Hidden-charm uds,c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model

arXiv:2602.18075 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-02-20 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Hidden-charm uds,c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Hidden-charm uds c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model is investigated using Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) to solve the Schrödinger equation within a non-relativistic constituent quark model, revealing four physically symmetry-constrained J P = 1/2− udscc¯ pentaquark configurations, two of which are compatible with the experimentally favored Pcs(4338) and Pcs(4459) signals.

Kai: Theoretical Framework and Methodology The study employs the non-relativistic constituent quark model Hamiltonian, which includes a Coulomb term for one-gluon exchanges, a linear confining potential, and a hyperfine spin-spin interaction.

Mira: The diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) technique is used to solve the Schrödinger equation in imaginary time.

Kai: The Hamiltonian is defined by H = X 5 i=1 mi + ⃗p 2i 2mi!−P⃗ 2cm 2Mtot + X i<j Vij, where Vij denotes the pairwise interaction between the i and j quarks.

Title and authors: Kai: The title itself tells you a lot about what they're doing—hidden-charm uds c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model. It’s immediately signaling that the focus is on how these five quarks behave when you look at them from the perspective of their flavor symmetry.

Mira: Right, and the authors are M.C. Gordilloa and J.M. Alcaraz-Pelegrina, working out of universities in Spain, specifically Pablo de Olavide and Carlos I Institute in Granada, who are bringing together both theoretical insight and computational methods here at the moment.

Lev: From my side, I'm thinking about what that means for actual computation; they used diffusion Monte Carlo to solve the Schrödinger equation within a non-relativistic constituent quark model. That’s a big step because DMC is powerful for solving these kinds of many-body equations statistically.

Kai: So, it’s not just a simple calculation; it's an attempt to get the actual wave function and its properties, like the mass spectrum and internal structure of these uds c c bar pentaquarks.

Mira: And what they found is that to explain the experimental Pcs(four thousand three hundred thirty-eight) and Pcs(four thousand four hundred fifty-nine) signals, they need to impose a condition where the total wavefunction has to be an eigenvector of the SU three flavor operator <ref:2602.18075#pg1,Pcs(4338) and Pcs(4459>.

Lev: That’s a huge assumption because it dictates how the quarks are arranged in terms of flavor, which directly influences how you calculate the energy levels. If that assumption isn't true, you just get a different picture of what those particles might actually be.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize what this paper is doing—this research uses diffusion Monte Carlo to solve the Schrödinger equation describing uds c c bar pentaquarks inside a non-relativistic constituent quark model. They start by considering states with defined parity, color, spin and isospin that match the J plus P equals one over two minus assignment for one of the candidates.

Mira: And when they add that condition about the SU three flavor operator eigenvector requirement, they obtain two structures that line up with masses extracted from the J plus psi lambda spectrum. They also predict two additional states below the J plus psi lambda threshold but above the eta c lambda one, which aren't expected in that region of mass.

Lev: It’s interesting because it shows how imposing a specific symmetry condition, like SU three flavor symmetry, isn't just an academic exercise; it’s necessary to reproduce two distinct structures compatible with the experimental Pcs signals.

Kai: So what this implies for us listening here is that we can use this model to predict not just one state, but potentially two different structural realizations of these hidden-charm systems based on how you organize the flavor symmetry.

Mira: And structurally, they characterize them by looking at the mean interquark distances. For instance, they find that states Ia and IIa are essentially compact with all separations between quarks being in the range of zero point seven to one femtometer.

Lev: That means we can get a physical picture of what’s happening internally; for example, state Ia looks like a distorted lambda plus cc bar configuration, with the cc bar separation being quite large compared to charmonium.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest that enforcing SU three flavor symmetry is not optional but necessary to reproduce two distinct structures compatible with the experimentally reported Pcs pentaquarks. That’s a significant methodological point they are making here.

Mira: They also highlight how this constraint forces them to consider different dominant correlation patterns within the same multiquark system, rather than just treating them as separate sectors of the Hilbert space.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this suggests that if we want to build a model that matches experimental data, we can't just guess the structure; we have to enforce these fundamental symmetries upfront during the wave function construction.

Kai: And they also point out that if you treat the strange quark as distinguishable and restrict it to a single isospin eigenfunction, you only get one pentaquark state predicted, and its mass around four thousand two hundred MeV falls below the J plus psi lambda threshold.

Mira: So, this comparison shows that treating the flavor sector too loosely misses those other structures entirely; the symmetry enforcement is what reveals them.

Lev: It’s a warning for any future simulations that if you try to find multiple states, you have to be very careful about how you're defining your initial constraints on the spin, color and flavor spaces.

Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up this paper on "Hidden-charm uds c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model", the main conclusion is that enforcing SU three flavor symmetry is necessary to reproduce two distinct structures compatible with the experimental Pcs signals.

Mira: It shows that the different configurations we see in experiments might actually reflect different dominant correlation patterns within the same system, not just completely separate sectors of the Hilbert space.

Lev: I'd add that this work provides a concrete prediction for state Ia and IIa, where they have the same spin, color, and isospin eigenvalues but belong to different flavor states.

Kai: And for those two states—Ia and IIa—their masses are compatible with the experimental Pcs signals within the uncertainties of this model. The remaining two states, Ib and IIb, have masses below the J plus psi lambda threshold but above the eta c lambda one, suggesting they should decay into that channel which hasn't been explored experimentally.

Mira: We need to keep pushing these models because it shows that enforcing SU three flavor symmetry is required to reproduce what we see experimentally in the Pcs pentaquarks.

Lev: So this paper gives us a clearer roadmap for how we can use these constituent quark models to distinguish between possible structures in multiquark systems, which is important for guiding future experimental searches.

Kai: That’s all on this paper today about the hidden-charm uds c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model. Thanks for listening.

M.C. Gordilloa, J.M. Alcaraz-Pelegrina, J. Segovia

Universidad Pablo de Olavide · Universidad de Granada

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-02-20

Updated: 2026-11-09

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 73/100

The gist: Hidden-charm uds c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model is investigated using Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) to solve the Schrödinger equation within a non-relativistic…

Key concepts

Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC)
DMC is a computational technique used to solve the Schrödinger equation for quantum systems by simulating the system evolving in imaginary time. It helps determine ground state properties and wave functions with statistical uncertainties, improving upon simple trial functions.
Constituent Quark Model
This model treats quarks as non-relativistic particles interacting via potentials like Coulomb and linear confinement. It is used here to describe the internal structure of the hidden-charm pentaquark by solving its quantum mechanical equation.
Flavor Eigenstates
Flavor eigenstates refer to different ways the quarks can be arranged in terms of their flavor (udscc̄). The study constructs four specific configurations based on spin, color, and flavor symmetry constraints to see which ones align with experimental observations.

Terminology

Summary

Hidden-charm uds c c pentaquarks as flavor eigenstates in a constituent quark model is investigated using Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) to solve the Schrödinger equation within a non-relativistic constituent quark model, revealing four physically symmetry-constrained J P = 1/2− udscc¯ pentaquark configurations, two of which are compatible with the experimentally favored Pcs(4338) and Pcs(4459) signals. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Segovia a aUniversidad Pablo de Olavide, Departamento de Sistemas Físicos, Químicos y Naturales, E-41089, Dos Hermanas, Sevilla, Spain bUniversidad de Granada, Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Granada, E-18071, Spain Abstract We use a diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) algorithm to solve the Schrödinger equation that describes udscc¯ pentaquarks within the framework of a non-relativistic constituent quark model. We considered only multiquark states with defined values of parity, color, spin and isospin, selected to be compatible with the experimentally favored assignment J P = 1/2− for one of the candidates, and assumed I = 0.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The study employs the non-relativistic constituent quark model Hamiltonian, which includes a Coulomb term for one-gluon exchanges, a linear confining potential, and a hyperfine spin-spin interaction. The diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) technique is used to solve the Schrödinger equation in imaginary time. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Many interpretations consider these states as hadronic molecules near the ΞcD¯(∗) and Ξ ( ′ ,∗) c D¯(∗) thresholds, but other configurations have also been proposed [16, 15, 40, 45, 8]. In this work we use the diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) technique to solve the Schrödinger equation that describes udscc¯ pentaquarks in the framework of a non-relativistic constituent quark model.

The Hamiltonian is defined by H = X 5 i=1 mi + ⃗p 2i 2mi! p. 2
Where the paper says it

4 contains our conclusions. Formalism We chose to describe the udscc¯ pentaquarks by the non-relativistic constituent quark model Hamiltonian: H = X 5 i=1 mi + ⃗p 2 i 2mi !

−P⃗ 2cm 2Mtot + X i<j Vij, where Vij denotes the pairwise interaction between the i and j quarks. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Formalism We chose to describe the udscc¯ pentaquarks by the non-relativistic constituent quark model Hamiltonian: H = X 5 i=1 mi + ⃗p 2 i 2mi ! − P⃗ 2 cm 2Mtot + X i<j Vij , (5) where mi are the constituent quark masses, Pcm is the total center-of-mass momentum, and Vij denotes the pairwise interaction between the i and j quarks.

The interquark interaction is taken as the standard AL1 potential defined in Refs. p. 2
Where the paper says it

− P⃗ 2 cm 2Mtot + X i<j Vij , (5) where mi are the constituent quark masses, Pcm is the total center-of-mass momentum, and Vij denotes the pairwise interaction between the i and j quarks. That interquark interaction was taken to be the standard AL1 potential defined in Refs.

[50, 52].

Wavefunction Construction and Constraints

The trial wave function ΨT (R, α) is constructed as a single state in the full Hilbert space. The spatial part of the trial wave function adopts a Jastrow-type ansatz, ϕT (⃗r1,. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Under this assumption, the spatial part of the trial wave function should depend only on the set of inter-particle distances, what makes it symmetric under permutations of the spatial coordinates. To fulfill this requirement, we adopt the Jastrow-type ansatz, ϕT (⃗r1, .

.., ⃗rn) = Yn j>i=1 exp(−aij rij), which is compatible with the L 2 = 0 construction. p. 4
Where the paper says it

, ⃗rn) = Yn j>i=1 exp(−aij rij ), (12) where the coefficients aij are chosen so as to satisfy the cusp conditions derived from the Coulomb-like part of the interquark interaction for each pair of constituents. This is the function compatible with the L 2 = 0 construction with the lowest number of nodes, that it should produce the lowest masses [33] for the pentaquarks.

The spin sector is constructed by coupling the spins of the five quarks to a desired total spin S = 1/2. p. 4
Where the paper says it

This is the function compatible with the L 2 = 0 construction with the lowest number of nodes, that it should produce the lowest masses [33] for the pentaquarks. The spin sector is constructed by coupling the spins of the five quarks to the desired total spin S = 1/2 to produce the 5 possible (degenerate) spin wavefunctions.

Special care is taken when defining the flavor wave function, as both candidates have been observed with isospin I = 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Special care must be taken when defining the flavor wave function. Both udscc¯ pentaquark candidates, Pcs(4338) and Pcs(4459), have been observed as enhancements in the J/ψ Λ invariant-mass distribution.

The total wavefunction must be colorless, and antisymmetry must be imposed with respect to the exchange of identical quarks using the operator A. p. 5
Where the paper says it

However, not all these functions are admissible, since antisymmetry must be imposed with respect to the exchange of identical quarks, since quarks are fermions. A wavefunction is antisymmetric when it is an eigenvector of the operator: A = 1 Np X Np α=1 (−1)P Pα , (20) applied only to the spin-color-flavor part of wavefunction, since the radial part is symmetrical with respect to the exchange of any quarks.

Predicted Mass Spectrum

The calculated masses for the four symmetry-constrained J P = 1/2− udscc¯ pentaquark configurations are as follows:

  1. M(Ia, F2 = 0) = 4473 ± 5 MeV. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Masses In this section, we present our numerical results of the mass spectrum and internal structure of the possible J P = 1/2 −, I = 0 udscc¯ pentaquarks. The obtained masses are as follows, M(Ia, F2 = 0) = 4473 ± 5 MeV M(Ib, F2 = 3) = 4237 ± 3 MeV M(IIa, F2 = 3) = 4350 ± 6 MeV M(IIb, F2 = 0) = 4245 ± 7 MeV .

  2. M(Ib, F2 = 3) = 4237 ± 3 MeV. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Masses In this section, we present our numerical results of the mass spectrum and internal structure of the possible J P = 1/2 −, I = 0 udscc¯ pentaquarks. The obtained masses are as follows, M(Ia, F2 = 0) = 4473 ± 5 MeV M(Ib, F2 = 3) = 4237 ± 3 MeV M(IIa, F2 = 3) = 4350 ± 6 MeV M(IIb, F2 = 0) = 4245 ± 7 MeV .

  3. M(IIa, F2 = 3) = 4350 ± 6 MeV. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Masses In this section, we present our numerical results of the mass spectrum and internal structure of the possible J P = 1/2 −, I = 0 udscc¯ pentaquarks. The obtained masses are as follows, M(Ia, F2 = 0) = 4473 ± 5 MeV M(Ib, F2 = 3) = 4237 ± 3 MeV M(IIa, F2 = 3) = 4350 ± 6 MeV M(IIb, F2 = 0) = 4245 ± 7 MeV .

  4. M(IIb, F2 = 0) = 4245 ± 7 MeV. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Masses In this section, we present our numerical results of the mass spectrum and internal structure of the possible J P = 1/2 −, I = 0 udscc¯ pentaquarks. The obtained masses are as follows, M(Ia, F2 = 0) = 4473 ± 5 MeV M(Ib, F2 = 3) = 4237 ± 3 MeV M(IIa, F2 = 3) = 4350 ± 6 MeV M(IIb, F2 = 0) = 4245 ± 7 MeV .

Structural Characterization

The mean interquark distances indicate that the Ia and IIa states are essentially compact, with all separations lying in the range ⟨rij⟩ ∼ 0.7–1.0 fm. The Ia pentaquark resembles a distorted Λ + cc¯ configuration, with a significantly enlarged cc¯ separation relative to charmonium. p. 8

Where the paper says it

For comparison, the relevant baryon-meson thresholds obtained with the same AL1 Hamiltonian using DMC are: ηc + Λ : 4161 MeV J/ψ + Λ : 4257 MeV which have been determined by calculating within the same theoretical framework the masses of the light (uds)-baryon with I = 0, J = 1/2 + (Λ-like configuration): M(Λ) = 1156 ± 2 MeV to be compared with M(Λ) = 1154 MeV of Ref. For the lowest s-wave charmonium states, we have [26].

Conversely, the IIa pentaquark is structurally closer to a compact qqc+q′c¯ arrangement with the baryon + meson very close to each other. p. 9
Where the paper says it

In the Ia and IIa cases, the mean distances reported indicate that both states are essentially compact: all separations lie in the range ⟨rij ⟩ ∼ 0. 0 fm, with no evidence for a large baryon–meson separation as expected in a loosely bound molecular configuration.

The Ib and IIb structures resemble in both cases a baryon + cc¯ meson whose constituents are fairly separated from each other. p. 9
Where the paper says it

We also give the same values for structures Ib and IIb for the sake of comparison. In the Ia and IIa cases, the mean distances reported indicate that both states are essentially compact: all separations lie in the range ⟨rij ⟩ ∼ 0.

Conclusion on Experimental Compatibility

The states Ia and IIa have the same set of spin, color, and isospin eigenvalues but belong to different flavor states, and their masses are compatible with the experimental Pcs signals within the model's uncertainties. The remaining two states (Ib and IIb) have masses below the J/ψ Λ threshold but above the ηc Λ one, suggesting they should predominantly decay into that channel, which has not been experimentally explored. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Therefore, pentaquark Ia lies above the J/ψ Λ threshold and can decay into this experimentally observed channel. In contrast, pentaquark Ib lies below J/ψ Λ but above ηc Λ, implying that it should predominantly decay by that channel.

Enforcing SU(3) flavor symmetry is necessary to reproduce two distinct structures compatible with the experimentally reported Pcs pentaquarks. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This demonstrates that enforcing SU(3) flavor symmetry is not optional but necessary to reproduce the experimental spectrum, something that previous literature do not consider explicitly. Internal structure To characterize the spatial structure of the pentaquarks that have been identified as possible candidates to be assigned to the Pcs(4459) and Pcs(4338) signals, we provide the mean interquark distances ⟨rij ⟩ (in fm) in Tables 1 and 2, respectively.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The calculation has been performed by constructing trial wavefunctions with well-defined quantum numbers in the spin, color and flavor (not only isospin) spaces. The combination of flavor eigenvectors with the full colorless and S = 1/2 spin functions yields four physically symmetry-constrained J P = 1/2− udscc¯ pentaquark configurations. p. 8

Where the paper says it

To obtain those two candidates for the two experimental pentaquarks, we have to consider eigenfunctions of the flavor (not only isospin) operator. If we break the flavor symmetry at the level of the wavefunction, we end up with a single I = 0 configuration: χf2 = 1 √ 2 (uds − dus) what produces a single family of functions: 3 (colorless) × 5 (S = 1/2) × 1 (I = 0) = 15 functions, that are not eigenvectors of the full flavor operator.

The existence of two structures in the experimental mass region may reflect different dominant correlation patterns in the same multiquark system, rather than distinct sectors of the Hilbert space. p. 6
Where the paper says it

These constructions do not define orthogonal sectors of the full Hilbert space, but rather alternative descriptions of correlations within the system, analogous to the cluster configurations commonly explored in multiquark studies. In particular, we analyze the following two realizations: • A first construction in which the three light quarks are treated on equal footing and full antisymmetry under their exchange is imposed.

How the training signal is built

The flavor wave function is constructed by linear combinations of three functions with eigenvalue F2 = 0 and two functions with eigenvalue F2 = 3. These linear spin-color-flavor combinations are multiplied by the spatial part given by Eq. p. 5

Where the paper says it

(18) Those two functions are the same as the corresponding to the Λ baryon [6], and have, by construction an isospin I = 0. Taking everything into account, the pentaquark system allows for two independent families of states with definite quantum numbers: 3 (colorless) × 5 (S = 1/2) × 1 (F 2 = 0, I = 0) = 15 functions, 3 (colorless) × 5 (S = 1/2) × 2 (F 2 = 3, I = 0) = 30 functions from which we have to produced linear combinations that will have to be multiplied by the spatial part given by Eq.

12 to build the total trial function defined by Eq. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Taking everything into account, the pentaquark system allows for two independent families of states with definite quantum numbers: 3 (colorless) × 5 (S = 1/2) × 1 (F 2 = 0, I = 0) = 15 functions, 3 (colorless) × 5 (S = 1/2) × 2 (F 2 = 3, I = 0) = 30 functions from which we have to produced linear combinations that will have to be multiplied by the spatial part given by Eq. 12 to build the total trial function defined by Eq.

10. The final set of four states arises from combining these flavor eigenvectors with the full colorless and S = 1/2 spin functions. p. 8
Where the paper says it

To obtain those two candidates for the two experimental pentaquarks, we have to consider eigenfunctions of the flavor (not only isospin) operator. If we break the flavor symmetry at the level of the wavefunction, we end up with a single I = 0 configuration: χf2 = 1 √ 2 (uds − dus) what produces a single family of functions: 3 (colorless) × 5 (S = 1/2) × 1 (I = 0) = 15 functions, that are not eigenvectors of the full flavor operator.

Where the gains come from

The necessity to reproduce two distinct structures compatible with the experimentally reported Pcs pentaquarks implies that enforcing SU(3) flavor symmetry is not optional but necessary. The prediction of a single state (pentaquark III) below the J/ψ Λ threshold demonstrates that this symmetry enforcement is required to reproduce the experimental spectrum. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Consequently, it cannot be the one observed in the experimental analyses. This demonstrates that enforcing SU(3) flavor symmetry is not optional but necessary to reproduce the experimental spectrum, something that previous literature do not consider explicitly.

If instead of considering the full I = 0 flavor subspace, the strange quark is treated as distinguishable and the flavor sector is restricted to a single isospin eigenfunction, only one pentaquark state is obtained. Its predicted mass, MIII = 4200 ± 4 MeV lies below the J/ψ Λ threshold, and therefore it cannot be assigned to any of the observed structures. p. 9

Where the paper says it

We predict its mass to be: M(III) = 4200 ± 4 MeV This state lies below the J/ψ Λ threshold and therefore cannot decay into this channel. Consequently, it cannot be the one observed in the experimental analyses.

This implies that s necessary to reproduce two distinct structures compatible with the experimentally reported Pcs pentaquarks. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This demonstrates that enforcing SU(3) flavor symmetry is not optional but necessary to reproduce the experimental spectrum, something that previous literature do not consider explicitly. Internal structure To characterize the spatial structure of the pentaquarks that have been identified as possible candidates to be assigned to the Pcs(4459) and Pcs(4338) signals, we provide the mean interquark distances ⟨rij ⟩ (in fm) in Tables 1 and 2, respectively.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform ab initio calculations for multiquark systems by utilizing diffusion Monte Carlo to solve Schrödinger equation within a non-relativistic constituent quark model framework. This allows for obtaining ground state wave functions and their properties with statistical uncertainties, correcting shortcomings of trial functions if they share the same nodal surface as the exact solution.

  2. Improved AI can accurately predict and distinguish between different structural realizations of pentaquarks by constructing four physically symmetry constrained J P 1/2- uds cc-bar configurations based on spin, color, and flavor eigenvectors. This capability allows for distinguishing states like Ia and IIa, which arise from different symmetry constrained constructions of the wave function.

  3. Improved AI can perform structural characterization of predicted pentaquark states by calculating mean interquark distances for various configurations in Table 1 and Table 2. This enables the identification of whether a state resembles a distorted Lambda plus cc-bar configuration or a compact qqc plus q'c-bar arrangement.

Abstract

We use a diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) algorithm to solve the Schrödinger equation describing udsc c pentaquarks within a non-relativistic constituent quark model. We consider multiquark states with well-defined parity, color, spin and isospin quantum numbers, consistent with the experimentally favored assignment J P = 1/2- for one of the observed candidates, and impose I = 0. We find that, in order to reproduce the presence of multiple structures in the experimental mass region, the total wavefunction must also be an eigenstate of the SU(3) flavor operator. Under this condition, two structures emerge with masses lying in the same region as the experimentally observed signals in the J/ψ,Λ spectrum. In addition, two states are predicted below the J/ψ,Λ threshold but above the η c,Λ one, which would not contribute to that channel. If only the I = 0 condition is imposed, a single structure is obtained, with a mass below the J/ψ,Λ threshold.

Sources

Related papers