On the complexity of the free space of a translating box in R cubed

arXiv:2510.22386 · cs.CG · Submitted 2025-10-25 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "On the complexity of the free space of a translating box in R cubed".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Consider a convex polyhedral robot B that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R3 The complexity of F is asymptotically determined by the number of triple contacts between the robot and obstacles, i.e., the number of free placements in which three distinct robot features (vertices, edges, or faces) simultaneously make contact with three distinct obstacle features Complexity Bounds for Box Robots The paper proves that if B is a box-shaped robot, then the complexity of the free space of B is O(n 2) Furthermore, if B is a convex polygon whose edges come in parallel pairs, then the complexity of F is O(n 2) as well.

Tom: These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons Theorem 1 states that for a box-shaped robot, the complexity of the free space is O(n 2).

Jane: Analysis of Polygonal Robots The paper studies polygonal robots in more depth, calling a convex polygon fully parallel if its edges come in parallel pairs Theorem 1 also states that for a fully-parallel convex polygon, the complexity of F is O(n 2).

Tom: The lower bound of Omega(n squared alpha(n)) can be achieved with any polygonal robot that is not fully parallel.

Paper summary: Tom: So wrapping this up on "On the complexity of the free space of a translating box in R cubed", it really boils down to confirming that for a box robot moving around polyhedral obstacles, you can expect the number of possible free placements to scale at most quadratically with n >

Jane: And they do prove that this O of n squared bound holds for boxes and also for fully parallel convex polygons, which is a nice piece of closure on those specific cases >

Lu: The implication here is that we have a solid understanding of the scaling behavior for these robot types, moving past just knowing an upper bound derived from earlier work like Aronov and Sharir's O of n squared log n >

Meng: For me, what this means in practice is that if you are designing a system to plan paths for a box in three dee, you can rely on this O of n squared scaling for the worst case scenario, assuming the obstacles are polyhedra > <ref:2510.22386#pg1>

Lalam: I'm confident they’ve done their job by proving Theorem one and Theorem two which show that these specific robot geometries lead to O of n squared complexity > <ref:2510.22386#pg1>

Tom: It gives engineers a concrete number to work with when estimating the size of the search space they might have to explore >

Jane: And it also helps us understand why those other polygonal robots that aren't fully parallel can exhibit a higher lower bound, like Omega of n squared alpha of n >

Lu: It also points toward the next steps, which is trying to close the gap between that Omega of n squared alpha of n and O of n squared log n for the general case >

Tom: So while this paper gives us solid bounds for boxes and parallel shapes, the challenge remains finding a better bound for completely general convex polyhedral robots, which is where we still have some open problems >

Conclusion: Jane: So we’re wrapping up this look at "On the complexity of the free space of a translating box in R cubed," which basically deals with how many different ways a box can move without hitting obstacles.

Tom: Yeah, it’s about figuring out that number, you know? It looks at all those possible placements where three different parts of your robot touch three different parts of the obstacles.

Jane: Right, and they found that for a box robot moving in three dee space around polyhedra, the complexity scales with n squared.

Lu: That’s what they proved for boxes—O of n squared complexity for the free space. And it extends to fully parallel convex polygons too, which is kind of a neat restriction on the shape.

Meng: So it means if you’re planning a path with a box robot, you can estimate how big that search space gets based on how many sides those obstacles have.

Tom: Exactly. It settles the question about boxes, which was always interesting because it gave us a concrete upper bound for this kind of motion planning problem.

Jane: But they also pointed out that for any general polygonal robot, you can still get a worse lower bound, something like Omega of n squared alpha of n.

Lu: That gap between O of n squared log n and that Omega stuff is still an open problem in the field right now. It’s about getting a tighter bound for those more complex robot shapes.

Tom: So they nailed the box case, but the real challenge for researchers is figuring out how to get a better number for robots that aren't so simple.

Ariel University

cs.CG

Submitted: 2025-10-25

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 19 pages, 13 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 84/100

The gist: Consider a convex polyhedral robot B that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R3 The complexity of F is asymptotically determined by the number…

Key concepts

Triple Contacts
This refers to situations where three distinct features of the robot (like vertices, edges, or faces) simultaneously touch three distinct features of an obstacle. The paper argues that the complexity of the free space is determined by counting these specific triple contact placements.
Box-Shaped Robot Complexity
For a robot shaped like a box (or parallelepiped), the analysis shows that the complexity of its free space is bounded by O(n^2). This means the number of critical regions in which motion planning must be considered grows quadratically with respect to some parameter 'n'.
Fully-Parallel Convex Polygon
This describes a convex polygon where all edges come in parallel pairs. The paper proves that for such a robot, the complexity of its free space is also O(n^2), similar to the box case. This shows that certain highly symmetric polygonal shapes have manageable complexity.

Terminology

Summary

Consider a convex polyhedral robot B that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R3 The complexity of F is asymptotically determined by the number of triple contacts between the robot and obstacles, i. p. 0

Where the paper says it

On the complexity of the free space of a translating box in R 3 Gabriel Nivasch∗ Abstract Consider a convex polyhedral robot B that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R 3 . The free space F of B is the set of all positions in which B is disjoint from the interior of every obstacle.

e., the number of free placements in which three distinct robot features (vertices, edges, or faces) simultaneously make contact with three distinct obstacle features

Complexity Bounds for Box Robots

The paper proves that if B is a box-shaped robot, then the complexity of the free space of B is O(n 2) Furthermore, if B is a convex polygon whose edges come in parallel pairs, then the complexity of F is O(n 2) as well. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this paper we prove that if B is a box, then the complexity of F is O(n 2 ). Furthermore, if B is a convex polygon whose edges come in parallel pairs, then the complexity of F is O(n 2 ) as well.

These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons Theorem 1 states that for a box-shaped robot, the complexity of the free space is O(n 2). p. 0
Where the paper says it

These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons. Keywords: motion planning, computational geometry, Minkowski sum, lower envelope 1 Introduction One of the most basic problems studied in algorithmic motion planning is that of moving a rigid “robot” B among fixed obstacles.

Analysis of Polygonal Robots

The paper studies polygonal robots in more depth, calling a convex polygon fully parallel if its edges come in parallel pairs Theorem 1 also states that for a fully-parallel convex polygon, the complexity of F is O(n 2). The lower bound of Omega(n squared alpha(n)) can be achieved with any polygonal robot that is not fully parallel. p. 2

Where the paper says it

See Figure 2. It is easy to see that the lower bound of Ω(n 2α(n)) shown in Figure 1 can be achieved with any polygonal robot that is not fully parallel: Any edge of B that does not have a parallel edge on the other side can serve as the vertical robot edge of Figure 1.

Bounding Triple Vertex Contacts

Lemma 4 proves that the number of triple vertex contacts that B can make with obstacles is O(n 2). This result is derived by analyzing contact specifications and using Lemma 3 (Case 3) to bound the number of intersection points q, which leads to a total bound for this type of triple-intersection contacts being O(n 2). p. 9

Where the paper says it

Hence, Lemma 3 (Case 3) bounds the number of these intersection points q, for fixed O1, by O(n). Since there are O(n) choices of O1, the total bound for this type of triple-intersection contacts is O(n 2 ).

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Hence, Lemma 3 (Case 3) bounds the number of these intersection points q, for fixed O1, by O(n). Since there are O(n) choices of O1, the total bound for this type of triple-intersection contacts is O(n 2 ).

Analysis for Cubical Robots

For the case where B is a cube (or a box or a parallelepiped), Theorem 1 is proven, assuming B = [0, 1]3 is an axis-parallel cube of side-length 1. The proof involves examining all types of triple contacts and using lemmas to bound the number of such contacts involving specific robot features. p. 1

Where the paper says it

As will be explained below in more detail, the complexity of F is asymptotically determined by the number of triple contacts between the robot and obstacles, i. , the number of free placements in which three distinct robot features (vertices, edges, or faces) simultaneously make contact with three distinct obstacle features.

Analysis for Fully-Parallel Robots

Theorem 2, regarding a fully-parallel polygonal robot, follows by a few small modifications to the proof of Theorem 1. This involves considering face contacts, edge contacts involving equal or parallel edges, and cases where three mutually nonparallel edges are involved. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Furthermore, each face is bounded by at least three edges, so the number of faces is at most 2/3 times the number of edges. The number of vertices of F that involve degenerate contact specifications is easily bounded by O(n 2 ), since each such vertex arises from at most two contacts.

The final case analysis concludes the proof of Theorem 2. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The other possibilities, in which some of the coverings take place at the left, are treated similarly. This concludes the proof of Lemma 4.

Discussion and Open Problems

The main open problem is to close the gap between O(n squared log n) and Omega(n squared alpha(n)) for the general case of a convex polyhedral robot. Another open problem is to obtain more refined bounds that depend on the complexity of the robot, as well as on the number of obstacles, and not just on the total number of obstacle vertices, under the assumption that the obstacles are convex. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The free space F of B is the set of all positions in which B is disjoint from the interior of every obstacle. Aronov and Sharir (1997) derived an upper bound of O(n 2 log n) for the combinatorial complexity of F, where n is the total number of vertices of the obstacles, and the complexity of B is assumed constant.

The currently best known bounds are O(rnk log k) for an r-vertex polyhedron and Omega(nk) for any robot. p. 1
Where the paper says it

For each such possibility, B can slide up and down, so the opposite vertex of B can make Ω(n) different third contacts with an edge of (b). In this paper we consider the case in which the robot is either a “flat” convex polygon or a convex polyhedron that can only translate, and the obstacles are polyhedra in R 3 .

References

[1] Boris Aronov and Micha Sharir. On translational motion planning of a convex polyhedron in 3-space. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons. Keywords: motion planning, computational geometry, Minkowski sum, lower envelope 1 Introduction One of the most basic problems studied in algorithmic motion planning is that of moving a rigid “robot” B among fixed obstacles.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons. Keywords: motion planning, computational geometry, Minkowski sum, lower envelope 1 Introduction One of the most basic problems studied in algorithmic motion planning is that of moving a rigid “robot” B among fixed obstacles.

SIAM Journal on Computing, 26(6):1785–1803, 1997

[2] Dan Halperin, Oren Salzman, and Micha Sharir. Algorithmic motion planning. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons. Keywords: motion planning, computational geometry, Minkowski sum, lower envelope 1 Introduction One of the most basic problems studied in algorithmic motion planning is that of moving a rigid “robot” B among fixed obstacles.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons. Keywords: motion planning, computational geometry, Minkowski sum, lower envelope 1 Introduction One of the most basic problems studied in algorithmic motion planning is that of moving a rigid “robot” B among fixed obstacles.

In Csaba D. Toth, Joseph O’Rourke, and Jacob E. Goodman, editors, Handbook of discrete and computational geometry, pages 1311–1342

[3] Dan Halperin and Chee-Keng Yap. Combinatorial complexity of translating a box in polyhedral 3-space. p. 0

Where the paper says it

On the complexity of the free space of a translating box in R 3 Gabriel Nivasch∗ Abstract Consider a convex polyhedral robot B that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R 3 . The free space F of B is the set of all positions in which B is disjoint from the interior of every obstacle.

Computational Geometry, 9(3):181–196, 1998

[4] Sergiu Hart and Micha Sharir. Nonlinearity of Davenport–Schinzel sequences and of generalized path compression schemes. Combinatorica, 6(2):151–177, 1986

[5] Klara Kedem, Ron Livne, J´anos Pach, and Micha Sharir. On the union of Jordan regions and collision-free translational motion amidst polygonal obstacles. p. 0

Where the paper says it

On the complexity of the free space of a translating box in R 3 Gabriel Nivasch∗ Abstract Consider a convex polyhedral robot B that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R 3 . The free space F of B is the set of all positions in which B is disjoint from the interior of every obstacle.

Discrete & Computational Geometry, 1(1):59–71, 1986

[6] Tom´as Lozano-P´erez and Michael A Wesley. An algorithm for planning collision-free paths among polyhedral obstacles. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In the case where both the robot and the obstacles are polyhedra in R 3 and the robot can only translate, the configuration space is also three-dimensional, and the free space has polyhedral boundaries, consisting of vertices, edges, and faces. A basic parameter in the analysis of many motion planning algorithms is the combinatorial complexity of the free space, meaning the total number of vertices, edges and faces in the boundary of the free space.

Communications of the ACM, 22(10):560–570, 1979

[7] Ady Wiernik and Micha Sharir. Planar realizations of nonlinear Davenport-Schinzel sequences by segments. p. 1

Where the paper says it

For both these cases they derived an upper bound of O(n 2α(n)), where α(n) is the very slow-growing inverse Ackermann function. The inverse-Ackermann factor arises from consideration of upper and lower envelopes of segments.

Discrete & Computational Geometry, 3(1):15–47, 1988

B is a convex polyhedral robot that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R3 The complexity of F is asymptotically determined by the number of triple contacts between the robot and obstacles, i.e., the number of free placements in which three distinct robot features (vertices, edges, or faces) simultaneously make contact with three distinct obstacle features

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper proves that if B is a box-shaped robot, then the complexity of the free space of B is O(n 2). Furthermore, if B is a convex polygon whose edges come in parallel pairs, then the complexity of F is O(n 2) as well. These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Furthermore, if B is a convex polygon whose edges come in parallel pairs, then the complexity of F is O(n 2 ) as well. These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons.

How the training signal is built

Lemma 4 proves that the number of triple vertex contacts that B can make with obstacles is O(n 2). This result is derived by analyzing contact specifications and using Lemma 3 (Case 3) to bound the number of intersection points q, which leads to a total bound for this type of triple-intersection contacts being O(n 2).

Where the gains come from

The complexity analysis relies on bounding the number of vertices of F, noting that each vertex arises from a robot placement simultaneously realizing three generic contact specifications The proof for polygonal robots uses Lemma 3 (Case 3) to bound intersection points q by O(n) for fixed O1, leading to a total bound of O(n 2). For cubical robots, the analysis in Section 5 shows that the number of triple contacts involving specific features is at most O(n 2). p. 1

Where the paper says it

As will be explained below in more detail, the complexity of F is asymptotically determined by the number of triple contacts between the robot and obstacles, i. , the number of free placements in which three distinct robot features (vertices, edges, or faces) simultaneously make contact with three distinct obstacle features.

The fully-parallel case uses a strip partitioning method to show that illegal regions are bounded by horizontal strips, leading to an overall O(n 2) bound. p. 2
Where the paper says it

See Figure 2. It is easy to see that the lower bound of Ω(n 2α(n)) shown in Figure 1 can be achieved with any polygonal robot that is not fully parallel: Any edge of B that does not have a parallel edge on the other side can serve as the vertical robot edge of Figure 1.

[1] Boris Aronov and Micha Sharir. On translational motion planning of a convex polyhedron in 3-space. SIAM Journal on Computing, 26(6):1785–1803, 1997

[2] Dan Halperin, Oren Salzman, and Micha Sharir. Algorithmic motion planning. In Csaba D. Toth, Joseph O’Rourke, and Jacob E. Goodman, editors, Handbook of discrete and computational geometry, pages 1311–1342 <ref:2510. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons. Keywords: motion planning, computational geometry, Minkowski sum, lower envelope 1 Introduction One of the most basic problems studied in algorithmic motion planning is that of moving a rigid “robot” B among fixed obstacles.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved complexity bounds for free space analysis: The system can now determine that for a box robot in R3, the complexity of F is O(n 2), and for a fully parallel convex polygon, the complexity of F is O(n 2).

  2. Enhanced motion planning algorithms: The system can use the proven bounds to design motion planning algorithms that are guaranteed to terminate within a polynomial time dependent only on the number of obstacle vertices n, specifically O(n 2) for box robots.

  3. Specialized triple contact detection: The system can efficiently detect and count triple vertex contacts for polyhedral robots, achieving a bound of O(n 2), which is an improvement over previous bounds like O(n squared log n) or the worst-case lower bounds of O(n squared alpha(n)).

  4. Handling fully parallel polygons: The system can solve motion planning problems involving fully-parallel convex polygon[s] by leveraging the result that the complexity of F is O(n 2) as well.

Abstract

Consider a convex polyhedral robot B that can translate (without rotating) amidst a finite set of non-moving polyhedral obstacles in R cubed. The "free space" F of B is the set of all positions in which B is disjoint from the interior of every obstacle. Aronov and Sharir (1997) derived an upper bound of O(n squared n) for the combinatorial complexity (number of vertices, edges, and faces) of F, where n is the total complexity of the obstacles, and the complexity of B is assumed constant. Halperin and Yap (1993) showed that, if B is either a box or a "flat" convex polygon, then a tighter bound of O(n 2α(n)) holds. Here α(n) is the inverse Ackermann function. In this paper we prove that if B is a box, then the complexity of F is O(n 2). Furthermore, if B is a convex polygon whose edges come in parallel pairs, then the complexity of F is O(n 2) as well. These results settle the question of the asymptotical worst-case complexity of F for a box, as well as for all convex polygons.

Related papers