Modular Witten Diagrams and Quantum Extremality

arXiv:2512.11754 · hep-th · Submitted 2025-12-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Modular Witten Diagrams and Quantum Extremality".

Paper summary: Mira: So we've looked at how turning on that double trace operator at first order changes the shape of our entanglement wedge, and this paper is about using modular flow tools to see how that shapes itself further up to second order in the perturbation lambda zero >

Kai: The authors are really digging into those modular Witten diagrams. They use them to calculate these correlation functions on page four which is essentially the mathematical language for describing how the geometry and entanglement structure shift as you add that small amount of operator >

Lev: From my view, what this means for us in quantum error correction is that we’re not dealing with a static surface anymore. The required surface shape actually changes depending on the state we are preparing, and they give us an equation for exactly how that shape shifts under the perturbation zero >

Mira: That displacement profile equation on page six is key because it gives us a concrete way to see the CFT side of this deformation, showing how much stuff moves >

Kai: It’s connecting those pieces: we start with the geometry shift at page one move to these correlation functions at page four and end up with that shape profile equation on page six zero it’s a complete picture of how quantum extremality emerges from modular flow >

Lev: The implication here is that if you're building error correction for these holographic states, you need a way to handle these complicated modular flow effects when designing the surface structure zero. That complexity is what we have to account for on real hardware.

Conclusion: Mira: So, this paper is called "Modular Witten Diagrams and Quantum Extremality," and it’s essentially about using these diagrams to look at entanglement entropy in holographic states when you add a small amount of operator stuff, which we call lambda zero.

Kai: The authors are really using modular flow tools to calculate specific correlation functions on page four, which is basically the math that describes how the geometry and the entanglement structure shift when you introduce that small perturbation.

Lev: From my view, what this means for us in quantum error correction is that we’re not dealing with a static surface anymore; the required surface shape actually changes depending on what state we are preparing, and they give us an equation for exactly how that shape shifts under this perturbation zero.

Mira: That displacement profile equation on page six is key because it gives us a concrete way to see the CFT side of this deformation, showing exactly how much stuff moves in response to the state change.

Kai: It’s connecting those pieces: from the bulk geometry deformation at page one, moving to these specific correlation functions at page four, and finally ending up with that concrete displacement profile equation at page six zero. It’s a complete picture of how quantum extremality emerges from modular flow.

Lev: The implication is that if you're building error correction for these holographic states, you need a way to model these complex modular flow effects when designing the surface structure zero; that complexity is what we have to account for on real hardware.

Mira: It shows us how the geometric structure of entanglement isn't fixed; it responds dynamically to the quantum state you put into that system.

Kai: So, if we can nail this shape shift equation, it gives us a blueprint for how entanglement itself evolves in these complex systems.

Lev: That evolution is what we have to build our error correction protocols around when we're trying to get real quantum hardware working.

Department of Theoretical Physics, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research

hep-th

Submitted: 2025-12-12

Updated: 2026-11-17

Comments: 53 pages, 12 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: We study entanglement entropy for ball-shaped regions in excited states of holographic conformal field theories to show how quantum extremality emerges from modular-flowed correlation functions on…

Key concepts

Entanglement Entropy
This measures the quantum correlations between different parts of a system. In this context, it quantifies the entanglement present in a specific ball-shaped region within the excited states of a holographic conformal field theory.
Quantum Extremal Surface (QES)
The QES is a geometric surface whose area is related to the entanglement entropy. The paper aims to find an equation describing how this surface's shape changes when the state in the CFT is deformed by quantum effects.
Modular Flowed Correlation Functions
These are correlation functions that exhibit a specific transformation property under modular transformations. The authors use these functions to study how entanglement entropy changes as the system undergoes a change, revealing insights into quantum extremality.
Double-Trace Operators
These are specific types of operators in the CFT used in this study. By turning on O(1) sources for these operators, the authors examine how their presence affects the entanglement entropy and its dependence on state deformation.

Terminology

Summary

We study entanglement entropy for ball-shaped regions in excited states of holographic conformal field theories to show how quantum extremality emerges from modular-flowed correlation functions on page 1. p. 0

Where the paper says it

in, parrikar@theory. in Abstract: We study entanglement entropy for ball-shaped regions in excited states of holographic conformal field theories.

Setup and Motivation

The paper investigates the deformation of the shape of the entanglement wedge due to backreaction and quantum effects, which becomes manifest in the entanglement entropy at O(λ 2GN) on page 1. The authors aim to generalize previous calculations by turning on O(1) sources for double-trace operators in the CFT and studying the corresponding change in entanglement entropy to second order, which involves modular-flowed correlation functions of double-trace operators on page 4. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The purpose of the present paper is to generalize the calculations of [16] to the case of sources which deform the bulk geometry and matter entanglement structure, and show the emergence of the quantum extremality formula from modular-flowed correlation functions which arise in the second order perturbation of entanglement entropy in the CFT (see also [18–20] for previous work along these lines). Specifically, we will turn on O(1) sources for double-trace operators in the CFT and study the corresponding change in the entanglement entropy to second order, which involves, among other things, modular-flowed correlators of double-trace operators.

Quantum Extremal Surface Displacement

The goal is to derive an equation for the displacement profile (i.e., the shape) of the quantum extremal surface (QES) under a state deformation in the CFT on page 6. p. 5

Where the paper says it

2 Displacement profile of the quantum extremal surface Our main goal in this section is to derive an equation for the displacement profile (i. , the shape) of the quantum extremal surface (QES) under a state deformation in the CFT, – 5 –

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to derive quantum extremal surface displacement profiles for deformed boundary states by implementing a concrete formula derived from modular-flowed correlation functions in second order perturbation theory. This allows the system to predict how bulk geometry and matter entanglement structure deform when subjected to double-trace operator sources at O lambda squared.

  2. Enhanced capability to compute entanglement entropy corrections up to O lambda squared by systematically using the quantum RT formula in conjunction with gravitational covariant phase space formalism and modular Witten diagrams for double-trace operators. This includes calculating the second order correction S(2) CFT(rhoR rho0R).

  3. Development of a robust framework for computing bulk-to-boundary two point functions for double-trace operators using modular Witten diagrams, which can be analytically continued to real time to yield the Schwinger-Keldysh correlation function. This allows the system to bridge Euclidean path integrals with Lorentzian physics in holographic setups.

  4. Implementation of analytic continuation techniques on complex contour integrals within the context of modular flow diagrams, enabling the calculation of s channel graviton exchange contributions and its precise correspondence with terms in the gravitational symplectic flux. This directly verifies the quantum extremality prescription at O GN and O lambda squared corrections.

Abstract

We study entanglement entropy for ball-shaped regions in excited states of holographic conformal field theories. The excited states are prepared by the Euclidean path integral in the CFT with a source turned on for some double-trace operator, with a small, O(1) amplitude λ. On the gravity side, the double-trace operator deforms the bulk geometry as well as the entanglement structure of the state of bulk matter fields. By the quantum extremal surface formula, this leads to a deformation of the shape of the entanglement wedge, an effect which becomes manifest in the entanglement entropy at O(λ squared G N). On the CFT side, we explicitly calculate the entanglement entropy perturbatively in the source amplitude to O(λ 2), in terms of modular-flowed correlation functions of double-trace operators. We then evaluate these modular-flowed correlation functions using Witten diagrams. This calculation involves a Schwinger-Keldysh contour ordering prescription in the bulk, which we motivate using analytic continuation from Euclidean replica correlators. Focusing on a particular graviton-exchange diagram, we rewrite it in a form where it manifestly reproduces the canonical energy term present in the quantum Ryu-Takayanagi formula, including the shape deformation of the entanglement wedge due to backreaction and quantum effects.

Sources

Related papers