Nonrelativistic versus relativistic quantum scars in billiard systems

arXiv:2601.11224 · nlin.CD · Submitted 2026-01-16 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nonlinear Sciences. The day in nonlinear science: chaos, patterns, networks and adaptation.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Nonrelativistic versus relativistic quantum scars in billiard systems".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We study the features of scarred eigenstates of relativistic neutrino billiards (NBs), graphene billiards (GBs) and Haldane graphene billiards (HGBs) and recapitulate those for nonrelativistic quantum billiards (NRQBs) with the shapes of a full- and quarter-stadium billiard The objective is to demonstrate that the properties of the scarred eigenstates observed in the full- and quarter-stadium GB do not comply with those of relativistic quantum systems Comparison of Quantum Scars The research investigates quantum scars, or more generally, scarred wave function in neutrino billiards (NBs), graphene billiards (GBs) and Haldane-graphene billiards (HGBs) with the shapes of full- and quarter-stadium billiards and compares them with those of nonrelativistic quantum billiards (NRQBs)

1–12: Scarred wave functions of the nonrelativistic billiards and spinor functions of the relativistic ones are localized along the same types of periodic orbits, the most prominent ones being bouncing-ball orbits The objective is to demonstrate that the properties of the scarred eigenstates observed in the full- and quarter-stadium GB do not comply with those of relativistic quantum systems For the GB, the semiclassical approach, spectral properties, symmetry properties and generally properties of the wave functions all comply with those of the NRQB, whereas for the HGB they agree well with those of the NB Thus, even though around the Fermi energy GBs are described by the relativistic Dirac equation, the quantum scars, or generally, the quantum scarred eigenstates observed in GBs do not exhibit those of relativistic ones Semiclassical and Spectral Analysis The study applies a semiclassical approach associated with such non-generic contributions to extract contributions from eigenvalue spectra This approach provides semiclassical trace formulas in terms of the periodic orbits associated with a scarred wave function and a procedure to extract such contributions from the eigenvalue spectra The momentum distributions and Husimi functions of such scarred states are analyzed and employed to classify scarred wave functions according to the periodic orbits along which they are localized For all measures, the features of scarred eigenstates and generally eigenstates of GBs and HGBs are well captured by those of the corresponding NRQB and NB, respectively Distinctions in System Behavior The comparison reveals specific differences between the systems based on their underlying physics.

Kai: For the GB, spectral properties, symmetry properties and generally properties of the wave functions all comply with those of the NRQB However, for the HGB they agree well with those of the NB This suggests that while GBs are described by a relativistic equation around the Fermi energy, their quantum scars do not exhibit relativistic features The final conclusion is that contrary to the general belief, the quantum scars observed in GBs do not exhibit the features, like chirality, of relativistic QBs even though they are effectively governed by the Dirac equation of relativistic spin-1/2 particles On the contrary, HGBs exhibit the features required for relativistic quantum scars Consequently, GBs do not provide a suitable model for the study of aspects of relativistic quantum chaos Experimental Realization Potential The recent proposal to simulate the Haldane model with photonic crystals provides a possibility to realize energy spectra exhibiting the particular features of NBs and thus of relativistic quantum scars experimentally Although the Haldane model has been realized experimentally on several platforms, observing quantum chaos in these systems remains challenging due to limitations in system size, boundary control, and the precise measurement of an energy spectrum Exploring alternative platforms for realizing the Haldane model represents a fruitful direction for future research Detailed Spectral Agreement The spectral properties of the full-stadium GB agree well with those of the NRQB, of which the spectrum is a superposition of The fluctuating part of the integrated spectral density resulting from scarred eigenstates of the HGB agrees very well with that of NBs This indicates that the GB like the NRQB has mirror symmetries with respect to the x and y axes The study presents a thorough study of properties of quantumscarred eigenstates of nonrelativistic quantum billiards, relativistic neutrino billiards, and of graphene and Haldanegraphene billiards and their impact on the spectral properties The researchers employ RMT and the semiclassical approach for the analysis of the spectral properties, momentum distributions and for the NRQB and NB also Husimi functions to identify and classify scarred eigenstates They find that the nongeneric contributions to the spectral density of GB are well described by the semiclassical trace formula for the corresponding NRQB derived in Ref.

4: Furthermore, they confirm that for all considered billiard systems only eigenstates that are scarred along BBOs have a perceivable impact on the spectral properties The final conclusion is that contrary to the general belief, the quantum scars observed in GBs do not exhibit the features, like chirality, of relativistic QBs even though they are effectively governed by the Dirac equation of relativistic spin-1/2 particles Key Observations on Orbit Localization The momentum distributions and participation numbers show that the enhancement of localization along BBOs, almost BBOs and orbits from the family of the bow-tie orbits is strongest for the NBs The largest values correspond to BBOs with two bounces as depicted in Fig.

Kai: 5(a) In both the NB and NRQB, the largest participation numbers correspond to BBOs with two bounces as depicted in Fig.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Nonrelativistic versus relativistic quantum scars in billiard systems". It sounds like they are comparing how wave functions behave in different kinds of quantum rooms, specifically when you go from nonrelativistic to relativistic.

Mira: Exactly. The title sets up this comparison between nonrelativistic and relativistic quantum scarring effects in different shapes of billiards. It’s about whether those specific wave function patterns we see in one type of system hold true for another type when the physics is changed to be more relativistic.

Lev: From my side, I'm interested in how they set up these models because if you want to run this on real hardware, you need a solid tight-binding model or whatever they use for the graphene lattices.

Kai: Right, and what they are really trying to show is that the properties of scarred states in full-stadium or quarter-stadium graphene billiards don't match up with what you’d expect from a relativistic system.

The paper's summary: Mira: They summarize by looking at neutrino billiards, which are relativistic, and graphene billiards, and Haldane graphene billiards. The main point is that while the nonrelativistic systems have scars localized along certain paths like bouncing ball orbits, the way those things look in the graphene systems doesn't always match up with the relativistic ones.

Kai: So they are checking if these scarring features are preserved when you introduce effects like spin-one/two particles governed by a Dirac equation, which is what happens around the Fermi energy in graphene <ref:2601.11224#pg1>.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, that distinction matters because if we assume it's relativistic when it's actually nonrelativistic, our whole error correction scheme might be based on a false assumption about the underlying physics.

Mira: They find a specific split: for graphene billiards, the spectral properties and symmetry properties match the nonrelativistic quantum billiard systems, but for Haldane graphene billiards they agree better with neutrino billiards.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest that they are using a semiclassical approach to extract information from the eigenvalue spectra. They use trace formulas based on periodic orbits associated with these scarred wave functions to pull out the contributions from those states.

Lev: That sounds like it's trying to bridge the gap between the discrete quantum states and a more continuous, classical description via those orbits, which is what we always need when building simulators.

Mira: They analyze momentum distributions and Husimi functions to classify these scarred wave functions based on which periodic orbits they are localized along. They find that for all measures, the features of the scarred eigenstates in graphene billiards and Haldane graphene billiards are well captured by those of their corresponding nonrelativistic quantum billiard or neutrino systems.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, the big conclusion is that contrary to some expectations, the quantum scars observed in graphene billiards don't show features like chirality you would expect from a relativistic quantum system, even though they are governed by a Dirac equation for spin-one/two particles <ref:2601.11224#pg1>.

Mira: And on the other hand, Haldane graphene billiards actually exhibit those features required for relativistic quantum scars. This means graphene billiards aren't a perfect model if you want to study the aspects of relativistic quantum chaos.

Lev: For real hardware, this tells us that we need to be careful about which system we model; if you treat it as fully relativistic, your simulation won't capture the right physics for those specific scars in graphene.

Kai: So they also point out that only eigenstates scarred along bouncing ball orbits have a visible impact on the spectral properties, which is important because it tells us exactly where to look when analyzing the data.

Mira: That’s what they found regarding orbit localization, and it connects back to how we classify these states using momentum distributions and Husimi functions.

Lev: So, while this is interesting theoretically, for now, the next step is figuring out how to build a model that can actually reproduce those specific features of relativistic quantum scars if we want to test them experimentally.

Barbara Dietz,  Dung Xuan Nguyen, ☓Tilen Cadež♁

Center for Theoretical Physics of Complex Systems, Institute for Basic Science (IBS) · Basic Science Program, Korea University of Science and Technology (UST) · Institute For Interdisciplinary Research in Science and Education, ICISE · Asia Pacific Center for Theoretical Physics

nlin.CD

Submitted: 2026-01-16

Updated: 2026-03-23

DOI: 10.1007/s44464-026-00018-8

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: We study the features of scarred eigenstates of relativistic neutrino billiards (NBs), graphene billiards (GBs) and Haldane graphene billiards (HGBs) and recapitulate those for nonrelativistic…

Key concepts

Quantum Scars
These are specific wave functions within a billiard system that become localized along certain periodic orbits. They represent non-generic states whose properties deviate from typical random wave functions, allowing for detailed spectral analysis.
Semiclassical Approach
This method uses mathematical formulas derived from classical mechanics, specifically trace formulas related to periodic orbits. It helps extract information about the quantum system's energy spectrum by linking it to the geometry and paths of these classical orbits.
Bouncing Ball Orbits (BBOs)
These are specific types of periodic orbits—like bouncing balls—that are crucial for understanding scar localization. The study shows that states localized along these BBOs significantly impact the spectral properties of the billiard system.
Chirality
This refers to a property related to directionality or handedness in wave behavior, often associated with relativistic systems like those governed by the Dirac equation. The paper concludes that GBs lack this feature, unlike HGBs.

Terminology

Summary

We study the features of scarred eigenstates of relativistic neutrino billiards (NBs), graphene billiards (GBs) and Haldane graphene billiards (HGBs) and recapitulate those for nonrelativistic quantum billiards (NRQBs) with the shapes of a full- and quarter-stadium billiard The objective is to demonstrate that the properties of the scarred eigenstates observed in the full- and quarter-stadium GB do not comply with those of relativistic quantum systems

Comparison of Quantum Scars

The research investigates quantum scars, or more generally, scarred wave function in neutrino billiards (NBs), graphene billiards (GBs) and Haldane-graphene billiards (HGBs) with the shapes of full- and quarter-stadium billiards and compares them with those of nonrelativistic quantum billiards (NRQBs) [1–12] Scarred wave functions of the nonrelativistic billiards and spinor functions of the relativistic ones are localized along the same types of periodic orbits, the most prominent ones being bouncing-ball orbits The objective is to demonstrate that the properties of the scarred eigenstates observed in the full- and quarter-stadium GB do not comply with those of relativistic quantum systems For the GB, the semiclassical approach, spectral properties, symmetry properties and generally properties of the wave functions all comply with those of the NRQB, whereas for the HGB they agree well with those of the NB Thus, even though around the Fermi energy GBs are described by the relativistic Dirac equation, the quantum scars, or generally, the quantum scarred eigenstates observed in GBs do not exhibit those of relativistic ones

Semiclassical and Spectral Analysis

The study applies a semiclassical approach associated with such non-generic contributions to extract contributions from eigenvalue spectra This approach provides semiclassical trace formulas in terms of the periodic orbits associated with a scarred wave function and a procedure to extract such contributions from the eigenvalue spectra The momentum distributions and Husimi functions of such scarred states are analyzed and employed to classify scarred wave functions according to the periodic orbits along which they are localized For all measures, the features of scarred eigenstates and generally eigenstates of GBs and HGBs are well captured by those of the corresponding NRQB and NB, respectively

Distinctions in System Behavior

The comparison reveals specific differences between the systems based on their underlying physics. For the GB, spectral properties, symmetry properties and generally properties of the wave functions all comply with those of the NRQB However, for the HGB they agree well with those of the NB This suggests that while GBs are described by a relativistic equation around the Fermi energy, their quantum scars do not exhibit relativistic features

Conclusion on Scarring Features

The final conclusion is that contrary to the general belief, the quantum scars observed in GBs do not exhibit the features, like chirality, of relativistic QBs even though they are effectively governed by the Dirac equation of relativistic spin-1/2 particles On the contrary, HGBs exhibit the features required for relativistic quantum scars Consequently, GBs do not provide a suitable model for the study of aspects of relativistic quantum chaos

Experimental Realization Potential

The recent proposal to simulate the Haldane model with photonic crystals provides a possibility to realize energy spectra exhibiting the particular features of NBs and thus of relativistic quantum scars experimentally Although the Haldane model has been realized experimentally on several platforms, observing quantum chaos in these systems remains challenging due to limitations in system size, boundary control, and the precise measurement of an energy spectrum Exploring alternative platforms for realizing the Haldane model represents a fruitful direction for future research

Detailed Spectral Agreement

The spectral properties of the full-stadium GB agree well with those of the NRQB, of which the spectrum is a superposition of The fluctuating part of the integrated spectral density resulting from scarred eigenstates of the HGB agrees very well with that of NBs This indicates that the GB like the NRQB has mirror symmetries with respect to the x and y axes

Summary of Findings

The study presents a thorough study of properties of quantumscarred eigenstates of nonrelativistic quantum billiards, relativistic neutrino billiards, and of graphene and Haldanegraphene billiards and their impact on the spectral properties The researchers employ RMT and the semiclassical approach for the analysis of the spectral properties, momentum distributions and for the NRQB and NB also Husimi functions to identify and classify scarred eigenstates They find that the nongeneric contributions to the spectral density of GB are well described by the semiclassical trace formula for the corresponding NRQB derived in Ref. [4] Furthermore, they confirm that for all considered billiard systems only eigenstates that are scarred along BBOs have a perceivable impact on the spectral properties The final conclusion is that contrary to the general belief, the quantum scars observed in GBs do not exhibit the features, like chirality, of relativistic QBs even though they are effectively governed by the Dirac equation of relativistic spin-1/2 particles

Key Observations on Orbit Localization

The momentum distributions and participation numbers show that the enhancement of localization along BBOs, almost BBOs and orbits from the family of the bow-tie orbits is strongest for the NBs The largest values correspond to BBOs with two bounces as depicted in Fig. 5(a) In both the NB and NRQB, the largest participation numbers correspond to BBOs with two bounces as depicted in Fig. p. 6

Where the paper says it

and ψ2(x, y) = ψ2(x, −y), ψ2(x, y) = −ψ ∗ 2 (x, −y), respectively, resulting from the mirror symmetries with respect to the x and y axes, implying that ψ1(r) and ψ2(r) are real for such scarred spinors. In both the NB and NRQB the largest participation numbers correspond to BBOs with two bounces as depicted in Fig.

5(a) They lie on a straight line

Symmetry and Chirality Effects

The Husimi functions of the NB are asymmetric with respect to the p = 0 axis, which is attributed to the BCs Eq. (4), which induce a unidirectional current and chirality along the boundary The wave functions of GB exhibit a mirror-symmetry along the central armchair axis and a slightly perturbed mirror symmetry along the central zigzag axis, and they are real for both billiard systems On the other hand, the fluctuating part of the spectral density resulting from scarred eigenstates of the HGB agrees very well with that of NBs of corresponding shape The wave functions are complex and don’t exhibit mirror symmetries as expected for the solutions of the Dirac equation Eq. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Therefore, if the spectral properties of a typical NRQB with the shape of a chaotic CB agree well with those of random matrices from the GOE, then those of the corresponding NB exhibit GUE statistics [40] if there is no mirror symmetry, otherwise GOE statistics. • Mirror symmetries The eigenfunctions of a NRQB whose shape has a mirror symmetry can be separated into symmetric and antisymmetric ones with respect to the symmetry axes, that is, they fulfill either Neumann or Dirichlet BCs along these lines.

(2)

Spectral Rigidity Comparison

For the HGB they agree well with those of the NB after separation into the symmetry classes l = 0 and l = 1 for which spectral properties are the same For the GB, its nearest-neighbor spacing distribution and its cumulant agree well with that of the full-stadium NRQB This good agreement reflects the fact that the addition of Haldane tunneling and onsite-potential of opposite sign on the sublattices A and B of a hexagonal lattice leads to a breaking of the twofold symmetry

Comparison with Relativistic Systems

The findings suggest that GBs do not exhibit the features, like chirality, of relativistic QBs even though they are effectively governed by the Dirac equation of relativistic spin-1/2 particles On the contrary, HGBs exhibit the features required for relativistic quantum scars This means that GBs do not provide a suitable model for the study of aspects of relativistic quantum chaos

Experimental Realization Direction

The recent proposal to simulate the Haldane model with photonic crystals provides a possibility to realize energy spectra exhibiting the particular features of NBs and thus of relativistic quantum scars experimentally Exploring alternative platforms for realizing the Haldane model represents a fruitful direction for future research

Final Conclusion on Scarring Impact

The authors conclude that contrary to the general belief, the quantum scars observed in GBs do not exhibit the features, like chirality, of relativistic QBs even though they are effectively governed by the Dirac equation of relativistic spin-1/2 particles On the contrary, HGBs exhibit the features required for relativistic quantum scars This means that GBs do not provide a suitable model for the study of aspects of relativistic quantum chaos The study confirms that only eigenstates that are scarred along BBOs have a perceivable impact on the spectral properties

Detailed Spectral Extraction Method

The analysis employs the semiclassical trace formula for the corresponding NRQB derived in Ref. [4] The procedure allows for the computation of contributions of BBOs and also other periodic orbits shown in Fig. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Indeed, in Ref. [4] a procedure is developed for NRQBs which allows the computation of contributions of the BBOs and also the other periodic orbits shown in Fig.

5 to the semiclassical trace formulas for the associated fluctuating part of the spectral density This is achieved by unfolding with the sum of the smooth part, i. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The connection between length spectra and POs was established within the periodic-orbit theory in the semiclassical limit ℏ → 0, which was pioneered by Gutzwiller [22, 23]. Within this semiclassical approach Gutzwiller derived for chaotic systems trace formulas for the fluctuating part of the spectral density of a quantum system in terms of a sum over the POs of the associated classical dynamic.

e. the Weyl term and the slow oscillations which are described by these trace formulas The analysis confirms that contributions from BBOs are completely extracted when comparing length spectra

Confirmation of Spectral Behavior

The comparison of length spectra reveals that both at the band edges and at the Dirac point the length spectra exhibit peaks associated with BBOs of comparable relative heights as in the NRQB and NB However, generally the peak structure differs especially for the quarter-stadium GB around the Dirac point, in the sense that additional peaks appear The slow oscillations observed for the GB are well described by Eq.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Relativistic quantum scar identification in graphene systems can be accurately predicted by comparing spectral properties to relativistic neutrino billiards (NBs) when applied to Haldane graphene billiards (HGBs). This allows AI systems to distinguish between nonrelativistic and relativistic quantum scars based on observed spectral features, as the paper shows that the scarred states of full- and quarter-stadium GBs agree with those of the NRQB, whereas those of the HGB coincide with those of the corresponding NB.

  2. Enhanced classification of wave functions can be achieved by analyzing momentum distributions and participation numbers to localize eigenstates along specific periodic orbits. The AI system can use these features to identify such scarred wave functions and spinor functions by matching observed localization patterns against known families like bouncing ball orbits (BBOs) or edge orbits.

  3. Spectral density prediction for graphene billiards can be improved by incorporating semiclassical trace formulas derived from non-generic modes, specifically the bouncing ball orbits (BBOs). The AI system can use these formulas to calculate the contributions of nongeneric modes to the fluctuating part of the spectral density which are well described by the semiclassical trace formula for the corresponding NRQB.

  4. Discrimination between different quantum system regimes can be made by analyzing Husimi functions and momentum distributions. The AI system can classify states based on these functions, as they provide information on preferred directions of the waves propagating through the billiard and help distinguish between systems where the Husimi functions of the NB are asymmetric with respect to the p = 0 axis versus those in NRQBs.

  5. Development of robust spectral analysis tools for topological phases can be facilitated by comparing length spectra derived from BBO contributions against smooth density estimates. The AI system can use this comparison to confirm that peaks located at the lengths of the BBOs are absent or suppressed in the former one for specific systems, thereby validating predictions regarding scar enhancement.

Abstract

We study the features of scarred eigenstates of relativistic neutrino billiards (NBs), graphene billiards (GBs) and Haldane graphene billiards (HGBs) and recapitulate those for nonrelativistic quantum billiards (NRQBs) with the shapes of a full- and quarter-stadium billiard. Here, we restrict for the GBs and HGBs to the region of linear dispersion around the Fermi energy, where they are effectively described by the same Dirac equation for massless spin-1/2 particles as NBs. Scarred wave functions of the nonrelativistic billiards and spinor functions of the relativistic ones are localized along the same types of periodic orbits, the most prominent ones being bouncing-ball orbits. The objective is to demonstrate that the properties of the scarred eigenstates observed in the full- and quarter-stadium GB do not comply with those of relativistic quantum systems. For this we apply the semiclassical approach associated with such non-generic contributions, which was developed for the spectral density of NRQBs and NBs. It provides semiclassical trace formulas in terms of the periodic orbits associated with a scarred wave function and a procedure to extract such contributions from the eigenvalue spectra. Furthermore, we analyze momentum distributions and Husimi functions of such scarred states and employ them to classify scarred wave functions according to the periodic orbits along which they are localized. We show that for the GB the semiclassical approach, the spectral properties, the symmetry properties and generally properties of the wave functions all comply with those of the NRQB, whereas for the HGB they agree well with those of the NB. Thus, even though around the Fermi energy GBs are described by the relativistic Dirac equation the quantum scars, or generally, the quantum scarred eigenstates observed in GBs do not exhibit those of relativistic ones.

Sources

Related papers