Relating the Neural Representations of Vocalized, Mimed, and Imagined Speech

arXiv:2602.22597 · cs.SD, eess.AS, eess.SP · Submitted 2026-02-26 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Relating the Neural Representations of Vocalized, Mimed, and Imagined Speech".

Paper summary: Tom: So to recap, the paper "Relating the Neural Representations of Vocalized, Mimed, and Imagined Speech" investigates if brain signals from vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech share common underlying neural representations. The authors tested this by training linear models to reconstruct spectrograms for each condition and seeing if those models could transfer across conditions.

Jane: They show that when you train a linear decoder on one condition, like Mimed speech, it performs well on both Vocalized and Mimed data, though it struggles more with Imagined speech > Page three of this work reads: "For the Mimed-trained decoder (Gm), performance on Mimed and Vocalized data does not differ significantly (p = zero point six), while both exceed performance on Imagined speech (p much less than zero point zero zero one)."

Lu: They also compared this linear approach to a nonlinear neural network reconstruction, and while the nonlinear model transferred well too, the linear model was better at preserving the specific structure of individual sentences > Page three of this work reads: "However, comparing the linear and nonlinear models demonstrated stronger preservation of stimulus-specific structure in the linear case."

Meng: This is about finding that if you can find these shared representations, it means that a single model trained on one type of speech could potentially be more general than having three separate models > Page one of this work reads: "We demonstrate that linear decoders trained on one condition generally transfer successfully to others, implying shared speech representations <ref:2602.22597#pg1,We demonstrate that linear decoders trained on one condition generally transfer successfully>."

Tom: It implies that the neural activity isn't totally specialized for each speech act; it's sharing some basic components across them > Page one of this work reads: "implying shared speech representations" <ref:2602.22597#pg1>

Jane: So what does this mean practically is that the brain might be using a common set of neural building blocks to handle different ways of producing the same language > Page one of this work reads: "We investigated the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech recorded using publicly available stereotactic EEG recordings <ref:2602.22597#pg1,We investigated the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined>."

Lu: It points toward a hierarchical organization where imagined speech is simpler than vocalized speech because it lacks some components > Page three of this work reads: "The authors hypothesize a hierarchical relationship where imagined speech contains planning-related activity, mimed speech contains planning plus articulatory activity, and vocalized speech contains planning, articulatory, and sensory/feedback-related components."

Meng: If we think about deployment on a production system, finding these shared features could mean we only need to train one core decoder for a broad range of inputs instead of three separate ones > Page one of this work reads: "We investigate the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech recorded using publicly available stereotactic EEG recordings <ref:2602.22597#pg1,the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech recorded>."

Tom: Exactly. The paper is showing that the neural representations are more interconnected than we might have thought across these different speech modalities > Page one of this work reads: "We investigated the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech recorded using publicly available stereotactic EEG recordings <ref:2602.22597#pg1,We investigated the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined>."

Jane: So we're looking at how the brain handles the underlying structure of speech whether it's being spoken aloud or just thought about > Page one of this work reads: "We investigated the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech recorded using publicly available stereotactic EEG recordings <ref:2602.22597#pg1,We investigated the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined>."

Conclusion: Tom: So we've been looking at how the brain represents speech when you vocalize it, when you just mimic someone, and when you're just imagining speaking to yourself. This paper is titled "Relating the Neural Representations of Vocalized, Mimed, and Imagined Speech."

Jane: Right. So basically they trained linear models on each of those three conditions—vocalized, mimed—and imagined speech too—to see if those models could transfer across them. It's a big question about whether the brain uses a single set of rules for all these different ways of using language.

Lu: The core finding is that they show linear decoders trained on one condition generally work well on the others, which strongly suggests there are shared speech representations across those modes. It means the neural activity isn't totally specialized for just speaking out loud or just thinking about it.

Meng: But how do we know this isn't just some random correlation? The authors tested this using rank analysis to see if they could actually tell the difference between the reconstructed sounds, and they found that yes, those specific sentence structures were preserved above chance in both within-condition and across-condition tests.

Tom: That’s important because it moves it beyond just saying "they correlate." It proves that even if you're looking at vocalized speech versus imagined speech, the fundamental structure of the input is still recognizable by a linear system.

Jane: And they did compare this linear approach to a nonlinear neural network reconstruction, and while both models transferred well, the paper showed that the linear model actually preserved that sentence-specific structure better than its nonlinear counterpart.

Lu: That comparison is key because it gives us a reason to trust the linear model for interpretation when we're trying to understand what those brain signals are actually doing. It suggests simplicity can be powerful here.

Meng: For deployment, if you only need one decoder trained on vocalized speech, and it works reasonably well on mimed speech, that cuts down your training time and complexity a lot. That would be a win for scaling things up in real-world applications.

Tom: So the big picture here is that we’re not looking at three completely separate neural systems for speaking; we’re looking at one system with overlapping functional parts, and figuring out which part is which helps us understand the whole picture of how language works in the brain.

Jane: It really makes you wonder what other kinds of brain activity might be shared across these speech types. It opens up a whole new area for researchers to explore what those shared building blocks actually *do*.

Maryam Maghsoudi, Rupesh Chillale, Shihab A. Shamma

University of Maryland - College Park

cs.SD, eess.AS, eess.SP

Submitted: 2026-02-26

Updated: 2026-02-26

Journal ref: Proc. Interspeech 2026, pp. 4785-4789

DOI: 10.21437/Interspeech.2026-2836

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: We investigated how neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech relate by training linear spectrogram reconstruction models for each condition and evaluating their generalization…

Key concepts

Vocalized Speech
This involves producing actual sound through the vocal cords, resulting in an overt acoustic output. It represents the most complete speech process studied, including planning and motor execution.
Mimed Speech
This condition involves planning and executing speech movements without making any audible sound or receiving auditory feedback. It sits between vocalized and imagined speech in terms of motor involvement.
Imagined Speech
This represents internal mental processes for speaking, involving planning and generative activity without any overt motor movement or acoustic output. It reflects the cognitive aspects of speech production.

Terminology

Summary

We investigated how neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech relate by training linear spectrogram reconstruction models for each condition and evaluating their generalization across conditions <ref:2602. p. 022597#pg2> Most prior studies have focused on decoding speech responses within each condition separately <ref:2602. p. 022597#pg2>. We demonstrate that linear decoders trained on one condition generally transfer successfully to others, implying shared speech representations This commonality was assessed with stimulus-level discriminability by performing a rank-based analysis demonstrating preservation of stimulusspecific structure in both within- and across-conditions <ref:2602. p. 022597#pg5>. Finally, linear models achieve superior stimulus-level discriminability when compared to nonlinear neural network reconstructions

Investigating Speech Conditions

The study focuses on the relationship among neural representations of vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech recorded using publicly available stereotactic EEG recordings. The conditions investigated are vocalized speech, which involves overt acoustic output, mimed speech, which involves articulatory planning and motor execution without overt acoustic output or auditory feedback, and imagined speech, which reflects internal generative and planning processes without overt motor movement or acoustic output. p. 0 The authors are specifically interested in neural representation similarities among these three conditions

How the Training Signal is Built

The linear reconstruction model is defined by the equation Sˆ(t, f) = Xc sum l g(c, l, f) X(t − l, c) (1), where g(c, l, f) are the model weights for each channel c, lag l, and frequency f In matrix form this is written as Sˆ = G T Xlag. The solution involves minimizing the Frobenius norm S − G T Xlag2 F + αG2 F (2), where L represents the set of all lags used. p. 1 Transfer functions called Gv, Gm, and Gi are fitted separately for Vocalized, Mimed, and Imagined conditions respectively. p. 1

Where the Gains Come From

Cross-condition evaluation assesses how well decoders transfer across speaking conditions by testing a model trained on one condition on held-out data from the other two Reconstruction performance is quantified using linear correlations between reconstructed and target spectrogram envelopes. For example, for the Mimed-trained decoder (Gm), performance on Mimed and Vocalized data does not differ significantly (p = 0. p. 26), while both exceed performance on Imagined speech (p ≪ 0. p. 2001). The authors hypothesize a hierarchical relationship where imagined speech contains planning-related activity, mimed speech contains planning plus articulatory activity, and vocalized speech contains planning, articulatory, and sensory/feedback-related components. p. 2

Preserving Stimulus Specificity

Sentence-level discriminability is measured by performing rank analysis to compute the AUC above chance for the top-k curves of reconstructed envelopes Sentence-level discriminability is strongest when models are tested on Vocalized responses, with the highest AUC obtained for Gv applied to Xv (AUC = 0.32). The linear model better preserves sentence-specific structure compared to the nonlinear model, as AUC increases with mean reconstruction correlation for both models but the linear model exhibits a steeper relationship. p. 3

Non-linear Model Comparison

The non-linear neural network decoder also shows cross-condition transfer and above-chance discriminability. When trained on Vocalized speech, the model achieves its highest performance on Vocalized responses and remains significantly above null for Mimed and Imagined speech (p ≪ 0. p. 3001). However, comparing the linear and nonlinear models demonstrated stronger preservation of stimulus-specific structure in the linear case. p. 3 The authors conclude that the linear model better preserves sentence-specific structure in this setting. p. 3

Conclusion

We demonstrated that linear decoders can map sEEG responses to acoustic spectrograms during vocalized, mimed, and imagined speech When applied cross-conditionally, these decoders still perform significantly above chance, suggesting that neural responses across speech modes share a common structure. We observed transfer patterns consistent with a hierarchical representational organization where imagined speech engages a subset of processes present in mimed speech, and mimed speech engages a subset of those present in vocalized speech. p. 3 Rank analysis also showed that stimulus-specific discriminability is preserved above chance in the reconstructions. p. 3 We also showed that a nonlinear neural network achieves similar cross-condition transfer and above-chance discriminability. p. 3 However, comparing the linear and nonlinear models demonstrated stronger preservation of stimulus-specific structure in the linear case emphasizing the importance of interpretability when evaluating neural decoding performance. p. 3 The paper is arXiv:2602. p. 0 p. 022597v1 [cs. p. 0 p. 0SD] 26 Feb 2026

Acknowledgements

This work is supported in part by a grant from the Airforce Office of Scientific Research and NIH R01-DC005779 to SAS. The paper is arXiv:2602.22597v1 [cs.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Transfer Learning for Speech Decoding

AI systems can be improved by training linear decoders on one speech condition (e.g., Vocalized) and applying them to decode responses from other conditions (Mimed or Imagined speech). This suggests that linear decoders trained on one condition generally transfer successfully to others, implying shared speech representations.

  1. Subspace Decomposition for Representational Analysis

AI systems can be enhanced by decomposing neural activity into components reflecting different processing stages, such as imagining speech primarily containing internal planning or generative processes (XP). By examining how test-condition activity projects onto the learned subspace defined by a decoder trained on one condition, researchers can assess subspace overlap to determine if cross-condition generalization occurs.

  1. Integrating Interpretability Constraints in Nonlinear Models

When using complex nonlinear neural networks for speech reconstruction, incorporating the findings from linear models can improve system reliability. The paper notes that linear models achieve superior stimulus-level discriminability compared to nonlinear models, suggesting that imposing constraints derived from linear interpretability can yield more robust results in certain decoding tasks.

Sources

Related papers