Two-loop renormalisation of the quark fields in the presence of four-fermion SMEFT operators
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Two-loop renormalisation of the quark fields in the presence of four-fermion SMEFT operators".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Two-loop renormalisation of the quark fields in the presence of four-fermion SMEFT operators is computed in both on-shell and MS schemes to complete calculations relevant for two-loop computations in QCD involving dimension-six SMEFT operators The Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) provides a framework to parametrize the effects of heavy new physics by modifying Standard Model interactions through higher-dimensional operators A systematic effort is ongoing to improve theoretical predictions in SMEFT, including the two-loop renormalisation of the SMEFT at dimension-6 through the computation of anomalous dimensions In this work, the authors complete previous results by computing the renormalisation of quark fields and masses in both schemes in the presence of four-quark operators This extension introduces complexity due to chirality-dependent operators and evanescent operators which play a crucial role because spinor identities only hold in four dimensions Operator Basis and Regularization Schemes The paper focuses on dimension-six SMEFT operators involving only third-generation quarks, specifically listing several four-quark operators such as O(1)QQ, O(8)QQ, Qt, Qb, Ott, and tb When constructing a minimal basis of four-fermion operators using Fierz identities in dimensional regularization requires accounting for evanescent operators which can contribute to the finite parts of one-loop diagrams The choice of regularisation scheme is critical because chirality-dependent operators demand a continuation scheme for γ5, with Naive Dimensional Regularisation (NDR) and Breitenlohner-Maison-‘t Hooft-Veltman (BMHV) being the options The authors perform computations in both schemes, noting that BMHV is algebraically consistent to all orders in perturbation theory Renormalization Procedures The computation involves two main approaches for renormalisation: MS and on-shell schemes, with results presented for both.
Kai: In the MS-scheme, since evanescent operators are present, finite counterterms are added to the usual MS renormalisation factors to cancel effects from finite mixing into physical operators The on-shell scheme imposes conditions on the fermionic two-point function to extract renormalisation factors through combinations of form factors The authors define a combination of form factors as Σ˜ψ (p squared, m0t, m0b) which is used to extract the renormalisation factors ZMψ Key Results in NDR and BMHV Schemes The results for the quark mass renormalisation factors are presented in both schemes.
Mira: In the NDR-scheme, the two-loop running of the top-quark mass is given by an expression involving Wilson coefficients c(1)Qt and c(8)Qt The running of the bottom quark mass in the BMHV-scheme is also derived, showing a specific form for its anomalous dimension In the on-shell scheme, two-loop results for the top-quark mass counterterm are shown as expressions involving dilogarithms and various Wilson coefficients The comparison between MS and on-shell masses is established through a relation derived from the renormalisation factors The work completes the computation of two-loop renormalisation of fields within the QCD sector of dimension-6 SMEFT in both schemes, providing vital ingredients for subsequent phenomenological studies The results are presented in terms of two-point renormalisation functions proportional to physical Wilson coefficients and one-loop counterterms proportional to evanescent Wilson coefficients The computation complements previous work on chromomagnetic and triple gluon operators, as well as four-quark operators contributing to the gluon wavefunction A Renormalisation factors for the quark mass The full expressions for the renormalisation factors for the masses of quarks both in NDR- and BMHV-schemes are shown by expanding the mass counterterm as δZ(2)mt,4q = X−1 k=−2 CF εk δZ(2,k)mt,4q The results for the top-quark read: δZ(2,-2) mt,4q = − 4/3 c(1)QQ m2t − 8/3 ctt m2t − 2/3 c(8)Qb m2t − 2/3 c(8)QtQb + 1/3 c(8)QQ(CA − 2(1 + CF))m2t + 36 c(1)Qt m2t – 24+ 2c(8)Qt(−1 + 18CF) m2t − 3 c(1)QtQb mbmt (5 + 6CA)m2b + m2t + 3/2 c(8)QtQb mbmt CA(2m2b + m2t) − 2CF (5m2b + m2t) B Definition of evanescent operators Table 1 shows the set of Fierz-evanescent operators required for the calculation of the top-quark self-energy at two loops, including master integrals Table 2 defines the set of Fierz-evanescent operators where only E F QtQb(R) are generated at one loop and which contribute to the quark self-energy in the NDR-scheme Table 4 shows the two- and four-quark relevant evanescent operators in the BMHV-scheme C Definitions for the results in electronic format The results are presented in terms of Zq2
type, scheme, N loops: , Zq2ev
type, scheme: , and γ
mψ, scheme, N loops: For example, the counterterm for the mass of the top-quark in the BMHV-scheme at two loops is obtained via δZ(2)mt,4q BMHV = Zq2
"mt", "BMHV", "2": The running of the bottom quark mass (only in the 4FS) at two loops is obtained via γ(2)mb,4q BMHV = γ
"mb", "BMHV", "2": The evanescent contribution to the mass of the top counterterm in the NDR-scheme is given by δmNDR t,ev = Zq2ev
"mt", "NDR": D Comparison with existing results The two-loop running of quark masses in the presence of four-fermion operators is compared to results in refs.
50: and
51: The authors map their operators to those used in ref.
Paper summary: Kai: So we’re looking at this paper called "Two-loop renormalisation of the quark fields in the presence of four-fermion SMEFT operators". It's tackling how to correctly calculate things at two loops when there are these four-fermion SMEFT operators involved.
Mira: Essentially, the authors are completing a systematic effort to improve predictions for new physics effects in this framework by figuring out the two-loop renormalisation of quark fields and masses. They do this in both Naive Dimensional Regularisation and Breitenlohner-Maison Veltman schemes, and they give results in both the on-shell and MS schemes.
Lev: That means they are calculating how to handle those dimension six operators involving only third-generation quarks, like O(one)QQ, O(eight)QQ, Qt, Qb, Ott, and tb <ref:2602.01250#pg2>. And the paper focuses on how these operators affect the quark masses.
Kai: It's important because these four-quark operators introduce complexity with chirality dependent ones and evanescent operators that really matter because spinor identities only hold in four dimensions.
Mira: Right. They’re dealing with those things, like having to account for evanescent operators which contribute to the finite parts of one loop diagrams when you use dimensional regularization. The choice of scheme, like Naive Dimensional Regularisation versus BMHV, is critical because it dictates how they handle those chirality dependent operators.
Lev: And they actually do computations in both schemes, noting that the BMHV scheme is algebraically consistent to all orders in perturbation theory. That’s a nice piece of information for building actual hardware where you need consistency.
Kai: The paper presents results for the quark mass renormalisation factors in both schemes, and also shows how those results compare when you use the on-shell scheme versus the MS scheme.
Mira: In the MS scheme, since those evanescent operators are there, they add finite counterterms to cancel out effects from mixing into physical operators. The on-shell scheme extracts renormalisation factors through combinations of form factors, specifically using a combination called sigma psi p squared m0t m0b.
Lev: So they define this sigma psi p squared m0t m0b and use it to get the mass renormalisation factors, Zm psi, which is useful for running those masses.
Kai: They give specific results for the top quark mass renormalisation factors in both Naive Dimensional Regularisation and Breitenlohner-Maison Veltman schemes. The expression they show for the top quark is quite detailed, involving Wilson coefficients like c(one)QQ, ctt, c(eight)Qb, and c(eight)QtQb <ref:2602.01250#pg2>.
Mira: And they also derive the running of the bottom quark mass in the BMHV scheme, showing a specific form for its anomalous dimension. This helps constrain how that mass evolves with energy.
Paper summary: Lev: For me as someone building error correction hardware, seeing those results means knowing exactly what kind of terms you’re dealing with when you try to run this on real hardware. The complexity of the two loop top quark counterterm is quite high, involving dilogarithms and various Wilson coefficients.
Kai: They compare the MS and on-shell masses by establishing a relation between the renormalisation factors, which gives you that connection between them. It shows how they relate to each other through a combination of terms like xi two t four q NDR equals CF m2t c(one)QQ m2t minus eight over three ctt m2t <ref:2602.01250#pg2>...
Mira: That relation is key because it links the MS and on-shell results together, which is what you need for consistency across different ways of defining things. They also show that the NDR scheme results agree with those of a previous work for overlapping operator sets when taking cev equal to one.
Lev: It’s interesting they map their operators to those used in a reference, but they skip the O(eight)QQ operators because it requires extra evanescent operators, which makes sense given the complexity <ref:2602.01250#pg2>.
Kai: The paper completes the computation of two-loop renormalisation of fields within the QCD sector of dimension six SMEFT in both schemes. It gives you two-point renormalisation functions proportional to physical Wilson coefficients and one-loop counterterms proportional to evanescent Wilson coefficients.
Mira: This set of results is a vital ingredient for subsequent phenomenological studies involving quarks and gluons in the SMEFT at two loops. It provides the necessary inputs for higher order calculations.
Lev: This computation complements previous work they did on chromomagnetic and triple gluon operators, as well as four-quark operators that contribute to the gluon wavefunction. It fills in a gap for those specific contributions.
Kai: The results are presented in terms of Zq two
type, scheme, N loops: , Zq two ev
type, scheme: , and gamma m psi
scheme, N loops: . For example, the counterterm for the top quark mass in the BMHV scheme at two loops is given by delta z two mt four q BMHV equals z q two
"mt", "BMHV", "two": <ref:2602.01250#pg1>
Mira: And they show how to get the running of the bottom quark mass, only from four fermion operators, at two loops using gamma two mb four q BMHV equals gamma
"mb", "BMHV", "two": <ref:2602.01250#pg1>.
Paper summary: Lev: So, for someone looking at this practically, it means you have concrete formulas for those crucial mass corrections that you need to incorporate into your simulations or experimental fits.
Kai: The paper also details the set of Fierz-evanescent operators required for the calculation of the top quark self energy at two loops, including master integrals. They define them in tables, and they even show which ones only generate E F QtQb(R) at one loop in the Naive Dimensional Regularisation scheme.
Mira: That level of detail on the evanescent operators is important because it tells you exactly what finite parts you need to worry about when you set up your counterterms. It shows where those extra pieces come from in the calculation process.
Lev: When I think about running this on hardware, I’m thinking about how much overhead these evanescent terms add to the computational cost of achieving a certain fidelity level for the quark mass measurement.
Kai: The comparison with existing results shows that their NDR scheme results agree with those of a previous work when taking cev equal to one, which gives confidence in their calculation. They also confirm agreement with the BMHV computation from a reference after accounting for scheme differences.
Mira: The paper lays out the relation between the on-shell and MS renormalised masses, showing how that connection is made using terms like xi two t four q NDR equals CF m2t c(one)QQ m2t minus eight over three ctt m2t <ref:2602.01250#pg2>...
Lev: So, for someone just listening to this, it’s about getting a unified set of tools. You have the MS scheme and you have the on-shell scheme, and they tell you how to translate between them using these specific coefficients.
Kai: Overall, this work completes the computation of two-loop renormalisation of fields within the QCD sector of dimension six SMEFT in both on-shell and MS schemes. It’s a vital ingredient for subsequent phenomenological studies involving quarks and gluons in the SMEFT at two loops.
Mira: It also complements previous work they did on chromomagnetic and triple gluon operators, as well as four-quark operators that contribute to the gluon wavefunction. This set of results is a vital ingredient for subsequent phenomenological studies of processes involving quarks and gluons in the SMEFT at two loops.
Lev: So, this means you have these tools ready for the next step in studying how new physics shows up in QCD processes at two loops. The calculation helps set up what you need to measure or simulate next.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up on this paper about two-loop renormalisation of quark fields in the presence of four-fermion SMEFT operators, and what it actually means for our work on real hardware.
Mira: It’s a lot of heavy math, Kai, but basically they finished calculating how to correctly handle those dimension six operators at two loops in both the Naive Dimensional Regularisation and Breitenlohner-Maison Veltman schemes.
Lev: What that means is they’ve given us the necessary tools to calculate the running of quark masses when those four-fermion interactions are present, which is crucial for error correction overheads.
Kai: Exactly. The authors did this in both MS and on-shell schemes, showing how you can relate them together using these specific renormalisation factors they developed.
Mira: They’re essentially providing the building blocks—the two-point renormalisation functions and the one-loop counterterms proportional to those evanescent operators—that we need for any serious two-loop SMEFT studies.
Lev: So, for us working on error correction, this means we know exactly what kind of terms are creeping in at that second order when we try to model these new physics effects on a real machine.
Kai: Right. It’s not just theoretical math; it translates directly into the computational cost and stability of our experiments.
Mira: The paper connects their results back to previous work, confirming consistency between different calculation methods, which builds confidence in the final numbers they present for things like the top quark mass running.
Lev: And that agreement is important because it tells us that even though there are so many ways to do the math—NDR versus BMHV—the physical answer should be consistent if you use those right connections.
Kai: So, they’ve laid out a roadmap for anyone trying to calculate how these four-fermion operators affect quarks at two loops in this new SMEFT framework.
Mira: And now we need to look closely at the specific results for the top quark mass and bottom quark running that they derived in those different schemes.
Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics, University of Bonn · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester · Department of Physics, University of Cyprus
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-02-01
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: 36 pages
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 82/100
The gist: Two-loop renormalisation of the quark fields in the presence of four-fermion SMEFT operators is computed in both on-shell and MS schemes to complete calculations relevant for two-loop computations in…
Key concepts
- SMEFT
- Standard Model Effective Field Theory is a framework used to describe new physics by modifying the Standard Model interactions with higher-dimensional operators. These operators parametrize the effects of heavy new particles that are too heavy to be directly produced, allowing for systematic theoretical predictions.
- Four-fermion SMEFT Operators
- These are specific dimension-six operators in SMEFT that involve four quark fields interacting together, such as O(1)QQ or Qt. The paper focuses on these operators involving only third-generation quarks and requires careful treatment due to their chirality dependence.
- Renormalization Schemes (MS vs. On-Shell)
- These are different mathematical procedures used to define the physical parameters of the theory, like quark masses. The MS scheme is common but requires adding finite counterterms for evanescent operators, while the on-shell scheme extracts renormalization factors by imposing conditions on fermionic two-point functions.
- Evanescent Operators
- These are extra operators that appear during calculations in dimensional regularization, particularly when using Fierz identities. They are necessary to ensure the algebraic consistency of the theory and contribute to finite parts of one-loop diagrams.
Terminology
Summary
Two-loop renormalisation of the quark fields in the presence of four-fermion SMEFT operators is computed in both on-shell and MS schemes to complete calculations relevant for two-loop computations in QCD involving dimension-six SMEFT operators
Introduction and Scope
The Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) provides a framework to parametrize the effects of heavy new physics by modifying Standard Model interactions through higher-dimensional operators A systematic effort is ongoing to improve theoretical predictions in SMEFT, including the two-loop renormalisation of the SMEFT at dimension-6 through the computation of anomalous dimensions In this work, the authors complete previous results by computing the renormalisation of quark fields and masses in both schemes in the presence of four-quark operators This extension introduces complexity due to chirality-dependent operators and evanescent operators which play a crucial role because spinor identities only hold in four dimensions
Operator Basis and Regularization Schemes
The paper focuses on dimension-six SMEFT operators involving only third-generation quarks, specifically listing several four-quark operators such as O(1)QQ, O(8)QQ, Qt, Qb, Ott, and tb When constructing a minimal basis of four-fermion operators using Fierz identities in dimensional regularization requires accounting for evanescent operators which can contribute to the finite parts of one-loop diagrams The choice of regularisation scheme is critical because chirality-dependent operators demand a continuation scheme for γ5, with Naive Dimensional Regularisation (NDR) and Breitenlohner-Maison-‘t Hooft-Veltman (BMHV) being the options The authors perform computations in both schemes, noting that BMHV is algebraically consistent to all orders in perturbation theory
Renormalization Procedures
The computation involves two main approaches for renormalisation: MS and on-shell schemes, with results presented for both. In the MS-scheme, since evanescent operators are present, finite counterterms are added to the usual MS renormalisation factors to cancel effects from finite mixing into physical operators The on-shell scheme imposes conditions on the fermionic two-point function to extract renormalisation factors through combinations of form factors The authors define a combination of form factors as Σ˜ψ (p squared, m0t, m0b) which is used to extract the renormalisation factors ZMψ
Key Results in NDR and BMHV Schemes
The results for the quark mass renormalisation factors are presented in both schemes. In the NDR-scheme, the two-loop running of the top-quark mass is given by an expression involving Wilson coefficients c(1)Qt and c(8)Qt The running of the bottom quark mass in the BMHV-scheme is also derived, showing a specific form for its anomalous dimension In the on-shell scheme, two-loop results for the top-quark mass counterterm are shown as expressions involving dilogarithms and various Wilson coefficients The comparison between MS and on-shell masses is established through a relation derived from the renormalisation factors
Conclusion
The work completes the computation of two-loop renormalisation of fields within the QCD sector of dimension-6 SMEFT in both schemes, providing vital ingredients for subsequent phenomenological studies The results are presented in terms of two-point renormalisation functions proportional to physical Wilson coefficients and one-loop counterterms proportional to evanescent Wilson coefficients The computation complements previous work on chromomagnetic and triple gluon operators, as well as four-quark operators contributing to the gluon wavefunction
A Renormalisation factors for the quark mass
The full expressions for the renormalisation factors for the masses of quarks both in NDR- and BMHV-schemes are shown by expanding the mass counterterm as δZ(2)mt,4q = X−1 k=−2 CF εk δZ(2,k)mt,4q The results for the top-quark read: δZ(2,-2) mt,4q = − 4/3 c(1)QQ m2t − 8/3 ctt m2t − 2/3 c(8)Qb m2t − 2/3 c(8)QtQb + 1/3 c(8)QQ(CA − 2(1 + CF))m2t + 36 c(1)Qt m2t – 24+ 2c(8)Qt(−1 + 18CF) m2t − 3 c(1)QtQb mbmt (5 + 6CA)m2b + m2t + 3/2 c(8)QtQb mbmt CA(2m2b + m2t) − 2CF (5m2b + m2t)
B Definition of evanescent operators
Table 1 shows the set of Fierz-evanescent operators required for the calculation of the top-quark self-energy at two loops, including master integrals Table 2 defines the set of Fierz-evanescent operators where only E F QtQb(R) are generated at one loop and which contribute to the quark self-energy in the NDR-scheme Table 4 shows the two- and four-quark relevant evanescent operators in the BMHV-scheme
C Definitions for the results in electronic format
The results are presented in terms of Zq2[type, scheme, N loops], Zq2ev[type, scheme], and γ[mψ, scheme, N loops] For example, the counterterm for the mass of the top-quark in the BMHV-scheme at two loops is obtained via δZ(2)mt,4q BMHV = Zq2["mt", BMHV
, "2] The running of the bottom quark mass (only in the 4FS) at two loops is obtained via γ(2)mb,4q BMHV = γ[
mb", BMHV
, "2] The evanescent contribution to the mass of the top counterterm in the NDR-scheme is given by δmNDR t,ev = Zq2ev[
mt", NDR
]
D Comparison with existing results
The two-loop running of quark masses in the presence of four-fermion operators is compared to results in refs. [50] and [51] The authors map their operators to those used in ref. p. 8 [50], but refrain from doing so for O(8)QQ due to the need for additional Fierz-evanescent operators The results in the NDR-scheme agree with those of ref. p. 7 [51] for overlapping operator sets when taking cev = 1 The authors are confident that their results are correct because they agree with the BMHV computation from ref. p. 5 [50] after accounting for scheme differences
E The relation between the MS and on-shell masses
The relation between the on-shell and MS renormalised masses is written as Mψ = Zmψ ZMψ mψ For the top-quark, the two-loop term in NDR is shown as ξ(2)t,4q NDR = CF m2t c(1)Qt (29 − 8cev) + CF m2t c(8)Qt 18[36cev(CA − 4CF) + 387CA + 522CF +28π−387+ CF m2b c(8)Qt72(20π−441) − M2b c(8)Qt Fc(8)Qt(Mt, Mb) >
F Results in the BMHV-scheme
The two-loop result for the top-quark mass renormalisation factor in the on-shell scheme is δZ(2,0) Mt,4q BMHV = 160/9 M2t c(1)Qt + 2M2t c(8)Qt 9/80CF + 95CA − 7π−2 + 123− M2b c(8)Qt72(20π−513) + c(8)Qt Fc(8)Qt(Mt, Mb) > The two-loop running of the bottom quark mass in the BMHV-scheme is shown as γ (2)mb,4q BMHV = γ["mb", BMHV
, "2"]
G Conclusion
The work completes the computation of two-loop renormalisation of fields within the QCD sector of dimension-6 SMEFT in both on-shell and MS schemes The computation complements previous work on chromomagnetic and triple gluon operators, as well as four-quark operators contributing to the gluon wavefunction This set of results is a vital ingredient for subsequent phenomenological studies of processes involving quarks and gluons in the SMEFT at two loops
H Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to Peter Stoffer for help with the comparison to results of ref. [50] and also for careful reading and comments on the manuscript GV and EV are supported by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 949451) and by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship through grant URF/R1/201553 The work of CD is supported by the DFG project 499573813 “EFTools”
I A Renormalisation factors for the quark mass
The results for the top-quark read: δZ(2) mt,4q = − 4/3 c(1)QQ m2t − 8/3 ctt m2t − 2/3 c(8)Qb m2t − 2/3 c(8)QtQb + 1/3 c(8)QQ(CA − 2(1 + CF))m2t + 36 c(1)Qt m2t – 24+ 2c(8)Qt(−1 + 18CF) m2t − 3 c(1)QtQb mbmt (5 + 6CA)m2b + m2t + 3/2 c(8)QtQb mbmt CA(2m2b + m2t) − 2CF (5m2b + m2t)
J Definition of evanescent operators
Table 1 shows the set of Fierz-evanescent operators required for the calculation of the top-quark self-energy at two loops, including master integrals Table 2 defines the set of Fierz-evanescent operators where only E F QtQb(R) are generated at one loop and which contribute to the quark self-energy in the NDR-scheme Table 4 shows the two- and four-quark relevant evanescent operators in the BMHV-scheme
K Definitions for the results in electronic format
The results are presented in terms of Zq2[type, scheme, N loops], Zq2ev[type, scheme], and γ[mψ, scheme, N loops] For example, the counterterm for the mass of the top-quark in the BMHV-scheme at two loops is obtained via δZ(2)mt,4q BMHV = Zq2["mt", BMHV
, "2] The running of the bottom quark mass (only in the 4FS) at two loops is obtained via γ(2)mb,4q BMHV = γ[
mb", BMHV
, "2] The evanescent contribution to the mass of the top counterterm in the NDR-scheme is given by δmNDR t,ev = Zq2ev[
mt", NDR
]
L Summary of our choices of regularisation schemes
The discussions from preceding sections make it clear that precise definition of dimensional regularisation scheme requires careful settings and conventions The authors perform computations in both NDR- and BMHV-schemes, noting that BMHV is algebraically consistent to all orders in perturbation theory
M Two-loop self-energy amplitudes
The diagrams have been generated with FeynArts [97], and the Dirac and color algebra have been performed with FeynCalc [98–100] The integration-by-parts (IBP) reduction is performed with Kira [103–105]
N One-loop results
The one-loop results are defined by the mass renormalisation factor in the MS-scheme such that m0ψ = Zmψ mψ, ψ ∈ t, b The expansion for the one-loop term δZ(1)mt,4q takes the form involving c(1)Qt and c(8)Qt
O Off-shell reduction and renormalisation
The loop integrals contributing to the top-quark self-energy at two loops are mapped onto integral families shown in Table 1 The novel feature is the presence of evanescent operators which need to be inserted in one-loop counterterm diagrams To cancel finite mixing into physical operators, a renormalisation scheme is adopted where finite counterterms depend on the coefficients of evanescent operators
P On-shell reduction and renormalisation
The on-shell limit is performed by imposing the onshell renormalisation conditions on the fermionic two-point function The combination of form factors Σ˜ψ (p squared, m0t, m0b) is used to extract the renormalisation factors ZMψ The resulting MIs are known in the literature [115–116]
Q Results in the NDR-scheme
The results for the running of quark masses in the MS scheme read dmψ dlog µ = γmψ NDR mψ The two-loop coefficient for top-quark mass anomalous dimension in NDR is given by γ(2)mt,4q NDR = 64/3 c(1)QQm2t + 128/3 c(1)tt m2t + 4/3 c(8)Qb (9m2b + m2t) + 4/3 c(8)tb (9m2b + m2t) >
R Running of the quark masses
The running of the quark mass in the NDR-scheme is given by dmψ dlog µ = γmψ NDR mψ The full expression for the two-loop coefficient is complex, involving terms up to c(8)QtQb
S Comparison with existing results
The two-loop running of quark masses in the presence of four-fermion operators is compared to results in refs. [50] and [51] The authors note that their results agree with the BMHV computation from ref. p. 7 [50] after accounting for scheme differences
T Results in the BMHV-scheme
The two-loop result for the top-quark mass renormalisation factor in the on-shell scheme is δZ(2,0) Mt,4q BMHV = 160/9 M2t c(1)Qt + 2M2t c(8)Qt 9/80CF + 95CA − 7π−2 + 123− M2b c(8)Qt72(20π−513) + c(8)Qt Fc(8)Qt(Mt, Mb) >
U Conclusion
The work completes the computation of two-loop renormalisation of fields within the QCD sector of dimension-6 SMEFT in both on-shell and MS schemes The calculation complements previous work on chromomagnetic and triple gluon operators, as well as four-quark operators contributing to the gluon wavefunction This set of results is a vital ingredient for subsequent phenomenological studies of processes involving quarks and gluons in the SMEFT at two loops
V Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to Peter Stoffer for help with comparison to results of ref. [50] and also for careful reading and comments on the manuscript GV and EV are supported by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced calculation of two-loop renormalization of quark fields and masses in SMEFT by providing explicit results for all relevant field and mass renormalisation constants in both on-shell and MS schemes across both NDR and BMHV schemes.
-
Improved ability to distinguish between scheme dependencies by explicitly discussing
all scheme choices which affect the final results
as mentioned in the abstract, allowing researchers to critically evaluate the impact of regularization choices on two-loop computations. -
Capability to guide future two-loop computations in QCD involving dimension-six SMEFT operators by providing a complete set of conventions and schemes, serving as a
useful guide with regards to all the choices which need to be made and explicitly spelled out before presenting results for such a twoloop computation.
-
Increased precision in phenomenological studies by including contributions from four-quark operators to the gluon wavefunction running, which is described as a
vital ingredient for the computation and subsequent phenomenological studies of processes involving quarks and gluons in the SMEFT at two loops.
-
Advanced analysis of chiral symmetry treatment by providing detailed comparisons between Naive Dimensional Regularisation (NDR) and Breitenlohner-Maison-’t Hooft-Veltman (BMHV) schemes, including the specific structures of evanescent operators relevant to each scheme.
Sources
- Automated one-loop computations in the SMEFT
- Electroweak Loops as a Probe of New Physics in $t\bar{t}$ Production at the LHC
- Flavorful Electroweak Precision Observables in the Standard Model Effective Field Theory
- Higgs decay to two photons at one-loop in the SMEFT
- On one-loop corrections in the standard model effective field theory; the $\Gamma(h \rightarrow \gamma \, \gamma)$ case
- One-loop corrections to $h\to b\bar b$ and $h\to \tau\bar \tau$ decays in the Standard Model Dimension-6 EFT: four-fermion operators and the large-$m_t$ limit
- The $Z$ decay width in the SMEFT: $y_t$ and $\lambda$ corrections at one loop
- SMEFT and the Drell-Yan Process at High Energy
- SMEFT Corrections to $Z$ Boson Decays
- Electroweak Corrections to Higgs to $\gamma\gamma$ and $W^+W^-$ in the SMEFT
- Higgs Decays to $ZZ$ and $Z\gamma$ in the SMEFT: an NLO analysis
- The decay $h\to \gamma\gamma$ in the Standard-Model Effective Field Theory
- The decay $h\to Z \gamma$ in the Standard-Model Effective Field Theory
- NLO corrections to $h\to b\bar b$ decay in SMEFT
- Top quark decay at next-to-leading order in the Standard Model Effective Field Theory
- Higgs decay to fermion pairs at NLO in SMEFT
- Consistent higher order $\sigma(\mathcal{G} \,\mathcal{G}\rightarrow h)$, $\Gamma(h \rightarrow \mathcal{G} \,\mathcal{G})$ and $\Gamma(h \rightarrow \gamma \gamma)$ in geoSMEFT
- New Physics Through Drell Yan SMEFT Measurements at NLO
- Gluon-fusion Higgs production in the Standard Model Effective Field Theory
- Probing the scalar potential via double Higgs boson production at hadron colliders
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses