Proxy-Reliance Control in Conformal Recalibration of One-Sided Value-at-Risk

arXiv:2603.22569 · q-fin.RM, stat.ME · Submitted 2026-03-23 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantitative Finance. The day in quantitative finance: models of markets, risk and prices.

Ruth: I'm Ruth.

Warren: And I'm Warren, here with Iris.

Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Proxy-Reliance Control in Conformal Recalibration of One-Sided Value-at-Risk".

Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. Proxy-reliance control in conformal recalibration of one-sided value-at-risk introduces a framework to explicitly study how strongly recalibration should depend on an imperfect volatility proxy.

Ruth: The empirical results suggest that proxy reliance control is most valuable for stressed-state robustness rather than uniform overall dominance.

Warren: Core Framework and Design Choice The paper formalizes a proxy-reliance parameter ρ in

the framework: to continuously interpolate between an approximately constant-shift correction and a fully proxy-scaled correction.

Ruth: This makes proxy reliance a distinct and practically interpretable design choice in one-sided VaR recalibration.

Title and authors: Ruth: So we're looking at this paper called "Proxy Reliance Control in Conformal Recalibration of One-Sided Value-at-Risk." The authors are Tenghan Zhong from the University of Southern California. It tackles a question that existing state aware methods don't usually isolate: how strongly should the recalibration adjustment depend on an imperfect volatility proxy when we're worried about tail risk.

Warren: I read the title and authors, and it sounds like they're trying to formalize a way to choose between two extremes in how much we trust that volatility forecast. It sets up this parameter called rho, which goes from zero to one.

Iris: That parameter rho is key because it lets you interpolate continuously between a correction that's almost constant and a correction that scales fully with the proxy. So, if rho is zero, you get an approximately constant shift; if it's one, you get a fully proxy scaled correction.

Ruth: Exactly. And the paper shows theoretically that this rho parameter controls two things: how sensitive the tail adjustment is to changes in the proxy scale, and also how fragile we are in stressed states when that proxy underreacting.

Warren: That means larger values of rho mean more responsiveness to those changes, but they also increase exposure to errors from the proxy itself when things get bad. That’s a trade off they explicitly model.

Iris: And Proposition four point one shows this sensitivity directly: it proves that the adjustment gets proportional to the power of rho, which is really about how much the correction scales with that proxy scale change >.

Ruth: It also shows something interesting in Proposition four point three where for any rho greater than zero, the conditional exceedance distortion is non-negative assuming a clean proxy exactness >. That’s a technical way of saying it keeps things from going completely haywire under certain conditions.

Warren: So, moving to what they actually did, empirically, the authors tested this in a rolling out-of-sample study on a panel of six ETFs using VIX linked state variables and SPY as a benchmark >. And what they found is that proxy reliance control isn't about uniform dominance across everything >.

Title and authors: Iris: That’s important because it suggests we shouldn't just want the one setting that performs best every single time, but rather something more targeted based on the market state >. They found it's most valuable for stressed-state robustness instead of broad unconditional dominance >.

Ruth: So, even though it doesn't beat every other raw proxy aware benchmark in terms of tick loss or capital usage, it really shines when the baseline forecast is already weak and the volatility proxy underreacting in adverse states >.

Warren: Specifically, they found that lower or intermediate proxy reliance can actually outperform a fully proxy scaled recalibration when there's still residual stress period undercoverage after the baseline forecast forms >. That’s a practical finding for anyone managing capital during a crisis.

Iris: It highlights that the choice of rho isn't just about getting the lowest number on one chart, but about where you draw your line between trusting the model and hedging against proxy misspecification >.

Ruth: And they take this further by suggesting a regime aware extension, looking at separate proxy reliance levels for low, medium, and high stress states based on VIX distribution partitions >. This is an improvement because it tailors the reliance dynamically rather than using one global setting for everyone >.

Warren: That sounds like a way to manage the cost of that strategy; you can choose your reliance level based on how stressed you think things are in that specific period, balancing stress period pinball loss and capital usage >. It's about feasibility tolerances.

Iris: And they allow for dynamic selection, either a global average selector or a global stress aware selector, which lets you trade off those costs based on what your operational constraints are >. That gives risk managers more control over the execution of the strategy itself >.

Title and authors: Ruth: So, we're looking at how this paper on Proxy Reliance Control in Conformal Recalibration of One-Sided Value-at-Risk suggests we can make a more nuanced decision about proxy reliance by controlling it with that rho parameter from zero to one >. It’s a distinct design choice for one-sided VaR recalibration.

Warren: I think the big picture here is that volatility signals are informative but they aren't ground truth, and the decision margin isn't just average performance, but rather stressed-state fragility >. The regime dependent extension is more useful as a structural diagnostic than a uniformly superior forecasting rule >.

Iris: I agree that it’s a diagnostic tool; it helps us understand how sensitive the model is to proxy errors under stress, which is valuable for building better risk models overall >. It confirms that the focus should be on where downside protection matters most when we look at this paper Proxy Reliance Control in Conformal Recalibration of One-Sided Value-at-Risk >.

Ruth: So, to wrap up, the core idea from this paper is that proxy reliance isn't a one size fits all thing; it’s a distinct design choice you make with rho to manage the trade off between responsiveness and error exposure >. We see empirical results showing that for stressed-state robustness, lower or intermediate proxy reliance can be better than fully scaled recalibration when the proxy underreacting in adverse states >.

Warren: It puts a lot on the practitioner to think about what they are actually trying to protect—is it uniform coverage, or specifically protection during a crisis when volatility signals are unreliable >?

Iris: Exactly. And while the study is restricted, focusing on six ETFs and VIX linked variables, the framework itself gives us a solid tool for analyzing this dependency >. It’s about how much you want to depend on that imperfect proxy in that specific context >.

Ruth: We're going to leave it there for now. This paper Proxy Reliance Control in Conformal Recalibration of One-Sided Value-at-Risk gives us a concrete way to think about when and how much we should lean on our volatility forecasts >. We'll be back after the break with some other work on financial risk measurement.

The paper's summary: Ruth: So, this paper is about how we build that Value at Risk measure when we don't have perfect volatility data, and it introduces a new tool called proxy reliance control to manage that uncertainty >

Warren: Right, it formalizes this parameter rho from zero to one. It lets you choose between two things: either an almost constant adjustment or a full scaling based on the proxy data >

Iris: And the theoretical part of it shows that this rho parameter controls how much sensitivity we have to changes in the proxy scale, and also how fragile our system is when those stresses happen with the proxy underreacting >

Ruth: Exactly. So, what this means practically is that you're not just picking one setting for your recalibration; you're choosing a level of trust in that imperfect volatility forecast based on the stress situation >

Warren: That’s where I see the value. It says the most useful part of this control isn't about getting a perfectly uniform result across every single market condition >

Iris: No, it points toward stressed-state robustness. The empirical results show that this control is most valuable when you're trying to protect capital specifically during adverse states rather than just beating the average performance benchmark >

Ruth: So, even if your recalibration isn't the absolute best every single time in terms of raw losses, it performs better when you have residual stress period undercoverage and that volatility proxy is underreacting >

Warren: That means lower or intermediate reliance settings can actually outperform a fully scaled one when you look at left-tail control during a crisis >

Iris: It shows that the regime where this strategy helps is where downside protection matters most, which we can see by analyzing both the unconditional exceedance frequency and the strict stress exceedance frequency >

Ruth: The authors suggest this isn't just one setting to use forever; it’s a structural diagnostic tool to understand how sensitive your model is to proxy errors under different market stresses >

Warren: And they’re looking ahead by suggesting a regime aware extension where you can pick different reliance levels for low, medium, and high stress states based on things like the VIX distribution partitions >

Iris: That dynamic selection is interesting because it lets you manage the trade-off between stress period pinball loss and capital usage based on your own feasibility tolerances >

Ruth: It moves us away from just looking at one single performance number and toward a more nuanced decision about how much we let an imperfect proxy dictate our risk adjustment >

Warren: So, if you're running a strategy that relies heavily on volatility inputs, this paper gives you the machinery to explicitly control that dependency to focus your protection where it actually counts >

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, this part of the discussion is about how the authors suggest making this proxy reliance control framework even better than what they initially proposed >

Ruth: They're talking about adding a regime aware extension to it. Instead of one single setting for rho, you can pick different levels for low, medium, and high stress states >

Warren: That means you tailor the reliance level based on how stressed the market is right now using VIX distribution partitions >

Iris: I think that’s smart because it lets you manage those costs better. You can choose your reliance setting to balance stress period pinball loss and capital usage based on what your operational tolerances are >

Ruth: It shifts the focus from a one-size-fits-all rule to something that reacts specifically to the current market climate >

Warren: And they allow you to do this selection dynamically, using either a global average selector or a global stress aware selector based on those tolerances >

Iris: That’s an improvement because it gives risk managers more control over how they execute this strategy based on what they know about their own operational constraints >

Ruth: So, the implication here is that the framework isn't just a static model; it can be used as a dynamic tool to adjust its reliance level based on real-time stress conditions >

Warren: It’s less of a fixed rule and more of an adaptive process where you trade off different costs depending on whether you're in a calm or chaotic market >

Iris: It solidifies the idea that this approach is best used as a structural diagnostic tool to see how sensitive the model is across different states, not just as a universal forecasting rule >

Ruth: The authors flag that their study itself has limitations. It’s based on just six liquid daily ETFs and one specific VIX-linked state proxy >

Warren: And they also used a deliberately coarse three-bin partition for those stress states, which might limit how finely you can tune the regime awareness >

Iris: They say that future work should involve richer state variables and testing this framework on other risk measures like expected shortfall instead of just value at risk >

Ruth: So, while the tool is solid for understanding proxy reliance, the authors point out it’s still a specific application and needs more flexibility to be widely used across different asset classes or risk types >

Warren: It's a focused answer to a narrow question about how much we should trust that volatility forecast when stress period protection is the main priority >

Conclusion: Tom: So we've covered how this paper, "Proxy Reliance Control in Conformal Recalibration of One-Sided Value at Risk," uses that rho parameter to manage the trade-off between responsiveness and proxy error >

Ruth: Right, it boils down to explicitly modeling how much you want your risk adjustment to depend on that imperfect volatility forecast >

Warren: And the main thing we saw is that for stressed state robustness, a lower or intermediate reliance setting can actually outperform a fully scaled one when things are bad >

Iris: I think what this means for us is that the decision isn't just about finding the single best setting; it’s about picking the right level of trust based on where you are in the market >

Ruth: Exactly. The authors suggest this framework is most useful as a structural diagnostic to see how sensitive your model is under stress, not necessarily as a single forecasting rule >

Warren: And they're looking ahead by suggesting regime aware extensions, letting you pick different reliance levels for low, medium, and high stress states based on things like the VIX distribution partitions >

Iris: That dynamic selection is smart because it lets you manage the trade-off between stress period pinball loss and capital usage based on your own operational tolerances >

Ruth: It moves us away from just looking at one single performance number and toward a more nuanced decision about how much we let an imperfect proxy dictate our risk adjustment >

Warren: So, if you're running a strategy that relies heavily on volatility inputs, this paper gives you the machinery to explicitly control that dependency to focus your protection where it actually counts >

Iris: And just remember they flag the limitations: their study is restricted to six liquid ETFs and one specific VIX-linked state proxy >

Ruth: That’s true. The method doesn't cover everything, so we have to keep an eye on those caveats when thinking about applying this framework broadly >

Warren: It’s a focused answer to a narrow question about how much we should trust that volatility forecast when stress period protection is the main priority >

University of Southern California

q-fin.RM, stat.ME

Submitted: 2026-03-23

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: Withdrawn by the author due to a fundamental gap in the theoretical analysis that cannot be resolved within the current framework, and insufficient novelty relative to prior work

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Proxy-reliance control in conformal recalibration of one-sided value-at-risk introduces a framework to explicitly study how strongly recalibration should depend on an imperfect volatility proxy.

Key concepts

Proxy Reliance Parameter ($\rho$)
This parameter, ranging from 0 to 1, controls the trade-off between two recalibration methods. A value of $\rho=0$ results in an approximately constant correction, while $\rho=1$ means the adjustment is fully scaled by the volatility proxy. Intermediate values offer a continuous compromise between responsiveness and protection against proxy errors.
Stressed-State Robustness
The study found that controlling proxy reliance is most beneficial for protecting against risk during periods of high stress. This means prioritizing capital preservation when the baseline forecast is already weak or when the volatility proxy underreacting in adverse market conditions.
One-Sided VaR Recalibration
This refers to a method used to adjust Value-at-Risk (VaR) estimates based on one side of the distribution, typically focusing on left-tail risk. The paper explores how this adjustment should depend on an imperfect volatility proxy.
Conditional Exceedance Distortion ($\Delta t(\rho)$)
This measure quantifies the distortion in exceedance frequency when using a specific level of proxy reliance ($\rho$). For $\rho > 0$, the theoretical results show this distortion is non-negative under ideal conditions, suggesting that some level of proxy reliance provides a predictable benefit to risk control.

Terminology

Summary

Proxy-reliance control in conformal recalibration of one-sided value-at-risk introduces a framework to explicitly study how strongly recalibration should depend on an imperfect volatility proxy. p. 0 The empirical results suggest that proxy reliance control is most valuable for stressed-state robustness rather than uniform overall dominance. p. 0

Core Framework and Design Choice

The paper formalizes a proxy-reliance parameter ρ in [the framework] to continuously interpolate between an approximately constant-shift correction and a fully proxy-scaled correction. This makes proxy reliance a distinct and practically interpretable design choice in one-sided VaR recalibration. p. 0 The framework introduces ρ ∈ [0, 1] through the scaling rule v rho t so that ρ = 0 corresponds to an approximately constant correction, ρ = 1 corresponds to a fully proxy-scaled correction, and intermediate values provide a continuous compromise between state responsiveness and protection from proxy misspecification. p. 1

Theoretical Properties of Proxy Reliance

The theoretical results characterize the role of ρ by showing that it governs both the sensitivity of the adjustment to proxy scale and stressed-state fragility under stress-specific proxy underreaction. Specifically, Proposition 4.1 shows that A rho (eta v; c) = eta rho A rho (v; c), which proves the homogeneity statement regarding sensitivity to proportional changes in proxy scale. p. 2 Furthermore, Proposition 4.3 demonstrates that for ρ > 0, the conditional exceedance distortion Δt(ρ) is non-negative under the assumption of clean-proxy exactness. p. 9

Empirical Findings on Performance

The empirical evidence indicates that proxy reliance control is most valuable for stressed-state robustness rather than broad unconditional dominance. The panel results show that recalibration repairs weak baselines, but does not uniformly dominate the strongest raw proxy-aware benchmarks in tick loss or capital usage. In particular, when residual stress-period undercoverage remains after the baseline forecast is formed and the volatility proxy underreacts in adverse states, lower or intermediate proxy reliance can outperform fully proxy-scaled recalibration in left-tail control. p. 2

Implications for Risk Management

The results identify proxy reliance as a distinct design choice in one-sided VaR recalibration. Volatility signals are informative but not ground truth, and the decisive margin is stressed-state fragility rather than average performance. p. 1 The regime-dependent extension is most useful as a structural diagnostic rather than as a uniformly superior forecasting rule. p. 4 The paper concludes that proxy reliance should itself be treated as a separate and explicit design choice in one-sided VaR recalibration. p. 1

Limitations and Future Directions

Several limitations remain, including the empirical study being restricted to six liquid daily U.S.-traded ETFs and a common VIX-linked state proxy. p. 5 The regime-aware specification uses a deliberately coarse three-bin partition with a monotone restriction on (rho low, rho mid, rho high). p. 8 Natural extensions include richer state variables and alternative proxies and applications to other one-sided risk functionals such as expected shortfall. p. 1 The paper contributes a focused answer to a narrower but important question: how strongly a one-sided recalibration adjustment should depend on an imperfect volatility proxy when stress-period protection is the priority. p. 0

References

Viral V. Acharya, Lasse H. p. 4 Pedersen, Thomas Philippon, and Matthew Richardson. Measuring systemic risk. p. 0 Tobias Adrian and Markus K. p. 4 Brunnermeier. p. 4 CoVaR. Agnideep Aich, Ashit Baran Aich, and Dipak C. p. 4 Jain. Temporal conformal prediction (TCP): A distribution-free statistical and machine learning framework for adaptive risk forecasting. p. 3 Torben G. Andersen and Tim Bollerslev. p. 2 p. 4 Answering the skeptics: yes, standard volatility models do provide accurate forecasts. p. 2 Torben G. Andersen, Tim Bollerslev, Francis X. p. 4 Diebold, and Paul Labys. Modeling and forecasting realized volatility. p. 6 Andrew Ang and Geert Bekaert. p. 4 International asset allocation with regime shifts. p. 3 Anastasios N. Angelopoulos and Stephen Bates. p. 3 Conformal prediction: A gentle introduction. p. 3 David Ardia, Keven Bluteau, Kris Boudt, and Leopoldo Catania. p. 4 Forecasting risk with markovswitching GARCH models: A large-scale performance study. p. 6 Yunfei Bai and Charlie X. p. 3 Cai. Predicting VIX with adaptive machine learning. p. 3 Giovanni Barone-Adesi, Kostas Giannopoulos, and Les Vosper. p. 2 VaR without correlations for portfolios of derivative securities. p. 8 Osbert Bastani, Varun Gupta, Christopher Jung, Georgy Noarov, Ramya Ramalingam, and Aaron Roth. p. 3 Practical adversarial multivalid conformal prediction. p. 3 Tim Bollerslev. Generalized autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity. p. 3 Victor Chernozhukov, Kaspar W¨uthrich, and Yinchu Zhu. p. 3 Exact and robust conformal inference methods for predictive machine learning with dependent data. p. 3 Peter F. Christoffersen. p. 3 p. 3 Evaluating interval forecasts. p. 4 Peter F. Christoffersen. Elements of financial risk management. p. 1 Robert F. Engle and Simone Manganelli. p. 3 CAViaR: Conditional autoregressive value at risk by regression quantiles. p. 3 Dean Fantazzini. p. 4 Adaptive conformal inference for computing market risk measures: An analysis with four thousand crypto-assets. p. 4 Mark B. Garman and Michael J. p. 3 Klass. On the estimation of security price volatilities from historical data. p. 6 Isaac Gibbs and Emmanuel J. p. 3 Candes. Adaptive conformal inference under distribution shift. p. 4 Paul Glasserman, Chulmin Kang, and Wanmo Kang. p. 4 Stress scenario selection by empirical likelihood. p. 2 James D. Hamilton. A new approach to the economic analysis of nonstationary time series and the business cycle. p. 4 John Hull and Alan White. p. 2 Incorporating volatility updating into the historical simulation method for value-at-risk. p. 2 Masahiro Kato. p. 4 Conformal predictive portfolio selection. p. 4 Roger Koenker. p. 3 Quantile regression, volume 38 of Econometric Society Monographs. p. 3 Paul H. Kupiec. Techniques for verifying the accuracy of risk measurement models. p. 1 Fernando Moreno-Pino and Stefan Zohren. p. 3 DeepVol: volatility forecasting from high-frequency data with dilated causal convolutions. p. 3 Michael Parkinson. p. 3 The extreme value method for estimating the variance of the rate of return. p. 9 Ser-Huang Poon and Clive W. p. 4 J. Granger. Forecasting volatility in financial markets: A review. p. 2 Marc Schmitt. p. 4 Taming tail risk in financial markets: conformal risk control for nonstationary portfolio VaR. p. 4 Giuseppe Storti and Chao Wang. p. 3 A semi-parametric dynamic conditional correlation framework for risk forecasting. p. 2 Vladimir Vovk, Alexander Gammerman, and Glenn Shafer. p. 3 Algorithmic learning in a random world. p. 3 Du-Yi Wang, Guo Liang, Kun Zhang, and Qianwen Zhu. p. 3 Reliable real-time value at risk estimation via quantile regression forest with conformal calibration. p. 4 Robert E. Whaley. Understanding the VIX. p. 0 Chen Xu, Hanyang Jiang, and Yao Xie. Conformal prediction for multi-dimensional time series by ellipsoidal sets. p. 4 Jingyan Zhang, Cong Ma, and Wim Schoutens. p. 3 Forward-looking physical tail risk: a deep learning approach. p. 3

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Proxy reliance control in one-sided Value-at-Risk recalibration allows AI systems to explicitly model how strongly a tail adjustment depends on an imperfect volatility proxy through a parameter rho from 0 to 1. This enables the system to choose between an approximately constant correction (rho=0) and a fully proxy scaled correction (rho=1).

  2. The improved system can identify when proxy reliance control is most valuable by focusing on stressed-state robustness rather than uniform overall dominance, allowing it to prioritize capital protection when the baseline forecast remains exposed to proxy imperfection in adverse states.

  3. The regime-aware extension allows the AI system to select a specific proxy reliance level for low, medium, and high stress states based on VIX distribution partitions, leading to a more nuanced risk control strategy that weakens proxy dependence in more stressed states as suggested by the structure rho low greater than rho mid greater than rho high.

  4. The system can dynamically select the optimal proxy reliance level using either a global average selector or a global stress-aware selector, which trades off stress-period pinball loss and capital usage based on pre-defined feasibility tolerances.

  5. The framework enables the AI to perform stress period analysis by reporting both unconditional exceedance frequency and strict-stress exceedance frequency, allowing for targeted assessment of performance specifically during periods when downside protection matters most.

Sources

Related papers