ResponsibleRobotBench: Benchmarking Risk-Aware Task-Level Decision Making for Robotic Manipulation with Large Multimodal Models

arXiv:2512.04308 · cs.RO · Submitted 2025-12-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: I'm Rosa.

Dev: And I'm Dev, here with Taro.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "ResponsibleRobotBench: Benchmarking Risk-Aware Task-Level Decision Making for Robotic Manipulation with Large Multimodal Models".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. ResponsibleRobotBench introduces a systematic benchmark designed to evaluate and accelerate progress in responsible robotic manipulation from simulation to real world This benchmark consists of 23 multi-stage tasks spanning diverse risk types, including electrical, chemical, and human-related hazards, and varying levels of physical and planning complexity These tasks require agents to detect and mitigate risks, reason about safety, plan sequences of actions, and engage human assistance when necessary The benchmark includes a general-purpose evaluation framework that supports multimodal model-based agents with various action representation modalities It also provides a rich multimodal dataset, supports reproducible experiments, and includes standardized metrics such as success rate, safety rate, and safe success rate Through extensive experimental setups, ResponsibleRobotBench enables analysis across risk categories, task types, and agent configurations Benchmark Composition The benchmark is constructed with a multi-dimensional classification system where tasks are distinguished by whether or not they involve hazards Hazardous conditions fall into three main categories: electrical, fire/chemical, and human-related risks The benchmark includes attack and defense scenarios where instructions may be adversarial or intentionally harmful Tasks also vary in terms of planning difficulty, ranging from straightforward single-step manipulations to complex, multi-step procedures requiring contextual reasoning Each task is annotated with a binary safety flag indicating whether it is safe to execute under current constraints Task and Action Representation Diversity The benchmark supports multiple action representation formats, including predefined low-level skills

2: , manipulation poses

11: , and code generation pipelines

3: This modularity enables fair comparisons across systems that differ in their levels of abstraction or embodiment The instruction modes are categorized into three types: normal, attack, and defense For example, "Normal" instructions describe safe and goal-directed behaviors, while "attack" instructions are adversarial or intentionally harmful Evaluation Metrics and Framework The benchmark proposes multi-dimensional metrics that jointly capture safety-aware task success, human intervention and task cost Core evaluation metrics include the task success rate, which measures the proportion of tasks completed correctly, and the safety rate, defined as the proportion of tasks executed without triggering hazardous conditions The safe success rate jointly captures tasks that are both completed and executed without safety violations, providing a holistic metric for responsible behavior A cost evaluation metric is introduced to capture resource consumption during task execution, including the number of low-level action steps, frequency of calls to perception and reasoning modules, and reliance on human intervention Experimental Results Summary The experimental results indicate that GPT-4o achieves the highest overall performance across different hazard categories Among the three hazard categories evaluated, tasks involving fire/chemical hazards exhibit the lowest safety success rate The results show that GPT models achieved the best overall performance, suggesting a superior ability to interpret and act upon preference related information embedded in prompts Limitations and Future Directions Our observations suggest that while LMMs exhibit strong semantic understanding, they still face significant limitations in spatial planning, risk perception, and reliable safe action execution—especially in scenarios with complex planning requirements or long-horizon task structures The current simulation environment, while high-fidelity, does not yet capture all nuances of real-world contact dynamics or unstructured human-robot interactions Future work will expand the benchmark to include richer multimodal feedback and broader task diversity for unstructured human-robot interaction scenarios Error Analysis Insights Error analysis cases illustrate various failure modes, such as action deviation, output formatting errors, perception errors, repeated outputs, failures caused by failed motion planning, and cases where the predicted actions are physically unreachable For instance, a trajectory planning error occurred when the system was unable to compute a feasible path to the target pose during execution The agent's rejection of an unsafe task demonstrates its risk awareness and refusal capability against harmful instructions Model Performance Trends As task sequence length increases, the overall success rate across models declines significantly in long-horizon scenarios A clear trend emerges that as task sequence length increases, the overall success rate across models declines significantly in long-horizon scenarios The performance of large models in robotic manipulation deteriorates more significantly than it does with increasing scene complexity When using manipulation pose as the action representation, experimental results across different action abstraction levels reveal a significant drop in both success rate and safety success rate—decreasing from high-level action performance to near zero This degradation highlights the limitations of current LMMs in spatial reasoning The performance gap between code-based and high-level action representations reveals the limitations of current LMMs in reliably generating executable code under complex planning and scene reasoning demands for robotic manipulation Cognitive Guidance Impact Experiments on in-context learning include the impact of incorporating cognitive knowledge as contextual information By comparing the performance of context learning with and without cognition related information, we assess the contribution of cognitive cues to large model-based responsible robotic manipulation Based on a comprehensive assessment of each model’s demonstrated safety awareness, robotic planning capabilities, and token-level inference cost, we select CONFIG7 as the default configuration for all evaluation experiments This configuration leverages multi-modal inputs (vision and language), incorporates historical context during inference, and adopts 5-shot in-context learning Policy Learning Capabilities

Paper summary: Dev: So, wrapping up this discussion on ResponsibleRobotBench, the paper is really focused on using this benchmark to push large multimodal models toward reliable behavior in manipulation from simulation right into the real world. The authors are looking at how these models handle electrical, fire and chemical hazards, and human related risks within twenty-three multi-stage tasks <ref:2512.04308#pg1>.

Rosa: The authors introduce this framework because they felt that current approaches often lack the risk-aware reasoning needed for high stakes environments. They show that this benchmark allows us to analyze performance across different risk categories, task types, and even different agent configurations using multimodal inputs and various action representations like code or poses.

Taro: It’s about showing how language guided agents can generate robot actions in unstructured scenes while also being able to reason about the risks associated with those actions.

Dev: And they used a specific configuration for their experiments, CONFIG7, which leverages multi-modal inputs like vision and language, incorporates historical context during inference, and uses five-shot in-context learning. That’s how they measured the performance of these models against each other.

Rosa: The implication here is that we need these benchmarks to move past simple task completion and start focusing on what the robot does when things go wrong—specifically, how it plans for risk, makes moral decisions, and interacts safely with humans.

Taro: So, the main thing this paper points toward is that language guided agents can demonstrate greater context awareness than older methods like symbolic planning or rule based safety verification.

Dev: It’s about showing that these multimodal models have a stronger ability to reason about task intent and associated risks in a more flexible way than prior approaches.

Rosa: So, this paper suggests that the next step for responsible robotics is to build benchmarks like this one so we can see how far we've actually come in handling those tricky real-world safety scenarios.

Conclusion: Rosa: So, this paper is introducing ResponsibleRobotBench, which is basically this systematic test to see if large multimodal models can actually do safe robotic manipulation from simulation all the way to real life.

Dev: Right, it's about a benchmark that checks how these models handle risks like electrical or chemical hazards and human stuff across twenty-three different tasks.

Taro: The authors built this framework to evaluate risk detection, safety reasoning, and planning sequences for agents that might need help from humans when things get tricky.

Rosa: They use a really cool setup with different ways to describe actions, like low-level skills or even generating code pipelines for the robot.

Dev: And they track performance using these metrics—task success rate, safety rate, and that safe success rate which shows both doing it right and doing it safely.

Taro: The results show that models like GPT-4o do well overall, but they struggle most with fire or chemical hazards when we look at the safety success rate <ref:2512.04308#pg1>.

Rosa: It seems like these models are good at understanding the instructions, but there's still a lot of room to improve their spatial reasoning and how they perceive risk in complex situations.

Dev: The paper points out that as task sequences get longer, the overall success rate drops significantly for all models, showing a real limitation in long-horizon planning.

Taro: And when they use manipulation poses to describe the action, both the success rate and safety success rate really plummet compared to using code generation.

Rosa: So what this means is that we need better ways for these AI agents to plan their movements without just guessing, especially in environments where things are unpredictable.

Dev: It suggests that future work needs to focus on giving these models stronger spatial reasoning and more reliable safe action execution capabilities.

Lei Zhang, Ju Dong, Kaixin Bai, Minheng Ni, Âoltan-Csaba Márton ľZhaopeng Chen, Jianwei Zhang

University of Hamburg · Agile Robots SE · Technical University of Munich · Hong Kong Polytechnic University

cs.RO

Submitted: 2025-12-03

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: 28 pages, including a 12-page appendix. Revised manuscript with expanded experimental analysis and supplementary details. Project website: https://responsible-robot-benchmark.github.io/

Code: https://github.com/ultralytics/ultralytics

Project page: https://sites.google.com/view/responsible-robotbench

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 98/100

The gist: ResponsibleRobotBench introduces a systematic benchmark designed to evaluate and accelerate progress in responsible robotic manipulation from simulation to real world This benchmark consists of 23…

Key concepts

ResponsibleRobotBench
A systematic benchmark designed to test how well large multimodal models can perform risk-aware robotic manipulation from simulation to the real world. It involves 23 multi-stage tasks covering various hazards and planning complexities.
Hazard Categories
Risks in the benchmark are grouped into three main types: electrical, fire/chemical, and human-related hazards. The tasks also include adversarial scenarios where instructions might be intentionally harmful or dangerous.
Safe Success Rate
This metric measures the proportion of tasks that are both completed successfully and executed without triggering any hazardous conditions. It provides a holistic view of responsible behavior by combining task completion and safety.
Action Representation Diversity
The benchmark supports different ways to describe robot actions, such as low-level skills, manipulation poses, or code generation pipelines. This allows researchers to compare models using different levels of abstraction.

Terminology

Summary

ResponsibleRobotBench introduces a systematic benchmark designed to evaluate and accelerate progress in responsible robotic manipulation from simulation to real world This benchmark consists of 23 multi-stage tasks spanning diverse risk types, including electrical, chemical, and human-related hazards, and varying levels of physical and planning complexity These tasks require agents to detect and mitigate risks, reason about safety, plan sequences of actions, and engage human assistance when necessary The benchmark includes a general-purpose evaluation framework that supports multimodal model-based agents with various action representation modalities It also provides a rich multimodal dataset, supports reproducible experiments, and includes standardized metrics such as success rate, safety rate, and safe success rate Through extensive experimental setups, ResponsibleRobotBench enables analysis across risk categories, task types, and agent configurations

Benchmark Composition

The benchmark is constructed with a multi-dimensional classification system where tasks are distinguished by whether or not they involve hazards Hazardous conditions fall into three main categories: electrical, fire/chemical, and human-related risks The benchmark includes attack and defense scenarios where instructions may be adversarial or intentionally harmful Tasks also vary in terms of planning difficulty, ranging from straightforward single-step manipulations to complex, multi-step procedures requiring contextual reasoning Each task is annotated with a binary safety flag indicating whether it is safe to execute under current constraints

Task and Action Representation Diversity

The benchmark supports multiple action representation formats, including predefined low-level skills [2], manipulation poses [11], and code generation pipelines [3] This modularity enables fair comparisons across systems that differ in their levels of abstraction or embodiment The instruction modes are categorized into three types: normal, attack, and defense For example, Normal instructions describe safe and goal-directed behaviors, while attack instructions are adversarial or intentionally harmful

Evaluation Metrics and Framework

The benchmark proposes multi-dimensional metrics that jointly capture safety-aware task success, human intervention and task cost Core evaluation metrics include the task success rate, which measures the proportion of tasks completed correctly, and the safety rate, defined as the proportion of tasks executed without triggering hazardous conditions The safe success rate jointly captures tasks that are both completed and executed without safety violations, providing a holistic metric for responsible behavior A cost evaluation metric is introduced to capture resource consumption during task execution, including the number of low-level action steps, frequency of calls to perception and reasoning modules, and reliance on human intervention

Experimental Results Summary

The experimental results indicate that GPT-4o achieves the highest overall performance across different hazard categories Among the three hazard categories evaluated, tasks involving fire/chemical hazards exhibit the lowest safety success rate The results show that GPT models achieved the best overall performance, suggesting a superior ability to interpret and act upon preference related information embedded in prompts

Limitations and Future Directions

Our observations suggest that while LMMs exhibit strong semantic understanding, they still face significant limitations in spatial planning, risk perception, and reliable safe action execution—especially in scenarios with complex planning requirements or long-horizon task structures The current simulation environment, while high-fidelity, does not yet capture all nuances of real-world contact dynamics or unstructured human-robot interactions Future work will expand the benchmark to include richer multimodal feedback and broader task diversity for unstructured human-robot interaction scenarios

Error Analysis Insights

Error analysis cases illustrate various failure modes, such as action deviation, output formatting errors, perception errors, repeated outputs, failures caused by failed motion planning, and cases where the predicted actions are physically unreachable For instance, a trajectory planning error occurred when the system was unable to compute a feasible path to the target pose during execution The agent's rejection of an unsafe task demonstrates its risk awareness and refusal capability against harmful instructions

Model Performance Trends

As task sequence length increases, the overall success rate across models declines significantly in long-horizon scenarios A clear trend emerges that as task sequence length increases, the overall success rate across models declines significantly in long-horizon scenarios The performance of large models in robotic manipulation deteriorates more significantly than it does with increasing scene complexity When using manipulation pose as the action representation, experimental results across different action abstraction levels reveal a significant drop in both success rate and safety success rate—decreasing from high-level action performance to near zero This degradation highlights the limitations of current LMMs in spatial reasoning The performance gap between code-based and high-level action representations reveals the limitations of current LMMs in reliably generating executable code under complex planning and scene reasoning demands for robotic manipulation

Cognitive Guidance Impact

Experiments on in-context learning include the impact of incorporating cognitive knowledge as contextual information By comparing the performance of context learning with and without cognition related information, we assess the contribution of cognitive cues to large model-based responsible robotic manipulation Based on a comprehensive assessment of each model’s demonstrated safety awareness, robotic planning capabilities, and token-level inference cost, we select CONFIG7 as the default configuration for all evaluation experiments This configuration leverages multi-modal inputs (vision and language), incorporates historical context during inference, and adopts 5-shot in-context learning

Policy Learning Capabilities

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Develop agents capable of risk-aware reasoning by integrating hazard detection, planning, and execution within a unified framework that supports multimodal inputs like visual data, context learning examples (N-shot), and cognitive information. This allows agents to intelligently identify hazards, plan safe corrective behaviors as described in the core problem definition.

  2. Enhance generalization across different manipulation styles by supporting multiple action representation modalities, including predefined low-level skills, manipulation poses, and code generation pipelines. This enables fair comparisons across systems that differ in their levels of abstraction or embodiment.

  3. Improve safety robustness against harmful instructions by designing agents that can differentiate between normal tasks and adversarial or defense-type instructions. This includes the ability to respond appropriately by refusing execution or altering their plan, as demonstrated in the Attack and Defense experiments.

  4. Increase operational reliability under complex planning demands by incorporating historical context (prior task execution records) and cognitive information into in-context learning prompts. This helps agents introspectively assess the scenario, justify its safety assessment, and plan accordingly.

  5. Optimize resource consumption during manipulation by implementing a cost evaluation metric that accounts for the number of low-level action steps and frequency of calls to perception and reasoning modules. This allows for objective evaluation of efficiency under resource-constrained scenarios.

  6. Improve spatial reasoning capabilities by systematically testing performance across varying levels of scene complexity and planning difficulty. This helps identify limitations where large models struggle to effectively handle high-dimensional spatial data, particularly when using manipulation pose as the action representation.

Sources

Related papers