Ergotropy of macroscopic classical systems
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Ergotropy of macroscopic classical systems".
Paper summary: Mira: To get into the details of "Ergotropy of macroscopic classical systems," the authors focus on providing a general expression for ergotropy that works even when the phase space density has some jumps or flat regions.
Kai: They frame this problem as a function rearrangement problem, which is what leads to this new idea of "ergotropic rearangement" as a generalization of symmetric decreasing rearrangement.
Lev: The paper shows how they use assumptions about the phase volume and the density to derive a specific form for ergotropic rearrangement, which is equation nineteen in their text.
Mira: Equation nineteen gives us this general expression for the ergotropic rearrangement, which is defined by integrating over all possible values of r of sigma minus omega zero of h zero.
Kai: This general expression then allows them to write down an explicit form for the ergotropy, which they call E-two.
Lev: They also show how this relates back to the simpler symmetric decreasing rearrangement when the Hamiltonian is spherically symmetric, like a quadratic one, where it matches rho star.
Mira: The paper then looks at the thermodynamic limit and finds that any density of the form rho equals f of H zero becomes asymptotically passive under these conditions.
Kai: And this asymptotic passivity happens even when we consider a system with an ideal gas evenly distributed on an energy shell.
Lev: That's a big statement because it implies that for very large systems, the available energy you can extract from these states really tends to zero.
Mira: So, the thesis is that the general machinery of ergotropic rearrangement leads to this conclusion about asymptotic passivity in the thermodynamic limit.
Kai: It’s a lot of theory leading to a statement about what happens when you scale up physical systems.
Lev: And they also note that they need to assume invertibility for some steps in their derivation, which means they are relying on those densities not having flat regions or jump discontinuities.
Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up the "Ergotropy of macroscopic classical systems" paper, the main thing is this connection between energy extraction and mathematical rearrangement.
Mira: They establish that any equilibrium state of the form f of H zero is asymptotically passive when we look at these thermodynamic limits.
Lev: This finding strengthens some mechanical foundations for things like the Kelvin formulation of the second law of thermodynamics and it also sets a condition on dimensionality for certain engines to work.
Kai: But they also found something interesting about what happens in that limit regarding the uniqueness of states.
Mira: They concluded that in the thermodynamic limit, the uniqueness of those ground states breaks down, and instead, there is a multiplicity of passive states emerging.
Lev: It means if you're working on error correction or state preparation for large systems, you can't just expect one single passive state to be the only one available.
Kai: It suggests that in the large N limit, an N-copy compound system typically tends to become active instead of passive.
Mira: That’s a complex picture: the theory gives us a general tool, but it tells us that when you scale up, the simple expectation of extractable energy going to zero is true.
Lev: And the caveat is that for finite systems, we still have to deal with those non-passive states before we can rely on this asymptotic behavior.
Istituto Nanoscienze-CNR · NEST Scuola Normale Superiore
cond-mat.stat-mech, physics.plasm-ph
Submitted: 2026-03-30
Updated: 2026-11-17
Comments: v2 largely revised and expanded, accepted for publication in New Journal of Physics (2026)
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 77/100
The gist: Ergotropy, or available energy, denotes the maximal amount of energy that can be extracted from a thermally isolated mechanical system by means of a cyclic time-dependent perturbation…
Key concepts
- Ergotropy (E)
- Ergotropy is defined as the maximal amount of energy that can be extracted from a thermally isolated mechanical system using cyclic, time-dependent driving forces. Mathematically, it represents the maximum extractable work achievable under these specific conditions.
- Passive State ($ ho^ullet$)
- A passive state is a mathematical concept related to the density distribution of a system. The paper suggests that certain equilibrium states are asymptotically passive, meaning they behave like a passive state when the system size becomes infinitely large, implying limited extractable energy in that limit.
- Ergotropic Rearrangement ($ ho^ullet$)
- This concept generalizes symmetric decreasing rearrangement to define how the density distribution of a system should be rearranged to maximize ergotropy. It is defined by an integral involving the probability density $ ho(x)$ and its relation to energy levels $H_0(z).
- Thermodynamic Limit Findings
- When applied to ideal gases, the general expression shows that any state $ ho = f(H_0)$ becomes passive in the thermodynamic limit. Crucially, both characteristic energies tend toward a constant value $E$, meaning the extractable ergotropy vanishes as system size grows infinitely large.
Terminology
Summary
Ergotropy, or available energy, denotes the maximal amount of energy that can be extracted from a thermally isolated mechanical system by means of a cyclic time-dependent perturbation <ref:2603. p. 0 We apply it to investigate
the fate of classical ergotropy in the thermodynamic limit, and find that any density of the form 𝜌 = 𝑓 (𝐻0) is
asymptotically passive, where 𝐻0 is the system Hamiltonian and 𝑓 a generic function. INTRODUCTION
Ergotropy, or available energy, denotes the maximal amount
of energy that can be extracted from a thermally isolated mechanical system by means of a cyclic time-dependent perturbation. available energy) of a classical system is known for the case when
the system phase space density is continuous and with no plateaus. Here we provide the general expression
of ergotropy that applies without those limitations. It easily follows upon casting the ergotropy problem as a
function rearrangement problem. This leads to the notion of “ergotropic rearangement” which generalises that
of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement” (an advanced topic of measure theory). This leads to the notion of “ergotropic rearangement” which generalises that
of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement” (an advanced topic of measure theory). We apply it to investigate
the fate of classical ergotropy in the thermodynamic limit, and find that any density of the form 𝜌 = 𝑓 (𝐻0) is
asymptotically passive, where 𝐻0 is the system Hamiltonian and 𝑓 a generic function.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Definition and Mathematical Framework
Ergotropy E is defined as the maximal amount of energy that can be extracted from a thermally isolated mechanical system by means of a cyclic time-dependent driving V(z, t) <ref:2603.28388#pg2>. In formal terms, E [rho] = max ∫ dzH0 (z) [rho(z) − ρ(phi−1 (z))] <ref:2603. p. 0 Here z = (q, p) is a point in the system phase space. In formal terms:
E [𝜌] = max
𝜑
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z) [𝜌(z) − 𝜌(𝜑
−1
(z)] (1)
where the maximisation is over all possible Hamiltonian flows
𝜑 : R
2𝑠 → R
2𝑠
(𝑠 denotes the number of degrees of freedom). We shall use the symbol 𝜌˘ for the state of minimal energy
expectation among all possible evolved states 𝜌(𝜑
−1
(z)). 𝜌˘ is
the passive companion of 𝜌 [36, 37]. [34] provides an explicit formula for E valid in the
case where 𝜌 is continuous and does not present flat plateaus,
which we review below. The derivation of Ref. [34] provides an explicit formula for E valid in the
case where 𝜌 is continuous and does not present flat plateaus,
which we review below. The derivation of Ref. [34] is based on Gardner’s principles
[25], according to which i) the passive state 𝜌˘(z) is of the form
𝑔(𝐻0 (z)) with 𝑔 a non-increasing function, ii) the measure of
the set 𝜌 > 𝑟 has to be the same as the measure of the set 𝜌 > 𝑟 ˘ ,
for all 𝑟 > 0. Introducing the function
Σ(𝑟) =
∫
𝑑z𝜃 [𝜌(z) − 𝑟] (2)
where 𝜃 is Heaviside step function, the Gardner principles can
be succintly expressed as:
Σ(𝑟) =
∫
𝑑z𝜃 [𝑔(𝐻0 (z)) − 𝑟] , (3)
arXiv:2603.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Ergotropic Rearrangement Concept
The problem of classical ergotropy is mathematically analogous to the problem of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement” discussed, e.g., in the text of Lieb and Moss [35] <ref:2603. p. 0 The problem of
classical ergotropy, is, mathematically speaking, analogous to
the problem of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement”, discussed, e. , in the text of Lieb and Moss [35]. This in turn leads to
an explicit expression of classical ergotropy, see Eq. (15) that
generalises the previous Eq. (15) that
generalises the previous Eq. (7), without restrictions on its
applicability. Let us then quickly review the theory of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement”, and then formulate its generalisation,
leading to the notion of “ergotropic rearrangement”. One begins by defining the symmetric rearrangement 𝐴
∗ of
a set 𝐴:
𝐴
∗ = {z : |z| ≤ 𝑅(𝐴)}, (8)
where 𝑅(𝐴) is the radius of the Ball that has same Lebesgue
measure 𝜇(𝐴) of the set 𝐴.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Thermodynamic Limit Findings
The application of the general expression to an ideal gas evenly distributed on an energy shell leads to the conclusion that any phase space density of the formrho = f (H0) tends to become passive as the system size increases <ref:2603.28388#pg2>. Most remarkably, in the thermodynamic limit γ → ∞ both E¯i and E¯f tend to E, thus the ergotropy vanishes in said limit <ref:2603. p. 3 Substituting in Eq. p. 3 (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (24) we have
Ω
−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) = [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾 𝐸
′
(31)
where we used the symbol 𝐸
′
to represents the energy of the
hypersurface of constant 𝐻0 that encloses the volume 𝜇(𝑆). Substituting in Eq. (28) we get
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝐸
′ − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝐶𝛾𝐸′𝛾
(32)
The system energy expectation is easily calculated as:
𝐸¯
𝑖 =
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)𝜌(z) =
𝛾
𝛾 + 1
𝐸
𝛾+1 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾+1
𝐸𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
(33)
The lowest energy expectation the system can reach is
𝐸¯
𝑓 =
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)𝜌˘(z) =
𝛾
𝛾 + 1
[𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾
(34)
The ergotropy is their difference E = 𝐸¯
𝑖 − 𝐸¯
𝑓
It is interesting to note that both 𝐸¯
𝑖 and 𝐸¯
𝑓 (therefore also
E) do not depend on the mass 𝑚, nor on the volume 𝑉 of the
box,
Most remarkably, in the thermodynamic limit 𝛾 → ∞ both
𝐸¯
𝑖 and 𝐸¯
𝑓
tend to 𝐸, thus the ergotropy vanishes in said limit. This evidences that despite the state 𝜌(z) is not a passive
state for any finite 𝑁, the energy you can extract therefrom
tends to vanish as 𝑁 increases.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion and Implications
We have established a connection between the physical problem of finding the available energy, a.k.a. ergotropy, of a classical system and the mathematical theory of rearrangement <ref:2603. p. 3 ergotropy, of a classical system and the mathematical theory of rearrangement. By
noting that the “ergotropic rearrangement” is a generalisation
of the classic concept of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement”, one easily finds an expression of the minimal energy
state 𝜌˘, valid under most general assumptions, including the
case when the system state 𝜌 presents jump discontinuities and
flat regions, thus extending the results previously obtained in
Ref. As an interesting application, we have used the “ergotorpic
rearrangement” formula to study the fate of ergotropy in the
thermodynamic limit. Our main conclusion, Eq. Our main conclusion, Eq. (35), is that
any equilibrium state of the form 𝑓 (𝐻0), is asymptotically passive. On the contrary, you should be able to do
so in low dimensional systems, as was in fact demonstrated in
various works [42–45]. This finding strengthens the mechanical foundations of Kelvin formulation of the second Law of
Thermodynamics [39, 41] while establishing that low dimensionality is a necessary condition for microcanonical Szilard
engines to work [42–45]. [41] for quantum systems. Furthermore, note that any state of the form 𝜌 = 𝑓 (𝐻0),
with 𝑓 a generic function can be approximated to any wanted
degree, by convex linear combinations of flat distributions defined over sufficiently thin energy shells. Furthermore, Eq. (35) leads to the interesting conclusion that in the thermodynamic limit, the uniqueness of the
“ground state” breaks down, while a multiplicity of passive
states emerges, a topic that deserves further investigation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The expression in Eq. (19) generalises that of Eq. p. 0 It easily follows upon casting the ergotropy problem as a
function rearrangement problem. This leads to the notion of “ergotropic rearangement” which generalises that
of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement” (an advanced topic of measure theory). By
noting that the “ergotropic rearrangement” is a generalisation
of the classic concept of “symmetric decreasing rearrangement”, one easily finds an expression of the minimal energy
state 𝜌˘, valid under most general assumptions, including the
case when the system state 𝜌 presents jump discontinuities and
flat regions, thus extending the results previously obtained in
Ref. In “ergotropic rearrangement” a phase space density 𝜌0 (z)
is rearranged in decreasing manner relative to the increase of
the Hamilton function 𝐻0 (z). , the quadratic
Hamiltonian 𝐻0 (z) = |z|
2
, 𝜌˘ coincides with 𝜌
∗
, so we see
that ergotropic rearrangement is a generalisation of symmetric
decreasing rearrangement. (19), the minimal energy can be conveniently
written as:
𝐸˘ =
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)𝜌˘(z)
=
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)
∫ ∞
0
𝑑𝑟𝜃 [Σ(𝑟) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z))]
=
∫ ∞
0
𝑑Φ 𝐸0 (Φ)
∫ ∞
0
𝑑𝑟 𝜃 [Σ(𝑟) − Φ]
=
∫ ∞
0
𝑑𝑟 ∫ Σ(𝑟 )
0
𝑑Φ 𝐸0 (Φ)
where we made the usual changes of variables z → 𝑒 =
𝐻0 (z), 𝑒 → Φ = Ω0 (𝑒) [34, 39] , with 𝑑z = Ω′
0
(𝑒)𝑑𝑒 = 𝑑Φ,
and introduced the function 𝐸0
𝐸0 Ω
−1
0
(21)
such that 𝐸0 (Φ) denotes the energy of the hypersurface of 𝐻0
that encloses the volume Φ [34, 39]. Substituting in Eq. (28) we get
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝐸
′ − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝐶𝛾𝐸′𝛾
(32)
The system energy expectation is easily calculated as:
𝐸¯
𝑖 =
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)𝜌(z) =
𝛾
𝛾 + 1
𝐸
𝛾+1 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾+1
𝐸𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
(33)
The lowest energy expectation the system can reach is
𝐸¯
𝑓 =
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)𝜌˘(z) =
𝛾
𝛾 + 1
[𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾
(34)
The ergotropy is their difference E = 𝐸¯
𝑖 − 𝐸¯
𝑓
It is interesting to note that both 𝐸¯
𝑖 and 𝐸¯
𝑓 (therefore also
E) do not depend on the mass 𝑚, nor on the volume 𝑉 of the
box,
Most remarkably, in the thermodynamic limit 𝛾 → ∞ both
𝐸¯
𝑖 and 𝐸¯
𝑓
tend to 𝐸, thus the ergotropy vanishes in said limit. Substituting in Eq. (28) we get
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝐸
′ − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝐶𝛾𝐸′𝛾
(32)
The system energy expectation is easily calculated as:
𝐸¯
𝑖 =
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)𝜌(z) =
𝛾
𝛾 + 1
𝐸
𝛾+1 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾+1
𝐸𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
(33)
The lowest energy expectation the system can reach is
𝐸¯
𝑓 =
∫
𝑑z𝐻0 (z)𝜌˘(z) =
𝛾
𝛾 + 1
[𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
]
1/𝛾
(34)
The ergotropy is their difference E = 𝐸¯
𝑖 − 𝐸¯
𝑓
It is interesting to note that both 𝐸¯
𝑖 and 𝐸¯
𝑓 (therefore also
E) do not depend on the mass 𝑚, nor on the volume 𝑉 of the
box,
Most remarkably, in the thermodynamic limit 𝛾 → ∞ both
𝐸¯
𝑖 and 𝐸¯
𝑓
tend to 𝐸, thus the ergotropy vanishes in said limit.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
How the training signal is built
The explicit expression of ergotropy, see Eq. (7) below, which, however only applies to phase-space densitiesrho that are continuous and without flat plateaus <ref:2603. p. 0 That was possible
thanks to writing an explicit expression of ergotropy, see Eq. (7) below, which, however only applies to phase-space densities 𝜌 that are continuous and without flat plateaus. The derivation of Ref. [34] proceeds from Eq. [34] proceeds from Eq. (5), by
further assuming Σ is invertible. This
will be illustrated below, in Sec. Under the above assumption, rewriting Eq. Under the above assumption, rewriting Eq. (4) as Σ =
Ω0 ◦ 𝑔
−1
, and applying Σ
−1
to the left and 𝑔 to the right, one
obtains 𝑔 = Σ−1 ◦ Ω0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the gains come from
The paper demonstrates that any state of the formrho = f (H0), with f a generic function can be approximated to any wanted degree, by convex linear combinations of flat distributions defined over sufficiently thin energy shells <ref:2603.28388#pg2>. Any time dependent perturbation maps (in the thermodynamic limit), each shell to a set of larger or same energy expectation, so that the full distribution gets mapped to a new distribution with higher or same energy <ref:2603. p. 3 Furthermore, note that any state of the form 𝜌 = 𝑓 (𝐻0),
with 𝑓 a generic function can be approximated to any wanted
degree, by convex linear combinations of flat distributions defined over sufficiently thin energy shells. Any time dependent
perturbation maps (in the thermodynamic limit), each shell
to a set of larger or same energy expectation, so that the full
distribution gets mapped to a new distribution with higher or
same energy. Any time dependent
perturbation maps (in the thermodynamic limit), each shell
to a set of larger or same energy expectation, so that the full
distribution gets mapped to a new distribution with higher or
same energy. It follows that
lim
𝑁→∞
E [ 𝑓 (𝐻0)] = 0 (35)
namely, in the thermodynamic limit, any stationary state of the
form 𝑓 (𝐻0) is asymptotically passive. 5
because, while the compound state of the 𝑁-copy system
𝜌tot(z) = 𝜌(z1)𝜌(z2) . 𝜌(z𝑁 ) is a stationary state relative to
the total Hamiltonian 𝐻tot(z) = 𝐻(z1) + 𝐻(z2) + · · · + 𝐻(z𝑁 )
it is generally not of the form 𝑓 (𝐻tot(z)). 5
because, while the compound state of the 𝑁-copy system
𝜌tot(z) = 𝜌(z1)𝜌(z2) . 𝜌(z𝑁 ) is a stationary state relative to
the total Hamiltonian 𝐻tot(z) = 𝐻(z1) + 𝐻(z2) + · · · + 𝐻(z𝑁 )
it is generally not of the form 𝑓 (𝐻tot(z)). This is known for both classical [36] and quantum systems [5]. Thus, in the large 𝑁
limit, an 𝑁-copy compound system typically tends to become active.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The explicit expression of μ(S) is Ω0 (E) − Ω0 (E − ε) = Cγ [E/γ − (E - ε)/γ] <ref:2603. p. 3 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. 4
Plugging it in Eq. (19) and recalling that by definition
Ω0 ≥ 0 we swiftly obtain
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [𝜇(𝑆) − Ω0 (𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(28)
Using that Ω−1
0
is a strictly increasing function, we obatin
𝜌˘(z) =
𝜃 [Ω−1
0
(𝜇(𝑆)) − 𝐻0 (z)]
𝜇(𝑆)
(29)
The explicit expression of 𝜇(𝑆) is
𝜇(𝑆) = Ω0 (𝐸) − Ω0 (𝐸 − 𝜀) = 𝐶𝛾 [𝐸
𝛾 − (𝐸 − 𝜀)
𝛾
] (30)
Using Eq. [34] is based on Gardner’s principles
[25], according to which i) the passive state 𝜌˘(z) is of the form
𝑔(𝐻0 (z)) with 𝑔 a non-increasing function, ii) the measure of
the set 𝜌 > 𝑟 has to be the same as the measure of the set 𝜌 > 𝑟 ˘ ,
for all 𝑟 > 0. Introducing the function
Σ(𝑟) =
∫
𝑑z𝜃 [𝜌(z) − 𝑟] (2)
where 𝜃 is Heaviside step function, the Gardner principles can
be succintly expressed as:
Σ(𝑟) =
∫
𝑑z𝜃 [𝑔(𝐻0 (z)) − 𝑟] , (3)
arXiv:2603. [34] is based on Gardner’s principles
[25], according to which i) the passive state 𝜌˘(z) is of the form
𝑔(𝐻0 (z)) with 𝑔 a non-increasing function, ii) the measure of
the set 𝜌 > 𝑟 has to be the same as the measure of the set 𝜌 > 𝑟 ˘ ,
for all 𝑟 > 0. Introducing the function
Σ(𝑟) =
∫
𝑑z𝜃 [𝜌(z) − 𝑟] (2)
where 𝜃 is Heaviside step function, the Gardner principles can
be succintly expressed as:
Σ(𝑟) =
∫
𝑑z𝜃 [𝑔(𝐻0 (z)) − 𝑟] , (3)
arXiv:2603.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can calculate maximal energy extraction from a system by analyzing its phase space density using ergotropic rearrangement, which generalizes symmetric decreasing rearrangement.
-
The improved AI can determine that any phase space density of the form rho = f (H0) is asymptotically passive in the thermodynamic limit, meaning any stationary state of this form is asymptotically passive.
-
The system can predict that for a large ergodic system where only its energy with finite accuracy is known, no energy will be extractable, which strengthens the mechanical foundations of Kelvin formulation of the second law of Thermodynamics.
-
The AI can establish that low dimensionality is a necessary condition for microcanonical Szilard engines to work by leveraging the finding that any equilibrium state of the form f (H0) is asymptotically passive in this limit.
Abstract
We address the fundamental question of what is the maximal amount of energy (a.k.a. ergotropy) that can be extracted from a macroscopic classical system by means of a cyclical variation of an external parameter. We show that if the system is prepared in a statistical state of the form ρ= F(H), with H the Hamiltonian and F a generic limited function, then the ergotropy is vanishing in the large N limit, provided the thermodynamic entropy obeys the scaling S(E) N αs (E / N β) with α,β>0 and s some strictly increasing function with certain reasonable properties. We stress that such ubiquitous condition also ensures the equivalence of the so-called "surface" and "volume" entropies. We illustrate this by introducing the notion of ``ergotropic rearrangement'' of a phase space density which we then apply to find the exact ergotropy expression of systems with constant (positive or negative) heat capacity being evenly distributed over energy shells in phase space. We discuss cases where the above mentioned equivalence does (does not) break and the ergotropy does (does not) vanish accordingly, in the large N limit. The presented results shed new light on the statistical-mechanical foundations of the second law of thermodynamics.
Sources
Related papers
- Emergent long-tail dynamics in driven magnets with dynamical frustration
- Statistical Mechanics of Dynamical System Identification
- Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems
- Chemical potentials from structure factors: II. Charged multi-component mixtures
- Genuine quantum scars in Floquet chaotic many-body systems
- Stochastic Thermodynamics for Autoregressive Generative Models: A Non-Markovian Perspective