Thermal Leptogenesis in SO(10) times U(1) A SUSY GUT
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Thermal Leptogenesis in SO(10) times U(1) A SUSY GUT".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Thermal leptogenesis in SO(10) × U(1)A SUSY GUT investigates how baryon asymmetry is generated within a supersymmetric grand unified theory based on the SO(10) × U(1)A symmetry, resolving issues like doublet–triplet splitting and unrealistic Yukawa relations under natural assumptions.
Kai: The predicted baryon asymmetry is too small when all O(1) coefficients are unity, but a moderate enhancement factor r1 ∼ 5.4 for the lightest right-handed neutrino mass reproduces the observed baryon asymmetry without spoiling low-energy neutrino data.
Mira: Model Framework and Natural Assumptions The study is built upon a natural SO(10) GUT where both the doublet–triplet splitting problem and unrealistic Yukawa relations are resolved under the natural assumption that all symmetry-allowed interactions appear with O(1) coefficients.
Kai: This framework dictates that the structures of Dirac neutrino Yukawa couplings and right-handed neutrino masses are determined entirely by the symmetry.
Paper summary: Kai: So to recap on "Thermal Leptogenesis in SO(ten times U one A SUSY GUT", this paper investigates how baryon asymmetry is generated within a supersymmetric grand unified theory based on that specific SO(ten times U one A symmetry <ref:2511.11100#pg1,within a supersymmetric grand unified theory>.
Mira: The main thesis is that by making the natural assumption that all symmetry allowed interactions appear with O one coefficients, they resolve two major issues in these GUTs: the doublet-triplet splitting problem and those unrealistic Yukawa relations.
Lev: So they are using this specific framework to determine how the Dirac neutrino Yukawa couplings and those right-handed neutrino masses are fixed entirely by the symmetry itself.
Kai: And then they compute the baryon asymmetry of the universe by including flavor effects, Higgs asymmetry contributions, and specifically looking at the impact of that second-lightest right-handed neutrino.
Mira: The key finding is that while their initial prediction for the asymmetry is too small when all O one coefficients are unity for those couplings, a specific enhancement factor r one about five point four makes it match the observed baryon asymmetry without contradicting low-energy neutrino data.
Lev: So to put it simply, they show that this specific GUT structure can work for leptogenesis if you allow for that particular enhancement in the right-handed neutrino mass scale.
Kai: And they even look at how flavor effects change things when the temperature drops below one thousand thirteen giga electron volts, suggesting those effects aren't negligible there.
Mira: That means they are linking the observed baryon asymmetry directly to predictions for the lightest left-handed neutrino mass in this specific model.
Lev: It’s important because it gives us a concrete prediction for a low-energy particle mass based on a high-energy symmetry structure, which is exactly what we need to check against experimental results or future collider constraints.
Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about "Thermal Leptogenesis in SO(ten times U one A SUSY GUT", this work ties together particle physics structure, cosmology, and the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry <ref:2511.11100#pg1,Thermal Leptogenesis in SO(10>.
Mira: It’s important because it shows that a specific symmetry framework can naturally generate the necessary ingredients for baryogenesis while simultaneously solving some of the structural headaches inherent in those theories.
Lev: So what does this mean for us as researchers? It means we have a specific set of parameters to test, and we know which physical states—like that second-lightest right-handed neutrino—are going to be important in the dynamics.
Kai: Yeah, it means the connection between high energy symmetry and low energy neutrino masses is much tighter than we might have thought before.
Mira: It confirms that thermal leptogenesis can happen within this SUSY GUT structure under natural assumptions, provided you allow for that specific factor of five point four enhancement in the right-handed neutrino mass.
Lev: For us on the hardware side, it means we know what kind of flavor dynamics we need to account for when we're designing simulations or looking at error correction overheads.
Kai: It gives us a more focused direction for searching for these asymmetries in any experimental setup that might probe these high energy scales.
Mira: And it confirms that the complexity of the model doesn't automatically mean it’s unphysical; sometimes the symmetry itself dictates a specific, workable path forward.
Nobuhiro Maekawa, Kei Shibata, Masato Yamanaka
Department of Physics, Nagoya University · Kobayashi-Maskawa Institute for the Origin of Particles and the Universe · Department of Global Environment Studies, Hiroshima Institute of Technology
hep-ph, gr-qc
Submitted: 2025-11-14
Updated: 2026-10-31
Comments: 24 pages + appendices, 9 figures, 5 tables 29 pages, 5 figures. v2 incorporates the corrections published in JHEP 09 (2026) 149
Journal ref: JHEP 06 (2026) 202; Erratum: JHEP 09 (2026) 149
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 76/100
The gist: Thermal leptogenesis in SO(10) × U(1)A SUSY GUT investigates how baryon asymmetry is generated within a supersymmetric grand unified theory based on the SO(10) × U(1)A symmetry…
Key concepts
- SO(10) × U(1)A GUT
- This is a grand unified theory framework combining the SO(10) symmetry with an additional U(1A) gauge symmetry. This structure is used to naturally resolve problems like the doublet-triplet splitting issue and ensures that Yukawa couplings follow realistic patterns when assuming all interactions have O(1) coefficients.
- Thermal Leptogenesis
- This mechanism describes how the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry (baryon asymmetry) is created via CP-violating decays and scatterings of right-handed neutrinos in a hot, early universe. The generated B-L asymmetry depends on the neutrino Yukawa couplings and the RH neutrino mass spectrum dictated by the GUT structure.
- Flavor Effects
- These effects occur when temperatures drop below 1013 GeV, qualitatively changing how efficiently leptogenesis proceeds. They are crucial because they can alter both the efficiency and even the final sign of the generated baryon asymmetry, especially when neutrino Yukawa couplings are hierarchical.
Terminology
Summary
Thermal leptogenesis in SO(10) × U(1)A SUSY GUT investigates how baryon asymmetry is generated within a supersymmetric grand unified theory based on the SO(10) × U(1)A symmetry, resolving issues like doublet–triplet splitting and unrealistic Yukawa relations under natural assumptions. p. 0 The predicted baryon asymmetry is too small when all O(1) coefficients are unity, but a moderate enhancement factor r1 ∼ 5. p. 04 for the lightest right-handed neutrino mass reproduces the observed baryon asymmetry without spoiling low-energy neutrino data. p. 0
Model Framework and Natural Assumptions
The study is built upon a natural SO(10) GUT where both the doublet–triplet splitting problem and unrealistic Yukawa relations are resolved under the natural assumption that all symmetry-allowed interactions appear with O(1) coefficients. This framework dictates that the structures of Dirac neutrino Yukawa couplings and right-handed neutrino masses are determined entirely by the symmetry. p. 0 The anomalous U(1)A gauge symmetry plays a crucial role, where it is canceled by the Green–Schwarz mechanism. p. 4
Leptogenesis Mechanism and Flavor Dynamics
The baryon (B) and lepton (L) asymmetries are dynamically generated through CP-violating (inverse) decays and scatterings of RH neutrinos. The generated B − L asymmetry depends on both the neutrino Yukawa couplings and the RH-neutrino mass spectrum, which are dictated by the SO(10) × U(1)A GUT structure. p. 9 Flavor effects are essential, as they can qualitatively change the efficiency and even the sign of the final baryon asymmetry when temperatures fall below 1013 GeV. p. 2
Numerical Results and Parameter Space
Numerical calculations show that for r1 ∼ 5–6, the observed baryon asymmetry can indeed be obtained, with the mass of the lightest LH neutrino predicted to be 1/r1 of its symmetry-determined value. The favored value for the lightest RH-neutrino mass is determined as M1 = 5. p. 04 × (2.6 × 108 GeV) = 1. p. 34 × 109 GeV, consistent with the SO(10) × U(1)A symmetry structure and the observed baryon asymmetry. p. 2 This implies a prediction for the lightest LH neutrino mass of mν1 ∼ mν1(r1 = 1)/r1 ∼ λ2mν3/r1 ∼ 4. p. 05 × 10−4 eV.
Comparison with Alternative Scenarios
The SO(10) × U(1)A scenario tends to yield a larger baryon asymmetry than the E6 × U(1)A case with fixed r1 < 5.4, owing to the milder suppression of the CP asymmetry with respect to λ. p. 3 The SO(10) × U(1)A model produces approximately twice the B−L asymmetry of the E6 × U(1)A scenario. p. 3
Conclusion
The work demonstrates that thermal leptogenesis is realized in this SO(10)×U(1)A SUSY GUT, establishing a link between the observed baryon asymmetry and predictions for the lightest neutrino mass. The importance of the second-lightest RH neutrino N2 in leptogenesis with flavor effects is reconfirmed. p. 3 The analysis of 45 sign-flip patterns shows that seven of fifteen patterns can achieve the observed asymmetry with certain r1 < 15, suggesting the model's robustness.
Appendix A: Boltzmann Equations
The evolution of the B − L asymmetry is governed by a set of coupled Boltzmann equations for the right-handed neutrinos N1, N2, and the flavored B−L asymmetries Δα. These equations include scattering terms such as (inverse-) decays and scattering processes involving species like s-tops.
Appendix B: Sign-flipped Dirac neutrino Yukawa and flavored CP asymmetries
The study examines the consequences of flipping the signs of individual entries in the Dirac neutrino Yukawa matrix to classify sign-flipped patterns that yield the same prediction on the Baryon asymmetry. It is shown that all other CP asymmetries are invariant under certain sign-flip operations, which allows for a reduction of arbitrary sign-flip configurations to those involving only one or two entries.
Appendix C: Flavor Effect on Leptogenesis
The flavor effect in leptogenesis is crucial because it can qualitatively change the efficiency and even the sign of the final baryon asymmetry when temperatures fall below 1013 GeV. The enhancement is particularly pronounced for hierarchical neutrino Yukawa couplings, which is exactly the case in SO(10)×U(1)A models where most O(1) coefficients are taken to be unity except for the one controlling the mass of the lightest RH neutrino. p. 0
Appendix D: Other patterns of neutrino Yukawa matrices
The analysis explores alternative patterns of neutrino Yukawa matrices by considering scenarios where some Yukawa entries have −1 as their O(1) coefficient. Flipping signs in the neutrino Yukawa matrix changes the flavored CP asymmetries in magnitude and sign, while the decay parameters remain unchanged. p. 8
Table I: Field content of a natural SO(10) GUT with U(1)A charges which are denoted by small characters
Table I lists the field content of a natural SO(10) GUT with U(1)A charges which are denoted by small characters. The crucial point is that under the natural assumption that all symmetry-allowed operators appear with O(1) coefficients, hierarchical Yukawa structures are reproduced automatically. p. 5 p. 5
Table II: Three RH-neutrino masses and Dirac neutrino Yukawa entries fixed by symmetry in this scenario, up to O(1) coefficients
Table II summarizes the three RH-neutrino masses and Dirac neutrino Yukawa entries fixed by symmetry in this scenario, up to O(1) coefficients. The resulting LH-neutrino masses are generated via the seesaw formula. p. 8 p. 8
Table III: Flavored CP asymmetries and decay parameters for r1 = ๑ in SO(๑๐) × U(๑)A GUT scenario
Table III presents the flavored CP asymmetries and decay parameters for r1 = ๑ in SO(10) × U(1)A GUT scenario. These values confirm that the τ flavor asymmetry is strongly washed out, while the e and µ channels are comparatively weaker. p. 2
Table IV: The correlation between the sign pattern of each component of the Yukawa matrix yνD and resulting sign of the flavored CP asymmetry, and the corresponding maximum value of YB−L
Table IV shows the correlation between the sign pattern of each component of the Yukawa matrix yνD and resulting sign of the flavored CP asymmetry, and its corresponding maximum value.
Table V: Masses of the lightest and heaviest RH neutrinos, and ij components of y†νD yνD
Table V provides the masses of the lightest and heaviest RH neutrinos, and ij components of y†νD yνD. The CP asymmetry follows from the symmetries in each model as shown in equation (25). p. 1
Table VI: ๑๕ Groups among all operations for flipping the signs of Dirac neutrino Yukawa couplings
Table VI classifies all possible sign-flip patterns involving Dirac neutrino Yukawa couplings into ๑๕ groups. The models given by some sign flip operations in each group give the same prediction on the Baryon asymmetry. p. 2
Table I lists typical quantum numbers for a natural SO(10) GUT with U(1)A charges which are denoted by small characters. The crucial point is that under the natural assumption that all symmetry-allowed operators appear with O(1) coefficients, hierarchical Yukawa structures are reproduced automatically.
Table II lists typical quantum numbers for a natural SO(10) GUT with U(1)A charges which are denoted by small characters. The resulting LH-neutrino masses are generated via the seesaw formula.
Table IV: The correlation between the sign pattern of each component of the Yukawa matrix yνD and resulting sign of the flavored CP asymmetry, and its corresponding maximum value of YB−L
Table IV shows the correlation between the sign pattern of each component of the Yukawa matrix yνD and resulting sign of the flavored CP asymmetry, and its corresponding maximum value.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Ability to constrain model parameter space based on observed baryon asymmetry by calculating required values for r1, such as
for r1 5–6, the observed baryon asymmetry can indeed be obtained.
-
Capability to predict low-energy neutrino mass constraints from high-scale leptogenesis parameters, specifically predicting
the lightest LH neutrino mass is reduced to 1/r1 of its symmetry-determined value.
-
Proficiency in identifying which sign flip patterns of Dirac neutrino Yukawa couplings generate the observed baryon asymmetry, such as noting that "seven of fifteen patterns can achieve the observed asymmetry with certain r1 < 15."
-
Skill in comparing predictions between different Grand Unified Theories by quantifying the difference, such as concluding that
the SO(10)×U(1)A scenario tends to yield a larger baryon asymmetry than the E6 × U(1)A case with fixed r1.
-
Accuracy in calculating flavor effects on leptogenesis by determining how they amplify the asymmetry, specifically noting that
the final B−L asymmetry is enhanced by roughly an order of magnitude
when flavor effects are included. -
Capacity to analyze the role of the second-lightest right-handed neutrino, identifying when its contribution becomes significant, such as noting that
the N2 contribution becomes significant when some of the flavored decay parameters of the lightest RH neutrino are smaller than 3.
Sources
- Complex Spinors and Unified Theories
- A lower bound on the right-handed neutrino mass from leptogenesis
- Heavy Majorana Neutrinos and Baryogenesis
- SO(10) unified models and soft leptogenesis
- Leptogenesis in Realistic SO(10) Models
- Neutrino Oscillations v.s. Leptogenesis in SO(10) Models
- Lopsided Mass Matrices and Leptogenesis in SO(10) GUT
- Seesaw geometry and leptogenesis
- The importance of N2 leptogenesis
- Successful type I Leptogenesis with SO(10)-inspired mass relations
- Impact of flavour coupling on $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis
- Baryogenesis through leptogenesis
- Primordial Lepton Family Asymmtries in Seesaw Model
- The importance of flavor in leptogenesis
- Neutrino masses, anomalous U(1) gauge symmetry and doublet-triplet splitting
- Gauge Coupling Unification with Anomalous U(1)_A Gauge Symmetry
- Gauge Coupling Unification in GUT with Anomalous U(1) Symmetry
- Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters
- CP violating decays in leptogenesis scenarios
- Flavour Matters in Leptogenesis
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses