Radiative Dirac Neutrino Masses from Modular S 3 Symmetry in an Axion Model
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Radiative Dirac Neutrino Masses from Modular S 3 Symmetry in an Axion Model".
Paper summary: Kai: So looking at the paper Radiative Dirac Neutrino Masses from Modular S three Symmetry in an Axion Model, the authors are essentially proposing a unified picture of these fundamental puzzles > <ref:2601.22740#pg1,Radiative Dirac Neutrino Masses from Modular>
Mira: They use modular symmetry to explain neutrino flavor and then show how radiative mass generation at one loop level handles the neutrino masses >
Lev: The most important thing they demonstrate is that this framework can simultaneously address the strong CP problem through the axion and provide a viable dark matter candidate via misalignment >
Kai: And they do this while keeping experimental constraints on charged lepton flavor violation and lepton g minus two within acceptable limits for both normal and inverted hierarchies >
Mira: It’s about showing how a modular symmetry can impose structure on neutrino mixing, which is a really neat way to get predictive results for those flavor patterns >
Lev: The main implication is that if this kind of structure exists, it should be visible in the way neutrinos mix and the properties of dark matter we look for in experiments >
Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about radiative Dirac neutrino masses using modular S three symmetry in an axion model.
Mira: It's trying to tie together neutrino masses, flavor structure, the strong CP problem, and dark matter all into one framework.
Lev: The core idea is that you have a global u one pq symmetry combined with modular s three symmetry to unify these puzzles.
Kai: And they use vector-like fermions and scalars under su two l and a doublet of su two l to build the model structure itself.
Mira: Then they generate the neutrino masses at one loop level through an effective operator LH nu t r sigma star that gets UV completed by colored fields and scalars.
Lev: The result is a rank two neutrino mass matrix, meaning one massless neutrino in their minimal version, which they compute using color factor n c and loop integrals over masses m one and m two.
Kai: They show this mechanism can handle both normal hierarchy and inverted hierarchy for the neutrino masses.
Mira: In the normal hierarchy case, no parameter points are found within the one sigma region, and the imaginary part of tau is localized near one point seven.
Lev: For inverted hierarchy, both the real part of tau and its imaginary part are confined to narrow intervals. The sum of all neutrino masses is about fifty-eight to one hundred meV for both hierarchies.
Kai: Then they look at the axion aspect, treating it as a viable cold dark matter candidate through the misalignment mechanism.
Mira: They predict the axion decay constant fa is around five point four times ten to ten gigaparsecs, and the axion photon coupling is between three and five times ten to minus fourteen GeV negative one.
Lev: That coupling strength should be detectable by experiments like iaxo, admx, madmax, and capp.
Kai: They also checked against charged lepton flavor violation processes like muon to electron gamma transitions and lepton g minus two loop-induced contributions.
Mira: The predicted rates for those are consistent with the experimental limits, and the axion coupling is fine with existing astrophysical bounds.
Lev: So, they've built a complete picture that addresses neutrino masses, strong cp, dark matter, and flavor structure using modular symmetry.
Kai: It’s a predictive model that fits both normal and inverted hierarchies while respecting all the current experimental constraints on flavor violation and lepton g minus two.
Mira: This work provides a unified way to understand these fundamental puzzles through the lens of modular symmetry.
Lev: The next step would be to see how this framework scales when you try to build it into real hardware for error correction or dark matter detection experiments.
Seoul National University of Science and Technology · Institute for Convergence of Basic Studies, Seoul National University of Science and Technology · Department of Physics, Henan Normal University
hep-ph, hep-ex
Submitted: 2026-01-30
Updated: 2026-11-18
The gist: Radiative Dirac neutrino masses from modular S3 symmetry in an axion model presents a unified framework addressing neutrino masses, leptonic flavor structure, the strong CP problem…
Key concepts
- Modular S3 Symmetry
- This symmetry dictates how Yukawa couplings behave in the model. It organizes the leptonic flavor structure by transforming these couplings in a specific, non-trivial way under the modular group, linking flavor physics to a fundamental mathematical structure.
- Radiative Neutrino Mass Generation
- Neutrino masses are not generated directly but through a one-loop process involving exotic colored fermions and scalars. This mechanism is analogous to the scotogenic model, where interactions mediated by these particles create the neutrino mass matrix at the quantum level.
- Axion as Cold Dark Matter
- The axion emerges from spontaneous symmetry breaking and serves as a viable cold dark matter candidate through a misalignment mechanism. Its predicted decay constant and coupling strength are consistent with cosmological observations, making it a potential source for observed dark matter.
Terminology
Summary
Radiative Dirac neutrino masses from modular S3 symmetry in an axion model presents a unified framework addressing neutrino masses, leptonic flavor structure, the strong CP problem, and dark matter through a novel KSVZ-type axion model The PQ charge assignment forbids tree-level neutrino masses and leaves a residual Z3 symmetry that ensures the Dirac nature of neutrinos Exotic colored fermions and scalars mediate radiative neutrino mass generation at the one loop-level The axion emerging from this framework dynamically resolves the strong CP problem and accounts for the observed dark matter abundance
Model Construction
The model introduces a global U(1)PQ symmetry combined with a modular S3 symmetry to unify several puzzles The PQ symmetry is spontaneously broken by the vacuum expectation value (vev) of the newly added complex scalar σ, which generates the axion as a pseudo-Goldstone boson The model incorporates vector-like fermions (ΨLi, ΨRi), scalar χ, and singlets under SU(2)L and scalar η, doublet of SU(2)L The modular S3 symmetry dictates the leptonic flavor structure by promoting Yukawa couplings to modular forms that transform non-trivially under the modular group
Neutrino Mass Generation
Neutrino masses are generated radiatively at the one loop-level via the effective operator LHν ˜Rσ∗, which is UV-completed by colored fields and scalars The neutrino mass matrix is of rank two in the minimal realization, predicting one massless neutrino The resulting one loop neutrino mass matrix (mν) can be computed using a formula involving color factor Nc and loop integrals over masses M1, M2 This mechanism is analogous to that of the scotogenic model
Phenomenological Predictions
The numerical analysis shows that the model successfully accommodates both normal hierarchy (NH) and inverted hierarchy (IH) of neutrino masses In the NH scenario, no parameter points are found within the 1σ region, while Im[τ] is localized near 1.7 For IH, both Re[τ] and Im[τ] are confined to narrow intervals The sum of neutrino masses (PDν) is directly intertwined with the ∆m2atm and ∆m2sol, yielding PDν ≃ 58 (100) meV for both hierarchies
Dark Matter and Axion Coupling
The axion serves as a viable cold DM candidate through the misalignment mechanism, leading to a predicted decay constant fa ≈ 5.4 × 10 10 GeV The axion-photon coupling is predicted to be in the range gaγγ ≃ (3 − 5) × 10-14 GeV−1 This predicted coupling lies well within the sensitivity of forthcoming experiments like IAXO, ADMX, MADMAX, and CAPP
Experimental Constraints
The model's predictions for charged lepton flavor violation (cLFV) processes are calculated based on the Yukawa interactions LαΨRj η˜ The branching ratios for cLFV processes like BR(µ → eγ) are constrained by experimental limits, and the model predicts rates consistent with these bounds Similarly, loop-induced contributions to lepton g − 2 are predicted to be small, such as ∆ae ≲ 7.88 × 10-16 in the NH case The axion's coupling is consistent with existing astrophysical and cosmological bounds The model remains consistent with all existing constraints
Conclusion
In summary, the explicit model presents a predictive and experimentally accessible explanation of neutrino masses, the strong CP problem, and dark matter, unifying axion phenomenology with leptonic flavor structure via an underlying modular symmetry The framework successfully accommodates both NH and IH of neutrino masses while remaining consistent with experimental observations The axion emerging from the model simultaneously addresses the strong CP problem and constitutes a viable DM candidate across multiple cosmological scenarios This work provides a predictive explanation of these fundamental puzzles through modular symmetry The resulting predictions are fully compatible with current astrophysical and cosmological limits The explicit model presents a predictive and experimentally accessible explanation of neutrino masses, the strong CP problem, and dark matter, unifying axion phenomenology with leptonic flavor structure via an underlying modular symmetry.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved neutrino mass prediction accuracy: The model can predict neutrino mass eigenvalues using equations (15) and (16) derived from numerical analysis, allowing for precise determination of normal hierarchy (NH) versus inverted hierarchy (IH) scenarios based on atmospheric and solar mass-squared differences.
-
Enhanced flavor structure mapping: The introduction of modular S3 symmetry allows the model to predict specific lepton and quark mixing patterns by promoting Yukawa couplings to modular forms that transform non-trivially under the modular group, as discussed in Section 2.
-
Comprehensive phenomenology analysis: The system can perform a detailed numerical scan over parameter ranges, utilizing five reliable observables from Nufit6.0 to show allowed regions up to 5 sigma confidence level for both NH and IH cases.
-
Charged lepton flavor violation (cLFV) prediction: The model can calculate specific branching ratios for cLFV processes like BR(mu -> egamma) and BR(tau -> egamma) based on the derived Yukawa couplings, providing a verifiable test against experimental limits.
-
Lepton g-2 calculation: The system can compute loop-induced contributions to lepton g-2, such as deltaae and deltaa mu, which are predicted for both NH and IH scenarios based on the best-fit parameter values from Table III and Table IV.
-
Axion coupling constraint evaluation: The model can predict the axion-photon coupling ga γγ in the range of (3 to 5) x 10-14 GeV inverse, allowing researchers to verify if this prediction lies within the sensitivity of upcoming experiments like IAXO and ADMX.
Sources
- Evidence for oscillation of atmospheric neutrinos
- Direct Evidence for Neutrino Flavor Transformation from Neutral-Current Interactions in the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory
- Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters
- Verifiable Radiative Seesaw Mechanism of Neutrino Mass and Dark Matter
- Scotogenic neutrino mass with large $SU(2)_L$ multiplet fields
- Observable Signatures of Scotogenic Dirac Model
- Scotogenic dark matter and Dirac neutrinos from unbroken gauged $B-L$ symmetry
- Muon $g-2$ in $U(1)_{\mu-\tau}$ Symmetric Gauged Radiative Neutrino Mass Model
- A Radiative Neutrino Mass Model in Dark Non-Abelian Gauge Symmetry
- Observable ${\rm \Delta{N_{eff}}}$ in Dirac Scotogenic Model
- Dark $SU(2)_D$ Gauge Symmetry and Scotogenic Dirac Neutrinos
- Absolute neutrino mass scale and dark matter stability from flavour symmetry
- Scotogenic models with a general lepton flavor dependent $U(1)$ gauge symmetry
- Low Scale Leptogenesis in Singlet-Triplet Scotogenic Model
- Cutting the Scotogenic loop: Adding flavor to Dark Matter
- Dark Matter Escaping Direct Detection Runs into Higgs Mass Hierarchy Problem
- Discrete dark matter with light Dirac neutrinos
- Comprehensive Phenomenology of the Dirac Scotogenic Model: Novel Low Mass Dark Matter
- Non-Holomorphic Modular $\mathcal{A}_4$ Symmetric Scotogenic Model
- Extended Scotogenic Model of Neutrino Mass and Proton Decay
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses