Band splitting in the altermagnet CrSb
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Band splitting in the altermagnet CrSb".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Band splitting in the altermagnet CrSb is established using magnetic groups formalism that allows to find the additional spin splitting missed in frame of exchange approximation The problem of electron band splitting should be discussed based on crystal symmetry of concrete altermagnet material Formal Approach Limitations The initial description of the momentum dependent spin splitting of electron bands in altermagnets was based on the spin groups approach, which is valid when relativistic interactions are neglected Then the spin-orbit coupling has been taken into account with time-reversal-odd, even-parity irreducible representations of centrosymmetric point groups considered by R.M.Fernandes et al Here we show inadequacy of this formal approach The band spin-splitting in hexagonal altermagnet CrSb is established using magnetic groups formalism that allows to find the additional spin splitting missed in frame of exchange approximation Symmetry Analysis of CrSb CrSb crystallizes as a hexagonal NiAs-type structure in the centrosymmetric non-symmorphic space group P63/mmc (N194) The symmetry group of paramagnetic state consists of the same elements as (1) but rotations with odd numbers n = 2k + 1, k = 0, 1, 2 are accompanied by a shift t on half period of crystal cell along the hexagonal axis In the ordered state (see Fig 1.) each improper rotation containing the shift t should be accompanied by time inversion R (as it should be in altermagnet state) and magnetic group of symmetry is Ga = Da6 ×I, Da6 = Band Structure Description According to spin-group symmetry approach spin part of energy dispersion γk is the product of scalar function of momentum corresponding to one of irreducible representations of symmetry group of paramagnetic state (8) and axial vector ˆz along hexagonal axis which is invariant in respect to symmetry operations acting only on magnetic moments that is on arrows in Fig.1 For B1g representations the corresponding vector function is γBk = bkzkx(k 2x − 3k 2y)ˆz Taking into account that time inversion changes the sign k-vector components and axial vectors ˆx, y, ˆz it is easy to check that the vector function γA k = c1(k 2x − k 2y)ˆx − 2kxkyyˆ + c2kzkx(k 2x − 3k 2y)ˆz The diagonalization of the matrix (3) results in band dispersion laws ε±(k) = εk ± γk Piezomagnetic Properties The symmetry of altermagnet CrSb allows piezomagnetic effect The thermodynamic potential invariant in respect all operation group Ga is Φ = −λ
(σxx − σyy)Hx − 2σxyHy: This leads to the magnetization My = λ(σxx − σyy) (16) and deformation arising under external field is uxx = λHx Hidden Altermagnetism Another interesting situation takes place in so called hidden altermagnets
32, 33: These type materials do not possess symmetry in respect to space inversion I and time inversion R = −iσˆyK but are symmetric in respect to the product IR of these operations known as toroid symmetry In case of toroid symmetry the Kramers theorem is valid that is to each band energy εk corresponds two mutually orthogonal spinor Bloch functions ψkα(r) and ϕkα(r) = −iσy αβKIψkβ(r) This means that to each spin density S↑ in the point r corresponds the opposite directed density of spin S↓ in the point −r such that the total magnetisation ˆd3r (S↑(r) + S↓(r)) = 0 The developed approach allows to establish the band splitting in the altermagnetic metal CrSb Along with the standard description of momentum dependent electron band spin splitting in altermagnets based on spingroup formalism valid in exchange approximation there was found an additional contribution to electron band splitting corresponding to actual crystal symmetry of antiferromagnet CrSb Additional momentum dependent spin-splitting in basal plane hardly distinguishable in quantum oscillation measurements but certainly can be revealed in neutron scattering experiments and by ARPES technic The structure of additional terms in band structure missed in exchange approximation corresponds to structure of piezomagnetic thermodynamic potential determining piezomagnetic properties of CrSb altermagnet At the end there was considered the phenomenon of hidden altermagnetism taking place in compounds with toroid symmetry The spin-splitting on these planes is recreated by spin-orbit coupling according to Eq.
Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper, "Band splitting in the altermagnet CrSb". Basically, they are tackling how electron bands split in these materials. Mira They start by saying the initial way to describe this was using spin groups when you ignore relativistic effects. Kai But they point out that that approach isn't enough because it misses some of the spin splitting that actually happens when you consider time-reversal-odd and even-parity representations in centrosymmetric point groups.
Lev: So, they are suggesting we need to look at the crystal symmetry of the concrete altermagnet material itself to get a better picture than just using those simpler group theories ten <ref:2602.15131#pg1>. Kai That means they're moving away from the spin groups approach for this specific case because it's inadequate.
Mira: Exactly. In their work on hexagonal CrSb, they establish the band spin-splitting using magnetic groups formalism, which lets them find that extra splitting that you miss when you only use the exchange approximation <ref:2602.15131#pg1>. Lev So, what's the big deal for us in terms of real hardware? If we try to model this on a real system, how much overhead does this symmetry analysis add?
Kai: Well, they show that the band dispersion laws are epsilon plus or minus a term that depends on this vector function gamma k <ref:2602.15131#pg3>. Mira And they find something specific for the B one g representations, which is gamma B k being related to k squared terms in x and y directions along the z axis <ref:2602.15131#pg3>.
Lev: If we have to run this on actual hardware, that means we're dealing with momentum dependent splitting where the axial vector is fixed along the hexagonal axis, which is invariant under certain symmetry operations <ref:2602.15131#pg3>. Kai It sounds like a lot of geometric constraints are being imposed on the spin part of the energy dispersion gamma k based on how time reversal acts in this material.
Mira: And they show that when you take into account time reversal, the vector function for some representations, like gamma A k, has terms involving both x and y directions along with z <ref:2602.15131#pg3>. Lev So what does that tell us about the actual physics we need to simulate? Does it require a more complex Hamiltonian than we're currently using for these materials?
Kai: It suggests that the simple picture of just momentum dependent z-component splitting isn't complete; there are other components they find. Mira And they link this to piezomagnetic properties, which is interesting because it connects the electronic structure directly to how the material deforms under an external field <ref:2602.15131#pg2>.
Lev: The paper mentions a thermodynamic potential invariant under all those operations, which leads to a specific magnetization M and deformation u xx when you apply an external field H x <ref:2602.15131#pg2>. Kai So the electronic band splitting isn't just theoretical; it has measurable consequences tied to mechanical stress.
Mira: And then they introduce another concept called hidden altermagnetism, which is interesting because these materials don't even have symmetry with respect to space inversion or time reversal <ref:2602.15131#pg2>. Kai This hidden aspect is symmetric under the product of space inversion and time reversal, which they call toroid symmetry.
Lev: If you have that toroid symmetry, Kramers theorem still holds for each band energy, meaning each spin density at a point is opposite the density at the opposite point in terms of direction <ref:2602.15131#pg2>. Mira So this hidden splitting on these planes is recreated by spin-orbit coupling, which is another layer we need to account for <ref:2602.15131#pg2>.
Kai: It seems like the main point here is that just using the exchange approximation misses a part of the band splitting determined by actual crystal symmetry, and there are also these hidden effects linked to toroid symmetry <ref:2602.15131#pg2>. Lev For real hardware, this means we need to incorporate these full magnetic group symmetries into our calculations if we want fidelity.
Mira: It really shows that the description of electron band splitting needs to be based on the actual crystal symmetry of the altermagnet material rather than just neglecting things like relativistic interactions <ref:2602.15131#pg1>. So, what does this mean for how we think about these magnetic metals?
Kai: It means that even when you're working with a material like CrSb, you have to consider all the way the symmetry group to fully capture what's going on with those electron bands. Lev And for the hidden altermagnets, it suggests that spin-orbit coupling is what brings back that specific splitting on those planes through toroid symmetry.
Mira: So to wrap up this paper, "Band splitting in the altermagnet CrSb", they argue that this new approach establishes a band splitting missed by the exchange approximation due to crystal symmetry <ref:2602.15131#pg1>. Kai And they connect this electronic structure directly to piezomagnetic properties and hidden altermagnetism linked to toroid symmetry.
Lev: For us, the implication is that if we are building devices based on these materials, we need models that account for this full magnetic group structure, not just the simpler spin group approach <ref:2602.15131#pg3>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we've looked at how they figured out the band splitting in chromium antimony, or CrSb. Mira They used this new magnetic groups formalism to find that extra spin splitting that you miss when you just use the basic exchange approximation for these materials.
Lev: So what does this mean when we think about building actual hardware? Does this complexity translate into a bigger error correction overhead we have to manage?
Kai: Well, it means the physics isn't just simple momentum dependent splitting along one axis; there are these other components related to the crystal symmetry itself. Mira Exactly. They link this electronic structure directly to how the material deforms under an external field, which is called piezomagnetism.
Lev: So we’re talking about a connection between the quantum state of the electrons and mechanical stress in a solid, that’s something we have to model if we want real hardware fidelity. Kai And they also looked at hidden altermagnetism in other materials with toroid symmetry, where spin splitting comes back through spin-orbit coupling.
Mira: That hidden aspect suggests that even when you think the material is simple, you have to consider these deeper symmetries like toroid symmetry to get the full picture of the electron behavior. Lev So what's the next step for us if we want to model this accurately on a real chip?
Landau Institute for Theoretical Physics
cond-mat.str-el
Submitted: 2026-02-16
Updated: 2026-11-14
Comments: Misprints in Phys. Rev. B 114,065130(2026)are corrected
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: Band splitting in the altermagnet CrSb is established using magnetic groups formalism that allows to find the additional spin splitting missed in frame of exchange approximation The problem of…
Key concepts
- Magnetic Groups Formalism
- This approach is used to describe the spin splitting in altermagnets by considering the crystal symmetry of the material. It helps identify extra spin splitting that is not accounted for when only using a basic exchange approximation.
- Piezomagnetic Properties
- The symmetry of CrSb allows for a piezomagnetic effect, meaning mechanical strain can induce magnetization. This relationship is described by a specific thermodynamic potential invariant under the crystal's symmetry operations, linking deformation to magnetization changes.
- Hidden Altermagnetism
- Some materials lack space inversion symmetry but possess toroid symmetry (the product of inversion and time reversal). In these cases, Kramers' theorem applies, leading to a unique spin structure where spin density at a point is opposite to the density at the point reflected through the center.
- Spin-Orbit Coupling
- This interaction couples an electron's spin to its orbital motion. It is crucial for recreating the additional momentum-dependent spin splitting observed in certain planes, as described by specific equations derived from symmetry analysis.
Terminology
Summary
Band splitting in the altermagnet CrSb is established using magnetic groups formalism that allows to find the additional spin splitting missed in frame of exchange approximation The problem of electron band splitting should be discussed based on crystal symmetry of concrete altermagnet material
Formal Approach Limitations
The initial description of the momentum dependent spin splitting of electron bands in altermagnets was based on the spin groups approach, which is valid when relativistic interactions are neglected Then the spin-orbit coupling has been taken into account with time-reversal-odd, even-parity irreducible representations of centrosymmetric point groups considered by R.M.Fernandes et al Here we show inadequacy of this formal approach The band spin-splitting in hexagonal altermagnet CrSb is established using magnetic groups formalism that allows to find the additional spin splitting missed in frame of exchange approximation
Symmetry Analysis of CrSb
CrSb crystallizes as a hexagonal NiAs-type structure in the centrosymmetric non-symmorphic space group P63/mmc (N194) The symmetry group of paramagnetic state consists of the same elements as (1) but rotations with odd numbers n = 2k + 1, k = 0, 1, 2 are accompanied by a shift t on half period of crystal cell along the hexagonal axis In the ordered state (see Fig 1.) each improper rotation containing the shift t should be accompanied by time inversion R (as it should be in altermagnet state) and magnetic group of symmetry is Ga = Da6 ×I, Da6 =
Band Structure Description
According to spin-group symmetry approach spin part of energy dispersion γk is the product of scalar function of momentum corresponding to one of irreducible representations of symmetry group of paramagnetic state (8) and axial vector ˆz along hexagonal axis which is invariant in respect to symmetry operations acting only on magnetic moments that is on arrows in Fig.1 For B1g representations the corresponding vector function is γBk = bkzkx(k 2x − 3k 2y)ˆz Taking into account that time inversion changes the sign k-vector components and axial vectors ˆx, y, ˆz it is easy to check that the vector function γA k = c1(k 2x − k 2y)ˆx − 2kxkyyˆ + c2kzkx(k 2x − 3k 2y)ˆz The diagonalization of the matrix (3) results in band dispersion laws ε±(k) = εk ± γk
Piezomagnetic Properties
The symmetry of altermagnet CrSb allows piezomagnetic effect The thermodynamic potential invariant in respect all operation group Ga is Φ = −λ [(σxx − σyy)Hx − 2σxyHy] This leads to the magnetization My = λ(σxx − σyy) (16) and deformation arising under external field is uxx = λHx
Hidden Altermagnetism
Another interesting situation takes place in so called hidden altermagnets [32, 33] These type materials do not possess symmetry in respect to space inversion I and time inversion R = −iσˆyK but are symmetric in respect to the product IR of these operations known as toroid symmetry In case of toroid symmetry the Kramers theorem is valid that is to each band energy εk corresponds two mutually orthogonal spinor Bloch functions ψkα(r) and ϕkα(r) = −iσy αβKIψkβ(r) This means that to each spin density S↑ in the point r corresponds the opposite directed density of spin S↓ in the point −r such that the total magnetisation ˆd3r (S↑(r) + S↓(r)) = 0
Conclusion
The developed approach allows to establish the band splitting in the altermagnetic metal CrSb Along with the standard description of momentum dependent electron band spin splitting in altermagnets based on spingroup formalism valid in exchange approximation there was found an additional contribution to electron band splitting corresponding to actual crystal symmetry of antiferromagnet CrSb Additional momentum dependent spin-splitting in basal plane hardly distinguishable in quantum oscillation measurements but certainly can be revealed in neutron scattering experiments and by ARPES technic The structure of additional terms in band structure missed in exchange approximation corresponds to structure of piezomagnetic thermodynamic potential determining piezomagnetic properties of CrSb altermagnet At the end there was considered the phenomenon of hidden altermagnetism taking place in compounds with toroid symmetry The spin-splitting on these planes is recreated by spin-orbit coupling according to Eq.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can accurately predict electron band structure in altermagnets by incorporating actual crystal symmetry rather than relying solely on spin groups approach or exchange approximation. This allows for a determination of
the bands spin-splitting difference found in frame of nonrelativistic and relativistic approach.
-
Improved AI system can distinguish between different types of band splitting by analyzing the required symmetry operations, specifically differentiating between those that are
time-reversal-odd, even-parity irreducible representations
and those corresponding toactual magnetic symmetry of this material.
-
Improved AI system can model hidden altermagnetism by recognizing materials with toroid symmetry and understanding their resulting spin density distributions where the total magnetization is absent, as described by equations (18) and (20).
-
Improved AI system can predict piezoelectric properties in altermagnets like CrSb by calculating the thermodynamic potential invariant in respect to the group Ga, which relates stress to magnetization via equation (16).
-
Improved AI system can simulate the effect of an external magnetic field H on altermagnet CrSb by incorporating the Zeeman term, allowing it to predict how
the symmetry does not include the rotations U2k
when a field is applied along the z axis.
Sources
- Toroid, Altermagnetic and Noncentrosymmetric ordering in metals
- Altermagnets versus Antiferromagnets
- Topological nontrivial berry phase in altermagnet CrSb
- 3D bulk-resolved $g$-wave altermagnetic order parameter in CrSb
- Altermagnetic spin-split Fermi surfaces in CrSb revealed by quantum oscillation measurements
- Coherent high-velocity chiral magnons in the metallic altermagnet CrSb
- Observation of hidden altermagnetism in Cs$_{1-\delta}$V$_2$Te$_2$O
Related papers
- Coupled Magnetic and Lattice Excitations in Multiferroic Ba3HoRu2O9: Insights from Neutron Scattering, Raman Spectroscopy, and Machine-Learned Phonon Calculations
- Gossamer Superconductivity in Moir'e WSe 2 Bilayer
- Spin-density wave of ferrimagnetic building blocks masking the ferromagnetic quantum-critical point in NbFe2
- Raman Circular Dichroism and spinon Quantum Geometry of Chiral Quantum Spin Liquids
- Twin Algebras: Condensable Algebras beyond Anyons
- Spin supersolid in triangular lattice easy-axis spin-1/2 antiferromagnet: a fermionic parton perspective