Constraints on Vector-Like Top Dipole Interactions from Top-Associated Photon Measurements at the LHC

arXiv:2604.13270 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-04-14 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Constraints on Vector-Like Top Dipole Interactions from Top-Associated Photon Measurements at the LHC".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Precision measurements of top-quark production with energetic photons provide a complementary probe of vector-like quarks with nonstandard radiative decays The analysis reinterprets the CMS differential ttγ¯ measurement and the ATLAS fiducial ttγγ ¯ cross section to constrain the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition interactions of a charge-2/3 vector-like top partner, T.

Kai: Theoretical Framework The effective transition interactions are formulated directly in terms of the physical photon and gluon fields after electroweak symmetry breaking This description is a restricted broken-phase phenomenological parametrization and is not assumed to constitute a complete SU(2)L × U(1)Y-gauge-invariant effective theory at energies above the electroweak scale.

Mira: The interaction is formulated as Lint = X 3 i=1 fi Λ gγ T σ¯ µνuiFµν + gg T σ¯ µνT AuiG A µν + h.c., where gγ and gg are dimensionless parameters controlling the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transitions, respectively The dimensionful transition coefficients used in the interpretation are ctγ = f3gγ / Λ, ctg = f3gg / Λ, (2.2) and are quoted throughout in GeV−1.

Kai: Production and Decay Modeling The pairproduction cross section can be decomposed as σTT¯ = σQCD + c 2 tgσint + c 4 tgσdip.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're talking about the title and authors for this paper, "Constraints on Vector-Like Top Dipole Interactions from Top-Associated Photon Measurements at the LHC". It’s important to know who did this work because it sets the context for what they are constraining.

Mira: M. Sahraei, Y. Hosseini, and M. Mohammadi Najafabadi are the authors, and their school is the School of Particles and Accelerators at IPM in Tehran, Iran.

Lev: The main thing to grasp here is that they are not just looking at one type of decay; they're specifically focusing on those decays where T turns into a top quark and a photon, T to t gamma, and also T turns into a top quark and a gluon, T to t g.

Kai: Right. They are reinterpreting the CMS differential top-to-photon measurement and the ATLAS fiducial cross section measurement to constrain these specific interactions. It's about finding new information that existing searches might miss if they only look at conventional decays like T decaying into a W boson or a Z boson or a Higgs boson.

Mira: The implication is that even if we don't see the conventional decay channels, these radiative modes, like T to t gamma and T to t g, could still be present and we can use this data to put limits on how strongly they couple.

Lev: It tells us that the conventional search channels aren't exhaustive for vector-like quarks; there’s more physics out there involving these specific radiative decays.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes their approach by saying they formulate the effective transition interactions directly in terms of the physical photon and gluon fields after electroweak symmetry breaking.

Mira: It sets up this description as a restricted broken-phase phenomenological parametrization, not necessarily a complete gauge-invariant theory at high energies. This is important because it tells us the assumptions they are making about how these interactions behave above the electroweak scale.

Lev: The specific interaction term they use is Lint equal to x three i equals one f three g gamma lambda g gamma t sigma mu nu ui F mu nu plus gg t sigma mu nu T A ui G A mu nu plus h dot c. That’s the mathematical way they write down the coupling between these fields.

Kai: And they define some dimensionful transition coefficients, like c tau gamma equal f three g gamma over lambda, and c tau g equal f three g g over lambda, which are measured in units of one per GeV minus one. These are what they use to quantify the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transitions respectively.

Mira: They then decompose the pair-production cross section into QCD production plus contributions from these transition-induced gluon fusion amplitudes, which are proportional to c tau g.

Lev: So, when they talk about T t bar cross section being sigma TT bar equal sigma QCD plus c two tau g sigma int plus c four tau g sigma dip, they are saying the part driven by these transitions is tied directly to that c two tau g parameter.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest a few key improvements to make this analysis more robust. First, they implement an event-level effective field theory truncation requirement.

Mira: They use MTT bar less than lambda eff c which is defined as one over q squared tau g plus c squared tau gamma. This gives them a phenomenological validity convention for the two neutral transition coefficients they are scanning.

Lev: That means they only keep the parts of the interaction that are below this cutoff, which helps them control what happens when they use signal templates, like MTT bar sigma trunc i x equals x e in i we,x(c) theta lambda eff c minus MTT bar.

Kai: Secondly, they introduce a mass-dependent detector-response transfer factor C of m t which accounts for how different the detectors are. It's defined as N reco over N fidtt bar times N reco over N fidtt bar Delphes tt gamma bar.

Mira: That factor is supposed to isolate only the response difference associated with the signal topology, making sure we are only looking at what those specific events look like in the detector.

Lev: And they handle uncertainties by scaling them based on luminosity and experimental systematics, using a factor of p one hundred forty over three thousand for ATLAS uncertainty and similarly for CMS statistical uncertainty.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper shows that the observed Run two constraints in the tau gamma g plane show distinct behavior depending on the topology dependence of the CMS signal.

Mira: They project that for both analyses, they find statistically excluded regions satisfying those effective field theory and narrow-width requirements when we look at a top mass of one thousand two hundred fifty GeV <ref:2604.13270#pg2>.

Lev: The physical interpretation is restricted to where the resonance width divided by its mass is less than zero point one, which keeps the factorized on-shell production and decay treatment controlled.

Kai: The overall implication is that these two measurements probe complementary radiative configurations, showing that existing top-associated photon measurements provide meaningful sensitivity to nonstandard radiative vector-like top partner interactions and complement dedicated searches targeting conventional vector-like quark decay modes.

Mira: They report the projected HL LHC sensitivities, which show that for an integrated luminosity of three thousand fb minus one, scaling the CMS statistical uncertainty with luminosity and halving its Run two experimental systematic uncertainties, the projected CMS intersections at a top mass of five hundred GeV and one thousand GeV are approximately zero point five times ten to the minus seven and one point four times ten to the minus six per GeV minus one.

Lev: The corresponding ATLAS intersections are about one point eight times ten to the minus six and five point nine times ten to the minus six per GeV minus one.

Kai: And looking at the projected sensitivities for B tau t gamma for both CMS and ATLAS, they are approximately zero point zero four six nine percent and two hundred thirty-seven percent respectively.

Mira: These results are summarized in Table three, which shows the observed Run two ninety-five percent confidence level exclusion reaches and projected expected HL LHC sensitivities in c tau gamma for the benchmark slice where c tau g is one point zero times ten to the minus five per GeV minus one, along with the corresponding physical branching fraction B tau t gamma <ref:2604.13270#pg2>.

Lev: The final result is that these constraints are reported separately because the information needed to determine the correlations between those two measurements isn't publicly available.

Kai: The projected sensitivities show that for an integrated luminosity of three thousand fb minus one, scaling the CMS statistical uncertainty with luminosity and halving its Run two experimental systematic uncertainties, the projected CMS intersections at a top mass of five hundred GeV and one thousand GeV are approximately zero point five times ten to the minus seven and one point four times ten to the minus six per GeV minus one.

Lev: The projected sensitivities for B tau t gamma for CMS and ATLAS are approximately zero point zero four six nine percent and two hundred thirty-seven percent respectively.

Mira: The physical interpretation is restricted to the portions of the effective field theory truncated statistical exclusions satisfying the resonance width divided by its mass is less than zero point one.

Lev: So in short, this paper on Constraints on Vector-Like Top Dipole Interactions from Top-Associated Photon Measurements at the LHC shows that these measurements are complementary probes for nonstandard radiative vector-like top partner interactions.

School of Particles and Accelerators, Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM)

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-04-14

Updated: 2026-09-17

Comments: 27 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114, 095017 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/dbn4-jjh5

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Precision measurements of top-quark production with energetic photons provide a complementary probe of vector-like quarks with nonstandard radiative decays The analysis reinterprets the CMS…

Key concepts

Vector-Like Top Partner (T)
This is a hypothetical heavy quark that couples to the top quark. The paper investigates its nonstandard radiative decays, which are crucial for probing physics beyond the Standard Model. Constraints are placed on its mass and coupling strengths based on experimental data.
Effective Transition Interactions
These interactions describe how T couples to photons and gluons after electroweak symmetry breaking. They are parameterized by dimensionless coefficients (c_tγ, c_tg) that control the strength of electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transitions, allowing physicists to test specific theoretical models.
EFT Truncation Requirement
This is a rule used to ensure the theoretical description of the interactions remains valid at different energy scales. The analysis only considers events where T's contribution to the overall process is smaller than a defined threshold (Λeff(c)), ensuring the mathematical model accurately reflects physical reality.

Terminology

Summary

Precision measurements of top-quark production with energetic photons provide a complementary probe of vector-like quarks with nonstandard radiative decays The analysis reinterprets the CMS differential ttγ¯ measurement and the ATLAS fiducial ttγγ ¯ cross section to constrain the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition interactions of a charge-2/3 vector-like top partner, T. p. 0

Where the paper says it

ir Abstract Precision measurements of top-quark production with energetic photons provide a complementary probe of vector-like quarks with nonstandard radiative decays. We reinterpret the CMS differential ttγ¯ measurement and the ATLAS fiducial ttγγ ¯ cross section to constrain the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition interactions of a charge-2/3 vector-like top partner, T.

Theoretical Framework

The effective transition interactions are formulated directly in terms of the physical photon and gluon fields after electroweak symmetry breaking This description is a restricted broken-phase phenomenological parametrization and is not assumed to constitute a complete SU(2)L × U(1)Y-gauge-invariant effective theory at energies above the electroweak scale. The interaction is formulated as Lint = X 3 i=1 fi Λ gγ T σ¯ µνuiFµν + gg T σ¯ µνT AuiG A µν + h. p. 3

Where the paper says it

In the present work, we consider the photon and gluon tensor vertices but no correlated off-diagonal T tZ vertex. The interaction is therefore formulated directly in the mass-eigenstate electroweak-broken phase as Lint = X 3 i=1 fi Λ gγ T σ¯ µνuiFµν + gg T σ¯ µνT AuiG A µν + h.

c., where gγ and gg are dimensionless parameters controlling the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transitions, respectively The dimensionful transition coefficients used in the interpretation are ctγ = f3gγ / Λ, ctg = f3gg / Λ, (2. p. 3
Where the paper says it

1) where σ µν = i[γ µ , γν ]/2, ui = (u, c, t), and T A are the fundamental SU(3)c generators. The coefficients fi specify the flavor weights, while gγ and gg are dimensionless parameters controlling the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transitions, respectively.

2) and are quoted throughout in GeV−1. p. 3
Where the paper says it

For the third generation, the dimensionful transition coefficients used in the interpretation are ctγ = f3gγ Λ , ctg = f3gg Λ , (2. 2) and are quoted throughout in GeV−1 .

Production and Decay Modeling

The pairproduction cross section can be decomposed as σTT¯ = σQCD + c 2 tgσint + c 4 tgσdip. The transition-induced gluon-fusion amplitude contains two T tg insertions and is therefore proportional to c 2 tg. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The qq¯ → TT¯ contribution is included separately. The transition-induced gluon-fusion amplitude contains two T tg insertions and is therefore proportional to c 2 tg.

The dominant production mechanisms and decay transitions are illustrated in Fig. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The interference coefficient can have either sign after phase-space integration and can vary across the kinematic phase space; it must not be interpreted as an independently positive event yield. The dominant production mechanisms and decay transitions are illustrated in Fig.

1.

Data Interpretation Strategies

The CMS reinterpretation uses only the absolute unfolded p γ T spectrum in the CMS dilepton fiducial region at √s = 13 TeV and 138 fb−1. The ATLAS measurement is treated as a single fiducial counting observable, with a signal-specific, mass-dependent detector-response transfer factor. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The latter contribution is evaluated with its own topology-dependent acceptance rather than being inferred from the mixed sample. The ATLAS result is treated as a counting measurement with a signal-specific, mass-dependent correction for the reconstruction response.

Validity and Constraints

The validity of the effective description is assessed independently at every coupling point by imposing the event-level EFT truncation requirement MTT¯ < Λeff(c). The physical interpretation is further restricted to ΓT /mT < 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The signal samples use factorized on-shell production and decay. The physical interpretation is therefore restricted to ΓT /mT < 0.

1, ensuring that T remains a well-defined resonance for which the factorized on-shell production and decay treatment is expected to remain controlled. p. 4
Where the paper says it

1, for which T remains a well-defined resonance and corrections to the narrow-width treatment are expected to remain controlled. This upperwidth requirement excludes broad-resonance regions in which production and decay cannot be factorized reliably.

Results and Projections

The observed Run 2 constraints in the (ctγ, ctg) plane show distinct behavior along different slices, reflecting the topology dependence of the CMS signal. The projected HL-LHC sensitivities show that for both analyses, statistically excluded regions satisfying the EFT and narrow-width requirements are obtained through mT = 1250 GeV. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The CMS signal includes both the mixed (tγ)(tg) topology and double-radiative ttγγ ¯ events entering the exactly-one-photon fiducial region, while the ATLAS rate is interpreted using a signal-specific detector-response transfer factor. Signal uncertainties are included, and the interpretation is restricted point by point to the domain satisfying the EFT and narrow-width requirements.

Conclusion

The two measurements probe complementary radiative configurations, demonstrating that existing top-associated photon measurements provide meaningful sensitivity to nonstandard radiative vector-like-top-partner interactions and complement dedicated searches targeting conventional VLQ decay modes. The results show that the CMS and ATLAS constraints are reported separately because the information required to determine the correlations between the two measurements is not publicly available. p. 2

Where the paper says it

1 ensures that the heavy state remains a well-defined resonance for which on-shell production and subsequent decay can be factorized reliably, with finite-width, nonresonant, and nonfactorizable effects remaining controlled. Constraints from the CMS and ATLAS measurements are reported separately because the information required to account reliably for correlations between the two data sets is not publicly available.

The projected sensitivities indicate that for an integrated luminosity of 3000 fb−1, scaling the CMS statistical uncertainty with luminosity and halving its Run 2 experimental systematic uncertainties, the projected CMS intersections at mT = 500 and 1000 GeV are approximately 2. p. 7
Where the paper says it

These variations are propagated through the full event selection and incorporated as correlated systematic uncertainties in the statistical interpretation. 1 Object definitions and fiducial implementation Stable-particle lifetimes, lepton dressing, prompt-photon ancestry, photon isolation, jet inputs, heavy-flavor labeling, and overlap removal are implemented separately for CMS and ATLAS.

5 × 10−7 and 1.4 × 10−6 GeV−1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Denoting the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition coefficients by ctγ and ctg, respectively, we find that, for ctg = 1. 0 × 10−5 GeV−1 and mT = 500 GeV, the observed Run 2 exclusions at 95% confidence level extend down to ctγ ≃ 4.

The corresponding ATLAS intersections are approximately 1. p. 9
Where the paper says it

For ctγ = ctg = 1. 0 × 10−4 GeV−1 , the double-radiative topology contributes approximately 11– 14% of the total selected CMS single-photon signal, corresponding to an increase of about 12–16% relative to the mixed (tγ)(tg) contribution alone.

8 × 10−6 and 5.9 × 10−6 GeV−1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Denoting the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition coefficients by ctγ and ctg, respectively, we find that, for ctg = 1. 0 × 10−5 GeV−1 and mT = 500 GeV, the observed Run 2 exclusions at 95% confidence level extend down to ctγ ≃ 4.

The projected sensitivities to B(T → tγ) for CMS and ATLAS are approximately 0. p. 9
Where the paper says it

For ctγ = ctg = 1. 0 × 10−4 GeV−1 , the double-radiative topology contributes approximately 11– 14% of the total selected CMS single-photon signal, corresponding to an increase of about 12–16% relative to the mixed (tγ)(tg) contribution alone.

0469% and 237% respectively. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Signal uncertainties are included, and the interpretation is restricted point by point to the domain satisfying the EFT and narrow-width requirements. Denoting the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition coefficients by ctγ and ctg, respectively, we find that, for ctg = 1.

The results are summarized in Table 3. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The results are presented in Sec. 8, and our conclusions are summarized in Sec.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The results are presented in Sec. 8, and our conclusions are summarized in Sec.

The observed Run 2 constraints and projected HL-LHC sensitivities are presented as two-dimensional regions in the (ctγ, ctg) plane. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Denoting the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition coefficients by ctγ and ctg, respectively, we find that, for ctg = 1. 0 × 10−5 GeV−1 and mT = 500 GeV, the observed Run 2 exclusions at 95% confidence level extend down to ctγ ≃ 4.

The physical interpretation is restricted to the portions of the EFT-truncated statistical exclusions satisfying ΓT /mT < 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The signal samples use factorized on-shell production and decay. The physical interpretation is therefore restricted to ΓT /mT < 0.

1. The results are summarized in Table 3.

Table 3: Observed Run 2 95% CL exclusion reaches and projected expected HL-LHC sensitivities in ctγ for the benchmark slice ctg = 1. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Denoting the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition coefficients by ctγ and ctg, respectively, we find that, for ctg = 1. 0 × 10−5 GeV−1 and mT = 500 GeV, the observed Run 2 exclusions at 95% confidence level extend down to ctγ ≃ 4.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Denoting the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition coefficients by ctγ and ctg, respectively, we find that, for ctg = 1. 0 × 10−5 GeV−1 and mT = 500 GeV, the observed Run 2 exclusions at 95% confidence level extend down to ctγ ≃ 4.

0 × 10−5 GeV−1, together with the corresponding physical branching fraction B(T → tγ). p. 9
Where the paper says it

The heavy-T prediction includes the mixed T T¯ → (tγ)(tg¯ ) topology, together with its chargeconjugate assignment, and double-radiative T T¯ → (tγ)(tγ¯ ) events satisfying the exactly-onefiducial-photon requirement. These contributions are evaluated independently and normalized using their corresponding physical branching-fraction weights.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

The heavy-T prediction includes the mixed T T¯ → (tγ)(tg¯ ) topology, together with its chargeconjugate assignment, and double-radiative T T¯ → (tγ)(tγ¯ ) events satisfying the exactly-onefiducial-photon requirement. These contributions are evaluated independently and normalized using their corresponding physical branching-fraction weights.

The coupling values are given in units of 10−5 GeV−1, and the branching fractions are expressed as percentages. p. 9
Where the paper says it

3% at mT = 3000 GeV. The weak mass dependence refers to this benchmark; throughout the coupling scan, the relative contribution is evaluated using the physical branching fractions and topology-dependent acceptances at each tested point.

Table 3: Observed Run 2 95% CL exclusion reaches and projected expected HL-LHC sensitivities in ctγ for the benchmark slice ctg = 1.0 × 10−5 GeV−1, together with the corresponding physical branching fraction B(T → tγ). Each coupling entry gives the smallest value reached by the exclusion along the specified slice.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved event-level EFT validity check by implementing a step function to retain only events satisfying MTTbar less than Λeff(c), which is defined as 1/q 2tg + c 2tγ, ensuring that The truncated contribution to bin i is σtrunc i,X (c) = X e∈i we,X(c) Θ Λeff(c) − MTT,e ¯ is used for signal templates.

  2. Enhanced constraint generation by adopting a point-dependent effective scale definition Λeff(c) = 1/q 2tg + c 2tγ, which provides a phenomenological validity convention for the two scanned neutral transition coefficients. This allows the analysis to test the EFT-energy and narrow-width requirements at every coupling point.

  3. More physically transparent signal modeling by applying a mass-dependent detector-response transfer factor C(mT) to account for reconstruction differences, as described by C(mT) = (Nreco/Nfid)TT¯ (Nreco/Nfid) Delphes ttγγ ¯, ensuring that the transfer factor isolates only the response difference associated with the signal topology.

  4. Robust handling of measurement uncertainties by employing a dedicated mass-dependent uncertainty treatment, where the total reported ATLAS experimental uncertainty is scaled by p140/3000 and CMS statistical uncertainty is scaled similarly, reflecting how The projected CMS exclusions in the left panel of Fig. 5 extend down to ctγ ≃ 2.5 × 10−7 when accounting for luminosity scaling.

  5. Improved sensitivity analysis by restricting physical interpretation to the narrow-width domain, specifically retaining only points satisfying "ΓT /mT < 0.1, which ensures that the factorized on-shell production and decay treatment is expected to remain controlled."

Abstract

Precision measurements of top-quark production with energetic photons provide a complementary probe of vector-like quarks with nonstandard radiative decays. We reinterpret the CMS differential t tγ measurement and the ATLAS fiducial t tγγ cross section to constrain the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition interactions of a charge- 2/3 vector-like top partner, T. We consider effective interactions written in terms of physical fields after electroweak symmetry breaking, retaining only the decays T to tγ and T to tg. The CMS signal includes both the mixed (tγ)(tg) topology and double-radiative t tγγ events entering the exactly-one-photon fiducial region, while the ATLAS rate is interpreted using a signal-specific detector-response transfer factor. Signal uncertainties are included, and the interpretation is restricted point by point to the domain satisfying the EFT and narrow-width requirements. Denoting the electromagnetic and chromomagnetic transition coefficients by c tγ and c tg, respectively, we find that, for c tg=1.0 times10-5-1 and m T=500, the observed Run 2 exclusions at 95% confidence level extend down to c tγ 4.7 times10-7-1 for CMS and 2.3 times10-6-1 for ATLAS within the valid domain. At m T=1000, the corresponding values are 2.1 times10-6 and 8.5 times10-6-1. Projections to the HL-LHC indicate improved sensitivity to these radiative transition interactions. These results establish top-associated photon measurements as complementary probes of radiative top-partner interactions beyond searches targeting conventional decay modes.

Sources

Related papers