Critical aging and relaxation dynamics in long-range systems
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Critical aging and relaxation dynamics in long-range systems".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper studies the dynamical scaling of long-range O(N) models after a sudden quench to the critical temperature using functional renormalization group, which is important because it characterizes both short-time aging and long-time relaxation as functions of symmetry index N, interaction range decay exponent σ, and dimension d Model Setup and Quench Dynamics The system under consideration is an O(N)-symmetric classical Hamiltonian where the non-negative matrix elements Jij decay algebraically with the distance between the sites i and j, d is the spatial dimension, σ > 0 parametrizes the range of the interactions, and Si are N-component vectors of unit length The system undergoes a sudden quench from a high-temperature disordered configuration to its critical temperature Tc at time t = t0 Short-time universality manifests as critical aging in two-point functions, characterized by G R(q, t, t′) ∼ (t/t′) θ fR(q(t − t′) 1/z, t′ / t), as shown in equation (2) The magnetization M(t) exhibits scaling M(t) = M0 t θ' fM(M0 t θ' + β/(νz)), where θ' is the initial slip exponent Renormalization Group and Exponent Calculation The functional renormalization group (fRG) approach is employed to calculate the dynamical exponent z and the aging exponent θ across the whole range of σ ∈ (0, ∞) The large-N limit yields a scaling form for the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with an aging exponent θ = 1 − d/(2σ) This result is compared to the large-N estimate of the short-range counterpart, which matches exactly if D = 2d/σ Effective Dimension Approach The effective dimension approach relates the critical properties of long-range models to a corresponding local model in dimension D = D(σ) This correspondence is extended to out-of-equilibrium systems, confirming that the aging exponent satisfies θ(σ) = θSR(D(σ)) For the two-dimensional long-range Ising model, the equilibrium critical properties are captured by this approach with an accuracy exceeding 97% Thermodynamic Advantages Long-range interactions provide a thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines by improving the scaling of the performance rate, quantified by πth = α − zν A key observation is that long-range interactions generically facilitate relaxation close to criticality by improving the scaling of τrelax, which can lead to a significantly lower dynamical exponent z compared to short-range systems Results in Specific Dimensions In one dimension (d = 1), the results for z and θ' lie between Monte Carlo points and perturbative RG predictions In two dimensions (d = 2), the aging exponent θ is shown to converge rapidly towards its large-N limit as N increases, confirming the robustness of the approach The work provides a comprehensive qualitative picture of critical long-range systems dynamics by deriving universal scaling exponents as functions of N, σ, and d The applicability of the initial slip exponent is extended to sub-critical quenches, establishing a direct link between early-time growth and long-time aging behavior Long-range interactions offer a versatile means to control the system’s dynamical evolution and achieve a thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines Appendix Details The derivation of the scaling function F(s) is obtained by evaluating integrals using the identity (F4), which leads to the critical form of the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with θ = 1 − d/(2σ) The flow equations for the renormalization functions are derived by projecting the Wetterich equation onto a truncation, leading to expressions for the anomalous dimensions ηZ0 and ηZ that determine z and θ The inverse propagator G−1 evaluated at the fixed point yields G R 0,i(t, t′) = G R eq,i(t, t′) Performance Rate Scaling The performance-rate exponent πth reaches values larger than those of the two- and three-dimensional Ising model with short-range interactions when σ is sufficiently close to the mean-field limit σmf = d/2 This finding aligns with previous studies highlighting the thermodynamic advantages of long-range interactions in quantum many-body systems Two-Dimensional O(N) Models For generic O(N) models in d = 2, the aging exponent θ = θ(σ) is shown to converge rapidly towards its large-N limit as N increases, with the approach being from below for σ < σint and from above otherwise The dynamical exponent z also reaches its mean-field limit zmf = σ as σ → d/2, independent of N Final Remarks The analysis confirms that the dimensional equivalence between long- and short-range models is not exact but yields reasonable accuracy for the Ising case The results demonstrate that tuning universal behavior through long-range interactions offers a robust pathway to thermodynamic advantage The applicability of the initial slip exponent is not confined to quenches at criticality but extends to the phase-ordering regime Acknowledgments N.
Kai: D.
Mira: is grateful to M.
Kai: Campisi for useful discussions which inspired this work V.
Title and authors: Kai: So we’re looking at this paper, "Critical aging and relaxation dynamics in long-range systems." It really dives into how these long-range models behave after a sudden quench to the critical temperature. It’s about studying both the short-time aging and the longer time relaxation as functions of several things: the symmetry index N, how far out the interactions reach, that's sigma, and importantly, it's all tied to our spatial dimension d.
Mira: Exactly. What I find interesting is how they use functional renormalization group to calculate these dynamical exponents across this whole range of parameters for N and sigma and d. That lets us really characterize the aging behavior at different scales of time and space, which is crucial for understanding non-equilibrium systems like this one one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we’re thinking about running this on real hardware, we need to know how these exponents affect the actual measurement times. The paper does a lot of work getting the numbers right by comparing their results against Monte Carlo simulations and the large N limit predictions one <ref:2601.03355#pg1,against Monte Carlo simulations and the large N limit>.
Kai: They focus a lot on the results for large N, and they get this scaling form for the response function, G R(q, t, t′), which looks like it has an aging exponent theta equal to one minus d over two sigma. That’s a specific prediction we can test against other models.
Mira: That result is particularly neat because they compare it directly to the large N estimate for short-range systems and say it matches exactly when d equals two d over sigma, which is a nice consistency check one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It tells us something about how these long-range interactions relate to local ones in certain dimensions.
Lev: But the real challenge for me is translating that theoretical scaling into what we would actually measure on a piece of hardware. The paper does touch on the effective dimension approach, relating these long-range models to a local model in a specific dimension D equal to D over sigma, and confirming that the aging exponent theta equals the short-range one calculated for that effective dimension one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>.
Kai: That mapping is pretty powerful because it lets us take equilibrium properties of a local model and use them to understand the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of these long-range systems. It suggests that even though interactions are long range, we can sometimes simplify the problem by looking at a related, simpler local system in a different effective dimension.
Title and authors: Mira: And then they show an advantage for long-range interactions in critical heat engines, suggesting they improve the scaling of the performance rate because they help relax closer to criticality one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. This leads to a lower dynamical exponent z compared to short-range systems, which is pretty significant thermodynamically.
Lev: From an error correction perspective, if we can reduce z by using long-range interactions, it means our overhead for maintaining coherence or stability in a simulation would be reduced for these types of critical dynamics one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. But they also flag that the correspondence between the effective dimension and local models isn't exact, only accurate up to about ninety-seven percent for the two dimensional long range Ising model.
Kai: That's a fair caveat. So, despite that not being perfect, the qualitative picture they give us is strong regarding how tuning sigma through these parameters can control the system’s dynamical evolution one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It’s about controlling how fast things relax.
Mira: And they also extend the initial slip exponent to sub-critical quenches, which establishes a direct link between that early-time growth behavior and the long-term aging behavior of these systems one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. That connects two different regimes of dynamics in one framework.
Lev: For our real hardware, if we're dealing with a quench that isn't perfectly critical, this extension means we have to account for how the system gets into that initial non-universal slip state before settling into the long-time scaling regime one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. That’s something you have to model carefully.
Kai: Moving on to what they suggest as improvements, one key thing is the prediction of a crossover time t cross proportional to M psi zero where psi is defined as theta prime plus beta over nu z minus one one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. This gives us a way to control the time window we are looking at when we observe these characteristic aging properties.
Mira: That’s useful for experimentalists because it tells you exactly how long you need to wait after the quench before the system settles into that universal scaling behavior. It gives you a measurable time scale, not just an abstract concept one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>.
Lev: From an implementation view, having a specific time window helps us design our measurement sequences better. If we know this crossover happens around some time t cross, we can focus our data collection on that specific intermediate regime where the scaling is most relevant for testing the theory one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>.
Title and authors: Kai: So to wrap up on what they suggest as improvements, it's really about getting a handle on when and how fast these universal behaviors kick in. It’s moving from just observing dynamics to actively controlling the time scale of those observations one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>.
Mira: And I think the biggest implication for me is confirming that tuning long-range interactions offers a versatile means to control the system’s dynamical evolution and achieves that thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It confirms this isn't just a theoretical curiosity, but has tangible physical consequences.
Lev: For error correction, if we can tune things like this, it means we might be able to engineer systems where the relaxation is faster than what short-range models allow us to achieve on real hardware one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. That’s the practical goal.
Kai: So essentially, this paper on "Critical aging and relaxation dynamics in long-range systems" gives us a set of universal scaling exponents that depend on N, sigma, and d. It characterizes both the short-time aging and long-time relaxation across these parameters one <ref:2601.03355#pg1,short-time aging and long-time relaxation>.
Mira: And they show how the large N limit predicts an aging exponent theta equal to one minus d over two sigma, which serves as a benchmark for testing functional renormalization group for O(N) models with N greater than one one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It’s a concrete prediction.
Lev: The paper also touches on performance rate scaling, specifically the exponent pi th equals alpha minus z nu, and they show that long-range interactions can lead to values larger than those of the two and three dimensional Ising model with short-range interactions when sigma is close to the mean field limit sigma mf equal d over two one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>.
Kai: So we see a clear path here. We get these scaling exponents as functions of N, sigma, and d, which helps us characterize both short-time aging and long-time relaxation one <ref:2601.03355#pg1,characterize both short-time aging and long-time relaxation>. It's a comprehensive characterization.
Mira: And they connect it to the effective dimension approach, where the critical properties of long range models are captured by a corresponding local model in dimension D equal to D over sigma one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. That’s a useful way to relate different types of physics.
Title and authors: Lev: The limitations they state are that this dimensional equivalence between long and short-range models is not exact, yielding reasonable accuracy only for the Ising case with an accuracy exceeding ninety-seven percent one. So we have to be careful about applying those local results outside of that specific context.
Kai: Overall, this work provides a comprehensive qualitative picture of critical long-range systems dynamics by deriving these universal scaling exponents as functions of N, sigma, and d one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It’s a big piece for anyone studying non-equilibrium statistical mechanics.
Mira: And it demonstrates that tuning universal behavior through long-range interactions offers a robust pathway to thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It shows how interaction range can be used to control the system’s dynamical evolution.
Lev: For me, what this means is that we have a versatile tool here. If we can use these long-range interactions to tune the dynamics, it might lead us toward achieving better performance rates on real hardware than what short-range systems allow one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>.
Kai: So, looking at the paper "Critical aging and relaxation dynamics in long-range systems," we get a framework that lets us understand how N, sigma, and d affect these dynamics. It's about characterizing both short-time aging and long-time relaxation across these parameters one <ref:2601.03355#pg1,both short-time aging and long-time relaxation>.
Mira: It’s also about connecting this to the effective dimension D equals D over sigma, which is a useful way to relate long range models to local ones in different dimensions one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. That connection is pretty important.
Lev: And remember that the accuracy of that connection is not perfect, it's only good for the Ising case when d equals two d over sigma one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. We have to be cautious about taking those results too far.
Kai: It’s a comprehensive study, and I think the main thing is that tuning these parameters allows us to control the system’s dynamical evolution one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It's a big piece for understanding how these systems behave when they're driven out of equilibrium.
Mira: And it confirms that long-range interactions offer a versatile means to control this evolution and achieve thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. It shows the physical utility of tuning sigma.
Lev: For error correction, it points toward engineering systems where we can use these long-range interactions to speed up relaxation compared to what short-range models allow us to achieve on real hardware one <ref:2601.03355#pg1>. That’s the practical goal.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to wrap up on what we just talked about, this paper is essentially mapping out how these long-range systems age and relax after they're suddenly shocked at their critical temperature using functional renormalization group calculations across different dimensions and interaction ranges.
Mira: Right. It’s like they’re creating a universal rulebook for how these systems behave when you change the size of the interactions or the dimension you're in, which is pretty deep stuff for non-equilibrium physics.
Lev: I see it as finding a way to predict system behavior without having to run simulations on every single possible combination of those parameters, which saves massive amounts of compute time for real hardware testing.
Kai: That’s what the paper aims for, it’s giving us these scaling exponents—like theta and z—that depend on N, sigma, and d. And they show how this helps us understand both the very short-term aging and the long-term relaxation behavior simultaneously.
Mira: What I find really compelling is that they link these long-range systems to a local model in an effective dimension D equal to D over sigma. It suggests that you can take equilibrium physics from a simpler, local system and use it to predict the dynamics of these more complex, long-range ones.
Lev: That connection is useful, but we gotta remember they admit the dimensional equivalence isn't perfect; they say it only works with about ninety seven percent accuracy for the two dimensional Ising model when d equals two d over sigma. So we have to be careful when we try to apply those local results outside of that specific setup.
Kai: Exactly, so while the theory is powerful for setting up the framework, we need those caveats when we actually try to build something with superconducting qubits or whatever hardware I'm working on.
Mira: And it’s not just about the scaling exponents; they also show a thermodynamic advantage for long-range interactions in critical heat engines by improving how fast things relax near that critical point, which can lead to a lower dynamical exponent z compared to short-range systems.
The paper's summary: Lev: Lower z means less overhead for us when we think about running these kinds of simulations on actual quantum hardware; it’s a real practical benefit if the scaling holds up.
Kai: So what this paper really changes for us is giving us a more controlled way to tune the system's evolution by just tweaking the interaction range, which gives us more knobs to turn than we thought.
Mira: It confirms that tuning these long-range interactions is a versatile means to control the dynamics and achieve that thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines, which shows it has tangible physical consequences beyond just abstract math.
Lev: For my work on error correction, this suggests we might be able to engineer systems where the relaxation happens faster than what short-range models allow us to achieve on real hardware, which is the practical goal for me.
Kai: So basically, it’s a comprehensive framework that gives us these universal scaling exponents as functions of N, sigma, and d that characterize both short-time aging and long-term relaxation across those parameters.
Mira: And they show how the large N limit predicts an aging exponent equal to one minus d over two sigma, which serves as a concrete benchmark for testing functional renormalization group calculations for O(N) models where N is bigger than one.
Lev: That specific prediction is something we can use to test our models, but remember that the mathematical derivation relies on certain assumptions about the system's dynamics.
Kai: So overall, this work provides a solid qualitative picture of how critical long-range systems behave by deriving these universal scaling exponents across all those parameters.
Mira: It’s also important because it connects the initial slip exponent to sub-critical quenches, establishing a direct link between that early time growth and the long time aging behavior.
Lev: That means we have to account for how the system gets into that initial non-universal slip state before it settles into the long term scaling regime, which is something you have to model carefully in a simulation.
Kai: Moving forward, they also suggest a way to control the time window during which we observe these characteristic aging properties by finding a crossover time proportional to M psi zero where psi is defined by theta prime plus beta over nu z minus one.
The paper's summary: Mira: That crossover time gives us something measurable, not just an abstract concept, so it tells us exactly how long we need to wait after the quench before the system really starts behaving in that universal way.
Lev: Having that specific time window helps us design our measurement sequences better; we can focus our data collection on that intermediate regime where the scaling is most relevant for testing the theory.
Kai: So, it’s about moving from just observing dynamics to actually controlling *when* and *how fast* those universal behaviors kick in.
Mira: And I think it confirms that long-range interactions offer a versatile means to control this evolution and achieve that thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines, showing the physical utility of tuning sigma.
Lev: If we can use these long-range interactions to tune the dynamics, it might lead us toward achieving better performance rates on real hardware than what short-range models allow us to achieve.
Kai: So looking at this paper, we get a framework that lets us understand how N, sigma, and d affect these dynamics by characterizing both short-time aging and long-term relaxation across those parameters.
Mira: It’s also about connecting this to the effective dimension D equal to D over sigma, which is a useful way to relate long range models to local ones in different dimensions.
Lev: Remember that the accuracy of that connection isn't perfect; it's only good for the Ising case when d equals two d over sigma, so we have to be careful about applying those local results too far.
Kai: It’s a comprehensive study, and I think the main thing is that tuning these parameters allows us to control the system’s dynamical evolution.
Mira: It shows how interaction range can be used to control this evolution and achieve thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines, proving it has physical utility beyond just abstract math.
Lev: For me, what this means is that we have a versatile tool here; if we can use these long-range interactions to tune the dynamics, it might lead us toward achieving better performance rates on real hardware than what short-range systems allow.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, to wrap up on what we just discussed about the core results, the paper actually suggests some ways to improve how we can use this long-range model framework for other things.
Mira: Right. They're not just stopping at calculating those exponents; they’re looking at how you can get better control over time itself in these non-equilibrium setups.
Lev: I mean, the idea of the crossover time being proportional to M psi zero, where psi is defined by theta prime plus beta over nu z minus one, that gives us a concrete way to pinpoint exactly when we should stop looking at the initial slip behavior and start seeing the long-term aging scaling.
Kai: That’s useful for experimentalists because it tells you exactly how long you need to wait after the quench before things settle into that universal scaling behavior.
Mira: I think that makes a big difference because it gives us a measurable time scale, instead of just an abstract concept for when the system starts behaving predictably.
Lev: From my side, having that specific time window helps us design our measurement sequences better; we can focus our data collection on that intermediate regime where the scaling is most relevant for testing the theory.
Kai: So it’s about getting a handle on *when* and *how fast* these universal behaviors kick in, which gives us a way to actively control the time scale of our observations.
Mira: And I think this whole set of improvements points toward using long-range interactions not just for understanding dynamics, but as a tool to actively manage the system’s evolution itself.
Lev: That means we can engineer systems where we can use those long-range interactions to speed up relaxation compared to what short-range models allow us to achieve on real hardware.
Kai: So the implication is that if we tune sigma correctly, it might lead us toward engineering systems with much faster relaxation times than what traditional short-range setups enable.
Mira: It really shows that long-range interactions offer a versatile means to control this evolution and achieve that thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines, confirming this isn't just a theoretical curiosity.
Lev: That’s the practical goal for error correction research; if we can tune things like this, it might lead us toward engineering systems where relaxation is faster than what short-range models allow us to achieve.
Kai: So in short, the paper gives us a set of tools—scaling exponents and control mechanisms—that let us understand how N, sigma, and d affect these dynamics across both time scales.
Conclusion: Tom: So to wrap up on what we've been hearing about "Critical aging and relaxation dynamics in long-range systems," this paper gives us a way to map out the universal scaling exponents for these models across different dimensions and interaction ranges.
Kai: It really shows how the symmetry index N, that sigma, and our dimension d all affect both short-time aging and long-time relaxation.
Mira: What I think is important is that they connect these dynamics to an effective local model in a different dimension D equal to D over sigma, which gives us a new way to relate complex long-range physics back to simpler local models.
Lev: That connection is useful, but remember they admit the dimensional equivalence isn't perfect; it only works with about ninety seven percent accuracy for the two dimensional Ising model when d equals two d over sigma.
Kai: So while the theory is powerful for setting up the framework, we gotta be careful when we try to apply those local results outside of that specific setup.
Mira: And they also show a thermodynamic advantage for long-range interactions in critical heat engines by improving how fast things relax near that critical point, which can lead to a lower dynamical exponent z compared to short-range systems.
Lev: Lower z means less overhead for us when we think about running these kinds of simulations on actual quantum hardware; it’s a real practical benefit if the scaling holds up.
Kai: So what this paper really changes for us is giving us a more controlled way to tune the system's evolution by just tweaking the interaction range, which gives us more knobs to turn than we thought.
Mira: It confirms that tuning these long-range interactions is a versatile means to control this evolution and achieve that thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines, showing it has tangible physical consequences.
Lev: For my work on error correction, this suggests we might be able to engineer systems where we can use those long-range interactions to speed up relaxation compared to what short-range models allow us to achieve on real hardware.
Kai: So in short, the paper gives us a comprehensive framework that gives us universal scaling exponents as functions of N, sigma, and d that characterize both short-time aging and long-term relaxation across those parameters.
Mira: It’s also important because it connects the initial slip exponent to sub-critical quenches, establishing a direct link between that early time growth and the long time aging behavior.
Lev: That means we have to account for how the system gets into that initial non-universal slip state before it settles into the long term scaling regime, which is something you have to model carefully in a simulation.
Kai: Moving forward, they also suggest a way to control the time window during which we observe these characteristic aging properties by finding a crossover time proportional to M psi zero where psi is defined by theta prime plus beta over nu z minus one.
Mira: That crossover time gives us something measurable, not just an abstract concept for when the system starts behaving in that universal way.
Lev: Having that specific time window helps us design our measurement sequences better; we can focus our data collection on that intermediate regime where the scaling is most relevant for testing the theory.
Kai: So it’s about getting a handle on *when* and *how fast* these universal behaviors kick in, which gives us a way to actively control the time scale of our observations.
Mira: That whole discussion boils down to how long-range interactions give us more flexibility in controlling the system's non-equilibrium evolution.
Lev: If we can use those long-range interactions to tune the dynamics, it might lead us toward engineering systems with much faster relaxation times than what traditional short-range setups enable.
Kai: So looking at "Critical aging and relaxation dynamics in long-range systems," we get a framework that lets us understand how N, sigma, and d affect these dynamics by characterizing both short-time aging and long-term relaxation across those parameters.
Mira: It’s also about connecting this to the effective dimension D equal to D over sigma, which is a useful way to relate long range models to local ones in different dimensions.
Lev: Remember that the accuracy of that connection isn't perfect; it's only good for the Ising case when d equals two d over sigma, so we have to be careful about applying those local results too far.
Institut für Theoretische Physik, ETH Zürich · Institut für Theoretische Physik, Universit่t Heidelberg
cond-mat.stat-mech
Submitted: 2026-01-06
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 21 pages, 5 figures
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 8, 043144 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/31g2-slsh
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: The paper studies the dynamical scaling of long-range O(N) models after a sudden quench to the critical temperature using functional renormalization group…
Key concepts
- Functional Renormalization Group (fRG)
- This is a theoretical tool used to study how physical properties of a system change as you look at different length scales. It helps calculate universal scaling exponents by tracking the flow of correlation functions, allowing researchers to understand the critical dynamics across various interaction ranges and dimensions.
- Dynamical Scaling
- This describes how physical quantities in a system behave when time and space are scaled together near a critical point. In this paper, it is used to characterize both short-time aging (early behavior) and long-time relaxation (later behavior) after the system is suddenly quenched to its critical temperature.
- Aging Exponent ($ heta$)
- This exponent quantifies the rate at which a system ages or relaxes over time after being driven out of equilibrium. For long-range models, the paper finds $\theta = 1 - d/(2\sigma)$, linking this behavior directly to the spatial dimension and interaction range.
- Effective Dimension ($D$)
- This concept relates a complex long-range model to a simpler local model in a different, effective spatial dimension. By mapping properties onto this effective dimension, researchers can use known results from simpler models to predict the critical behavior of the long-range system.
Terminology
Summary
The paper studies the dynamical scaling of long-range O(N) models after a sudden quench to the critical temperature using functional renormalization group, which is important because it characterizes both short-time aging and long-time relaxation as functions of symmetry index N, interaction range decay exponent σ, and dimension d
Model Setup and Quench Dynamics
The system under consideration is an O(N)-symmetric classical Hamiltonian where the non-negative matrix elements Jij decay algebraically with the distance between the sites i and j, d is the spatial dimension, σ > 0 parametrizes the range of the interactions, and Si are N-component vectors of unit length The system undergoes a sudden quench from a high-temperature disordered configuration to its critical temperature Tc at time t = t0 Short-time universality manifests as critical aging in two-point functions, characterized by G R(q, t, t′) ∼ (t/t′) θ fR(q(t − t′) 1/z, t′ / t), as shown in equation (2) The magnetization M(t) exhibits scaling M(t) = M0 t θ' fM(M0 t θ' + β/(νz)), where θ' is the initial slip exponent
Renormalization Group and Exponent Calculation
The functional renormalization group (fRG) approach is employed to calculate the dynamical exponent z and the aging exponent θ across the whole range of σ ∈ (0, ∞) The large-N limit yields a scaling form for the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with an aging exponent θ = 1 − d/(2σ) This result is compared to the large-N estimate of the short-range counterpart, which matches exactly if D = 2d/σ
Effective Dimension Approach
The effective dimension approach relates the critical properties of long-range models to a corresponding local model in dimension D = D(σ) This correspondence is extended to out-of-equilibrium systems, confirming that the aging exponent satisfies θ(σ) = θSR(D(σ)) For the two-dimensional long-range Ising model, the equilibrium critical properties are captured by this approach with an accuracy exceeding 97%
Thermodynamic Advantages
Long-range interactions provide a thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines by improving the scaling of the performance rate, quantified by πth = α − zν A key observation is that long-range interactions generically facilitate relaxation close to criticality by improving the scaling of τrelax, which can lead to a significantly lower dynamical exponent z compared to short-range systems
Results in Specific Dimensions
In one dimension (d = 1), the results for z and θ' lie between Monte Carlo points and perturbative RG predictions In two dimensions (d = 2), the aging exponent θ is shown to converge rapidly towards its large-N limit as N increases, confirming the robustness of the approach
Conclusions and Future Directions
The work provides a comprehensive qualitative picture of critical long-range systems dynamics by deriving universal scaling exponents as functions of N, σ, and d The applicability of the initial slip exponent is extended to sub-critical quenches, establishing a direct link between early-time growth and long-time aging behavior Long-range interactions offer a versatile means to control the system’s dynamical evolution and achieve a thermodynamic advantage in critical heat engines
Appendix Details
The derivation of the scaling function F(s) is obtained by evaluating integrals using the identity (F4), which leads to the critical form of the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with θ = 1 − d/(2σ) The flow equations for the renormalization functions are derived by projecting the Wetterich equation onto a truncation, leading to expressions for the anomalous dimensions ηZ0 and ηZ that determine z and θ The inverse propagator G−1 evaluated at the fixed point yields G R 0,i(t, t′) = G R eq,i(t, t′)
Performance Rate Scaling
The performance-rate exponent πth reaches values larger than those of the two- and three-dimensional Ising model with short-range interactions when σ is sufficiently close to the mean-field limit σmf = d/2 This finding aligns with previous studies highlighting the thermodynamic advantages of long-range interactions in quantum many-body systems
Two-Dimensional O(N) Models
For generic O(N) models in d = 2, the aging exponent θ = θ(σ) is shown to converge rapidly towards its large-N limit as N increases, with the approach being from below for σ < σint and from above otherwise The dynamical exponent z also reaches its mean-field limit zmf = σ as σ → d/2, independent of N
Final Remarks
The analysis confirms that the dimensional equivalence between long- and short-range models is not exact but yields reasonable accuracy for the Ising case The results demonstrate that tuning universal behavior through long-range interactions offers a robust pathway to thermodynamic advantage The applicability of the initial slip exponent is not confined to quenches at criticality but extends to the phase-ordering regime
Acknowledgments
N. D. is grateful to M. Campisi for useful discussions which inspired this work V. p. 5 P. acknowledges G. Piccitto for her useful comments on the role of fluctuations in critical heat engines This research was funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) grant numbers 200021–207537 and 200021–236722, by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under Germany’s Excellence Strategy EXC2181/1-390900948 (the Heidelberg STRUCTURES Excellence Cluster) and the Swiss State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SERI)
Appendix A Summary
In the large-N limit, the Gaussian correlators are provided, and a self-consistent procedure based on equation (13) is outlined to determine the scaling behavior The critical form of the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with θ = -γ/2 = 1 − d/(2σ), is obtained The only solution allowed by the condition γ > -1 in equation (A6) is γ = −ϵ/σ = d/σ − 2
Appendix B Summary
The variation of the ansatz (24) leads to relations for δϕiΓ and δϕ˜iΓ, which form the Hessian matrix Γ(2) The flow of Z0 is determined by a complex expression involving momentum integrals, where in the approximation where omegak = Zk = Z0,k we find η(m)Z0 = −Z q ∂κR2 (3U''k(ρ) + 12ρU(3)k(ρ) + 4ρ 2U(4)k(ρ)) The flow of Ω is found to be approximately time-independent, suggesting that deviations from the fluctuation-dissipation theorem decay exponentially fast in time
Appendix C Summary
The inverse propagator G−1 evaluated for Φu = (√2ρmin, 0,..., 0) becomes field-independent and equal to G−1 0, since V vanishes The long-time correlation function is obtained as G R 0,i(t, t′) = G R eq,i(t, t′)
Appendix D Summary
The flow of Z0 is determined by a complex expression involving momentum integrals that can be split into two parts to find the variation at the time-boundary t' = t0 The calculation yields the critical form of the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with θ = -γ/2 = 1 − d/(2σ) The flow of Ω is found to be approximately time-independent, suggesting that deviations from the fluctuation-dissipation theorem decay exponentially fast in time
Appendix E Summary
The threshold functions L(d,σ)n (w) are defined using the dimensionless variable ˜y ≡ qσ/kσ and auxiliary quantities s(˜y) and p(˜y)) If the flat cutoff is chosen, the corresponding threshold functions reduce to well-known functions of the theory with momentum dependence ∼ q squared [82]
Appendix F Summary
Using the identity (F4), it is found that J = χ(Φ(t0)) 1/ϖ + f'(0) ϖ squared + f''(0) ϖ cubed +... = 1 + a/2 + b/2 ϖ χ(Φ(t0)) +... The flow of Z0 is determined by a complex expression involving momentum integrals that can be split into two parts to find the variation at the time-boundary t' = t0 The calculation yields the critical form of the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with θ = -γ/2 = 1 − d/(2σ) The flow of Ω is found to be approximately time-independent, suggesting that deviations from the fluctuation-dissipation theorem decay exponentially fast in time The inverse propagator G−1 evaluated for Φu = (√2ρmin, 0,..., 0) becomes field-independent and equal to G−1 0
The long-time correlation function is obtained as G R 0,i(t, t′) = G R eq,i(t, t′) The correction to the equilibrium response function breaks time-translation invariance and vanishes in the limit t0 → −∞ or t + t′ → ∞
The flow of Z is determined by a complex expression involving momentum integrals that can be split into two parts to find the variation at the time-boundary t' = t0 The calculation yields the critical form of the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with θ = -γ/2 = 1 − d/(2σ) The flow of Ω is found to be approximately time-independent, suggesting that deviations from the fluctuation-dissipation theorem decay exponentially fast in time
Using the identity (F4), it is found that J = χ(Φ(t0)) 1/ϖ + f'(0) ϖ squared + f''(0) ϖ cubed +... = 1 + a/2 + b/2 ϖ χ(Φ(t0)) +... The flow of Z0 is determined by a complex expression involving momentum integrals that can be split into two parts to find the variation at the time-boundary t' = t0 The calculation yields the critical form of the response function G R(q, t, t′) = ϑ(t − t′)(t/t′) θ e−qσ (t−t′), with θ = -γ/2 = 1 − d/(2σ) The flow of Ω is found to be approximately time-independent, suggesting that deviations from the fluctuation-dissipation theorem decay exponentially fast in time The inverse propagator G−1 evaluated for Φu = (√2ρmin, 0,...
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved prediction of dynamical exponents z and theta for long-range O(N) models by using functional renormalization group to calculate them for all values of N, interaction range decay exponent sigma, and dimension d. This allows for characterization of both short-time aging and long-time relaxation as a function of these parameters.
-
Ability to predict the performance rate exponent pi th = alpha - z nu with precision using the calculation of what is dubbed 'performance-rate exponent' pi th = alpha - z nu, demonstrating a thermodynamic advantage over local active media.
-
Enhanced ability to map short-range critical exponents onto long-range models using an effective dimension D that enables the reconstruction of equilibrium properties from a corresponding local model in dimension D.
-
Precise calculation of the aging exponent theta for long-range O(N) models using the large N limit, finding θ = 1 - d over 2 sigma, which serves as a benchmark for testing functional renormalization group for O(N) models with N greater than 1.
-
Determination of the crossover time tcross through the relation tcross proportional to M psi 0 where psi is defined as [theta prime + beta over nu z] minus one, allowing control over the time window during which characteristic aging properties are observed.
Sources
- Dynamics of glassy systems
- Critical behavior of the Ising model with long range interactions
- One-dimensional long-range Ising model: two (almost) equivalent approximations
- Long range to short range crossover in one dimension
Related papers
- Emergent long-tail dynamics in driven magnets with dynamical frustration
- Statistical Mechanics of Dynamical System Identification
- Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems
- Chemical potentials from structure factors: II. Charged multi-component mixtures
- Genuine quantum scars in Floquet chaotic many-body systems
- Stochastic Thermodynamics for Autoregressive Generative Models: A Non-Markovian Perspective