Hadamard tails from flat space perturbation theory
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Hadamard tails from flat space perturbation theory".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents an alternative derivation for computing the short-distance singular behavior of correlation functions in quantum field theory in curved spacetime by leveraging equivalence principles and perturbative field theory methods This approach allows for the computation of these corrections, including those for interacting field theories, where traditional Green’s function strategies are difficult to generalize Derivation Strategy The authors apply the equivalence principle by choosing coordinates where the metric is locally approximately flat and expanding the action in powers of the metric perturbation hµν To first order in hµν, the correlation function is approximated by a sum involving flat space correlation functions and terms proportional to hµν The analysis then proceeds by working in momentum space, identifying hard and soft momenta corresponding to the separation between points This allows for an expansion to second order in q/p≪1, where q is the wavenumber carried by the external gravitational field and p is a hard momentum Singular Behavior Analysis The paper shows that computing leading short-distance corrections requires knowing a three-point function between the operators and the stress-energy tensor The resulting expression for the two-point function in four dimensions, taking the limit d→4, yields a logarithmic singularity proportional to 1/R(x0) ln s 2(x1, x2) This matches the known Hadamard tail prediction for a free scalar field For non-minimally coupled fields, the correction involves terms proportional to R(x0) and its derivatives Generalizations and Scope The framework is designed to be general, allowing application to correlation functions of non-scalar operators in generic Conformal Field Theories (CFTs) The leading short-distance correction for a generic conformal primary scalar operator involves terms expressed in terms of biscalar invariants such as the squared geodesic distance s 2(x1, x2) and the van Vleck determinant D(x1, x2) This result represents a genuine EFT prediction of Quantum Field Theory in curved spacetime Physical Relevance The method captures the short-distance behavior of correlators on scales larger than the UV cut-off, which is analogous to computing low-momentum non-analyticities in momentum space The work suggests relevance for physical contexts like black holes and early universe cosmology, potentially aiding in the computation of high-frequency quasinormal modes The results are applicable to both weakly and strongly coupled CFTs, as the equivalence principle ensures that only the weakness of gravity in a neighborhood of x0 is exploited Some useful integral identities The paper provides several integral identities, including the inverse Fourier transform Iα(x) and its position space representation The analysis shows that after taking enough derivatives with respect to ∆x squared, the resulting integral becomes finite in the IR as long as N > α - d/2 This confirms that non-analytic contributions to two-point functions can be reliably computed in this framework The authors also show how the result for a conformally coupled free scalar matches results obtained via Weyl transformations of the flat space Green’s function The final expression for generic operators includes terms proportional to R(x0) and Rµν(x0), representing the EFT prediction The result is expressed in terms of biscalar invariants, such as s 2(x1, x2) and D(x1, x2), which are regular for x1 → x2 This confirms that the singular part of the two-point function in the coincident limit can be expressed this way The result for generic operators is expressed in terms of biscalar invariants, such as the geodesic distance and the van Vleck determinant, as before The result agrees with (4.26), upon setting ξ to the conformal coupling (4.27) The term proportional to the scalar curvature R(x0) has a non-analytic dependence from the geodesic distance s, representing a genuine EFT prediction of Quantum Field Theory in curved spacetime The result is consistent with the one obtained performing a Weyl transformation of the Green’s function in flat space Bi-tensors and their coincident limit expansion To express results covariantly, the paper utilizes bitensors, which are functions of two spacetime points that transform covariantly The squared geodesic distance s 2(x1, x2) is an example of a biscalar The expansion of geometric invariants to first order in h in the coincident limit yields s 2(x1, x2) = (∆x) squared + hµν (x0) ∆xµ∆xn + 1/24 ∆xµ∆xnσ ∂ρ∂σhµν (x0) The van Vleck determinant D(x1, x2) is another biscalar that appears in many applications of quantum field theory in curved spacetime In the coincident limit, the expansion of the determinant yields D(x1, x2) = 1 + 1/6 Rµν (x0) ∆xµ∆xn +...
Kai: Conformal primaries from Weyl transformations The two-point function in a conformally flat spacetime is related to the flat-space two-point function by a conformal transformation of the fields In the weak gravity approximation, the first order contribution to the two-point function in a weak conformally flat background in the coincident limit is given by ⟨TO∆ (x1) O∆ (x2)⟩1 = - 2∆ Cd/(∆x squared + iϵ) ∆ xµ∆xn ∂µ∂xnω(x0) This result is consistent with the one obtained in the main text, (5.13), where ω(x0) = 0 The result for generic ∆ includes a term proportional to the scalar curvature R(x0) that has a non-analytic dependence from the geodesic distance s This term, together with the D-term, represents a genuine EFT prediction of Quantum Field Theory in curved spacetime The result agrees with (4.26), upon setting ξ to the conformal coupling (4.27) For generic ∆, the term proportional to the scalar curvature R(x0) has a non-analytic dependence from the geodesic distance s The result is consistent with (4.20), where in the second equality we worked at leading order in curvature The result for generic ∆ includes a term proportional to R(x0) and its derivatives, representing the EFT prediction Discussion The method is formulated in position space and computes universal non-analytic terms in the short-distance, rather than low-momentum, limit The results are meaningful only for scales within the EFT regime of validity, capturing short-distance behavior on scales larger than the UV cut-off r >> lUV This work represents only a first step toward higher orders in curvature or derivatives and extension to higher-point correlation functions is in progress The authors hope this approach can help explore properties of interacting QFTs in contexts like black holes and early universe cosmology The results on the short-distance analytic structure of the two-point function could be relevant for the computation of high-frequency quasinormal modes The paper is supported by various grants including the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship under Grant No.
Mira: DGE-2036197 The work was also partially supported by the U.S.
Kai: Department of Energy (award no.
Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap what we just covered, this paper, "Hadamard tails from flat space perturbation theory," is all about providing an alternative way to compute the short-distance singular structure of correlation functions. The thesis is that they can use equivalence principles and perturbative field theory methods to tackle these corrections even for interacting theories where standard green's function methods are too hard to generalize.
Mira: They claim this framework allows for the computation of these corrections, including those for interacting field theories, which is a tough area. It’s important because traditional Green's function strategies often hit roadblocks when you move beyond free fields or highly symmetric spacetimes.
Lev: So, the core claim is that by choosing coordinates where space looks locally flat and expanding the action in powers of that metric perturbation h mu nu, they can approximate the correlation function to first order in h mu nu.
Kai: They then work in momentum space and separate hard and soft momenta corresponding to the separation between points, allowing them to expand to second order when the external gravitational field wavenumber is much smaller than a hard momentum.
Mira: The key result they show is that computing these leading short-distance corrections requires knowing a three-point function between the operators and the stress-energy tensor in order to get that result.
Lev: And once you get that, when you take the four dimension limit, it yields a logarithmic singularity proportional to one over distance times a logarithm of separation squared. This is their match for the known Hadamard tail prediction for a free scalar field.
Kai: For non-minimally coupled fields, they show that those corrections involve terms proportional to the Ricci scalar curvature and its derivatives as well. They generalize this framework to be applicable to generic Conformal Field Theories in CFTs, where the leading short-distance correction involves biscalar invariants like the squared geodesic distance and the van Vleck determinant.
Mira: This result represents a genuine effective field theory prediction of quantum field theory in curved spacetime, which is what makes it significant for testing our understanding of how gravity couples to quantum fields.
Lev: From an engineering perspective, this means that if we wanted to run simulations on real hardware, we'd need to account for these terms involving the scalar curvature and its derivatives when setting up the Hamiltonian or the action.
Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this discussion on "Hadamard tails from flat space perturbation theory," the paper is presenting a new way to systematically compute short-distance singular behavior using perturbative methods. The authors are showing that they can handle interacting theories where traditional methods fail.
Mira: They emphasize that the method is designed to be general, allowing it to apply to correlation functions of non-scalar operators in generic CFTs, and the leading correction involves specific geometric invariants like those biscalars we talked about.
Lev: The implication for us is that this gives us a concrete prediction—terms involving the scalar curvature and its derivatives—that we expect from quantum field theory in curved spacetime itself when gravity is treated perturbatively.
Kai: In simple terms, it means they’ve found a way to predict the non-analytic parts of quantum field theory correlators using tools from flat space perturbation theory.
Mira: It confirms that these short-distance behaviors are governed by the geometry in a way we can calculate, and it points toward using these results in physical contexts like black holes or cosmology to figure out high-frequency quasinormal modes.
Lev: The work is a first step, though they admit the method is formulated in position space and only captures universal non-analytic terms within the EFT regime of validity. That’s where we stop for now, and they are planning to go higher order or extend it to higher-point correlation functions.
Ameya Chavda, Alberto Nicolis, Alessandro Podo, John Staunton
Center for Theoretical Physics and Department of Physics, Columbia University · Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques
hep-th
Submitted: 2025-10-29
Updated: 2026-11-13
Comments: 33 pages, v2 new sections (5 and 6)
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 92/100
The gist: The paper presents an alternative derivation for computing the short-distance singular behavior of correlation functions in quantum field theory in curved spacetime by leveraging equivalence…
Key concepts
- Equivalence Principle
- This principle allows the authors to choose coordinates where spacetime is locally flat. By expanding the action in powers of metric perturbations, they can simplify complex curved-space calculations into manageable flat-space problems, enabling a systematic perturbative approach.
- Short-Distance Singular Behavior
- This refers to how correlation functions behave when points are very close together, probing physics at very high energies or short distances. The paper focuses on computing the non-analytic parts of these functions that arise from quantum effects in curved backgrounds.
- Biscalars
- These are mathematical objects that depend on two spacetime points and transform covariantly under coordinate changes. Examples include the squared geodesic distance ($s^2$) and the van Vleck determinant ($D$), which appear naturally when describing geometric invariants in curved spacetimes.
Terminology
Summary
The paper presents an alternative derivation for computing the short-distance singular behavior of correlation functions in quantum field theory in curved spacetime by leveraging equivalence principles and perturbative field theory methods This approach allows for the computation of these corrections, including those for interacting field theories, where traditional Green’s function strategies are difficult to generalize
Derivation Strategy
The authors apply the equivalence principle by choosing coordinates where the metric is locally approximately flat and expanding the action in powers of the metric perturbation hµν To first order in hµν, the correlation function is approximated by a sum involving flat space correlation functions and terms proportional to hµν The analysis then proceeds by working in momentum space, identifying hard and soft momenta corresponding to the separation between points This allows for an expansion to second order in q/p≪1, where q is the wavenumber carried by the external gravitational field and p is a hard momentum
Singular Behavior Analysis
The paper shows that computing leading short-distance corrections requires knowing a three-point function between the operators and the stress-energy tensor The resulting expression for the two-point function in four dimensions, taking the limit d→4, yields a logarithmic singularity proportional to 1/R(x0) ln s 2(x1, x2) This matches the known Hadamard tail prediction for a free scalar field For non-minimally coupled fields, the correction involves terms proportional to R(x0) and its derivatives
Generalizations and Scope
The framework is designed to be general, allowing application to correlation functions of non-scalar operators in generic Conformal Field Theories (CFTs) The leading short-distance correction for a generic conformal primary scalar operator involves terms expressed in terms of biscalar invariants such as the squared geodesic distance s 2(x1, x2) and the van Vleck determinant D(x1, x2) This result represents a genuine EFT prediction of Quantum Field Theory in curved spacetime
Physical Relevance
The method captures the short-distance behavior of correlators on scales larger than the UV cut-off, which is analogous to computing low-momentum non-analyticities in momentum space The work suggests relevance for physical contexts like black holes and early universe cosmology, potentially aiding in the computation of high-frequency quasinormal modes The results are applicable to both weakly and strongly coupled CFTs, as the equivalence principle ensures that only the weakness of gravity in a neighborhood of x0 is exploited
Some useful integral identities
The paper provides several integral identities, including the inverse Fourier transform Iα(x) and its position space representation The analysis shows that after taking enough derivatives with respect to ∆x squared, the resulting integral becomes finite in the IR as long as N > α - d/2 This confirms that non-analytic contributions to two-point functions can be reliably computed in this framework The authors also show how the result for a conformally coupled free scalar matches results obtained via Weyl transformations of the flat space Green’s function The final expression for generic operators includes terms proportional to R(x0) and Rµν(x0), representing the EFT prediction The result is expressed in terms of biscalar invariants, such as s 2(x1, x2) and D(x1, x2), which are regular for x1 → x2 This confirms that the singular part of the two-point function in the coincident limit can be expressed this way The result for generic operators is expressed in terms of biscalar invariants, such as the geodesic distance and the van Vleck determinant, as before The result agrees with (4.26), upon setting ξ to the conformal coupling (4. p. 1 p. 127) The term proportional to the scalar curvature R(x0) has a non-analytic dependence from the geodesic distance s, representing a genuine EFT prediction of Quantum Field Theory in curved spacetime The result is consistent with the one obtained performing a Weyl transformation of the Green’s function in flat space
Bi-tensors and their coincident limit expansion
To express results covariantly, the paper utilizes bitensors, which are functions of two spacetime points that transform covariantly The squared geodesic distance s 2(x1, x2) is an example of a biscalar The expansion of geometric invariants to first order in h in the coincident limit yields s 2(x1, x2) = (∆x) squared + hµν (x0) ∆xµ∆xn + 1/24 ∆xµ∆xnσ ∂ρ∂σhµν (x0) The van Vleck determinant D(x1, x2) is another biscalar that appears in many applications of quantum field theory in curved spacetime In the coincident limit, the expansion of the determinant yields D(x1, x2) = 1 + 1/6 Rµν (x0) ∆xµ∆xn +...
Conformal primaries from Weyl transformations
The two-point function in a conformally flat spacetime is related to the flat-space two-point function by a conformal transformation of the fields In the weak gravity approximation, the first order contribution to the two-point function in a weak conformally flat background in the coincident limit is given by ⟨TO∆ (x1) O∆ (x2)⟩1 = - 2∆ Cd/(∆x squared + iϵ) ∆ xµ∆xn ∂µ∂xnω(x0) This result is consistent with the one obtained in the main text, (5.13), where ω(x0) = 0 The result for generic ∆ includes a term proportional to the scalar curvature R(x0) that has a non-analytic dependence from the geodesic distance s This term, together with the D-term, represents a genuine EFT prediction of Quantum Field Theory in curved spacetime The result agrees with (4. p. 026), upon setting ξ to the conformal coupling (4.27) For generic ∆, the term proportional to the scalar curvature R(x0) has a non-analytic dependence from the geodesic distance s The result is consistent with (4. p. 020), where in the second equality we worked at leading order in curvature The result for generic ∆ includes a term proportional to R(x0) and its derivatives, representing the EFT prediction
Discussion
The method is formulated in position space and computes universal non-analytic terms in the short-distance, rather than low-momentum, limit The results are meaningful only for scales within the EFT regime of validity, capturing short-distance behavior on scales larger than the UV cut-off r >> lUV This work represents only a first step toward higher orders in curvature or derivatives and extension to higher-point correlation functions is in progress The authors hope this approach can help explore properties of interacting QFTs in contexts like black holes and early universe cosmology The results on the short-distance analytic structure of the two-point function could be relevant for the computation of high-frequency quasinormal modes The paper is supported by various grants including the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship under Grant No. DGE-2036197 The work was also partially supported by the U. p. 2S. Department of Energy (award no. p. 0 p. 0 DE-SC0011941) The authors thank Lam Hui, Sebastian Mizera, and Massimiliano Riva for useful comments and discussions
Acknowledgments
The work of A.C. is supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship under Grant No. p. 2 DGE-2036197 The work of A. p. 3P. is supported by the Huawei Young Talents Program at IHES This work is also partially supported by the U. p. 2S. Department of Energy (award no. DE-SC0011941) The paper was prepared for submission to JHEP The arXiv identifier is arXiv:2510. p. 0
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved system can compute leading short-distance non-analytic behavior for two-point functions of scalar primaries in arbitrary Conformal Field Theories in curved backgrounds by rederiving it from perturbative field theory methods rather than relying on traditional Green's function strategies.
-
Improved system can compute the leading order gravitational corrections to the two-point correlation function of a generic conformal primary scalar O delta x by expanding the metric to second order in derivatives around the midpoint, yielding an expression involving Ricci scalar R and Ricci tensor R mu nu.
-
Improved system can express general covariant results for two-point functions in terms of biscalar invariants such as the squared geodesic distance s2 (x1, x2) and the van Vleck determinant D (x1, x2), which is crucial for describing focusing and defocusing of geodesics.
-
Improved system can compute higher order corrections to two-point functions by extending the framework to include higher orders in curvature or derivatives, allowing researchers to distinguish between these independent expansions beyond the leading order.
-
Improved system can be applied to contexts of physical interest like black holes and early universe cosmology, specifically for computing high-frequency quasinormal modes of (anti-)de Sitter and black hole spacetimes by analyzing the poles of retarded Green's functions.
Sources
- Quantum fields in curved spacetime
- Central charges of N=2 superconformal field theories in four dimensions
- Towards the classification of rank-$r$ $\mathcal{N}=2$ SCFTs. Part I: twisted partition function and central charge formulae
- Rationality in Four Dimensions
- Cosmology as a weak gravitational field and the trans-Planckian problem
- Gravitational Self Force from Scattering Amplitudes in Curved Space
- Effective Field Theory for Extreme Mass Ratios
- Microcausality in Curved Space-Time
- Microcausality without Lorentz invariance
- Scale Invariance, Conformality, and Generalized Free Fields
- The motion of point particles in curved spacetime
- Weyl versus Conformal Invariance in Quantum Field Theory
- The Conformal Bootstrap: Theory, Numerical Techniques, and Applications
- Quasinormal modes of black holes and black branes
- Generation and propagation of nonlinear quasi-normal modes of a Schwarzschild black hole
- TASI Lectures on the Conformal Bootstrap
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions