Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p, alpha) O reaction rate

arXiv:2604.13280 · nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-04-14 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p, alpha) O reaction rate".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Observation of the 511-keV positron-annihilation line would be a powerful probe of classical novae, with the primary source of positrons likely from the β+ decay of 18F We have determined the properties of important resonances in 19Ne which govern the 18F(p, α) reaction rate and the production of 18F in novae Measured α and proton angular distributions from states populated in the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne reaction identified six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (Lp = 0) states The authors improved their understanding of states contributing to the 18F(p, α) O reaction rate and show that earlier studies significantly underestimated the uncertainties Nuclear Structure Investigation The research focused on determining the properties of important resonances in 19Ne which govern the 18F(p, α) reaction rate.

Kai: Specifically, they studied six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (Lp = 0) states identified in the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne reaction.

Mira: The study also examined the asymptotic normalization of these states using the symmetry-adapted no-core shell model.

Kai: Reaction Rate Uncertainties The paper addressed significant uncertainty arising from interference effects between Jπ = 1/2+ and 3/2+ states near the proton threshold in 19Ne (Sp = 6410 keV) that have an L = 0 (s wave) 18F+p entrance channel.

Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper from arXiv, "Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p, alpha) O reaction rate" <ref:2604.13280#pg1,Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p>. Basically, they are digging into the nuclear structure of nineteen neon to understand how fast certain reactions happen.

Mira: The main point here is that they found six specific near-threshold proton s wave states in nineteen neon that really control the rate of the 18F(p, alpha) reaction <ref:2604.13280#pg1>. This is crucial because this reaction dictates how much 18F gets produced inside a classical nova <ref:2604.13280#pg1>.

Lev: It sounds like they are focusing on states that are right near the proton threshold, specifically those with angular momentum L equals zero, which we call s waves >

Kai: Right, and what they're doing is studying these states by measuring the alpha and proton angular distributions from reactions like 19F(3He,t) 19Ne to identify them <ref:2604.13280#pg1>. They even looked at the asymptotic normalization of these states using a no core shell model.

Mira: And then they tackle this uncertainty that comes from interference between certain spin parity states near that proton threshold, specifically J pi equals one half plus and three half plus states with an L equals zero entrance channel >

Lev: That interference is where the trouble starts because it makes the S factor really sensitive, especially when you are looking at lower energies where novae actually operate. The paper points out that adding these extra proton s wave levels, including some sub threshold states and proton unbound resonances, just increases that uncertainty in the S factor >

Kai: So what's the connection to classical novae then? Why should we care about nineteen neon states when we're talking about nova explosions?

Mira: Because the amount of 18F in the envelope of a nova is very sensitive to how fast it gets destroyed by that 18F(p, alpha) reaction, so if they underestimate that destruction rate, it means there will be more 18F produced than previously thought > <ref:2604.13280#pg1>

Lev: They found that the (p, alpha) cross section at energies relevant for novae, which is about zero point one to zero point four gigakelvins, is really sensitive to the asymptotic normalization constants of those bound proton s wave states >

Kai: That means even small uncertainties in how we measure the size or normalization of these states translate into a big uncertainty in the reaction rate itself >

Mira: The interference between resonances creates a wide range of possible reaction rates for 18F(p, alpha) 15O, suggesting that the actual destruction rate might be lower than some previous determinations we've seen > <ref:2604.13280#pg1>

Lev: They conclude that getting an accurate spin parity assignment and knowing those proton ANC values for the sub and near threshold region is absolutely critical for pinning down the reaction rates >

Kai: So what does this mean for how we look at gamma rays from novae? Does it change what we can actually see?

Mira: The results show that the upper and lower bounds they set include all these possibilities, but they significantly reduce the upper range of allowed reaction rates >

Lev: This implies that detecting fainter novae using gamma ray telescopes might become possible because the predicted flux of five hundred eleven kiloelectron volts gamma rays is tied to this destruction rate >

Kai: And that connects directly to the work coming up with COSI, which aims to measure the luminosity of those gamma rays from classical novae, specifically that five hundred eleven kiloelectron volt line >

Mira: Exactly, so this paper provides a constraint on how much 18F can survive in a nova envelope and what that means for the gamma ray observations we're hoping to get > <ref:2604.13280#pg1>

Lev: It shows that we need better data on these specific proton s wave levels if we want to make those predictions accurate for astrophysical observations >

Kai: So, moving away from the nuclear structure study, how does this paper ultimately change our view of classical novae?

Mira: It shifts the understanding of the 18F production process by showing that the destruction pathway is less certain than we thought because of these interference effects > <ref:2604.13280#pg1>

Lev: The uncertainty in the S factor at lower energies is what really matters for modeling a nova explosion, and this paper quantifies how much that uncertainty blows up >

Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper on "Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p, alpha) O reaction rate" basically tells us that we need much tighter control over the nuclear structure of nineteen neon near its proton threshold to accurately predict gamma ray fluxes from novae > <ref:2604.13280#pg1,Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p>

Conclusion: Kai: So, we've been looking at how we can understand classical novae through gamma rays and this paper is all about figuring out the nuclear structure of nineteen neon to get there.

Mira: Exactly, this paper focuses on states in nineteen neon that are key to understanding how fast the 18F production reaction actually goes <ref:2604.13280#pg1>.

Kai: The title says "Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p, alpha) O reaction rate <ref:2604.13280#pg1,Properties of states in 19Ne important for the 18F(p>." That sounds pretty specific.

Mira: It is. They're not just looking at any states; they are zeroing in on those six near-threshold proton s wave states that really drive that reaction rate.

Lev: From an experimental standpoint, identifying those six levels required measuring the alpha and proton angular distributions from a transfer reaction called nineteen fluorine three helium to nineteen neon.

Kai: That sounds like some serious work at the accelerator lab, getting those measurements done in coincidence with tritons. How did they confirm these states were what they thought they were?

Mira: They used a symmetry-adapted no core shell model to examine the asymptotic normalization of these states, which helps pin down their properties.

Lev: And then they hit this big problem with uncertainty, specifically interference effects between certain spin parity states near that proton threshold, and how that messes with the S factor at low energies.

Kai: So, what does all this nuclear physics stuff actually mean for the actual explosion we are trying to model?

Mira: It means the rate of 18F destruction in a nova envelope could be much slower than previous estimates suggested because of these interference effects <ref:2604.13280#pg1>.

Lev: If that destruction rate is lower, then there’s more 18F left around, which changes how bright those gamma ray signals from the nova should be <ref:2604.13280#pg1>.

Kai: So, ultimately it seems like this research is a big piece of the puzzle for predicting what we can actually see with gamma ray telescopes like COSI.

Mira: It is a crucial step in constraining how much 18F survives and what that tells us about Galactic chemical evolution <ref:2604.13280#pg1>.

Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, Louisiana State University · Cyclotron Institute, Texas A&M University · Physics Department, Florida State University · Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute · S&C Electric Company · Center for Plasma Science and Technology, Florida A&M University · Facility for Rare Isotope Beams, Michigan State University · © Los Alamos National Laboratory · Physics Division, Argonne National Laboratory · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Tennessee

nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-04-14

Updated: 2026-11-08

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: Observation of the 511-keV positron-annihilation line would be a powerful probe of classical novae, with the primary source of positrons likely from the β+ decay of 18F We have determined the…

Key concepts

Near-threshold proton s-wave states
These are specific quantum states in the nucleus $^{19} ext{Ne}$ that are very close in energy to the threshold for a proton to be captured. The study identified six such states, which are crucial because they directly affect how fast the $^{18} ext{F}$ particle reacts with a proton during nova explosions.
Reaction Rate Uncertainties
The calculation of reaction rates is complicated by interference effects between different quantum states near the proton threshold. The authors found that including more states, such as sub-threshold ones, increased the uncertainty in these rates, especially at lower energies where novae occur.
Asymptotic Normalization Coefficients (ANCs)
ANCs are a set of parameters used to describe the behavior of bound proton s-wave states far away from the nucleus. The study showed that uncertainties in these ANCs heavily influence the calculated cross-section for the $^{18} ext{F}( ext{p}, oldsymbol{ ext{ iny }oldsymbol{eta}}^+) ext{O}$ reaction, making accurate knowledge of them vital.
Astrophysical Implications
The properties of these nuclear states directly determine how much $^{18} ext{F}$ is produced in the envelope of a nova. The findings imply that the destruction rate of $^{18} ext{F}$ might be slower than previously assumed, which means more $^{18} ext{F}$ survives and leads to a higher predicted flux of 511-keV gamma rays.

Terminology

Summary

Observation of the 511-keV positron-annihilation line would be a powerful probe of classical novae, with the primary source of positrons likely from the β+ decay of 18F We have determined the properties of important resonances in 19Ne which govern the 18F(p, α) reaction rate and the production of 18F in novae Measured α and proton angular distributions from states populated in the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne reaction identified six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (Lp = 0) states The authors improved their understanding of states contributing to the 18F(p, α) O reaction rate and show that earlier studies significantly underestimated the uncertainties

Nuclear Structure Investigation

The research focused on determining the properties of important resonances in 19Ne which govern the 18F(p, α) reaction rate. Specifically, they studied six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (Lp = 0) states identified in the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne reaction. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We have determined the properties of important resonances in 19Ne which govern the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction rate and the production of 18F in novae. Measured α and proton angular distributions from states populated in the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne reaction identified six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (Lp = 0) states, and the asymptotic normalization of these states was studied using the symmetry-adapted no-core shell model.

The study also examined the asymptotic normalization of these states using the symmetry-adapted no-core shell model. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We have determined the properties of important resonances in 19Ne which govern the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction rate and the production of 18F in novae. Measured α and proton angular distributions from states populated in the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne reaction identified six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (Lp = 0) states, and the asymptotic normalization of these states was studied using the symmetry-adapted no-core shell model.

Reaction Rate Uncertainties

The paper addressed significant uncertainty arising from interference effects between Jπ = 1/2+ and 3/2+ states near the proton threshold in 19Ne (Sp = 6410 keV) that have an L = 0 (s wave) 18F+p entrance channel. The addition of additional proton s-wave levels, including sub-threshold states and proton-unbound resonances, resulted in a greater uncertainty in the S-factor, especially at lower energies. p. 1

Where the paper says it

421-MeV states near the proton threshold [10, 11]. The addition of these proton s-wave levels, along with variations in the signs of the reduced partial widths and the proton and alpha widths, resulted in a greater uncertainty in the S-factor, especially at lower energies.

Experimental Methodology

The authors measured the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne transfer reaction to study states in 19Ne at the John D. Fox Superconducting Linear Accelerator Laboratory. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We measured the 19F(3He,t) 19Ne transfer reaction to study states in 19Ne at the John D. Fox Superconducting Linear Accelerator Laboratory at Florida State University.

A Silicon Array for Branching Ratio Experiments (SABRE) was used to detect light ions from the decays of unbound states populated in 19Ne in coincidence with tritons. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Further position-corrections and energy calibrations were applied to (3He,t) events. The Silicon Array for Branching Ratio Experiments (SABRE) was placed at backward angles in the target chamber to detect light ions from the decays of unbound states populated in 19Ne in coincidence with tritons at the focal plane.

Astrophysical Implications

The properties of these states are crucial because the amount of 18F in the envelope of a nova is particularly sensitive to its rate of destruction by the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction. The results imply that the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction rate could be significantly lower than previous determinations, resulting in an increased abundance of 18F and a higher predicted flux of 511-keV gamma rays. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Specifically, the results of this work imply that the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction rate could be significantly lower than the most recent determination by Portillo et al. , resulting in an increased abundance of 18F and, consequently, a higher predicted flux of 511-keV gamma rays.

Sensitivity to Input Parameters

The analysis showed that the (p, α) cross section at energies important for novae (0.1 - 0.4 GK) is highly sensitive to uncertainties in ANCs for the bound proton s-wave states. p. 4

Where the paper says it

4 that illustrate that the (p, α) cross section at energies important for novae (0. 4 GK) is highly sensitive to uncertainties in ANCs for the bound proton s-wave states.

The interference between resonances results in a broad range of reaction rates, suggesting that the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction rate could be significantly lower than the most recent determination by Portillo et al. p. 4
Where the paper says it

From these results, it is clear that with our current state of knowledge of resonance parameters for 19Ne, the interference between resonances results in a broad range of reaction rates, as suggested most recently by Kahl et al. Specifically, the results of this work imply that the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction rate could be significantly lower than the most recent determination by Portillo et al.

Conclusion on Reaction Rates

The study concludes that accurate knowledge of the spin-parity assignments and the proton ANCs for the sub- and near-threshold region is critical. The findings suggest that a higher spin state may exist but will only impact the reaction rate if it is Jπ = 1/2+, 3/2+. p. 3

Where the paper says it

However, if a higher-spin state exists as suggested by Ref. [10, 12], we find it to be weakly populated, and only the J π = 1 2 + , 3 2 + state will impact the 18F(p, α) 15O reaction rate.

Impact on Gamma Ray Detection

The outcome of this work implies that the detection of fainter novae via gamma-ray telescopes is possible. The upper and lower bounds shown include all rates from this work, and the results greatly reduce the upper range of allowed reaction rates. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The upper and lower bounds shown as black dashed lines (and within the yellow shading) include all rates from this work. The solid black lines (and gray shading) indicate the range of rates consistent with 18F(p, α) 15O cross section measurements as described in the text.

Support for Future Missions

The aim of the upcoming Compton Spectrometer and Imager (COSI) mission is to measure the luminosity of γ rays from classical novae, and specifically the 511-keV line. This presents an exciting opportunity to constrain these astrophysical phenomena and their contribution to Galactic chemical evolution. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu trometer and Imager (COSI) mission is to measure the luminosity of γ rays from classical novae, and specifically the 511-keV line [5]. This presents an exciting opportunity to constrain these astrophysical phenomena and their contribution to Galactic chemical evolution.

Funding Acknowledgements

This work was partially supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science under Grant Nos. p. 4

Where the paper says it

This work was partially supported by the U. Department of Energy, Office of Science under Grant Nos.

DEFG02-96ER40989, DE-SC0026091, and DE-SC0023532. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Department of Energy, Office of Science under Grant Nos. DEFG02-96ER40989, DE-SC0026091, and DE-SC0023532, by the National Science Foundation under Grant No.

The authors thank A. p. 4
Where the paper says it

DE-AC02-05CH11231, as well as the Frontera computing project at the Texas Advanced Computing Center, made possible by the National Science Foundation award OAC-1818253. The authors thank A.

Laird, R. Longland, and G. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The authors thank A. Longland, and G.

Sargsyan for helpful discussions. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Longland, and G. Sargsyan for helpful discussions.

References

The paper cites numerous references to support its findings regarding the nuclear structure and astrophysical reaction rates. The list includes works on nuclear physics, astrophysics, and experimental techniques for excited states. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Hernanz, and C. Iliadis, Nuclear Physics A 777, 550 (2006).

The authors also reference previous studies that have investigated interference effects in this region. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A recent analysis of the properties of important states in 19Ne is provided in Ref. Previous examinations of the 18F(p, α) 15O astrophysical S-factor and reaction rate have also shown that significant uncertainty arises from interference effects between J π = 1 2 + , 3 2 + states near the proton threshold in 19Ne (Sp = 6410 keV) that have an L = 0 (s wave) 18F+p entrance channel.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. More accurate prediction of 18F destruction rate in novae by incorporating improved knowledge of resonance properties in 19Ne, specifically identifying six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (Lp = 0) states and their asymptotic normalization.

  2. Enhanced ability to constrain the luminosity of the 511-keV line from classical novae by utilizing refined nuclear constraints on the destruction rate, which directly impacts the predicted flux of gamma rays.

  3. Improved sensitivity in MeV transient searches by providing a better understanding of how interference effects between J pi = 1/2+ and 3/2+ states near the proton threshold in 19Ne influence the reaction rate uncertainty.

  4. More robust determination of alpha angular distributions for excited states in 19Ne, allowing for better discrimination between competing spin-parity assignments, such as distinguishing between L alpha = 1 (J pi = 1/2+, 3/2+) fit and other possibilities.

  5. Better modeling of the uncertainty in astrophysical S-factors by considering the impact of interference between resonances results in a broad range of reaction rates, leading to a more realistic assessment of the predicted abundance of 18F.

Abstract

Observation of the 511-keV positron-annihilation line would be a powerful probe of classical novae, with the primary source of positrons likely from the β+ decay of 18F. We have determined the properties of important resonances in 19Ne which govern the 18F(p,α) 15O reaction rate and the production of 18F in novae. Measured α and proton angular distributions from states populated in the 19F(cubedHe,t) 19Ne reaction identified six near-threshold proton s-wave 18F+p (L p=0) states, and the asymptotic normalization of these states was studied using the symmetry-adapted no-core shell model. We have improved our understanding of states contributing to the 18F(p,α) 15O reaction rate and show that earlier studies significantly underestimated the uncertainties.

Sources

Related papers