Nucleating an Inflationary Universe: Euclidean Wormholes and their No-Boundary Limit
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Nucleating an Inflationary Universe".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Nucleating an Inflationary Universe: Euclidean Wormholes and their No-Boundary Limit investigates how Euclidean wormholes and no-boundary instantons provide initial conditions favorable to an inflationary phase in quantum gravity, which is crucial for understanding the start of the universe.
Kai: The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: No-boundary instantons dominate the probability distribution overall Common Family of Euclidean Solutions The study finds that wormholes and no-boundary instantons are part of a common family of Euclidean solutions, as the throat of the wormholes pinches off in the zero-charge limit, leaving a no-boundary instanton disconnected from the asymptotic Anti-de Sitter region Along this path, they resolve the long-known puzzle that wineglass wormholes can become negative Furthermore, small-charge wormholes lead to a longer inflationary phase than large-charge solutions, while no-boundary instantons dominate the probability distribution overall Quantum Gravity Scenarios Quantum gravity currently offers two main settings for studying the creation of an expanding universe: the no-boundary proposal, which describes space and time from nothing
1: , and a tunneling event from an assumed Anti-de Sitter ground state
2, 3: In both scenarios, the start of expansion is caused by quantum events mediated by finite action (instanton) solutions The no-boundary instanton prototype corresponds to half of a 4-sphere Wormhole Dynamics and Inflationary Preference The proposal for up-tunneling from a Euclidean Anti-de Sitter (EAdS) spacetime is achieved via (half-)wormholes that interpolate between EAdS field values and an analogous inflationary starting point To obtain an expanding universe after analytic continuation to Lorentzian time, one requires a wormhole of “wineglass” type
5: Wineglass wormholes with asymptotically flat boundary conditions and supported by an axion field were studied numerically in
7: The main reason for the proposal of wormholes was the argument that they would have a higher weighting when interpolating to higher locations on the potential, thus giving preference to a longer inflationary phase Key Results and Conclusions The results show that wineglass wormholes obtain a higher weighting when interpolating to higher locations on the potential, but the weighting of no-boundary solutions is even higher (our results thus only partially support the conjectures made in
8: ) The overall probability for nucleating an expanding, inflationary universe is dominated by no-boundary instantons In the zero-charge limit, all wineglass wormholes tend to the no-boundary instanton sitting at a local maximum of the potential This indicates that the EAdS vacuum is non-perturbatively unstable Furthermore, the Euclidean action of wineglass wormholes can be negative, as was already noticed long ago by Shvedov
23: Stability and Future Directions A rigorous stability analysis for the wineglass wormholes is still required due to the persistence of the so-called ’negative mode’ problem
21: The paper suggests that it may be of interest to look for (complex?) wormholes related to the more general no-boundary instantons as a promising avenue for further extending our understanding The authors also note that if one were to stick to purely Euclidean solutions, only the no-boundary instanton at the top of the potential would be allowed and the puzzle would disappear Supplementary Material The first equation relates the “superpotential” W to the scalar potential V (ϕ) The second equation describes how the scalar field evolves in relation to the scale factor For a local AdS maximum, the dangerous mode is the one that scales with ∆− The procedure for solving (S2) is straightforward: one simply expands Φ = Pn k=0 fk k!
Mira: ϕ k and solves (S2) order by order The optimized boundary values for the wormhole solutions with unit charge are listed at the end of the paper Page 7 --- The size at the origin is fairly independent of the charge, and is given by the Hubble radius p −3/V (ϕmax) at the potential maximum By contrast, the throat size depends crucially on the charge At smaller charge values, the throat shrinks and reaches zero size in the limit of zero charge Thus at zero charge, we are left with a Euclidean dS solution, with the scalar sitting at the potential maximum and the scale factor interpolating between the Hubble radius and zero size – in other words, we are left with a disconnected no-boundary instanton!
Kai: The figure shows that small-charge instantons, interpolating to higher locations in the potential, come out as preferred The weighting of all wineglass wormhole solutions tend to the same value in the zero-charge limit, and this limit can be identified as the weighting of a no-boundary instanton sitting at a local maximum of the potential This is our key result: wineglass wormholes and no-boundary instantons are part of a common family of Euclidean solutions The action for the EAdS background being subtracted off again, −∆SE(Q = 0) = −S no-bdy E Page 6 --- The figure shows that the weighting of solutions, which is given by −∆SE = -(S ren E − SEAdS) The figure shows the same trend that was already discovered for wineglass wormholes with flat asymptotics
7: It is of interest to look at the evolution of the scale factor in more detail The size at the origin is fairly independent of the charge, and is given by the Hubble radius p −3/V (ϕmax) at the potential maximum By contrast, the throat size depends crucially on the charge At smaller charge values, the throat shrinks and reaches zero size in the limit of zero charge Thus at zero charge, we are left with a Euclidean dS solution, with the scalar sitting at the potential maximum and the scale factor interpolating between the Hubble radius and zero size – in other words, we are left with a disconnected no-boundary instanton!
Paper summary: Kai: We’ve covered how the paper "Nucleating an Inflationary Universe: Euclidean Wormholes and their No-Boundary Limit" connects wormholes and no-boundary instantons as a common family of solutions <ref:2603.11003#pg4>. The paper investigates how these configurations provide initial conditions for an inflationary phase in quantum gravity, which is vital for understanding the start of the universe.
Mira: And the main conclusion we pull from this work is that no-boundary instantons dominate the probability distribution overall <ref:2603.11003#pg4>. This means when we look at all these ways to start an expanding universe, the instanton scenario has a higher weighting than most other solutions.
Lev: From my perspective on running this on hardware, it suggests that if we are looking for a starting point, focusing on solutions that interpolate toward higher locations on the potential is where the action should be <ref:2603.11003#pg4>. That’s where the preferred small-charge instantons come from.
Kai: So, to summarize what this paper does: it shows that wormholes and no-boundary instantons are connected in a Euclidean sense, and the no-boundary instanton is the more probable way to nucleate an inflationary universe <ref:2603.11003#pg4>. This gives us a clearer picture of the initial conditions we might need to model.
Mira: It moves us toward understanding that specific quantum gravity scenarios are more likely than others when we consider the action and probability, which is something we need to keep in mind as we build our models <ref:2603.11003#pg4>.
Lev: And for future work, the authors hint that exploring complex wormholes related to these no-boundary instantons might be a promising avenue for further research <ref:2603.11003#pg4>. That points us toward the next set of questions in this area.
Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper "Nucleating an Inflationary Universe: Euclidean Wormholes and their No-Boundary Limit" is really looking at how these wormholes and instantons can set up the very beginning of our universe in quantum gravity.
Mira: It connects two different ideas—Euclidean wormholes and no-boundary instantons—and shows that they belong to the same family of solutions. That's a neat connection because it suggests they aren't totally separate concepts.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means we might be looking at a unified way to describe the transition into inflation, which is exactly what we need for our error correction models.
Kai: The authors point out that no-boundary instantons end up dominating the probability distribution overall when you're trying to nucleate this expanding universe. That’s a pretty strong statement about which initial conditions are favored by quantum mechanics in this setting.
Mira: I think that implies that the simple, non-perturbative starting point—the instanton—is more likely than other possibilities we might consider. It pushes us toward focusing our theoretical work there first.
Lev: But we still have to figure out how to actually simulate those things on real hardware, because if the action calculation is too complicated, we can't get the fidelity needed for a proof. That’s where my world comes in.
Kai: Right, so it's about the probability favoring instantons and wormholes being related solutions, but we still need to figure out how to measure that transition happening.
Mira: Exactly. This work sets up a framework, but the next step is figuring out the actual dynamics of that phase once it starts. That's where things get interesting for cosmology.
Lev: And that's where we look at those wineglass wormholes and how they connect to our real-world models of spacetime expansion.
George Lavrelashvili, *, Jean-Luc Lehners, *
Department of Theoretical Physics, A.Razmadze Mathematical Institute at I.Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University · Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute)
hep-th, gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-03-11
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: 9 pages, v2: typo fixed and equation added, v3: replaced with published version
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 86/100
The gist: Nucleating an Inflationary Universe: Euclidean Wormholes and their No-Boundary Limit investigates how Euclidean wormholes and no-boundary instantons provide initial conditions favorable to an…
Key concepts
- Euclidean Wormholes
- These are specific solutions in Euclidean spacetime used to model transitions between different gravitational states. The paper explores how these wormholes can connect regions and influence the dynamics of quantum gravity scenarios, particularly those leading to inflation.
- No-Boundary Instantons
- These are a type of quantum event solution in quantum gravity that describes the start of space and time from nothing. The research indicates that these instantons have the highest probability weighting for nucleating an inflationary phase in the universe.
- Wineglass Wormholes
- These are a specific type of wormhole studied, characterized by their ability to interpolate between different field values. The paper finds that these solutions have a higher weighting when interpolating toward higher locations on the potential, but still fall under the dominance of no-boundary instantons.
- Inflationary Phase
- This refers to a period of rapid exponential expansion in the early universe. The paper examines how Euclidean wormholes and instantons provide favorable initial conditions that allow for this inflationary phase to begin in quantum gravity models.
Terminology
Summary
Nucleating an Inflationary Universe: Euclidean Wormholes and their No-Boundary Limit investigates how Euclidean wormholes and no-boundary instantons provide initial conditions favorable to an inflationary phase in quantum gravity, which is crucial for understanding the start of the universe. p. 0 The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: No-boundary instantons dominate the probability distribution overall
Common Family of Euclidean Solutions
The study finds that wormholes and no-boundary instantons are part of a common family of Euclidean solutions, as the throat of the wormholes pinches off in the zero-charge limit, leaving a no-boundary instanton disconnected from the asymptotic Anti-de Sitter region Along this path, they resolve the long-known puzzle that wineglass wormholes can become negative Furthermore, small-charge wormholes lead to a longer inflationary phase than large-charge solutions, while no-boundary instantons dominate the probability distribution overall
Quantum Gravity Scenarios
Quantum gravity currently offers two main settings for studying the creation of an expanding universe: the no-boundary proposal, which describes space and time from nothing [1], and a tunneling event from an assumed Anti-de Sitter ground state [2, 3] In both scenarios, the start of expansion is caused by quantum events mediated by finite action (instanton) solutions The no-boundary instanton prototype corresponds to half of a 4-sphere
Wormhole Dynamics and Inflationary Preference
The proposal for up-tunneling from a Euclidean Anti-de Sitter (EAdS) spacetime is achieved via (half-)wormholes that interpolate between EAdS field values and an analogous inflationary starting point To obtain an expanding universe after analytic continuation to Lorentzian time, one requires a wormhole of “wineglass” type [5] Wineglass wormholes with asymptotically flat boundary conditions and supported by an axion field were studied numerically in [7] The main reason for the proposal of wormholes was the argument that they would have a higher weighting when interpolating to higher locations on the potential, thus giving preference to a longer inflationary phase
Key Results and Conclusions
The results show that wineglass wormholes obtain a higher weighting when interpolating to higher locations on the potential, but the weighting of no-boundary solutions is even higher (our results thus only partially support the conjectures made in [8]) The overall probability for nucleating an expanding, inflationary universe is dominated by no-boundary instantons In the zero-charge limit, all wineglass wormholes tend to the no-boundary instanton sitting at a local maximum of the potential This indicates that the EAdS vacuum is non-perturbatively unstable Furthermore, the Euclidean action of wineglass wormholes can be negative, as was already noticed long ago by Shvedov [23]
Stability and Future Directions
A rigorous stability analysis for the wineglass wormholes is still required due to the persistence of the so-called ’negative mode’ problem [21] The paper suggests that it may be of interest to look for (complex?) wormholes related to the more general no-boundary instantons as a promising avenue for further extending our understanding The authors also note that if one were to stick to purely Euclidean solutions, only the no-boundary instanton at the top of the potential would be allowed and the puzzle would disappear
Supplementary Material
The first equation relates the “superpotential” W to the scalar potential V (ϕ) The second equation describes how the scalar field evolves in relation to the scale factor For a local AdS maximum, the dangerous mode is the one that scales with ∆− The procedure for solving (S2) is straightforward: one simply expands Φ = Pn k=0 fk k! ϕ k and solves (S2) order by order The optimized boundary values for the wormhole solutions with unit charge are listed at the end of the paper
--- Page 7 ---
The size at the origin is fairly independent of the charge, and is given by the Hubble radius p −3/V (ϕmax) at the potential maximum By contrast, the throat size depends crucially on the charge At smaller charge values, the throat shrinks and reaches zero size in the limit of zero charge Thus at zero charge, we are left with a Euclidean dS solution, with the scalar sitting at the potential maximum and the scale factor interpolating between the Hubble radius and zero size – in other words, we are left with a disconnected no-boundary instanton! The figure shows that small-charge instantons, interpolating to higher locations in the potential, come out as preferred The weighting of all wineglass wormhole solutions tend to the same value in the zero-charge limit, and this limit can be identified as the weighting of a no-boundary instanton sitting at a local maximum of the potential This is our key result: wineglass wormholes and no-boundary instantons are part of a common family of Euclidean solutions The action for the EAdS background being subtracted off again, −∆SE(Q = 0) = −S no-bdy E
--- Page 6 ---
The figure shows that the weighting of solutions, which is given by −∆SE = -(S ren E − SEAdS) The figure shows the same trend that was already discovered for wineglass wormholes with flat asymptotics [7] It is of interest to look at the evolution of the scale factor in more detail The size at the origin is fairly independent of the charge, and is given by the Hubble radius p −3/V (ϕmax) at the potential maximum By contrast, the throat size depends crucially on the charge At smaller charge values, the throat shrinks and reaches zero size in the limit of zero charge Thus at zero charge, we are left with a Euclidean dS solution, with the scalar sitting at the potential maximum and the scale factor interpolating between the Hubble radius and zero size – in other words, we are left with a disconnected no-boundary instanton! The figure shows that small-charge instantons, interpolating to higher locations in the potential, come out as preferred The weighting of all wineglass wormhole solutions tend to the same value in the zero-charge limit, and this limit can be identified as the weighting of a no-boundary instanton sitting at a local maximum of the potential This is our key result: wineglass wormholes and no-boundary instantons are part of a common family of Euclidean solutions The action for the EAdS background being subtracted off again, −∆SE(Q = 0) = −S no-bdy E
--- Page 5 ---
The figure shows the weighting of solutions, which is given by −∆SE = -(S ren E − SEAdS) The figure shows the same trend that was already discovered for wineglass wormholes with flat asymptotics [7] It is of interest to look at the evolution of the scale factor in more detail The size at the origin is fairly independent of the charge, and is given by the Hubble radius p −3/V (ϕmax) at the potential maximum By contrast, the throat size depends crucially on the charge At smaller charge values, the throat shrinks and reaches zero size in the limit of zero charge Thus at zero charge, we are left with a Euclidean dS solution, with the scalar sitting at the potential maximum and the scale factor interpolating between the Hubble radius and zero size – in other words, we are left with a disconnected no-boundary instanton! The figure shows that small-charge instantons, interpolating to higher locations in the potential, come out as preferred The weighting of all wineglass wormhole solutions tend to the same value in the zero-charge limit, and this limit can be identified as the weighting of a no-boundary instanton sitting at a local maximum of the potential This is our key result: wineglass wormholes and no-boundary instantons are part of a common family of Euclidean solutions The action for the EAdS background being subtracted off again, −∆SE(Q = 0) = −S no-bdy E
--- Page 4 ---
The size at the origin is fairly independent of the charge, and is given by the Hubble radius p −3/V (ϕmax) at the potential maximum By contrast, the throat size depends crucially on the charge At smaller charge values, the throat shrinks and reaches zero size in the limit of zero charge Thus at zero charge, we are left with a Euclidean dS solution, with the scalar sitting at the potential maximum and the scale factor interpolating between the Hubble radius and zero size – in other words, we are left with a disconnected no-boundary instanton! The figure shows that small-charge instantons, interpolating to higher locations in the potential, come out as preferred The weighting of all wineglass wormhole solutions tend to the same value in the zero-charge limit, and this limit can be identified as the weighting of a no-boundary instanton sitting at a local maximum of the potential This is our key result: wineglass wormholes and no-boundary instantons are part of a common family of Euclidean solutions The action for the EAdS background being subtracted off again, −∆SE(Q = 0) = −S no-bdy E
--- Page 4 ---
The size at the origin is fairly independent of the charge, and is given by the Hubble radius p −3/V (ϕmax) at the potential maximum By contrast, the throat size depends crucially on the charge At smaller charge values, the throat shrinks and reaches zero size in the limit of zero charge Thus at zero charge, we are left with a Euclidean dS solution, with the scalar sitting at the potential maximum and the scale factor interpolating between the Hubble radius and zero size – in other words, we are left with a disconnected no-boundary instanton!
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved Inflationary Initial Condition Modeling: The AI system can now generate physically motivated initial conditions for an inflationary universe by calculating preferred Euclidean solutions, specifically favoring those that
interpolate to higher locations on the potential
as indicated by Fig 6. -
Enhanced Probability Weighting Assessment: The system can quantify the relative probability of different starting geometries by calculating the renormalized weighting -DeltaSE, allowing it to determine which configurations, such as
small-charge instantons, interpolating to higher locations in the potential,
are preferred over others likeno-boundary instantons.
-
Negative Action Detection and Interpretation: The AI can detect Euclidean actions that are negative and interpret this negativity not as a failure but as a geometric feature where
their geometry resembles the no-boundary geometry more and more when the charge is reduced.
-
Critical Charge Limit Prediction: The system can predict topological changes in wormhole solutions by determining the zero-charge limit, concluding that
at zero charge, the throat pinches off and the topology of the solution changes,
leading to adisconnected no-boundary instanton!
-
Stability Analysis Guidance: The AI can identify potential instabilities in existing models by flagging modes that are
completely unstable
or those where counter terms cannot eliminate them, guiding researchers toward necessary initial condition adjustments to ensure modes like the AdS minimum's negative mode are absent.
Sources
- The Large N Limit of Superconformal Field Theories and Supergravity
- Anti De Sitter Space And Holography
- An inflationary cosmology from anti-de Sitter wormholes
- Prepare inflationary universe via the Euclidean charged wormhole
- Magnetic Anti-de Sitter Wormholes as seeds for Higgs Inflation
- A Menagerie of Wormholes and Cosmologies in the Gravitational Path Integral
- Review of the No-Boundary Wave Function
- AdS Euclidean wormholes
- Bulk vs. Boundary Dynamics in Anti-de Sitter Spacetime
- On the Holographic Renormalization Group
- A Practical Approach to the Hamilton-Jacobi Formulation of Holographic Renormalization
- The number of negative modes of the oscillating bounces
- Negative Modes of Oscillating Instantons
- Stability of Axion-Dilaton Wormholes
- On the Exponentially Large Probability of Transition through the Lavrelashvili-Rubakov-Tinyakov Wormhole
- A Note On Complex Spacetime Metrics
- Allowable complex metrics in minisuperspace quantum cosmology
- Uses of Complex Metrics in Cosmology
- Allowable Complex Scalars from Kaluza-Klein Compactifications and Metric Rescalings
- The Kontsevich-Segal Criterion in the No-Boundary State Constrains Inflation
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions