Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon and Schr"odinger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon and Schr"odinger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon and Schrödiger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities is a study highlighting a fundamental incompatibility between these two quantum mechanical descriptions in regimes where they should converge.
Kai: The paper demonstrates that adding a constant energy offset changes the phase velocity in quantum mechanics, leading to significantly different predictions for wave function attenuation in interferometers.
Mira: Phase Velocity Differences The core difference stems from the rest energy term present in the Klein-Gordon equation but absent in the Schrödinger equation.
Kai: The phase velocity for a free particle plane wave solution of the Schrödinger equation is defined as KE/p = vg/2.
Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up this paper, "Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon and Schrödinger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities," what we're seeing is that the total energy of a particle can be determined through measurements of how fast that phase velocity is changing.
Mira: And it also says that the shape of a wave group depends on its Fourier components, which are uniformly attenuated in the Klein-Gordon equation because they only get one transit through the beamsplitter.
Lev: This demonstrates how the phase velocity influences wave packet dynamics, and this influence happens independently of using interferometric methods.
Kai: So what this means for us is that we need to reevaluate how we interpret probability distribution functions when using the Born rule with the correspondence principle.
Mira: It really pushes us to think about how these two different descriptions interact when dealing with particles that have a non-zero rest mass, which is where the Klein-Gordon equation lives.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've seen how these two different quantum equations, the Schrödinger and Klein-Gordon ones, predict different things when you measure something with an interferometer because they move at different speeds.
Mira: Yeah, that's a core problem here because these equations should agree in some situations but they don't do so when you look at phase velocity.
Lev: From where I sit on hardware, this means if we build an experiment trying to measure one of these things using a beam splitter, the Schrödinger equation gives us one kind of attenuation while the Klein-Gordon equation predicts something totally different for how many times the wave passes through.
Kai: So it's not just a small number difference; it's about fundamental differences in how we calculate the speed of those waves themselves because of that rest energy term in the Klein-Gordon thing.
Mira: Exactly, and this discrepancy isn't just theoretical noise; it suggests a real incompatibility between these two descriptions when they should actually be matching up.
Lev: If you're trying to build a real quantum device, this points to how sensitive the measurement is to those very small differences in phase velocity that we might not even account for in our current error correction models.
Kai: It makes me wonder what this means for how we interpret the probability distribution when we use the standard Born rule with these different wave equations.
Mira: It definitely suggests that just looking at a measurement of the phase velocity isn't enough to fully understand the total energy of a particle in these relativistic scenarios.
Lev: If this holds up experimentally, it would force us to seriously reevaluate how we treat wave packet dynamics and what we think is correct about the correspondence principle.
Kai: It opens up a whole new avenue for testing which quantum description actually matches our reality when particles have mass.
Frank V. Kowalski
Physics Department, Colorado School of Mines
quant-ph
Submitted: 2026-01-12
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 7 pages, 2 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 74/100
The gist: Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon and Schrödiger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities is a study highlighting a fundamental…
Key concepts
- Phase Velocity Differences
- The two equations predict different speeds for waves. The Schrödinger equation's phase velocity is related to kinetic energy (KE/p), while the Klein-Gordon equation's includes rest energy, resulting in a speed involving the speed of light squared (c^2/vg). This difference is fundamental to their incompatibility.
- Attenuation in Beamsplitter Motion
- The differing phase velocities cause different wave function loss when interacting with a moving beamsplitter. For Schrödinger waves, attenuation occurs if the beam splitter's speed exceeds the wave's phase velocity. Klein-Gordon eigenstates do not show this attenuation because their speed limits are different.
- Wave Group Interference Outcomes
- Interference results at the output port of an interferometer depend on whether a harmonic wave or a wave group is used. The Schrödinger equation shows uniform attenuation for momentum eigenstates, while the Klein-Gordon equation predicts only one transit through the beamsplitter regardless of trajectory.
Terminology
Summary
Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon and Schrödiger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities is a study highlighting a fundamental incompatibility between these two quantum mechanical descriptions in regimes where they should converge. p. 0 Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon
and Schr¨odinger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities
Frank V. Kowalski
Physics Department, Colorado School of Mines, Golden CO. Adding a constant energy offset leaves classical dynamics unchanged. In quantum mechanics
it changes the phase velocity of the wavefunction.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Phase Velocity Differences
The core difference stems from the rest energy term present in the Klein-Gordon equation but absent in the Schrödinger equation. The phase velocity for a free particle plane wave solution of the Schrödinger equation is defined as KE/p = vg/2. p. 0 These differing
predictions restrict the validity of either adding a rest
energy term (non-relativistic Klein-Gordon equation) or
not (Schr¨odinger equation). INTRODUCTION
The phase velocity of a free particle plane wave solution (momentum eigenstate) of the Schr¨odinger equation
is ω/k = KE/p = vg/2 where KE = p
2/2m, p, and vg
are the kinetic energy, momentum, and group or particle
velocity. INTRODUCTION
The phase velocity of a free particle plane wave solution (momentum eigenstate) of the Schr¨odinger equation
is ω/k = KE/p = vg/2 where KE = p
2/2m, p, and vg
are the kinetic energy, momentum, and group or particle
velocity. In the non-relativistic limit the phase velocity
for eigenstates of momentum in the Klein-Gordon equation is, in this case, ω/k = (mc2 + KE)/p ≈ c
2/vg where
c is the speed of light. In the non-relativistic limit the phase velocity
for eigenstates of momentum in the Klein-Gordon equation is, in this case, ω/k = (mc2 + KE)/p ≈ c
2/vg where
c is the speed of light. This difference in phase velocities arises from the rest
energy term present in the Klein-Gordon eqn.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Attenuation in Beamsplitter Motion
The differing phase velocities lead to dissimilar attenuation when interacting with a moving beam splitter. The Schrödinger equation predicts an attenuation of the wavefunction along one path in a Sagnac interferometer when a beamsplitter’s trajectory includes a segment where its speed exceeds the phase velocity of a free particle. p. 0 The inclusion of the constant rest energy
in the Klein-Gordon formulation leads to significantly higher phase velocities compared with the
Schr¨odinger equation. The Schr¨odinger equation predicts an attenuation of the wavefunction along
one of the paths in a Sagnac interferometer when a beamsplitter’s trajectory along that path includes
a segment where its speed exceeds the phase velocity of a free particle. The Schr¨odinger equation predicts an attenuation of the wavefunction along
one of the paths in a Sagnac interferometer when a beamsplitter’s trajectory along that path includes
a segment where its speed exceeds the phase velocity of a free particle. Such an attenuation does
not occur for electromagnetic waves nor for eigenstates of momentum in the Klein-Gordon equation
since the speed of the beamsplitter cannot then exceed the phase velocity of the wave. This attenuation reduces the amplitude without introducing a phase shift, preserving the overall structure of
the transmitted wave group. While a Klein-Gordon wave group undergoes three traversals of the
beamsplitter that moved, it experiences attenuation equivalent to only a single pass, whereas the
Schr¨odinger equation predicts the expected attenuation for three passes.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Wave Group Interference Outcomes
The interference at the output port of the Sagnac interferometer differs between the two equations based on whether a harmonic wave or a wave group is injected. For a wave group, the Schrödinger equation shows that each momentum eigenstate experiences the same attenuation factor resulting in a distorted PDF when moving. p. 3 As the BS speed increases, this distortion decreases and
is assumed to be negligible. Each of the momentum eigenstates that form the wave
group experiences the same attenuation factor resulting For the Klein-Gordon eqn. all momentum eigenstates
experience only one transit through the BS.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Experimental Relevance and Limitations
The discrepancy highlights a fundamental incompatibility between the Klein-Gordon equation and the Schrödinger equation in regimes where their predictions should converge. While interferometric measurements provide information about phase velocity, they do not reveal the BS trajectory for EM or Klein-Gordon equations because the PDF is static. p. 5 This process can be modeled with the Schr¨odinger
equation since the particle’s energy in not altered. Interference generated at the output port of this
Sagnac interferometer provides no information about the
BS trajectory in the EM and Klein-Gordon equations
since the PDF is static. Their relative magnitudes determine the level of
attenuation. Experimental confirmation of the Klein-Gordon prediction would demonstrate that the Schr¨odinger equation
has limited validity, failing in regimes where it was previously expected to hold.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Material Media Complications
When considering plate or grating beamsplitters, complications arise due to retro-reflection and transmission through a moving medium characterized by an index of refraction. The frequency shift of transmitted wave crests is given by ∆ν = mgL(1 − n)/n¯h for neutrons propagating through such a slab. p. 3 [4]
The effect of accelerating the slab to sub-phase
velocity speeds has been calculated[6] and verified
experimentally. [7] The frequency shift of the transmitted wave crests is ∆ν = mgL(1 − n)/n¯h where m, g,
L, and n are the neutron mass, slab acceleration, slab
length, and slab index of refraction, respectively. The frequency of the wave crests (or speed of the
transmitted particle during slab acceleration) increases
or decreases for n > 1 or n < 1, respectively. A grating beamsplitter avoids these accelerating matter complications since the phases of the incident and
zeroth order diffracted beams are the same at the grating apertures.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Interpretation
The total energy of the particle is determined by such a PDF measurement of phase velocity. The wave group's shape is determined by the interference between its Fourier components, which are uniformly attenuated in the Klein-Gordon equation. This demonstrates the influence of phase velocity on wave packet dynamics, independent of interferometric methods. p. 5 In the
Schr¨odinger equation certain components escape threefold attenuation when the BS moves slower than their
phase velocity, thereby distorting the PDF. This demonstrates the influence of phase velocity on wave packet
dynamics, independent of interferometric methods. Experimental confirmation of the Klein-Gordon prediction would demonstrate that the Schr¨odinger equation
has limited validity, failing in regimes where it was previously expected to hold. The discrepancy between the
three-pass wave group traversal of the BS and the resulting single-pass attenuation of the wave group warrants
a reevaluation of how the PDF is interpreted using the
Born rule with the correspondence principle.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
REFERENCES
Bjorken, J. D., & Drell, S. p. 5 [1] Bjorken, J. , & Drell, S.Where the paper says it
Cronin, A. D., Schmiedmayer, J. p. 5 [2] Cronin, A. , Schmiedmayer, J. , Schmiedmayer, J. , & Pritchard, D. , & Pritchard, D. ,
Interference of nonzero-rest-mass particles with timevarying energy and momentum, Rev.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Kowalski, F. V., & Kowalski, B. p. 0 Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon
and Schr¨odinger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities
Frank V. Kowalski
Physics Department, Colorado School of Mines, Golden CO. & Kowalski, B. , Interference of
nonzero-rest-mass particles with time-varying energy and
momentum, Phys.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Horne, M., & Zeilinger A. p. 5 [4] Horne, M. & Zeilinger A. Interferometric discrepancy between the non-relativistic solution to the Klein-Gordon
and Schr¨odinger wave equations due to their dissimilar phase velocities
Frank V. Kowalski
Physics Department, Colorado School of Mines, Golden CO. & Zeilinger A. ,
Neutron phase shift in moving matter, Phys.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Levy-Leblond, J. M., Quantum fact and classical fiction: Clarifying Lande’s pseudo-paradox, Am. p. 5 [5] Levy-Leblond, J. , Quantum fact and classical fiction:
Clarifying Lande’s pseudo-paradox, Am.Where the paper says it
Kowalski, F. V., Interaction of neutrons with accelerating matter: test of the equivalence principle, Phys. p. 5 [6] Kowalski, F. , Interaction of neutrons with accelerating
matter: test of the equivalence principle, Phys.Where the paper says it
Frank, A. I., Interaction of neutrons with a birefringent medium moving with an acceleration, Phys. p. 5 [7] Frank, A. , Interaction of neutrons with a birefringent
medium moving with an acceleration, Phys.Where the paper says it
Balzas, N. L., The Energy-Momentum Tensor of the Electromagnetic Field inside Matter, Phys. p. 6 7
tromagnetic Field inside Matter, Phys. , 91, 408-411
(1953).Where the paper says it
Kowalski, F. V., Inquiry-based pedagogy for quantum many-body systems: examples of entanglement, quantum correlated interference, inelastic scattering, collective recoil, and asynchronous measurement, Eur. p. 6 [11] Kowalski, F. Inquiry-based pedagogy for quantum
many-body systems: examples of entanglement, quantum correlated interference, inelastic scattering, collective recoil, and asynchronous measurement, Eur.Where the paper says it
Kowalski F V., Threshold in Quantum Correlated Interference for a Particle Interacting with Two Scatterers, Ann. p. 6 [12] Kowalski, F. , Threshold in Quantum Correlated Interference for a Particle Interacting with Two Scatterers,
Ann.Where the paper says it
Kawasaki, Y., et al., Sagnac-type neutron displacement noise-free interferometeric gravitational-wave detector, Class. p. 6 [13] Kawasaki, Y. Sagnac-type neutron displacementnoise-free interferometeric gravitational-wave detector,
Class. Sagnac-type neutron displacementnoise-free interferometeric gravitational-wave detector,
Class. Quantum Grav.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Zhou, Y. and Lesanovsky, I. p. 6 [14] Zhou, Y. and Lesanovsky, I. and Lesanovsky, I. and Fernholz, T. and Fernholz, T. , Controlling the dynamical scale factor in a trapped
atom Sagnac interferometer, Phys.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved simulation of wave group interference for quantum systems by incorporating phase velocity effects, allowing prediction of attenuation based on whether a particle beam intensity is given by ISch or IKG as described in the text.
-
Enhanced ability to model wave packet dynamics when a beamsplitter moves at constant velocity, specifically predicting that
The transmitted wave crests move slower than the BS and are left behind it as shown in fig. 1(b)
for the Schrödiner equation, contrasting this with Klein-Gordon predictions wherethe transmitted wavecrests move ahead, rather than lagging behind it.
-
Development of a system capable of distinguishing between quantum mechanical predictions by measuring attenuation patterns in interferometers; specifically, the system could differentiate between
three traversals of the BS
for a wave group under the Schrödiner equation versusonly one pass through the BS
for all momentum eigenstates in the Klein-Gordon equation. -
Application of phase velocity measurements to infer physical properties like total energy; this improved system can determine
The total energy of the particle is determined by such a PDF measurement of the phase velocity.
-
Creation of a model capable of predicting frequency chirps in transmitted wave trains when interacting with an accelerating slab, as described by the relationship
∆ν = mgL(1 − n)/n¯h,
which relates acceleration to frequency increases or decreases.
Abstract
Adding a constant energy offset leaves classical dynamics unchanged. In quantum mechanics it changes the phase velocity of the wavefunction. The inclusion of the constant rest energy in the Klein-Gordon formulation leads to significantly higher phase velocities compared with the Schrödinger equation. The Schrödinger equation predicts an attenuation of the wavefunction along one of the paths in a Sagnac interferometer when a beamsplitter's trajectory along that path includes a segment where its speed exceeds the phase velocity of a free particle. Such an attenuation does not occur for electromagnetic waves nor for eigenstates of momentum in the Klein-Gordon equation since the speed of the beamsplitter cannot then exceed the phase velocity of the wave. This attenuation reduces the amplitude without introducing a phase shift, preserving the overall structure of the transmitted wave group. While a Klein-Gordon wave group undergoes three traversals of the beamsplitter that moved, it experiences attenuation equivalent to only a single pass, whereas the Schrödinger equation predicts the expected attenuation for three passes. This discrepancy highlights a fundamental incompatibility between the Klein-Gordon equation and the Schrödinger equation in a regime where their predictions should converge.
Related papers
- Computational regimes in matrix-product-state-based quantum trajectory simulations
- Toward chemically accurate quantum simulations on quantum hardware: A quantum-HPC hybrid approach
- Transversal surface-code game with reconfigurable qubits
- Fulqrum: a generalized framework for quantum subspace diagonalization
- Flux-Activated Resonant Control of a Bosonic Quantum Memory
- Machine learning the effects of many quantum measurements