Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of the 2023-2024 Oversight of AI Hearings
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.
Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI".
Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. This paper investigates early legislative deliberations over Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the United States through a thematic analysis of the 2023-2024 Oversight of AI hearings held by the Senate Judiciary Committee’s subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law.
Tom: It examines how participants create narratives for understanding AI impacts to argue for particular forms of AI governance, revealing arrangements of power enacted through these hearings Deconstructing the Term AI The term itself functions to promote a particular understanding of these technologies and their capabilities Bender (2023) explains that “In fact this
AI: is a marketing term" It’s a way to make certain kinds of automation sound sophisticated, powerful, or magical and as such it’s a way to dodge accountability by making the machines sound like autonomous thinking entities rather than tools that are created and used by people and companies The Three Dominant Understandings The thematic analysis identified three understandings of AI frequently invoked by industry representatives and taken up by Senators 1.
Jane: AI has Tremendous Potential Benefits, which focuses on broad and unspecified claims to future possible capabilities of AI across sectors like health and climate change 2.
Tom: AI is Inevitable, where participants suggest that the development of AI is unavoidable and limits legislation 3.
Paper summary: Tom: So, we've got the overview of "Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of the two thousand twenty-three-two thousand twenty-four Oversight of AI Hearings <ref:2603.03193#pg1,Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of>." The paper argues that participants, mostly from industry, are using narratives to frame what AI is capable of and how it should be controlled.
Jane: It claims that these shared understandings function as a substitute for real evidence, which in turn hides existing harms and promotes speculative future capabilities instead. It shows how the discourse used in those hearings actually upholds power arrangements favoring certain ideas about AI governance.
Lu: Specifically, the paper identifies three dominant ways people talk about AI: first, that it has tremendous potential benefits across sectors like health and climate change; second, that its development is inevitable; and third, a focus on American companies doing what's necessary to protect national values.
Meng: Those understandings are really just proxies for evidence because they let people avoid talking about real problems like increased energy use or discrimination that already exist. When you talk about AI nationalism, it gets tied up with American ideas of innovation and business, which shields certain groups from scrutiny.
Lalam: It points out those narratives are full of contradictions. For example, people claim AI will cure cancer and help stop climate change but then suggest the technology is so fragile that we need really limited and permissive rules. This reliance on shared understandings instead of contestable evidence is a key finding > Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of the two thousand twenty-three-two thousand twenty-four Oversight of AI Hearings <ref:2603.03193#pg1,Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of>
Conclusion: Tom: So, to wrap up this paper, it shows that these shared understandings function as a way to substitute for actual evidence, which lets people focus on future possibilities instead of current material harms. The narratives used in those hearings are what support the power structures around AI governance.
Jane: It really highlights how early attempts to govern this technology are being shaped by these specific shared ideas rather than a full picture of the situation on the ground. It’s about recognizing that those understandings aren't neutral; they actively shape who gets power in these debates.
Lu: The core implication is that we need to look closely at what those dominant discourses are and how they are being used to justify specific rules for AI development and deployment. It forces a re-evaluation of the evidence being used in these legislative settings > Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of the two thousand twenty-three-two thousand twenty-four Oversight of AI Hearings <ref:2603.03193#pg1,Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of>
Meng: For those who are actually trying to deploy models, this means that the way we talk about what AI can do—the hype versus the reality—is heavily influenced by these pre-existing narratives. You have to be aware of that framing when you're building something at scale.
Lalam: It shows how these early deliberations are less about technical solutions and more about establishing a specific language for what AI governance means in the first place > Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of the two thousand twenty-three-two thousand twenty-four Oversight of AI Hearings <ref:2603.03193#pg1,Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of>
Rachel Leach
Senate Judiciary Committee
cs.CY
Submitted: 2026-03-03
Updated: 2026-10-30
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of the 2023-2024 Oversight of AI Hearings investigates early legislative deliberations over Artificial Intelligence (AI) in…
Key concepts
- Deconstructing the Term AI
- The term 'AI' is often a marketing tool. It makes complex automation sound magical or powerful, which helps companies avoid accountability by portraying machines as thinking entities instead of tools made by people.
- The Three Dominant Understandings
- Participants frequently used three main ideas about AI: 1) Tremendous Potential Benefits (unspecified future good), 2) Inevitability (AI development is unstoppable), and 3) AI Nationalism (American companies are doing the necessary work).
- How Power is Enacted Through Discourse
- These shared understandings act as a stand-in for actual proof. They obscure real harms, such as increased energy use or discrimination, while framing AI benefits as a universal good that protects American innovation and business.
Terminology
Summary
Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI: A Thematic Analysis of the 2023-2024 Oversight of AI Hearings investigates early legislative deliberations over Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the United States through a thematic analysis of the 2023 - 2024 Oversight of AI hearings held by the Senate Judiciary Committee’s subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law <ref:2603. p. 0 1
Shared (Mis)Understandings and the Governance of AI:
A Thematic Analysis of the 2023-2024 Oversight of AI Hearings
Rachel Leach
Abstract
This paper investigates early legislative deliberations over Artificial Intelligence (AI) 1
in the
United States through a thematic analysis of the 2023 - 2024 Oversight of AI hearings held by the
Senate Judiciary Committee’s subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law. I focus on
these hearings as a site where participants draw from, and renegotiate, accustomed ways of
thinking about technology and society.Where the paper says it
Deconstructing AI Terminology
The term AI itself functions to promote a particular understanding of these technologies and their capabilities. Bender (2023) explains that “In fact this [AI] is a marketing term". This term is used to make certain kinds of automation sound sophisticated, powerful, or magical and as such it’s a way to dodge accountability by making the machines sound like autonomous thinking entities rather than tools that are created and used by people and companies. p. 0 When defining AI, Bender (2023) explains: “In fact this [AI] is a marketing term. It’s a way to make
certain kinds of automation sound sophisticated, powerful, or magical and as such it’s a way to dodge accountability
by making the machines sound like autonomous thinking entities rather than tools that are created and used by people
and companies.Where the paper says it
The Three Dominant Understandings
The thematic analysis identified three understandings of AI frequently invoked by industry representatives and taken up by Senators. These understandings are:
-
AI has Tremendous Potential Benefits, which focuses on the potential of AI to achieve otherwise unattainable goals in areas like health, education, and the environment. p. 2
Where the paper says it
The goal of building AGI contributes to, and is in turn justified by, what Bender (2021) terms “AI Hype. ” She argues that the impact of AI is frequently overstated, leading to false perceptions of the potential benefits of the technology.
-
AI is Inevitable, where participants suggest that the development of AI is unavoidable and legislation attempting to limit its spread is neither possible nor desirable. p. 2
Where the paper says it
Despite this, companies attempting to develop it agree AGI is a machine intelligence that can complete tasks previously only done by humans, especially tasks that are cognitive (according to Google)5 and tasks that are economically useful (according to OpenAI). 6 Whether this is possible, or desirable, is still up for debate (Salvaggio, 2025; Heaven, 2025).
-
AI Nationalism, centered around the belief that American companies are doing the necessary work of building technologies which promotes the culture, values, and interests of the country. p. 8
Where the paper says it
In turn, values centered by many who viewed the internet as liberating, including flexibility and entrepreneurship, helped proponents of the changing economic system obscure its harms. Utopian understandings of emergent technologies continue to be invoked today, including in discussions about the government's role in shaping AI development.
How Narratives Justify Governance
The understanding that AI presents a novel possibility to bring tremendous benefits works to justify any potential harm of the technology as ultimately worth it. This discourse frames the benefits of developing AI tools as categorically more important than any of the current harms or risks presented by the technology. Conversely, industry participants frequently suggest that the development of AI is unavoidable, arguing that legislation attempting to limit its spread is neither possible nor desirable. p. 2 Despite this, companies attempting to
develop it agree AGI is a machine intelligence that can complete tasks previously only done by
humans, especially tasks that are cognitive (according to Google)5
and tasks that are
economically useful (according to OpenAI). 6 Whether this is possible, or desirable, is still up for
debate (Salvaggio, 2025; Heaven, 2025).Where the paper says it
The Role of Shared Misunderstandings
These shared understandings are based on speculative and forward-looking claims rather than contestable evidence. The paper argues that these understandings function as a proxy for evidence, obscuring existing harms such as expanding energy use and environmental degradation. p. 4 11
The imperative for extraction does not stop at the non-consentual rendering of human
knowledge and creativity as data to be processed (Curzi, 2025). Rather, this data imperative
means the technology necessarily relies on expansive energy use and environmental harms.Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Power Arrangements
The investigation sought to understand what arrangements of power are upheld through the discourses that are dominant in the Oversight of AI hearings asking what role do shared (mis)understandings of AI play in early attempts at governing this technology. The paper concludes that these understandings rely on a particular techno-social vision where current material harms are largely unconsidered, as industry is promising “everything machines” but the technology will never live up to this hype. p. 9 Because choices tend to become strongly fixed in
material equipment, economic investment, and social habit, the original flexibility
vanishes for all practical purposes once the initial commitments are made. ”
14 While this paper focuses on industry use of informational asymmetries, control over understandings, assumptions, expertise as
a means of shaping AI governance, other factors such as lobbying (Cook, 2024) and the funding of academic research (Burrell
and Metcalf, 2024) also play an important role in industry influence over regulatory discussions. Each of the works above highlight the impact value-laden understandings of
technological progress generally, and of particular kinds of technologies specifically, have on the
governance of these technologies. 14 Building on this foundation, I investigate how AI and
technological progress are understood in early legislative discussions on the Oversight of AI in
the United States; I am interested in what power arrangements support, and are in turn supported
by, these dominant discourses.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can be designed to explicitly address environmental harms by integrating resource constraints into their operational parameters, mitigating
expansive energy use and environmental harms
by incorporating considerations from papers like Extractive AI to reduce reliance on intensive data center infrastructure. -
Improved AI systems can incorporate mechanisms to counteract the tendency of
stochastic parrot
models to generate incorrect information by utilizing Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) techniques, as suggested by Li et al., which helpsEnhancing LLM Factual Accuracy with RAG to Counter Hallucinations.
-
Improved AI governance frameworks should be structured to incorporate a more nuanced view of potential benefits versus current risks, moving beyond the dominant understanding that
the benefits accrued by AI are largely treated as a universal, social good
by actively investigating thepotential for the benefits of this technology to be disproportionately accumulated by a small group.
-
Improved systems can operate under governance models that prioritize
precision regulation
rather than attempting to regulatethe technology itself,
aligning with Christina Montgomery's suggestion that rules should govern deployment in specific use cases, not the underlying technology. -
Improved AI systems can be developed with built-in transparency regarding their training data sources to counter the practices of Big Tech companies that rely on
mass amounts of data scraped from the internet, copyrighted works, and sensitive or personal information
without meaningful consent.
Abstract
This paper investigates early legislative deliberations over Artificial Intelligence in the United States through a thematic analysis of the 2023 - 2024 Oversight of AI hearings held by the Senate Judiciary Committee's subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law. I focus on these hearings as a site where participants draw from, and renegotiate, accustomed ways of thinking about technology and society. First, I examine how participants, who overwhelmingly represent the technology industry, work to create narratives for understanding the future impacts of AI, and the relationship between technology and progress. Second, I examine how these narratives are invoked to argue for a particular form of AI governance, while casting alternative approaches as everything from infeasible to anti-American. By tracing industry influence over dominant understandings of the impacts of AI and the proper role of government, I examine the arrangements of power enacted and upheld through these hearings. In all, I ask: what role do shared (mis)understandings of AI play in early deliberations over governing this technology?
Sources
- Mind the Gap: Foundation Models and the Covert Proliferation of Military Intelligence, Surveillance, and Targeting
- Enhancing LLM Factual Accuracy with RAG to Counter Hallucinations: A Case Study on Domain-Specific Queries in Private Knowledge-Bases
- Estimating the Carbon Footprint of BLOOM, a 176B Parameter Language Model
Related papers
- AI-Mediated Communication Can Steer Collective Opinion
- Epistemic Infrastructures of Science in AI Era Should Rebalance Costs of Generation and Verification
- AI out-persuades expert humans in text-based dialogue
- Evaluating Ambient Clinical Scribes in India: The Need for Multilingual Real-World Clinical Conversation Data
- AI Value Alignment for Evolving Social Norms
- Voting Biases in Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO) Governance