A dynamical implementation of colour coherence for quenched jets in JEWEL

arXiv:2604.13932 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-04-15 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A dynamical implementation of colour coherence for quenched jets in JEWEL".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Colour coherence affects the radiation pattern of hard partons both in vacuum and in a dense coloured background formed in heavy ion collisions In this paper I present the implementation of colour coherence in the Jewel event generator for jet evolution in a dense medium This dynamical implementation dynamically decides which structures stay coherent by checking whether the momentum transfer of the scattering is sufficient to resolve the colour dipole Scatterings that resolve an individual parton disrupt the colour coherence, which affects the next splitting via the loss of angular ordering This leads to a suppression of hard radiation, and consequently a reduction in overall scattering rate, which is the dominant source of effects of colour coherence observable in reconstructed jets.

Kai: Colour coherence is defined as the interference between partons carrying matching colour and anti-colour The physical picture suggests that when two partons are not resolved individually by a process, like the emission of an additional gluon, they remain coherent and effectively act as one object.

Mira: This interference leads to phenomena such as the string or drag effect experimentally first observed in electron–positron collisions Another consequence of soft gluon interference is the formation of the hump-backed plateau of the MLLA observed at Lep by the Opal experiment.

Kai: Colour coherence is also responsible for angular ordering property of subsequent gluon emissions in parton showers.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap this paper on "A dynamical implementation of colour coherence for quenched jets in JEWEL," the thesis is that colour coherence affects the radiation pattern of hard partons in both vacuum and a dense coloured background formed in heavy ion collisions Kai They present an implementation of colour coherence within the Jewel event generator for jet evolution in a dense medium Kai The key mechanism they introduce is checking if the momentum transfer of a scattering is sufficient to resolve the colour dipole Kai This dynamically decides which structures stay coherent because scatterings that resolve an individual parton disrupt the colour connection, which affects subsequent splitting via the loss of angular ordering Kai

Mira: They argue that this dynamic approach leads to a suppression of hard radiation and consequently a reduction in overall scattering rate, which they identify as the dominant source of effects of colour coherence observable in reconstructed jets Mira This is important because it ties the physical concept, like interference between matched colour and anti-colour partons, directly to measurable jet observables Mira

Lev: From a theoretical viewpoint, this means that instead of treating coherence as a global property we can test it locally based on the interaction scale between the hard parton and the medium constituent Lev That’s a shift from what you might see in simpler models where you just assume some medium modification factor Lev

Kai: And they show how this impacts jet observables, including the nuclear modification factor, jet fragmentation function, and jet–hadron correlations Kai They also show how this implementation changes Jewel two point six compared to earlier versions Kai <ref:2604.13932#pg2,Jewel 2.6 compared to earlier versions>

Mira: It’s significant that they compare the ratios of these jet fragmentation functions and those correlations in central Pb+Pb collisions with colour coherence versus without induced emissions Mira That comparison is what really highlights the impact on observables Mira

Lev: If we were translating this to a real simulation, we have to think about how this new feature impacts the performance of the code when running compared to older versions where angular ordering was always enforced Lev It’s not just a conceptual change; it’s about computational feasibility on actual hardware.

Kai: And they detail the parameter settings for Jewel two point six, including PTMIN three PTMAX one thousand two hundred ETAMAX four and PDFSET thirteen thousand one hundred for p+p and PDFSET nine hundred one thousand three hundred for Pb+Pb Kai They also mention that the angular ordering options are now ANGORD equals zero to five Kai

Mira: And they point out the default choice is to have coherent scattering always on because the first splitting typically has a very short formation time and the scattering rate at very early times is not high Mira That’s a practical setting based on physics about early-time evolution Mira.

Lev: I see that, from an engineering standpoint, that default choice makes sense because it minimizes unnecessary checks when the system is evolving quickly and coherence is likely to persist initially Lev But we still need to worry about the constraints they mentioned on coherent states not being able to consist of more than two partons Lev.

Kai: So, this paper demonstrates how you can dynamically implement colour coherence in Jewel for jet evolution in a dense medium Kai It sets up the stage for understanding how it affects things like angular ordering when resolved scatterings disrupt the coherence Kai

Conclusion: Mira: To conclude this paper on "A dynamical implementation of colour coherence for quenched jets in JEWEL," the main point is that turning colour coherence on doesn't affect the number of scatterings per parton much Mira But it has important consequences for the radiation because it suppresses both medium induced and hard vacuum-like emissions Mira

Kai: The changes in the fragmentation pattern are largely responsible for those effects of colour coherence observed in the hadronic final state Kai And this reduction in medium response due to colour coherence is also visible in the jet fragmentation function and jet–hadron correlations Kai

Lev: So, what this means practically is that modeling that subtle change in fragmentation pattern might be crucial if we want to accurately interpret those final state measurements from heavy ion collisions Lev It’s not just about the overall quenching factor; it’s about the internal structure of how the jet fragments Lev

Kai: This paper on "A dynamical implementation of colour coherence for quenched jets in JEWEL" shows that we have a way to dynamically implement colour coherence by checking if the momentum transfer is sufficient to resolve the colour dipole Kai It sets up the stage for understanding how this affects angular ordering when resolved scatterings disrupt it Kai

Mira: The authors are also making changes in Jewel two point six, allowing angular ordering to be turned on or off for each individual splitting based on whether the parton or its colour partner experienced a resolved scattering Mira They note that coherent states can only consist of more than two partons and that coherent scatterings of dipoles must be elastic Mira <ref:2604.13932#pg2,changes in Jewel 2.6>

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, we have to make sure our simulation handles those constraints correctly when mapping those coherence checks onto a physical realization Lev That constraint about elastic coherent scattering of dipoles is something you have to model carefully in the hardware mapping.

Korinna Zapp

Lund University

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-04-15

Updated: 2026-10-29

Comments: 51 pages, 33 figures, published version, code available at jewel.hepforge.org

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Colour coherence affects the radiation pattern of hard partons both in vacuum and in a dense coloured background formed in heavy ion collisions In this paper I present the implementation of colour…

Key concepts

Colour Coherence
This is the interference between partons carrying matching color and anti-color. When two partons are not resolved individually by a process, they act as one object, leading to interference effects like the string effect and influencing angular ordering in gluon emissions.
Colour Dipole Scattering
The model checks if the momentum transfer from a scattering is enough to resolve a color dipole. If it is resolved, the color connection between the two partons breaks, disrupting coherence and causing subsequent splitting behavior to change.
Angular Ordering
This property dictates that subsequent gluon emissions in parton showers must be ordered angularly. Color coherence affects this by suppressing radiation when coherence is maintained, which impacts how jets fragment and how they look in detectors.

Terminology

Summary

Colour coherence affects the radiation pattern of hard partons both in vacuum and in a dense coloured background formed in heavy ion collisions In this paper I present the implementation of colour coherence in the Jewel event generator for jet evolution in a dense medium This dynamical implementation dynamically decides which structures stay coherent by checking whether the momentum transfer of the scattering is sufficient to resolve the colour dipole Scatterings that resolve an individual parton disrupt the colour coherence, which affects the next splitting via the loss of angular ordering This leads to a suppression of hard radiation, and consequently a reduction in overall scattering rate, which is the dominant source of effects of colour coherence observable in reconstructed jets. p. 0

Introduction to Colour Coherence

Colour coherence is defined as the interference between partons carrying matching colour and anti-colour The physical picture suggests that when two partons are not resolved individually by a process, like the emission of an additional gluon, they remain coherent and effectively act as one object. This interference leads to phenomena such as the string or drag effect experimentally first observed in electron–positron collisions Another consequence of soft gluon interference is the formation of the hump-backed plateau of the MLLA observed at Lep by the Opal experiment. p. 1 Colour coherence is also responsible for angular ordering property of subsequent gluon emissions in parton showers. p. 1 In heavy ion collisions, interest arises from theoretical expectations that interactions with a coloured background medium are also affected by it The physical picture emerging from first calculations suggests that an antenna radiates coherently when the medium does not resolve the separation between two partons, and they radiate independently when resolved by the medium. p. 1

Implementation in Jewel

The implementation of colour coherence in Jewel involves checking if the momentum transfer of a scattering is sufficient to resolve the colour dipole Scatterings that resolve an individual parton disrupt the colour connection and thus break the coherence. The model simulates individual re-scatterings off medium constituents, allowing for a more dynamical modelling of colour coherence at the level of individual interactions. p. 3 Specifically, Jewel checks whether parton b or c underwent a re-scattering before splitting to decide if angular ordering is required when b and c split. p. 7 The coherent scattering of a dipole is only elastic, and its transverse momentum transfer must be larger than the transverse size of the dipole for coherence to be lost. p. 3

Effects on Jet Observables

The consequences of colour coherence are visible in jet observables, including the nuclear modification factor, jet fragmentation function, and jet–hadron correlations. The implementation leads to a significantly harder fragmentation pattern with fewer splittings. p. 3 The number of scatterings per parton does not change much, but since fewer partons are produced, the total number of scatterings and with it the medium response component is reduced. p. 3 This reduction in medium response is visible in the jet fragmentation function and jet–hadron correlations. p. 0

Comparison with Experimental Data

The comparison of different angular ordering options shows that the kinematics first option yields better agreement with p+p data on jet fragmentation functions and jet–hadron correlations. The angular ordering first option leads to a clearly too soft fragmentation when angular ordering is always enforced. p. 9 The nuclear modification factor changes much less when colour coherence is turned on compared to the kinematics only setting. p. 0 p. 0 The jet fragmentation functions distinguish between scenarios with and without colour coherence even when the nuclear modification factor is the same. p. 0

Conclusion

The main conclusion is that turning colour coherence on does not affect the number of scatterings per parton much, but it has important consequences for the radiation since it suppresses both medium induced and hard vacuum-like emissions. The changes in the fragmentation pattern are to a large extent responsible for the effects of colour coherence observed in the hadronic final state. p. 1 The reduction in medium response due to colour coherence is also visible in the jet fragmentation function and jet–hadron correlations. p. 0

Changes in Jewel 2. p. 16

The new version of Jewel 2.6 includes a main new feature, the colour coherence implementation. p. 1 This implementation allows angular ordering to be turned on or off for each individual splitting depending on whether the splitting parton or its colour partner experienced a resolved scattering. p. 3 The main limitations are that coherent states cannot consist of more than two partons and coherent scatterings of dipoles can only be elastic. p. 3

Parameter Settings

The parameter settings for Jewel 2.6 include PTMIN 3, PTMAX 1200, ETAMAX 4, ISOCHANNEL PP SQRTS 5020, PDFSET 13100 (p+p) and 901300 (Pb+Pb), WEXPO 4. p. 2 p. 25. The angular ordering options are now ANGORD = 0 to ANGORD = 5. p. 6 The switch for coherent scattering of unresolved colour dipoles is COHSCAT T, F. p. 2 p. 2 The default choice is to have it always on since the first splitting typically has a very short formation time and the scattering rate at very early times is not high. p. 8

Final Summary of Effects

The general approach to only treat partons as individual objects after their separation is resolved by the medium and to let the coherent state interact until then is similar to in the Hybrid Model. The key difference lies in how hard partons interact in the background medium, as Jewel simulates individual scattering processes while the Hybrid Model assumes a strong coupling scenario where resolution scale is defined solely by temperature. p. 3 The effects of colour coherence on the radiation pattern are absent in the Hybrid Model because it does not treat fluctuations in momentum transfers due to strong coupling. p. 2

Key Findings on Coherence

The fraction of coherent dipoles that experience re-scatterings hard enough to induce radiation is roughly 5 · 10−4. Colour coherence thus affects only a small number of all partons, but for those that are affected it is an important effect. p. 1 The left panel of figure 14 shows the squared four-momentum transfers tˆ for different types of re-scatterings. p. 2 Colour coherence is more important at early times when the colour charges are still close together and the parton shower evolves rapidly producing new dipoles. The coherent scenarios with and without induced emissions yield almost identical nuclear modification factors. p. 9 The jet fragmentation functions reveal a reduction of soft particles inside the jets due to colour coherence. p. 0 p. 0

Experimental Validation

The results in central Pb+Pb collisions show that the scenario without colour coherence and reduced scattering rate tends to produce more particles close to the jet axis in the intermediate hadron p⊥ range, which is in tension with Cms data. The overall suppression is not the same in different scenarios, and a better agreement with data is obtained with colour coherence. p. 0 The survivor bias hardening the fragmentation function is stronger when the overall suppression is larger. p. 0 The differences between angular ordering options are largely due to vacuum effects, while the nuclear modification factor differences arise from Pb+Pb spectra. p. 6

References

[1] B. Andersson, G. Gustafson and T. Sjostrand, How to Find the Gluon Jets in e+ eAnnihilation, Phys. p. 8 Lett. B 94 (1980) 211 [2] Y.I. Azimov, Y.L. Dokshitzer, V.A. Khoze and S.I. Troian, The String Effect and QCD Coherence, Phys Lett. p. 1 B 165 (1985) 147 [3] Y.L. Dokshitzer, V.A. Khoze, S.I. Troian and A.H. Mueller, QCD Coherence in High-Energy Reactions, Rev Mod Phys 60 (1988) 373 [4] JADE collaboration, Experimental Study of Jets in electron - Positron Annihilation, Phys Lett. p. 1 B 101 (1981) 129 [5] CDF collaboration, Evidence for color coherence in pp¯ collisions at √s = 1. p. 1 p. 18 TeV, Phys. Rev. D 50 (1994) 5562 [6] A.H. Mueller, Multiplicity and Hadron Distributions in QCD Jets: Nonleading Terms, Nucl Phys B 213 (1983) 85 [7] Y. p. 1I. Azimov, Y.L. Dokshitzer, V.A. Khoze and S.I. Troyan, Humpbacked QCD Plateau in Hadron Spectra, Z Phys C 31 (1986) 213 [8] A Bassetto, M Ciafaloni and G Marchesini, Jet Structure and Infrared Sensitive Quantities in Perturbative QCD, Phys Rept. p. 1 100 (1983) 201 [9] OPAL collaboration, A Study of coherence of soft gluons in hadron jets, Phys Lett. p. 1 B 247 (1990) 617 [10] G Marchesini and B.R. Webber, Simulation of QCD Jets Including Soft Gluon Interference, Nucl. p. 1 Phys B 238 (1984) 1 [11] J. Casalderrey-Solana and E Iancu, Interference effects in medium-induced gluon radiation, JHEP 08 (2011) 015 [12] Y. p. 1 Mehtar-Tani, C.A. Salgado and K. Tywoniuk, Jets in QCD Media: From Color Coherence to Decoherence, Phys Lett. p. 1 B 707 (2012) 156 [13] Y. Mehtar-Tani and K. Tywoniuk, Jet coherence in QCD media: the antenna radiation spectrum, JHEP 01 (2013) 031 [14] Y. p. 2 Mehtar-Tani, C.A. Salgado and K. Tywoniuk, The radiation pattern of a QCD antenna in a dilute medium, JHEP 04 (2012) 064 [15] Y. p. 2 Mehtar-Tani, C.A. Salgado and K. Tywoniuk, The Radiation pattern of a QCD antenna in a dense medium, JHEP 10 (2012) 197 [16] Y. p. 0 Mehtar-Tani, C.A. Salgado and K. Tywoniuk, Anti-angular ordering of gluon radiation in QCD media, 1009. p. 42965 [17] J. Casalderrey-Solana, Y. Mehtar-Tani, C.A. Salgado and K. Tywoniuk, New picture of jet quenching dictated by color coherence, Phys. p. 2Lett B725 (2013) 357 [18] N Armesto, H Ma, M Martinez, Y Mehtar-Tani and C A Salgado, Interference between initial and final state radiation in a QCD medium, Phys Lett. p. 8 B 717 (2012) 280 [19] L Apolinário, N Armesto, J.G. Milhano and C A Salgado, Medium-induced gluon radiation and colour decoherence beyond the soft approximation, JHEP 02 (2015) 119 [20] J a Barata, F Domínguez, C A Salgado and V Vila, A modified in-medium evolution equation with color coherence, JHEP 05 (2021) 148 [21] S Abreu, X Mayo López, G Milhano and A Soto-Ontoso, A generalized picture of colour decoherence in dense QCD media, JHEP 03 (25) 216 [22] M V Kuzmin and J M Silva, QCD antenna radiative spectrum in dense media: accounting for full jet-medium interactions, 2507.00143 [23] C Andres, L Apolinário, N Armesto, A Cordeiro, F Dominguez, P Guerrero-Rodríguez et al., Gluon emission by a qq¯ antenna with realistic parton-medium interactions, in 31st International Conference on Ultra-relativistic Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions 8 (2025) [24] A. p. 1S. Kudinoor, D Pablos and K Rajagopal, Visualizing how the structure of large-radius jets shapes their wakes, JHEP 01 (2026) 020 [25] A. p. 0S. Kudinoor, D Pablos and K Rajagopal, Constraining the Resolution Length of Quark-Gluon Plasma with New Jet Substructure Measurements, 2509. p. 318683 [26] J Casalderrey-Solana, D C Gulhan, J.G. Milhano, D Pablos and K Rajagopal, A Hybrid Strong/Weak Coupling Approach to Jet Quenching, JHEP 10 (2014) 019 [27] P Caucal, E Iancu and G Soyez, Deciphering the zg distribution in ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions, JHEP 10 (2019) 273 [28] T Lundberg and L Lönnblad, A spacetime model for the perturbative swing, Eur Phys J C 85 (2025) 1139 [29] Z. p. 2 Hulcher, D Pablos and K Rajagopal, Resolution Effects in the Hybrid Strong/Weak Coupling Model, JHEP 03 (2018) 010 [30] J Casalderrey-Solana, G Milhano, D Pablos and K Rajagopal, Modification of Jet Substructure in Heavy Ion Collisions as a Probe of the Resolution Length of Quark-Gluon Plasma, JHEP 01 (2020) 044 [31] P Caucal, E Iancu, A. p. 2H. Mueller and G Soyez, Vacuum-like jet fragmentation in a dense QCD medium, Phys Rev Lett. p. 0 120 (2018) 232001

Parameter Settings for Jewel 2.6

The parameter settings for Jewel 2.6 include PTMIN 3, PTMAX 1200, ETAMAX 4, ISOCHANNEL PP SQRTS 5020, PDFSET 13100 (p+p) and 901300 (Pb+Pb), WEXPO 4.5. The angular ordering options are ANGORD = 0 to ANGORD = 5. p. 6 The switch for coherent scattering of unresolved colour dipoles is COHSCAT T, F.

Final Implementation Details

The implementation requires that for each re-scattering of an individual parton the inverse transverse momentum transfer is smaller than the separation between the parton and its colour partner if it is part of a colour dipole, otherwise there is no restriction. For coherent scatterings of colour dipoles, it is required that the inverse transverse momentum transfer is larger than the transverse size of the dipole. p. 3 The coherence of a dipole is lost as soon as one of the legs experienced a resolved scattering. p. 3 The temperature defines the average coherence length, and large fluctuations due to power-law behaviour are accounted for. p. 2 Jewel can perform the subtraction of thermal momenta using the Constituent Subtraction method. p. 9 The default choice is to have angular ordering always on since the first splitting typically has a very short formation time and scattering rate at very early times is not high. p. 8 The default choice for angular ordering strategy is ANGORD = 1, meaning kinematic constraints are imposed before angular ordering constraints when a scattering took place. p. 6 The kinematics first option is the new default choice because it allows to turn angular ordering off after a resolved scattering. p. 3

Summary of Results

The main effect of turning on angular ordering of the first splitting is a substantial increase of the jet p⊥-spectrum, mostly at lower p⊥. The nuclear modification factor changes much less when colour coherence is turned on compared to the kinematics only setting. The jet fragmentation functions reveal a reduction of soft particles inside the jets due to colour coherence. The total number of scatterings thus goes down, which leads to a corresponding reduction in the medium response component. p. 3 The changes in the fragmentation pattern are largely responsible for the effects of colour coherence observed in the hadronic final state. p. 1 The number of scatterings per parton does not change significantly, but unresolved scatterings are replaced by coherent scattering. p. 3

[1] B. Andersson, G Gustafson and T Sjostrand, How to Find the Gluon Jets in e+ eAnnihilation, Phys Lett. p. 8 B 94 (1980) 211 [2] YI Azimov, YL Dokshitzer, V A Khoze and S I Troian, The String Effect and QCD Coherence, Phys Lett. p. 1 B 165 (1985) 147 [3] YL Dokshitzer, V A Khoze, S I Troian and A H Mueller, QCD Coherence in High-Energy Reactions, Rev Mod Phys 60 (1988) 373 [4] JADE collaboration, Experimental Study of Jets in electron - Positron Annihilation, Phys Lett. p. 1 B 101 (1981) 129 [5] CDF collaboration, Evidence for color coherence in pp¯ collisions at √s = 1.8 TeV, Phys Rev. D 50 (1994) 5562 [6] A H Mueller, Multiplicity and Hadron Distributions in QCD Jets: Nonleading Terms, Nucl Phys B 213 (1983) 85 [7] YI Azimov, YL Dokshitzer, V A Khoze and S I Troyan, Humpbacked QCD Plateau in Hadron Spectra, Z Phys C 31 (1986) 213 [8] A Bassetto, M Ciafaloni and G Marchesini, Jet Structure and Infrared Sensitive Quantities in Perturbative QCD, Phys Rept. p. 1

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Color coherence implementation in jet evolution allows AI systems to dynamically turn angular ordering on and off for each individual splitting depending on whether a splitting parton or its color partner experienced a resolved scattering. This capability enables the model to capture effects where the temperature, which determines the screening mass and therefore how hard scatterings are on average, defines the average coherence length.

  2. The system can distinguish between vacuum-like and medium induced emissions by observing that the number of medium-induced emissions can only be estimated as an ensemble average by a comparing standard simulation to one where re-scatterings are not allowed to reset the parton shower. This provides a diagnostic tool for separating quenching effects from vacuum radiation.

  3. The AI system can utilize different angular ordering options, such as kinematics first, kinematics first exact angle, and angular ordering first, allowing researchers to compare how these choices affect jet fragmentation functions and correlations, as the paper shows these options yield different results in p+p collisions.

  4. By implementing checks for resolved scatterings before splitting, the system can dynamically adjust the splitting scale, leading to the new splitting scale is lower than the rejected one by construction and therefore the formation time increases, which impacts how radiation is treated in subsequent steps.

  5. The AI system can quantify how color coherence affects observables by showing that the number of scatterings per parton does not change significantly, because unresolved scatterings are replaced by coherent scattering while simultaneously reducing the total number of scatterings thus goes down, which leads to a corresponding reduction in the medium response component.

  6. The AI system can provide a detailed analysis of jet-hadron correlations by comparing results across different color coherence settings, such as with rejection of unresolved scatterings and coherent scatterings of dipoles versus scenarios with only rejections or no medium induced emissions.

Sources

Related papers