Energy dependence of cross sections in proton-proton and antiproton-proton collisions
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Energy dependence of cross sections in proton-proton and antiproton-proton collisions".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Energy dependence of global scattering parameters, mostly of total cross section, is studied for proton–proton and antiproton–proton collisions Results are presented for physical analysis updated with taken into account the recent data from accelerator experiments as well as from cosmic ray measurements The analytic parameterizations suggested within Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory (AQFT) provide the quantitative description of energy dependence of global scattering parameters for rather wide energy range Detailed scan on low boundary of the fitting range for energy dependence of global scattering parameters allows the observation of the onsets for regions in which Pomeranchuk theorem and / or Froissart–Martin one is valid It is obtained that global scattering parameters show the behavior corresponded to any formulations of Pomeranchuk theorem and closed to (modified) Froissart–Martin limit in functional sense in multi-TeV energy region Bosonic condensation is considered as one of the possible dynamical mechanisms which would be provide the total cross section approaches to (modified) Froissart–Martin limit at quantitative level but not functionally only.
Kai: Asymptotic Relations and Theoretical Framework The Pomeranchuk theorem relates the difference between pp and antiproton-proton total cross sections tending to zero in the asymptotic region, assuming asymptotically constant cross sections The modified formulation means that the ratio of total cross sections tends to one at infinity, which is proved if σ±t grow with energy.
Mira: The Froissart–Martin theorem sets an upper bound on the total cross section growth, stating that any total cross section cannot grow faster than ln2ε.
Kai: Analytic parameterizations in AQFT describe the energy dependence of global scattering parameters like σ±t and ρ-parameter.
Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap this paper on "Energy dependence of cross sections in proton-proton and antiproton-proton collisions," the authors are studying how these global parameters change as we increase energy.
Mira: The thesis is that analytic parameterizations from Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory can provide a quantitative description for these scattering parameters over a rather wide range of energy.
Lev: They focus on proton-proton and antiproton-proton collisions, specifically looking at the total cross section and the ratio of the real to imaginary part of the forward scattering amplitude, which is called the rho parameter.
Kai: The main claim is that they can see how these parameters behave near the limits defined by both Pomeranchuk theorem and Froissart–Martin theorem.
Mira: They find that for global scattering parameters, this behavior corresponds to any formulation of the Pomeranchuk theorem, and they get close to a modified Froissart–Martin limit in terms of function when we look at high energy.
Lev: The authors also investigate the low boundary of their fitting range for these parameters to see where the onsets are for when those two theorems become valid.
Kai: And what this matters is that they find that global scattering parameters show behavior consistent with any formulation of the Pomeranchuk theorem and close to a modified Froissart–Martin limit in functional sense in the multi-TeV energy region.
Mira: They suggest bosonic condensation as a possible dynamical mechanism for why the total cross section approaches this modified Froissart–Martin limit at a quantitative level, not just functionally.
Lev: So, it sets up this picture where the theory predicts specific scaling behavior that aligns with established asymptotic theorems in a way that requires some new physics to fully explain the quantitative agreement they see.
Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about the title, "Energy dependence of cross sections in proton-proton and antiproton-proton collisions," it’s about mapping out the behavior of these fundamental interactions as we push the energy higher.
Mira: The authors are using AQFT to create a quantitative map for how things like total cross section and the rho parameter evolve across a huge energy scale.
Lev: What this suggests is that in that multi-TeV region, even though we have established theorems like Pomeranchuk, the actual behavior of these cross sections isn't just an abstract math problem anymore.
Kai: It means they are seeing concrete scaling laws that point towards something specific happening dynamically, like bosonic condensation.
Mira: It implies that to truly understand the strong interaction at those extreme energies, we need dynamical models that go beyond simple asymptotic relations and account for these quantitative limits.
Lev: So, the authors are pointing toward needing new physics—something involving condensation—to explain why the observed cross section growth matches these specific mathematical limits so closely.
V. A. Okorokov
National Research Nuclear University MEPhI (Moscow Engineering Physics Institute)
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-02-23
Updated: 2026-09-21
Comments: 9 pages, 4 tables, 2 figures. XXXVII-th International workshop on high energy physics (HEPFT2025). IHEP, Protvino, Russia. July 22-24, 2025
Journal ref: Phys. Part. Nuclei 57, 1449, 2026
DOI: 10.1134/S1063779626702011
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 75/100
The gist: Energy dependence of global scattering parameters, mostly of total cross section, is studied for proton–proton and antiproton–proton collisions Results are presented for physical analysis updated…
Key concepts
- Pomeranchuk theorem
- This theorem relates the total cross sections of proton-proton (pp) and antiproton-proton ($\bar{p}p$) collisions. It suggests that the difference between these two cross sections tends to zero as energy increases, assuming the cross sections remain constant in their asymptotic behavior.
- Froissart–Martin theorem
- This theorem sets an upper limit on how fast a total cross section can grow with energy. It states that no total cross section can increase faster than the natural logarithm of twice the energy ($\ln 2\epsilon$).
- Global scattering parameters
- These are key physical quantities measured in particle collisions, such as the total cross section ($\sigma_{t}$) and the ratio of real to imaginary parts of scattering amplitudes ($ ho$ parameter). The paper analyzes their energy dependence using theoretical frameworks like AQFT.
- Modified Froissart–Martin limit
- This is an extended version of the Froissart–Martin theorem. The study found that global parameters approach this modified limit in a functional sense at multi-TeV energies, indicating a specific high-energy behavior for scattering processes.
Terminology
Summary
Energy dependence of global scattering parameters, mostly of total cross section, is studied for proton–proton and antiproton–proton collisions Results are presented for physical analysis updated with taken into account the recent data from accelerator experiments as well as from cosmic ray measurements The analytic parameterizations suggested within Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory (AQFT) provide the quantitative description of energy dependence of global scattering parameters for rather wide energy range Detailed scan on low boundary of the fitting range for energy dependence of global scattering parameters allows the observation of the onsets for regions in which Pomeranchuk theorem and / or Froissart–Martin one is valid It is obtained that global scattering parameters show the behavior corresponded to any formulations of Pomeranchuk theorem and closed to (modified) Froissart–Martin limit in functional sense in multi-TeV energy region Bosonic condensation is considered as one of the possible dynamical mechanisms which would be provide the total cross section approaches to (modified) Froissart–Martin limit at quantitative level but not functionally only. p. 0
Asymptotic Relations and Theoretical Framework
The Pomeranchuk theorem relates the difference between pp and antiproton-proton total cross sections tending to zero in the asymptotic region, assuming asymptotically constant cross sections The modified formulation means that the ratio of total cross sections tends to one at infinity, which is proved if σ±t grow with energy. The Froissart–Martin theorem sets an upper bound on the total cross section growth, stating that any total cross section cannot grow faster than ln2ε. p. 1 Analytic parameterizations in AQFT describe the energy dependence of global scattering parameters like σ±t and ρ-parameter. p. 1
Experimental Data and Fitting Procedure
The set of global physical quantities under study is G1 = 4 i=1 = 4 i=1 = 4 i=1 = 4 i=1 = total cross section (σt) and the ratio of the real to the imaginary part of the forward scattering amplitude (ρ parameter). The experimental database for G1 is denoted as DB24 while DB24+ incorporates results from STAR [16] and ATLAS [17]. p. 2 The set of free parameters used within AQFT approach P = 9 i=1 = 9 i=1 = 9 i=1 = P can be obtained from the fitting procedures of experimental data. p. 2
Fit Results and Discussion
The numerical results of the simultaneous fits show that suggested approximation functions provide reasonable fit qualities at smallest √smin = 3 GeV and may be at √smin = 1 TeV. The functional behavior of σ±t(s) approaches consecutively and gradually to the modified Froissart–Martin limit with growth of √smin starting with high value √smin,14 = 1 TeV. p. 3 All global scattering parameters considered here reach the modified Froissart–Martin limit at least in functional sense at √s ≥ 5 TeV. p. 5
Conclusion and Future Directions
The large quantitative discrepancy between σ±t and σFM observed here and in previous studies may indicate on the necessity of some novel dynamical mechanisms for pp/pp¯ scattering which could be provide significant increase of total cross sections. It seems that the development and building of new ¯pp collider for study of multi-TeV energy region would be very useful, in particular, for physics of strong interaction processes at large distance and for direct search for the onset of asymptotic region for global scattering parameters. p. 5 The investigation of bosonic condensation will shed new light on the nature of this quantitative discrepancy. p. 5
TABLE I: Relations for AQFT parameters for validity of Pomeranchuk theorem
α+ = α− ≡ αP β+ = β− ≡ βP γ+ = γ− ≡ γP > −6 δ± are finite
γP + 6 ≥ αP β± are finite γ+ = γ− ≡ γP = −6 δ+ = δ− ≡ δP
TABLE II: Values of AQFT parameters for modified Froissart–Martin limit
αFM βFM −γFM δFM
0.0 1.0 6.0 0.0
FIG. 1: The energy dependence for σ+t(a), σ-t(b), ρ+(c), ρ-(d) and results of simultaneous fits of all four parameters by equations (4), (5). p. 7 Solid points are from DB24 and these points are included in the fitted sample, open points are additional for DB24 and they are not included in the fitted data sample (detailed explanation – see in text)
FIG. 2: Dependence on √smin for fit parameters α± (a), β± (b) and γ± (c). p. 3 Open points are for pp, solid ones – for ¯pp. p. 8
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can perform rigorous verification of asymptotic theorems by testing analytic parameterizations such as equation (4) and (5) against experimental data across a wide range of collision energies up to 104 GeV. This allows for the
detailed scan
mentioned in Section III to precisely determine the onsets for regions where Pomeranchuk theorem or Froissart Martin one are valid. -
Improved AI system can quantitatively assess the quantitative discrepancy between total cross sections and their asymptotic limits by incorporating theoretical mechanisms like bosonic condensation into its fitting models. This capability allows the system to move beyond functional agreement and provide physical reasons for the growth of total cross sections at high energies, potentially reaching grand unified theory energy domains.
-
Improved AI system can distinguish between different formulations of asymptotic theorems by analyzing which specific AQFT parameters lead to the validity of each formulation, referencing Table I. This enables the system to provide a more nuanced understanding of when and how Pomeranchuk theorem or Froissart Martin inequality are applicable in various high-energy regimes.
-
Improved AI system can predict the behavior of secondary observables like the rho parameter by using a full set of nine free parameters from equation (5), which accounts for interference terms between pp and antiproton proton scattering. This allows for simultaneous fitting of all global scattering parameters, providing a more complete picture than fitting only total cross sections.
-
Improved AI system can identify the limitations imposed by current experimental data, specifically the
limited data sample for pp collisions
and the "complete absence of such data at sqrt s > 2 TeV" for antiproton proton scattering. This capability allows the system to flag areas where qualitative conclusions are preliminary and emphasize the necessity of future multi-TeV antiproton collider projects.
Sources
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses