. The authors speculate that amber achieves enthalpic stabilization through increased bonding, not ageing, to account for the persistence of TLSs <ref:2604. p. 021109#pg4>.
Ergodicity Breaking and Memory
The physics of glasses is tied to ergodicity breaking, where the average can no longer be conflated with a typical value <ref:2604.21109#pg8>. The free energy cost of making a memory 1 is given by (G1−G) > 0 and for memory 2 it is (G2 − G) > 0 <ref:2604. p. 521109#pg9>. This free energy cost quantifies probabilities in a history-independent fashion <ref:2604. p. 521109#pg9>. The residual stress per particle is given by Γ(N∗)(N/N∗)/N = T sc <ref:2604. p. 921109#pg10>. Less configurational entropy at freezing implies more ergodicity breaking, less residual stress, and fewer TLSs <ref:2604. p. 921109#pg9>.
Experimental and Computational Findings
Several experimental studies show that the density of states for the TLSs should vary by about an order of magnitude within the range of quench rates available in principle <ref:2604.21109#pg4>. Computational studies suggest that search for candidate TLSs has a substantially lower success rate for more stable structures <ref:2604. p. 421109#pg4>. The RFOT theory predicts that in a glass made by quenching near Tcr, a TLS should encompass 20 to 30 beads <ref:2604. p. 421109#pg9>.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Develop predictive models for two-level system density of states based on preparation history by incorporating concepts like configurational entropy and residual stress. This improved AI system can predict whether an enthalpically stable glass, such as amber, will exhibit a depletion of two-level systems by comparing its stabilization mechanism to conventional quenching.
-
Enhance simulation algorithms for model liquids to accurately sample the
glass ceiling
of long relaxation times using methods like swap Monte Carlo sampling. The improved AI system can perform more efficient Gibbs sampling, allowing it to explore potential energy surfaces for highly stable glasses and identify candidate TLS modes with greater success rate than current methods allow. -
Implement a framework that distinguishes between different types of ergodicity breaking mechanisms in glasses, such as those arising from thermal quenching versus those induced by chemical processes like polymerization and cross-linking. This system can analyze experimental data on ultra-stable films to determine if the observed depletion of two-level systems is due to local ordering or bulk structural changes.
-
Create a quantitative tool that relates the cooperativity size N star to the configurational entropy per bead and activation barrier, allowing for comparison across different chemical substances. This improved system can predict the density of TLSs based on the calculated volume of reconfiguring regions, linking it directly to residual stress and entropic content as described by Eq (2) through (4).
Sources
- Long time derivation of the Boltzmann equation from hard sphere dynamics
- The Microscopic Quantum Theory of Low Temperature Amorphous Solids
- A convex polyhedron without Rupert's property
Related papers
- Topological metal-insulator transitions in one-dimensional non-Hermitian quasicrystals: beyond PT-symmetry
- Microscopic and collective signatures of feature learning in neural networks
- Synchronous and asynchronous Monte Carlo dynamics of mean-field spin glasses with rotationally invariant couplings: what they share and where they differ
- Reentrant Localization Length in a Quasiperiodic Thue-Morse Chain
- Beyond Ground States: Learning Many-Body Hamiltonians for p-Bit Invertible Arithmetic
- Linear equivalence of nonlinear recurrent neural networks