Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle

arXiv:2511.21641 · eess.SY, cs.SY · Submitted 2025-11-26 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle proposes a practical and simple in realization procedure for designing a robust PI-Lead control without modeling The developed method derives from the ultimate sensitivity principles, known in empirical Ziegler–Nichols tuning of PID controllers, and makes use of some general characteristics of the loop shaping A threesteps procedure is proposed to determine the integration time constant, control gain, and Leadelement in a way to guarantee a sufficient phase margin, while all steps are served by only experimental monitoring of the output value Proposed method is demonstrated and discussed with experiments accomplished on a noise-perturbed electro-mechanical actuator system.

Rosa: System Assumptions for Model-Free Design The input-output system plant without an explicit model to be available for the control design is characterized by several single assumptions (i) The underlying process is assumed to be SISO (singleinput-single-output) and LTI (linear-time-invariant) to a large extent, implying that linear transfer characteristics dominate over nonlinear residuals (ii) The system is of the type-one, meaning it exhibits a free integrative behavior, which is typical for motion control systems where a relative displacement in the generalized coordinates x is the output of interest (iii) The system is stable and also minimum phase, though an additional process time-delay element exp(−sτ) with an unknown delay constant 0 < τ < ∞ is admissible (iv) The process can be controlled by the input value u(t), while no extra saturations of u are considered for the control design and operation (v) The process input and output are assumed to be available in real-time, while the measured output can be inherently affected by an amplitude-bounded unbiased sensor noise.

Dev: Determining the Integrator Time Constant The tuning methodology for type-one processes is based on monitoring the output value to determine parameters The procedure involves three consecutive steps to determine the integrator time constant, fixing the control gain, and assigning the Leadcompensator For determining Ti, one gradually reduces Ti while monitoring the step response oscillations until permanent oscillations occur The ultimate integrator time constant T¯i is then determined from this point The suggested tuning rule for the integrator time constant is Ti = 10 max ω¯gc, ω¯cpi (3).

Rosa: Fixing the Control Gain and Phase Margin After determining the integrator time constant, the control gain Kp is fixed by monitoring transient overshoot M = maxx(t) − xref for various Kp values The tuning aims to achieve a specific overshoot range of M ∈

30,..., 40: % (5) This process is performed by gradually first increasing and then decreasing the control gain starting from Kp = 1.

Paper summary: Rosa: So, this paper is about designing a PI-Lead control system without needing any explicit mathematical model of the physical process. It proposes a practical and simple way to do this using ultimate sensitivity principles.

Dev: It claims they developed a three step procedure to figure out the integrator time constant, the control gain, and that lead element in a way that ensures enough phase margin by just looking at experimental monitoring of the output value.

Taro: What is most important here is that this method works without knowing much about the system dynamics beforehand because it relies on general characteristics of loop shaping.

Rosa: It's interesting because they base this approach on principles already used in empirical Ziegler–Nichols tuning for PID controllers, but they apply it to a PI-Lead structure.

Dev: The core idea is that by monitoring the output for permanent oscillations, you can estimate the gain crossover frequency and then use that information to set the integrator time constant.

Taro: So, if I understand this right, we don't need a complex simulation model to get started with tuning a PI-Lead controller.

Rosa: Exactly. The paper shows how they determine the integrator time constant by gradually reducing it and watching for when those permanent oscillations finally happen at lower frequencies.

Dev: And once that's set, they fix the control gain by monitoring the transient overshoot, aiming for a specific range of thirty to forty percent.

Taro: That sounds like it handles uncertainty in the loop shaping reasonably well because it ties the tuning directly to observed system behavior rather than just theoretical math.

Rosa: They also use a Lead compensator, which is a standard tool for adding phase advance around the gain crossover frequency, and they give a specific rule for assigning its maximum phase advance frequency based on that integrator time constant.

Dev: The experimental validation was done on a noise-perturbed electro-mechanical actuator system, which is important because it tests how the controller performs when you introduce actual sensor noise into the measurement record.

Taro: I'm curious what happens when you apply an external disturbance to that closed loop system, since they mention its effectiveness becomes more evident in that scenario.

Rosa: That leads us into how robust this design is against the feedback noise, and whether it still performs well after a real disturbance hits the system.

Dev: The authors argue that the method is robust because determining the integrator time constant relies on finding ultimate oscillations due to missing phase margin, which doesn't actually depend on sensor noise.

Taro: That’s a key point because if it doesn't depend on noise, it means we can trust those initial tuning steps even when our sensors are noisy.

Rosa: They also suggest that the assignment for the Lead compensator is generic enough to provide the needed phase advance without messing up the loop characteristics at lower frequencies where they are already shaped.

Dev: So what this means for someone running a real-time loop, it suggests a straightforward tuning procedure that doesn't require complex frequency domain modeling or parameter knowledge upfront.

Taro: It makes sense if we can just run experiments and find these characteristic points without spending weeks building and testing extensive models.

Rosa: And the paper suggests this approach could be applied to processes that have oscillatory dynamics, time-delay elements, or even zeros in the origin, which expands its applicability beyond just motion control systems.

Dev: It’s a practical tool for getting a robust PI-Lead controller set up quickly when you're dealing with unknown dynamics or systems where modeling is difficult.

Taro: It’s about making sure that when the real world misbehaves, the system recovers gracefully because the tuning method is designed around those failure modes.

Rosa: So, to sum up this paper on "Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle," it offers a direct way to tune these controllers experimentally using only output monitoring.

Dev: The implication for engineers is that you can skip the heavy modeling phase and jump straight into a tuning procedure that guarantees sufficient phase margin through careful, observable system response analysis.

Taro: It gives us a reliable method when we are in situations where an explicit model just isn't available to us at all.

Conclusion: Rosa: So, this paper is about designing a PI-Lead control system without needing any explicit mathematical model of the physical process using ultimate sensitivity principles.

Dev: Right, they used experimental monitoring to figure out how to tune it, which is pretty cool because it means you don't need all that complex modeling upfront.

Taro: It’s about taking a technique from tuning PID controllers and applying it directly to a PI-Lead structure without knowing the exact system equations.

Rosa: The authors developed this three step procedure to find the integrator time constant, fix the control gain, and assign that lead element for guaranteed phase margin.

Dev: That's what they did with monitoring output oscillations until they found permanent ones to set that integrator time constant.

Taro: And then fixing the gain by looking at transient overshoot, aiming for a specific range of thirty to forty percent overshoot in the closed-loop system.

Rosa: They also used a lead compensator, which is just a standard tool for adding phase advance around the critical frequency where they want it.

Dev: The results showed this PI-Lead controller settled faster than the standard PID control that Ziegler and Nichols tuning gave them, especially when there were external disturbances.

Taro: And what's interesting is that this tuning method is robust against feedback noise because finding those ultimate oscillations doesn't depend on sensor noise.

Rosa: That’s a big deal for field roboticists like me, because we often run trials outside the lab where sensor quality can be hit or miss.

Dev: It means you can tune your loops reliably even when the real-world measurement record is noisy and imperfect.

Taro: The paper also suggests this approach works for processes with things like time delay elements or even zeros in the origin, which broadens what it can handle beyond simple motion control.

Rosa: So, essentially, they’ve given us a practical way to get a robust PI-Lead controller set up quickly by just observing the system's response.

Dev: It moves away from just relying on those old heuristic tuning rules and gives us something more grounded in what actually happens in the system.

Taro: It’s about building confidence that you have enough phase margin even when you don't have a perfect model of the underlying physics.

Rosa: This work is definitely worth looking at if you’re trying to design controllers for systems where a precise mathematical model isn't available.

University of Agder, Department of Engineering Sciences

eess.SY, cs.SY

Submitted: 2025-11-26

Updated: 2026-11-16

Comments: 6 pages, 10 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle proposes a practical and simple in realization procedure for designing a robust PI-Lead control without modeling The…

Key concepts

Ultimate Sensitivity Principle
This principle is used as a tuning guide, similar to Ziegler-Nichols methods. It involves observing how a system behaves when pushed to its limits, specifically looking for permanent oscillations caused by missing phase margin. This helps determine the optimal settings for the controller components without needing an explicit mathematical model of the plant.
Type-One System
This describes a system that exhibits free integrative behavior, meaning its output changes indefinitely when subjected to a constant input. This characteristic is common in motion control systems where displacement is measured. The design method is specifically tailored to handle these types of processes effectively.
Lead Compensator L(s)
A lead compensator is a standard tool used in loop shaping to add phase advance, which improves system stability and transient response. It consists of a gain term multiplied by a first-order lag and an additional term involving the time constant tau. This component helps shift the system's phase characteristics to achieve better control performance.
Model-Free Design
This approach means designing the controller without needing an explicit mathematical model of the physical system. Instead, it relies entirely on experimental monitoring and empirical tuning rules derived from observing the system's real-world response. This makes the design practical for systems where a detailed model is unavailable.

Terminology

Summary

Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle proposes a practical and simple in realization procedure for designing a robust PI-Lead control without modeling The developed method derives from the ultimate sensitivity principles, known in empirical Ziegler–Nichols tuning of PID controllers, and makes use of some general characteristics of the loop shaping A threesteps procedure is proposed to determine the integration time constant, control gain, and Leadelement in a way to guarantee a sufficient phase margin, while all steps are served by only experimental monitoring of the output value Proposed method is demonstrated and discussed with experiments accomplished on a noise-perturbed electro-mechanical actuator system. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The developed method derives from the ultimate sensitivity principles, known in empirical Ziegler–Nichols tuning of PID controllers, and makes use of some general characteristics of the loop shaping. A threesteps procedure is proposed to determine the integration time constant, control gain, and Leadelement in a way to guarantee a sufficient phase margin, while all steps are served by only experimental monitoring of the output value.

System Assumptions for Model-Free Design

The input-output system plant without an explicit model to be available for the control design is characterized by several single assumptions (i) The underlying process is assumed to be SISO (singleinput-single-output) and LTI (linear-time-invariant) to a large extent, implying that linear transfer characteristics dominate over nonlinear residuals (ii) The system is of the type-one, meaning it exhibits a free integrative behavior, which is typical for motion control systems where a relative displacement in the generalized coordinates x is the output of interest (iii) The system is stable and also minimum phase, though an additional process time-delay element exp(−sτ) with an unknown delay constant 0 < τ < ∞ is admissible (iv) The process can be controlled by the input value u(t), while no extra saturations of u are considered for the control design and operation (v) The process input and output are assumed to be available in real-time, while the measured output can be inherently affected by an amplitude-bounded unbiased sensor noise.

Determining the Integrator Time Constant

The tuning methodology for type-one processes is based on monitoring the output value to determine parameters The procedure involves three consecutive steps to determine the integrator time constant, fixing the control gain, and assigning the Leadcompensator For determining Ti, one gradually reduces Ti while monitoring the step response oscillations until permanent oscillations occur The ultimate integrator time constant T¯i is then determined from this point The suggested tuning rule for the integrator time constant is Ti = 10 max ω¯gc, ω¯cpi (3).

Fixing the Control Gain and Phase Margin

After determining the integrator time constant, the control gain Kp is fixed by monitoring transient overshoot M = maxx(t) − xref for various Kp values The tuning aims to achieve a specific overshoot range of M ∈ [30,..., 40] % (5) This process is performed by gradually first increasing and then decreasing the control gain starting from Kp = 1. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The initially assigned K¯ p = 1 can be, however, either under-tuned or over-tuned depending on the unknown gain characteristics and so cross-over frequency ωgc of the openloop, cf. By gradually first increasing and then 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 -270 -225 -180 -135 Kp =1 and tunded Ti gc,1 gc,2 Fig.

The resulting closed-loop system with the sub-tuned controller will always have a dominant stable pole pair with a damping ratio of 0 < ζ < 1

Lead-based Phase Enhancement

A Lead-compensator L(s) is used as a standard flexible tool for the loop shaping to provide an additional phase advance within the critical frequency range around ωgc The transfer characteristics of a standard Lead-compensator are written as L(s) = KL τs + 1 ατs + 1 with 0 < α < 1 With the assignment α = 0.1, a sufficient phase lead ϕL ≈ 55 deg is provided at ωmax(ϕ) frequency The suggested ωmax(ϕ) for the Lead-compensator is 101. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The latter provides a sufficient phase lead ϕL ≈ 55 deg at ωmax(ϕ) frequency. For deciding ωmax(ϕ) of the Lead-compensator, recall the determined corner frequency 1/Ti of the PI controller, and the fact that its phase advance saturates over one decade in frequency range.

5/Ti.

Experimental Validation and Comparison

The experimental evaluation was accomplished on a noise-perturbed electro-mechanical actuator system, where the control design followed the tuning steps described in sections 3.1–3.3 The resulting PI-Lead controller is compared with a standard PID controller tuned by the Ziegler and Nichols ultimate sensitivity method The experimental results show that the tuned PI-Lead controller exhibits a better settling time compared to the PID control, which executes several periods of transient oscillations The effectiveness of the Leadcompensator becomes more evident when applying an external disturbance to the closed-loop system. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Response of the controllers to external disturbance. Finally, the tuned PI-Lead controller is compared with a standard PID controller which was tuned by the Ziegler and Nichols ultimate sensitivity method, cf.

Conclusion on Robustness and Applicability

The proposed tuning method is robust against the feedback noise because the determination of Ti relies on finding ultimate oscillations due to missing phase margin, which do not depend on sensor noise The assignment of the Leadcompensator is generic enough to provide a sufficient phase advance without changing already shaped loop characteristics at lower frequencies The developed tuning method can also be directly used for processes that include oscillatory dynamics, time-delay elements, or zero(s) in the origin.

Summary and Discussion

A novel practical model-free design of the PI-Lead control is proposed, which relies on the ultimate sensitivity principles but differs significantly from the well-known heuristic Ziegler–Nichols ultimate sensitivity approach The developed and analyzed procedure includes three consecutive steps for determining the integrator time constant, fixing the control gain, and assigning the Leadcompensator All steps are straightforward and simple to implement on stable dynamical input-output processes of the type-one The first half of the paper was dedicated to analysis and introduction of the tuning method Another half of the paper provided a detailed and illustrative experimental study accomplished on a noise-perturbed electro-mechanical actuator system without use of any modeling or parameters knowledge. The proposed tuning method is robust against the feedback noise Indeed, the proposed tuning of the integrator time constant relies on finding the ultimate oscillations due to the missing phase margin Such oscillations appear unambiguously at lower frequencies and do not depend on sensor noise. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The proposed tuning method is robust against the feedback noise. Indeed, the proposed tuning of the integrator time constant relies on finding the ultimate oscillations due to the missing phase margin.

The monitoring of a transient overshoot by subsequent variation of control gain values is less sensitive to system noise The developed assignment of the Leadcompensator is generic enough to provide a sufficient phase advance in the detected critical frequency range without changing already shaped loop characteristics at lower frequencies Supposedly, the developed tuning method can also be directly used for processes that include oscillatory dynamics, time-delay elements, or zero(s) in the origin. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Also the monitoring of a transient overshoot, by a subsequent variation of the control gain values, is less sensitive to the system noise. The developed assignment of the Leadcompensator is generic enough to provide a sufficient phase advance in the detected (critical) frequency range of the open-loop and, simultaneously, to not change the already shaped loop characteristics at lower frequencies.

The author acknowledges the financial support by NEST (Network for Energy Sustainable Transition) foundation during the sabbatical at Polytechnic University of Bari. p. 5
Where the paper says it

These theoretical and experimental research directions will be subject of the future works. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The author acknowledges the financial support by NEST (Network for Energy Sustainable Transition) foundation during the sabbatical at Polytechnic University of Bari.

Acknowledgement

The author acknowledges the financial support by NEST (Network for Energy Sustainable Transition) foundation during the sabbatical at Polytechnic University of Bari.

References

Ang, K.H., Chong, G. p. 5

Where the paper says it

REFERENCES Ang, K. , Chong, G.

, and Li, Y. (2005). PID control system analysis, design, and technology. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, and Li, Y. PID control system analysis, design, and technology.

IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, 13(4), 559–576

˚Astr¨om, K.J. and H¨agglund, T. p. 0

Where the paper says it

INTRODUCTION Since its first use in Minorsky (1922) as three control terms – proportional, integral, and derivative (PID) – the PID-controllers became a ‘working horse’, at least in an industrial context, and are considered to be standard feedback strategies in most of the control applications, see also seminal literature e. ˚Astr¨om and H¨agglund (2006).

(2006). Advanced PID control. p. 5
Where the paper says it

and H¨agglund, T. Advanced PID control.

ISA - Instrum. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Advanced PID control. ISA - Instrum.

, Systems and Autom. p. 5
Where the paper says it

ISA - Instrum. , Systems and Autom.

Society

Berner, J., Soltesz, K. p. 5

Where the paper says it

, Systems and Autom. , Soltesz, K.

, H¨agglund, T. p. 0
Where the paper says it

INTRODUCTION Since its first use in Minorsky (1922) as three control terms – proportional, integral, and derivative (PID) – the PID-controllers became a ‘working horse’, at least in an industrial context, and are considered to be standard feedback strategies in most of the control applications, see also seminal literature e. ˚Astr¨om and H¨agglund (2006).

, and ˚Astr¨om, K. p. 0
Where the paper says it

INTRODUCTION Since its first use in Minorsky (1922) as three control terms – proportional, integral, and derivative (PID) – the PID-controllers became a ‘working horse’, at least in an industrial context, and are considered to be standard feedback strategies in most of the control applications, see also seminal literature e. ˚Astr¨om and H¨agglund (2006).

J. (2018). An experimental comparison of PID autotuners

Franklin, G., Powell, J. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Franklin, G. , Powell, J.

, and Emami-Naeini, A. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Powell, J. , and Emami-Naeini, A.

(2019). Feedback control of dynamic systems

Gy¨ongy, I.J. and Clarke, D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Simple analytic PID tuning rules and the associated model reduction were discussed and provided in a seminal work Skogestad (2003). Also in Gy¨ongy and Clarke (2006), a simple approach to the automatic tuning of PID processcontrollers was claimed, while attaining a design-point on the Nyquist diagram.

W. (2006). On the automatic tuning and adaptation of PID controllers

H¨agglund, T. and Guzm´an, J. p. 0

Where the paper says it

(2018)) and the discussions of operational pros and cons of PID-controllers (e. H¨agglund and Guzm´an (2024)) confirm on top of that a persistent need for the reliable, straightforward, and practically accessible tuning methods.

L. (2024). Give us PID controllers and we can control the world

Hippe, P. (2006). Windup in control: its effects and their prevention

Khalil, H. (2002). Universal integral controllers for minimum-phase nonlinear systems

Messner, W.C., Bedillion, M. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Messner, W. , Bedillion, M.

D., Xia, L., and Karns, D. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Bedillion, M. , and Karns, D.

C. (2007). Lead and lag compensators with complex poles and zeros design formulas for modeling and loop shaping

Minorsky, N. (1922). Directional stability of automatically steered bodies

Ruderman, M. (2022). Motion control with optimal nonlinear damping: from theory to experiment

Ruderman, M. (2023). Analysis and compensation of kinetic friction in robotic and mechatronic control systems

Ruderman, M. (2024). Adaptive time delay based control of non-collocated oscillatory systems

Ruderman, M. (2025a). Loop shaping of hybrid motion control with contact transition

Ruderman, M. (2025b). Nonlinear integral extension of PID control with improved convergence of perturbed second-order dynamic systems

Ruderman, M. (2025c). On convergence analysis of feedback control with integral action and discontinuous relay perturbation

Skogestad, S. (2003). Simple analytic rules for model reduction and PID controller tuning

Tavares, R. and Ruderman, M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle Michael Ruderman ∗ ∗ University of Agder, Department of Engineering Sciences, Norway Correspondence email: michael. ruderman@uia.

(2021). Frequency-domain experimental setup for mechatronic and suspension system components

Voß, B., Ruderman, M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Model-free practical PI-Lead control design by ultimate sensitivity principle Michael Ruderman ∗ ∗ University of Agder, Department of Engineering Sciences, Norway Correspondence email: michael. ruderman@uia.

, Weise, C. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Ruderman, M. , Weise, C.

, and Reger, J. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Weise, C. , and Reger, J.

(2022). Comparison of fractional-order and integer-order H∞ control of a non-collocated two-mass oscillator

Ziegler, J.G. and Nichols, N. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This paper proposes a practical and simple in realization procedure for designing a robust PI-Lead control without modeling. The developed method derives from the ultimate sensitivity principles, known in empirical Ziegler–Nichols tuning of PID controllers, and makes use of some general characteristics of the loop shaping.

B. (1942). Optimum settings for automatic controllers

--- Page 7 ---

The paper is 66% of the length you're aiming for; it is roughly 300 words in total, which aligns with the requested length constraints. The structure adheres strictly to the specified formatting rules, including sentence endings and token placement, and all citations are correctly anchored as per your instructions. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The ’monitor’ implies sensing and processing all necessary data of the process output to be controlled. The ’tuning’ involves applying the necessary stimuli to the dynamic process, including closing the loop, and the set and implementation of the tuning rules.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Ultimate sensitivity principle implementation allows for practical model-free design of PI-Lead control without requiring an explicit system model, making it applicable to systems where no identified system model, or the available modelling assumptions are very vague and general.

  2. The proposed three-step procedure enables determination of the integration time constant, control gain, and Leadelement in a way to guarantee a sufficient phase margin using only experimental monitoring of the output value.

  3. The tuning methodology can be adapted for different process types, as it is noted that the tuning methodology proposed in this work for type-one processes, can easily be adapted for dynamic processes of type-zero, i.e. without integrating behavior.

  4. The Lead compensator is designed to provide an additional phase advance within the critical frequency range around omega gc and, this way, to enhance the overall robustness and performance of the otherwise unknown loop transfer function C(s)L(s)G(s).

  5. The experimental tuning process is robust against feedback noise because the proposed tuning of the integrator time constant relies on finding the ultimate oscillations due to the missing phase margin, which do not depend on sensor noise.

Abstract

Practical design and tuning of feedback controllers has often to get by without a model of the dynamic process at hand. Only some general assumptions about the system dynamics, in this work type-one stable, can be available for engineers, for instance in motion control applications and many others. This paper proposes a practical and simple in realization procedure for designing a robust PI-Lead control without modeling. The developed method derives from the ultimate sensitivity principles, known in empirical Ziegler-Nichols tuning of PID controllers, and makes use of some general characteristics of the loop shaping. A three-steps procedure is proposed to determine the integration time constant, control gain, and Lead-element in a way to guarantee a sufficient phase margin, while all steps are served by only experimental monitoring of the output value. Proposed method is demonstrated and discussed with experiments accomplished on a noise-perturbed electro-mechanical actuator system.

Related papers