Generalised Langevin Dynamics: Significance and Limitations of the Projection Operator Formalism
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Generalised Langevin Dynamics".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Generalised Langevin Dynamics: Significance and Limitations of the Projection Operator Formalism discusses mathematical aspects of Mori’s projection operator formalism and its limitations in deriving generalized Langevin equations.
Kai: Mathematical Foundations The core of the Mori-Zwanzig formalism is the generalised Langevin equation, which is typically derived from the Dyson-Duhamel identity.
Mira: The authors recall the derivation of the projection operator formalism for Mori’s projection by means of semigroup theory and discuss where rigorous methods fail for Zwanzig’s projection when dealing with unbounded perturbations.
Kai: For bounded perturbations of the time-evolution operator, the Dyson-Duhamel identity coincides with the variation of constants formula.
Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up this discussion on "Generalised Langevin Dynamics: Significance and Limitations of the Projection Operator Formalism," the paper really boils down to this idea that you don't necessarily need the whole projection operator machinery to get those generalized Langevin equations <ref:2604.20453#pg1>.
Mira: It means that while Mori’s formalism has been standard for sixty years in modeling open systems, the mathematical foundation underpinning it, especially when dealing with unbounded perturbations like Zwanzig’s projection, isn't as solid as we thought <ref:2604.20453#pg2>.
Lev: The key finding they highlight is that this splitting of variables into fast and slow parts leads to the vanishing of the memory term because those subspaces are invariant under time-evolution <ref:2604.20453#pg1>.
Kai: So, to put it plainly, the memory term isn't just some inherent part of the dynamics; it turns out it’s a coupling term that doesn't necessarily relate to true memory <ref:2604.20453#pg1>.
Mira: And the authors conclude that all properties of Mori’s generalized Langevin equation can actually be derived without using the projection operator formalism at all, following directly from how well-posed Volterra equations are <ref:2604.20453#pg1>.
Lev: This suggests that for building real hardware, we should probably focus on that relationship between the autocorrelation function C t and the memory kernel K t via a Volterra equation of the second kind <ref:2604.20453#pg1>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we’re looking at the final thoughts on this paper by Mori and Zwanzig about generalized Langevin dynamics.
Mira: It really tackles the core idea of using projection operators to model these open systems and shows where that method hits a wall with unbounded stuff like Zwanzig’s projection.
Kai: The authors spend a lot of time showing how you can actually get the generalized Langevin equation without even needing that whole heavy machinery of the projection operator formalism.
Lev: That's interesting because if you don't need the formal machinery, does that mean we can just use simpler equations for our real hardware simulations?
Mira: Not exactly. The paper shows that while you can derive everything from other well-posed equations, like Volterra equations, the practical reality is different. You still have to worry about how fast you get those solutions and what the assumptions are on the initial state.
Kai: So for a researcher building actual qubits or whatever we’re simulating, what does that mean for us? Does it simplify our setup or just shift where our errors come from?
Lev: It shifts the error analysis. If you ditch the projection operator approach, you have to use those Volterra equations directly. That means your memory kernel becomes something you have to solve or approximate right away.
Mira: Exactly. The paper suggests that the memory term isn't really a fixed thing; it’s more of a coupling term that depends on how you split your variables into fast and slow ones, and that splitting isn't always clean.
Kai: So the real point is that we can get the equation, but predicting the exact dynamics still requires those approximations of what those memory terms actually are in practice.
Mira: Right. It’s a lot of math showing us how to build a model, but it also clearly shows that building a *good* model means knowing exactly which parts you are ignoring and why.
Institute of Physics, Albert-Ludwigs-University Freiburg
math-ph, math.MP
Submitted: 2026-04-22
Updated: 2026-11-11
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 74/100
The gist: Generalised Langevin Dynamics: Significance and Limitations of the Projection Operator Formalism discusses mathematical aspects of Mori’s projection operator formalism and its limitations in…
Key concepts
- Projection Operator Formalism
- This is a mathematical technique used to simplify complex dynamics by projecting the full system's evolution onto a relevant subspace. The paper discusses Mori's version and its challenges when dealing with unbounded operators, which complicates deriving standard equations like the GLE.
- Generalized Langevin Equation (GLE)
- The GLE describes the time evolution of a system by including both deterministic forces and memory effects from past interactions. The authors explore how to derive this equation, noting that for unitary evolution, it can be found directly without complex projection methods.
- Slow and Fast Variables Splitting
- This involves dividing the system's variables into two groups: fast ones that evolve quickly and slow ones that change slowly. The paper suggests defining slow variables based on a small time-derivative, which leads to the crucial finding that this splitting causes the memory term in the dynamics to vanish.
- Memory Term as Coupling Term
- The authors argue that the memory term in coarse-grained models should be viewed not strictly as 'memory' but as a coupling term. The splitting into slow and fast parts shows why this coupling vanishes under specific conditions, resembling a spectral decomposition where the memory effect disappears.
Terminology
Summary
Generalised Langevin Dynamics: Significance and Limitations of the Projection Operator Formalism discusses mathematical aspects of Mori’s projection operator formalism and its limitations in deriving generalized Langevin equations. p. 0
Mathematical Foundations
The core of the Mori-Zwanzig formalism is the generalised Langevin equation, which is typically derived from the Dyson-Duhamel identity. The authors recall the derivation of the projection operator formalism for Mori’s projection by means of semigroup theory and discuss where rigorous methods fail for Zwanzig’s projection when dealing with unbounded perturbations. p. 0 For bounded perturbations of the time-evolution operator, the Dyson-Duhamel identity coincides with the variation of constants formula. p. 0 Conversely, for unbounded perturbations like Zwanzig’s projection, the Dyson-Duhamel identity should be considered an equation for orthogonal dynamics for which unique solutions have not yet been established. p. 0
Derivation and Bounded Perturbations
The derivation of the generalized Langevin equation from sec. II A applies to the Mori projection operator provided that 0 ≠ z ∈ D(L) ∩ D(L†). p. 7 Since PM is a finite-rank projection with range in D(L†), the operator PML is densely defined and bounded. p. 7 This boundedness allows the use of semigroup theory to make sense of the Dyson-Duhamel equation as a variation of constants formula. p. 3 Specifically, for bounded PL, it follows that QL generates a strongly continuous semigroup G(t). p. 4 This leads to the generalized Langevin equation (6) for z ∈ D(L) and t ≥ 0. p. 0
Mori's GLE Derivation
For unitary time-evolution on real Hilbert spaces, the Mori-GLE can be derived directly from the continuity of the semigroup U(t) irrespective of projection or variation of constants methods. The authors show that for unitary time-evolution, one can demand a specific form for the GLE and impose the 2FDT to find unique functions f(t) and g(t). p. 8 This process results in a Volterra equation of the second kind for g(t), which yields the memory kernel K(t) and fluctuating forces η(t). p. 8
Limitations of Coarse-Graining
The Mori-GLE is not well-suited for modelling coarse-grained systems unless one can obtain a priori estimates of the different terms. The authors show that the fluctuation forces contain the full complexity of the dynamics because η(t) ∈ H requires full knowledge about the initial state Γ. p. 0 In practice, this often leads to resorting to Gaussian models, which merely reproduce statistical quantities rather than predicting dynamics. p. 9
Fast and Slow Variables
The notion of splitting into fast and slow variables requires careful consideration because a precise notion is often avoided. A suitable definition of slow variables involves finding a closed linear subspace Fω such that the time-derivative for some vector x in D(L) is small in some sense. This leads to the projection Pω onto Fω, and this splitting implies that the memory term vanishes because PωLQωx = 0 ∀x ∈ D(L). p. 0
Conclusion on Memory Term
The authors illustrate that the memory term should be considered a coupling term that is not necessarily related to memory. The projection operator formalism splits dynamics into slow and fast parts, but the closest definition of slow variables leads to subspaces invariant under time-evolution, hence they do not couple, causing the memory term to vanish. p. 0 The authors conclude that this splitting resembles a spectral decomposition where the memory term vanishes. p. 0
Where the gains come from
The paper establishes that all properties of Mori’s GLE can be derived without using the projection operator formalism at all, following directly from the well-posedness of Volterra equations. The fluctuation dissipation theorem holds by construction and should be viewed as defining the memory kernel rather than a theorem. p. 0 This derivation shows that Mori’s GLE does not reveal any non-trivial structure of the dynamics, and holds for any system described by a strongly continuous unitary group on a real Hilbert space. p. 9 The autocorrelation function C(t) can be related to the memory kernel K(t) via a Volterra equation of the second kind. p. 9 The authors note that in practice, analyzing the autocorrelation function C(t) is simpler than analyzing the memory kernel K(t). p. 9 The coarse-grained simulation reproduces statistical quantities but cannot predict dynamics unless reasonable approximations of the memory kernel are obtained. p. 9 The final point is that the memory term vanishes because the subspaces associated with spectral decomposition of skew-adjoint operators are invariant under time-evolution. p. 0 The authors conclude that this vanishing implies a coupling term compensates for the fact that QH is typically not U(t)-invariant. p. 9 The paper concludes by stating that the memory term vanishes because PωLQωx = 0 ∀x ∈ D(L). p. 0 The final sentence states that this splitting implies that the memory term vanishes. p. 0
Summary and Conclusion
The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is that all properties of Mori’s GLE can actually be derived without using the projection operator formalism at all. The authors conclude that this splitting implies that the memory term vanishes. p. 0 This demonstrates that the memory term is a coupling term that is not necessarily related to memory. p. 0 The paper concludes by stating that this splitting implies that the memory term vanishes. p. 0
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge funding by the German Research Foundation (DFG) in Project 535083866. We thank Martin Oettel, Jens Weimar, Nico van der Vegt, Niklas Wolf and Fabian Koch for helpful discussions. The paper cites numerous foundational works on projection operators and stochastic processes. p. 2 The authors provide several examples of unbounded perturbations like the Zwanzig-projector applied to a harmonic oscillator. p. 7 The work is situated within the context of open quantum systems and coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations. p. 2
References
[1] Robert Zwanzig. Nonequilibrium Statistical Mechanics. p. 1 Oxford University Press, 2001.
[2] Hermann Grabert. p. 0 Projection operator techniques in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics, volume 95. p. 1 Springer, 2006.
[3] Michael te Vrugt and Raphael Wittkowski. Projection operators in statistical mechanics: a pedagogical approach. p. 1 European Journal of Physics, 41(4):045101, 2020. p. 0
[4] Ian Snook. The Langevin and generalised Langevin approach to the dynamics of atomic, polymeric and colloidal systems. p. 0 Elsevier, 2006.
[5] Wolfgang G¨otze. Complex dynamics of glass-forming liquids: A mode-coupling theory, volume 143. p. 1 Oxford University Press, 2009.
[6] Heinz-Peter Breuer and Francesco Petruccione. The theory of open quantum systems. p. 1 OUP Oxford, 2002.
[7] Pep Espanol and Hartmut L¨owen. Derivation of dynamical density functional theory using the projection operator technique. p. 1 The Journal of chemical physics, 131(24), 2009. p. 0
[8] K Kawasaki. Simple derivations of generalized linear and nonlinear Langevin equations. p. 3 Journal of Physics A: Mathematical, Nuclear and General, 6(9):1289, sep 1973. p. 1
[9] Hazime Mori. p. 0 Transport, collective motion, and Brownian motion. p. 1 Progress of theoretical physics, 33(3):423–455, 1965. p. 6
[10] Alexandre J Chorin, Ole H Hald, and Raz Kupferman. Optimal prediction and the Mori–Zwanzig representation of irreversible processes. p. 9 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 97(7):2968–2973, 2000.
[11] Tanja Schilling. p. 0 Coarse-grained modelling out of equilibrium. p. 0 Physics Reports, 972:1–45, 2022. p. 0
[12] Anja Seegebrecht and Tanja Schilling. p. 0 The Concept of Minimal Dissipation and the Identification of Work in Autonomous Systems: a View from Classical Statistical Physics. p. 1 Journal of Statistical Physics, 192(10):133, 2025. p. 0
[13] Dror Givon, Raz Kupferman, and Ole H. p. 6 Hald. Existence proof for orthogonal dynamics and the Mori-Zwanzig formalism. p. 6 Israel Journal of Mathematics, 145(1):221–241, Dec 2005.
[14] Christoph Widder, Johannes Zimmer, and Tanja Schilling. p. 0 On the generalized Langevin equation and the Mori projection operator technique. p. 0 Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical, 58(40):405001, sep 2025. p. 0
[15] Robert Zwanzig. p. 0 Memory Effects in Irreversible Thermodynamics. p. 9 Phys. Rev., 124:983–992, Nov 1961.
[16] Klaus-Jochen Engel and Rainer Nagel. One-Parameter Semigroups for Linear Evolution Equations. p. 9 Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Springer New York, 2000.
[17] A. Pazy. Semigroups of Linear Operators and Applications to Partial Differential Equations. p. 6 Applied Mathematical Sciences. p. 1 Springer New York, 1983.
[18] Christoph Widder, Johannes Zimmer, and Tanja Schilling. p. 0 ADDENDUM: On the generalized Langevin equation and the Mori projection operator technique (2025 J. p. 0 Phys. A: Math. Theor. 58 405001). Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical, 59(22):229401, jun. p. 0
[19] Yuanran Zhu, Jason M. p. 4 Dominy, and Daniele Venturi. On the estimation of the Mori-Zwanzig memory integral. p. 0 Journal of Mathematical Physics, 59(10):103501, 09 2018. p. 0
[20] B. L. Holian and D. J. Evans. Classical response theory in the Heisenberg picture. p. 1 The Journal of Chemical Physics, 83(7):3560–3566, 10 1985. p. 0
[21] M. Reed and B. Simon. I: Functional Analysis. p. 1 p. 1 Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics. p. 0 Academic Press, revised and enlarged edition edition, 1980.
[22] W. Rudin. Functional Analysis. McGraw-Hill, second edition edition, 1991. p. 2
[23] J. M. Ball. Shorter Notes: Strongly Continuous Semigroups, Weak Solutions, and the Variation of Constants Formula. p. 3 Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 63(2):370–373, 1977. p. 0
[24] K. O. Friedrichs. p. 6 Symmetric hyperbolic linear differential equations. p. 6 Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 7(2):345–392, 1954. p. 1
[25] T. Kato. Perturbation Theory for Linear Operators. p. 6 Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 1995.
[26] Wolfgang Arendt. p. 7 Vector-valued laplace transforms and cauchy problems. p. 7 Israel Journal of Mathematics, 59(3):327–352, Oct 1987.
[27] K Richard Miller. p. 7 Volterra integral equations in a Banach space. p. 0 Funkcialaj Ekvacioj, 18(2):163–193, 1975.
[28] R. Grimmer and J. p. 7 Pr¨uss. On linear Volterra equations in Banach spaces. p. 0 Computers & Mathematics with Applications, 11(1):189–205, 1985.
[29] T. A. Burton. Volterra Integral and Differential Equations, volume 202 of Mathematics in Science and Engineering. p. 6 Elsevier, 2005.
[30] Ryogo Kubo. The fluctuation-dissipation theorem. p. 0 Reports on progress in physics, 29(1):255, 1966. p. 6
[31] Viktor Klippenstein, Madhusmita Tripathy, Gerhard Jung, Friederike Schmid, and Nico FA Van Der Vegt. Introducing memory in coarse-grained molecular simulations. p. 2 The Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 125(19):4931–4954, 2021. p. 9
[32] Zhen Li, Xin Bian, Xiantao Li, and George Em Karniadakis. Incorporation of memory effects in coarse-grained modeling via the Mori-Zwanzig formalism. p. 0 The Journal of chemical physics, 143(24), 2015. p. 0
[33] Sergei Izvekov. Microscopic derivation of particle-based coarse-grained dynamics. p. 2 The Journal of chemical physics, 138(13), 2013. p. 0
[34] Benjamin A Dalton, Anton Klimek, Henrik Kiefer, Florian N Br¨unig, H´el´ene Colinet, Lucas Tepper, Amir Abbasi, and Roland R Netz. Memory and friction: from the nanoscale to the macroscale. p. 0 Annual Review of Physical Chemistry, 76(1):431–454, 2025. p. 9
[35] Carmen Hij´on, Pep Espa˜nol, Eric Vanden-Eijnden, and Rafael Delgado-Buscalioni. Mori–Zwanzig formalism as a practical computational tool. p. 0 Faraday Discussions, 144:301–322, 10 2009.
[36] Yen Ting Lin, Yifeng Tian, Daniel Livescu, and Marian Anghel. Data-Driven Learning for the Mori–Zwanzig Formalism: A Generalization of the Koopman Learning Framework. p. 0 SIAM Journal on Applied Dynamical Systems, 20(4):2558–2601, 2021. p. 1
[37] Wong Eugene and Zakai Moshe. On the relation between ordinary and stochastic differential equations. p. 9 International Journal of Engineering Science, 3(2):213–229, 1965.
[38] Dror Givon and Raz Kupferman. p. 6 White noise limits for discrete dynamical systems driven by fast deterministic dynamics. p. 6 Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 335(3):385–412, 2004. p. 1
[39] Matthias Post, Steffen Wolf, and Gerhard Stock. Molecular origin of driving-dependent friction in fluids. p. 2 Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 18(5):2816–2825, 2022. p. 0
[40] Christoph Widder, Fabian Koch, and Tanja Schilling. p. 0 Generalized Langevin dynamics simulation with non-stationary memory kernels: How to make noise. p. 0 The Journal of Chemical Physics, 157(19):194107, 11 2022. p. 0
[41] M. Berkowitz, J. D. Morgan, and J. Andrew McCammon. Generalized Langevin dynamics simulations with arbitrary time-dependent memory kernels. p. 0 The Journal of Chemical Physics, 78(6):3256–3261, 03 1983. p. 0
[42] D. L. Cohn. Measure Theory. p. 0 Birkh¨auser New York, NY, 2013.
[43] A. Klenke. Probability Theory. p. 0 Springer Cham, 2020.
[44] Peter J. Brockwell and Richard A. Davis. Time Series: Theory and Methods. p. 0 Springer New York, 1991.
[45] B. O. Koopman. Hamiltonian Systems and Transformation in Hilbert Space, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 17(5):315–318, 1931. p. 6
[46] H. Spohn. Spectral properties of Liouville operators and their physical interpretation. p. 0 Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 80(4):323–338, 1975. p. 1
[47] W. Hunziker. The S-matrix in classical mechanics. p. 1 Communications in Mathematical Physics, 8(4):282–299, Dec 1968. p. 0
[48] B. A. Lengyel and M. H. Stone. Elementary Proof of the Spectral Theorem. p. 0 Annals of Mathematics, 37(4):853–864, 1936.
[49] Herbert Leinfelder. A geometric proof of the spectral theorem for unbounded self-adjoint operators. p. 0 Mathematische Annalen, 242(1):85–96, Feb 1979.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Better handling of projection operator formalism application by distinguishing between bounded and unbounded perturbations, which is crucial for rigorously deriving Generalized Langevin Equations (GLEs). This allows AI systems to correctly assess whether a derivation based on the Dyson-Duhamel identity is mathematically sound or requires further investigation into the existence of unique solutions for unbounded cases.
-
Implementation of a mechanism to automatically determine if a projection operator leads to a memory term vanishing by checking invariance under time evolution, as shown in Section V. This capability allows AI systems to identify situations where the memory term
vanishes
and simplify complex dynamics into subspace semigroups. -
Development of an approach for coarse-grained simulations that avoids fitting the GLE to data, instead allowing direct sampling from multivariate Gaussian distributions based on autocorrelation functions. This enables AI systems to reproduce statistical quantities without numerical integration errors associated with fitting, leading to more robust coarse-grained models for complex systems.
Related papers
- Existence of a fluid phase for the two-dimensional one-component plasma
- The Huang-Yang conjecture for the low-density Fermi gas
- Anderson localisation in infinite and finite resonator crystals with long-range interactions
- Free energy and spectral edge of the SYK model
- Anderson localization for 1-d quasi-periodic Schr"odinger operators with degenerate weights
- Irregular SLE(4) martingales and isomonodromic deformations