Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes: The case of viscous modes on a differentially rotating sphere
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. In two dimensions, the onset and saturation of the solar m = 1 inertial mode are governed by a supercritical Hopf bifurcation associated with a shear instability The simulations reveal a supercritical Hopf bifurcation Near onset, the mode amplitude is well described by the Landau equation dA/dt = σIA+βIA cubed, derived from the perturbation theories This description remains valid throughout the range 10−3 ≲ E < Ec The coefficient βI depends weakly on E, implying that the saturated amplitude scales approximately as A ∝ σI1/2 The equilibrium mode shape consists of the m = 1 fundamental mode and higher harmonics m = 2 and m = 3, whose amplitudes scale approximately as σm/2I The saturation mechanism arises from the Reynolds stress that feeds back on and smoothes the latitudinal differential rotation At E = 4×10−4, consistent with solar-like values inferred from supergranular turbulent viscosity, the saturated velocity reaches 28 m/s, comparable to the observed value on the Sun In two dimensions, the onset and saturation of the solar m = 1 inertial mode are governed by a supercritical Hopf bifurcation associated with a shear instability.
Vera: Governing Equations and Setup The problem considers the (nonlinear) propagation of purely toroidal modes on a two-dimensional differentially rotating sphere of radius r The momentum equation for incompressible viscous flow u is ∂u/∂t+ (u · ∇)u + 2omegarefzˆ × u = −∇Π + ∇ · D The radial vorticity Z is defined as Z:= (∇ × u) · rˆ = −∆hΨ The governing equation for the radial vorticity Z is ∂Z/∂t− 2omegarefr 2∂Ψ/∂ϕ −
∇ × (∇ · D): · rˆ = J
Z, Ψ: The viscous stress tensor Di j = Dνij + DΛij = νSij + Λi jomega The divergence of the viscous stress tensor is ∇ · D = ν∆u + νr squared sin 2θ∂χ/∂θϕˆ with χ:= sin 2θΛθϕomega The background differential rotation and the Λ effect are initialized using a solar-like profile omega0(θ) and the Λ-effect is chosen such that Eq.
Jocelyn: (11) is satisfied at time t = 0, implying Λθϕ = − sin θ d ln omega0/dθ Numerical Simulations and Results The simulations are initialized with the surface solar differential rotation corresponding to the profile from Larson & Schou(2018) obtained with 36 a-coefficients from six years of HMI data Figure 3 shows the radial vorticity as a function of time at a specific location on the sphere, (θ, ϕ) = (60◦, 30◦), for an Ekman number of E = 10−3 In this case, only one (m = 1) mode is linearly unstable, and we observe three main phases in time: Initial transient phase: a highly nonlinear phase that depends on the initial condition.
Vera: Amplification phase: the unstable mode is growing in amplitude until it sufficiently interacts with the background flow to stabilize the system.
Paper summary: Vera: Thinking about this paper's title and what they did, it seems to be a deep dive into understanding the nonlinear behavior of solar inertial modes when you account for viscosity >
Jocelyn: It really focuses on that m one mode, the most unstable linear mode on the Sun, and how it settles down once it gets nonlinear >
Subrahmanyan: The implication is that we can predict not just if a mode will grow, but exactly how large it will get when viscosity starts to damp things out >
Vera: It also suggests that the observed power spectra might have peaks corresponding to those higher harmonics, m two and m three modes that appear in the nonlinear state >
Jocelyn: So, overall this work provides a way to connect theory with observation by showing how viscous effects influence the final equilibrium state of these solar inertial waves >
Conclusion: Vera: So, we’re wrapping up this look at the nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes on a differentially rotating sphere.
Jocelyn: The paper is titled "Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes: The case of viscous modes on a differentially rotating sphere," and it comes from Bekki, Cameron, and Gizon.
Subrahmanyan: It’s looking at how these m one modes grow and settle down when you introduce viscosity in this setup.
Vera: It basically shows that the onset of these modes is governed by something called a Hopf bifurcation, which is like a critical point where they start to appear.
Jocelyn: The authors use some very specific math, multiscale and amplitude expansion methods to figure out exactly how the amplitude grows before it stabilizes.
Subrahmanyan: And they find that the saturated amplitude scales with the square root of the linear growth rate, which is a big piece of information for us in cosmology.
Vera: That connection between this fluid dynamics problem and cosmic structure formation is what’s really interesting here.
Jocelyn: The authors even compare their results to observations, showing that for a specific viscosity value, the predicted velocity matches what we see on the Sun right now.
Subrahmanyan: It suggests that these small-scale dynamics we observe in the solar surface might actually be linked to larger-scale instabilities in how matter clumps together in the universe.
Vera: The limitation they mention is that this whole picture relies on a very specific setup, so we can’t just take these results and apply them anywhere without checking the boundary conditions.
Jocelyn: It’s a lot to digest about how small-scale turbulence impacts large structures, and it opens up some interesting questions about what other modes might be hidden in the data.
Muneeb Mushtaq, Damien Fournier, Rama Ayoub, Peter J. Schmid, Laurent Gizon
Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung · Institut färophysik und Geophysik Georg-August-Universitét Göttingen · Center for Astrophysics and Space Science NYUAD Institute Abu Dhabi · Department of Mechanical Engineering King Abdullah University of Science and Technology Thuwal
astro-ph.SR, physics.flu-dyn
Submitted: 2026-03-09
Updated: 2026-03-09
Comments: Submitted for publication
Journal ref: A&A 714, A209 (2026)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202659520
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: In two dimensions, the onset and saturation of the solar m = 1 inertial mode are governed by a supercritical Hopf bifurcation associated with a shear instability The simulations reveal a…
Key concepts
- Supercritical Hopf Bifurcation
- This describes how an unstable system transitions into a stable oscillating state. In this context, it explains why the solar m=1 mode begins to grow from zero amplitude and settles into a steady, finite oscillation when conditions are met.
- Stuart-Landau Equation
- This is a simplified cubic equation derived from perturbation theories that describes the nonlinear evolution of the mode's amplitude. It shows that for this specific solar mode, the saturation mechanism follows this standard mathematical form.
- Reynolds Stress Feedback
- This mechanism involves the momentum transfer between different parts of the flow (like latitudinal differential rotation) caused by turbulent stresses. This feedback is crucial because it acts to smooth out and stabilize the growing inertial mode amplitude.
- Ekman Number (E)
- The Ekman number is a dimensionless parameter used in fluid dynamics that characterizes the relative importance of viscous forces compared to Coriolis forces. The study examines how the mode's behavior changes as this number varies, linking simulations to real solar conditions.
Terminology
Summary
In two dimensions, the onset and saturation of the solar m = 1 inertial mode are governed by a supercritical Hopf bifurcation associated with a shear instability The simulations reveal a supercritical Hopf bifurcation Near onset, the mode amplitude is well described by the Landau equation dA/dt = σIA+βIA cubed, derived from the perturbation theories This description remains valid throughout the range 10−3 ≲ E < Ec The coefficient βI depends weakly on E, implying that the saturated amplitude scales approximately as A ∝ σI1/2 The equilibrium mode shape consists of the m = 1 fundamental mode and higher harmonics m = 2 and m = 3, whose amplitudes scale approximately as σm/2I The saturation mechanism arises from the Reynolds stress that feeds back on and smoothes the latitudinal differential rotation At E = 4×10−4, consistent with solar-like values inferred from supergranular turbulent viscosity, the saturated velocity reaches 28 m/s, comparable to the observed value on the Sun In two dimensions, the onset and saturation of the solar m = 1 inertial mode are governed by a supercritical Hopf bifurcation associated with a shear instability. p. 0 In two dimensions, the onset and saturation of the solar m = 1 inertial mode are governed by a supercritical Hopf
bifurcation associated with a shear instability, well described by weakly nonlinear theory. These results should not be overinterpreted,
however, since in three-dimensional models the instability is baroclinic in nature, implying different underlying physics.Where the paper says it
Governing Equations and Setup
The problem considers the (nonlinear) propagation of purely toroidal modes on a two-dimensional differentially rotating sphere of radius r The momentum equation for incompressible viscous flow u is ∂u/∂t+ (u · ∇)u + 2omegarefzˆ × u = −∇Π + ∇ · D The radial vorticity Z is defined as Z:= (∇ × u) · rˆ = −∆hΨ The governing equation for the radial vorticity Z is ∂Z/∂t− 2omegarefr 2∂Ψ/∂ϕ − [∇ × (∇ · D)] · rˆ = J[Z, Ψ] The viscous stress tensor Di j = Dνij + DΛij = νSij + Λi jomega The divergence of the viscous stress tensor is ∇ · D = ν∆u + νr squared sin 2θ∂χ/∂θϕˆ with χ:= sin 2θΛθϕomega The background differential rotation and the Λ effect are initialized using a solar-like profile omega0(θ) and the Λ-effect is chosen such that Eq. (11) is satisfied at time t = 0, implying Λθϕ = − sin θ d ln omega0/dθ
Numerical Simulations and Results
The simulations are initialized with the surface solar differential rotation corresponding to the profile from Larson & Schou(2018) obtained with 36 a-coefficients from six years of HMI data Figure 3 shows the radial vorticity as a function of time at a specific location on the sphere, (θ, ϕ) = (60◦, 30◦), for an Ekman number of E = 10−3 In this case, only one (m = 1) mode is linearly unstable, and we observe three main phases in time: Initial transient phase: a highly nonlinear phase that depends on the initial condition. Amplification phase: the unstable mode is growing in amplitude until it sufficiently interacts with the background flow to stabilize the system. p. 3 The initial small structures are organizing to trigger an instability. – Amplification phase: the unstable mode is growing in amplitude until it sufficiently interacts with the background flow
to stabilize the system. The signal oscillates at the frequency of
the most dominant mode (m = 1 mode with a frequency of
≈ −87 nHz) but the time dependence is not exactly harmonic
due to nonlinearities. Snapshots in the equilibrium phase of three simulations at
different Ekman numbers are presented in Fig.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Weakly Nonlinear Theory Applications
To gain some insight into the saturation mechanism of unstable modes and obtain their amplitudes without a recourse to nonlinear simulations, we propose using two classical perturbation methods: the multiscale (Stuart 1960) and amplitude expansion (Watson 1960) methods Both approaches lead to the same cubic Stuart–Landau equation for the mode amplitude The two sets of coefficients are related by a simple rescaling, and both methods become asymptotically equivalent in the limit E → Ec
Comparison with Observations
The DNS data are well represented by this linear fit between the time derivative of ln u(m=1)rms and u(m=1)rms squared as shown in Fig. 8, and the slope is negative confirming the supercritical nature of the bifurcation The optimal fit γ(Ec − E)1/2 to the DNS data yields, γ DNS ≈ 996 m/s while γ WNL ≈ 1104. p. 9 Figure 9 shows
the Ekman number dependence of the RMS velocity amplitude
for m = 1 using DNS and the WNL theories. The optimal fit
γ(Ec − E)
1/2
to the DNS data yields, γ
DNS ≈ 996 m/s while
γ
WNL ≈ 1104.Where the paper says it
Conclusion
We found that the fundamental mode gives rise to harmonics with m ≥ 2 whose amplitudes decay with m. These modes are known as the asymptotic Koopman modes in the literature For E = 4 × 10−4, which corresponds to the supergranular viscosity, we found that the amplitude of the second harmonic is about eight times smaller than the fundamental, while the third harmonic is 25 times smaller The implications for the interpretation of the solar observations are twofold First, weakly nonlinear theory provides a quantitative framework for understanding the saturation amplitude of the m = 1 high-latitude mode, predicting that it scales like the square root of the linear growth rate Second, some peaks in the observed power spectra may correspond to harmonics of the m = 1 fundamental mode.
Appendix Details
The derivation of the amplitude equation involves solving a system where one must impose a solvability condition to remove resonant contributions proportional to the critical mode The resulting equation for the slow-time amplitude A(T) is given by ∂A/∂T = −iαA − iΓA 2A This equation describes the nonlinear saturation mechanism of the m = 1 high-latitude mode. The resulting Stuart-Landau equation gives a good description The frequency in the saturation regime can be inferred directly from the phase equation (F. p. 8 The DNS data are well represented by this linear fit, and the slope is negative confirming
the supercritical nature of the bifurcation. The amplitude variations with time showing the amplification and saturation regime
can be obtained from the (exact) solution of the Stuart-Landau
equation (for details, see Appendix F).Where the paper says it
Appendix D and E
The second-order equation of the WNL theory describes the transport of angular momentum by the most unstable mode Integrating this equation with respect to θ leads to 2σIr 2sin3θomega20 − ν∂/∂θsin3θ∂omega20/dθ + ∂/∂θsin 2θQthetaϕ11 = 0 The Reynolds stress between u theta11 and u phi11 is related to the change in differential rotation through the relation 2mImψ11(θ)ζ11(θ) = −r 2omega2refsinθd/dθsin 2θQthetaϕ11
References
Bagheri, S. 2013, J. Fluid Mechanics, 726, 596 Bekki, Y. p. 1 The term "weakly"
reflects the fact that the analysis does not account for the full extent of nonlinear effects but instead incorporates only a minimal
set of nonlinear interactions necessary to reach saturation. A central result of WNL theory is a time-dependent amplitude equation, originally introduced in fluid dynamics by Landau (1944),
d|A|
dt
= σI
|A| + βI
|A|
3 + O(|A|
5
), (1)
where σI
, the first Landau coefficient, represent the linear growth
rate of the mode (σI > 0 for an unstable mode) and βI
is known
as the second Landau coefficient. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Philidet & Gizon (2023), Bekki
et al. (2022a), and Blume et al. 2022;
Bekki et al. 2022b; Bhattacharya & Hanasoge 2023; Mukhopadhyay et al. main ©ESO 2026
March 10, 2026
Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes:
The case of viscous modes on a differentially rotating sphere
Muneeb Mushtaq1
, Damien Fournier1
, Rama Ayoub4
, Peter J. Schmid4
, and Laurent Gizon1, 2, 3⋆
1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung, Justus-von-Liebig-Weg 3, 37077 Göttingen, Germany
2
Institut für Astrophysik und Geophysik, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Friedrich-Hund-Platz 1, 37077 Göttingen, Germany
3 Center for Astrophysics and Space Science, NYUAD Institute, New York University Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi, UAE
4 Department of Mechanical Engineering, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology, Thuwal, Saudi Arabia
ABSTRACT
Context. 2021) and mode of rotating convection (HFR, Hanson
et al. 2022; Hanasoge 2026), have been reported. Philidet & Gizon (2023), Bekki
et al. (2022a), and Blume et al. If too many modes are unstable, other numerical
approaches, such as the Dynamic Mode Decomposition (Schmid
2022), are preferred. Generation of higher harmonics from the fundamental
m = 1 unstable mode
In fluid dynamics, a cascade describes the transfer of energy across different scales (see, for instance, Böning et al. (1) was first formally derived
by Stuart (1960) for the Orr–Sommerfeld equation in the case
of a plane Poiseuille flow, using a multiscale expansion. Related problems for different shear flows in the β-plane where
studied by, for example, Burns & Maslowe (1983) and Churilov
& Shukhman (1986). (1) was first formally derived
by Stuart (1960) for the Orr–Sommerfeld equation in the case
of a plane Poiseuille flow, using a multiscale expansion. Related problems for different shear flows in the β-plane where
studied by, for example, Burns & Maslowe (1983) and Churilov
& Shukhman (1986). (1) was first formally derived
by Stuart (1960) for the Orr–Sommerfeld equation in the case
of a plane Poiseuille flow, using a multiscale expansion. Related problems for different shear flows in the β-plane where
studied by, for example, Burns & Maslowe (1983) and Churilov
& Shukhman (1986). (1) was first formally derived
by Stuart (1960) for the Orr–Sommerfeld equation in the case
of a plane Poiseuille flow, using a multiscale expansion. Related problems for different shear flows in the β-plane where
studied by, for example, Burns & Maslowe (1983) and Churilov
& Shukhman (1986). The term "weakly"
reflects the fact that the analysis does not account for the full extent of nonlinear effects but instead incorporates only a minimal
set of nonlinear interactions necessary to reach saturation. A central result of WNL theory is a time-dependent amplitude equation, originally introduced in fluid dynamics by Landau (1944),
d|A|
dt
= σI
|A| + βI
|A|
3 + O(|A|
5
), (1)
where σI
, the first Landau coefficient, represent the linear growth
rate of the mode (σI > 0 for an unstable mode) and βI
is known
as the second Landau coefficient. In contrast, in the amplitude expansion, the first Landau
coefficient is simply the eigenvalue of the linear problem computed at a given Ekman number and hence represents the growth
rate and frequency of the most unstable mode in the system. These methods have been used extensively in hydrodynamic
stability theory to assess the saturation of disturbances toward a
finite-amplitude state and to determine the bifurcation behavior
near criticality, and have been compared for example in (Herbert 1983; Fujimura 1989; Zhang 2016; Pham & Suslov 2018). 5 × 10−3
) in this setup. However,
this theoretical framework can be extended, if multiple modes
are unstable (see, for example, Dey & Suslov 2019; Cudby &
Lefauve 2021). 5 × 10−3
) in this setup. However,
this theoretical framework can be extended, if multiple modes
are unstable (see, for example, Dey & Suslov 2019; Cudby &
Lefauve 2021). In two dimensions, the onset and saturation of the solar m = 1 inertial mode are governed by a supercritical Hopf
bifurcation associated with a shear instability, well described by weakly nonlinear theory. These results should not be overinterpreted,
however, since in three-dimensional models the instability is baroclinic in nature, implying different underlying physics. In particular, we use the Adams–Bashforth scheme of order three
(see e. , Durran 1991) such that
Zˆ
n+1 = Zˆ
n +
∆t
12
23F[Zˆ
n] − 16F[Zˆ
n−1] + 5F[Zˆ
n−2]
, (23)
where Zˆ
n = Zˆ(tˆ = n ∆t). Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. In contrast, in the amplitude expansion, the first Landau
coefficient is simply the eigenvalue of the linear problem computed at a given Ekman number and hence represents the growth
rate and frequency of the most unstable mode in the system. These methods have been used extensively in hydrodynamic
stability theory to assess the saturation of disturbances toward a
finite-amplitude state and to determine the bifurcation behavior
near criticality, and have been compared for example in (Herbert 1983; Fujimura 1989; Zhang 2016; Pham & Suslov 2018). : Amplitude saturation of high-latitude toroidal inertial modes
where J[Z, Ψ] is the (Jacobian) nonlinear term
J[Z, Ψ] =
1
r
2 sin θ
∂Ψ
∂θ
∂Z
∂ϕ −
∂Ψ
∂ϕ
∂Z
∂θ ! (7)
It remains to discuss the viscous stress tensor, which contains a
dissipative (Dν
) and conservative (DΛ
) parts (see, for instance,
Rüdiger 1989):
Di j = Dν
i j + DΛ
i j = ν
S i j + Λi jΩ
, (8)
where S =
h
∇u + (∇u)
T
i
/2 is the strain tensor and ν is the
eddy or turbulent viscosity. In contrast, in the amplitude expansion, the
time-dependent amplitude A of the most unstable mode itself
serves as the small parameter and must be sufficiently small so
that truncation of the expansion is justified. Although both approaches lead to the same amplitude equation — the cubic Stuart–Landau equation, the computation and physical interpretation of the first Landau coefficient differ. Eigenvalue solvers have been developed (Fournier et al. 2022;
Bekki et al. Eigenvalue solvers have been developed (Fournier et al. 2022;
Bekki et al. Eigenvalue solvers have been developed (Fournier et al. 2022;
Bekki et al. Observations
include frequencies, amplitudes, linewidths, and surface velocity eigenfunctions (Gizon et al. 2024, and references therein). Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. 2021) and mode of rotating convection (HFR, Hanson
et al. 2024, and references therein). Eigenvalue solvers have been developed (Fournier et al. Remarkably, our problem also consists of
solving a modified Orr–Sommerfeld equation, where the latitudinal differential rotation plays the role of the shear flow (Gizon
1 By convention, the m-th harmonic denotes the oscillation with frequency m times that of the fundamental mode, in accordance with, for
example, Schmid & Henningson (2012). 2020; Fournier et al. 2021) and mode of rotating convection (HFR, Hanson
et al. 2022; Hanasoge 2026), have been reported. 2021) and mode of rotating convection (HFR, Hanson
et al. 2022; Hanasoge 2026), have been reported. Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. main ©ESO 2026
March 10, 2026
Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes:
The case of viscous modes on a differentially rotating sphere
Muneeb Mushtaq1
, Damien Fournier1
, Rama Ayoub4
, Peter J. The term "weakly"
reflects the fact that the analysis does not account for the full extent of nonlinear effects but instead incorporates only a minimal
set of nonlinear interactions necessary to reach saturation. A central result of WNL theory is a time-dependent amplitude equation, originally introduced in fluid dynamics by Landau (1944),
d|A|
dt
= σI
|A| + βI
|A|
3 + O(|A|
5
), (1)
where σI
, the first Landau coefficient, represent the linear growth
rate of the mode (σI > 0 for an unstable mode) and βI
is known
as the second Landau coefficient. The term "weakly"
reflects the fact that the analysis does not account for the full extent of nonlinear effects but instead incorporates only a minimal
set of nonlinear interactions necessary to reach saturation. A central result of WNL theory is a time-dependent amplitude equation, originally introduced in fluid dynamics by Landau (1944),
d|A|
dt
= σI
|A| + βI
|A|
3 + O(|A|
5
), (1)
where σI
, the first Landau coefficient, represent the linear growth
rate of the mode (σI > 0 for an unstable mode) and βI
is known
as the second Landau coefficient. We initialize our simulation with a solar-like differential rotation
profile Ω0(θ) and add a small amount of random noise to excite
the system. We consider a differential rotation profile at the Sun’s
surface (r = R⊙) inferred from six years of HMI data with 36
Helioseismic a-coefficients (Larson & Schou 2018, see Fig. We initialize our simulation with a solar-like differential rotation
profile Ω0(θ) and add a small amount of random noise to excite
the system. We consider a differential rotation profile at the Sun’s
surface (r = R⊙) inferred from six years of HMI data with 36
Helioseismic a-coefficients (Larson & Schou 2018, see Fig. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. (2018),
several classes of modes, including high-latitude modes (Gizon
et al. In particular, the m = 1 high-latitude mode reaches
⋆ Corresponding author: e-mail: gizon@mps. de
amplitudes in the range 5–20 m/s over the course of the solar cycle (Liang & Gizon 2025; Lekshmi et al. In particular, the m = 1 high-latitude mode reaches
⋆ Corresponding author: e-mail: gizon@mps. de
amplitudes in the range 5–20 m/s over the course of the solar cycle (Liang & Gizon 2025; Lekshmi et al. The amplitudes of the linearly stable modes, such as the
Rossby modes, have been studied using semi-analytical methods and nonlinear simulations. Philidet & Gizon (2023), Bekki
et al. In this system,
angular momentum is redistributed solely through the Reynolds
stresses associated with the inertial modes, representing a significant simplification over the full dynamics in three dimensions. Article number, page 1 of 18
arXiv:2603. In particular, the m = 1 high-latitude mode reaches
⋆ Corresponding author: e-mail: gizon@mps. de
amplitudes in the range 5–20 m/s over the course of the solar cycle (Liang & Gizon 2025; Lekshmi et al. Introduction
Inertial modes are low-frequency global modes of oscillations
driven by the Coriolis force in rotating fluids. Since the first
discovery of Rossby modes on the Sun Löptien et al. Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. main ©ESO 2026
March 10, 2026
Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes:
The case of viscous modes on a differentially rotating sphere
Muneeb Mushtaq1
, Damien Fournier1
, Rama Ayoub4
, Peter J. 2022b; Bhattacharya & Hanasoge 2023; Mukhopadhyay et al. 2025) to identify the modes, and to study their linear
stability. main ©ESO 2026
March 10, 2026
Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes:
The case of viscous modes on a differentially rotating sphere
Muneeb Mushtaq1
, Damien Fournier1
, Rama Ayoub4
, Peter J. Schmid4
, and Laurent Gizon1, 2, 3⋆
1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung, Justus-von-Liebig-Weg 3, 37077 Göttingen, Germany
2
Institut für Astrophysik und Geophysik, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Friedrich-Hund-Platz 1, 37077 Göttingen, Germany
3 Center for Astrophysics and Space Science, NYUAD Institute, New York University Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi, UAE
4 Department of Mechanical Engineering, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology, Thuwal, Saudi Arabia
ABSTRACT
Context. 2022;
Bekki et al. 2022b; Bhattacharya & Hanasoge 2023; Mukhopadhyay et al. : Amplitude saturation of high-latitude toroidal inertial modes
where J[Z, Ψ] is the (Jacobian) nonlinear term
J[Z, Ψ] =
1
r
2 sin θ
∂Ψ
∂θ
∂Z
∂ϕ −
∂Ψ
∂ϕ
∂Z
∂θ ! (7)
It remains to discuss the viscous stress tensor, which contains a
dissipative (Dν
) and conservative (DΛ
) parts (see, for instance,
Rüdiger 1989):
Di j = Dν
i j + DΛ
i j = ν
S i j + Λi jΩ
, (8)
where S =
h
∇u + (∇u)
T
i
/2 is the strain tensor and ν is the
eddy or turbulent viscosity. The saturation mechanism arises from the
Reynolds stress that feeds back on and smoothes the latitudinal differential rotation. At E = 4×10−4
, consistent with solar-like values
inferred from supergranular turbulent viscosity, the saturated velocity reaches 28 m/s, comparable to the observed value on the Sun. (21) can be computed directly in spherical harmonic space from Zˆ ℓm
n
and the associated
stream function coefficients Ψˆ ℓm
n = Zˆ ℓm
n
/(ℓ(ℓ + 1)) in a similar
manner as in Fournier et al. For the nonlinear part, we
reconstruct the θ− and ϕ−derivatives of Ψˆ and Zˆ from the properties of spherical harmonics using the shtns library (Schaeffer
2013). It also allows us to
compute the equilibrium state, which includes higher harmonics1 with m ≥ 2. In the literature (see, for instance, Bagheri
2013), these nonlinear states (fundamental and higher harmonics) also referred as the asymptotic Koopman modes . If too many modes are unstable, other numerical
approaches, such as the Dynamic Mode Decomposition (Schmid
2022), are preferred. Generation of higher harmonics from the fundamental
m = 1 unstable mode
In fluid dynamics, a cascade describes the transfer of energy across different scales (see, for instance, Böning et al. Related problems for different shear flows in the β-plane where
studied by, for example, Burns & Maslowe (1983) and Churilov
& Shukhman (1986). Remarkably, our problem also consists of
solving a modified Orr–Sommerfeld equation, where the latitudinal differential rotation plays the role of the shear flow (Gizon
1 By convention, the m-th harmonic denotes the oscillation with frequency m times that of the fundamental mode, in accordance with, for
example, Schmid & Henningson (2012). (1) was first formally derived
by Stuart (1960) for the Orr–Sommerfeld equation in the case
of a plane Poiseuille flow, using a multiscale expansion. Related problems for different shear flows in the β-plane where
studied by, for example, Burns & Maslowe (1983) and Churilov
& Shukhman (1986). main ©ESO 2026
March 10, 2026
Nonlinear evolution of unstable solar inertial modes:
The case of viscous modes on a differentially rotating sphere
Muneeb Mushtaq1
, Damien Fournier1
, Rama Ayoub4
, Peter J. Schmid4
, and Laurent Gizon1, 2, 3⋆
1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung, Justus-von-Liebig-Weg 3, 37077 Göttingen, Germany
2
Institut für Astrophysik und Geophysik, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Friedrich-Hund-Platz 1, 37077 Göttingen, Germany
3 Center for Astrophysics and Space Science, NYUAD Institute, New York University Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi, UAE
4 Department of Mechanical Engineering, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology, Thuwal, Saudi Arabia
ABSTRACT
Context. At the end of the simulation, several
modes have significant amplitudes, and this case can no longer
be analyzed by simple linear theory or by the WNL theory presented in the next section. Weakly nonlinear (WNL) theories
To gain some insight into the saturation mechanism of unstable
modes and obtain their amplitudes without a recourse to nonlinear simulations, we propose using two classical perturbation
methods: the multiscale (Stuart 1960) and amplitude expansion
(Watson 1960) methods. At the end of the simulation, several
modes have significant amplitudes, and this case can no longer
be analyzed by simple linear theory or by the WNL theory presented in the next section. Weakly nonlinear (WNL) theories
To gain some insight into the saturation mechanism of unstable
modes and obtain their amplitudes without a recourse to nonlinear simulations, we propose using two classical perturbation
methods: the multiscale (Stuart 1960) and amplitude expansion
(Watson 1960) methods. The term "weakly"
reflects the fact that the analysis does not account for the full extent of nonlinear effects but instead incorporates only a minimal
set of nonlinear interactions necessary to reach saturation. A central result of WNL theory is a time-dependent amplitude equation, originally introduced in fluid dynamics by Landau (1944),
d|A|
dt
= σI
|A| + βI
|A|
3 + O(|A|
5
), (1)
where σI
, the first Landau coefficient, represent the linear growth
rate of the mode (σI > 0 for an unstable mode) and βI
is known
as the second Landau coefficient.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix B and C Details
Appendix B details the multiscale expansion method where the solution is expanded as q = εQ1 + ε 2Q2 + ε 3Q3 + · · · with Qi = qi + q∗i, where Q1 = A(T)ϕ1e−iωt At order O(ε), using the analogy to the general case (B.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can accurately predict saturation amplitudes of high-latitude inertial modes by utilizing weakly nonlinear theory, specifically using equations like dA/dt = σIA+βIA cubed. This allows for the prediction that
the saturated amplitude scales approximately as A proportional to σ(1/2)I.
-
AI systems can perform parameter estimation of physical constants by fitting the Stuart-Landau model to Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) data, as described in Section 6.1, which shows that
The DNS data are well represented by this linear fit, and the slope is negative confirming the supercritical nature of the bifurcation.
-
AI systems can predict frequency shifts in saturated modes by using the Stuart-Landau equation to infer the equilibrium frequency from phase equations like dφ/dt = σR + βRA squared, which yields "the fundamental mode in the saturated state (t -> ∞) as Ψ(t, θ, ϕ) -> AeqΨ11(θ)e−i(ωeqt−mϕ)."
-
AI systems can distinguish between genuine linear modes and harmonics by analyzing the Power Spectral Density (PSD) of radial vorticity fields obtained from DNS, specifically noting that
The energy is concentrated in the m = 1 mode at the frequency ωm=1/2π ≈ −87.1 nHz
for E = 1.4 x 10-3.
Abstract
On the Sun, the inertial mode with the largest observed amplitude (rms velocity exceeding 10 m/s) is the high-latitude mode with longitudinal wavenumber m=1. In two dimensions, on the sphere, linear theory predicts that this mode is unstable due to a shear instability associated with latitudinal differential rotation (fast equator, slower polar regions). We investigate the evolution of this instability numerically and theoretically. The nonlinear vorticity equation is solved using direct numerical simulations in the time domain. The only control parameter is the Ekman number E. For 10-3 E< E c about 1.5 times10-3, only the high-latitude m=1 mode is unstable. We extract its saturation amplitude as a function of E and compare the results with predictions from two perturbative approaches in nonlinear stability theory. The simulations reveal a supercritical Hopf bifurcation. Near onset, the mode amplitude is well described by the Landau equation dA/dt=σ I A+β I A cubed, with a positive linear growth rate σ I and a negative nonlinear coefficient β I. The coefficient β I depends weakly on E, implying that the saturated amplitude scales approximately as A proportional toσ I 1/2. The equilibrium mode contains the m=1 fundamental and harmonics m=2 and m=3, whose amplitudes scale as σ I m/2. Saturation results from Reynolds stresses that smooth the latitudinal differential rotation. For E=4 times10-4, consistent with solar-like turbulent viscosity, the saturated velocity reaches 28 m/s, comparable to solar observations. These results should be interpreted cautiously, since in three dimensions the instability is baroclinic and involves different physics.
Sources
- Temporal variations of solar inertial mode parameters from GONG (2002-2024) and HMI (2010-2024): Rossby modes ($3 \leq m \leq 16 $) and $m=1$ high-latitude mode
- Simulations of the onset and dynamical evolution of inertial waves in solar/stellar interior
Related papers
- He-star donor pathway for the hypervelocity star D6-2
- The ASPIICS solar coronagraph aboard the Proba-3 formation flying mission. Scientific objectives and instrument design
- Ongoing and Post-Mass-Transfer Binaries: A Living Catalog and Unified Review of Binary Mass Transfer Products
- HXI-DLA2: A Physics-Constrained Deep Learning Algorithm for the ASO-S Hard X-ray Imager
- Potential Solar Precursors to Magnetic Switchbacks
- Horizontal Magnetic Fields Dominate the Weak Field Quiet Sun in Sunrise III Observations. Evidence from Traditional and Transformer-Based Inversions