On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs

arXiv:2604.19885 · hep-th, math-ph, math.MP · Submitted 2026-04-21 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs, this paper elaborates on the relation between generalized Schur indices of N=2 SCFTs in four dimensions and the non-relativistic limit of the elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model, which is important because it connects these limits to other integrable models and N=1 SCFTs Connecting Integrable Models to Index Limits The paper discusses how the non-relativistic limits of various integrable models give rise naturally to generalized Schur-like limits of classes of N=1 SCFTs The authors elaborate on the relation between the generalized Schur index of N=2 SCFTs in four dimensions and the non-relativistic limit of the elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model They explicitly discuss how to express generalized Schur indices of theories of class S in terms of elliptic Jack functions, noting that in the A1 case, these indices are given naturally in terms of eigenfunctions of the Lamé equation The mapping between different theories in the Deligne-Cvitanović series is shown to imply non-trivial identities on unrefined sums of eigenfunctions of non-relativistic elliptic Calogero-Moser models associated with different root systems The Generalized Schur Limit for N=2 Theories The generalized Schur partition function is introduced as the elliptic non-relativistic limit of the RS model The full index of a 4d N=2 SCFT is given by a complex expression involving parameters q, p, and t The authors show that for the Schur limit, where t=q, the index counts states annihilated by two supercharges They demonstrate that this limit is independent of epsilon formally in both special values of alpha, and it is related to the free fermionic limit of a non-relativistic integrable model The generalized Schur index can be understood as being related to the free fermionic limit of a non-relativistic integrable model A1 Class S and Elliptic Jack Functions The study begins with the N=2 A1 class S, where all theories have an explicit N=2 Lagrangian description The eigenfunctions of the A1 RS operators are expected to be orthogonal under a specific measure For special limits such as Schur, Macdonald, and Hall-Littlewood, the eigenfunctions are known as Schur, Macdonald polynomials, and Hall-Littlewood polynomials respectively The paper derives explicit expressions for these eigenfunctions in the non-relativistic limit using a combination of diagonalizing the index and utilizing instanton partition functions Higher Rank Limits and E-string Compactifications The study extends to higher rank models, such as the A2 case, where the generalized Schur index can be expressed in terms of eigenfunctions of the A2 elliptic Calogero-Moser model The authors check an instance of the equality connecting the generalized Schur index of the rank one E6 Minahan-Nemeschansky theory and SU(2) N=2 conformal SQCD using A1 and A2 elliptic Jack functions Furthermore, they extend this notion to classes of N=1 theories obtained by compactifications of the 6d (1, 0) rank Q E-string theory, relating them to the Inozemtsev model which is the non-relativistic limit of the van Diejen model The paper concludes by summarizing that in both models, the Calogero-Moser and Inozemtsev models have potentials related to ratios of chemical potentials of the 4d index computation The results suggest that different limits of indices of different theories sometimes coincide, which hints at flows across dimensions The paper raises questions about whether well-defined non-relativistic limits exist for other types of compactifications and whether the strongly-coupled models obtained in this way are an indication of existence of a large landscape of such models or rather an esoteric curiosity The results suggest that the generalized indices corresponding to non-relativistic limits could be a useful tool to study such flows across dimensions B Contributions of N=2 Multiplets in the Non-Relativistic Limit The non-relativistic limit of the index of an interacting N=2 theory has pole singularities due to non-trivial Coulomb branches, and stripping off this singularity leads to an expansion with non-integer coefficients depending on alpha The paper discusses how different multiplets contribute as, for example, IC¯R,r(j1,j2) → 0 The contributions of E¯r(0,0) and D¯ 0(0,0) are order zero in rho (not suppressed by powers of rho), leading to divergences if there are infinite numbers of such multiplets Definitions of Special Functions The paper defines several basic special functions, including the q-Pochhammer symbol, the theta-function, and the elliptic Gamma function The elliptic Gamma function is defined to be Y∞ i,j=0 1 − q i+1p j+1z − 1 − p iq jz These definitions are used in the subsequent analysis of the index expansions More Technical Details on A2 Wavefunctions The appendix provides explicit expressions for normalized eigenfunctions and structure constants for the A2 case, derived both from 5d instanton computation and by solving the spectrum of the elliptic Calogero-Moser model The normalization coefficients Cλλ1,λ2 are computed to be as follows These eigenfunctions are related to the wavefunctions psi obtained by directly solving the elliptic A2 CM differential equation with the explicit results collected in appendix D The authors summarize that in both models, the Calogero-Moser and Inozemtsev models have potentials related to ratios of chemical potentials of the 4d index computation The results suggest that different limits of indices of different theories sometimes coincide, which hints at flows across dimensions The generalized indices corresponding to non-relativistic limits could be a useful tool to study such flows across dimensions The results raise many additional questions about the existence of well-defined non-relativistic limits for other types of compactifications and whether some observations can be explained by RG flows A Comments on the Schur Index and RG Flows The Schur index is independent of beta which serves as a regulator for the computation of the trace The careful analysis of the index as a partition function reveals that some UV data is retained [2604.19885> In particular this leads to the interesting relations of the Schur index of non-conformal theories and counting of massive BPS states on the Coulomb branch The full index can be obtained from (1.1) by setting t=q, where the regulator explicitly uses U(1r) symmetry and thus there is no puzzle regarding invariance under RG flows B Contributions of N=2 Multiplets in the Non-Relativistic Limit The non-relativistic limit of the index of an interacting N=2 theory has pole singularities due to non-trivial Coulomb branches, and stripping off this singularity leads to an expansion with non-integer coefficients depending on alpha The contributions of E¯r(0,0) and D¯ 0(0,0) are order zero in rho (not suppressed by powers of rho), leading to divergences if there are infinite numbers of such multiplets C Definitions of Special Functions The paper defines the q-Pochhammer symbol, the theta-function, and the elliptic Gamma function The elliptic Gamma function is defined to be Y∞ i,j=0 1 − q i+1p j+1z − 1 − p iq jz These definitions are used in the subsequent analysis of the index expansions D More Technical Details on A2 Wavefunctions The appendix provides explicit expressions for normalized eigenfunctions and structure constants for A2 case, derived both from 5d instanton computation and by solving the spectrum of the elliptic Calogero-Moser model The normalization coefficients Cλλ1,λ2 are computed to be as follows These eigenfunctions are related to the wavefunctions psi obtained by directly solving the elliptic A2 CM differential equation with the explicit results collected in appendix D The authors summarize that in both models, the Calogero-Moser and Inozemtsev models have potentials related to ratios of chemical potentials of the 4d index computation The results suggest that different limits of indices of different theories sometimes coincide, which hints at flows across dimensions The generalized indices corresponding to non-relativistic limits could be a useful tool to study such flows across dimensions A Comments on the Schur Index and RG Flows The Schur index is independent of beta which serves as a regulator for the computation of the trace The careful analysis of the index as a partition function reveals that some UV data is retained [2604.19885> In particular this leads to the interesting relations of the Schur index of non-conformal theories and counting of massive BPS states on the Coulomb branch The full index can be obtained from (1.

Title and authors: Kai: So, we’re starting with "On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs," and the title itself tells us this paper connects two seemingly different worlds: four dimensional superconformal field theories and these non-relativistic integrable models.

Mira: Exactly, Kai. The authors are linking the generalized Schur index of those four dimensional n two superconformal field theories to the non relativistic limit of something called the elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model.

Lev: I’m wondering what that means for us when we think about our own hardware. Is this just some abstract math, or does it point toward something tangible we can simulate?

Kai: It's not just abstract math, Lev; they show how the generalized Schur index of these four dimensional theories can be written in terms of elliptic Jack functions.

Mira: And for the A one class S theories specifically, those indices naturally show up as eigenfunctions of what’s called the Lamé equation. That’s a very concrete link to known mathematical physics tools.

Lev: So if we start with these specific eigenfunctions, does that mean we can actually calculate something useful, or is this just mapping abstract states to known functions?

Kai: It's more than mapping; they use those eigenfunctions to check a recent observation that the generalized Schur indices of different theories in the Deligne Cvitanović series can actually be mapped onto each other.

Mira: That mapping implies some non trivial identities on unrefined sums of eigenfunctions from those non relativistic elliptic Calogero Moser models associated with different root systems.

Lev: If they can map between these different theories, does that mean we find universal constraints on what kind of physics can exist in this context, regardless of the specific details we start with?

Kai: That’s right; it suggests that the underlying symmetries are more flexible than you might assume when you look at just one theory in isolation.

Mira: It's about establishing that the structure of these theories is dictated by these shared algebraic properties, which is a big deal for understanding the whole landscape.

Lev: So, it’s a way to find universal constraints on what kind of physics can actually exist in this context, regardless of the specific details we start with.

The paper's summary: Kai: Moving on to the actual summary of "On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs," it boils down to these two non relativistic integrable models, the Calogero Moser and the Inozemtsev model, having potentials that are directly related to ratios of chemical potentials from the four dimensional index computation.

Mira: That’s a strong point. They also suggest that different limits of indices from different theories sometimes coincide, which hints at flows across dimensions. This is a big idea for how we see physics flowing between different descriptions.

Lev: If those indices can coincide under certain limits, does that mean we might be able to use these generalized indices as a tool to study those flows across dimensions, which is an exciting prospect?

Kai: They raise questions about whether well defined non relativistic limits exist for other types of compactifications and whether the strongly coupled models obtained in this way are just an esoteric curiosity or something more significant.

Mira: The paper ends by suggesting that these generalized indices corresponding to non relativistic limits could be a useful tool to study those flows across dimensions. It’s about using these tools to map out the landscape of possible physical scenarios.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means if we can find a way to use this tool consistently, you might gain control over the flow between different regimes in your simulation.

Kai: I think it points toward a more holistic understanding where all these limits are part of one larger picture, not just separate pieces of research.

Mira: It’s about seeing how the renormalization group flows connect everything together through these non relativistic limits and indices. That’s the core message for us to take away from this work.

Lev: So, it’s telling us that we need to keep looking for ways to define those limits robustly because if we can't define them, then the whole picture of dimensional flows breaks down.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Regarding the improvements suggested by this paper, they suggest using eigenfunctions like elliptic Jack functions for a better connection to the A one class S theories, as discussed in section two and nine.

Mira: And they also mention checking the relationship between different supersymmetric indices through Figure one, which helps map out those Coulomb Hall Littlewood Macdonald limits and the non relativistic limit of the rs model.

Lev: For me, that means we need to be able to see those maps clearly. If you can't visualize that mapping easily, it’s hard for error correction because you can't see how one error scheme relates to another.

Kai: And they also suggest analyzing RG flows breaking u r symmetry by looking at how the generalized Schur partition functions are related by parameter maps involving superpotential deformations or vacuum expectation values.

Mira: That implies that the generalized Schur partition functions aren't static objects; they can change depending on those deformations, which is important because it shows they can track changes in the theory.

Lev: That’s useful for running simulations because it means you don't have to re-simulate everything from scratch if you can understand how a simulation will evolve under those specific parameter changes.

Kai: So, these suggested improvements suggest we need better methods for tracking how these generalized indices change as the parameters move. It’s about understanding the dynamics of the system through these index maps.

Mira: It’s about moving from static results to dynamic relationships where you can see how they evolve under those deformations and see what happens in those flows.

Lev: So, if we can track that evolution, we might be able to design systems that adapt to changing conditions rather than just being fixed points on a parameter landscape.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up this discussion on "On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs," the paper shows the main implication is that these generalized indices corresponding to non relativistic limits can be a useful tool to study those flows across dimensions.

Mira: It’s about using these tools to map out the landscape of possible physical scenarios, connecting different theoretical descriptions through dimensional flows.

Lev: And from an engineering perspective, it means if we can find a way to use this tool consistently, you might gain control over the flow between different regimes in your simulation.

Kai: We’ll be looking at how these tools help us understand those complex connections and see what they mean for the next steps in our research.

Mira: This work is important because it shows that renormalization group flows are connected to these non relativistic limits in a way that we can actually use to probe the landscape of physics.

Lev: We’re glad we could discuss this, but now it's time to move on and see what other papers have for us.

Rotem Ben Zeev, Anirudh Deb, Hee-Cheol Kim, Shlomo S. Razamat

Department of Physics, Technion · C.N.Yang Institute for Theoretical Physics, Stony Brook University · Department of Physics, POSTECH · Asia Pacific Center for Theoretical Physics, POSTECH

hep-th, math-ph, math.MP

Submitted: 2026-04-21

Updated: 2026-09-17

Comments: 50 pages, 3 figures; v3: Added clarifications on the non-relativistic limit, TQFT structure, and the class S/E-string relation. Expanded the discussion of the connection to integrable systems. Definitions and explanations improved, and typos corrected

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 21, 110 (2026)

DOI: 10.21468/SciPostPhys.21.5.110

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 84/100

The gist: On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs, this paper elaborates on the relation between generalized Schur indices of N=2 SCFTs in four dimensions and the non-relativistic limit of the…

Key concepts

Generalized Schur Index
This is a complex mathematical index calculated for N=2 SCFTs in four dimensions. The paper shows it relates directly to the non-relativistic limit of the Ruijsenaars-Schneider model, providing a way to count specific states in these theories.
Elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider Model
This is an integrable model that has a non-relativistic limit. The generalized Schur partition function is its elliptic non-relativistic limit. This connection allows researchers to study the SCFT index using tools from this simpler, related integrable system.
Elliptic Jack Functions
These are special functions used to express the generalized Schur indices of N=2 theories, particularly in the A1 class S. The paper derives explicit expressions for these functions in the non-relativistic limit, showing how they relate to eigenfunctions of specific differential equations.
RG Flows and Dimensional Flows
The paper suggests that different limits of indices from various theories can coincide. This hints at flows across dimensions, where one physical theory might smoothly transition into another as parameters change. The generalized indices are proposed as a tool to study these transitions.

Terminology

Summary

On non-relativistic integrable models and 4d SCFTs, this paper elaborates on the relation between generalized Schur indices of N=2 SCFTs in four dimensions and the non-relativistic limit of the elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model, which is important because it connects these limits to other integrable models and N=1 SCFTs

Connecting Integrable Models to Index Limits

The paper discusses how the non-relativistic limits of various integrable models give rise naturally to generalized Schur-like limits of classes of N=1 SCFTs The authors elaborate on the relation between the generalized Schur index of N=2 SCFTs in four dimensions and the non-relativistic limit of the elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model They explicitly discuss how to express generalized Schur indices of theories of class S in terms of elliptic Jack functions, noting that in the A1 case, these indices are given naturally in terms of eigenfunctions of the Lamé equation The mapping between different theories in the Deligne-Cvitanović series is shown to imply non-trivial identities on unrefined sums of eigenfunctions of non-relativistic elliptic Calogero-Moser models associated with different root systems

The Generalized Schur Limit for N=2 Theories

The generalized Schur partition function is introduced as the elliptic non-relativistic limit of the RS model The full index of a 4d N=2 SCFT is given by a complex expression involving parameters q, p, and t The authors show that for the Schur limit, where t=q, the index counts states annihilated by two supercharges They demonstrate that this limit is independent of epsilon formally in both special values of alpha, and it is related to the free fermionic limit of a non-relativistic integrable model The generalized Schur index can be understood as being related to the free fermionic limit of a non-relativistic integrable model

A1 Class S and Elliptic Jack Functions

The study begins with the N=2 A1 class S, where all theories have an explicit N=2 Lagrangian description The eigenfunctions of the A1 RS operators are expected to be orthogonal under a specific measure For special limits such as Schur, Macdonald, and Hall-Littlewood, the eigenfunctions are known as Schur, Macdonald polynomials, and Hall-Littlewood polynomials respectively The paper derives explicit expressions for these eigenfunctions in the non-relativistic limit using a combination of diagonalizing the index and utilizing instanton partition functions

Higher Rank Limits and E-string Compactifications

The study extends to higher rank models, such as the A2 case, where the generalized Schur index can be expressed in terms of eigenfunctions of the A2 elliptic Calogero-Moser model The authors check an instance of the equality connecting the generalized Schur index of the rank one E6 Minahan-Nemeschansky theory and SU(2) N=2 conformal SQCD using A1 and A2 elliptic Jack functions Furthermore, they extend this notion to classes of N=1 theories obtained by compactifications of the 6d (1, 0) rank Q E-string theory, relating them to the Inozemtsev model which is the non-relativistic limit of the van Diejen model

Summary and Future Directions

The paper concludes by summarizing that in both models, the Calogero-Moser and Inozemtsev models have potentials related to ratios of chemical potentials of the 4d index computation The results suggest that different limits of indices of different theories sometimes coincide, which hints at flows across dimensions The paper raises questions about whether well-defined non-relativistic limits exist for other types of compactifications and whether the strongly-coupled models obtained in this way are an indication of existence of a large landscape of such models or rather an esoteric curiosity The results suggest that the generalized indices corresponding to non-relativistic limits could be a useful tool to study such flows across dimensions

B Contributions of N=2 Multiplets in the Non-Relativistic Limit

The non-relativistic limit of the index of an interacting N=2 theory has pole singularities due to non-trivial Coulomb branches, and stripping off this singularity leads to an expansion with non-integer coefficients depending on alpha The paper discusses how different multiplets contribute as, for example, IC¯R,r(j1,j2) → 0 The contributions of E¯r(0,0) and D¯ 0(0,0) are order zero in rho (not suppressed by powers of rho), leading to divergences if there are infinite numbers of such multiplets

Definitions of Special Functions

The paper defines several basic special functions, including the q-Pochhammer symbol, the theta-function, and the elliptic Gamma function The elliptic Gamma function is defined to be Y∞ i,j=0 1 − q i+1p j+1z − 1 − p iq jz These definitions are used in the subsequent analysis of the index expansions

More Technical Details on A2 Wavefunctions

The appendix provides explicit expressions for normalized eigenfunctions and structure constants for the A2 case, derived both from 5d instanton computation and by solving the spectrum of the elliptic Calogero-Moser model The normalization coefficients Cλλ1,λ2 are computed to be as follows These eigenfunctions are related to the wavefunctions psi obtained by directly solving the elliptic A2 CM differential equation with the explicit results collected in appendix D

Summary and Discussion

The authors summarize that in both models, the Calogero-Moser and Inozemtsev models have potentials related to ratios of chemical potentials of the 4d index computation The results suggest that different limits of indices of different theories sometimes coincide, which hints at flows across dimensions The generalized indices corresponding to non-relativistic limits could be a useful tool to study such flows across dimensions The results raise many additional questions about the existence of well-defined non-relativistic limits for other types of compactifications and whether some observations can be explained by RG flows

A Comments on the Schur Index and RG Flows

The Schur index is independent of beta which serves as a regulator for the computation of the trace The careful analysis of the index as a partition function reveals that some UV data is retained [2604.19885> In particular this leads to the interesting relations of the Schur index of non-conformal theories and counting of massive BPS states on the Coulomb branch The full index can be obtained from (1. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Note that the full index can be defined as a weighted counting of certain supersymmetric states/operators in the theory. Coulomb/Macdonald/Hall-Littlewood/Schur limits still have a counting interpretation.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Note that the full index can be defined as a weighted counting of certain supersymmetric states/operators in the theory. Coulomb/Macdonald/Hall-Littlewood/Schur limits still have a counting interpretation.

1) by setting t=q, where the regulator explicitly uses U(1r) symmetry and thus there is no puzzle regarding invariance under RG flows

The non-relativistic limit of the index of an interacting N=2 theory has pole singularities due to non-trivial Coulomb branches, and stripping off this singularity leads to an expansion with non-integer coefficients depending on alpha The contributions of E¯r(0,0) and D¯ 0(0,0) are order zero in rho (not suppressed by powers of rho), leading to divergences if there are infinite numbers of such multiplets

C Definitions of Special Functions

The paper defines the q-Pochhammer symbol, the theta-function, and the elliptic Gamma function The elliptic Gamma function is defined to be Y∞ i,j=0 1 − q i+1p j+1z − 1 − p iq jz These definitions are used in the subsequent analysis of the index expansions

D More Technical Details on A2 Wavefunctions

The appendix provides explicit expressions for normalized eigenfunctions and structure constants for A2 case, derived both from 5d instanton computation and by solving the spectrum of the elliptic Calogero-Moser model The normalization coefficients Cλλ1,λ2 are computed to be as follows These eigenfunctions are related to the wavefunctions psi obtained by directly solving the elliptic A2 CM differential equation with the explicit results collected in appendix D

The authors summarize that in both models, the Calogero-Moser and Inozemtsev models have potentials related to ratios of chemical potentials of the 4d index computation The results suggest that different limits of indices of different theories sometimes coincide, which hints at flows across dimensions The generalized indices corresponding to non-relativistic limits could be a useful tool to study such flows across dimensions

The Schur index is independent of beta which serves as a regulator for the computation of the trace The careful analysis of the index as a partition function reveals that some UV data is retained [2604.19885> In particular this leads to the interesting relations of the Schur index of non-conformal theories and counting of massive BPS states on the Coulomb branch The full index can be obtained from (1.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to relate non-relativistic limits of integrable models directly to generalized Schur indices of N=2 SCFTs by explicitly using eigenfunctions like elliptic Jack functions for A1 class S theories, as discussed in Section 2 and 9.

  2. Enhanced capacity to derive structure constants for higher rank integrable models, such as the A2 case, by utilizing the Argyres-Seiberg duality to relate indices expressed in terms of A1 and A2 eigenfunctions.

  3. Capability to compute explicit non-relativistic limits of physical theories like E-string compactifications and the van Diejen model by applying specific parameter scaling limits (e.g., p -> 1, epsilon -> 0) to elliptic Gamma functions, as detailed in Section 4.1 and Page 29.

  4. Improved understanding of the relationship between different supersymmetric indices through Figure 1, enabling the mapping between Coulomb/Hall-Littlewood/Macdonald limits and the non-relativistic limit of the RS model.

  5. Enhanced ability to analyze RG flows breaking U(1r) symmetry by identifying how generalized Schur partition functions are related by parameter maps involving superpotential deformations or vacuum expectation values, as shown in Section 5.

Abstract

We elaborate on the relation between the generalized Schur index of N=2 SCFTs in four dimensions and the non-relativistic limit of the elliptic Ruijsenaars-Schneider model. In particular we discuss explicitly how to express generalized Schur indices of theories of class S in terms of elliptic Jack functions. For example, in the A 1 case the indices are given naturally in terms of eigenfunctions of the Lamé equation. We use the expression in terms of eigenfunctions to further check the recent observation that the generalized Schur indices of different theories in the Deligne-Cvitanović series can be mapped onto each other. This mapping implies non trivial identities on unrefined sums of eigenfunctions of non-relativistic elliptic Calogero-Moser models associated to different root systems. We claim then that the non-relativistic limits of various integrable models give rise naturally to generalized Schur-like limits of classes of N=1 SCFTs. As an example we discuss the relation of the Inozemtsev model, the non relativistic limit of the van Diejen model, and compactifications of the rank Q E-string theory. We argue that in general the ``Schur index'' of N=1 4d SCFTs can be understood as being related to the free fermionic limit of a non-relativistic integrable model.

Sources

Related papers