Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10,M peak in the merging black hole mass distribution
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10,M peak in the merging black hole mass distribution".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Gravitational-wave observations reveal that the rate of merging black holes drops by ∼ 2 orders of magnitude from component masses ∼ 10 M⊙ to ∼ 15 M⊙ In this paper, we consider the possibility that the overdensity is reinforced by supernova processes that result in efficient black hole formation from direct collapse in a narrow range around 10 M⊙ We extend previous studies by considering a distinct subpopulation of failed-supernovae black holes, possibly separated by a gap in the primary mass distribution from the rest of the population Using 153 observations from the latest GWTC-4.0 catalog, we confirm a strong peak in the primary mass distribution at 10 M⊙, with a peak rate density of 7.36+6.35 −3.11 M−1⊙ yr−1Gpc−3 Our results reveal structure in the mass distribution in the 10 − 20 M⊙ range, with rate changes of multiple orders of magnitude across a few solar masses, consistent with a distinct population of failed-supernova black holes.
Vera: The Proposed Population Model The primary mass distribution is modeled as a mixture of two subpopulations: the failed-sn subpopulation and the remainder, which are assumed to form a single population.
Jocelyn: The failed-sn subpopulation is modeled with a truncated Gaussian distribution centered at µf with a standard deviation of σf, and it is truncated at upper and lower masses mmin and mfmax.
Vera: The remainder of merging BBHs are considered “distinct,” and the model uses either the broken powerlaw (BPL) or powerlaw + peak (PLP) models for this subpopulation.
Title and authors: Vera: We're diving into this paper, "Low-mass failed supernovae and the ten M⊙ peak in the merging black hole mass distribution," to see how they explain that drop in merger rates from ten to fifteen solar masses <ref:2604.01420#pg1,Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10 M⊙ peak in the merging>.
Jocelyn: So we saw that this paper looks at a distinct population of failed supernovae black holes and how they might reinforce an overdensity around ten solar masses.
Subrahmanyan: It's connecting the core compactness of stars with carbon-oxygen cores, about six point five solar masses, to direct collapse into black holes thirty-three, which is what drives those peaks at nine solar masses and sixteen solar masses > <ref:2604.01420#pg2>
Vera: They are modeling this primary mass distribution as a mixture of two subpopulations: the failed-sn subpopulation and the remainder, which they assume form a single population >
Jocelyn: The failed-sn subpopulation is modeled with a truncated Gaussian distribution centered at mu f with a standard deviation of sigma f, and it's truncated at lower and upper masses m min and mf max >
Subrahmanyan: And the remainder of merging binary black holes are treated as distinct sources, so they use either the broken power law or power law plus peak models for that population >
Jocelyn: They say this is consistent with a true gap in these ranges, but they caution that it doesn't actually require one because of the long tail in the rate posterior >
Subrahmanyan: The turnover mass where the high-mass population starts is estimated at sixteen point two one plus three point eight one minus six point nine one solar masses >
The paper's summary: Vera: This segment summarizes what they actually found about the merging black hole mass distribution based on their model. They are trying to explain that rate drop from ten to fifteen solar masses.
Jocelyn: So they confirm a strong peak in the primary mass distribution right at ten solar masses with a peak rate density of seven point three plus six point three minus three point one one solar masses per year per gigaparsec cubed >
Subrahmanyan: That measurement is significant because it links that observed overdensity directly to the failed supernova component and direct collapse formation of black holes in that specific mass range >
Vera: They also show structure in the mass distribution within the ten to twenty solar mass range with rate changes of multiple orders of magnitude across a few solar masses, which they link to a distinct population of failed supernovae black holes >
Jocelyn: This means they see evidence for this distinct subpopulation that's separated from the rest based on how frequently those binaries merge >
Subrahmanyan: The model setup involves the fraction lambda f of sources in the failed-sn population, which is modeled as a truncated Gaussian distribution >
Vera: They also explore different modeling choices for that remainder population, using either broken power law or power law plus peak models depending on what fits best >
Jocelyn: The core idea is to use this mixture model to see if it can reproduce the observed merger rate data better than a simpler model >
Subrahmanyan: They are essentially testing whether adding this failed-sn component helps explain the rate drop from ten solar masses down to fifteen solar masses, or if it just adds noise >
The paper's improvements: Vera: Now let's talk about what the authors suggest they improved upon in previous studies by proposing this new model. They are looking at how this structure in the mass distribution is created.
Jocelyn: They are suggesting that the failed supernovae processes might be reinforcing that overdensity by causing efficient black hole formation from direct collapse in a narrow range around ten solar masses >
Subrahmanyan: This means they're proposing a mechanism where failure of stars to launch a supernova and instead collapsing directly to black holes depends on other details of the progenitor stars >
Vera: They are extending previous work by considering this distinct subpopulation of failed-supernovae black holes, possibly separated by a gap in the primary mass distribution from the rest of the population >
Jocelyn: The way they do it is by separating them out into their own model—a truncated Gaussian for failed-sn and then using broken power law or power law plus peak models for everything else >
Subrahmanyan: This model allows them to test whether a gap is actually present in the mass distribution, which is what a simpler model couldn't do >
Vera: They are using the Bayes factor between two different population models to see how much that difference depends on whether a gap is permitted >
Jocelyn: It shows that the large difference isn't just about having more freedom but depends specifically on whether a gap is allowed in their mass distribution >
Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up this paper "Low-mass failed supernovae and the ten M⊙ peak in the merging black hole mass distribution," they found that most of the posterior supports a local minimum in p(m one) between ten and twenty solar masses > <ref:2604.01420#pg1,Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10 M⊙ peak in the merging>
Jocelyn: That means a gap is supported by the majority of the posterior but not required at that ten percent credible level >
Subrahmanyan: The presence of substructure beyond a power law in primary mass distribution has been established in numerous other studies, so this supports that idea even if it's not strictly necessary here >
Vera: The main implication is that failed SNe could be the origin of this feature, but for the next step they need to do fully general relativistic simulations to determine the finer details theoretically >
Jocelyn: And they also confirmed that ten solar mass binaries have a narrower aligned spin distribution than other populations >
Subrahmanyan: That's a concrete result about spins, which is something that will be useful for predicting how many of these mergers we actually see in observations >
TAPIR · LIGO Laboratory · Illinois Center for Advanced Studies of the Universe
astro-ph.HE
Submitted: 2026-04-01
Updated: 2026-11-09
Comments: 19 pages, 12 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 82/100
The gist: Gravitational-wave observations reveal that the rate of merging black holes drops by ∼ 2 orders of magnitude from component masses ∼ 10 M⊙ to ∼ 15 M⊙ In this paper…
Key concepts
- Failed-SN Subpopulation
- This is a hypothesized group of black holes formed when supernovae fail to fully collapse. The study suggests this mechanism might efficiently produce black holes in a narrow mass range around 10 M⊙, potentially explaining the observed peak in the merger rate at that specific mass.
- Mass Distribution Gap
- A gap refers to an interval where the merger rate drops significantly between two mass ranges. The analysis tested whether this gap exists between low-mass and high-mass black holes, finding that while a gap is suggested by the data, it is not strictly required at a 10% confidence level.
- Bayes Factor
- The Bayes Factor is a statistical tool used to compare two competing models. In this study, it was used to compare two different models for the black hole population—one including failed-SN sources and another without—to determine which model better explains the observed merger rates.
- Turnover Mass
- This is the specific mass where the merger rate transitions from a steep decline to a flatter trend in a population. The study identified this point at 16.21+3.81−6.91 M⊙, marking where the high-mass black hole population begins.
Terminology
Summary
Gravitational-wave observations reveal that the rate of merging black holes drops by ∼ 2 orders of magnitude from component masses ∼ 10 M⊙ to ∼ 15 M⊙ In this paper, we consider the possibility that the overdensity is reinforced by supernova processes that result in efficient black hole formation from direct collapse in a narrow range around 10 M⊙ We extend previous studies by considering a distinct subpopulation of failed-supernovae black holes, possibly separated by a gap in the primary mass distribution from the rest of the population Using 153 observations from the latest GWTC-4. p. 0 In this paper, we consider the possibility that the overdensity is reinforced by supernova
processes that result in efficient black hole formation from direct collapse in a narrow range around
10 M⊙. We extend previous studies by considering a distinct subpopulation of failed-supernovae
black holes, possibly separated by a gap in the primary mass distribution from the rest of the
population. Using 153 observations from the latest GWTC-4. 0 catalog, we confirm a strong peak
in the primary mass distribution at 10 M⊙, with a peak rate density of 7. 1) M⊙, then rises again to confidently nonzero values above ∼ 16 M⊙ before falling at
higher masses. Our results reveal structure in the mass distribution in the 10 − 20 M⊙ range, with
rate changes of multiple orders of magnitude across a few solar masses, consistent with a distinct
population of failed-supernova black holes.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Proposed Population Model
The primary mass distribution is modeled as a mixture of two subpopulations: the failed-sn subpopulation and the remainder, which are assumed to form a single population. The failed-sn subpopulation is modeled with a truncated Gaussian distribution centered at µf with a standard deviation of σf, and it is truncated at upper and lower masses mmin and mfmax. p. 2 The failed-sn primary mass distribution is a Gaussian
distribution centered at µ
f with a standard deviation of
σ
f
, and truncated at upper and lower masses of m
f
min
and mf
max, respectively. All other events belong to the
subpopulation ΦX, whose hyperparameters ΛX are the
typical parameters of the corresponding models [5, 14,
15, 56]. The remainder of merging
BBHs are “distinct,” and therefore we are agnostic about
their origin, though we do assume they form a single population. For this subpopulation we consider the broken
powerlaw (2 power laws) and powerlaw + peak (1
power law and 1 Gaussian) models [5].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Key Findings on Mass Distribution
The analysis of the inferred differential merger rate shows consistency with a gap, meaning an interval with strongly suppressed merger rate between the low-mass and the high-mass subpopulations. Specifically, the data are consistent with a true “gap” in these ranges, but do not require it, as evident from the long tail of the rate posterior in Fig. p. 4 1) M⊙, while for the failedsn+broken powerlaw model the corresponding range
is (12. The data are consistent with a true
“gap” in these ranges, but do not require it, as evident
from the long tail of the rate posterior in Fig. The distribution of merging BBHs is further consistent with a separation between the ∼ 10M⊙
peak and the higher-mass component of the population,
with the data preferring but not requiring a “gap. ” The
turnover mass at which the high-mass population begins
is 16.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Comparison with Default Models
The failed-sn + powerlaw + peak model allows for a gap in the primary mass distribution between the ∼ 10 M⊙ peak and higher masses, which the default model does not permit. The Bayes Factor between failed-sn + powerlaw + peak and failedsn+broken powerlaw is ∼ 2. p. 2 Both models return similar results, including consistency with a gap, meaning an
interval with strongly suppressed merger rate (quantified
below), between the low-mass and the high-mass subpopulations. In terms of model comparison, the Bayes Factor
between failed-sn + powerlaw + peak and failedsn+broken powerlaw is ∼ 2.Where the paper says it
Implications for Astrophysical Origins
If failed SNe are the origin of such a feature, fully general relativistic simulations of BH formation from failed SNe will likely be necessary to determine the finer details of this distribution theoretically. The results confirm that the 10 M⊙ binaries have a narrower aligned spin distribution than the rest of the population. p. 7 They also did not explicitly search for a gap. Our results
confirm that the 10 M⊙ binaries have a narrower aligned
spin distribution than the rest of the population.Where the paper says it
Model Refinements and Outliers
Excluding sources below the failed-sn peak leads to rate changes above the peak is an outcome of the model choice, and especially the tightening of the failed-sn Gaussian. The presence of substructure in the BBH primary mass distribution beyond a power law has been established in numerous other studies. p. 7 If such a gap is confirmed with future data, it would constitute strong evidence that the
∼ 10 M⊙ BBHs originate from an astrophysically distinct
mechanism than the remaining high-mass population. The presence of substructure in the BBH primary mass
distribution beyond a power law has been established in
numerous other studies. If such a gap is confirmed with future data, it would constitute strong evidence that the
∼ 10 M⊙ BBHs originate from an astrophysically distinct
mechanism than the remaining high-mass population. The presence of substructure in the BBH primary mass
distribution beyond a power law has been established in
numerous other studies. Moreover, BHs formed from direct collapse of overcompact massive stars should have lower kicks [36], increasing
the chances of binary survival. A model directly based
on this scenario is explored in Ref. We adopt the same functional form for
both subpopulations, namely a Gaussian for χeff and a
power law for q (an alternative Gaussian model is presented in App. The hyperparameters ηFSN and ηX of
each subpopulation are distinct, motivated by evidence
that the high and low masses have different mass ratio and spin distributions [24].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Gap Existence
The majority of the posterior supports a local minimum in p(m1) between 10 and 20 M⊙ (88% for failed-sn + powerlaw + peak model). Overall, a gap is supported by the majority of the posterior but not required at the 10% credible level. p. 5 Indeed,
in the failed-sn + powerlaw + peak model there is
≈ 88% support for a local minimum in p(m1) between 10
and 20 M⊙ (54% for failed-sn+broken powerlaw). Overall, a gap is supported by the majority of the posterior but not required at the 10% credible level.Where the paper says it
Rate Estimation Justification
We conservatively adopt the same V T at 15+15 M⊙ as 20+20 M⊙. This comparison suggests that at the level of approximation we consider, jointly O1-O4a featured at most double the observed V T of O4a alone. p. 4 Using results from Ref. [1], we make a
liberal estimate of the total amount volume-time probed
for ∼ 15 + 15 M⊙ BBHs of ∼ 20 Gpc3 yr for observing runs O1–O4a, see App. At a differential rate of
10−3M−1
⊙ Gpc−3
yr−1
, we thus would expect ∼ 0. 1 detections from an interval of 5 M⊙ around this mass value.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Future Directions
Effort to identify gaps, dips, and in general features in the mass distribution will continue offering clues about subpopulations with potentially distinct astrophysical origins. It is possible that m1 and m2 display suppressed merger rates in different mass ranges. p. 8 9
It is possible, however, that m1 and m2 display suppressed merger rates in different mass ranges, e. , the recent evidence for a pair instability gap in m2 only [79–85]. Identifying differences in the m1 and m2 distributions
and connecting them to astrophysical models is complicated by label-swapping [59, 86, 87]. The GW signal,
and thus the analysis likelihood, is invariant under exchanging the binary components, with the convention
m1 > m2 breaking this invariance.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform population modeling that incorporates distinct astrophysical channels for black hole formation, specifically distinguishing between a failed-supernova subpopulation and a background power-law component. This allows the system to model phenomena like
efficient black hole formation from direct collapse in a narrow range around 10 M⊙
as proposed in the paper. -
Improved AI can accurately infer the presence or absence of astrophysical gaps in mass distributions by comparing different population priors, such as the failed-sn + powerlaw + peak model versus a default model. The system can determine that
the data are consistent with a gap, but do not require it,
by analyzing the posterior predictive distribution for primary masses. -
Improved AI can perform sensitivity analysis on detection limits to determine when an observed rate is
effectively zero.
This capability allows the system to justify the conclusion that at a differential rate of 10 minus 3 M-1 yr-1 Gpc-3 yr M-1,we thus would expect approximately 0.1 detections from an interval of 5 M⊙ around this mass value.
-
Improved AI can compare different modeling choices for pairing black hole masses to assess their impact on gap inference. The system can demonstrate that
the data are inconsistent with the same gap being present in both the m1 and m2 distributions
when using a pairing model, which is a key test of whether a gap in one mass distribution implies a gap in the other. -
Improved AI can assess the impact of specific outlier events on inferred subpopulation parameters. The system can show how
excluding sources below the failed-sn peak leads to rate changes above the peak is an outcome of the model choice, and especially the tightening of the failed-sn Gaussian.
Abstract
Gravitational-wave observations reveal that the rate of merging black holes drops by about2 orders of magnitude from component masses about 10,M to about 15,M. The increased compactness of the black hole progenitor cores may contribute to the about 10,M overdensity, but cannot fully explain the rate difference. In this paper, we consider the possibility that the overdensity is reinforced by supernova processes that result in efficient black hole formation from direct collapse in a narrow range around 10, M. We extend previous studies by considering a distinct subpopulation of failed-supernovae black holes, possibly separated by a gap in the primary mass distribution from the rest of the population. Using 153 observations from the latest GWTC-4.0 catalog, we confirm a strong peak in the primary mass distribution at 10,M, with a peak rate density of 7.36-3.11+6.35 M-1 yr-1 Gpc-3. The rate drops sharply and becomes consistent with zero at the 90 % level for primary mass m 1 in (12.0, 16.1), M, then rises again to confidently nonzero values above about 16,M before falling at higher masses. Our results reveal structure in the mass distribution in the 10-20,M range, with rate changes of multiple orders of magnitude across a few solar masses, consistent with a distinct population of failed-supernova black holes. These conclusions persist in the latest GWTC-5.0 catalog.
Sources
- GWTC-4.0: Updating the Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog with Observations from the First Part of the Fourth LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Observing Run
- Advanced LIGO
- Advanced Virgo: a 2nd generation interferometric gravitational wave detector
- Overview of KAGRA: Detector design and construction history
- GWTC-4.0: Population Properties of Merging Compact Binaries
- The Evolution of Compact Binary Star Systems
- Dynamical Formation of the GW150914 Binary Black Hole
- Formation channels of single and binary stellar-mass black holes
- Black hole - black hole total merger mass and the origin of LIGO/Virgo sources
- One Channel to Rule Them All? Constraining the Origins of Binary Black Holes using Multiple Formation Pathways
- Mass Distribution of Binary Black Hole Mergers from Young and Old Dense Star Clusters
- Population Properties of Compact Objects from the Second LIGO-Virgo Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog
- The population of merging compact binaries inferred using gravitational waves through GWTC-3
- Cover Your Basis: Comprehensive Data-Driven Characterization of the Binary Black Hole Population
- Things that might go bump in the night: Assessing structure in the binary black hole mass spectrum
- A Parameter-Free Tour of the Binary Black Hole Population
- Is there an excess of black holes around $20 M_{\odot}$? Optimising the complexity of population models with the use of reversible jump MCMC
- Searching for additional structure and redshift evolution in the observed binary black hole population with a parametric time-dependent mass distribution
- Spectral sirens cosmology from binary black holes populations with sharper mass features
- Ain't No Mountain High Enough: Semi-Parametric Modeling of LIGO-Virgos Binary Black Hole Mass Distribution
Related papers
- Low- T/W instabilities in differentially rotating neutron stars resembling merger remnants
- The imprint of individual neutron star spins on ejecta, r-process nucleosynthesis, and kilonovae in binary neutron star mergers
- Early panchromatic spectra reveal helium in the thermonuclear supernova 2024kce
- The Double-Peaked Calcium-Strong SN 2025coe: Progenitor Constraints from Early Interaction and Ejecta Asymmetries
- The pulsar population of Omega Centauri: New TRAPUM searches, timing, and cluster dynamics with MeerKAT and Parkes
- One year of broadband radio monitoring of the enigmatic transient GRB 250702B reveals the evolution of the relativistic jet