Testing the 3D QRNG by Undoing

arXiv:2604.12724 · quant-ph · Submitted 2026-04-14 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Testing the 3D QRNG by Undoing".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We propose a method to test whether a photonic 3D QRNG works according to the underlying theory, thereby generating highly incomputable/unpredictable sequences of random digits The test relies on undoing the unitary evolution realized by the 3D QRNG This test verifies the unitarity, the magnitude of the noise, and other potential errors, such as photon loss or systematic and reproducible fabrication errors Therefore, the test can confirm the theoretically proven features of the 3D QRNG, such as strong incomputability and unpredictability, or how one has to correct it, if necessary In addition, the test ensures that the QRNG is not affected by limits of quantum measurement accuracy, as those described in the Wigner-ArakiYanase Theorem Theoretical Foundations of Randomness Certification The algorithms used in cryptography are highly dependent on the quality of the random numbers used during the encryption processes; hence, the need for Quantum Random Number Generators (QRNG) is increasingly understood and accepted especially under the expectation that quantum computers could be able to break encryption methods previously considered secure Genuine randomness, which consists of a mathematical proof of maximal unpredictability, can only be achieved (to date) by Quantum Random Number Generators that measure value indefinite quantum observables, like the 3D-photonic QRNG Value indefiniteness is the best theoretical certification and can only be provided by applications of the Kochen-Specker Theorem in its localized form studied in

2, 4, 5: studied in

7: The three properties of quantum random sequences generated by a 3D QRNG are: 1.

Kai: Every quantum random sequence is 3-bi-immune, by Theorems 6 and 7 in

6: This is stronger than bi-immunity which is stronger than incomputability; see also

12: 2.

Mira: Every quantum random sequence is maximally unpredictable, meaning no algorithm can accurately predict any of its digits, Theorem 8 in

6: 3.

Kai: Every quantum random sequence is Borel normal, which means that any digit and any string of digits are generated with the same probability, see Lemma 1 in

6: Physical Constraints and Error Modeling The physical realization of any device encounters practical obstacles, which result in errors The primary source of errors in integrated quantum photonics is photon loss, which occurs in the couplings and waveguides Additionally, there could be fabrication errors associated with the beam splitter and phase shifter, as well as detection inefficiency These errors can be detected by specific experimental tests such as heralding and coincidence counting The paper suggests two optional modules for experimental certification: 1.

Paper summary: Kai: So to summarize this paper, "Testing the three dee QRNG by Undoing," the authors propose a method designed to check if a photonic three-dimensional quantum random number generator is operating according to its underlying quantum theory <ref:2604.12724#pg1,Testing the 3D QRNG by Undoing>.

Mira: The core thesis is that this test involves undoing the unitary evolution that happens inside the device, which allows them to verify key features of genuine randomness.

Lev: They claim this procedure can confirm unitarity, check for the magnitude of noise and errors like photon loss or fabrication mistakes, and ensure that systematic errors are minimal.

Kai: Essentially, they want a way to confirm if the sequences generated are truly highly incomputable and unpredictable as predicted by theory.

Mira: The paper also emphasizes that this test protects against limits imposed by the Wigner-ArakiYanase Theorem, meaning it ensures measurement accuracy doesn't undermine the randomness guarantees.

Lev: They’re looking at verifying properties like three-bi-immunity, which is a stronger form of randomness than just being unpredictable or even bi-immune <ref:2604.12724#pg1>.

Kai: This means they aren't just checking if you get a random string; they are checking if the *process* generating that string adheres to quantum predictions.

Mira: The paper presents this test as a feasible way to realize an experimental certification tool that can be delivered right along with the QRNG itself for interested parties.

Lev: The main point is making it practical so that users and investors have a concrete way to assess the quality of their quantum random number generator.

Kai: It moves the conversation from just theoretical proof of randomness to an actual experimental check on whether the physical device delivers on those quantum promises.

Mira: And they clearly state that this inversion test is useful for checking if there are any unexpected, non-systematic errors in the measurement process itself.

Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about this paper, "Testing the three dee QRNG by Undoing," it really focuses on moving beyond simply claiming a device is quantum random to actually proving that the physical implementation behaves correctly <ref:2604.12724#pg1,Testing the 3D QRNG by Undoing>.

Mira: The authors are essentially providing a practical toolkit for experimental certification, showing how you can use unitary inversion to check unitarity and error bounds on these complex photonic systems.

Lev: For the hardware guys, this means if we want our three dee QRNGs to be trusted in cryptography, we need to build in this test right from the start <ref:2604.12724#pg1>.

Kai: It's about making the assurance tangible for users and ensuring that the quantum features they pay for are actually present in the physical chip.

Mira: And it’s important to remember that while this test is powerful, it only applies when you have a system with a known prepared state and a unitary transformation you can reverse.

Lev: That's the key constraint; if your device operates on something fundamentally non-invertible, this specific inversion method just won't give you that certification.

Kai: So the paper provides a strong benchmark for what it means to certify quantum randomness in this domain, focusing on verifying conservation laws through experimental inversion rather than just statistical tests.

J. M. Agóero Trejo, Cristian S. Calude, O. C. Stoica

School of Computer Science, University of Auckland · Department of Theoretical Physics, NIPNE–HH

quant-ph

Submitted: 2026-04-14

Updated: 2026-10-31

Comments: To appear in Scientific Reports

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 75/100

The gist: We propose a method to test whether a photonic 3D QRNG works according to the underlying theory, thereby generating highly incomputable/unpredictable sequences of random digits The test relies on…

Key concepts

Unitary Undoing Test
This test involves using a mirror of the QRNG's unitary transformation to reverse its operation. If the output of this reversed process matches the original input, it proves that even with errors, the fundamental quantum evolution remains consistent and reversible.
Unitarity
Unitarity is a property in quantum mechanics that ensures information is conserved during a process. In this context, testing unitarity confirms that the 3D QRNG correctly processes its quantum states without losing or corrupting the randomness inherent in the system.
3-bi-immune
This is a strong mathematical property of quantum random sequences, meaning they are highly resistant to prediction. It is a stronger version of incomputability, proving that no algorithm can accurately predict any sequence generated by the 3D QRNG.
Wigner-ArakiYanase Theorem
This theorem sets limits on how much randomness can be extracted from quantum measurements. The test ensures the QRNG's performance respects these conservation laws, guaranteeing that measurement inaccuracies do not compromise its theoretically proven unpredictability.

Terminology

Summary

We propose a method to test whether a photonic 3D QRNG works according to the underlying theory, thereby generating highly incomputable/unpredictable sequences of random digits The test relies on undoing the unitary evolution realized by the 3D QRNG This test verifies the unitarity, the magnitude of the noise, and other potential errors, such as photon loss or systematic and reproducible fabrication errors Therefore, the test can confirm the theoretically proven features of the 3D QRNG, such as strong incomputability and unpredictability, or how one has to correct it, if necessary In addition, the test ensures that the QRNG is not affected by limits of quantum measurement accuracy, as those described in the Wigner-ArakiYanase Theorem

Theoretical Foundations of Randomness Certification

The algorithms used in cryptography are highly dependent on the quality of the random numbers used during the encryption processes; hence, the need for Quantum Random Number Generators (QRNG) is increasingly understood and accepted especially under the expectation that quantum computers could be able to break encryption methods previously considered secure Genuine randomness, which consists of a mathematical proof of maximal unpredictability, can only be achieved (to date) by Quantum Random Number Generators that measure value indefinite quantum observables, like the 3D-photonic QRNG Value indefiniteness is the best theoretical certification and can only be provided by applications of the Kochen-Specker Theorem in its localized form studied in [2, 4, 5] studied in [7] The three properties of quantum random sequences generated by a 3D QRNG are:

  1. Every quantum random sequence is 3-bi-immune, by Theorems 6 and 7 in [6] This is stronger than bi-immunity which is stronger than incomputability; see also [12]

  2. Every quantum random sequence is maximally unpredictable, meaning no algorithm can accurately predict any of its digits, Theorem 8 in [6]

  3. Every quantum random sequence is Borel normal, which means that any digit and any string of digits are generated with the same probability, see Lemma 1 in [6]

Physical Constraints and Error Modeling

The physical realization of any device encounters practical obstacles, which result in errors The primary source of errors in integrated quantum photonics is photon loss, which occurs in the couplings and waveguides Additionally, there could be fabrication errors associated with the beam splitter and phase shifter, as well as detection inefficiency These errors can be detected by specific experimental tests such as heralding and coincidence counting The paper suggests two optional modules for experimental certification:

  1. A module that can be coupled to the 3D QRNG and count the output photons, to verify the given probabilities, e. p. 1g. 1/4, 1/2, and 1/4

  2. A module that can undo the unitary transformation and prove that the initial state of the photon was recovered, which will be discussed in Section §7

Verification via Unitary Undoing Test

The test aims to verify two things: 1. the unitarity of the realized QRNG, and 2. p. 0 the accuracy of its physical implementation is ensured by ensuring that the unpredictable errors, which are not systematic, i. p. 6e. consistent deviations in measurements due to imperfect equipment or flawed experimental setups, are very small The procedure to test this involves:

  1. To test a simple phase shift gate P(φ), we add another phase shift gate with opposite phase, as in Figure 4 This will recover the original state

  2. For an imperfect implementation of the unitary transformation from equation (11), we use its mirror image to undo the time evolution The test is successful if the output of the mirror QRNG is identical to the inputs of the original QRNG This will show that even if there are errors, expressed by the difference between the angles and phases from Table 2 and from Table 1, they do not break the unitarity of the device

Generalizations and Conclusion

The test based on inversion can be applied to any dimension, including 2D QRNGs based on beam splitters It can be applied to any QRNGs that rely on a known prepared state and known measurement achievable by realizing a unitary transformation The test does not apply to QRNGs based on noise or decay, because these processes are not invertible In summary, it is of extreme importance to test all aspects of the 3D QRNG, both to ensure the quality of the product and to gain the trust of users This includes: 1. the physical testing of possible errors and deviations from the ideal ratios, 2. p. 8 testing the conservation of 3-bi-immunity, 3. p. 8 ensuring that the limits imposed by the conservation laws, as per the Wigner-ArakiYanase Theorem don’t affect the product; for this, we need to follow [18], and 4. p. 8

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. A test module can be added to a 3D QRNG to undo the unitary transformation, which allows verification that the initial state of the photon was recovered, ensuring that nothing was lost or disturbed in the process.

  2. AI systems could incorporate error propagation testing by coupling multiple imperfect copies of a QRNG and their mirror images to amplify potential errors and make them easier to detect and quantify.

  3. The system can be designed to verify the conservation of 3-bi-immunity, providing assurance that the 3D QRNG is actually quantum by testing this property alongside other experimental certifications.

  4. Implement a test based on inversion where the output of a mirror QRNG is compared to the input by using interference, which can verify that the output of the mirror QRNG is identical to the inputs of the original QRNG.

  5. The system can be designed to verify that orthogonal vectors in the input are mapped to orthogonal vectors in the output, ensuring sharpness and satisfying conditions of Theorem 1.

Sources

Related papers