Pole skipping from universal hydrodynamics of (1+1)d QFTs
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Pole skipping from universal hydrodynamics of (1+1)d QFTs".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. (1+1)d QFTs provide a tractable arena for understanding the emergence of hydrodynamics in thermal states At high temperatures this process is governed by the weak breaking of conformal symmetry, and so in this limit many features of the hydrodynamic theory that emerges have been argued to be universal In this paper we study aspects of the stress tensor thermal two-point function in holographic QFTs of this kind and show that they are consistent with the universal hydrodynamic theory proposed to apply at late times Specifically, we identify the locations of the ‘pole skipping’ points in momentum space at which there is an intersection of poles and zeroes of this two-point function in holographic QFTs Although these points lie outside the regime where the hydrodynamic theory is controlled, we show that their locations are consistent with those found by resumming the hydrodynamic derivative expansion near the lightcone For example, this resummation of the universal hydrodynamics correctly predicts the butterfly velocity of holographic theories Emergence of Hydrodynamics and Universal Features One of the key steps in a typical thermalising system is the emergence of dissipative hydrodynamics at late times when the system has equilibrated locally, and subsequent relaxation is described by an effective theory for a fluidlike state In (1+1)d CFTs, conformal symmetry prevents this emergence, so its emergence in generic (1+1)d QFTs is tied to the breaking of this symmetry Conformal perturbation theory provides a tool to address the emergence of hydrodynamics for QFTs at high temperature as the dimensionless coupling in units of temperature is small However, accessing the hydrodynamic regime requires resumming conformal perturbation theory, even when this parameter is small The fluid-like state that emerges at late times is characterized by transport coefficients (speed of sound, viscosity, etc.) and infinitely many of these appear in the stress tensor thermal two-point function These relations are universal as they depend only on the dimension ∆ and are otherwise completely independent of the original CFT Near-Lightcone Resummation and Pole Skipping We investigate pole skipping in holographic theories, which refers to where a pole and a zero intersect in momentum space for the stress tensor two-point function Pole skipping points exist when corresponding graviton modes exhibit an extra ingoing solution at the black hole horizon The butterfly velocity vB is a fundamental speed characterizing out-of-time-ordered correlations, and its appearance in k2 is evidence that these correlations are governed by a simple effective theory for scrambling We show that pole skipping points near the lightcone are consistent with resummed universal hydrodynamics This suggests that after the resummation, the proposed universal hydrodynamics provides a good description of the dynamics near the lightcone at all times Holographic Butterfly Velocity Calculation We determine vB by constructing the thermal equilibrium state to quadratic order in small λ¯ and then computing it using equation (3.26) This expression agrees exactly with that found in (2.15) from the near-lightcone resummation of universal hydrodynamics of
4: It also agrees with the holographic calculation of
42: when ∆ = 3/2 and the numerical holographic results for general ∆ in
43: Pole Skipping Locations and Universality We identify a pole skipping point at ω∗ = i2πT and wavenumber k2∗ = −(2πT)2/vB squared, which agrees with that predicted by the near-lightcone resummation of universal hydrodynamics We also confirm that one of the pole skipping points at ω = −i2πT agrees with the other predicted pole skipping point of the near-lightcone resummation of universal hydrodynamics The wavenumber k21+ is close to the lightcone and agrees exactly with the prediction (2.
Paper summary: Kai: So we've seen that this paper, "Pole skipping from universal hydrodynamics of (one plusone)d QFTs", is looking at how dissipation emerges in thermal systems <ref:2512.11024#pg1,Pole skipping from universal hydrodynamics of (1+1)d QFTs>. The core thesis is that even when the conformal symmetry breaks slightly in these two-dimensional quantum field theories, the resulting hydrodynamic features are universal and depend only on the dimension of spacetime.
Mira: They focus specifically on the stress tensor thermal two-point function within holographic QFTs, trying to match what we expect from a late-time fluid state described by universal hydrodynamics. Their main claim is that they find specific locations for pole skipping points where poles and zeros intersect in momentum space for these holographic theories.
Lev: What matters here is that these pole skipping points, even though they are outside the regime where the simple hydrodynamic theory usually applies, their locations match what you get when you resum the universal hydrodynamic derivative expansion near the lightcone.
Kai: So it's like they're showing that this more complex behavior near those points is still predictable if you take that universal hydrodynamics and add in some specific mathematical corrections.
Mira: And a concrete piece of evidence they give is that when you use this resummation of the universal hydrodynamics, it correctly predicts the butterfly velocity for holographic theories.
Lev: That's a big deal because the butterfly velocity is fundamental to how we describe scrambling, and seeing it predicted in this way suggests that the universal theory provides a good description even when you look near those lightcone regions.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper by Davison and Jiang is about taking the concepts of universal hydrodynamics in two-dimensional quantum field theories and checking if they hold up when we look at holographic models. They found that the features of the stress tensor match what we expect from late-time fluid dynamics.
Mira: The key finding is identifying those pole skipping points and showing they align with resummed hydrodynamic predictions, which includes correctly predicting the butterfly velocity. It suggests that this universal theory has a broader applicability than just the very late times where it's supposed to dominate.
Lev: For someone working on error correction hardware, this means that if you can connect your physical system to these holographic descriptions, you might be able to use these universal hydrodynamic predictions as a guide for what your scrambling dynamics should look like near the lightcone.
Kai: It’s about seeing how physics from a highly symmetric starting point evolves into something simple and predictable through the breaking of symmetry, and this paper gives us tools to test that simplicity in more complex setups.
Richard A. Davison, Hanzhi Jiang
Department of Mathematics and Maxwell Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Heriot Watt University · Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics, University of Oxford
hep-th, cond-mat.str-el
Submitted: 2025-12-11
Updated: 2025-12-11
Comments: 29 pages + appendices, 1 figure
Journal ref: JHEP 04 (2026) 162
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: (1+1)d QFTs provide a tractable arena for understanding the emergence of hydrodynamics in thermal states At high temperatures this process is governed by the weak breaking of conformal symmetry…
Key concepts
- Hydrodynamics Emergence
- In thermal systems, dissipation and fluid-like behavior (hydrodynamics) appear at late times after local equilibration. In (1+1)d QFTs, this emergence is linked to the weak breaking of conformal symmetry at high temperatures. This process is studied using conformal perturbation theory to find universal transport coefficients.
- Pole Skipping
- This refers to specific points in momentum space where a pole and a zero of the stress tensor two-point function intersect. These intersections occur when corresponding graviton modes have an extra ingoing solution at the black hole horizon in holographic theories, providing insight into correlation dynamics.
- Universal Hydrodynamics
- This is an effective theory describing the fluid-like state that emerges after thermalization. Its transport coefficients (like speed of sound and viscosity) are universal because they depend only on the spacetime dimension (∆) and are independent of the original QFT details.
- Butterfly Velocity (vB)
- A fundamental speed characterizing out-of-time-ordered correlations in holographic theories. Its appearance in momentum space is evidence that these correlations are governed by a simple effective theory for scrambling, and its prediction from universal hydrodynamics is confirmed by this study.
Terminology
Summary
(1+1)d QFTs provide a tractable arena for understanding the emergence of hydrodynamics in thermal states At high temperatures this process is governed by the weak breaking of conformal symmetry, and so in this limit many features of the hydrodynamic theory that emerges have been argued to be universal In this paper we study aspects of the stress tensor thermal two-point function in holographic QFTs of this kind and show that they are consistent with the universal hydrodynamic theory proposed to apply at late times Specifically, we identify the locations of the ‘pole skipping’ points in momentum space at which there is an intersection of poles and zeroes of this two-point function in holographic QFTs Although these points lie outside the regime where the hydrodynamic theory is controlled, we show that their locations are consistent with those found by resumming the hydrodynamic derivative expansion near the lightcone For example, this resummation of the universal hydrodynamics correctly predicts the butterfly velocity of holographic theories
Emergence of Hydrodynamics and Universal Features
One of the key steps in a typical thermalising system is the emergence of dissipative hydrodynamics at late times when the system has equilibrated locally, and subsequent relaxation is described by an effective theory for a fluidlike state In (1+1)d CFTs, conformal symmetry prevents this emergence, so its emergence in generic (1+1)d QFTs is tied to the breaking of this symmetry Conformal perturbation theory provides a tool to address the emergence of hydrodynamics for QFTs at high temperature as the dimensionless coupling in units of temperature is small However, accessing the hydrodynamic regime requires resumming conformal perturbation theory, even when this parameter is small The fluid-like state that emerges at late times is characterized by transport coefficients (speed of sound, viscosity, etc.) and infinitely many of these appear in the stress tensor thermal two-point function These relations are universal as they depend only on the dimension ∆ and are otherwise completely independent of the original CFT
Near-Lightcone Resummation and Pole Skipping
We investigate pole skipping in holographic theories, which refers to where a pole and a zero intersect in momentum space for the stress tensor two-point function Pole skipping points exist when corresponding graviton modes exhibit an extra ingoing solution at the black hole horizon The butterfly velocity vB is a fundamental speed characterizing out-of-time-ordered correlations, and its appearance in k2 is evidence that these correlations are governed by a simple effective theory for scrambling We show that pole skipping points near the lightcone are consistent with resummed universal hydrodynamics This suggests that after the resummation, the proposed universal hydrodynamics provides a good description of the dynamics near the lightcone at all times
Holographic Butterfly Velocity Calculation
We determine vB by constructing the thermal equilibrium state to quadratic order in small λ¯ and then computing it using equation (3.26) This expression agrees exactly with that found in (2. p. 4 13) below). By extending the regime of validity of universal hydrodynamics near the lightcone
to early times in this way, we find an expression for k∗ (and therefore vB) and one
of the k1 that agree with those found holographically.Where the paper says it
Pole Skipping Locations and Universality
We identify a pole skipping point at ω∗ = i2πT and wavenumber k2∗ = −(2πT)2/vB squared, which agrees with that predicted by the near-lightcone resummation of universal hydrodynamics We also confirm that one of the pole skipping points at ω = −i2πT agrees with the other predicted pole skipping point of the near-lightcone resummation of universal hydrodynamics The wavenumber k21+ is close to the lightcone and agrees exactly with the prediction (2.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve prediction of butterfly velocity by using equation (2.8) to predict vB in holographic theories with a universal expression that depends only on delta, matching numerical results for general delta and specific cases like delta 3/2 and 1, 2.
-
Enable holographic QFTs to be used as a testing ground for the universal hydrodynamics proposed in reference [4] by explicitly showing how the near-lightcone resummation of universal hydrodynamics correctly predicts the butterfly velocity.
-
Allow AI systems to calculate pole skipping locations in holographic theories dual to (1+1)d QFTs by using the resummed two-point function (2.11) and identifying when it is consistent with the near-lightcone limit of conformal perturbation theory (2.2).
-
Enable AI systems to determine the universal pole skipping wavenumber k star using equation (4.8) combined with the small lambda bar expression for vB in equation (3.26), which agrees exactly with the prediction from near-lightcone resummation of universal hydrodynamics (2.15).
-
Allow AI systems to distinguish between universal and non-universal pole skipping points by analyzing the dependence of k squared on the scalar potential coefficients V3 and V4, as seen in equations (4.20) and (4.18).
-
Enable AI systems to derive explicit expressions for pole skipping wavenumbers at higher orders for frequencies n greater than 1 by solving the polynomial equations (4.13) using small lambda bar expansion up to order two, although this requires assuming the small lambda bar expansion first.
-
Allow AI systems to verify that the near-lightcone limit of the universal hydrodynamic correlator in equation (2.14) agrees with the near-lightcone limit of conformal perturbation theory (2.2) when expanded for small lambda bar and small k, providing a check on the resummation method.
-
Enable AI systems to analyze non-universal pole skipping points by using the specific expressions for k squared in equations (4.18), which depend on the coefficients of the scalar potential V3 and V4, thus revealing details about operator O beyond just its dimension.
Abstract
(1+1)d QFTs provide a tractable arena for understanding the emergence of hydrodynamics in thermal states. At high temperatures this process is governed by the weak breaking of conformal symmetry, and so in this limit many features of the hydrodynamic theory that emerges have been argued to be universal. In this paper we study aspects of the stress tensor thermal two-point function in holographic QFTs of this kind and show that they are consistent with the universal hydrodynamic theory proposed to apply at late times. Specifically, we identify the locations of the `pole skipping' points in momentum space at which there is an intersection of poles and zeroes of this two-point function in holographic QFTs. Although these points lie outside the regime where the hydrodynamic theory is controlled, we show that their locations are consistent with those found by resumming the hydrodynamic derivative expansion near the lightcone. For example, this resummation of the universal hydrodynamics correctly predicts the butterfly velocity of holographic theories.
Sources
- Thermalization and Hydrodynamics of Two-Dimensional Quantum Field Theories
- Universal thermalization dynamics in (1+1)d QFTs
- Notes on the bulk viscosity of holographic gauge theory plasmas
- Black hole scrambling from hydrodynamics
- A quantum hydrodynamical description for scrambling and many-body chaos
- Many-body chaos and energy dynamics in holography
- Horizon constraints on holographic Green's functions
- On the connection between hydrodynamics and quantum chaos in holographic theories with stringy corrections
- Thermal Diffusion and Quantum Chaos in Neutral Magnetized Plasma
- Scrambling in Hyperbolic Black Holes: shock waves and pole-skipping
- Quantum chaos, pole-skipping and hydrodynamics in a holographic system with chiral anomaly
- Quantum Chaos in Topologically Massive Gravity
- Pole-skipping of scalar and vector fields in hyperbolic space: conformal blocks and holography
- Pole skipping and chaos in anisotropic plasma: a holographic study
- Chaos and pole-skipping in rotating black holes
- Quantum information scrambling and quantum chaos in little string theory
- Pole skipping in holographic theories with bosonic fields
- Chaos and pole-skipping in a simply spinning plasma
- Pole-skipping of gravitational waves in the backgrounds of four-dimensional massive black holes
- Higher-spin localized shocks
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions