Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling".
Title and authors: Kai: Now that we’ve talked about the dynamics, let’s go over what this paper actually says in terms of the core phenomenon of tunnelling dynamics.
Mira: Basically, quantum tunnelling allows particles to cross barriers even when their kinetic energy isn't high enough to go over them classically.
Lev: The underlying dynamics are subtle because it’s still a subject of active debate among physicists, so we need to understand what they actually found here.
Kai: So the core finding is that the particle velocity inside the barrier continuously relaxes from a large initial value toward a smaller one, and it may even approach zero in the evanescent regime.
Mira: This result resolves that issue where you have a vanishing steady-state velocity but still have a finite particle density, which is what we saw earlier.
Lev: It means that the particle isn't just instantly stopped; it’s actively changing its speed during the process of tunnelling.
Kai: And this happens regardless of whether we define velocity using Bohmian definitions or something else, as long as we are careful about what we measure.
Mira: They distinguish between the Bohmian velocity, which comes from the phase gradient of the wave function, and other velocities inferred from probability density.
Lev: The Bohmian velocity is well-defined within quantum mechanics because it follows directly from the wave function and the Schrödinger equation.
Kai: However, they show that defining an effective speed from probability density instead of probability current can lead to those spurious nonzero stationary speeds, as you saw in another reference.
Mira: This confirms that the definition matters a lot for what we calculate when analyzing tunnelling.
Lev: So when we build simulations, we have to be extremely careful about which physical quantity—current or density—we are using to define the speed.
Kai: The paper "Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling" shows that this distinction is crucial for getting a physically meaningful characterization of local motion.
The paper's summary: Mira: They don't just stop at describing the dynamics; they suggest how we can actually use these findings to improve our understanding of tunnelling.
Lev: One improvement they suggest is that improved AI systems can accurately predict particle velocity inside a barrier using time-dependent Schrödinger equation simulations to resolve discrepancies between Bohmian velocity and inferred speeds from probability density.
Kai: That means the AI could provide a clearer dynamical picture for the formation of tunnelling flow, which would be really helpful for experimental validation.
Mira: Another suggestion is that AI systems can distinguish between different steady-state velocities based on that energy detuning delta, specifically predicting that the velocity in evanescent states approaches zero when the barrier is sufficiently wide by analyzing the explicit relation derived from steady-state equations.
Lev: That would be useful because it means we can use simulation to test these predictions about how wide a barrier needs to be for things to freeze out.
Kai: And they also suggest improved systems could model and predict complex transient tunnelling dynamics by incorporating finite particle lifetimes, for example, setting a finite particle lifetime of two hundred seventy picoseconds to study how velocity remains stable within a pulse plateau region.
Mira: That’s important because it helps us understand how long things persist in these transient phases before they settle down.
Lev: Incorporating dissipation like that would be necessary when we're trying to run this on real hardware, so modeling that kind of physics is where the overhead really lands.
Kai: And finally, AI systems can differentiate between various definitions of tunnelling time, such as group delay versus continuity-equation dwell time, which allows them to argue that focusing on the instantaneous velocity distribution inside the barrier combined with programmable quantum simulation platforms offers a promising route toward clarifying tunnelling time debates.
Mira: It sounds like they’re pushing for a method where we use these dynamic measurements to get a clearer picture of what is actually happening inside those barriers, rather than just relying on static numbers.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So to wrap up, the paper "Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling" summarizes the main implications for our understanding of how particles move through classically forbidden regions.
Mira: Essentially, they’re showing that the instantaneous velocity inside the barrier continuously relaxes from a large initial value toward a smaller one, and may even approach zero in the evanescent regime.
Lev: They resolve that paradox of a vanishing steady-state velocity coexisting with finite particle density by showing this continuous relaxation is happening dynamically.
Kai: And they clarify which velocity definition provides the best characterization of local motion by highlighting how the definitions matter for what we measure.
Mira: The main point is that focusing on the instantaneous velocity distribution inside the barrier, combined with programmable quantum simulation platforms, offers a promising route toward clarifying tunnelling time debates.
Lev: I just want to weigh in on how this helps us understand where those transient causal flows lie and what they look like when we try to measure them.
Kai: It’s about moving past relying only on steady-state solutions and looking at the full dynamical picture of the process instead.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’re talking about "Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling" and how the particle actually moves while it’s inside that barrier.
Mira: Basically, they show that even though a particle is tunnelling, its speed doesn't just stay constant; it continuously relaxes from a big starting value down toward something smaller.
Lev: That’s the key thing—the velocity is not some fixed number you can just plug in; it’s evolving during the event.
Kai: And they address that vanishing steady-state velocity issue, which is a real head-scratcher when you look at particle density versus current.
Mira: They show that this continuous relaxation explains why you see a finite density even when the current drops to zero in the evanescent regime.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it means our models need to account for this temporal evolution, not just the final state.
Kai: They also made a big distinction between different ways of measuring speed, like using the Bohmian velocity versus inferring speed from probability density.
Mira: And they pointed out that if you use the probability density to calculate speed instead of the current, you can get these spuriously nonzero speeds that don't make physical sense.
Lev: That makes sense when you think about running this on real hardware; defining your observable incorrectly leads to garbage results.
Kai: The paper suggests that focusing on this instantaneous velocity distribution inside the barrier, combined with programmable quantum simulation platforms, is a good way to test things out.
Mira: Because it lets us compare what we predict based on local velocity against what measurements from wave-packet or phase-based methods tell us.
Lev: It’s about finding that distinction between a continuity equation dwell time and group delay; they suggest that apparent contradictions often come down to which physical observable you are actually measuring.
Kai: So, the big picture here is that understanding how the particle moves *during* the tunnelling process is what we need to tackle this debate.
Mira: They also pointed out how the velocity changes depending on something called delta, which is like energy minus zero potential energy.
Lev: When you look at that formula for three milliseconds, if you make the barrier width bigger, that velocity inside just drops toward zero over a much wider region.
Kai: That means for a very wide barrier, the particle essentially gets frozen inside it.
Mira: So, to wrap up on "Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling," this paper emphasizes that we need to look at the time-resolved dynamics of speed itself.
Lev: It’s interesting stuff because it gives us a clearer dynamical picture for how tunnelling flow actually forms.
Xiao-Wen Shang, * Jian-Peng Dou, † Feng Lu, Sen Lin, № Hao Tang, ℗ Xian-Min Jin
Center for Integrated Quantum Information Technologies (IQIT) · Hefei National Laboratory · School of Mathematics and Statistics, Jiangsu Normal University · Chip Hub for Integrated Photonics Xplore (CHIPX) · TuringQ Co. Ltd.
quant-ph, physics.optics
Submitted: 2025-12-18
Updated: 2026-11-18
Comments: 35 pages, 8 figures. Comments are welcome!
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling shows that particle velocity inside the barrier continuously relaxes from a large initial value toward a smaller one and may even approach zero in the…
Key concepts
- Bohmian Velocity
- This is a specific definition of particle velocity derived from the phase gradient of the wave function. It is well-defined within quantum mechanics and follows directly from the Schrödinger equation, offering a physically meaningful characterization of local motion.
- Spurious Nonzero 'Stationary Speed'
- This refers to an apparent speed calculated by inferring velocity solely from probability density, rather than the actual probability current. The paper shows this inferred speed can be misleading and does not always represent the true physical velocity of the particle.
- Velocity Dependence on Barrier Width
- The instantaneous velocity inside a barrier is dependent on its width. For a finite barrier, as the width increases, the velocity within that region approaches zero. This indicates that particles become effectively frozen inside very wide barriers.
- Transient Causal Flow
- This concept describes the underlying motion during tunnelling that exists beyond simple steady-state analyses. It highlights a time-resolved view of how particles move, suggesting that conventional steady-state measurements might miss crucial dynamic information.
Terminology
Summary
Instantaneous velocity during quantum tunnelling shows that particle velocity inside the barrier continuously relaxes from a large initial value toward a smaller one and may even approach zero in the evanescent regime <ref:2512. p. 0 Yet the underlying dynamics
of particle motion during tunnelling remain subtle and are still the subject of active debate. Here, by
analyzing the temporal evolution of the tunnelling process, we show that the particle velocity
inside the barrier continuously relaxes from a large initial value toward a smaller one,
and may even approach zero in the evanescent regime.Where the paper says it
Core Phenomenon of Tunnelling Dynamics
Quantum tunnelling allows particles to traverse classically forbidden potential barriers even when their kinetic energy is insufficient to surmount them <ref:2512.16385#pg2>. The underlying dynamics of particle motion during tunnelling remain subtle and are still the subject of active debate <ref:2512. p. 0 It underpins fundamental processes ranging from nuclear
fusion and photosynthesis to the operation of superconducting qubits. Yet the underlying dynamics
of particle motion during tunnelling remain subtle and are still the subject of active debate. Yet the underlying dynamics
of particle motion during tunnelling remain subtle and are still the subject of active debate. Here, by
analyzing the temporal evolution of the tunnelling process, we show that the particle velocity
inside the barrier continuously relaxes from a large initial value toward a smaller one,
and may even approach zero in the evanescent regime. These findings resolve
the apparent paradox of a vanishing steady-state velocity coexisting with a finite particle density. We point out that defining an effective speed from the probability density, rather than from the
probability current, can lead to spuriously nonzero “stationary speed,” as appears to be the case in
Ref.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Velocity Definitions and Physical Interpretation
The paper distinguishes between different velocity definitions, specifically the Bohmian velocity derived from the phase gradient of the wave function and velocities inferred from probability density or relative probability densities <ref:2512.16385#pg2>. The Bohmian velocity, defined as v(x, t) = ħ/m∇S(x, t), is well-defined within quantum mechanics and follows directly from the wave function and the Schrödinger equation <ref:2512. p. 0 It follows directly from the
wave function and the Schr¨odinger equation and is fully
consistent with the continuity equation [13, 14]. From
a mathematical standpoint, it is therefore well-defined
within quantum mechanics. These findings resolve
the apparent paradox of a vanishing steady-state velocity coexisting with a finite particle density. We point out that defining an effective speed from the probability density, rather than from the
probability current, can lead to spuriously nonzero “stationary speed,” as appears to be the case in
Ref. These findings resolve
the apparent paradox of a vanishing steady-state velocity coexisting with a finite particle density. We point out that defining an effective speed from the probability density, rather than from the
probability current, can lead to spuriously nonzero “stationary speed,” as appears to be the case in
Ref. We point out that defining an effective speed from the probability density, rather than from the
probability current, can lead to spuriously nonzero “stationary speed,” as appears to be the case in
Ref. [Nature 643, 67 (2025)].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Dynamical Evolution in One-Dimensional Systems
The simulation of a one-dimensional tunnelling process reveals how the velocity changes based on the energy detuning ∆ = E - V0 0 <ref:2512.16385#pg3>. For a finite barrier width 'a', the velocity v∆<0(x) = v0 / (1 + V0∆) sinh2[κ (x − a)] is distinctly nonzero and approaches zero as the barrier width increases. When the barrier width 'a' becomes sufficiently large, the velocity within the barrier approaches zero over an extended region, indicating that the particle becomes effectively frozen within the barrier.
Coexistence of Steady States and Transient Flow
The analysis shows that during the plateau stage of tunnelling, the velocity inside the barrier vanishes, corresponding to zero probability current density j = ρv = 0, which recovers the familiar steady-state solution in the evanescent state. The results resolve two key questions: which velocity definition provides a physically meaningful characterization of local motion and how to account for particle residence within the barrier when Bohmian velocity vanishes. p. 1 First,
which of these two velocity definitions provides a physically meaningful characterization of the particle’s local
motion in the evanescent region? Second, if the Bohmian
velocity vanishes in an evanescent state, how can one consistently account for the particle’s residence within the
barrier? These results
resolve the two questions raised in the Introduction and
provide a coherent physical picture of tunnelling dynamics. Notably, the transient causal flow underlying tunnelling, uncovered here, lies beyond the reach of conventional steady-state analyses and offers new insights into
the time-resolved observation of tunnelling phenomena.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Implications for Experimental Testing
The findings suggest that focusing on the instantaneous velocity distribution inside the barrier, combined with programmable quantum-simulation platforms, offers a promising route toward clarifying the long-standing debate on tunnelling time. This approach allows for comparisons between local-velocity based predictions and wave-packet or phase-based measurements. p. 5 Experimentally, several rapidly developing directions
make it realistic to expect decisive tests. Optical-lattice
and cold-atom platforms permit highly controlled, programmable barriers and have already been used to directly access tunnelling delay in lattice potentials [25, 26],
offering an ideal testbed for comparing local-velocitybased predictions to wave-packet and phase-based mea- Group delay typically reflects wave-packet peak propagation, while
a continuity-equation dwell time reflects local probability flow through the barrier. This distinction aligns
with critical analyses of purported “superluminal” tunnelling and shows that apparent contradictions often
reduce to mismatches between which physical observable is being measured.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Steady-State Velocity vs. p. 0 Meanwhile, the probability
density within the barrier gradually builds up before reaching its stationary profile, in
contrast to existing inherently. In addition, starting from the steady-state equations, we derive
an explicit relation between the particle velocity and the barrier width, and show that the velocity
in evanescent states approaches zero when the barrier is sufficiently wide.Where the paper says it
The This “steadystate velocity,” determined solely by the probability densities, hardly reflects the true velocity of particles within
the barrier, particularly in the evanescent region. Conversely, the Bohmian speed experimentally measured in
Ref. Conversely, the Bohmian speed experimentally measured in
Ref. [23] approaches zero, consistent with our observation
that particle velocity vanishes in steady-state conditions. Numerical results are
denoted by filled circles; see Methods for derivation details. The velocities of all five points within the potential barrier (two in the main waveguide and three in the auxiliary waveguide) vanish entirely during the pulse plateau
phase.steadystate velocity,
determined solely by probability densities, can be spurious, as illustrated by a value of 2292 km/s derived from fitting data in the auxiliary waveguide. This contrasts with the Bohmian speed experimentally measured in Ref. p. 5Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Velocity Dependence on Barrier Width
The steady-state velocity v∆<0(x) = v0 / (1 + V0∆) sinh2[κ (x − a)] is dependent on the barrier width 'a'. When the barrier width 'a' is small, the velocity inside the barrier can be large, and positions farther from the left boundary of the barrier correspond to higher velocities. As the barrier width increases toward infinity, the velocity inside the barrier approaches zero, indicating that the particle becomes effectively frozen within the barrier. p. 5 When
the barrier width is small, the velocity inside the barrier
can be large, and positions farther from the left boundary
of the barrier correspond to higher velocities. As the
barrier width increases toward infinity, the velocity inside
the barrier approaches zero, indicating that the particle
becomes effectively frozen within the barrier. As the
barrier width increases toward infinity, the velocity inside
the barrier approaches zero, indicating that the particle
becomes effectively frozen within the barrier. This result
is consistent with Fig. This result
is consistent with Fig. 2(c), where a semi-infinite barrier
is considered.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can accurately predict particle velocity inside a barrier using time-dependent Schrödinger equation simulations to resolve discrepancies between Bohmian velocity and inferred speeds from probability density. This allows for a
clear dynamical picture for the formation of tunnelling flow.
-
AI systems can distinguish between different steady-state velocities based on the energy detuning delta. Specifically, they can predict that
the velocity in evanescent states approaches zero when the barrier is sufficiently wide
by analyzing the explicit relation derived from steady-state equations. -
Improved systems can model and predict complex transient tunnelling dynamics by incorporating finite particle lifetimes to account for dissipation, such as setting a
finite particle lifetime of 270 ps
to study how velocity remains stable within a pulse plateau region. -
AI systems can differentiate between various definitions of tunneling time, such as group delay versus continuity-equation dwell time. This capability allows the AI to argue that
focusing on the instantaneous velocity distribution inside the barrier, combined with programmable quantum-simulation platforms
offers a promising route toward clarifying tunnelling time debates.
Abstract
Quantum tunneling, the phenomenon by which particles traverse regions forbidden by classical mechanics, underpins a range of processes including nuclear fusion, photosynthesis, and superconducting qubits. Its fundamental dynamics, however, remain heavily debated. A prominent open controversy concerns the apparent energy--speed paradox reported by Sharoglazova et al., where particles with lower incident energy exhibit a higher tunneling "speed". Here we resolve this paradox using a dynamical framework of tunneling. We show that, at the rising edge of the incident wavepacket, the particle velocity inside the barrier continuously decreases from an initially large value; it stays constant across the wavepacket plateau and reverses sign at the falling edge. In tandem with this velocity evolution, the in-barrier probability density gradually accumulates, holds steady over the plateau, and subsequently decays. We further derive closed-form expressions relating velocity and dwell time to barrier width and height, and investigate how coupling between internal and external states modulates the tunneling of massive particles. This dynamical picture reconciles the counterintuitive lower-energy--"higher-speed" paradox and provides a theoretical basis for time-resolved tunneling measurements.
Sources
- Experimental evidence that a photon can spend a negative amount of time in an atom cloud
- Overcoming a challenge for Bohmian mechanics
- Critical Reflections on Overcoming a Challenge for Bohmian Mechanics by H. Nikolic and the Experimental Findings of Sharoglazova et al
- Apparent energy-speed relationship poses no challenge to Bohmian mechanics
- Tunneling photons pose no challenge to Bohmian mechanics
- Comment on "Energy-speed relationship of quantum particles challenges Bohmian mechanics"
- Trajectories in coupled waveguides: an application to a recent experiment and Hiley's lessons on the falsification of the Bohmian model
- Is Bohmian mechanics missing some motion? Why a recent experiment is inconclusive
- Formal equivalence between Maxwell equations and the de Broglie-Bohm theory for two-dimensional optical microcavities
- Reaffirming a Challenge to Bohmian Mechanics
- Intensified optical camera with Timepix4 readout
Related papers
- Computational regimes in matrix-product-state-based quantum trajectory simulations
- Toward chemically accurate quantum simulations on quantum hardware: A quantum-HPC hybrid approach
- Transversal surface-code game with reconfigurable qubits
- Fulqrum: a generalized framework for quantum subspace diagonalization
- Flux-Activated Resonant Control of a Bosonic Quantum Memory
- Machine learning the effects of many quantum measurements