The Baryon Budget of Galaxies across the First Billion Years
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: I'm Vera.
Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The Baryon Budget of Galaxies across the First Billion Years".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates the baryon budget of galaxies across cosmic time to understand the efficiency and timescales of star formation in early galaxies The results show that gas phases are quantitatively related to underlying stellar populations and can be used to infer unknown quantities Global Trends in Baryon Phases The cosmic gas prior to reionisation is mostly cold, while at later epochs the warm phase becomes dominant as a consequence of enhanced star formation activity and increasing UV reionising radiation Stellar return fractions at these times are ∼ 0.15–0.20, a factor of two lower than the values usually adopted Mass functions and mass density parameters in bound objects increase with cosmic time, closely tracing the overall structure formation process Cold, warm, and hot gas masses as well as HI and H2 components show increasing trends with mass and star formation rate Phase Relations and Environmental Dependence The cold phase dominates the epoch of reionisation, but warm gas is present by z ∼ 20 and increases with time, taking over the cosmic baryon budget at z ≲ 6 The hot gas mass generated during cosmic structure assembly is subdominant, since it traces larger and rarer objects Gas phase masses generally increase with Mstar and SFR and the results in the figure show that the hot component is subdominant by a factor of ∼ 102–103 at all z Warm and cold phases share comparable amounts of mass with slightly more cold gas in smaller systems (Mstar ≲ 107M⊙) Gas Depletion and Star Formation Efficiency Depletion times effectively quantify the timescales needed to transfer mass from the cold HI and H2 phases to the stellar phase and are defined as: tdepl,HI = MHI/SFR and tdepl,H2 = MH2/SFR In Fig.
Vera: 11, median HI (thin symbols) and H2 (thick symbols) depletion times vs Z at different z (coloured symbols) and for the whole z range (solid magenta lines), their behaviour is bracketed by the average trends Typical tdepl,HI and tdepl,H2 decrease with Mstar and SFR and correlate weakly with Z Baryon Cycling Mechanisms Baryon phases are influenced by both the stellar activity – that returns a fraction of stellar mass to the gaseous environment during stellar evolutionary stages (stellar return fraction; R) – and the efficiency with which gas is converted into stars during a typical depletion time (star formation efficiency; SFE) The resulting average trend for R(tage) at z = 5, 12, and 18, fitted as a function of tage as follows: R(tage) = 0.0885 Log tage/3.853 Myr!, if tage > 3.853 Myr and R = 0 otherwise Observational Insights and Model Variations Observation-based µHI, µH2, and Fgas fractions show decreasing trends with cosmic time, Mstar, and SFR, but cannot be considered as fair proxies of the whole galaxy gas content The broad scatter in the gas phases is reflected in the depletion times The sSFR trends we find are in line with observational data (Appendix C); however, caution must be taken when comparing numerical models with observations that may rely on different assumptions about the galaxy main sequence The heterogeneity of theoretical results suggests that current uncertainties or degeneracies are still remarkable, almost two dex (z ≃ 6) or larger (z > 6) Our findings can be summarised as follows: 1.
Jocelyn: Baryon mass density parameters at z > 5 are dominated by gas, both in bound structures (galaxies/CGM) and in the IGM, and bound objects contain only a small fraction of the entire baryonic mass, around 10−6–10−2 2.
Vera: The cold phase dominates the epoch of reionisation, but warm gas is present by z ∼ 20 and increases with time, taking over the cosmic baryon budget at z ≲ 6 3.
Paper summary: Vera: So to summarize "The Baryon Budget of Galaxies across the First Billion Years," these authors are essentially mapping out how gas behaves in galaxies from redshift five up to earlier times. Their main thesis is that understanding these different gas phases—cold, warm, and hot—and their mass budgets helps us grasp the efficiency and timescales of star formation in those early galaxies.
Jocelyn: What they claim is that there’s a shift over time: cold gas dominates early on during reionisation, but by redshift six or lower, the warm phase takes over the whole cosmic baryon budget due to increased star formation and UV radiation.
Subrahmanyan: The results show that while gas phases are quantitatively related to underlying stellar populations, this relationship allows them to infer unknown quantities about the galaxy's evolution.
Vera: They quantify the different gas masses for cold, warm, and hot components and their HI and H2 parts. They find that cold gas masses are increasing with star formation rate.
Jocelyn: The paper also shows how depletion times—how long it takes to move mass from cold neutral or molecular gas into stars—change based on the stellar mass and star formation rate, showing a weak link to cosmic time.
Subrahmanyan: This work matters because it gives us a clearer picture of where the bulk of the matter resides in these early structures, especially since they found that at redshift greater than five, gas dominates both in bound structures and in the intergalactic medium.
Vera: They also show that even though hot gas is present, it’s subdominant when looking at total mass compared to the cold and warm phases.
Conclusion: Jocelyn: So looking at "The Baryon Budget of Galaxies across the First Billion Years," these authors are connecting how gas phases behave over cosmic time to understand star formation timescales. The implication is that we can start using these gas measurements to get a better handle on the unknown parts of galaxy evolution.
Vera: They’re essentially saying that by linking the cold, warm, and hot phases together, we can infer more about how stars actually form and recycle matter in those early cosmic structures.
Subrahmanyan: The core implication is that at high redshifts above five, the gas itself—both inside galaxies and in the space between them—is what’s dominating the total baryonic mass budget.
Jocelyn: So even though galaxies are important, they only contain a small fraction of all baryons in that epoch, around one point zero to two point zero percent.
Vera: And this whole investigation helps constrain how much gas is actually available for stars and what it takes to get those stars formed in those early environments.
Umberto Maio, Céline Péroux
INAF-Italian National Institute of Astrophysics · Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe · European Southern Observatory · Aix Marseille Université, CNRS, Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Marseille
astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.SR, physics.space-ph
Submitted: 2026-02-27
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: Meminisse iuvabit - published in A&A
Journal ref: A&A 708, A244 (2026)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202557624
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 69/100
The gist: The paper investigates the baryon budget of galaxies across cosmic time to understand the efficiency and timescales of star formation in early galaxies The results show that gas phases are…
Key concepts
- Baryon Phases
- These refer to the different states of gas in galaxies, categorized as cold, warm, and hot. The paper shows how the dominance of these phases shifts over cosmic time as star formation activity changes.
- Star Formation Efficiency (SFE)
- This measures how efficiently a galaxy converts its available gas into stars during a typical depletion time. It helps explain the relationship between gas mass, star formation rate, and stellar mass growth.
- Depletion Times
- These are calculated as the ratio of gas mass (like HI or H2) to the star formation rate. They quantify how long it takes for a galaxy to use up its cold gas reservoir to form stars.
Terminology
Summary
The paper investigates the baryon budget of galaxies across cosmic time to understand the efficiency and timescales of star formation in early galaxies The results show that gas phases are quantitatively related to underlying stellar populations and can be used to infer unknown quantities
Global Trends in Baryon Phases
The cosmic gas prior to reionisation is mostly cold, while at later epochs the warm phase becomes dominant as a consequence of enhanced star formation activity and increasing UV reionising radiation Stellar return fractions at these times are ∼ 0.15–0.20, a factor of two lower than the values usually adopted Mass functions and mass density parameters in bound objects increase with cosmic time, closely tracing the overall structure formation process Cold, warm, and hot gas masses as well as HI and H2 components show increasing trends with mass and star formation rate
Phase Relations and Environmental Dependence
The cold phase dominates the epoch of reionisation, but warm gas is present by z ∼ 20 and increases with time, taking over the cosmic baryon budget at z ≲ 6 The hot gas mass generated during cosmic structure assembly is subdominant, since it traces larger and rarer objects Gas phase masses generally increase with Mstar and SFR and the results in the figure show that the hot component is subdominant by a factor of ∼ 102–103 at all z Warm and cold phases share comparable amounts of mass with slightly more cold gas in smaller systems (Mstar ≲ 107M⊙)
Gas Depletion and Star Formation Efficiency
Depletion times effectively quantify the timescales needed to transfer mass from the cold HI and H2 phases to the stellar phase and are defined as: tdepl,HI = MHI/SFR and tdepl,H2 = MH2/SFR In Fig. 11, median HI (thin symbols) and H2 (thick symbols) depletion times vs Z at different z (coloured symbols) and for the whole z range (solid magenta lines), their behaviour is bracketed by the average trends Typical tdepl,HI and tdepl,H2 decrease with Mstar and SFR and correlate weakly with Z
Baryon Cycling Mechanisms
Baryon phases are influenced by both the stellar activity – that returns a fraction of stellar mass to the gaseous environment during stellar evolutionary stages (stellar return fraction; R) – and the efficiency with which gas is converted into stars during a typical depletion time (star formation efficiency; SFE) The resulting average trend for R(tage) at z = 5, 12, and 18, fitted as a function of tage as follows: R(tage) = 0.0885 Log tage/3. p. 6853 Myr!, if tage > 3. p. 1853 Myr and R = 0 otherwise
Observational Insights and Model Variations
Observation-based µHI, µH2, and Fgas fractions show decreasing trends with cosmic time, Mstar, and SFR, but cannot be considered as fair proxies of the whole galaxy gas content The broad scatter in the gas phases is reflected in the depletion times The sSFR trends we find are in line with observational data (Appendix C); however, caution must be taken when comparing numerical models with observations that may rely on different assumptions about the galaxy main sequence The heterogeneity of theoretical results suggests that current uncertainties or degeneracies are still remarkable, almost two dex (z ≃ 6) or larger (z > 6)
Conclusions
Our findings can be summarised as follows:
-
Baryon mass density parameters at z > 5 are dominated by gas, both in bound structures (galaxies/CGM) and in the IGM, and bound objects contain only a small fraction of the entire baryonic mass, around 10−6–10−2
-
The cold phase dominates the epoch of reionisation, but warm gas is present by z ∼ 20 and increases with time, taking over the cosmic baryon budget at z ≲ 6
-
Due to uncertainties in the adopted IMF, the stellar mass density parameter can vary within 0. p. 8
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved simulation accuracy for baryon budget modeling by explicitly tracking
cold, warm, hot, and stellar phases
using nonequilibrium atomic and molecular chemistry to ensure HI and H2 abundances aretraced consistently with metaldependent cooling, heating, and feedback processes during cosmic structure evolution.
-
Enhanced predictive capability for star formation efficiency by providing explicit fit functions describing trends of the gas-to-star fractions, main sequence relations, phase mass relations, and depletion timescales.
-
Refined understanding of stellar return fraction by computing R
self-consistently at different times
rather than relying on IMF-integrated averages, which improves the accuracy for high redshift SFRD estimates. -
Ability to predict the evolution of gas depletion times tdepl,HI and tdepl,H2 as functions of Mstar, gas metallicity Z, and sSFR across a wide range of redshifts.
-
Improved inference on galaxy properties by providing detailed scaling relations for HI and H2 mass fractions (muHI, muH2) versus Mstar using various environmental factors like virial mass and SFR.
Sources
- How much gas and dust is in the z=5.7 Lyman Break Galaxy HZ10? An ALMA Band 10 to 4 and JWST/NIRSpec study of its interstellar medium
- MUSE-ALMA Haloes XIII. Molecular gas in $z \sim 0.5$ HI-selected galaxies
- Cosmic CO and [CII] backgrounds and the fueling of star formation over 12 Gyr
- Infrared fine-structure lines at high redshift
- ALMA Observations of [OI]145um and [NII]205um Emission lines from Star-Forming Galaxies at $z\sim7$
- Mysteries of Capotauro: investigating the puzzling nature of an extreme F356W-dropout
- Neutral hydrogen in and around galaxies during the Epoch of Reionization
- The Initial Mass Function as the Equilibrium State of a Variational Process: why the IMF cannot be sampled stochastically
- Spectral Evolution of Rotating Population III Stars
- The Stellar Populations and Rest-Frame Colors of Star-Forming Galaxies at $z \approx 8$: Exploring the Impact of Filter Choice and Star Formation History Assumption with JADES
- ASKAP discovery of a 30 kpc bipolar outflow from the edge-on disk of the nearby spiral galaxy ESO 130-G012
- Figuring Out Gas & Galaxies In Enzo (FOGGIE) XI: Circumgalactic O VI Emission Traces Clumpy Inflowing Recycled Gas
- A Cosmic Miracle: A Remarkably Luminous Galaxy at $z_{\rm{spec}}=14.44$ Confirmed with JWST
- Unveiling the Ionized and Neutral ISM at z > 10 : The Origin of [O III] /[C II] Ratios from a Sub-parsec Resolution Radiative Transfer Simulation
- The Multi-Scale Multi-Phase Circumgalactic Medium: Observed and Simulated
- The Three Hundred Project: Modeling Baryon and Hot-Gas Fraction Evolution in Simulated Clusters
- REBELS-IFU: Linking damped Lyman-$\alpha$ absorption to [CII] emission and dust content in the EoR
- Deep Constraints on [CII]158$\mu$m in JADES-GS-z14-0: Further Evidence for a Galaxy with Low Gas Content at z=14.2
- A census of star-formation and gas mass tracers in two lensed $z \sim 4$ dusty star-forming galaxies
- Gas excitation of post-starburst galaxies at 0.6 < z < 1.3
Related papers
- The Pristine survey XXVIII. Journey to the Galactic outskirts: Mapping the outer halo red giant stars down to the very metal-poor end
- Origins of Extreme Emission-Line Ratios in z > 3 Galaxies: Insights from the Lumen Model
- The Kinematically Hot, Extremely Metal-Poor C-19 Stellar Stream in DESI DR2
- UV slopes of Starforming Galaxies in Strong Lensing fields at the Epoch of Reionization with JWST
- Evolution of Binaries Under Stochastic Perturbations
- The hydrodynamical response of cold circumgalactic clouds to quasar radiation