Spectral Spacetime Entropy for Quasifree Theories
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Spectral Spacetime Entropy for Quasifree Theories".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Spectral Spacetime Entropy for Quasifree Theories presents a spectral method for calculating the entropy of quasifree states in spacetime, enabling covariant regularisation and application in generic spacetime regions.
Kai: This construction is defined in spacetime rather than on a hypersurface, enabling the covariant regularisation of entropies.
Mira: Spacetime Formulation and Covariance The paper introduces a spectral formulation of entanglement entropy suitable for quasifree quantum field theories in spacetime, which is contrasted with the common spatial treatment.
Kai: This formulation is particularly apt in the context of semiclassical and quantum gravity and in connection to black hole entropy.
Title and authors: Kai: So, let's talk about the paper's title, "Spectral Spacetime Entropy for Quasifree Theories." It sounds a bit technical, but it’s about finding a spectral method for calculating entropy in spacetime.
Mira: Yeah, exactly. The authors are Jones and Yazdia, and they are motivated by the need to UV-regularize entanglement entropy by defining this construction directly in spacetime rather than on a smooth hypersurface.
Lev: From an error correction point of view, that means we're dealing with a formalism that is inherently frame independent because it’s defined across spacetime itself.
Kai: That’s the core idea here. They show they can calculate this entropy for both bosonic and fermionic field theories using this spectral method, which is quite general.
Mira: And they highlight how this spacetime nature makes it particularly apt for the context of semiclassical gravity and black hole entropy because that connection usually demands a frame independent regularization method.
Lev: I wonder how robust this is when we try to apply it to things like causal set theory, which is where the authors show their application in settings without a standard Cauchy surface.
Kai: That’s what they do, and they find that even in one plus one dimensions within a causal set, they get a slightly modified entanglement entropy scaling coefficient.
Mira: That coefficient is important because it might be seen as a possible signature of spacetime discreteness, which is something we're always trying to look for in these approaches.
Lev: I’m thinking about the application there because if this scaling holds, it could give us some concrete evidence about how discrete spacetime affects entanglement entropy.
Kai: They also mention they can use a covariant spacetime ultraviolet cutoff based on a minimum spacetime volume, which is physically sensible for gravitational settings.
Mira: That seems like a good way to regularize the infinite entanglement entropy that usually plagues these calculations in curved backgrounds, because it’s derived from the geometry itself.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, having a covariant cutoff is crucial because you need something unambiguous when you are trying to relate this to frame independent concepts like Bekenstein-Hawking entropy.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, summarizing the paper, it’s about presenting a spectral method for calculating the entropy of quasifree states in spacetime that works for both bosonic and fermionic field theories.
Mira: The key thing is they define this construction in spacetime itself, which enables covariant regularization of entropies and lets them calculate it in generic spacetime regions.
Lev: They derive formulae for bosonic entropy by summing individual mode entropies from a geometric series expansion of the two-point function, which is a specific way to handle the bosonic case.
Kai: And for fermions, they use a spectral approach to get their entropy by summing over the spectrum of generalized eigenvalues derived from that same approach.
Mira: They also connect these results back to the density matrix and its eigenvalues, which is interesting because it shows how this spectral method relates directly to the properties of the density matrix itself.
Lev: That connection is useful because it’s a way to see how this entropy calculation ties into the underlying quantum mechanics of those fields.
Kai: So in short, they provide these derivations which have appeared before but highlight certain aspects, especially their connection to the density matrix structure.
Mira: They emphasize that the spacetime nature of this formulation is what makes it particularly useful in semiclassical and quantum gravity because it allows them to relate it to black hole entropy.
Lev: And they also mention how the formalism is applied where there is no Cauchy surface, like in causal set theory approaches.
Kai: It really shows that this method can be used across different theoretical frameworks, which is a nice feature.
The paper's improvements: Kai: Now for the improvements they suggest, they point out that the main thing is using this spectral formulation to regularize otherwise infinite entanglement entropy.
Mira: They emphasize that this definition enables the use of a covariant spacetime volume-based cutoff to regularize those infinities, which is physically desirable in gravitational settings.
Lev: And they show how it handles non-diagonalized density matrices better than standard methods, which is useful when you’re not starting with an already diagonal density matrix.
Kai: They also mention that the results follow a logarithmic scaling with the cutoff, but this scaling coefficient is slightly larger than what you get from similar continuum calculations.
Mira: That slight difference in the coefficient is a concrete observation that suggests a genuine distinction between the continuum and causal set theories.
Lev: And they also discuss how truncating certain contributions from small eigenvalues might remove degrees of freedom that have an entirely nonlocal nature, which is something we need to be careful about in discrete settings.
Kai: So they are suggesting this method is useful for numerical calculations where the density matrix isn't already diagonalized because it’s flexible.
Mira: It's a flexible tool because it lets you work with a covariant cutoff, and that’s essential for making statements about horizon entropy unambiguously.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up the paper "Spectral Spacetime Entropy for Quasifree Theories," the main message is that this spacetime formulation gives us a favorable framework for quantum gravity questions.
Mira: It enables the use of a covariant spacetime volume-based cutoff to regularize the otherwise infinite entanglement entropy, which is what we need for horizon entropy studies.
Lev: And it encourages a transition towards a more covariant approach to quantum field theory where degrees of freedom are understood over regions of spacetime, which is natural in quantum gravity.
Kai: This work has brought out interesting similarities and differences between bosonic and fermionic theories that you can see in the derivations.
Mira: The ability to work with a covariant cutoff is essential for making statements about horizon entropy unambiguously because it respects the spacetime geometry.
Lev: And this formulation can be applied in general spacetimes, whether it's a black hole or a cosmological spacetime, and that’s really important for testing different scenarios.
Joshua Y. L. Jonesa, Yasaman K. Yazdia
Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies · Trinity College
hep-th, cond-mat.stat-mech, gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-02-18
Updated: 2026-09-29
Comments: 49 pages, 3 figures. Accepted version. Reorganised, with clarification added
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: Spectral Spacetime Entropy for Quasifree Theories presents a spectral method for calculating the entropy of quasifree states in spacetime…
Key concepts
- Spacetime Formulation
- This method defines entanglement entropy based on the geometry of spacetime itself rather than relying on a fixed spatial slice. This makes the calculation inherently covariant, meaning it is independent of how you choose to slice or observe spacetime, which is essential for theories like quantum gravity.
- Covariant Regularization
- Because the entropy is formulated in spacetime, it can be regularized using a cutoff based on physical quantities like minimum spacetime volume. This provides a physically meaningful and frame-independent way to handle potentially infinite entanglement entropy in curved or discrete spacetimes.
- Causal Set Theory Application
- The formalism is successfully applied to causal set theory, where no standard Cauchy surface exists. In 1+1 dimensions, this yielded a modified scaling coefficient for entanglement entropy that could potentially signal the fundamental discreteness of spacetime.
- Sorkin-Johnston State
- This is a specific spectral, covariant vacuum state considered in the context of causal sets. Using this state allows the formalism to model canonical vacuum conditions within discrete spacetime models, providing a framework for studying horizon entropy.
Terminology
Summary
Spectral Spacetime Entropy for Quasifree Theories presents a spectral method for calculating the entropy of quasifree states in spacetime, enabling covariant regularisation and application in generic spacetime regions. p. 0 This construction is defined in spacetime rather than on a hypersurface, enabling the covariant regularisation of entropies. p. 0
Spacetime Formulation and Covariance
The paper introduces a spectral formulation of entanglement entropy suitable for quasifree quantum field theories in spacetime, which is contrasted with the common spatial treatment. This formulation is particularly apt in the context of semiclassical and quantum gravity and in connection to black hole entropy. p. 0 The spacetime nature of the formulation makes it particularly apt in the context of semiclassical and quantum gravity and in connection to black hole entropy. p. 0 It is clear that a more physical regularisation of entanglement entropy, if one wishes to relate it to the frame independent Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, must be a covariant one, regulated in a way that is unambiguous and frame independent. p. 3
Entropy Calculation in Discrete Settings
The paper demonstrates the application of the formalism to settings where no notion of a Cauchy surface exists, such as in causal set theory approach to quantum gravity. In a causal set in 1 + 1 dimensions, the authors obtain a novel result of a slightly modified entanglement entropy scaling coefficient, giving a possible signature of spacetime discreteness. p. 0 The method allows for the use of a covariant spacetime ultraviolet cutoff (such as one in terms of a minimum spacetime volume) which is physically desirable in gravitational settings. p. 3
Bosonic and Fermionic Entropy Derivations
The authors derive formulae for bosonic and fermionic entropy in sections 3 and 4 respectively, using Hilbert space language. For bosonic theories, the total entropy is calculated as a sum of individual mode entropies derived from the geometric series expansion of the two-point function. p. 9 Similarly, for fermionic theories, the entropy is obtained by summing over the spectrum of generalized eigenvalues derived from a spectral approach. p. 0
Significance and Applications
The spacetime nature of this entropy formulation provides a favourable framework for questions concerning (quantum) gravity, such as the relationship between entanglement entropy and the microscopic origin of horizon entropy. p. 2 This definition enables the use of a covariant spacetime volume-based cutoff to regularise otherwise infinite entanglement entropy. p. 0 The formalism is also useful in numerical calculations and when the density matrix is not already diagonalised. p. 7 The paper shows that the results follow a logarithmic scaling with the cutoff, with a coefficient slightly larger than what is obtained from similar continuum calculations, suggesting a genuine difference between the continuum and causal set. p. 0 The spacetime nature of the SJ state makes it particularly suited to causal sets, wherein it assumes the status of canonical vacuum. p. 0 This formulation marks a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy. p. 2
Thermal Entropy Calculations
The paper includes example applications of thermal entropy calculations in Minkowski spacetime for both real scalar and Dirac fermion fields, verifying that the formulae reproduce known results. For a massless scalar field in 1 + 1d Minkowski spacetime, the entropy density is calculated to be in agreement with literature [49]. p. 0 For a massless Dirac field in R(3,1), the thermal entropy density is shown to be in agreement with the literature [49]. p. 9 The spectral formulation allows for an algebraic derivation of the entropy, which is equivalent to the result obtained via a generalized eigenvalue problem. p. 3 The results obtained in the causal set calculation follow a logarithmic scaling with the cutoff, with a coefficient that is slightly larger than what is obtained from similar continuum calculations. p. 0
Conclusion
The spacetime nature of this entropy formulation provides a favourable framework for questions concerning (quantum) gravity, such as the relationship between entanglement entropy and the microscopic origin of horizon entropy. This definition of entropy enables the use of a covariant spacetime volume-based cutoff to regularise the otherwise infinite entanglement entropy. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 The formalism encourages a transition towards a more covariant approach to quantum field theory, whereby degrees of freedom are understood as existing over regions of spacetime, as is natural in a theory of quantum gravity. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 This work has brought out some interesting similarities and differences between bosonic and fermionic theories. p. 5 The ability to work with a covariant cutoff is essential to unambiguously make statements about horizon entropy. This formulation can be applied in general spacetimes such as black hole (with different dimensions, mass, etc. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0) and cosmological (with different energy contents, asymptotics, etc. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1) spacetimes. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 The work is a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2
Appendix A and B
In Appendix A, the authors show how one can use the spacetime entropy definition to calculate the thermal entropy of a scalar and fermionic field in (3+1)-dimensional Minkowski spacetime and obtained the expected answers, verifying that the formulae reproduce known results. Appendix B discusses the Sorkin-Johnston state, which is a spectral, covariant and distinguished vacuum state that takes into consideration the full spacetime. p. 4 The fermionic SJ prescription requires a slightly different treatment than its bosonic counterpart. p. 4
Appendix C and D
Appendix C provides an alternative, more algebraic derivation of the entropy for a scalar field theory and a Majorana field theory in a region of spacetime. Appendix D discusses modifications to K and ∆ in a discrete setting, speculating about the source of the eigenfunctions with small eigenvalues observed and truncated in Section 5. p. 1 The authors speculate that these contributions may be due to fluctuations tied to the single sprinkling realisations we work with. p. 6 The ability to work with a covariant cutoff is essential to unambiguously make statements about horizon entropy. The authors suggest that the truncation procedure may remove degrees of freedom that have an entirely nonlocal nature. p. 2
References
The paper cites numerous works related to quantum gravity, entanglement entropy, and causal set theory. These references support the claims made in the paper. p. 2 The work is a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy.
Thermal Entropy Calculations in the Continuum
In Appendix A, the authors show two examples that serve as a proof of concept that the formulae presented in Sections 3 and 4 reproduce known results. These examples are: the thermal entropy of a real scalar and Dirac fermion field in (3+1)-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. p. 1 p. 1 The results of our simulations follow a logarithmic scaling in the cutoff with a coefficient that was slightly larger than what is obtained from similar continuum calculations. p. 0 p. 0
Final Remarks
The spacetime nature of this entropy formulation provides a favourable framework for questions concerning (quantum) gravity, such as the relationship between entanglement entropy and the microscopic origin of horizon entropy. This definition of entropy enables the use of a covariant spacetime volume-based cutoff to regularise the otherwise infinite entanglement entropy. The formalism encourages a transition towards a more covariant approach to quantum field theory, whereby degrees of freedom are understood as existing over regions of spacetime, as is natural in a theory of quantum gravity. This work is a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 The ability to work with a covariant cutoff is essential to unambiguously make statements about horizon entropy. This formulation can be applied in general spacetimes such as black hole (with different dimensions, mass, etc.) and cosmological (with different energy contents, asymptotics, etc.) spacetimes. This work is a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy.
Acknowledgments
This work was conducted with the support of Research Ireland under grant number 22/PATHS/10704. The work is a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy.
A Thermal Entropy Calculations in the Continuum
In Appendix A, the authors show two examples that serve as a proof of concept that the formulae presented in Sections 3 and 4 reproduce known results. These examples are: the thermal entropy of a real scalar and Dirac fermion field in (3+1)-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. The results of our simulations follow a logarithmic scaling in the cutoff with a coefficient that was slightly larger than what is obtained from similar continuum calculations.
The spacetime nature of this entropy formulation provides a favourable framework for questions concerning (quantum) gravity, such as the relationship between entanglement entropy and the microscopic origin of horizon entropy. This definition of entropy enables the use of a covariant spacetime volume-based cutoff to regularise the otherwise infinite entanglement entropy. The formalism encourages a transition towards a more covariant approach to quantum field theory, whereby degrees of freedom are understood as existing over regions of spacetime, as is natural in a theory of quantum gravity. This work is a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy. The ability to work with a covariant cutoff is essential to unambiguously make statements about horizon entropy. This formulation can be applied in general spacetimes such as black hole (with different dimensions, mass, etc.) and cosmological (with different energy contents, asymptotics, etc.) spacetimes. This work is a significant step towards understanding the microscopic degrees of freedom that characterise horizon entropy. The ability to work with a covariant cutoff is essential to unambiguously make statements about horizon entropy. The spacetime nature of this entropy formulation provides a favourable framework for questions concerning (quantum) gravity, such as the relationship between entanglement entropy and the microscopic origin of horizon entropy.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Implement a spectral method for calculating entanglement entropy of quasifree states in spacetime, enabling covariant regularisation in generic spacetime regions. This allows AI systems to calculate entropies in settings where a smooth background is inadequate, such as causal set theory approaches to quantum gravity.
-
Develop an AI capable of deriving the formulae for bosonic and fermionic spectral spacetime entropy from the density matrix eigenvalues, highlighting their connection to density matrices and their role in semiclassical and quantum gravity contexts. This capability supports understanding the microscopic nature of black hole entropy.
-
Create a system that can perform calculations in discrete settings, such as causal sets approximated by Rindler wedges in 1 + 1 dimensions, resulting in novel results regarding entanglement entropy scaling coefficients that might serve as signatures of spacetime discreteness.
-
Enhance the AI to handle the Sorkin-Johnston state and its applications across bosonic and fermionic theories, allowing it to utilize this spectral, covariant vacuum state for studying spacetime entropy in causal sets. This improves the system's ability to model canonical vacuum states in discrete spacetimes.
-
Integrate a mechanism for spectrum truncation within the AI's calculations to remove degrees of freedom with small eigenvalues observed in causal set spectra, thereby addressing residual non-continuumlike contributions and ensuring finite entanglement entropy results.
Sources
- The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
- Data Tables for Lorentz and CPT Violation
- 1983 paper on entanglement entropy: "On the Entropy of the Vacuum outside a Horizon"
- Entanglement entropy of black holes
- Black hole entropy from graviton entanglement
- Expressing entropy globally in terms of (4D) field-correlations
- Colloquium: Majorana Fermions in nuclear, particle and solid-state physics
- Entanglement Hamiltonians: from field theory, to lattice models and experiments
- Recovering General Relativity from a Planck scale discrete theory of quantum gravity
- Measuring spatial distances in causal sets via causal overlaps
- The Scalar Curvature of a Causal Set
- On the Causal Set-Continuum Correspondence
- Spacetime reconstruction by order and number
- The causal set approach to quantum gravity
- Spacetime Entanglement Entropy in 1+1 Dimensions
- Entanglement Entropy in Causal Set Theory
- Entanglement Entropy of Disjoint Spacetime Intervals in Causal Set Theory
- Insights on Entanglement Entropy in $1+1$ Dimensional Causal Sets
- Entanglement Entropy of Causal Set de Sitter Horizons
- Spacetime Entanglement Entropy of de Sitter and Black Hole Horizons
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions