Searching for New Physics Inside Jets with the Herwig 7 Generalised Parton Shower

arXiv:2604.00617 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-04-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Searching for New Physics Inside Jets with the Herwig 7 Generalised Parton Shower".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. This study investigates parton shower evolution incorporating both Standard Model (SM) and beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) radiation, focusing on the phenomenology of a massive Z′ boson While traditional approaches typically assume direct Z′ production in the hard process, the possibility of Z′ production within jets, enabled by subsequent emissions in the parton shower, offers a complementary opportunity to probe new physics through jet substructure and event topology The newly developed Herwig 7 framework supporting BSM parton showers enables efficient simulation of Z′ production in the logarithmically enhanced regime Using a simple BSM benchmark, the minimal U(1)B−L extension of the SM, the interplay between the SM and BSM showers is evaluated to identify kinematic features that distinguish Z′ -induced jets from conventional signatures The Standard Model (SM) is known to be incomplete because it neither incorporates gravity nor explains dark matter and dark energy, the hierarchy problem, or the observed matterantimatter asymmetry The motivation for physics beyond the SM (BSM) stems from issues such as small but non-zero neutrino masses and persistent tensions in B-meson decay observables State-of-the-art hadron colliders like the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) provide a unique environment to probe these open questions by accessing energy scales where new physics may manifest Searches have shifted towards signals concealed in less explored regions of phase space, including jet-associated soft objects and hidden-valley, dark-shower, and semi-visiblejet signatures Simulation Framework and Methodology The present work utilizes the Herwig 7 BSM parton shower framework to study Z′ radiation in the logarithmically enhanced regime within the U(1)B−L model The simulation compares kinematics of Z′ bosons produced via shower radiation with samples where the Z′ is produced at the matrix-element (ME) level Hard di-jet events are generated with MadGraph 5, and Herwig 7 is used to simulate both SM and BSM showers, then compared with Z′ + 2-jet samples generated in MadGraph 5 The analysis activates both SM and BSM showers simultaneously, enabling a phenomenological validation of the algorithm in the fully showered regime Sample Generation Strategies The signal samples are constructed by generating hard di-jet events with MadGraph 5 and then simulating subsequent Z′ radiation within Herwig 7 as part of the combined SM and BSM parton shower evolution Validation samples, denoted as “MG(Z’)+HW”, are generated by supplementing MadGraph 5-generated Z′ + 2-jet events with the SM shower in Herwig 7 Background samples, such as QCD and top-induced processes, are constructed using PYTHIA 8 at leading order to characterize the relevant phase space Kinematic Analysis and Sensitivity The analysis examines parton-level kinematic distributions using samples like HW(Z’+SM PS), HW(only Z’ PS), MG(Z’)+HW, and MG(Z’) to disentangle differences between Z′ bosons produced via parton shower radiation and those generated at fixed order The study maps the two key variables, the angular separation and the momentum fraction of the quark-Z′ system, onto reconstructed jets and leptons to examine how these trends are preserved Sensitivity projections are derived using an Asimov-based significance estimate for signal yields against smooth analytic background parametrisation The results indicate that evidence-level sensitivity may be achievable for Z′ masses up to ∼ 25 GeV for αqZ′ × BR(Z′ → µ+µ−) = 10−7 with standard muon triggers The scouting trigger strategy provides systematically higher sensitivity across the full mass range This work demonstrates that BSM parton shower radiation can act as a genuine signal mechanism, providing a concrete demonstration that new physics can be uncovered in regions that have so far remained largely unexplored The results establish a baseline for searches driven by BSM radiation in the parton shower and motivate extensions to broader models beyond the minimal U(1)B−L extension of the SM A dedicated treatment of systematic uncertainties, particularly electroweak Sudakov effects and heavy-flavour mass schemes, remains an important direction for future work The observed trend follows the behaviour of the expected significance, with stronger exclusion limits obtained in the low-mass region where the Z′ radiation rate is enhanced The scouting trigger strategy yields systematically stronger constraints than the nominal trigger across all mass ranges This work has explored an experimentally under-investigated phase space for new physics searches, characterised by non-isolated di-muon signatures embedded inside jets Using the newly developed BSM parton shower framework in Herwig 7, we generated fully showered event samples in which a light Z′ boson is emitted inside jets and subsequently decays into a collimated muon pair Focusing on a minimal U(1)B−L benchmark as a representative example, we have shown that shower-induced Z′ radiation leads to distinctive kinematic features, most notably di-muons residing well inside jets Based on a smooth analytic description of the dominant QCD- and top-induced backgrounds, we have performed a first-look sensitivity study using Asimov-based significance estimates and expected exclusion limits Already with Run-2+3 luminosity and standard muon triggers, the analysis indicates that evidence-level sensitivity may be achievable for Z′ masses up to ∼ 25 GeV for αqZ′ × BR(Z′ → µ+µ−) = 10−7 The reach is further enhanced when scouting-trigger strategies are employed, and projections to the HL-LHC suggest that searches across the O(10) GeV mass range could become accessible Given the increasing jet activity at the HL-LHC and future hadron colliders, the importance of such non-isolated signatures is expected to grow The study establishes a baseline for a class of searches driven by BSM radiation in the parton shower and motivates several natural extensions This work demonstrates that BSM parton shower radiation provides a realistic and phenomenologically rich mechanism for uncovering new physics in regions that have so far remained largely unexplored Acknowledgments This research was supported in Korea by National Research Foundation grants RS-2024- 00350406 and RS-2028-NR 7227 MRM is supported by the UK Science and Technology Facilities Council (grant numbers ST/T 11/1 and ST/X 745/1), as is MHS (grant numbers ST/T 38/1 and ST/X 77X/1) References

1: S.L.

Kai: Glashow, Partial symmetries of weak interactions, Nucl.

Mira: Phys.

Kai: 22 (1961) 579

38: S.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper investigates parton shower evolution incorporating both Standard Model and beyond-the-Standard-Model radiation with a focus on the phenomenology of a massive Z prime boson.

Mira: The authors claim that Z prime production inside jets, enabled by subsequent emissions in the parton shower, offers a complementary opportunity to probe new physics through jet substructure and event topology.

Lev: They are using the Herwig seven framework to simulate this BSM radiation efficiently in the logarithmically enhanced regime <ref:2604.00617#pg1>.

Kai: They test this with a simple U(one)B minus L model, evaluating how the Standard Model and BSM showers interact to identify kinematic features that separate Z prime induced jets from conventional signatures <ref:2604.00617#pg2>.

Mira: They are constructing signal samples by generating hard di-jet events with MadGraph five and then simulating subsequent Z prime radiation within Herwig seven as part of the combined SM and BSM parton shower evolution <ref:2604.00617#pg1>.

Lev: They also have validation samples, called MG(Z’)+HW, which supplement the hard production results with the Standard Model shower in Herwig seven to check if their algorithm works well in the fully showered regime <ref:2604.00617#pg1>.

Kai: The analysis looks at parton-level kinematic distributions using samples like HW(Z’+SM PS), HW(only Z’ PS), MG(Z’)+HW, and MG(Z’) to see the differences between Z prime bosons produced via shower radiation and those generated at fixed order.

Mira: They map two key variables onto reconstructed jets and leptons: the angular separation and the momentum fraction of the quark-Z prime system, trying to see how those trends are preserved in real data.

Lev: They also derive sensitivity projections using an Asimov-based significance estimate for signal yields against a smooth analytic background parametrisation.

Kai: Their results indicate that evidence-level sensitivity may be achievable for Z prime masses up to twenty-five GeV when the coupling strength times the branching ratio is one to ten to the minus seven with standard muon triggers <ref:2604.00617#pg1>.

Mira: They also point out that a scouting trigger strategy provides systematically higher sensitivity across the full mass range than using a nominal trigger.

Lev: And they note that this trend follows what you'd expect based on the significance, showing stronger exclusion limits in the low mass region where the Z prime radiation rate is enhanced.

Kai: So, what we are seeing here is that BSM parton shower radiation can act as a genuine signal mechanism, providing a concrete demonstration that new physics can be uncovered in regions that have so far remained largely unexplored.

Conclusion: Mira: Thinking about the whole thing, the title "Searching for New Physics Inside Jets with the Herwig seven Generalised Parton Shower" points to how they've shifted our search strategy from isolated signals to these non-isolated di-muon signatures embedded inside jets <ref:2604.00617#pg1,Searching for New Physics Inside Jets with the Herwig 7 Generalised Parton>.

Kai: It’s a significant point because it suggests that new physics doesn't have to show up as a simple, clean particle production in the hard scatter; it can be smeared out through the shower evolution.

Lev: They established a baseline for searches driven by BSM radiation in the parton shower, which is important because it gives us something concrete to build upon when we look for these signatures at future colliders like the HL-LHC.

Mira: The results show that this approach provides a realistic and phenomenologically rich mechanism for uncovering new physics in regions that have so far remained largely unexplored by focusing on jet substructure.

Kai: They motivate extensions to broader models beyond the minimal U(one)B minus L extension of the Standard Model, which is a natural next step for theory <ref:2604.00617#pg2>.

Lev: And they flag that a dedicated treatment of systematic uncertainties, especially electroweak Sudakov effects and heavy-flavour mass schemes, is an important direction for future work in this area.

Taehee Kima, Joon-Bin Lee, M.R. Masouminiab, Michael H. Seymour, Un-ki Yanga

Seoul National University · Institute for Particle Physics Phenomenology at Durham University · Department of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Manchester Department of Theoretical Physics at CERN

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-04-01

Updated: 2026-04-01

Journal ref: JHEP 10 (2026) 205

DOI: 10.1007/JHEP10(2026)205

License: http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: This study investigates parton shower evolution incorporating both Standard Model (SM) and beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) radiation…

Key concepts

Parton Shower Evolution
This is a computational technique used in particle physics simulations to model how quarks and gluons fragment after being produced. It describes the cascading emissions of radiation, which is crucial for accurately simulating complex events like those at the LHC.
Z' Boson Production in Jets
Traditional searches look for Z' bosons produced directly. This research explores a complementary search: looking for a Z' boson emitted *within* jets due to subsequent parton shower emissions. This allows probing new physics through jet substructure.
U(1)B-L Model
This is a specific Beyond-Standard-Model (BSM) extension of the Standard Model that introduces new gauge symmetries. It is used here as a simple benchmark to test how the SM and BSM radiation processes interact and generate unique signatures.
Scouting Trigger Strategy
This is an optimized trigger strategy for experimental data analysis. It systematically yields stronger constraints on potential new physics signals compared to standard triggers, especially in the low-mass region where Z' radiation is enhanced.

Terminology

Summary

This study investigates parton shower evolution incorporating both Standard Model (SM) and beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) radiation, focusing on the phenomenology of a massive Z′ boson While traditional approaches typically assume direct Z′ production in the hard process, the possibility of Z′ production within jets, enabled by subsequent emissions in the parton shower, offers a complementary opportunity to probe new physics through jet substructure and event topology The newly developed Herwig 7 framework supporting BSM parton showers enables efficient simulation of Z′ production in the logarithmically enhanced regime Using a simple BSM benchmark, the minimal U(1)B−L extension of the SM, the interplay between the SM and BSM showers is evaluated to identify kinematic features that distinguish Z′ -induced jets from conventional signatures

Introduction to Beyond-Standard-Model Physics

The Standard Model (SM) is known to be incomplete because it neither incorporates gravity nor explains dark matter and dark energy, the hierarchy problem, or the observed matterantimatter asymmetry The motivation for physics beyond the SM (BSM) stems from issues such as small but non-zero neutrino masses and persistent tensions in B-meson decay observables State-of-the-art hadron colliders like the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) provide a unique environment to probe these open questions by accessing energy scales where new physics may manifest Searches have shifted towards signals concealed in less explored regions of phase space, including jet-associated soft objects and hidden-valley, dark-shower, and semi-visiblejet signatures

Simulation Framework and Methodology

The present work utilizes the Herwig 7 BSM parton shower framework to study Z′ radiation in the logarithmically enhanced regime within the U(1)B−L model The simulation compares kinematics of Z′ bosons produced via shower radiation with samples where the Z′ is produced at the matrix-element (ME) level Hard di-jet events are generated with MadGraph 5, and Herwig 7 is used to simulate both SM and BSM showers, then compared with Z′ + 2-jet samples generated in MadGraph 5 The analysis activates both SM and BSM showers simultaneously, enabling a phenomenological validation of the algorithm in the fully showered regime

Sample Generation Strategies

The signal samples are constructed by generating hard di-jet events with MadGraph 5 and then simulating subsequent Z′ radiation within Herwig 7 as part of the combined SM and BSM parton shower evolution Validation samples, denoted as “MG(Z’)+HW”, are generated by supplementing MadGraph 5-generated Z′ + 2-jet events with the SM shower in Herwig 7 Background samples, such as QCD and top-induced processes, are constructed using PYTHIA 8 at leading order to characterize the relevant phase space

Kinematic Analysis and Sensitivity

The analysis examines parton-level kinematic distributions using samples like HW(Z’+SM PS), HW(only Z’ PS), MG(Z’)+HW, and MG(Z’) to disentangle differences between Z′ bosons produced via parton shower radiation and those generated at fixed order The study maps the two key variables, the angular separation and the momentum fraction of the quark-Z′ system, onto reconstructed jets and leptons to examine how these trends are preserved Sensitivity projections are derived using an Asimov-based significance estimate for signal yields against smooth analytic background parametrisation The results indicate that evidence-level sensitivity may be achievable for Z′ masses up to ∼ 25 GeV for αqZ′ × BR(Z′ → µ+µ−) = 10−7 with standard muon triggers The scouting trigger strategy provides systematically higher sensitivity across the full mass range

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work demonstrates that BSM parton shower radiation can act as a genuine signal mechanism, providing a concrete demonstration that new physics can be uncovered in regions that have so far remained largely unexplored The results establish a baseline for searches driven by BSM radiation in the parton shower and motivate extensions to broader models beyond the minimal U(1)B−L extension of the SM A dedicated treatment of systematic uncertainties, particularly electroweak Sudakov effects and heavy-flavour mass schemes, remains an important direction for future work The observed trend follows the behaviour of the expected significance, with stronger exclusion limits obtained in the low-mass region where the Z′ radiation rate is enhanced The scouting trigger strategy yields systematically stronger constraints than the nominal trigger across all mass ranges

Summary and Conclusions

This work has explored an experimentally under-investigated phase space for new physics searches, characterised by non-isolated di-muon signatures embedded inside jets Using the newly developed BSM parton shower framework in Herwig 7, we generated fully showered event samples in which a light Z′ boson is emitted inside jets and subsequently decays into a collimated muon pair Focusing on a minimal U(1)B−L benchmark as a representative example, we have shown that shower-induced Z′ radiation leads to distinctive kinematic features, most notably di-muons residing well inside jets Based on a smooth analytic description of the dominant QCD- and top-induced backgrounds, we have performed a first-look sensitivity study using Asimov-based significance estimates and expected exclusion limits Already with Run-2+3 luminosity and standard muon triggers, the analysis indicates that evidence-level sensitivity may be achievable for Z′ masses up to ∼ 25 GeV for αqZ′ × BR(Z′ → µ+µ−) = 10−7 The reach is further enhanced when scouting-trigger strategies are employed, and projections to the HL-LHC suggest that searches across the O(10) GeV mass range could become accessible Given the increasing jet activity at the HL-LHC and future hadron colliders, the importance of such non-isolated signatures is expected to grow The study establishes a baseline for a class of searches driven by BSM radiation in the parton shower and motivates several natural extensions This work demonstrates that BSM parton shower radiation provides a realistic and phenomenologically rich mechanism for uncovering new physics in regions that have so far remained largely unexplored

Acknowledgments

This research was supported in Korea by National Research Foundation grants RS-2024- 00350406 and RS-2028-NR 7227 MRM is supported by the UK Science and Technology Facilities Council (grant numbers ST/T 11/1 and ST/X 745/1), as is MHS (grant numbers ST/T 38/1 and ST/X 77X/1)

References

[1] S.L. Glashow, Partial symmetries of weak interactions, Nucl. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The SM Lagrangian remains otherwise unchanged. Other interactions that may arise in specific ultraviolet completions are not relevant for the collider phenomenology considered here [38–40].

p. 7
Where the paper says it

The SM Lagrangian remains otherwise unchanged. Other interactions that may arise in specific ultraviolet completions are not relevant for the collider phenomenology considered here [38–40].

Phys. 22 (1961) 579

[38] S. Amrith, J.M. Butterworth, F.F Deppisch, W. Liu, A. Varma and D Yallup, LHC constraints on a B – L gauge model using Contur, JHEP 2019 (2019) 154

[54] J.-B. Lee, M.R. Masouminia, M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

ch, mohammad. masouminia@durham.

H. Seymour and U ki Yang, Generalized angular-order parton showers in Herwig 7, JHEP 2024 (2024) 64

[79] G Cowan, K Cranmer, E Gross and O Vitells, Asymptotic formulae for likelihood-based tests of new physics, The European Physical Journal C 71 (2011)

[86] A Falkowski, S.F. King, E Perdomo and M Pierre, Flavourful Z′ portal for vector-like neutrino dark matter and rK(∗), JHEP 2018 (2018)

Figure Captions

Figure 1 shows the coupling-dependence study of Z′ radiation in the parton shower for MZ′ = 5, 10, 20, and 50 GeV Figure 2 shows three typical Feynman diagrams that can produce a Z′ boson in proton-proton collisions Figure 3 presents the parton-level kinematic distributions between the identified partner quark (q) and the Z′ boson for typical mass points, MZ′ = 5, 20, and 50 GeV Figure 4 presents the analysis-level observables corresponding to the parton-level variables Figure 5 shows the angular separation, ∆R, between the jet and the leading and subleading muons for the case MZ′ = 20 GeV Figure 6 shows di-muon invariant-mass distributions for the combined QCD and top backgrounds, together with the results of the analytic background fit Figure 7 summarizes the expected statistical sensitivity to Z′ radiation inside jets as a function of MZ′

Table Summaries

Table 1 specifies the event sample configurations used in these comparisons, following the definitions in Sec. 3 Table 1 summarizes the generator configurations used in these comparisons, following the definitions in Sec. 3

Final Notes

The analysis adopts a conservative requirement ∆R(µ, jet) < 0.3 in order to focus on muons that are robustly associated with the jet and have not influenced its direction unduly The results serve as a first assessment of the discovery and exclusion potential of non-isolated di-muon signatures arising from Z′ radiation inside jets The observed trend follows the behaviour of the expected significance, with stronger exclusion limits obtained in the low-mass region where the Z′ radiation rate is enhanced The scouting trigger strategy yields systematically stronger constraints than the nominal trigger across all mass ranges

References List

[1] S.L. Glashow, Partial symmetries of weak interactions, Nucl. Phys. 22 (1961) 579

[38] S Amrith, J M Butterworth, F F Deppisch, W Liu A Varma and D Yallup LHC constraints on a B – L gauge model using Contur, JHEP 2019 (2019) 154

[54] J-B Lee, M R Masouminia, M H Seymour and U ki Yang Generalized angular-order parton showers in Herwig 7, JHEP 2024 (2024) 64

[79] G Cowan, K Cranmer, E Gross and O Vitells Asymptotic formulae for likelihood-based tests of new physics, The European Physical Journal C 71 (2011)

[86] A Falkowski, S.F. King, E Perdomo and M Pierre Flavourful Z′ portal for vector-like neutrino dark matter and rK(∗), JHEP 2018 (2018)

[55] S Kulkarni, M R Masouminia, S Plätzer and D Stafford Dark sector showers and hadronisation in Herwig 7, The European Physical Journal C 84 (2024)

[69] L A Harland-Lang, A D Martin, P Motylinski and R S Thorne Parton distributions in the LHC era: MMHT 2014 PDFs, The European Physical Journal C 75 (2015)

[70] CMS collaboration CMS PYTHIA 8 colour reconnection tunes based on underlying-event data, The European Physical Journal C 83 (2023)

[75] CMS collaboration Determination of jet identification criteria with proton-proton collision at 13.6 TeV data collected with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC,. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Meanwhile, state-of-the-art hadron colliders such as the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and future high-energy machines provide a unique environment to probe these open questions by accessing energy scales where new physics may manifest. A broad programme of TeV-scale searches has therefore been pursued, including mono-lepton [11], di-lepton [12, 13], multi-lepton [14–16], missing-transverse-energy plus jets [17], di-jet [18, 19], and multi-jet signatures [20].

[78] CMS collaboration Performance of CMS muon reconstruction from proton-proton to heavy ion collisions, Journal of Instrumentation 19 (2024) P09012

[77] M Cacciari, G P Salam and G Soyez The anti-kt jet clustering algorithm, JHEP 2008 (2008) 063–063

[79] G Cowan, K Cranmer, E Gross and O Vitells Asymptotic formulae for likelihood-based tests of new physics, The European Physical Journal C 71 (2011)

[80] C Degrande Automatic evaluation of UV and R2 terms for beyond the Standard Model Lagrangians: A proof-of-principle, Computer Physics Communications 197 (2015) 239

[85] N Darvishi, A Pilaftsis and J-H Yu Maximising CP Violation in Naturally Aligned Two-Higgs Doublet Models, 2312.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Automated identification of new physics signals in jet substructure by simulating Z prime production within parton shower evolution, enabling searches for non-isolated lepton signatures.

  2. Enhanced ability to discriminate between Standard Model backgrounds like QCD and top-quark processes and BSM signatures by analyzing kinematic features such as di-muons residing well inside jets.

  3. Development of a model agnostic approach where the system can characterize how new physics manifests through non-isolated dimuons and identifying robust kinematic features, providing a baseline for future model extensions.

  4. Capability to estimate experimental sensitivity at the LHC and future colliders via statistical-significance projections based on signal and background samples, including comparisons between standard and scouting trigger strategies.

  5. Implementation of a framework that allows for a phenomenological validation of the algorithm in the fully showered regime by simultaneously activating SM and BSM showers, quantifying the impact of QCD logarithmic enhancements on soft and collinear Z prime production.

Abstract

This study investigates parton shower evolution incorporating both Standard Model (SM) and beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) radiation, focusing on the phenomenology of a massive Z' boson. While traditional approaches typically assume direct Z' production in the hard process, the possibility of Z' production within jets, enabled by subsequent emissions in the parton shower, offers a complementary opportunity to probe new physics through jet substructure and event topology. The newly developed Herwig 7 framework supporting BSM parton showers enables efficient simulation of Z' production in the logarithmically enhanced regime. Using a simple BSM benchmark, the minimal U(1) B - L extension of the SM, the interplay between the SM and BSM showers is evaluated to identify kinematic features that distinguish Z' -induced jets from conventional signatures. BSM-radiation signatures are contrasted with SM backgrounds such as QCD, top-quark, and Drell-Yan production, identifying potential discriminants for experimental searches. Experimental sensitivity at the LHC and prospective future colliders is estimated via statistical-significance projections. We find that Z' bosons produced through parton shower radiation populate non-isolated regions inside jets, providing an avenue for new-physics searches overlooked in traditional analyses.

Sources

Related papers