Bulk signatures of re-entrant superconductivity in UTe 2 from ultrasound measurements

arXiv:2512.17691 · cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2025-12-19 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Bulk signatures of re-entrant superconductivity in UTe 2 from ultrasound measurements".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Bulk ultrasound measurements up to 80 T and down to 0.5 K of the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe2 provide clear bulk signatures of superconductivity in the longitudinal c11 elastic mode The study reports that anomalies observed in c11 are reminiscent of superconducting vortices pinned to lattice defects The heavy-fermion material UTe2 is a prominent candidate for topological spin-triplet superconductivity, evidenced by an upper critical field Hc2 exceeding the Pauli limit and the occurrence of multiple superconducting phases under magnetic field or high pressure Bulk Signatures of SC3 Phase The researchers observed anomalies in sound velocity and attenuation in the longitudinal elastic mode c11 for fields applied at a tilt angle of θb−c = 30◦ from b-axis They confirmed an upper critical field of Hc2 ≈ 65 T at 0.5 K and bulk superconductivity which survives up to T ≈ 2 K for fields above the metamagnetic transition The anomalies in c11 are attributed to the presence of superconducting vortices pinned to lattice defects, implying the existence of a bulk (mixed) superconducting state A large residual ultrasound attenuation is found across the entire superconducting phase, suggesting non-trivial vortex pinning and dynamics Vortex Dynamics and Pinning Mechanisms The excess sound attenuation throughout the superconducting phase suggests unusual vortex dynamics and pinning in the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe2 The study discusses several possible origins for the ultrasound anomalies, including coupling between the superconducting order parameter and strain, Landau-Khalatnikov (LK) relaxation of the superconducting order parameter below Tc, and coupling between superconducting vortices and the crystal lattice via vortex pinning centers The analysis suggests that while vortex dynamics seem most likely, an inhomogeneous superconducting phase or anisotropic pinning barriers could also explain some features Modeling Vortex Contributions The Thermally Assisted Flux Flow (TAFF) model is used to describe the dynamics of flux lines in type-II superconductors with strong pinning This model successfully reproduces the temperature dependence of the sound velocity below Tc, but it fails to produce the observed excess attenuation for T ≪ Tc and overestimates the sound velocity with respect to measured attenuation at low T The model also cannot reproduce the large frequency dependence observed in Fig.

Kai: S2 Heating Effects and Thermal Relaxation Possible heating effects during pulsed field studies include Joule heating due to induced eddy currents or intrinsic heat released by the sample due to quasi adiabatic conditions when passing the first order metamagnetic transition The analysis indicates that the hysteresis found inside the SC3 phase does not originate from eddy current heating, but it cannot fully rule out that part of the hysteresis is due to a temperature cycling caused by the magnetocaloric effect at Hm In summary, the ultrasound data suggest that vortices contribute to the ultrasound properties inside the SC3 phase However, some features remain puzzling, such as an excess attenuation and strong frequency dependence Both observations suggest unconventional vortex dynamics in the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe2 and require further experimental investigation The contrast with lower field superconducting phases suggests that vortex pinning is different in the field re-entrant SC3 phase Frequency Dependence Findings The frequency dependence of the hysteresis is visible in Figs.

Mira: S2 and S3, where one clearly observes that the hysteresis associated with the superconductivity in field-polarized phase SC3 increases in size by lowering the ultrasonic frequency The irreversibility field is highlighted by the dashed line HSC At the highest frequency of 388 MHz nearly no hysteretic behaviour is visible in ∆α and in ∆v/v for f ≥ 296 MHz Temperature Dependence of Anomalies The onset temperature of the ultrasound anomalies shifts towards lower T as the magnetic field is increased, similar to superconducting Tc The data for the up-sweep part of the pulse and decreasing part are shown in Fig.

Kai: S3 The onset temperature of the ultrasound anomalies shifts towards lower T, in a similar way as superconducting Tc The anomaly which is probably linked to superconductivity in the field increasing curve is highlighted by the yellow star Hup Phase Diagram Correlation The red region of the phase diagram of Fig.

Paper summary: Kai: Building on what we just heard, this paper by Marquardt et al. focuses on using bulk ultrasound to find clear evidence of superconductivity in UTe two that appears after a certain magnetic field is applied <ref:2512.17691#pg1>. They’re measuring up to eighty Tesla and down to zero point five Kelvin of the field, looking specifically at the longitudinal c11 elastic mode when they tilt the field at a thirty-degree angle from the b-axis <ref:2512.17691#pg1,and down to 0.5>.

Mira: The core thesis is that they observe clear bulk signatures of superconductivity in this mode. Specifically, they confirm an upper critical field Hc2 around sixty-five Tesla at a very low temperature of zero point five Kelvin, and this bulk superconductivity survives up to about two Kelvin for fields above the metamagnetic transition point <ref:2512.17691#pg1,for fields above the metamagnetic transition>.

Lev: What's important is their interpretation of these anomalies in the c11 mode. They attribute these signals to superconducting vortices that are pinned by lattice defects, which implies there is a bulk mixed superconducting state present.

Kai: They also found that across the entire superconducting phase, there's a large residual ultrasound attenuation, which suggests non-trivial vortex pinning and dynamics throughout this re-entrant phase of UTe two <ref:2512.17691#pg1>.

Mira: The discussion then moves into modeling these vortices, where they use the Thermally Assisted Flux Flow model to describe flux line dynamics in strong pinning superconductors. While the model fits some temperature dependencies, it doesn't fully explain all the observed features, especially the excess attenuation at very low temperatures and a certain frequency dependence they measured.

Lev: They also looked into potential experimental artifacts like heating effects from eddy currents or intrinsic heat during the metamagnetic transition. Their analysis suggests that while some hysteresis might be due to temperature cycling from the magnetocaloric effect, it doesn't fully rule out other causes for all of it.

Kai: So, in short, the paper establishes clear evidence for bulk superconductivity in UTe two under specific field and temperature conditions using ultrasound measurements <ref:2512.17691#pg1>. It sets up a picture where vortices are pinned to defects causing these sound anomalies.

Conclusion: Mira: To wrap up the "Bulk signatures of re-entrant superconductivity in UTe two from ultrasound measurements," the authors have essentially provided strong experimental evidence that superconductivity exists in this material under specific field conditions, confirmed by measurable bulk ultrasound signals <ref:2512.17691#pg1,Bulk signatures of re-entrant superconductivity in>.

Kai: They've shown that these bulk signatures are most clearly seen in the longitudinal c11 elastic mode when the field is tilted at a thirty-degree angle from the b-axis, and they quantified an upper critical field of Hc2 as approximately sixty-five Tesla at zero point five Kelvin <ref:2512.17691#pg1,in the longitudinal c11 elastic mode>.

Lev: The implication for us is that this points toward unconventional vortex dynamics in the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe two and specifically that the pinning mechanism must be different in this phase compared to lower field superconducting states <ref:2512.17691#pg1,the field re-entrant superconducting phase of>.

Kai: So, they're looking at what these findings mean for the world—it means we need to understand how these vortices behave when they are pinned in this specific magnetic field range and temperature window.

Mira: Exactly. It highlights that the physics of superconductivity isn't always simple, and that materials like UTe two can exhibit complex superconducting states with unique vortex dynamics driven by their crystal structure or impurities <ref:2512.17691#pg1>.

University of Grenoble Alpes · CEA Grenoble INP INria Toulouse University Paul Sabatier EMFL CNRS LNCMI Institute for Materials Research Tohoku University

cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2025-12-19

Updated: 2025-12-19

Comments: Supplementary material included

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 114, 264505 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/bfzx-dwmb

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 86/100

The gist: Bulk ultrasound measurements up to 80 T and down to 0.5 K of the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe2 provide clear bulk signatures of superconductivity in the longitudinal c11 elastic mode…

Key concepts

Longitudinal c11 Elastic Mode
This is a specific type of sound wave measurement used in the ultrasound experiment. Anomalies (changes) in the speed and attenuation of this mode provide direct evidence of changes occurring within the material, specifically linked to the presence and dynamics of superconducting vortices.
Superconducting Vortices Pinned to Lattice Defects
The anomalies observed are interpreted as evidence that magnetic flux lines (vortices) from superconductivity are physically stuck or 'pinned' by imperfections in the crystal structure. This pinning mechanism is a key signature suggesting the existence of a bulk superconducting state rather than just surface effects.
Thermally Assisted Flux Flow (TAFF) Model
This model is used to mathematically describe how magnetic flux lines move in superconductors that have strong pinning. While it successfully predicts some temperature dependencies, it struggles to fully explain the observed excess sound attenuation and frequency-dependent behavior seen in the experimental data.

Terminology

Summary

Bulk ultrasound measurements up to 80 T and down to 0. p. 05 K of the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe2 provide clear bulk signatures of superconductivity in the longitudinal c11 elastic mode The study reports that anomalies observed in c11 are reminiscent of superconducting vortices pinned to lattice defects The heavy-fermion material UTe2 is a prominent candidate for topological spin-triplet superconductivity, evidenced by an upper critical field Hc2 exceeding the Pauli limit and the occurrence of multiple superconducting phases under magnetic field or high pressure

Bulk Signatures of SC3 Phase

The researchers observed anomalies in sound velocity and attenuation in the longitudinal elastic mode c11 for fields applied at a tilt angle of θb−c = 30◦ from b-axis They confirmed an upper critical field of Hc2 ≈ 65 T at 0.5 K and bulk superconductivity which survives up to T ≈ 2 K for fields above the metamagnetic transition The anomalies in c11 are attributed to the presence of superconducting vortices pinned to lattice defects, implying the existence of a bulk (mixed) superconducting state A large residual ultrasound attenuation is found across the entire superconducting phase, suggesting non-trivial vortex pinning and dynamics

Vortex Dynamics and Pinning Mechanisms

The excess sound attenuation throughout the superconducting phase suggests unusual vortex dynamics and pinning in the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe2 The study discusses several possible origins for the ultrasound anomalies, including coupling between the superconducting order parameter and strain, Landau-Khalatnikov (LK) relaxation of the superconducting order parameter below Tc, and coupling between superconducting vortices and the crystal lattice via vortex pinning centers The analysis suggests that while vortex dynamics seem most likely, an inhomogeneous superconducting phase or anisotropic pinning barriers could also explain some features

Modeling Vortex Contributions

The Thermally Assisted Flux Flow (TAFF) model is used to describe the dynamics of flux lines in type-II superconductors with strong pinning This model successfully reproduces the temperature dependence of the sound velocity below Tc, but it fails to produce the observed excess attenuation for T ≪ Tc and overestimates the sound velocity with respect to measured attenuation at low T The model also cannot reproduce the large frequency dependence observed in Fig. S2

Heating Effects and Thermal Relaxation

Possible heating effects during pulsed field studies include Joule heating due to induced eddy currents or intrinsic heat released by the sample due to quasi adiabatic conditions when passing the first order metamagnetic transition The analysis indicates that the hysteresis found inside the SC3 phase does not originate from eddy current heating, but it cannot fully rule out that part of the hysteresis is due to a temperature cycling caused by the magnetocaloric effect at Hm

Conclusion on Vortex Dynamics

In summary, the ultrasound data suggest that vortices contribute to the ultrasound properties inside the SC3 phase However, some features remain puzzling, such as an excess attenuation and strong frequency dependence Both observations suggest unconventional vortex dynamics in the field re-entrant superconducting phase of UTe2 and require further experimental investigation The contrast with lower field superconducting phases suggests that vortex pinning is different in the field re-entrant SC3 phase

Frequency Dependence Findings

The frequency dependence of the hysteresis is visible in Figs. S2 and S3, where one clearly observes that the hysteresis associated with the superconductivity in field-polarized phase SC3 increases in size by lowering the ultrasonic frequency The irreversibility field is highlighted by the dashed line HSC At the highest frequency of 388 MHz nearly no hysteretic behaviour is visible in ∆α and in ∆v/v for f ≥ 296 MHz

Temperature Dependence of Anomalies

The onset temperature of the ultrasound anomalies shifts towards lower T as the magnetic field is increased, similar to superconducting Tc The data for the up-sweep part of the pulse and decreasing part are shown in Fig. S3 The onset temperature of the ultrasound anomalies shifts towards lower T, in a similar way as superconducting Tc The anomaly which is probably linked to superconductivity in the field increasing curve is highlighted by the yellow star Hup

Phase Diagram Correlation

The red region of the phase diagram of Fig.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can detect bulk superconducting signatures in UTe2 by analyzing longitudinal c11 elastic mode measurements up to 80 Tesla and down to 0.5 Kelvin, specifically looking for anomalies in sound velocity and attenuation that correlate with the field re-entrant superconducting phase SC3.

  2. The improved system can identify the presence of unconventional vortex dynamics by detecting an excess attenuation, with respect to the normal state, observed throughout the entire superconducting phase, which suggests non-trivial vortex pinning and dynamics.

  3. AI can distinguish between different dynamical mechanisms causing ultrasound anomalies by analyzing frequency dependence; for example, it can determine that a Landau-Khalatnikov (LK) relaxation mechanism is not the sole explanation because the anomaly due to LK damping should increase, which is displayed in Fig. S4. This is not the case for the measured data in Fig. S2.

  4. The system can model vortex dynamics using the Thermally Assisted Flux Flow (TAFF) model to predict sound velocity changes, though it must account for limitations; specifically, it can recognize that the TAFF model works qualitatively, but fails to produce the observed excess attenuation for T less than Tc and overestimates the sound velocity with respect to the measured attenuation at low T.

  5. The improved AI can simulate thermal effects during pulsed field studies by modeling sample temperature evolution using a minimal model where a strong temperature change of about delta T equals 1 K when passing the metamagnetic transition for all temperatures measured here and then evaluate if this explains observed hysteresis in ultrasound properties.

  6. The system can assess the contribution of vortex lattice dynamics to sound velocity by comparing experimental data with theoretical predictions; for instance, it can note that the vortex elastic constant expected at 50 T is c v11 equal to 2 GPa which is roughly 30 times larger then the experimental determined change.

  7. The AI can determine the frequency dependence of hysteresis by analyzing data from Fig. S3; it can conclude that the size of the anomaly decreases rapidly with increasing frequency for both the attenuation and sound velocity, contrasting this with what a specific model might predict.

Sources

Related papers