RIS-Aided Spatial Nulling for Reflector Antennas: Algorithms, Analysis, and Nulling Limits

arXiv:2512.18426 · eess.SP · Submitted 2025-12-20 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Electrical Engineering. The day in electrical engineering: signals, systems and the hardware that carries them.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "RIS-Aided Spatial Nulling for Reflector Antennas".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) are being investigated as an auxiliary mechanism for spatial interference nulling in large ground-based reflector antennas to mitigate sidelobe interference Problem Motivation The work investigates RIS-equipped reflector antennas as a representative example of RIS-assisted spatial nulling and develop algorithms for sidelobe cancellation at specific directions and frequencies under various constraints.

Rosa: This is motivated by the growing density of satellites and terrestrial emitters, necessitating algorithms with faster convergence speed and better performance.

Dev: Traditional interference mitigation methods often rely on time/frequency blanking or feed arrays, which are ineffective if the interference aligns with sidelobe peaks.

Rosa: Algorithm Development The authors adapt projection-based methods like gradient projection (GP) and alternating projection (AP) for scalability and propose a closed-form near-optimal solution for the continuous-phase case.

Paper summary: Rosa: So what does this whole thing mean for us if we take this paper, "RIS-Aided Spatial Nulling for Reflector Antennas: Algorithms, Analysis, and Nulling Limits", as a whole? It’s about finding a practical way to use RIS to fight sidelobe interference in massive antennas.

Dev: It boils down to the fact that they found a clear mathematical boundary—that infinite norm of the optimal unconstrained weights being less than square root two—which tells us when we can actually expect those near-perfect nulls using simple, manageable algorithms.

Taro: So for someone who only cares about how this changes things, it means we have a way to determine if our system is even capable of achieving that high level of interference suppression without needing some overly complicated, slow optimization routines.

Rosa: Right. It moves the conversation from just "can we do it?" to "under what mathematical condition can we expect success with this kind of setup."

Dev: It provides a concrete metric for when the effort you put into setting up those RIS elements will actually translate into meaningful gain in suppressing sidelobe interference.

Taro: I think the real impact is showing that these specific algorithms, like EXPP, are more robust than some other optimization techniques when we're testing this in a real-world simulation environment.

Rosa: So the authors confirm that their proposed techniques work well and they meet those theoretical nulling limits they established for this type of antenna system.

Conclusion: Rosa: So this paper, "RIS-Aided Spatial Nulling for Reflector Antennas: Algorithms, Analysis, and Nulling Limits," basically wraps up how you use those reconfigurable surfaces to clean up interference from big antennas.

Dev: It does show that with the right setup—specifically when the math condition holds—you can get really good sidelobe suppression on a large reflector antenna.

Taro: What they found is a specific mathematical limit, related to how correlated those electric field vectors are, that tells you if you even have a shot at getting those perfect nulls.

Rosa: It’s about checking the size of this correlation term against some number, like square root two. If it’s smaller than that number, they say you can find a solution with straightforward algorithms.

Dev: That's the safety case for us; we get to use simpler optimization methods instead of needing something incredibly complex just to achieve a decent result.

Taro: The authors tested this by simulating an eighteen meter diameter reflector and showed that their proposed EXPP algorithm actually found a good spot consistently within three thousand iterations, which is better than some of the other searching methods they compared it against.

Rosa: So the practical side is solid; they show that the tools they built work in a real simulation environment for this kind of antenna setup.

Dev: But there's still stuff to consider on the hardware side, like how fast that loop runs and what happens when the actual interference doesn't perfectly match the model they used.

Taro: Exactly, because we need to know what happens when the world misbehaves and you have to recover quickly.

Rosa: So while this paper proves it’s possible under certain conditions, we still need to figure out how reliable that performance is when things get messy outside the lab.

Virginia Tech

eess.SP

Submitted: 2025-12-20

Updated: 2026-11-12

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) are being investigated as an auxiliary mechanism for spatial interference nulling in large ground-based reflector antennas to mitigate sidelobe interference…

Key concepts

Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS)
RIS are smart surfaces made of many small elements that can electronically control the phase and amplitude of incoming radio waves. In this context, they act as a programmable mirror to intelligently redirect signals, allowing them to precisely shape the antenna's radiation pattern to suppress unwanted interference.
Spatial Nulling
Spatial nulling is a technique used in antenna design where the antenna pattern is specifically shaped so that it has very low gain in certain directions. This allows the system to effectively ignore or cancel signals arriving from specific sources, such as interfering satellites or emitters.
Unimodular Weights
Weights are complex numbers assigned to each element of the RIS that determine how much each element contributes to the final signal manipulation. Unimodular weights mean these weights have a magnitude (or modulus) of exactly one, which is often used in phase-only control schemes for beamforming.
Infinite Norm of Optimal Weights
This is a mathematical measure that quantifies the overall magnitude or spread of the optimal weight solution found by the algorithms. The paper establishes a critical limit ($\sqrt{2}$) for this norm; if it stays below this value, a nearly perfect null can be achieved using simple algorithms.

Terminology

Summary

Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) are being investigated as an auxiliary mechanism for spatial interference nulling in large ground-based reflector antennas to mitigate sidelobe interference

Problem Motivation

The work investigates RIS-equipped reflector antennas as a representative example of RIS-assisted spatial nulling and develop algorithms for sidelobe cancellation at specific directions and frequencies under various constraints. This is motivated by the growing density of satellites and terrestrial emitters, necessitating algorithms with faster convergence speed and better performance. p. 0 Traditional interference mitigation methods often rely on time/frequency blanking or feed arrays, which are ineffective if the interference aligns with sidelobe peaks. p. 0

Algorithm Development

The authors adapt projection-based methods like gradient projection (GP) and alternating projection (AP) for scalability and propose a closed-form near-optimal solution for the continuous-phase case. For the discrete-phase case, they reformulate the problem using a penalty method and solve it via majorization–minimization, which outperforms heuristic methods. p. 0 They also derive a closed-form expression for approximate optimal unimodular weights for the continuous-phase solution to reduce computation time. p. 1

Nulling Limits and Constraints

The analysis examines the nulling limits of RIS-equipped reflector antennas by examining the electric field characteristics across multiple interference directions and frequencies. They identify a simple criterion for the existence of unimodular weights enabling perfect nulls, showing that finding such a solution becomes increasingly difficult as the correlation between electric field intensity vectors grows. p. 1 The paper shows that perfect nulling is feasible if the infinite norm of the unconstrained optimal weights is less than approximately √2. p. 7

Numerical Validation

Simulation results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed methods and confirm theoretical nulling limits. Numerical evaluations on an 18m diameter reflector showed that continuous-phase unimodular weights provide significantly suppressed sidelobe gain along a satellite's trajectory. The EXPP algorithm was found to consistently converge to a good stationary point within 10 cubed iterations, outperforming simulated annealing. p. 9 The achievable gains under different weight constraints are summarized in Table I. p. 9

Conclusion

In conclusion, RIS-equipped reflector antennas can provide excellent performance for interference mitigation provided that the infinite norm of the optimal unconstrained weights is less than √2. This criterion allows for determining when a unimodular weight solution which provides nearly perfect nulls can be found using straightforward algorithms. p. 8 The proposed techniques validate the theoretical limits and demonstrate effectiveness for interference mitigation in challenging environments. p. 0

Appendix A

Derivation of the Correlation Coefficient

Since the interference is non-negligible for the first few sidelobes which correspond to small zenith angles ψ, the co-pol direction is primarily aligned with yˆ. Under this assumption, equations (5), (12) and (13) indicate that the n-th element of two electric field intensity vectors only differs by a phase shift, which can be written as cn ≈ exp −j(β2 − β1)ρn 4f+ f exp jβ2ρn cos(ϕ′n) sin(ψ2) cos(ϕ2)+ β2ρn sin(ϕ′n) sin(ψ2) sin(ϕ2)) + ρ 2 n 4fβ1 cos(ψ1)− β1ρn cos(ϕ′n) sin(ψ1) cos(ϕ1)—β1ρn sin(ϕ′n) sin(ψ1) sin(ϕ1)) exp −j∆β ρ2 n 4f+ f exp jρ2 n[cos(ϕ′n)(β2 sin(ψ2 cos(ϕ2) − β1 sin(ψ1 cos(phi i))) + sin(phi'n)(β2 sin ψ i sin phi i))])exp (−j∆βf).

Appendix B

Proof of Lemma 1

The Courant–Fischer theorem provides the following bound for the eigenvalues of two Hermitian matrices X and Y: λi(X) − λi(Y) ≤∥ X − Y ∥, ∀ i. In our case, let D = diag AAH, which only contains the diagonal entries of AAH, and E = AAH − D, which only contains the off-diagonal entries of AAH. p. 7 Applying the inequality yields: λi(AAH) − λi(D) ≤∥E∥, ∀ i. p. 7 From the system model, the norm of ei is identical for all directions and frequencies, consequently all diagonal entries of D are equal to ei squared which is equal to the eigenvalue of D. p. 7 Substituting into (53), we obtain: ei − E ≤ λi(AAH) ≤ ei + E, ∀ i. p. 7

Appendix C

Correlation Coefficient Versus Condition Number

In the case where K = 2, matrix AAH can be expressed as AAH = ei squared e H 1 e 2 e H 2 e 1 ei squared. The eigenvalues of AAH can be determined by solving the equation: λ 2 − 2ei 3λ + ei 4 − e H ψ 1eψ 2/2 = 0. p. 7 Solving (58) yields: λ1,2 = ei cubed ± e H 1 e 2. p. 4 From the approximation used in (39), we have e H 1 e 2 ≈ Nσ 2C(e 1, e 2). p. 1 Inserting (60) in (59), the eigenvalues can be rewritten as λ1,2 = ei cubed ± Nσ 2C(e 1, e 2), which confirms the statement that a higher correlation between the electric field intensity vectors leads to a larger spread of the eigenvalues, resulting in a higher condition number. p. 7

References

[1] E. Basar, M. Di Renzo, J. De Rosny, M. Debbah, M.-S. Alouini, and R. Zhang, “Wireless communications through reconfigurable intelligent surfaces,” IEEE Access, vol. p. 0 7, pp. 116 753–116 773.

[2] C. Huang, A. Zappone, G. C. Alexandropoulos, M. Debbah, and C. Yuen, “Reconfigurable intelligent surfaces for energy efficiency in wireless communication,” IEEE Trans Wireless Commun. p. 0, vol. 18, no 8, pp 4157–4170.

[3] Q. Wu and R. Zhang, “Intelligent reflecting surface enhanced wireless network: Joint active and passive beamforming design,” in Proc IEEE Global Commun Conf (GLOBECOM), Dec 2018, pp 1–6.

[4] ——, “Beamforming optimization for intelligent reflecting surface with discrete phase shifts,” in Proc IEEE ICASSP, May 2019, pp 7830–7833.

[5] X. Tan, Z. Sun, D. Koutsonikolas, and J. M. Jornet, “Enabling indoor mobile millimeter-wave networks based on smart reflectarrays,” in Proc IEEE Conf Comput Commun (INFOCOM), Apr 2018, pp 270–278. p. 0

[6] C. Huang, G. C. Alexandropoulos, C. Yuen, and M. Debbah, “Indoor signal focusing with deep learning designed reconfigurable intelligent surfaces,” in Proc IEEE 20th Int Workshop Signal Process Adv Wireless Commun (SPAWC), Jul 2019, pp 1–5. p. 0

[7] Q. Wu and R. Zhang, “Intelligent reflecting surface enhanced wireless network via joint active and passive beamforming,” IEEE Trans Wireless Commun. p. 0, vol. 18, no 11, pp 5394–5409.

[8] B. Di, H. Zhang, L. Li, L. Song, Y. Li, and Z. Han, “Practical hybrid beamforming with finite-resolution phase shifters for reconfigurable intelligent surface based multi-user communications,” IEEE Trans Veh Technol. p. 0, vol 69, no 4, pp 4565–4570. p. 0

[9] M. A. ElMossallamy, K. G. Seddik, W. Chen, L. Wang, G. Y. Li, and Z. Han, “RIS optimization on the complex circle manifold for interference mitigation in interference channels,” IEEE Trans Veh Technol. p. 0, vol 70, no 6, pp 6184–6189. p. 0

[10] Handbook of Frequency Allocations and Spectrum Protection for Scientific Uses. p. 9 Washington DC, USA: National Academies Press, 2007. p. 0

[11] R. A. Monzingo and T. W. Miller, Introduction to Adaptive Arrays. p. 0 New York: Wiley, 1980. p. 0

[12] H.-T. Chou and H.-K. Ho, “Local area radiation sidelobe suppression of reflector antennas by embedding periodic metallic elements along the edge boundary,” IEEE Trans Antennas Propag. p. 0, vol 65, no 10, pp 5611–5616. p. 0

[13] Z. Zou, X. Wei, D. Saha, A. Dutta, and G Hellbourg, “SCISRS: Signal cancellation using intelligent surfaces for radio astronomy services,” in Proc IEEE Global Commun Conf (GLOBECOM), Dec 2022, pp 4238–4243. p. 0

[14] S. Ellingson and R. p. 0 Sengupta, “Sidelobe modification for reflector antennas by electronically reconfigurable rim scattering,” IEEE Antennas Wireless Propag Lett. p. 0, vol 20, pp 1083–1087. p. 0

[15] J. Budhu, S. V. Hum, S. Ellingson, and R. p. 0 M Buehrer, “Design of rim-located reconfigurable reflectarrays for interference mitigation in reflector antennas,” IEEE Trans Antennas Propag. p. 0, vol 72, no 4, pp 3736–3741. p. 0

[16] R. M. Buehrer and S. p. 0 W. Ellingson, “Pattern control for reflector antennas using electronically-reconfigurable rim scattering,” in Proc IEEE Int Symp Antennas Propag USNC-URSI Radio Sci Meeting (APS/URSI), Jul 2022, pp 577–578. p. 0

[17] ——, “Weight selection for pattern control of paraboloidal reflector antennas with reconfigurable rim scattering,” in Proc IEEE Aerosp Conf. p. 0, Mar 2023, pp 1–8.

[18] Z. Luo, W. Ma, A. M. So, Y. Ye, and S Zhang, “Semidefinite relaxation of quadratic optimization problems,” IEEE Signal Process Mag. p. 1, vol 27, no 3, pp 20–34. p. 0

[19] S. Smith, “Optimum phase-only adaptive nulling,” IEEE Trans Signal Process. p. 7, vol 47, no 7, pp 1835–1843. p. 0

[20] W.-S. Choi and T. Sarkar, “Phase-only adaptive processing based on a direct data domain least squares approach using the conjugate gradient method,” IEEE Trans Antennas Propag., vol 52, no 12, pp 3265–3272. p. 0

[21] J. Tranter, N. D. Sidiropoulos, X Fu, and A Swami, “Fast unit-modulus least squares with applications in beamforming,” IEEE Trans Signal Process. p. 0, vol 65, no 11, pp 2875–2887. p. 0

[22] T. Vu, R. Raich, and X Fu, “On local linear convergence of projected gradient descent for unit-modulus least squares,” IEEE Trans Signal Process. p. 0, vol 71, pp 3883–3897. p. 0

[23] R. Escalante and M. Raydan, Alternating Projection Methods. p. 0 Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, 2011, vol 8. p. 8

[24] J Liu, Y Liu, W.-K Ma, M Shao, and A M.-C So, “Extreme point pursuit—part I: A framework for constant modulus optimization,” IEEE Trans Signal Process. p. 0, vol 72, pp 4541–4556. p. 0

[25] Y Sun, P. Babu, and D. P. Palomar, “MajorizationMinimization algorithms in signal processing communications and machine learning,” IEEE Trans Signal Process. p. 0, vol 65, no 3, pp 794–816. p. 0

[26] X. Li, R. M. Buehrer, and S. p. 0 W Ellingson, “An improved weight selection algorithm for interference mitigation in paraboloidal reflector antennas with reconfigurable rim scattering,” in MILCOM 2024 - 2024 IEEE Military Communications Conference (MILCOM), 2024, pp 1–7. p. 0

[39] Defining cn = e n j/e 1,n as the ratio between the n-th elements at two electric field intensity vectors for any two given far field directions (ψ1, ϕ1) and (ψ2, ϕ2) with respective wavenumbers β1 and β2, the correlation coefficient C between e 1 and e 2 is approximated by C(e 1, e 2) ≈ 1/(N − 1) X N n=1 e n squared cn/σ squared ≈ 1/N X N n=1 cn,. p. 6

Appendix A

Derivation of the Correlation Coefficient

Since the interference is non-negligible for the first few sidelobes which correspond to small zenith angles ψ, the co-pol direction is primarily aligned with yˆ. Under this assumption, equations (5), (12) and (13) indicate that the n-th element of two electric field intensity vectors only differs by a phase shift, which can be written as cn ≈ exp −j(β2 − β1)ρ 2 n 4f+ f exp jβ2ρn cos(ϕ′n)(β2 sin ψ i cos(ϕ i)+ β1 sin ψ i cos(phi i)) + ρ 2 n 4fβ1 cos(ψ i−φ'n) sin(ψ1)cos(phi i)—β1ρn sin(ϕ′n)sin(ψ1)sin(phi i))−ρ 2 n 4fβ1 cos ψ i = exp −j∆β ρ2 n 4f+ f exp jρn[cos(ϕ′n)(β2ψ2 cos(ϕ2) − β1ψ1 cos(phi i))+ sin(phi'n)(β2ψ2 sin phi i - β1ψ1 sin phi i)]exp (−j∆βf).

Appendix A

Derivation of the Correlation Coefficient

By considering ϕ′ = ϕ′n as a random variable uniformly distributed from 0 to 2π and replacing ρn with the average radial distance for the RIS elements ρ¯ = E[ρn], the expectation of the R.H.S. of (50) can be expressed as C(e1, e2) ≈ E 1/N X N n=1 e jρn(cos(ϕ′n)a+sin(phi'n)b) e −j∆βf , = e −j∆βf 1/N X N n=1 Z 2π 0 /2π e jρn(cos(ϕ′n)a+sin(phi'n)b) dϕ′n, = J0 ρ¯ p a squared + b squared e −j∆βf,.

Appendix A

Derivation of the Correlation Coefficient

By considering ϕ′ = ϕ′n as a random variable uniformly distributed from 0 to 2π and replacing ρn with the average radial distance for the RIS elements ρ¯ = E[ρn], the expectation of the R.H.S. of (50) can be expressed as C(e1, e 2) ≈ E 1/N X N n=1 e jρn(cos(ϕ′n)a+sin(phi'n)b) e −j∆βf , = e −j∆βf 1/N X N n=1 Z 2π 0 /2π e jρn(cos(ϕ′n)a+sin(phi'n)b) dϕ′n, = J0 ρ¯ p a squared + b squared e −j∆βf,.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Gradient Projection (GP) algorithm adaptation enables scalable solutions for continuous-phase unimodular weights by providing a closed-form expression for the approximate optimal unimodular weights by exploiting structural properties unique to our problem. This significantly reduces computational time compared to iterative algorithms.

  2. Alternating Projection (AP) algorithm can be utilized for discrete-phase unimodular weights, where it is shown that it outperforming the heuristic methods from our earlier work in terms of performance under a penalty method formulation.

  3. Majorization-Minimization (MM) algorithm is proposed to solve the transformed problem with a convex constraint for discrete-phase quantization, demonstrating superior performance compared to heuristic algorithms in terms of both computational time and nulling ability.

  4. The analysis of electric field intensity correlation allows for the determination of nulling limits by showing that "finding an unimodular solution becomes increasingly difficult as the correlation between the electric field intensity from different interference directions grows—either due to larger number or smaller angular separations of the interference sources."

  5. A simple criterion for determining unimodular weights exists: we find a simple criterion for determining the existence of unimodular weights which strictly meet optimality criterion (minimizes the objective function to zero). This allows for quick determination of when perfect nulls are achievable.

  6. The system can perform interference mitigation in large ground-based reflector antennas by dynamically shaping the propagation environment through programmable reflection control, specifically targeting sidelobe cancellation at various directions and frequencies.

Related papers