Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity

arXiv:2511.04311 · hep-th · Submitted 2025-11-06 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT.

Kai: Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper studies the recent proposal of

1: which poses a precise holographic duality between a 3d TQFT summed over all topologies and a unitary ensemble of boundary 2d CFTs.

Mira: The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT.

Kai: This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity," and it’s about proposing a precise holographic duality between summing up three dimensional topological quantum field theories summed over all topologies and a unitary ensemble of two dimensional conformal field theories.

Mira: It claims that each member of this ensemble gets weighted by a symmetry factor, which is given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk theory acting as its SymTFT.

Lev: So what does that mean for us in terms of what we can actually build or measure?

Kai: It suggests that this weighting scheme is actually the natural, uniform way to average things up to isomorphism when you look at the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras describing those boundary theories.

Mira: And they do make this explicit by writing down how they sum over topologies using equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of three dimensional manifolds with a given boundary and commenting on those weights.

Lev: That sounds complicated for real hardware. How does that translate to something we can actually simulate?

Kai: Well, the paper says this framework allows us to view the holographic duality as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula

forty-three–forty-six: <ref:2511.04311#pg2>.

Mira: The authors discuss what this main result implies for noncompact three dimensional quantum field theories. For instance, in the Virasoro case, it means we get an ensemble of all conformal field theories at a given central charge where each one is weighted by its full invertible symmetry group.

Lev: That sounds like a lot of data to sift through if we try to run this on a real computer. What about the baby universe Hilbert space they mention? Is that something concrete?

Kai: They show how this three dimensional TQFT gravity framework gives us a natural construction for the baby universe Hilbert space.

Mira: The derivation of these weights comes from looking at the ensemble average, which they write as being related to X A one times the order of the automorphism group of A factorial minus one times X A one times Z alpha.

Lev: And they say that considering X alpha Z alpha as a partition function for a two dimensional TQFT with a categorical symmetry C alpha, in the large genus limit, it effectively counts the number of invertible topological line defects of C alpha.

Paper summary: Kai: So these weights aren't just some arbitrary numbers; they are intrinsic to the holographic duality itself and they also serve as natural weights for defining a uniform average up to isomorphism because each member is described by a Lagrangian algebra A.

Mira: They give examples, like with Abelian TQFTs where all the anyons are invertible, leading to an ensemble of equal weights. But for something more complex like the SU(two) four times SU(two) four example, the weights should be inversely proportional to the invertible symmetry group that commutes with this vertex operator algebra <ref:2511.04311#pg1>.

Lev: So if we take a theory with a high degree of symmetry, say a continuous symmetry, they imply that this theory will get heavily suppressed in the ensemble. That's an interesting constraint on what kind of theories we expect to see.

Kai: Exactly. For noncompact TQFTs, they argue that the holographic duality for Narain ensemble averages can be formally understood as a case of this TQFT gravity framework, specifically for the Virasoro case where the vertex algebra is Virc times Virc.

Mira: And in that Virasoro context, you get an ensemble including all conformal field theories of a given central charge c, but they are inversely weighted by the size of their full symmetry group.

Lev: That means theories with continuous symmetries will effectively drop out of the ensemble when we look at this average. It puts a strong filter on the resulting physical states.

Kai: The discussion also relates this holographic duality to a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula

forty-three–forty-six: <ref:2511.04311#pg2>. They suggest that if you look at coarse-grained ensemble averaging, where you only know about the asymptotic left and right vertex algebra symmetry on the boundary and the identity operator, maximal ignorance points us toward a uniform average on all theories with that specific vertex algebra symmetry.

Mira: The bulk gravity calculation involving the sum over all three dimensional manifolds exactly achieves this uniform average.

Lev: So from an engineering standpoint, it sounds like they are using a topological structure to define a consistent way to ensemble boundary physics, even if the underlying computation is massive.

Kai: They also touched on the classification for k equals one in chiral gravity, mentioning that their ensemble average is just the theories with dimension of V1 equal to zero which they conjecture might just be the Monster.

Paper summary: Mira: It’s interesting how they connect this to B normalization of quantum dimensions for simple objects in module categories, defining those quantum dimensions as a trace of the identity morphism of a simple object Mi.

Lev: So we are talking about defining these quantum dimensions based on the fusion ring structure of the category A, where you get X i FPdimC(Mi) two equals FPdimAFPdimC (B <ref:2511.04311#pg1>.one) <ref:2511.04311#pg1>.

Kai: The paper also touches on how to define quantum dimensions for simple objects in the module category CA, and they show how to connect that back to the fusion ring of CA.

Mira: They want to understand what normalization choice corresponds to their convention in equation four point three when talking about those quantum dimensions.

Lev: So they are trying to nail down the precise normalization for these dimensions so we know what physical quantity we're measuring when we talk about the simple objects Mi.

Kai: Overall, this paper, "Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity," presents a new way to weight boundary CFTs using symmetry factors derived from the bulk TQFT.

Mira: The main result is that this weighting is the natural way to get a uniform average up to isomorphism on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras describing those boundary theories.

Lev: It sounds like it provides a rigorous, if complex, justification for averaging over different topological configurations in gravity duals.

Kai: And they show how this framework connects TQFT gravity to concepts like the Siegel-Weil formula and gives a structure for the baby universe Hilbert space.

Mira: So to wrap up, this paper "Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity" suggests that the holographic duality between three dimensional topological quantum field theories summed over all topologies and boundary two dimensional conformal field theories is better understood when we introduce symmetry factors into the ensemble weighting.

Kai: Essentially, each boundary theory gets weighted by a factor based on the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk theory acting as its SymTFT.

Lev: It gives us a concrete way to think about how those weights arise from topology and symmetries, which is useful when you're trying to map these ideas onto real hardware or simulations.

Mira: And it connects this averaging procedure to concepts like the Siegel-Weil formula and provides a framework for understanding noncompact three dimensional theories by showing that highly symmetric theories are suppressed in the ensemble.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up on this paper, "Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity." It’s about proposing a way to weight different boundary theories based on their underlying symmetries derived from the bulk three dimensional topological quantum field theory.

Mira: Right, so essentially they’re taking that sum over all possible shapes and giving each resulting physics a weight tied directly to how much symmetry it has relative to the main gravity setup.

Lev: It means we've got this framework where the averaging isn't just some simple uniform average; it’s constrained by the group theory of those boundary theories.

Kai: That’s right, and what they do is show that this weighting scheme is actually what you need if you want a truly uniform average up to isomorphism when you look at all those Lagrangian algebras describing the boundary systems.

Mira: It connects this to some older ideas like the Siegel-Weil formula, which is interesting because it gives a geometric interpretation of how these different theories are related.

Lev: I’m interested in what that implies for building things. If we were trying to construct a real physical system based on this, how much overhead would we have to account for tracking all those symmetry groups?

Kai: Well, the paper suggests that this structure gives us a natural way to build the baby universe Hilbert space from the three dimensional theory itself.

Mira: And they pointed out that in specific cases like chiral gravity, their ensemble average might actually just be limited to a very small set of theories, like something called the Monster.

Lev: So it sounds like this framework imposes strong restrictions on which boundary physics are even allowed to exist in this gravitational context.

University of Kentucky

hep-th

Submitted: 2025-11-06

Updated: 2026-11-12

Comments: 65 pages, 6 figures. v2: minor corrections and clarifications, references updated; revised argument in Appendix B

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT…

Key concepts

Bulk TQFT
This refers to a topological quantum field theory defined on 3-manifolds. It acts as the fundamental structure whose symmetries are used to weight the boundary theories. In this context, it is related to 3D gravity and its topological aspects.
Categorical Symmetry
This is a symmetry associated with each member of the ensemble (boundary theory) relative to the bulk TQFT. It dictates how the boundary theory relates to the bulk structure, and its invertible symmetry group determines the weighting factor for that specific boundary theory.
SymTFT
This stands for Symmetry Topological Field Theory. Each member of the holographic ensemble is naturally described by a SymTFT derived from the bulk TQFT. This framework allows for a consistent description of the boundary theories and their relationship to the bulk geometry.
Ensemble Weighting
The ensemble average over boundary theories is not uniform; instead, each theory is weighted inversely by the order of its invertible symmetry group. This weighting ensures that the ensemble represents a natural, uniform measure up to isomorphism on the space of Lagrangian algebras describing the boundary theories.

Terminology

Summary

The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In that proposal, the sum over topologies is obtained via genus reduction from topologies with a large genus boundary Riemann surface, while the boundary ensemble is given by all CFTs described by Lagrangian condensations of the bulk TQFT. The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

In that proposal, the sum over topologies is obtained via genus reduction from topologies with a large genus boundary Riemann surface, while the boundary ensemble is given by all CFTs described by Lagrangian condensations of the bulk TQFT. The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper studies the recent proposal of [1] which poses a precise holographic duality between a 3d TQFT summed over all topologies and a unitary ensemble of boundary 2d CFTs. The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT. This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT. This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories.

We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

The holographic duality in this framework can then be viewed as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights. The holographic duality in this framework can then be viewed as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula.

We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The holographic duality in this framework can then be viewed as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula. We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs.

In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs. In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry.

Finally, we show how this TQFT gravity framework gives a natural construction of the baby universe Hilbert space. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry. Finally, we show how this TQFT gravity framework gives a natural construction of the baby universe Hilbert space.

How the training signal is built

The ensemble average can be written as = X A 1 Aut(A)!−1 X A 1 Aut(A) ZA. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Each member of the ensemble, being a Lagrangian condensation, is algebraically described by what is known as a Lagrangian algebra A. We will show that our resulting ensemble average can be written as < Z >= X A 1 |Aut(A)| !

The key point in deriving (4. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In a given boundary theory, these are the invertible TDLs that commute with the vertex algebra associated with the bulk TQFT. The key point in deriving (1.

4) is to consider ⟨ZαZα⟩ as a partition function of a 2d TQFT with a categorical symmetry C (α), and in the large genus limit this partition function will effectively count the number of invertible topological line defects (TDLs) of C (α). p. 4
Where the paper says it

The key point in deriving (1. 4) is to consider ⟨Zα|Zα⟩ as a partition function of a 2d TQFT with a categorical symmetry C (α) , and in the large genus limit this partition function will effectively count the number of invertible topological line defects (TDLs) of C (α) .

The weights in (4. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

4) are not only intrinsic to the TQFT holographic ensemble duality, but they are also — as we will argue — the natural weights for defining a uniform average up-to-isomorphism. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The weights in (1. 4) are not only intrinsic to the TQFT holographic ensemble duality, but they are also — as we will argue — the natural weights for defining a uniform average up-to-isomorphism.

Each member of the ensemble, being a Lagrangian condensation, is algebraically described by what is known as a Lagrangian algebra A. p. 4
Where the paper says it

4) are not only intrinsic to the TQFT holographic ensemble duality, but they are also — as we will argue — the natural weights for defining a uniform average up-to-isomorphism. Each member of the ensemble, being a Lagrangian condensation, is algebraically described by what is known as a Lagrangian algebra A.

Where the gains come from

The main result of this paper is that a 3d TQFT summed over all topologies as proposed in [1] is dual to an ensemble of boundary theories where each member of the ensemble is (inversely) weighted by a symmetry factor. The bulk TQFT naturally acts as a symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) for each member, and so each member α has a certain categorical symmetry C (α) relative to the bulk TQFT. p. 4

Where the paper says it

1 Summary of the main result The main result of this paper is that a 3d TQFT summed over all topologies as proposed in [1] is dual to an ensemble of boundary theories where each member of the ensemble is (inversely) weighted by a symmetry factor. The bulk TQFT naturally acts as a symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) for each member, and so each member α has a certain categorical symmetry C (α) relative to the bulk TQFT.

The weights are inversely related to the order of the group of invertible symmetries of this categorical symmetry, namely wα = 1 / Inv(C (α)) (4. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The bulk TQFT naturally acts as a symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) for each member, and so each member α has a certain categorical symmetry C (α) relative to the bulk TQFT. What we will show is that the weights are inversely related to the order of the group of invertible symmetries of this categorical symmetry, namely (up to an overall normalization) wα = 1 |Inv(C (α) )| (1.

5).

Ensemble weights from symmetries

The ensemble average can be written as = X A 1 Aut(A) ZA (4.12). The group Inv(TA) is known to be isomorphic to the automorphism group of the Lagrangian algebra A. p. 4

Where the paper says it

4) where Inv(C) denotes the group of isomorphism classes of invertible objects in the category C. In a given boundary theory, these are the invertible TDLs that commute with the vertex algebra associated with the bulk TQFT.

The ensemble average when written as a sum over algebra objects can be written as X A 1 Aut(A) ZA (4. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Each member of the ensemble, being a Lagrangian condensation, is algebraically described by what is known as a Lagrangian algebra A. We will show that our resulting ensemble average can be written as < Z >= X A 1 |Aut(A)| !

12).

Examples

The paper presents several examples to illustrate the main result of getting the weights from symmetries. For Abelian TQFTs, all the anyons are invertible and hence form an Abelian group under fusion, leading to an ensemble of equal weights. p. 3

Where the paper says it

In that limit, the duality simplifies drastically: the sum over topologies becomes just a sum over handlebodies, and the task of evaluating the weights of the boundary ensemble becomes much simpler as the states |Zα⟩ can be shown to become orthogonal in that limit. For Abelian TQFTs, as was shown explicitly in [1], all Lagrangian condensations are weighted equally, but in a general TQFT, the relative weights will have the form wα wα′ = lim g→∞ ⟨Zα′|Zα′⟩ ⟨Zα|Zα⟩ , (1.

In the SU(2)4 × SU(2)4 example, the weights should be inversely proportional to the invertible symmetry group that commutes with this VOA. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The bulk TQFT naturally acts as a symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) for each member, and so each member α has a certain categorical symmetry C (α) relative to the bulk TQFT. What we will show is that the weights are inversely related to the order of the group of invertible symmetries of this categorical symmetry, namely (up to an overall normalization) wα = 1 |Inv(C (α) )| (1.

Implications for noncompact TQFTs

The holographic duality of Narain ensemble average [26, 27] can be, at least formally, understood as a case of this TQFT gravity framework. For the Virasoro case, since our vertex algebra now is Virc × Virc, the ensemble should include all CFTs of central charge c, where each CFT is inversely weighted by the size of its full symmetry group. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs. In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry.

This tells us right away that highly symmetric theories will be heavily suppressed, for example theories with continuous symmetries will effectively drop out of the ensemble. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT. This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories.

Discussion

The holographic duality we present then can be viewed as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula [43–46]. The coarse-grained interpretation of ensemble averaging in our context can be backed up by the following argument. p. 2

Where the paper says it

This resolution seems to be backed up by the results of JT gravity [2]. The ensemble picture is an illustration of the early ideas considered by Coleman [3] and by Giddings and Strominger [4, 5] according to which the contribution of euclidean wormholes leads to disorder averaging.

The bulk calculation that we did involved no lines ending on the boundary. p. 7
Where the paper says it

A choice of basis states in Hg corresponding to inserting the shown network of lines inside in a handlebody SΣg. Using this basis, one can prepare wavefunctions corresponding to genus g conformal blocks4 of VT by doing the path integral with the corresponding insertion and using gapless boundary conditions analogous to our genus 1 case.

Information-wise, this amounts to having only knowledge about the asymptotic left and right vertex (chiral) algebra symmetry on the boundary and the identity operator. p. 5
Where the paper says it

1 3d TQFTs 3d TQFTs are closely connected to 2d rational CFTs (RCFTs) and the concept of chiral algebras which more formally known as Vertex Operator Algebras (VOAs) [47–49]. In 1See also [39] for upcoming work related to the mass formula and topological boundary conditions.

Maximal ignorance would then tell us that we should do a uniform (up to isomorphism) average on all theories that have this vertex algebra symmetry and the identity operator, and indeed the bulk gravity calculation involving the sum over all manifolds does exactly that. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT. This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories.

Chiral gravity

For k = 1, there is the well-known classification proposed by Schellekens [127] which contains 71 theories, classified by their space of spin 1 currents denoted as V1. Our ensemble average for k = 1 is then just the ensemble of theories with dim V1 = 0 which is highly conjectured to be just the Monster. p. 5

Where the paper says it

6) The holographic duality we present then can be viewed as a generalization of the SiegelWeil formula [43–46]. The Siegel-Weil formula relates the automorphism-weighted average over lattice Riemann theta functions (related to the partition functions of boundary free bosons) to an Eisenstein series (related to the sum over handlebodies), and explains the holographic duality of the ensemble average of Narain theories [26, 27].

Siegel-Weil formula for self-dual VOAs

The holographic duality of TQFT gravity gives a generalization for the Siegel-Weil formula. The usual Siegel-Weil formula can be cast in a VOA context by mapping the lattice to its corresponding lattice VOA via the known construction of [48]. p. 5

Where the paper says it

6) The holographic duality we present then can be viewed as a generalization of the SiegelWeil formula [43–46]. The Siegel-Weil formula relates the automorphism-weighted average over lattice Riemann theta functions (related to the partition functions of boundary free bosons) to an Eisenstein series (related to the sum over handlebodies), and explains the holographic duality of the ensemble average of Narain theories [26, 27].

This is the same result that leads to U(1) gravity (but chiral in this context) so there are no surprises there. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The ensemble picture is an illustration of the early ideas considered by Coleman [3] and by Giddings and Strominger [4, 5] according to which the contribution of euclidean wormholes leads to disorder averaging. These ideas were recently recast in the context of asymptotically AdS boundaries by Marolf and Maxfield [6].

The concept of a genus of VOAs was first proposed by Höhn [132] where he defined it as the set of all VOAs that have the same modular tensor category (MTC) as their representation category. p. 6
Where the paper says it

2) 2Note that to define the TQFT from an MTC, one should specify the chiral central charge c− since the category is only sensitive to c− = 0 mod 8. 3 In this context we say the VOA is nonchiral if it contains Vir × Vir; see [53–55] for definitions of nonchiral VOAs – 6 –

B Normalization of quantum dimensions of module categories

We want to understand how to define quantum dimensions for simple objects in CA, where a quantum dimension here is a trace of the identity morphism of the simple object. p. 7

Where the paper says it

4) which can be simplified, using the Verlinde formula to diagonalize the fusion rules, into dim Hg = D 2g−2 T X a d 2−2g a , (2. 5) where da denotes the quantum dimensions the anyon a, and DT = qP a d 2 a is the total quantum dimension of T .

We will denote these dimensions by FPdim, and the simple objects of the module categroy CA as Mi. p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 R Chern Simons 41 6. 2 Virasoro TQFT 41 7 Discussion 46 A Brief review of modular tensor categories 48 B Normalization of quantum dimensions of module categories 51 – 1 –

In this case we get X i FPdimC(Mi) 2 = FPdim(A)FPdim(C) (B. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The Siegel-Weil formula relates the automorphism-weighted average over lattice Riemann theta functions (related to the partition functions of boundary free bosons) to an Eisenstein series (related to the sum over handlebodies), and explains the holographic duality of the ensemble average of Narain theories [26, 27]. In our case, we get an automorphism-weighted average over partition functions of Lagrangian algebras equivalent to a sum over all 3-manifolds instead of just handlebodies.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The Siegel-Weil formula relates the automorphism-weighted average over lattice Riemann theta functions (related to the partition functions of boundary free bosons) to an Eisenstein series (related to the sum over handlebodies), and explains the holographic duality of the ensemble average of Narain theories [26, 27]. In our case, we get an automorphism-weighted average over partition functions of Lagrangian algebras equivalent to a sum over all 3-manifolds instead of just handlebodies.

1).

References

[86] J Hass, A Thompson and W Thurston, Stabilization of heegaard splittings, Geometry & Topology 13 (2009) 2029.

[87] M Scharlemann, Heegaard splittings of compact 3-manifolds, math/0007144. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

[88] U Oertel, Mapping class groups of compression bodies and 3-manifolds, math/0607444. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In section 3, we first review the main derivation of TQFT gravity following [1] and elaborate a bit more on the sum over topologies, writing it explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings. We then give some arguments that the mapping class group invariant subspace of the infinite genus Hilbert space has a natural interpretation as the baby universe Hilbert space.

[89] E Torres and X Yu, SymTFT entanglement and holographic (non)-factorization. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The holographic duality in this framework can then be viewed as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula. We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The holographic duality in this framework can then be viewed as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula. We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs.

[90] L Bhardwaj and Y Tachikawa, On finite symmetries and their gauging in two dimensions.

[98] R Vanhove, L Lootens, H.-H. Tu and F. Verstraete, Topological aspects of the critical three-state Potts model. p. 5

Where the paper says it

5), which defines the counting measure in the groupoid sense, is known as the groupoid cardinality [38]. It is the analog of the Smith–Minkowski–Siegel “mass” formula1 for lattices [40–42], and as we will show later it will be given by the norm of the HartleHawking (HH) state, which is the partition function of a closed universe ⟨HH|HH⟩ = X A 1 |Aut(A)| .

p. 5
Where the paper says it

5), which defines the counting measure in the groupoid sense, is known as the groupoid cardinality [38]. It is the analog of the Smith–Minkowski–Siegel “mass” formula1 for lattices [40–42], and as we will show later it will be given by the norm of the HartleHawking (HH) state, which is the partition function of a closed universe ⟨HH|HH⟩ = X A 1 |Aut(A)| .

[26] A Maloney and E Witten, Averaging Over Narain Moduli Space. p. 5

Where the paper says it

6) The holographic duality we present then can be viewed as a generalization of the SiegelWeil formula [43–46]. The Siegel-Weil formula relates the automorphism-weighted average over lattice Riemann theta functions (related to the partition functions of boundary free bosons) to an Eisenstein series (related to the sum over handlebodies), and explains the holographic duality of the ensemble average of Narain theories [26, 27].

p. 5
Where the paper says it

6) The holographic duality we present then can be viewed as a generalization of the SiegelWeil formula [43–46]. The Siegel-Weil formula relates the automorphism-weighted average over lattice Riemann theta functions (related to the partition functions of boundary free bosons) to an Eisenstein series (related to the sum over handlebodies), and explains the holographic duality of the ensemble average of Narain theories [26, 27].

[37] A Barbar, A Dymarsky and A. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity Ahmed Barbar Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky, 506 Library drive, Lexington, KY 40506 E-mail: a. barbar@uky.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity Ahmed Barbar Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky, 506 Library drive, Lexington, KY 40506 E-mail: a. barbar@uky.

D. Shapere, Global Symmetries, Code Ensembles, and Sums Over Geometries. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity Ahmed Barbar Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky, 506 Library drive, Lexington, KY 40506 E-mail: a. barbar@uky.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity Ahmed Barbar Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky, 506 Library drive, Lexington, KY 40506 E-mail: a. barbar@uky.

[48] I Frenkel, J Lepowsky and A Meurman, Vertex Operator Algebras and the Monster. p. 5

Where the paper says it

2 Preliminaries 2. 1 3d TQFTs 3d TQFTs are closely connected to 2d rational CFTs (RCFTs) and the concept of chiral algebras which more formally known as Vertex Operator Algebras (VOAs) [47–49].

p. 5
Where the paper says it

2 Preliminaries 2. 1 3d TQFTs 3d TQFTs are closely connected to 2d rational CFTs (RCFTs) and the concept of chiral algebras which more formally known as Vertex Operator Algebras (VOAs) [47–49].

[67] E P Verlinde, Fusion Rules and Modular Transformations in 2D Conformal Field Theory. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Nbg−1,g ag−1cg−1N bg−1,g agag . 4) which can be simplified, using the Verlinde formula to diagonalize the fusion rules, into dim Hg = D 2g−2 T X a d 2−2g a , (2.

p. 7
Where the paper says it

Nbg−1,g ag−1cg−1N bg−1,g agag . 4) which can be simplified, using the Verlinde formula to diagonalize the fusion rules, into dim Hg = D 2g−2 T X a d 2−2g a , (2.

[75] C.-M. Jian, A.W.W. Ludwig, Z.-X. Luo, H.-Y. Sun and Z Wang Establishing strongly-coupled 3D AdS quantum gravity with Ising dual using all-genus partition functions. p. 2

Where the paper says it

First, in the standard AdS/CFT, we expect gravity to be dual to a single CFT on the boundary. However, in multiboundary scenarios, contributions from Euclidean wormholes spoil the factorization of the partition function.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

First, in the standard AdS/CFT, we expect gravity to be dual to a single CFT on the boundary. However, in multiboundary scenarios, contributions from Euclidean wormholes spoil the factorization of the partition function.

[62] J Kaidi, Z Komargodski, K Ohmori, S Seifnashri and S.-H. Shao Higher central charges and topological boundaries in 2+1-dimensional TQFTs. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs. In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs. In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry.

[74] S Hensel, A primer on handlebody groups Handbook of group actions. p. 3

Where the paper says it

2) where the left-hand-side (LHS) describes the “TQFT gravity” partition function , which is a sum over the partition function ZT of the TQFT T placed on different topologies, while the RHS describes an ensemble of CFTs whose partition functions are denoted by Zα. This should be purely understood as a statement in the Hilbert space of the TQFT where the LHS is a sum over states prepared by putting the TQFT T on a particular topology, and the RHS is a sum over states corresponding to a fixed topology of a handlebody with insertion of line defects.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

2) where the left-hand-side (LHS) describes the “TQFT gravity” partition function , which is a sum over the partition function ZT of the TQFT T placed on different topologies, while the RHS describes an ensemble of CFTs whose partition functions are denoted by Zα. This should be purely understood as a statement in the Hilbert space of the TQFT where the LHS is a sum over states prepared by putting the TQFT T on a particular topology, and the RHS is a sum over states corresponding to a fixed topology of a handlebody with insertion of line defects.

[78] M Scharlemann, J Schultens and T Saito Lecture Notes on Generalized Heegaard Splittings. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

[80] J Johnson and H Rubinstein, Mapping class groups of Heegaard splittings. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In section 3, we first review the main derivation of TQFT gravity following [1] and elaborate a bit more on the sum over topologies, writing it explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings. We then give some arguments that the mapping class group invariant subspace of the infinite genus Hilbert space has a natural interpretation as the baby universe Hilbert space.

[83] K Reidemeister, Zur dreidimensionalen Topologie Abhandlungen aus dem Mathematischen Seminar der Universität Hamburg 9 (1933) 189.

[85] F Lei, On stability of Heegaard splittings in Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

129, pp. 55–57, Cambridge University Press, 2000. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity Ahmed Barbar Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky, 506 Library drive, Lexington, KY 40506 E-mail: a. barbar@uky.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Automorphism-weighted ensembles from TQFT gravity Ahmed Barbar Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky, 506 Library drive, Lexington, KY 40506 E-mail: a. barbar@uky.

[66] F Apruzzi, F Bonetti I García Etxebarria S.S Hosseini and S Schafer-Nameki Symmetry TFTs from String Theory Commun. p. 4

Where the paper says it

1 Summary of the main result The main result of this paper is that a 3d TQFT summed over all topologies as proposed in [1] is dual to an ensemble of boundary theories where each member of the ensemble is (inversely) weighted by a symmetry factor. The bulk TQFT naturally acts as a symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) for each member, and so each member α has a certain categorical symmetry C (α) relative to the bulk TQFT.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

1 Summary of the main result The main result of this paper is that a 3d TQFT summed over all topologies as proposed in [1] is dual to an ensemble of boundary theories where each member of the ensemble is (inversely) weighted by a symmetry factor. The bulk TQFT naturally acts as a symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) for each member, and so each member α has a certain categorical symmetry C (α) relative to the bulk TQFT.

Math. Phys. 402 (2023) 895.

[68] V G Drinfeld, Quantum groups Zap. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 R Chern Simons 41 6. 2 Virasoro TQFT 41 7 Discussion 46 A Brief review of modular tensor categories 48 B Normalization of quantum dimensions of module categories 51 – 1 –

p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 R Chern Simons 41 6. 2 Virasoro TQFT 41 7 Discussion 46 A Brief review of modular tensor categories 48 B Normalization of quantum dimensions of module categories 51 – 1 –

Nauchn. Semin. 155 (1986) 18.

[70] C Kassel and V Turaev, Double construction for monoidal categories Acta Mathematica 175 (1995) 1. p. 4

Where the paper says it

In this work, we calculate these weights explicitly for general 3d TQFTs based on semi-simple modular tensor categories and give them a physical interpretation in terms of symmetries. We also briefly shed some light on the sum over topologies, writing explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings, and also make a connection to the construction of the closed (baby) universe Hilbert space.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In this work, we calculate these weights explicitly for general 3d TQFTs based on semi-simple modular tensor categories and give them a physical interpretation in terms of symmetries. We also briefly shed some light on the sum over topologies, writing explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings, and also make a connection to the construction of the closed (baby) universe Hilbert space.

[63] D Gaiotto and J Kulp, Orbifold groupoids JHEP 02 (2021) 132. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Illustrative example: SU(2)4 × SU(2)4 33 5. 3 Z2 orbifold of the compact boson 36 5.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

2 Illustrative example: SU(2)4 × SU(2)4 33 5. 3 Z2 orbifold of the compact boson 36 5.

[79] L Goeritz, Die abbildungen der brezelfläche und der vollbrezel vom geschlecht 2, in Abhandlungen Aus Dem Mathematischen Seminar Der Universität Hamburg, vol. 9, pp. 244–259, Springer, 1933.

[88] U Oertel, Mapping class groups of compression bodies and 3-manifolds math/0607444. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In section 3, we first review the main derivation of TQFT gravity following [1] and elaborate a bit more on the sum over topologies, writing it explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings. We then give some arguments that the mapping class group invariant subspace of the infinite genus Hilbert space has a natural interpretation as the baby universe Hilbert space.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

In section 3, we first review the main derivation of TQFT gravity following [1] and elaborate a bit more on the sum over topologies, writing it explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings. We then give some arguments that the mapping class group invariant subspace of the infinite genus Hilbert space has a natural interpretation as the baby universe Hilbert space.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

In section 3, we first review the main derivation of TQFT gravity following [1] and elaborate a bit more on the sum over topologies, writing it explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings. We then give some arguments that the mapping class group invariant subspace of the infinite genus Hilbert space has a natural interpretation as the baby universe Hilbert space.

[87] M Scharlemann, Heegaard splittings of compact 3-manifolds math/0007144. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is the natural — uniform up to isomorphism — measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights.

We will start with the formalities and then explain the physics picture. We want to understand how to define quantum dimensions for simple objects in CA, where a quantum dimension here is a trace of the identity morphism of the simple object. If CA is tensor, then one can define quantum dimensions from the fusion ring of CA. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 R Chern Simons 41 6. 2 Virasoro TQFT 41 7 Discussion 46 A Brief review of modular tensor categories 48 B Normalization of quantum dimensions of module categories 51 – 1 –

We want to understand what choice of normalization that corresponds to our convention in eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

6) such that the vacuum conformal block from the CFT perspective is normalized to unity (particularly on S 2 ). We want to illustrate the meaning of this choice from the TQFT perspective.

(4.3) corresponds to in this case. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs. In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry.

First, we start by writing the simple objects of CA as objects in C and define their dimension as their dimension in C. p. 9
Where the paper says it

13) Invariance under braiding (commutativity) = (2. 14) In a unitary MTC, there is no simple object that satisfy these relations under fusion except the trivial/vacuum anyon; however, if we consider non-simple objects we will – 9 –

We will denote the dimensions by FPdim, and the simple objects of the module categroy CA as Mi. p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 R Chern Simons 41 6. 2 Virasoro TQFT 41 7 Discussion 46 A Brief review of modular tensor categories 48 B Normalization of quantum dimensions of module categories 51 – 1 –

In this case we get X i FPdimC(Mi) 2 = FPdim(A)FPdim(C) (B.1).

[86] J Hass, A Thompson and W Thurston, Stabilization of heegaard splittings, Geometry & Topology 13 (2009) 2029.

[87] M Scharlemann, Heegaard splittings of compact 3-manifolds math/0007144.

[88] U Oertel, Mapping class groups of compression bodies and 3-manifolds math/0607444.

[89] E Torres and X Yu, SymTFT entanglement and holographic (non)-factorization.

[90] L Bhardwaj and Y Tachikawa, On finite symmetries and their gauging in two dimensions.

[98] R Vanhove, L Lootens, H.-H. Tu and F. Verstraete, Topological aspects of the critical three-state Potts model.

[26] A Maloney and E Witten, Averaging Over Narain Moduli Space.

[37] A Barbar, A Dymarsky and A.D. Shapere, Global Symmetries, Code Ensembles, and Sums Over Geometries.

[48] I Frenkel, J Lepowsky and A Meurman, Vertex Operator Algebras and the Monster.

[67] E P Verlinde, Fusion Rules and Modular Transformations in 2D Conformal Field Theory.

[75] C.-M. Jian, A.W.W. Ludwig, Z.-X. Luo, H.-Y. Sun and Z Wang Establishing strongly-coupled 3D AdS quantum gravity with Ising dual using all-genus partition functions.

[62] J Kaidi, Z Komargodski, K Ohmori, S Seifnashri and S.-H. Shao Higher central charges and topological boundaries in 2+1-dimensional TQFTs.

[74] S Hensel, A primer on handlebody groups Handbook of group actions.

[78] M Scharlemann, J Schultens and T Saito Lecture Notes on Generalized Heegaard Splittings.

[80] J Johnson and H Rubinstein, Mapping class groups of Heegaard splittings math/0701119. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In section 3, we first review the main derivation of TQFT gravity following [1] and elaborate a bit more on the sum over topologies, writing it explicitly in terms of equivalences of Heegaard splittings. We then give some arguments that the mapping class group invariant subspace of the infinite genus Hilbert space has a natural interpretation as the baby universe Hilbert space.

[83] K Reidemeister, Zur dreidimensionalen Topologie Abhandlungen aus dem Mathematischen Seminar der Universität Hamburg 9 (1933) 189.

[85] F Lei, On stability of Heegaard splittings in Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, vol. 129, pp. 55–57, Cambridge University Press, 2000.

[66] F Apruzzi, F Bonetti I García Etxebarria S.S Hosseini and S Schafer-Nameki Symmetry TFTs from String Theory Commun. Math. Phys. 402 (2023) 895.

[68] V G Drinfeld, Quantum groups Zap. Nauchn. Semin. 155 (1986) 18.

[70] C Kassel and V Turaev, Double construction for monoidal categories Acta Mathematica 175 (1995) 1.

[63] D Gaiotto and J Kulp, Orbifold groupoids JHEP 02 (2021) 132.

[79] L Goeritz, Die abbildungen der brezelfläche und der vollbrezel vom geschlecht 2, in Abhandlungen Aus Dem Mathematischen Seminar Der Universität Hamburg, vol. 9, pp. 244–259, Springer, 1933.

[88] U Oertel, Mapping class groups of compression bodies and 3-manifolds math/0607444.

[87] M Scharlemann, Heegaard splittings of compact 3-manifolds math/0007144.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to derive holographic dualities for non-compact TQFTs by explicitly using symmetry factors as weights in a uniform average, moving beyond simple averaging over CFT partition functions.

  2. Enhanced capacity to construct explicit measures on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras, specifically providing the groupoid cardinality as an analog of the Smith–Minkowski–Siegel “mass” formula for lattices.

  3. Increased precision in classifying topological boundary conditions by relating them to Lagrangian algebras and their automorphism groups, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of ensemble equivalence classes.

  4. Capability to derive the baby universe Hilbert space from the mapping class group invariant subspace HMCG g in the large genus limit, providing a formal construction for this Hilbert space.

  5. Improved understanding of how genus reduction generates all 3-manifolds with boundary by showing it is equivalent to a generalized Heegaard splitting procedure involving compression bodies.

Abstract

We study the recent proposal of arXiv:2405.20366 which poses a precise holographic duality between a 3d TQFT summed over all topologies and a unitary ensemble of boundary 2d CFTs. In that proposal, the sum over topologies is obtained via genus reduction from topologies with a large genus boundary Riemann surface, while the boundary ensemble is given by all CFTs described by Lagrangian condensations of the bulk TQFT. The main result of this work is to show that each member of this ensemble is weighted by a symmetry factor given by the invertible symmetry group of its categorical symmetry relative to the bulk TQFT as its SymTFT. This is the natural uniform up to isomorphism measure on the groupoid of Lagrangian algebras that describe the boundary theories. We also write the sum over topologies more explicitly in terms of equivalence classes of Heegaard splittings of 3-manifolds with a given boundary and comment on their weights. The holographic duality in this framework can then be viewed as a generalization of the Siegel-Weil formula. We discuss the implications of the main result for non-compact TQFTs. In particular, for the Virasoro case, this implies an ensemble of all CFTs at a given central charge in which CFTs are weighted by their full invertible symmetry. Finally, we show how this TQFT gravity framework gives a natural construction of the baby universe Hilbert space.

Sources

Related papers