Weinberg Angle, Neutron Abundance in BBN, and Lifetime

arXiv:2603.02652 · hep-ph, astro-ph.CO, nucl-th · Submitted 2026-03-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Weinberg Angle, Neutron Abundance in BBN, and Lifetime".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We present state of the art kinetic theory determination of the neutron abundance available for the Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) using methods motivated by laboratory measurements and unknown weak interaction coupling constants in the primordial Universe Our work establishes how a small variation in the Weinberg angle influences neutron abundance available for BBN and neutron lifetime The primary motivation for this work is to quantify the primordial neutron abundance available for Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) using methods of kinetic theory and to study the impact of small weak interaction GF variation from present day value There is continued interest in understanding the cosmological variation of natural constants

1: , with much of recent interest arising in the context of the Hubble tension

2: Our present work extends these considerations to the temperature domain at the edge of BBN nucleosynthesis physics The motivation to study the neutron primordial abundance derives from a significant dependence of GF on Weinberg angle parameter used in the convenient form s 2W ≡ sin 2θW, c 2W ≡ cos2θW Allowing for higher radiative corrections, GF and thus the relevant weak interaction (WI) reaction rates become dependent on s 2W, a free parameter of the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics Electroweak Parameter Dependence The value of s 2W controls the splitting in mass of the gauge Bosons W, Z and yet it appears in the WI dominating charged current interactions mediated by W only in beyond the tree level radiative corrections, see Eq.

Kai: (1) Given this situation we expect that any future dynamic theory determining the value of s 2W by seeking the minimum of an effective action includes similar in magnitude effects of both charged and neutral currents contributions to the vacuum energy Since these questions are not yet addressed in the literature we advance intuitive arguments: Given the radiative dependence of GF on s 2W, the minimum in effective potential as a function of s 2W obtained at radiative level could be governed by much lower energy scale compared to the usual in the SM Therefore the value of the Weinberg angle and thus GF would be unusually sensitive to the environmental conditions including temperature, and external (strong) fields Fermi Constant Modification In this section we explore the sensitivity of the effective Fermi constant to variations in the Weinberg angle We work within the on-shell renormalization scheme set out by Sirlin and collaborators

6,12,18: , in which the independent input parameters are taken as α, GF, mZ, and the fermion masses, with s 2W defined through the on-shell relation s 2W = 1 − m 2W/m 2Z The quantum correction ∆r has seen extensive theoretical study Numerically, its impact is small, contributing at the ∼ 1% level

6: Medium Effects in Neutron Lifespan In this section, we explore medium effects modifying the neutron decay rate in the primordial Universe The relevant temperature range after neutron freeze-out Tf ⩾ T ⩾ TBBN, electrons and neutrinos in the background plasma can reduce the neutron decay rate by Fermi blocking We use their method to quantify the ambient cosmic plasma effect on neutron decay, including as a new element the consideration of variation of s 2W Dominant omitted corrections have been already addressed in the precision-BBN literature, in particular by Pitrou–Coc–Uzan–Vangioni

30: , and are estimated there at the ∼ 0.1–0.5% level on Xn in the temperature range T ≲ 1 MeV Kinetic Neutron Population Equation We now develop a kinetic model for the neutron concentration, i.e.

Mira: the abundance ratio between neutrons and baryons The population of neutrons is governed by gains and losses due to reactions we considered 1 V dNn/dt = dWpe→nνdVdt + dWpν→nedVdt − dWnν→pedVdt − dWne→pνdVdt − dWn→peν¯dVdt The kinetic equation for the neutron concentration Xn can be written as 1/V dNn/dt = np Γpe→nν + Γpν→ne − nnΓnν→pe + Γne→pν − nnΓn + npΓp Kinetic Evolution and Sensitivity The adiabatic solution arises from the competition between neutron production, weak interaction conversion, and decay rates, yielding the modified equilibrium neutron concentration The correction term Eq.

Kai: (51) is seen as a dotted line in Fig.

Paper summary: Kai: We're diving into the specifics of "Weinberg Angle, Neutron Abundance in BBN, and Lifetime." The paper sets out to show how a small variation in s squared W influences the neutron abundance available for BBN and the neutron lifetime.

Mira: They are motivated by quantifying that primordial neutron abundance using kinetic theory methods and studying the impact of small weak interaction GF variations from its present-day value.

Lev: The motivation stems from continued interest in how natural constants might vary across cosmological time, especially in connection with things like the Hubble tension we see now.

Kai: Their work extends this thinking to the temperature range right at the edge of BBN physics, looking at how these parameters behave under environmental conditions like temperature and external fields.

Mira: They explore how s squared W controls the mass splitting between gauge bosons, and since it appears in charged current interactions mediated by W bosons beyond tree level, they expect effects from both charged and neutral currents to be related.

Lev: The paper investigates the sensitivity of the effective Fermi constant to variations in the Weinberg angle, using an on-shell renormalization scheme where inputs are alpha, GF, mZ, and fermion masses.

Kai: They show that while quantum corrections affect things like the radiative correction delta r by about one percent numerically at this level, their main point is about how s squared W modifies reaction rates.

Mira: Then they look at medium effects in the neutron lifespan itself, exploring how electrons and neutrinos in the primordial plasma can reduce the neutron decay rate through Fermi blocking.

Lev: They use that method to quantify that cosmic plasma effect on neutron decay, adding the consideration of varying s squared W as a new element in their analysis.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at "Weinberg Angle, Neutron Abundance in BBN, and Lifetime," we see that precision BBN studies requiring neutron abundance at the sub-percent level depend on the precise value of GF.

Mira: And since GF is tied to s squared W through electroweak radiative corrections, this means it depends on the value of s squared W in the hot primordial plasma right at the edge of BBN.

Lev: The paper establishes that within measurement errors for s squared W, a small residual environmental component could potentially contribute to those discrepancies we observe in laboratory neutron-lifetime measurements.

Kai: That’s interesting because it links something happening deep in the early universe to what we measure in particle accelerators today.

Mira: And they suggest that if you are looking at future dynamic theories trying to determine s squared W by minimizing an effective action, the minimum found at radiative level could be governed by a much lower energy scale than usual.

Lev: So, this work points toward the idea that the value of the Weinberg angle and thus GF might be unusually sensitive to things like temperature and external strong fields.

Kai: The paper also touches on how neutrons are 'lost' during BBN because they get converted into other nuclei through reactions, especially net photoproduction of deuterons.

Mira: And that kinetic theory framework they build transfers in principle to other settings where weak rates compete with macroscopic timescales, like neutron-rich astrophysical environments.

Lev: It’s motivating future study of electro-weak physics to address whether s squared W and GF could be sensitive to these kinds of environmental factors.

University of Arizona

hep-ph, astro-ph.CO, nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-03-03

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 24 MDPI Particles pages, 9 figures, in Particles and Plasmas special volume, ancilliary files contain data fields generated for the figurs shown, V2 as published, V3 is a post publication update which clarifies isentropic expansion: see end of Appendix and Eq (52) with tetxt below

Journal ref: MDPI Particles 2026, 9(3), 68 - 26 Jun 2026

DOI: 10.3390/particles9030068

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 77/100

The gist: We present state of the art kinetic theory determination of the neutron abundance available for the Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) using methods motivated by laboratory measurements and unknown weak…

Terminology

Summary

We present state of the art kinetic theory determination of the neutron abundance available for the Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) using methods motivated by laboratory measurements and unknown weak interaction coupling constants in the primordial Universe Our work establishes how a small variation in the Weinberg angle influences neutron abundance available for BBN and neutron lifetime

Motivation for Variation of Parameters

The primary motivation for this work is to quantify the primordial neutron abundance available for Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) using methods of kinetic theory and to study the impact of small weak interaction GF variation from present day value There is continued interest in understanding the cosmological variation of natural constants [1], with much of recent interest arising in the context of the Hubble tension [2] Our present work extends these considerations to the temperature domain at the edge of BBN nucleosynthesis physics The motivation to study the neutron primordial abundance derives from a significant dependence of GF on Weinberg angle parameter used in the convenient form s 2W ≡ sin 2θW, c 2W ≡ cos2θW Allowing for higher radiative corrections, GF and thus the relevant weak interaction (WI) reaction rates become dependent on s 2W, a free parameter of the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics

Electroweak Parameter Dependence

The value of s 2W controls the splitting in mass of the gauge Bosons W, Z and yet it appears in the WI dominating charged current interactions mediated by W only in beyond the tree level radiative corrections, see Eq. (1) Given this situation we expect that any future dynamic theory determining the value of s 2W by seeking the minimum of an effective action includes similar in magnitude effects of both charged and neutral currents contributions to the vacuum energy Since these questions are not yet addressed in the literature we advance intuitive arguments: Given the radiative dependence of GF on s 2W, the minimum in effective potential as a function of s 2W obtained at radiative level could be governed by much lower energy scale compared to the usual in the SM Therefore the value of the Weinberg angle and thus GF would be unusually sensitive to the environmental conditions including temperature, and external (strong) fields

Fermi Constant Modification

In this section we explore the sensitivity of the effective Fermi constant to variations in the Weinberg angle We work within the on-shell renormalization scheme set out by Sirlin and collaborators [6,12,18], in which the independent input parameters are taken as α, GF, mZ, and the fermion masses, with s 2W defined through the on-shell relation s 2W = 1 − m 2W/m 2Z The quantum correction ∆r has seen extensive theoretical study Numerically, its impact is small, contributing at the ∼ 1% level [6]

Medium Effects in Neutron Lifespan

In this section, we explore medium effects modifying the neutron decay rate in the primordial Universe The relevant temperature range after neutron freeze-out Tf ⩾ T ⩾ TBBN, electrons and neutrinos in the background plasma can reduce the neutron decay rate by Fermi blocking We use their method to quantify the ambient cosmic plasma effect on neutron decay, including as a new element the consideration of variation of s 2W Dominant omitted corrections have been already addressed in the precision-BBN literature, in particular by Pitrou–Coc–Uzan–Vangioni [30], and are estimated there at the ∼ 0.1–0.5% level on Xn in the temperature range T ≲ 1 MeV

Kinetic Neutron Population Equation

We now develop a kinetic model for the neutron concentration, i.e. the abundance ratio between neutrons and baryons The population of neutrons is governed by gains and losses due to reactions we considered 1 V dNn/dt = dWpe→nνdVdt + dWpν→nedVdt − dWnν→pedVdt − dWne→pνdVdt − dWn→peν¯dVdt The kinetic equation for the neutron concentration Xn can be written as 1/V dNn/dt = np Γpe→nν + Γpν→ne − nnΓnν→pe + Γne→pν − nnΓn + npΓp

Kinetic Evolution and Sensitivity

The adiabatic solution arises from the competition between neutron production, weak interaction conversion, and decay rates, yielding the modified equilibrium neutron concentration The correction term Eq. (51) is seen as a dotted line in Fig. p. 4

Where the paper says it

21 < s 2 W < 0. The horizontal dotted line indicates the standard-model value GF = G exp F .

4 The combined result, the neutron concentration as a function of temperature in primordial Universe is the solid line In particular, near the BBN temperature regime, small variations of the Weinberg angle in the range 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

To conclude: • We believe that the effective electro-weak vacuum energy minimum as a function of s 2 W is relatively shallow rendering the value susceptible to modification by environmental factors; • In the primordial Universe the effective value of the Weinberg angle s 2 W can differ from its low-energy laboratory value due to the thermal plasma background effects. As a result, the Fermi constant GF in this environment could acquire a temperature dependent shift.

1 < s 2W < 0.5 lead to substantial changes in Xn, indicating a strong sensitivity

Conclusion and Outlook

We have shown that precision BBN studies that require Xn at the sub-percent level depend on the precise value of GF, or equivalently—assuming the dominant source of variability is the Weinberg angle—on the value of s 2W in the hot primordial plasma at the edge of the BBN epoch We have established that within measurement errors of s 2W, a small residual environmental component could in principle contribute to the discrepancies observed in laboratory neutron-lifetime measurements Looking forward to further work and impact of our results: BBN: In the presence of ongoing BBN nuclear reactions in addition to the neutron loss by decay, neutrons are ‘lost’ to the produced nuclei, for most part in net photoproduction of deuterons Outlook — astrophysical neutron-rich environments: The kinetic-theory framework presented here transfers in principle to other settings where weak rates compete with macroscopic timescales Weinberg symmetry breaking: We offered results for Xn motivating future study of unexplored phenomena in electro-weak physics addressing the question if the value of s 2W and thus GF could be sensitive to environmental factors

Appendix Summary

In this section, we summarize the key theoretical background relevant to our analysis and in particular the detailed value of the Hubble parameter H in the primordial Universe In Fig. A1, we show the effective number of ‘energy’ degrees of freedom g∗ as a function of temperature In Fig. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Thus we adapt the factor F into our calculation at finite T and use the following neutron decay rate in the cosmic plasma Γn = DF Γ ′ n (22) In Fig. 2, we show the ratio of the neutron lifetime in a cosmic plasma, τn, to its vacuum value, τ 0 n , as a function of plasma temperature T for three different values of the Weinberg angle, s 2 W.

A2, we plot the Hubble parameter as a function of temperature from 10 ⩾ T ⩾ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our work is motivated by the study of the neutron lifespan measured in the laboratory and the unknown strength of weak interactions coupling constant GF at finite temperature in the primordial Universe. We draw attention to the relevant dependence of GF on the symmetry breaking Weinberg angle s 2 W, a free parameter in the standard model of particle physics.

01MeV in the primordial Universe After neutrino freeze-out and when me >> T, the e± becomes non-relativistic and annihilate From entropy conservation we have Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

There is continued interest in understanding the cosmological variation of natural constants [1], with much of recent interest arising in the context of the Hubble tension [2]. We studied this context before, exploring the dependence of neutrino freeze-out on the variation of natural constants [3] in the primordial Universe.

(A6) where we use the subscripts k to denote quantities for neutrino freeze-out and g s∗ counts the degree of freedom for relativistic species in primordial Universe In this case, from entropy conservation, Eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

To obtain precise neutron abundance we need to have a precise understanding of the ratio of weak interaction strength to the Hubble expansion rate H, which we discuss in Appendix A based on our recent work [8]. We show the precise dependence of H on the baryon and entropy content, usually stated in form of baryon to photon ratio ηb , and the number of neutrino species Nν, which is near but above the value three, since by definition it comprises an inflow of entropy due to pre-freeze-out neutrino reheating by electron-positron annihilation.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Incorporate a kinetic model that solves for neutron concentration using equation 51 to determine Xn as a function of temperature T, incorporating both adiabatic and kinetic corrections. This allows for a more precise calculation of neutron abundance before Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN).

  2. Develop an improved method for quantifying the dependence of the Fermi constant GF on environmental factors by explicitly modeling the running of s2W from its dependence on temperature and external fields as discussed in section 2.1 and 3.3. This will provide a more robust framework for understanding potential variations in fundamental constants in the early Universe.

  3. Create an AI system capable of predicting the ratio of neutron lifetime to vacuum value (τn/τ0n) as a function of plasma temperature T, using equation 21 and figure 2 data across different s2W values. This will enable rapid assessment of how environmental variations influence neutron decay measurements.

  4. Implement a module that calculates the induced 'decay rate' of the proton into a neutron (Γp) in plasma conditions, utilizing equation 26 to determine the competition between weak interaction conversion and Hubble expansion rates. This is essential for understanding kinetic processes at different temperature regimes.

  5. Build a simulation tool that incorporates nuclear reaction loss terms, such as photoproduction of deuterons, into the kinetic neutron population equation (45). This will allow for more accurate determination of the neutron abundance by accounting for depletion via fusion reactions during BBN.

Abstract

We present state of the art kinetic theory determination of the neutron abundance available for the Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN). Our work is motivated by the study of the neutron lifespan measured in the laboratory and the unknown strength of weak interactions coupling constant G F at finite temperature in the primordial Universe. We draw attention to the relevant dependence of G F on the symmetry breaking Weinberg angle s 2 W, a free parameter in the standard model of particle physics. We establish how the value of s 2 W by way of G F modification influences neutron abundance available for BBN and neutron lifetime.

Sources

Related papers