Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering to predict solar cycle parameters in the next solar grand minimum

arXiv:2510.14355 · astro-ph.SR · Submitted 2025-10-16 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering to predict solar cycle parameters in the next solar grand minimum".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering of sunspot number records to forecast the next solar grand minimum is a new method developed to obtain a high resolution forecast for a solar grand minimum from cycle 26 at 2030 to cycle 37 at 2150 The paper develops a new method for forecasting sunspot number (SSN) applied to the annual SILSO SSN record, 1700 - 2024, to obtain a high resolution forecast and a reconstructed annual SSN record, 971 - 1899, to obtain a low resolution forecast Fourier analysis identifies eleven near-decadal periodicities in the range from 8 to 15 years in the SILSO record and four centennial scale periodicities between 60 and 800 years in the reconstructed SSN record Components at each period are isolated by a new method of narrow band pass filtering The procedure to obtain a band pass filtered version of SSN involved subtracting the mean SSN, applying a Press notch filter with bandwidth specified as a percentage of the frequency of the specified periodicity, and then subtracting the output from the SSN anomaly to provide an inverse notch filtered (INF) version Wavelet analysis was obtained with the application WaveletComp Spectral Content and Component Grouping The spectral content of SILSO SSN is characterized by three groups of periodicities in the period range 8 to 15 years, nominally octal, decadal and decadal-plus groups The SSN anomaly is shown as the full black line in Figure 1A The periodogram of the SSN anomaly in the decadal range of interest is shown (black full curve) in Figure 1B While the periodicity is primarily decadal it occasionally swings to the octal range, for example around 1780, or to the decadal-plus range, for example around 1800 The sum of all eleven INF components is compared with the SSN anomaly in Figure 1A The correlation coefficient, r = 0.83, indicates that the component combination closely replicates the SSN anomaly Forecasting and Grand Minima Prediction Forward projection from each record forecasts a grand solar minimum from 2030 to 2150 The sum of all three group projections shows an extended grand minimum between 2020 and 2150 The back projection from solar cycle 24 reproduces the SSN variation in the Dalton Minimum and the Maunder Grand Minimum The forward projection forecasts a grand minimum in SSN from about 2020 to 2150 labelled “Next” Mechanisms of Solar Cycle Variation The Waldmeier Effect is explained in terms of interference between the octal and decadal groups Interference between the summed decadal and octal components of SSN reproduced the Waldmeier Effect in its various manifestations The model, nominally the “shah” model, connecting the generation of grand minima/maxima to interference between the components in the decadal group was developed and was shown to reproduce grand minima/maxima the features which were consistent with features obtained from wavelet analysis of reconstructed SSN Planetary Connections A connection between planetary and SSN periodicity is established The close correspondence between the planetary periods obtained from the planetary function y+(t) and the periods associated with SILSO SSN are evidence of a connection The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model of SSN variability closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN The main findings are that the variation in SSN anomaly is largely characterized by three groups of periodicities, nominally octal, decadal and decadal-plus groups, in the period range 8 to 15 years The SSN variation due to the four components in the decadal group of periodicities dominates but is occasionally exceeded in amplitude by the octal or decadal-plus group When eleven components corresponding to the periodicities are found by the INF method, fitted to sinusoids at solar cycle 24, projected forward and summed, the sum forecasts a solar grand minimum in SSN extending from about 2030 to 2120 The forecast was validated by a back projection of SSN from solar cycle 24 that reproduced the SSN variation in the Dalton Minimum and the Maunder Grand Minimum A model, the “shah” model, connecting grand minima/maxima to interference between decadal group components was developed and was shown to reproduce grand minima/maxima features consistent with wavelet analysis Interference between summed octal and decadal components reproduced the Waldmeier Effect in its various manifestations An analysis isolating four long period components of a reconstructed SSN record, 971 to 1899, and projecting the components forward correctly forecasts the Gleissberg Minimum and the Modern grand maximum and forecasts a grand minimum between 2000 and 2150 The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model of SSN variability closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model of SSN variability closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN Evidence supporting the persistence included successful back projection from the SILSO SSN record, successful forward projection from the reconstructed 971 to 1899 record and the close coincidence of SILSO SSN periodicity with inherently persistent planetary periodicity The forecasts of the next grand minimum obtained in this work depend on the persistence of cycles identified in the SILSO SSN record and in a reconstructed SSN record How the training signal is built The components are fitted with sinusoids for back/forward projection The sinusoids were fitted at solar cycle 24, around year 2012, as follows The amplitude was measured as the peak height of each component and the phase was estimated as the average of the zero crossing times at solar cycle 24 for each component The projections of the decadal group of sinusoids between year 0 and 2500 are shown in Figure 3A along with the sum of the projections Where the gains come from The analysis suggests that grand minima and maxima may simply be the result of interference that occurs between the four decadal components of SSN The deterministic process described here contrasts with the view that grand minima episodes are caused by some type of stochastic process in the Sun Interference between octal, decadal and decadal-plus components would increase the possible range and complexity of long-term variability The close correspondence between the planetary periods obtained from the planetary function y+(t) and the periods associated with SILSO SSN is evidence of a connection The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN A comparison of periodograms (using relative values) of SILSO SSN and the impulse model is shown to be close in periodicity and amplitude The close match in periodicity and in amplitude is taken as further evidence of a planetary influence on solar activity The forecasts depend on the persistence of cycles identified in the SILSO SSN record and in a reconstructed SSN record Waldmeier Effect Explanation The Waldmeier Effect, reported in earlier studies, are explained in terms of interference between the octal and decadal groups The interference of the decadal and octal components provides an explanation of the Waldmeier Effect, which is the observation that the rise time of a sunspot cycle varies inversely with the cycle amplitude This model supports the idea that all manifestations of the Waldmeier Effect can be explained by interference between octal and decadal components Planetary Influence Assessment

Paper summary: Vera: So this paper we're looking at is titled "Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering to predict solar cycle parameters in the next solar grand minimum". It's basically trying to get a high resolution forecast for the next big dip in sunspot numbers.

Jocelyn: Right, so the main idea is they combine looking at different parts of sunspot number records with filtering those records to predict when we might see a solar grand minimum between cycle twenty-six at two thousand thirty and cycle thirty-seven at two thousand one hundred fifty <ref:2510.14355#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: And it's interesting because they are using two different datasets: the annual SILSO sunspot number record from one thousand seven hundred to two thousand twenty-four for a high resolution forecast, and then they reconstruct an annual sunspot number record from nine hundred seventy-one to one thousand eight hundred ninety-nine for a low resolution forecast <ref:2510.14355#pg1,a high resolution forecast, and>.

Vera: Exactly. The core of their thesis is that by using spectral analysis on these records, specifically identifying eleven near-decadal periodicities in the range of eight to fifteen years and four centennial scale periodicities between sixty and eight hundred years, they can isolate components at each of these periods using a new narrow band pass filtering technique.

Jocelyn: And they use this filtering method, which involves subtracting the mean sunspot number, applying a press notch filter based on the frequency of the periodicity, and then subtracting that output from the sunspot number anomaly to get an inverse notch filtered version.

Subrahmanyan: The results show that when you look at these eleven components summed up, they correlate with the sunspot number anomaly with a correlation coefficient of zero point eight three. That suggests this component combination closely replicates what's happening in the actual sunspot numbers.

Vera: And when they project these components forward from each record, from two thousand thirty to two thousand one hundred fifty the sum of all three groups of projections shows an extended grand minimum between two thousand twenty and two thousand one hundred fifty <ref:2510.14355#pg1>. They also back-projected solar cycle twenty-four, which reproduces the sunspot number variation seen during both the Dalton Minimum and the Maunder Grand Minimum.

Jocelyn: So, they are forecasting a grand minimum in sunspot number from about two thousand twenty to two thousand one hundred fifty labeled as "Next", based on this method <ref:2510.14355#pg1>. It's pretty bold given how complex these solar cycles are usually described.

Subrahmanyan: The mechanism they developed is called the "shah" model, which connects grand minima and maxima to interference between the decadal group components. This model was shown to reproduce grand minima and maxima features that match what they found with wavelet analysis of reconstructed sunspot number records.

Vera: And there's this connection they establish between planetary periods and sunspot number periodicity. The close correspondence between the planetary periods from a function called y plus t and the periods associated with SILSO sunspot number is presented as evidence of a connection, and they also found that a planetary impulse model of sunspot number variability closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO sunspot number.

Paper summary: Jocelyn: That suggests there's something more than just solar physics at play here, perhaps an underlying planetary influence on what we see in the solar activity. But I wonder how robust these connections are when you look at the data themselves.

Subrahmanyan: The analysis suggests that grand minima and maxima might simply be a result of interference between those four decadal components of sunspot number. They contrast this with some other views suggesting that grand minima episodes are caused by some type of stochastic process in the Sun.

Vera: Interference between the octal, decadal, and decadal-plus components reproduces the Waldmeier Effect, which is that observation about cycle rise times varying inversely with cycle amplitude. The model supports the idea that all manifestations of this effect can be explained by interference between those octal and decadal components.

Jocelyn: Speaking of complexity, they also found that when you isolate four long period components from the reconstructed sunspot number record, between nine hundred seventy-one and one thousand eight hundred ninety-nine and project those components forward correctly, they forecast the Gleissberg Minimum and the modern grand maximum as well <ref:2510.14355#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: And this projection also forecasts a grand minimum between two thousand and two thousand one hundred fifty <ref:2510.14355#pg1>. The persistence in their findings comes from successful back projection from solar cycle twenty-four that reproduced the sunspot number variation in the Dalton Minimum and the Maunder Grand Minimum, as well as successful forward projection from that reconstructed record.

Vera: So, to summarize this paper "Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering to predict solar cycle parameters in the next solar grand minimum", it claims that by combining spectral analysis on historical sunspot records with selective band pass filtering, they can forecast a grand minimum spanning from about two thousand thirty to two thousand one hundred twenty <ref:2510.14355#pg1,Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering>.

Jocelyn: The title points toward prediction, and the authors are Ian Edmonds and Peter Killen. They are suggesting that this new method gives us a high resolution outlook for future solar activity based on these identified periodicities.

Subrahmanyan: The implication is that grand minima might be more deterministically linked to the interference between decadal components than some purely stochastic theories suggest, though they're still careful about what they can actually predict with this model.

Vera: So, for someone listening who only wants to know what this means for their daily life or work, it suggests that understanding the underlying interference patterns in solar cycles could help us get a better handle on long-term solar variability, like predicting when we might see a significant dip in sunspot numbers.

Conclusion: Vera: So we’re wrapping up this look at the paper "Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering to predict solar cycle parameters in the next solar grand minimum." It’s by Edmonds and Killen, and they are trying to use these spectral techniques to forecast when we might see a big dip in sunspot numbers.

Jocelyn: Yeah, it’s interesting how they combine those two different ways of looking at the data—the spectral analysis on the long record and the filtering for high-resolution prediction. What do you think is their main point?

Vera: Their main point is that by finding these specific periodicities, like those near-decadal ones, and isolating them with this new filtering method, they can create a projection for a solar grand minimum between two thousand thirty and two thousand one hundred fifty. It’s about getting a high-resolution outlook for the next big dip.

Subrahmanyan: And what do you think that forecast means in the bigger picture? If they are predicting this grand minimum, does it suggest these long-term cycles have a more predictable pattern than we thought? Or is this just another complex statistical fit to historical noise?

Jocelyn: I’m leaning toward it being more than just noise. They even showed a connection between the periods they find in the sunspot number and some planetary rhythms, which adds an interesting layer to the whole thing. It suggests there might be something linking those two scales of time.

Vera: Exactly, that planetary link is what’s genuinely compelling for me. It moves it from just being a statistical prediction to suggesting some underlying physical connection we haven't fully mapped out yet.

Subrahmanyan: That’s where I get cautious though; the persistence they found, like successfully back-projecting solar cycle twenty-four to the Dalton and Maunder minima, is strong evidence. But we need more than just a good fit to history; we need that underlying mechanism proven by observation.

Jocelyn: Right, so it’s a strong forecast based on pattern recognition and historical validation, but the next thing we have to watch is whether those specific interference patterns they identified are truly what drives these grand events.

astro-ph.SR

Submitted: 2025-10-16

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 36 pages, 10 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering of sunspot number records to forecast the next solar grand minimum is a new method developed to obtain a high resolution forecast for a…

Key concepts

Narrow Band Pass Filtering
This technique isolates specific frequencies (periodicities) within a larger dataset of sunspot number data. It works by subtracting the mean signal and then applying a filter that only lets frequencies matching a target period through, effectively separating distinct cycles from noise.
Waldmeier Effect
This effect describes how the rise time of a solar cycle varies inversely with its amplitude—meaning larger cycles tend to have slower rises. The paper explains this variation as being caused by the interference between the octal and decadal groups of sunspot number components.
INF Method
The Inverse Notch Filter (INF) method is a specific procedure used to isolate individual periodicities from the sunspot data. It involves subtracting the mean, applying a Press notch filter tuned to a specific frequency, and then subtracting that filtered output from the original anomaly to reveal the isolated component.

Terminology

Summary

Combining spectral analysis and narrow band pass filtering of sunspot number records to forecast the next solar grand minimum is a new method developed to obtain a high resolution forecast for a solar grand minimum from cycle 26 at 2030 to cycle 37 at 2150

Methodology and Data Analysis

The paper develops a new method for forecasting sunspot number (SSN) applied to the annual SILSO SSN record, 1700 - 2024, to obtain a high resolution forecast and a reconstructed annual SSN record, 971 - 1899, to obtain a low resolution forecast Fourier analysis identifies eleven near-decadal periodicities in the range from 8 to 15 years in the SILSO record and four centennial scale periodicities between 60 and 800 years in the reconstructed SSN record Components at each period are isolated by a new method of narrow band pass filtering The procedure to obtain a band pass filtered version of SSN involved subtracting the mean SSN, applying a Press notch filter with bandwidth specified as a percentage of the frequency of the specified periodicity, and then subtracting the output from the SSN anomaly to provide an inverse notch filtered (INF) version Wavelet analysis was obtained with the application WaveletComp

Spectral Content and Component Grouping

The spectral content of SILSO SSN is characterized by three groups of periodicities in the period range 8 to 15 years, nominally octal, decadal and decadal-plus groups The SSN anomaly is shown as the full black line in Figure 1A The periodogram of the SSN anomaly in the decadal range of interest is shown (black full curve) in Figure 1B While the periodicity is primarily decadal it occasionally swings to the octal range, for example around 1780, or to the decadal-plus range, for example around 1800 The sum of all eleven INF components is compared with the SSN anomaly in Figure 1A The correlation coefficient, r = 0.83, indicates that the component combination closely replicates the SSN anomaly

Forecasting and Grand Minima Prediction

Forward projection from each record forecasts a grand solar minimum from 2030 to 2150 The sum of all three group projections shows an extended grand minimum between 2020 and 2150 The back projection from solar cycle 24 reproduces the SSN variation in the Dalton Minimum and the Maunder Grand Minimum The forward projection forecasts a grand minimum in SSN from about 2020 to 2150 labelled “Next”

Mechanisms of Solar Cycle Variation

The Waldmeier Effect is explained in terms of interference between the octal and decadal groups Interference between the summed decadal and octal components of SSN reproduced the Waldmeier Effect in its various manifestations The model, nominally the “shah” model, connecting the generation of grand minima/maxima to interference between the components in the decadal group was developed and was shown to reproduce grand minima/maxima the features which were consistent with features obtained from wavelet analysis of reconstructed SSN

Planetary Connections

A connection between planetary and SSN periodicity is established The close correspondence between the planetary periods obtained from the planetary function y+(t) and the periods associated with SILSO SSN are evidence of a connection The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model of SSN variability closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN

Summary and Conclusion

The main findings are that the variation in SSN anomaly is largely characterized by three groups of periodicities, nominally octal, decadal and decadal-plus groups, in the period range 8 to 15 years The SSN variation due to the four components in the decadal group of periodicities dominates but is occasionally exceeded in amplitude by the octal or decadal-plus group When eleven components corresponding to the periodicities are found by the INF method, fitted to sinusoids at solar cycle 24, projected forward and summed, the sum forecasts a solar grand minimum in SSN extending from about 2030 to 2120 The forecast was validated by a back projection of SSN from solar cycle 24 that reproduced the SSN variation in the Dalton Minimum and the Maunder Grand Minimum A model, the “shah” model, connecting grand minima/maxima to interference between decadal group components was developed and was shown to reproduce grand minima/maxima features consistent with wavelet analysis Interference between summed octal and decadal components reproduced the Waldmeier Effect in its various manifestations An analysis isolating four long period components of a reconstructed SSN record, 971 to 1899, and projecting the components forward correctly forecasts the Gleissberg Minimum and the Modern grand maximum and forecasts a grand minimum between 2000 and 2150 The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model of SSN variability closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model of SSN variability closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN Evidence supporting the persistence included successful back projection from the SILSO SSN record, successful forward projection from the reconstructed 971 to 1899 record and the close coincidence of SILSO SSN periodicity with inherently persistent planetary periodicity The forecasts of the next grand minimum obtained in this work depend on the persistence of cycles identified in the SILSO SSN record and in a reconstructed SSN record

How the training signal is built

The components are fitted with sinusoids for back/forward projection The sinusoids were fitted at solar cycle 24, around year 2012, as follows The amplitude was measured as the peak height of each component and the phase was estimated as the average of the zero crossing times at solar cycle 24 for each component The projections of the decadal group of sinusoids between year 0 and 2500 are shown in Figure 3A along with the sum of the projections

Where the gains come from

The analysis suggests that grand minima and maxima may simply be the result of interference that occurs between the four decadal components of SSN The deterministic process described here contrasts with the view that grand minima episodes are caused by some type of stochastic process in the Sun Interference between octal, decadal and decadal-plus components would increase the possible range and complexity of long-term variability The close correspondence between the planetary periods obtained from the planetary function y+(t) and the periods associated with SILSO SSN is evidence of a connection The periodicity obtained from a planetary impulse model closely matched the periodicity observed in SILSO SSN A comparison of periodograms (using relative values) of SILSO SSN and the impulse model is shown to be close in periodicity and amplitude The close match in periodicity and in amplitude is taken as further evidence of a planetary influence on solar activity The forecasts depend on the persistence of cycles identified in the SILSO SSN record and in a reconstructed SSN record

Waldmeier Effect Explanation

The Waldmeier Effect, reported in earlier studies, are explained in terms of interference between the octal and decadal groups The interference of the decadal and octal components provides an explanation of the Waldmeier Effect, which is the observation that the rise time of a sunspot cycle varies inversely with the cycle amplitude This model supports the idea that all manifestations of the Waldmeier Effect can be explained by interference between octal and decadal components

Planetary Influence Assessment

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Incorporate a method for forecasting grand minima using Fourier analysis and narrow band pass filtering, as described in Section 2 and 3.2, allowing AI systems to project SSN from solar cycle 24 forward to predict a grand minimum between 2030 and 2150.

  2. Develop a model of grand minima based on decadal group component interference, enabling the AI to identify which components (octal, decadal, or decadal-plus) dominate during specific phases of solar activity.

  3. Implement a model for Waldmeier Effects by analyzing the interference between octal and decadal groups, allowing AI systems to explain the Waldmeier Effect as observed in short-term SSN changes.

  4. Create a model of solar activity that exhibits periodicity evident in the SILSO SSN record by using sinusoidal projections based on identified periodicities, which allows the AI to generate a simple model of solar activity.

  5. Integrate spectral analysis into forecasting, where the AI can identify eleven near-decadal periodicities and four centennial scale periodicities from SSN records to inform its predictions.

  6. Enable connection between SSN periodicity and planetary periodicity by analyzing how planetary models (like the sum of cosinusoids) generate observed periodicities in SILSO SSN, which helps in assessing the possibility of a planet to SSN connection.

Abstract

The paper develops a method for forecasting grand minima in sunspot number (SSN). The method is applied to the annual SILSO SSN record, 1700 - 2024, to obtain a high resolution forecast and to a reconstructed annual SSN record, 971 - 1899, to obtain a low resolution forecast. Fourier analysis identifies eleven near-decadal periodicities, in the range from 8 to 15 years, in the SILSO record and four centennial scale periodicities, between 60 and 800 years, in the reconstructed SSN record. Components at each period are isolated by a new method of narrow band pass filtering. The components are fitted with sinusoids for back/forward projection. Forward projection from each record forecasts a grand solar minimum from 2030 to 2150. Short term features within the grand minimum are less certain. The eleven periodicities in the SILSO record are separated into octal, decadal and decadal-plus groups. The four components in the decadal group are, on average, higher in amplitude by a factor of three than components in the other two groups. During grand maxima the decadal group components constructively interfere and dominate SSN variation. Following grand maxima the four decadal group components move into destructive interference, a grand minimum in SSN occurs and the summed amplitudes of the octal and decadal-plus groups can match or exceed the summed decadal contribution. Short term change in SSN variation, specifically the Waldmeier Effect, is explained in terms of interference between the contributions of the octal and decadal groups.

Sources

Related papers