Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate

arXiv:2510.11551 · cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2025-10-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate provides concrete NMR identification of spinons, solitons, and the long-sought RS state in a single material by tuning the magnetic field at ultra-low temperatures The results establish copper benzoate as a unique experimental platform for studying one-dimensional quantum integrability and the interplay of disorder and correlations Identification of Excitations via NMR The study employed nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) on a high-quality single crystal of copper benzoate to identify three distinct excitation types by tuning the magnetic field at ultra-low temperatures At a low field of 0.2 T, a temperature-independent spin-lattice relaxation rate (1/T1) over more than a decade confirms the presence of spinons Below 0.4 K, an additional relaxation channel emerges, characterized by 1/T1 ∝ T and a spectral weight growing as − ln(T /T0), signaling a random-singlet ground state induced by weak quenched disorder At fields above 0.5 T, a field-induced spin gap ∆ ∝ H2/3 observed in both 1/T1 and the Knight shift signifies soliton excitations Theoretical Context of 1D Quantum Systems One-dimensional (1D) quantum spin systems are ideal platforms for exploring emergent phases and novel excitations in condensed matter physics, whose theoretical descriptions are particularly precise The celebrated S = 1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain (HAFC) uses the Bethe ansatz solution to lay the theoretical foundation for understanding 1D quantum magnets Continuous spin excitation spectrum of this system is attributed to unique spin-1/2 fractional excitations known as spinons In the presence of strong disorder, a random singlet (RS) state is predicted to emerge in 1D systems, characterized by the freezing of paired spin singlets over length scales extending to infinity Characterization of Spinon and RS State Signatures The fast component of 1/T1 at 0.2 T decreases gradually below 2 K and becomes nearly constant between 1.4 K and 0.03 K, which is a hallmark of spinon excitations in the HAFC The slow component of the relaxation rate emerges below 0.4 K, with its relaxation rate decreasing linearly with temperature upon cooling, signaling a new type of gapless excitation not captured by the pure HAFC model The relative spectral weight w2 of the slow T1 component is well described by the logarithmic function w2 = −a ln(T /T0) with T0 ≈ 0.4 K Field-Induced Soliton Excitations At high fields, a large upturn in the nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate, Kn, at ultra-low temperatures follows a thermal activation behavior with a gap scaling as ∆ ∼ H2/3 This gapped behavior is observed in 1/T1 and is consistent with soliton excitations arising from the field-induced staggered magnetization The low-energy effective theory for the HAFC under a uniform field is the integrable sine-Gordon model, whose elementary excitations are solitons with a gap scaling as ∆ ∝ H2/3 The work demonstrates that NMR serves as an excellent local, low-energy probe for identifying and characterizing novel excitations in one-dimensional systems The presence of weak quenched disorder drives the HAFC into a RS state, which accounts for the suppression of low-temperature thermal conductivity observed in copper benzoate The findings suggest that spin dynamics in both strong- and weak-disorder cases are governed by the same universal logarithmic scaling within their respective temperature regimes This approach is directly applicable to the exploration of exotic quantum phases in two-dimensional materials, such as spin liquids The observation of gapless excitations provides further evidence for the RS state The coupling constant β in the sine-Gordon model varies with the applied field, opening avenues to investigate other novel excitations predicted by the field theory, such as breathers The paper concludes that high-quality single crystals allow for the separation of intrinsic spinon excitations from those affected by weak quenched disorder Page 6 --- Materials and methods Copper benzoate crystallizes in the monoclinic I2/c space group, where the Cu2+ ions form 1D chains along the crystalline c-axis (see Supplementary Sec.

Kai: S1) The single crystal used for NMR measurements was grown by the chemical diffusion method (see Supplementary Secs.

Mira: S3 and S4) Measurements were performed using a variable-temperature insert (see Supplementary Secs.

Kai: S3 and S4) and a dilution refrigerator (down to 0.03 K) The magnetic field was applied along the crystalline b-axis Page 7 --- The Knight shift Kn at the H(1) site for field of 2 T was determined from the average frequency of the corresponding paired peaks to improve accuracy, and is plotted as a function of temperature in Fig.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to wrap up what we just talked about with this paper on "Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate," they’re showing that by tuning the magnetic field at ultra low temperatures, you can get concrete NMR identification for spinons, solitons, and even the random singlet state.

Mira: Basically, their thesis is that this material acts as a perfect platform to study how one dimensional quantum integrability plays out when disorder and correlations are at play.

Lev: They’re saying the key takeaway is that these three different excitation types show distinct signatures in the nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate across different temperature regimes.

Kai: The paper claims that at low fields, they see spinons, and below zero point four Kelvin, a random singlet ground state induced by weak quenched disorder emerges <ref:2510.11551#pg3>.

Mira: And for higher fields above zero point five Tesla, they observe field induced spin gap excitations which are identified as solitons with a gap scaling as H two over three.

Lev: So the core claim is that these different excitation regimes have very specific, measurable signatures that let you map out the phase diagram of this material using NMR measurements.

Kai: It matters because it confirms that these phenomena are not just theoretical predictions; they are observable in a real compound under experimental conditions.

Mira: And it’s important because the results suggest that spin dynamics in both strong and weak disorder cases are governed by the same universal logarithmic scaling within their respective temperature regimes.

Lev: That scaling relationship is what connects the different regimes, which is crucial for building a unified picture of how disorder affects these systems.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the title of "Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate," I think it really captures the essence of what they achieved here.

Mira: It’s not just about finding one thing; it’s about mapping out a phase diagram where different low energy excitations—spinons, solitons, and RS state—all compete depending on the magnetic field and disorder.

Lev: The implication for us is that we need to account for this complexity when designing our real hardware, because the physics isn't simple one excitation anymore.

Kai: It means that what we observe in copper benzoate gives us a blueprint for how to look at other two dimensional materials, like spin liquids and deconfined quantum critical points.

Mira: And they’re suggesting that the way disorder affects these systems is governed by universal scaling behavior within their respective temperature regimes.

Lev: That universal scaling behavior is what we need to know if we can generalize those findings to other complex materials outside of just this one compound.

School of Physics and Beijing Key Laboratory of Opto-electronic Functional Materials & Micro-nano Devices, Renmin University of China · Kavli Institute for Theoretical Sciences and CAS Center for Excellence in Topological Quantum Computation, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences · Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences · College of Physics and Optoelectronic Engineering, Ocean University of China · Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics and Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences · Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) · Spallation Neutron Source Science Center · School of Physics, Zhejiang University · Key Laboratory of Quantum State Construction and Manipulation (Ministry of Education) · State Key Laboratory of Surface Physics and Department of Physics, Fudan University

cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2025-10-13

Updated: 2025-10-13

Journal ref: Nature Communications (2026)

DOI: 10.1038/s41467-026-77134-7

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 88/100

The gist: Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate provides concrete NMR identification of spinons, solitons…

Key concepts

Spinons
These are unique spin-1/2 fractional excitations found in the S=1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain. They are characteristic of the system's continuous spin excitation spectrum and are identified by a temperature-independent component in the nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation rate (1/T1).
Random Singlet (RS) State
This state emerges in 1D systems when weak quenched disorder is present. It is characterized by the freezing of paired spin singlets over infinite length scales, which explains a linear temperature dependence in the slow relaxation rate and the logarithmic divergence of correlation length.
Solitons
These are excitations observed at high magnetic fields, appearing as a field-induced spin gap ($\Delta \propto H^{2/3}$). They arise from the low-energy effective theory (sine-Gordon model) describing 1D quantum magnets under a uniform field.
NMR Identification
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) is used as a local, low-energy probe to characterize excitations in copper benzoate. Different excitation types are distinguished by observing specific temperature and field dependencies in the spin-lattice relaxation rate (1/T1) and Knight shift (Kn).

Terminology

Summary

Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate provides concrete NMR identification of spinons, solitons, and the long-sought RS state in a single material by tuning the magnetic field at ultra-low temperatures The results establish copper benzoate as a unique experimental platform for studying one-dimensional quantum integrability and the interplay of disorder and correlations

Identification of Excitations via NMR

The study employed nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) on a high-quality single crystal of copper benzoate to identify three distinct excitation types by tuning the magnetic field at ultra-low temperatures At a low field of 0.2 T, a temperature-independent spin-lattice relaxation rate (1/T1) over more than a decade confirms the presence of spinons Below 0. p. 04 K, an additional relaxation channel emerges, characterized by 1/T1 ∝ T and a spectral weight growing as − ln(T /T0), signaling a random-singlet ground state induced by weak quenched disorder At fields above 0. p. 05 T, a field-induced spin gap ∆ ∝ H2/3 observed in both 1/T1 and the Knight shift signifies soliton excitations

Theoretical Context of 1D Quantum Systems

One-dimensional (1D) quantum spin systems are ideal platforms for exploring emergent phases and novel excitations in condensed matter physics, whose theoretical descriptions are particularly precise The celebrated S = 1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain (HAFC) uses the Bethe ansatz solution to lay the theoretical foundation for understanding 1D quantum magnets Continuous spin excitation spectrum of this system is attributed to unique spin-1/2 fractional excitations known as spinons In the presence of strong disorder, a random singlet (RS) state is predicted to emerge in 1D systems, characterized by the freezing of paired spin singlets over length scales extending to infinity

Characterization of Spinon and RS State Signatures

The fast component of 1/T1 at 0.2 T decreases gradually below 2 K and becomes nearly constant between 1. p. 24 K and 0.03 K, which is a hallmark of spinon excitations in the HAFC The slow component of the relaxation rate emerges below 0. p. 24 K, with its relaxation rate decreasing linearly with temperature upon cooling, signaling a new type of gapless excitation not captured by the pure HAFC model The relative spectral weight w2 of the slow T1 component is well described by the logarithmic function w2 = −a ln(T /T0) with T0 ≈ 0. p. 24 K

Field-Induced Soliton Excitations

At high fields, a large upturn in the nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate, Kn, at ultra-low temperatures follows a thermal activation behavior with a gap scaling as ∆ ∼ H2/3 This gapped behavior is observed in 1/T1 and is consistent with soliton excitations arising from the field-induced staggered magnetization The low-energy effective theory for the HAFC under a uniform field is the integrable sine-Gordon model, whose elementary excitations are solitons with a gap scaling as ∆ ∝ H2/3

Conclusion and Broader Implications

The work demonstrates that NMR serves as an excellent local, low-energy probe for identifying and characterizing novel excitations in one-dimensional systems The presence of weak quenched disorder drives the HAFC into a RS state, which accounts for the suppression of low-temperature thermal conductivity observed in copper benzoate The findings suggest that spin dynamics in both strong- and weak-disorder cases are governed by the same universal logarithmic scaling within their respective temperature regimes This approach is directly applicable to the exploration of exotic quantum phases in two-dimensional materials, such as spin liquids The observation of gapless excitations provides further evidence for the RS state The coupling constant β in the sine-Gordon model varies with the applied field, opening avenues to investigate other novel excitations predicted by the field theory, such as breathers The paper concludes that high-quality single crystals allow for the separation of intrinsic spinon excitations from those affected by weak quenched disorder

--- Page 6 ---

Materials and methods Copper benzoate crystallizes in the monoclinic I2/c space group, where the Cu2+ ions form 1D chains along the crystalline c-axis (see Supplementary Sec. S1) The single crystal used for NMR measurements was grown by the chemical diffusion method (see Supplementary Secs. p. 5 S3 and S4) Measurements were performed using a variable-temperature insert (see Supplementary Secs. p. 5 S3 and S4) and a dilution refrigerator (down to 0. p. 503 K) The magnetic field was applied along the crystalline b-axis

--- Page 7 ---

The Knight shift Kn at the H(1) site for field of 2 T was determined from the average frequency of the corresponding paired peaks to improve accuracy, and is plotted as a function of temperature in Fig. 2c Upon cooling below 100 K, Kn increases and develops a peak at approximately 12 K, marked by the downward arrow in Fig. p. 1 2c This peak temperature coincides with that observed in the magnetic susceptibility (see Supplementary Fig. p. 1 S3) and is identified as the Bonner-Fisher peak at Tmax = 0. p. 1641J, characteristic of the S = 1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain

--- Page 7 ---

The fast component of 1/T1f decreases gradually below 2 K and becomes nearly constant between 1.4 K and 0.03 K, which is a hallmark of spinon excitations in the HAFC A constant 1/T1 over a decade in temperature is a hallmark of spinon excitations in the 1D HAFC This can be understood from the scaling relation

for spinons with a linear dispersion ω ∼ k, where η is the correlation exponent [2]. For the S = 1/2 HAFC, η = 1, which directly yields a temperature-independent 1/T1

--- Page 7 ---

The slow component of the relaxation rate decreases linearly with temperature upon cooling, signaling a new type of gapless excitation not captured by the pure HAFC model This clear power-law temperature dependence signals a new type of gapless excitation not captured by the pure HAFC model

--- Page 7 ---

The relative spectral weight of the slow T1 component, denoted w2, is calculated from the P(1/T1) distribution in Fig. 3c and plotted as a function of temperature in Fig. p. 1 3d Remarkably, over more than a decade in temperature (0. p. 203 K to 0.4 K), w2 is well described by the logarithmic function w2 = −a ln(T /T0)

--- Page 7 ---

The observed logarithmic dependence, ξ ∝ − ln(T /T0), is distinct from the conventional quantum critical scaling ξ ∼ T − 1/z Instead, it signifies that the ground state is a disorder-induced 1D RS state, governed by an infinite-randomness fixed point with an effective dynamical exponent z → ∞

--- Page 7 ---

The formation of long-distance singlets closes the spin gap, resulting in the gapless behavior observed in the slow 1/T1s component Furthermore, the broad distribution of relaxation timescales inherent to the RS state is directly visualized in the spectral distribution of 1/T1 around the linear-T trajectory in Fig. 3c

--- Page 7 ---

The observation of gapless excitations in the present system provides further evidence for the RS state

--- Page 7 ---

The field-induced gap and soliton excitations are accounted for by a field-induced effective staggered field The precise theoretical form is given by ∆ = 1.85J(h/J)2/3

--- Page 7 ---

The coupling constant β in this sine-Gordon model varies with the applied field, opening avenues to investigate other novel excitations predicted by the field theory, such as breathers The work also demonstrates that NMR serves as an excellent local, low-energy probe for identifying and characterizing novel excitations in one-dimensional systems

--- Page 7 ---

The approach established here is directly applicable to the exploration of exotic quantum phases in two-dimensional materials, such as spin liquids and deconfined quantum critical points The paper establishes concrete NMR identification of spinons, solitons, and the long-sought RS state

--- Page 7 ---

The spinon excitations are revealed by a nearly constant 1/T1 in more than a decade of temperature Experimental evidence for a RS state are directly identified and characterized by a linear temperature dependence of 1/T1 and a logarithmic divergence of the correlation length The emergence of the RS state readily accounts for the significant suppression of thermal conductivity below 0.3 K reported in this material

--- Page 7 ---

The theory predicts quasi-localized spin excitations that yield a thermal conductivity with a quadratic temperature dependence This offers a consistent explanation for the suppression of low-temperature thermal conductivity observed in copper benzoate

--- Page 7 ---

The observation of gapless excitations in the present system provides further evidence for the RS state The formation of long-distance singlets closes the spin gap, resulting in the gapless behavior observed in the slow 1/T1s component

--- Page 7 ---

The fact that the disorder effect becomes apparent only below 0.4 K (≈0.02J) attests to the weakness of the disorder in our compound The condition is distinct from the high-temperature, strong-disorder limit treated in early theoretical work

--- Page 7 ---

The field-induced gap and soliton excitations are accounted for by a field-induced effective staggered field The precise theoretical form is given by ∆ = 1.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Precise identification of low-energy excitations in quantum magnets can be achieved by using nuclear magnetic resonance NMR on high-quality single crystals to distinguish between spinons, solitons, and random singlet states. This allows for the characterization of different excitation modes by tuning the magnetic field at ultra-low temperatures.

  2. The AI system can perform spectral characterization of 1H NMR spectra across varying magnetic fields and temperatures to assign specific nuclear sites based on hyperfine couplings, as demonstrated by resolving peaks P1–P5 in Figure 2a. This capability enables accurate identification of different proton environments within the material structure.

  3. The system can analyze spin-lattice relaxation rates (1/T1) using inverse Laplace transformation analysis to resolve fast and slow relaxation components, which are attributed to spinon excitations and disorder-induced random singlet states, respectively. This allows for the quantitative separation of intrinsic spin dynamics from those affected by quenched disorder.

  4. The AI can calculate correlation lengths as a function of temperature using quantum Monte Carlo simulations to confirm the presence of a disorder induced 1D RS state, showing a clear minus ln T dependence. This provides direct computational evidence supporting theoretical predictions regarding the system's ground state behavior.

  5. The system can model field-induced gap scaling by fitting Knight shift data and spin-lattice relaxation rates to thermal activation functions, yielding gap values such as Delta proportional to H two over three power of J. This allows the AI to predict and characterize soliton excitations based on magnetic field strength.

Sources

Related papers