The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks

arXiv:2604.20484 · physics.plasm-ph · Submitted 2026-04-22 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The development of operational scenarios without large Type-I ELMs is of utmost importance for the stable operation and longevity of future tokamaks.

Kai: The contribution focuses on the development and understanding of the NT and QCE regimes on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV.

Mira: Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The overarching aim of the research topic is directed at the physics understanding of large-ELM-free regimes rather than the development of an integrated high performance, detached ELM free scenario.

Kai: A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbation (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

Paper summary: Kai: The paper "The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks" is really focused on establishing robust operational scenarios for fusion devices that avoid those big Type-I ELMs, which is a major hurdle for making future tokamaks stable and long-lasting.

Mira: It claims that understanding these ELM-free regimes requires looking at the physics of transport within the pedestal determining the average pedestal gradient and identifying when a global peeling ballooning mode begins, as shown in their schematic on page three of The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks <ref:2604.20484#pg1,The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks>.

Lev: So, it sets up this framework by linking transport effects directly to the onset of instability modes across different plasma regimes.

Kai: They break down the avoidance strategies into two main types: one where you raise stability limits for things like QCE or quiescent H-mode by creating more transport, and another that drastically reduces stability so you can't even access standard H-mode, like in negative triangularity plasmas.

Mira: This categorization matters because it suggests that the physical reasons for ELM avoidance are quite different depending on whether you're dealing with a QCE or an NT plasma.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this helps us know what kind of physical control mechanisms we need to design into the tokamak systems for these different operational spaces.

Kai: They use experiments on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV to compare these scenarios against standard ELMy H-modes and also validate their modeling-driven stepladder approach across these devices.

Mira: The key contribution is using this stepping approach to shorten the time needed to develop scenarios for both QCE and NT demonstrations in JET.

Lev: That validation step is vital because it means we don't have to spend years building models only to find out they don't work on real hardware like TCV or JET.

Kai: They also use these comparisons, like the density profiles shown on page twelve to highlight the relative strengths of the QCE and NT approaches to ELM avoidance.

Mira: And ultimately, it uses ideal MHD predictions for the QCE regime to suggest that it's a relevant operational scenario for ITER based on predicted minimum separatrix density and pedestal top density values.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up "The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks," the core idea is that we can use a step-by-step approach across different devices to build a reliable understanding of how to operate fusion machines without those big Type-I ELMs.

Mira: The authors are showing that this approach works well for both quasi-continuous exhaust and negative triangularity regimes, and it provides concrete predictions for what ITER needs in terms of plasma density requirements.

Lev: It means the modeling is proving useful in a real way because they successfully validated the concepts on smaller machines before projecting them onto larger ones.

Kai: The implication for us is that we have a much clearer picture of how to design tokamak operations to be more stable over longer timescales, which is essential for any reactor aiming for long-term operation.

Mira: It's about moving from just observing ELMs to actively designing plasma conditions where they don't happen, whether you're looking at ITER or a future reactor.

Lev: The work suggests that the physics we understand now, especially regarding QCE access in ITER, is directly applicable to the design phase of future fusion devices.

Max-Planck-Institute for Plasma Physics · Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne Swiss Plasma Center · Dept. of Atomic, Molecular and Nuclear Physics University of Seville Spain · United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority Culham Science Centre United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland · Plasma Science and Fusion Center Massachusetts Institute of Technology United States of America · Laboratory for Plasma Physics LPP-ERM/KMS Brussels Belgium · Institute of Applied Physics TU Wien Fusion@ÖAW Vienna Austria · Laboratorio Nacional de Fusión CIEMAT Spain

physics.plasm-ph

Submitted: 2026-04-22

Updated: 2026-04-22

Journal ref: M.G. Dunne et al 2026 Nucl. Fusion 66 106024

DOI: 10.1088/1741-4326/ae99f1

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 88/100

The gist: The development of operational scenarios without large Type-I ELMs is of utmost importance for the stable operation and longevity of future tokamaks.

Key concepts

Type-I ELM Avoidance
This refers to two main ways to prevent large Edge-Localized Modes (ELMs). One method raises the stability limit for QCE/QH modes by creating additional transport via an MHD mode. The other significantly reduces stability limits, preventing H-mode access entirely, as seen in NT plasmas.
Quasi-Continuous Exhaust (QCE)
QCE is a plasma regime where ELMs are avoided through strong pedestal gradients. It requires high shaping and high separatrix density to be accessed. Its performance metrics, when normalized, are comparable to ELMy H-mode plasmas, making it a viable scenario for ITER.
Negative Triangularity (NT)
NT is a plasma regime where ELM avoidance is achieved by blocking access to ballooning second stability. This was demonstrated on JET using shaping requirements that proved sufficient for ELM suppression.

Terminology

Summary

The development of operational scenarios without large Type-I ELMs is of utmost importance for the stable operation and longevity of future tokamaks. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1088/1741-4326/ad3e16 Abstract. The development of operational scenarios without large Type-I ELMs is of utmost importance for the stable operation and longevity of future tokamaks.

The contribution focuses on the development and understanding of the NT and QCE regimes on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes. This contribution focuses on the development and understanding of the NT and QCE regimes on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The overarching aim of the research topic is directed at the physics understanding of large-ELM-free regimes rather than the development of an integrated high performance, detached ELM free scenario. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbation (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26].

The focus of this contribution is on the well-developed understanding of NT and QCE plasmas. p. 1
Where the paper says it

A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26]. The focus of this contribution is on the well-developed understanding of NT and QCE plasmas.

How the training signal is built

The physics picture of Type-I ELM avoidance can be understood as an intersection of transport in the pedestal determining the average pedestal gradient and the onset of a global peeling-ballooning mode. There are two main categories of large-ELM avoidance: one applies to e. p. 2

Where the paper says it

A large ELM crash can be avoided by tailoring both the transport and MHD limits. There are then two main categories of large-ELM avoidance: one applies to e.

g. QCE and QH mode where the Type-I ELM stability limit is raised and additional transport is created via an MHD mode. p. 2
Where the paper says it

QCE[31] and QH mode[19], where the Type-I ELM stability limit is raised (e. via increased plasma shaping) and additional transport is created via an MHD mode.

The second category reduces both stability limits significantly to the point where the H-mode is no longer accessed as is the case in NT plasmas. p. 2
Where the paper says it

This allows an ELMy H-mode-like pedestal gradient to be sustained, shown by the green star, without the presence of large ELMs. The second category reduces both stability limits significantly, to the point where the H-mode is no longer accessed, as is the case in NT plasmas, corresponding to the blue lines in figure 1; here, the star indicates the low expected pedestal gradient, which remains below the peeling-ballooning boundary.

Where the gains come from

The key feature of these experiments is the validation of the modelling-driven stepladder approach to the experiments. For negative triangularity (NT), blocking access to ballooning second stability avoids H-mode entry. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Initial negative triangularity discharges at AUG showed no signs of ELM-avoidance or Hmode avoidance[14, 42]. Since the original experiments the understanding of NT ELM avoidance[12, 39, 43] has developed, showing that blocking access to ballooning second stability avoids H-mode entry.

This involved developing and testing a negative triangularity scenario on JET. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The manuscript is structured as follows: an introduction to a simple conceptual model of ELM-avoidance is presented, along with the tools which are used for modelling. The progress in developing ELM-free negative triangularity scenarios on ASDEX Upgrade and JET, following detailed experiments at TCV will be mentioned.

The demonstration of NT ELM-avoidance in JET showed that the shaping required for ELM avoidance was sufficient. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Work is still ongoing to characterise the transport across the entire plasma radius in the full set of JET-NT discharges. These experiments have, however, shown that robust ELM avoidance can be obtained in a large device, at substantial levels of heating power, and that the shaping required for this can be predicted in advance via only the engineering parameters (current, field, and plasma shape), building confidence in our ability to design NT ELM-avoidance scenarios in future devices.

Comparison of NT and QCE at JET

A comparison of the electron temperature and density profiles for the two discharges is shown in figure 12. The QCE discharge has a significantly higher density than the NT discharge, which stems from a strong pedestal gradient. p. 8

Where the paper says it

70 Time (s) 0 20 40 kA (e) Figure 6. Plots of the (a) main ion fuelling, (b) pedestal top (solid) and separatrix (dashed) density and ELM monitor during the flat-top of an AUG QCE discharge.

This comparison highlights the relative strengths of the two approaches to ELM-avoidance. p. 2
Where the paper says it

paper will, however, focus more on recent progress in the QCE regime, describing the current access model and a comparison of the scenario with ELMing H-modes on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV. The physics picture of Type-I ELM avoidance The occurrence of Type-I ELMs can be understood as an intersection of transport in the pedestal (often considered to be a KBM[27]) determining the average pedestal gradient and the onset of a global peeling-ballooning mode.

Extrapolation to ITER

The ability to predict the minimum separatrix density and expected pedestal top density in the QCE regime using ideal MHD lends further support to the QCE as a plasma scenario for ITER. Previous work has indicated that the minimum separatrix density required for QCE access in ITER is approximately 30%nGW, which is in the range of densities achieved in present-day machines. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The integration of a high performance core with an ELMfree pedestal and relevant divertor physics is quite challenging in present-day machines owing to the typical requirement of high separatrix density operation, which imposes known limitations on plasma performance[1, 2, 3]. Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER.

The QCE can therefore be expected to be accessible in ITER, as its entry requirements are met by the expected operating conditions of the device. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26].

Summary and conclusions

The work presented here has shown the current understanding of the physics mechanisms for access to the QCE and NT large ELM-avoidance regimes. The stepladder approach within EUROfusion, understanding physics on smaller devices before applying it to larger ones, has significantly shortened scenario development time necessary for both QCE and NT demonstration in JET. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26].

The successful demonstration of the QCE in D plasmas in JET also paved the way for a successful series of QCE experiments in DT plasmas. p. 1
Where the paper says it

A highlight of these efforts is the development and exploration of NT and QCE scenarios in JET, enabled via predictive modelling. A second highlight of the recent JET ELM-free experiments is the demonstration of both the QCE[18] and XPR[26] regimes in DT plasmas.

Predictions for the minimum density for QCE access in ITER indicate that the regime should be accessible in ITER. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26].

NT ELM avoidance has been successfully demonstrated on both AUG and JET guided by modelling and similarity experiments in TCV. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The key feature of these experiments is the validation of the modelling-driven stepladder approach to the experiments. Predictions for the minimum shaping for ELM avoidance were made for JET and AUG, taking the restrictions of the PF coil-sets into account.

The expansion of the QCE operational range to higher current and even lower q95(< 3. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The region of stability lies in the lower left of the plot, and above and to the right of each curve is the unstable region. paper will, however, focus more on recent progress in the QCE regime, describing the current access model and a comparison of the scenario with ELMing H-modes on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV.

5) than has already been achieved has a high priority. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Due to the high-risk nature of the experiments (both programatically and to the machine), only the final experimental day was dedicated to this program. Advance preparation, as mentioned above, predicted that the shaping which could be achieved in JET was sufficient for ELM avoidance.

Finally, the plasma-wall interaction in QCE plasmas must also be understood as the falloff lengths in the SOL become significantly longer than in ELMy H-mode plasmas. p. 2
Where the paper says it

This allows an ELMy H-mode-like pedestal gradient to be sustained, shown by the green star, without the presence of large ELMs. The second category reduces both stability limits significantly, to the point where the H-mode is no longer accessed, as is the case in NT plasmas, corresponding to the blue lines in figure 1; here, the star indicates the low expected pedestal gradient, which remains below the peeling-ballooning boundary.

References

[1] M. G. Dunne, et al. The role of the density profile in the ASDEX-Upgrade pedestal structure. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Regions of the pedestal The description of pedestal structure and transport in terms of only the pedestal height and width does not capture the finer details of the various transport mechanisms which can be present in the pedestal region. Gyrokinetic studies[35] of the ASDEX Upgrade pedestal have shown a range of instabilities which can be present at a given time.

[2] L. Frassinetti, et al. Pedestal structure, stability and scalings in JET-ILW: The EUROfusion JET-ILW pedestal database. p. 3

Where the paper says it

In the case of NT, H-mode avoidance has been linked with blocking access to the second stable region in s-α space[12], particularly in the middle region of the pedestal, where second-stability access is most likely. Access to the QCE is linked to keeping access to second-stability open in the middle of the pedestal and an unstable ballooning mode localised at the pedestal foot[15, 41, 31], independently of the structure of the rest of the pedestal (which may tend towards low-, medium-, or high-n modes).

[3] U. A. Sheikh, et al. Pedestal structure and energy confinement studies on TCV. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Access to the QCE is linked to keeping access to second-stability open in the middle of the pedestal and an unstable ballooning mode localised at the pedestal foot[15, 41, 31], independently of the structure of the rest of the pedestal (which may tend towards low-, medium-, or high-n modes). Second stability access: negative triangularity The flexible shaping capabilities of TCV have helped drive the understanding of the separate elements of ELM-avoidance and confinement improvement in NT.

[4] M. Greenwald, et al. p. 5

Where the paper says it

4 fGW (d) Figure 3. NBI heating power (a), upper (dash-dot), lower (dashed), and average (solid) triangularity (b), plasma stored energy (c), and Greenwald fraction (d) for the TCV companion plasma to the JET NT shape.

Characterization of enhanced Dα high-confinement modes in Alcator CMod. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Access to the QCE is linked to keeping access to second-stability open in the middle of the pedestal and an unstable ballooning mode localised at the pedestal foot[15, 41, 31], independently of the structure of the rest of the pedestal (which may tend towards low-, medium-, or high-n modes). Second stability access: negative triangularity The flexible shaping capabilities of TCV have helped drive the understanding of the separate elements of ELM-avoidance and confinement improvement in NT.

[5] L. Gil, et al. EDA H-mode in ASDEX Upgrade: scans of heating power, fueling, and plasma current. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[6] T. E. Evans, et al. Suppression of Large Edge-Localized Modes in High-Confinement. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Access to the QCE is linked to keeping access to second-stability open in the middle of the pedestal and an unstable ballooning mode localised at the pedestal foot[15, 41, 31], independently of the structure of the rest of the pedestal (which may tend towards low-, medium-, or high-n modes). Second stability access: negative triangularity The flexible shaping capabilities of TCV have helped drive the understanding of the separate elements of ELM-avoidance and confinement improvement in NT.

[7] R. Nazikian, et al. Pedestal Bifurcation and Resonant Field Penetration at the Threshold of Edge-Localized Mode Suppression in the DIII-D Tokamak. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Recent modelling of a transient QH-mode phase in ASDEX Upgrade[36] has confirmed the physics picture, and highlighted the importance of low pedestal collisionality in sustaining the QH-mode in these plasmas. Previous studies[37] have posited the mechanism for ELM suppression via magnetic perturbations as being caused by the presence of an island at the pedestal top, blocking further expansion of the pedestal.

[8] W. Suttrop, et al. Experimental studies of high-confinement mode plasma response to nonaxisymmetric magnetic perturbations in ASDEX Upgrade. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Recent modelling of a transient QH-mode phase in ASDEX Upgrade[36] has confirmed the physics picture, and highlighted the importance of low pedestal collisionality in sustaining the QH-mode in these plasmas. Previous studies[37] have posited the mechanism for ELM suppression via magnetic perturbations as being caused by the presence of an island at the pedestal top, blocking further expansion of the pedestal.

[9] A. E. Hubbard, et al. Multi-device studies of pedestal physics and confinement in the I-mode regime. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26].

[10] T. Happel, et al. The I-mode confinement regime at ASDEX Upgrade: global properties and characterization of strongly intermittent density fluctuations. p. 2

Where the paper says it

paper will, however, focus more on recent progress in the QCE regime, describing the current access model and a comparison of the scenario with ELMing H-modes on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV. The physics picture of Type-I ELM avoidance The occurrence of Type-I ELMs can be understood as an intersection of transport in the pedestal (often considered to be a KBM[27]) determining the average pedestal gradient and the onset of a global peeling-ballooning mode.

[11] A. Marinoni, et al. A brief history of negative triangularity tokamak plasmas. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[12] A. O. Nelson, et al. Prospects for H-mode inhibition in negative triangularity tokamak reactor plasmas. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[13] S. Coda, et al. Enhanced confinement in diverted negative-triangularity L-mode plasmas in TCV. p. 1

Where the paper says it

A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26]. The focus of this contribution is on the well-developed understanding of NT and QCE plasmas.

[14] T. Happel, et al. Overview of initial negative triangularity plasma studies on the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[15] G. F. Harrer, et al. Parameter dependences of small edge localized modes (ELMs). p. 9

Where the paper says it

This critical αedge can be transformed into a critical ne,edge as follows: an expected αedge,exp is constructed as Rq2β/λp,scale with β ∝ ne,edgeTe,edge. Te,edge is determined from the input heating power and Spitzer-Harm conduction, while ne,edge is used as a free parameter to scan.

[16] B. Labit, et al. Dependence on plasma shape and plasma fueling for small edge-localized mode regimes in TCV and ASDEX Upgrade. p. 4

Where the paper says it

H-mode avoidance via NT in AUG New negative-triangularity experiments, motivated by advances in prediction, were performed in ASDEX Upgrade during the 2025 campaign; the full details of the shape development, modelling, and plasma performance will be detailed in a separate publication[44]. Here, we present two AUG discharges with small differences in the

[17] M. Faitsch, et al. Analysis and expansion of the quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE) regime in ASDEX Upgrade. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[18] M. Faitsch, et al. The quasi-continuous exhaust regime in JET. p. 7

Where the paper says it

These experiments have, however, shown that robust ELM avoidance can be obtained in a large device, at substantial levels of heating power, and that the shaping required for this can be predicted in advance via only the engineering parameters (current, field, and plasma shape), building confidence in our ability to design NT ELM-avoidance scenarios in future devices. Separatrix ballooning modes: the quasi-continuous exhaust regime The quasi-continuous exhaust regime is a regime which, in contrast to NT, is operated at high positive plasma shaping.

[19] K. H. Burrell, et al. Quiescent H-mode plasmas in the DIII-D tokamak. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[20] W. Suttrop, et al. Study of quiescent H-mode plasmas in ASDEX Upgrade. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[21] W. Suttrop, et al. Studies of the ‘Quiescent H-mode’ regime in ASDEX Upgrade and JET. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER. A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26].

[22] E. R. Solano, et al. Observation of Confined Current Ribbon in JET Plasmas. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks 3 Figure 1. Schematic of Type-I ELM avoidance for QCE (green) and NT (blue) plasmas vs an ELMy H-mode (red) in a j-α diagram where j is the peak edge current density and α is the normalised pressure gradient.

[23] X. Chen, et al. Expanding the parameter space of the wide-pedestal QH-mode towards ITER conditions. p. 3

Where the paper says it

In the case of NT, H-mode avoidance has been linked with blocking access to the second stable region in s-α space[12], particularly in the middle region of the pedestal, where second-stability access is most likely. Access to the QCE is linked to keeping access to second-stability open in the middle of the pedestal and an unstable ballooning mode localised at the pedestal foot[15, 41, 31], independently of the structure of the rest of the pedestal (which may tend towards low-, medium-, or high-n modes).

[24] J. Garcia, et al. New H-mode regimes with small ELMs and high thermal confinement in the Joint European Torus. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[25] E. de la Luna, et al. Exploring the physics of a high-performance H-mode scenario with small ELMs at low collisionality in JET with Be/W wall. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). The overarching aim of the research topic is directed at the physics understanding of large-ELM-free regimes, rather than the development of an integrated high performance, detached ELM free scenario.

[26] M. Bernert, et al. X-point radiation: From discovery to potential application in a future reactor. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Particular focus is paid to the performance of the QCE in terms of the achieved pedestal top values, which, when appropriately normalised, do not differ significantly from ELMy H-mode plasmas. This, combined with the predicted minimum separatrix density for the 15 MA ITER baseline plasma, highlight the relevance of the QCE as a potential operational scenario for both ITER and future reactors.

[27] P. B. Snyder, et al. Development and validation of a predictive model for the pedestal height. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The focus of this contribution is on the well-developed understanding of NT and QCE plasmas. A highlight of these efforts is the development and exploration of NT and QCE scenarios in JET, enabled via predictive modelling.

[28] P.B. Snyder, et al. A first-principles predictive model of the pedestal height and width development, testing and ITER optimization with the EPED model. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The main task of understanding the physics of ELM-free regimes is then one of understanding the transport mechanisms which regulate the pedestal gradient and the pedestal width. Regions of the pedestal The description of pedestal structure and transport in terms of only the pedestal height and width does not capture the finer details of the various transport mechanisms which can be present in the pedestal region.

[29] D. Dickinson, et al. Towards the construction of a model to describe the inter-ELM evolution of the pedestal on MAST. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Access to the QCE is linked to keeping access to second-stability open in the middle of the pedestal and an unstable ballooning mode localised at the pedestal foot[15, 41, 31], independently of the structure of the rest of the pedestal (which may tend towards low-, medium-, or high-n modes). Second stability access: negative triangularity The flexible shaping capabilities of TCV have helped drive the understanding of the separate elements of ELM-avoidance and confinement improvement in NT.

[30] E. Wolfrum, et al. Overview of recent pedestal studies at ASDEX Upgrade. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Recent modelling of a transient QH-mode phase in ASDEX Upgrade[36] has confirmed the physics picture, and highlighted the importance of low pedestal collisionality in sustaining the QH-mode in these plasmas. Previous studies[37] have posited the mechanism for ELM suppression via magnetic perturbations as being caused by the presence of an island at the pedestal top, blocking further expansion of the pedestal.

[31] J. Kalis, et al. Experimental characterization of the quasi-coherent mode in EDA H-Mode and QCE scenarios at ASDEX Upgrade. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[32] M. G. Dunne, et al. Quasi-continuous exhaust operational space. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[33] M. G. Dunne, Impact of impurity seeding and divertor conditions on transitions, pedestal structure and ELMs. p. 8

Where the paper says it

This results in an increase of both the pedestal top and separatrix densities (panel b), with the separatrix density increasing by almost 40%. A detailed view of the ELM signatures (panel c) from the poloidal current measured at the divertor tiles (which corresponds to the divertor heat loads[17]) for an ELMy time window and a QCE time window are shown in panels (d) and (e), highlighting the substantial difference in heat loads from large ELMs and the QCE filaments.

[34] P.B. Snyder, et al. High fusion performance in Super H-mode experiments on Alcator C-Mod and DIII-D. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Similar experiments were performed for the AUG discharges, also showing robust H-mode avoidance. H-mode avoidance via NT in AUG New negative-triangularity experiments, motivated by advances in prediction, were performed in ASDEX Upgrade during the 2025 campaign; the full details of the shape development, modelling, and plasma performance will be detailed in a separate publication[44].

[35] L.A. Leppin, et al. Complex structure of turbulence across the ASDEX Upgrade pedestal. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Regions of the pedestal The description of pedestal structure and transport in terms of only the pedestal height and width does not capture the finer details of the various transport mechanisms which can be present in the pedestal region. Gyrokinetic studies[35] of the ASDEX Upgrade pedestal have shown a range of instabilities which can be present at a given time.

[36] L. Meier, et al. MHD simulations of formation, sustainment and loss of quiescent H-mode in the all-tungsten ASDEX Upgrade. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[37] P. B. Snyder, et al. The EPED pedestal model and edge localized mode-suppressed regimes: Studies of quiescent H-mode and development of a model for edge localized mode suppression via resonant magnetic perturbations. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Recent modelling of a transient QH-mode phase in ASDEX Upgrade[36] has confirmed the physics picture, and highlighted the importance of low pedestal collisionality in sustaining the QH-mode in these plasmas. Previous studies[37] have posited the mechanism for ELM suppression via magnetic perturbations as being caused by the presence of an island at the pedestal top, blocking further expansion of the pedestal.

[38] M. Willensdorfer, et al. Observation of magnetic islands in tokamak plasmas during the suppression of edge-localized modes. p. 1

Where the paper says it

A wide range of scenarios are being investigated across the different machines, covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA)[4, 5], ELM suppression via magnetic perturbation (MP)[6, 7, 8], the I-mode[9, 10], negative triangularity(NT)[11, 12, 13, 14], the quasicontinuous exhaust (QCE) regime[15, 16, 17, 18], quiescent H-mode (QH)[19, 20, 21, 22, 23], the baseline small ELMs (SE)[24, 25], and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes[26]. The focus of this contribution is on the well-developed understanding of NT and QCE plasmas.

[39] A. O. Nelson, et al. Robust Avoidance of Edge-Localized Modes alongside Gradient Formation in the Negative Triangularity Tokamak Edge. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks 3 Figure 1. Schematic of Type-I ELM avoidance for QCE (green) and NT (blue) plasmas vs an ELMy H-mode (red) in a j-α diagram where j is the peak edge current density and α is the normalised pressure gradient.

[40] L. Radovanovic, et al. Developing a physics understanding of the quasi-continuous exhaust regime: Pedestal profile and ballooning stability analysis. p. 7

Where the paper says it

These experiments have, however, shown that robust ELM avoidance can be obtained in a large device, at substantial levels of heating power, and that the shaping required for this can be predicted in advance via only the engineering parameters (current, field, and plasma shape), building confidence in our ability to design NT ELM-avoidance scenarios in future devices. Separatrix ballooning modes: the quasi-continuous exhaust regime The quasi-continuous exhaust regime is a regime which, in contrast to NT, is operated at high positive plasma shaping.

[41] M. Griener, et al. Continuous observation of filaments from the confined region to the far scrape-off layer.

[42] B. Vanovac, et al. Pedestal properties of negative triangularity discharges in ASDEX Upgrade. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Similar experiments were performed for the AUG discharges, also showing robust H-mode avoidance. H-mode avoidance via NT in AUG New negative-triangularity experiments, motivated by advances in prediction, were performed in ASDEX Upgrade during the 2025 campaign; the full details of the shape development, modelling, and plasma performance will be detailed in a separate publication[44].

[43] O. Sauter et al. Negative triangularity tokamak operation in TCV, IAEA FEC 2023. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[45] O. Sauter, et al. Improved Confinement with Negative Triangularity in L-mode Plasmas in JET. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Access to the QCE is linked to keeping access to second-stability open in the middle of the pedestal and an unstable ballooning mode localised at the pedestal foot[15, 41, 31], independently of the structure of the rest of the pedestal (which may tend towards low-, medium-, or high-n modes). Second stability access: negative triangularity The flexible shaping capabilities of TCV have helped drive the understanding of the separate elements of ELM-avoidance and confinement improvement in NT.

[46] O. Sauter et al. Negative triangularity experiments in JET. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The manuscript is structured as follows: an introduction to a simple conceptual model of ELM-avoidance is presented, along with the tools which are used for modelling. The progress in developing ELM-free negative triangularity scenarios on ASDEX Upgrade and JET, following detailed experiments at TCV will be mentioned.

[47] E. R. Solano, et al. L-H transition studies in tritium and deuterium–tritium campaigns at JET with Be wall and W divertor. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Fusion 64 112023 ♭See the author list of N. Vianello et al, ”Results from the last DD and DT JET campaigns in the framework of the EUROfusion Tokamak Exploitation Work Package Activity”, 2026 submitted to Nuclear Fusion ♮See the author list of C.

[48] M. Faitsch, et al. The quasi-continuous exhaust regime in ASDEX Upgrade and JET. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes.

[50] T. Eich, et al. Turbulence driven widening of the near-SOL power width in ASDEX Upgrade H-Mode discharges. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Similar experiments were performed for the AUG discharges, also showing robust H-mode avoidance. H-mode avoidance via NT in AUG New negative-triangularity experiments, motivated by advances in prediction, were performed in ASDEX Upgrade during the 2025 campaign; the full details of the shape development, modelling, and plasma performance will be detailed in a separate publication[44].

[51] R. L. Miller, et al. p. 9

Where the paper says it

35 t )ρs, where αt is a collisional broadening parameter and ρs is the poloidal ion Larmor radius; all values are calculated self-consistently with the physical and magnetic geometry plus the power crossing the separatrix. This scaling for λp When comparing the predicted αedge,crit from HELENA and the expected αedge,exp it should be noted that the definitions are slightly different; HELENA uses the Miller definition of α[51], while the definition in the previous paragraph is a cylindrical approximation, with the simplification reflecting available experimental data.

Noncircular, finite aspect ratio, local equilibrium model. p. 1
Where the paper says it

A second highlight of the recent JET ELM-free experiments is the demonstration of both the QCE[18] and XPR[26] regimes in DT plasmas. The manuscript is structured as follows: an introduction to a simple conceptual model of ELM-avoidance is presented, along with the tools which are used for modelling.

[52] A. A. Pshenov, et al. SOLPS-ITER simulations of the ITER divertor with improved plasma-facing component geometry. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The integration of a high performance core with an ELMfree pedestal and relevant divertor physics is quite challenging in present-day machines owing to the typical requirement of high separatrix density operation, which imposes known limitations on plasma performance[1, 2, 3]. Instead, the general approach of the topic is to investigate physics mechanisms in smaller, flexible devices, such as TCV and ASDEX Upgrade, to validate this understanding on a larger device (typically JET) and then use the validated physics mechanisms to make predictions for future devices such as SPARC and ITER.

[53] P. Maget, et al. MHD stability of the pedestal in ITER scenarios. p. 2

Where the paper says it

This is sketched in figure 1, using the well-known j-α depiction for global pedestal stability; above and to the left of the lines are the unstable region, below and left shows the stable region, where pedestals are expected prior to large ELM crashes. Figure 1 shows an example stability boundary and operational point for an ELMy pedestal as the red line, where the transport and MHD limits coincide[28, 29, 30].

[54] T. Luda, et al. Effect of the plasma size on pedestal and global confinement and prediction for ITER with IMEP. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Particular focus is paid to the performance of the QCE in terms of the achieved pedestal top values, which, when appropriately normalised, do not differ significantly from ELMy H-mode plasmas. This, combined with the predicted minimum separatrix density for the 15 MA ITER baseline plasma, highlight the relevance of the QCE as a potential operational scenario for both ITER and future reactors.

[55] A. Kappatou, et al. Overview of the third JET deuterium-tritium campaign. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Similar experiments were performed for the AUG discharges, also showing robust H-mode avoidance. H-mode avoidance via NT in AUG New negative-triangularity experiments, motivated by advances in prediction, were performed in ASDEX Upgrade during the 2025 campaign; the full details of the shape development, modelling, and plasma performance will be detailed in a separate publication[44].

[56] A. Redl, et al. An extensive analysis of SOL properties in high-d plasmas in ASDEX Upgrade. p. 6

Where the paper says it

5 MA could be realised within this single experimental day. While a more detailed analysis of the various discharges will be presented elsewhere[45, 46], one highlight is presented here in figure 5 as time-traces of a high-power negative triangularity discharge.

[57] H. J. Sun, et al. Impact of the plasma boundary on machine operation and the risk mitigation strategy on JET. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Demonstration of NT ELM-avoidance in JET A strenuous test of the H-mode avoidance theory was facilitated via the opportunity to develop and test a negative triangularity scenario on JET. Due to the high-risk nature of the experiments (both programatically and to the machine), only the final experimental day was dedicated to this program.

--- Page 2 ---

The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks 2

highlighted, as well as the progress in developing access models based on ideal-MHD. In the case of the QCE, this can also be expressed as a minimum separatrix density which corresponds well to experimentally measured separatrix densities. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The physics of ELM-free regimes in EUROfusion tokamaks 2 highlighted, as well as the progress in developing access models based on ideal-MHD. In the case of the QCE, this can also be expressed as a minimum separatrix density, which corresponds well to experimentally measured separatrix densities.

Particular focus is paid to the performance of the QCE in terms of the achieved pedestal top values, which when appropriately normalised, do not differ significantly from ELMy H-mode plasmas. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the case of the QCE, this can also be expressed as a minimum separatrix density, which corresponds well to experimentally measured separatrix densities. Particular focus is paid to the performance of the QCE in terms of the achieved pedestal top values, which, when appropriately normalised, do not differ significantly from ELMy H-mode plasmas.

This, combined with the predicted minimum separatrix density for the 15 MA ITER baseline plasma highlight the relevance of the QCE as a potential operational scenario for both ITER and future reactors. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Particular focus is paid to the performance of the QCE in terms of the achieved pedestal top values, which, when appropriately normalised, do not differ significantly from ELMy H-mode plasmas. This, combined with the predicted minimum separatrix density for the 15 MA ITER baseline plasma, highlight the relevance of the QCE as a potential operational scenario for both ITER and future reactors.

The QCE regime is accessed at high shaping and high separatrix density. A sufficiently high shaping parameter and a critical separatrix density can be determined from machine parameters are the key requirements. p. 9

Where the paper says it

2 (1 + δ) 0. 9 ) and a critical separatrix density which can be determined from machine parameters are the key requirements.

The QCE can therefore be expected to be accessible in ITER, as its entry requirements are met by the expected operating conditions of the device.

The QCE access model posits access to the QCE regime at high shaping and high separatrix density. The model described in the previous section posits access to the QCE regime at high shaping and high separatrix density. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The critical separatrix density is found at the intersection of both lines, above which one expects access to the QCE regime. demonstration of the QCE at JET[18, 48], enabled by understanding of the operational space of the QCE from the separatrix parameters[15, 17] and MHD stability[40, 32]; a sufficiently high shaping parameter (defined as Sd = κ 2.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved scenario development by integrating predictive modeling with experimental validation across multiple devices. The paper shows that "The stepladder approach within EUROfusion, understanding physics on smaller devices before applying it to larger ones, notably JET, has significantly shortened scenario development time necessary for both QCE and NT demonstration in JET."

  2. Enhanced predictive capability for reactor operation by providing a methodology to predict critical shaping requirements. The text states that Predictions for the minimum shaping for ELM avoidance were made for JET and AUG, taking the restrictions of the PF coil-sets into account.

  3. Better evaluation of ITER suitability by establishing concrete density and confinement thresholds based on existing machine data. The authors conclude that Predictions for the minimum density for QCE access in ITER indicate that the regime should be accessible in ITER, and pedestal predictions made with ideal MHD codes are also expected to apply in the QCE regime in ITER.

  4. Improved comparison of transport mechanisms by normalizing plasma performance metrics across different regimes. The paper demonstrates this by noting that With this normalisation, no difference between ELMy H-mode pedestal top values and those in the QCE regime can be discerned.

  5. More robust understanding of filament scaling for reactor environments by contrasting QCE and NT signatures. The system can now analyze that Filaments are often associated with the QCE, and an open research question is how these filaments will scale to reactors, particularly the energy deposited not only on the divertor but also the first wall.

Abstract

The development of operational scenarios without large Type-I ELMs is of utmost importance for the stable operation and longevity of future tokamaks. The EUROfusion tokamak exploitation program has therefore made the understanding of ELM-free regimes a major topic of exploration across all its contributing devices (ASDEX Upgrade, JET, MAST-Upgrade, TCV, and WEST). An integrated program to investigate a range of Type-I ELM-free regimes has been developed covering the enhanced D-alpha (EDA), magnetic perturbations (MP), negative triangularity (NT), quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE), quiescent H-mode (QH), the baseline small ELMs (SE), I-mode, and X-point radiator (XPR) regimes. This contribution focuses on the development and understanding of the NT and QCE regimes on ASDEX Upgrade, JET, and TCV. The importance of transport via ballooning modes in both regimes is highlighted, as well as the progress in developing access models based on ideal-MHD. In the case of the QCE, this can also be expressed as a minimum separatrix density, which corresponds well to experimentally measured separatrix densities. Particular focus is paid to the performance of the QCE in terms of the achieved pedestal top values, which, when appropriately normalised, do not differ significantly from ELMy H-mode plasmas. This, combined with the predicted minimum separatrix density for the 15 MA ITER baseline plasma, highlight the relevance of the QCE as a potential operational scenario for both ITER and future reactors.

Related papers