Electron Lateral Trapping Induced by Non-Uniform Thickness in Solid Neon Layers

arXiv:2510.10351 · quant-ph · Submitted 2025-10-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Electron Lateral Trapping Induced by Non-Uniform Thickness in Solid Neon Layers".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Electron lateral trapping induced by non-uniform thickness in solid neon layers reveals that engineered thickness variations can generate lateral trapping potentials for electrons The main findings are that the binding energy for the electron above a 10 nmthick solid Ne layer reaches 44.6 meV on a superconducting substrate and 40.0 meV on a silicon substrate, both markedly exceeding the bulk value of 15.7 meV Thickness variations on the order of ∆L ∼ 3 nm can induce ground-state energy shifts of approximately 10 meV for the excess electron, revealing a fundamental lateral trapping mechanism arising from thickness nonuniformity Finite Thickness Effects on Binding Energy The binding energy for the electron above a 10 nmthick solid Ne layer reaches 44.6 meV on a superconducting substrate and 40.0 meV on a silicon substrate, both markedly exceeding the bulk value of 15.7 meV.

Kai: This enhancement is due to the finite thickness dependence of the trapping potential.

Mira: Mechanism of Lateral Trapping The authors propose a nanopatternedsubstrate mechanism in which engineered thickness variations generate lateral trapping potentials for electrons.

Kai: This mechanism is motivated by the observation that the ground-state energy of an excess electron correspondingly lowers as the solid Ne layer thickness decreases, indicating preferential trapping above thinner regions.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're wrapping up "Electron Lateral Trapping Induced by Non-Uniform Thickness in Solid Neon Layers." Toshiaki Kanai and Chuanwei Zhang looked at how finite thickness and spatial nonuniformity shape the trapping potential of an excess electron >

Mira: The main point is that thickness variations of about three nanometers can cause ground state energy shifts of approximately ten milli-electron volts for the excess electron, which reveals a fundamental lateral trapping mechanism arising from this unevenness >

Kai: And they show how you can use this to propose a single-electron charge qubit confined by a potential created by an engineered nanopillar on the flat substrate, paving the way toward scalable multi-qubit architectures based on patterned pillar arrays >

Mira: This points toward a solid neon based quantum computing platform where individual qubit sites can be periodically patterned on the substrate >

Kai: That’s the direction they’re heading, showing how these nanoscale thickness effects translate into a practical way to confine charge in a controllable manner.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at "Electron Lateral Trapping Induced by Non-Uniform Thickness in Solid Neon Layers." The authors, Toshiaki Kanai and Chuanwei Zhang, they basically show how messing with the thickness of a solid neon layer creates a sideways trap for an excess electron > Mira They found that even small variations, like three nanometers, can shift the ground state energy by about ten milli-electron volts > Kai This points to a new way to make lateral traps using patterned substrates rather than just uniform layers > Lev It means we're not just looking at bulk properties anymore; we're designing hardware where the physical shape dictates the quantum confinement > Mira Because they’ve shown how you can tune that trapping potential with an electric field, it opens up possibilities for controlling these charge states precisely > Kai This could lead to a solid neon based quantum computing platform where you can build individual qubit sites by patterning them onto a substrate > Lev We need to figure out if the fabrication techniques for creating those precise thickness variations are actually feasible on a chip and if we can maintain the required fidelity when you start adding these lateral confinement potentials > Mira

Toshiaki Kanai, Chuanwei Zhang

Department of Physics, Washington University, St Louis, Missouri

quant-ph

Submitted: 2025-10-11

Updated: 2025-10-11

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 114, 052606 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/3k7l-4597

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Electron lateral trapping induced by non-uniform thickness in solid neon layers reveals that engineered thickness variations can generate lateral trapping potentials for electrons The main findings…

Key concepts

Lateral Trapping Potential
This is a potential energy landscape that confines an excess electron to specific lateral positions, rather than just trapping it vertically. In this study, it arises from the non-uniform thickness of the solid neon layer, creating dips in the potential that guide the electron laterally.
Finite Thickness Effects on Binding Energy
The binding energy of an electron above a solid neon layer changes drastically when the layer is not infinitely thick. For a 10 nm layer, this energy reaches 44.6 meV on superconducting substrates, much higher than the bulk value of 15.7 meV.
Gibbs–Thomson Effect
This effect describes how surface curvature influences phase transitions, like solidification. In this context, substrate roughness causes local thickness variations in the solid neon layer by shifting its melting temperature based on the local curvature.

Terminology

Summary

Electron lateral trapping induced by non-uniform thickness in solid neon layers reveals that engineered thickness variations can generate lateral trapping potentials for electrons The main findings are that the binding energy for the electron above a 10 nmthick solid Ne layer reaches 44. p. 1 p. 1 p. 16 meV on a superconducting substrate and 40. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 10 meV on a silicon substrate, both markedly exceeding the bulk value of 15. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 17 meV Thickness variations on the order of ∆L ∼ 3 nm can induce ground-state energy shifts of approximately 10 meV for the excess electron, revealing a fundamental lateral trapping mechanism arising from thickness nonuniformity

Finite Thickness Effects on Binding Energy

The binding energy for the electron above a 10 nmthick solid Ne layer reaches 44.6 meV on a superconducting substrate and 40.0 meV on a silicon substrate, both markedly exceeding the bulk value of 15.7 meV. This enhancement is due to the finite thickness dependence of the trapping potential. p. 0

Mechanism of Lateral Trapping

The authors propose a nanopatternedsubstrate mechanism in which engineered thickness variations generate lateral trapping potentials for electrons. This mechanism is motivated by the observation that the ground-state energy of an excess electron correspondingly lowers as the solid Ne layer thickness decreases, indicating preferential trapping above thinner regions. p. 2 The thickness variation can be modeled as L(ρ) = L0 − ∆L / 2 (1 − ρ − R / (ρ − R) 2 + b 2! p. 2).

Tunability and Control

The lateral trapping potential and electron excitation energy can be finely tuned through a uniform electric field applied in the perpendicular direction. The lateral excitation energy has a nonlinear dependence on the direction of the applied field. p. 1 Specifically, a positive field (Eex > 0) increases the potential depth, leading to modest changes in ∆U, whereas a negative field (Eex < 0) reduces the depth and leads to a more pronounced shift. p. 3

Scalable Architecture Proposal

Building on this mechanism, the authors propose a single-electron charge qubit confined by the potential created by an engineered nanopillar on the flat substrate, paving the way toward scalable multi-qubit architectures based on patterned nanopillar arrays. This approach suggests that individual qubit sites can be periodically patterned on the substrate, with a bump radius of approximately 110 nm comparable to surface valleys observed experimentally. p. 4 The resulting lateral excitation energy is comparable to the typical microwave photon energy used in qubit operations. p. 4 p. 4

Future Directions and Feasibility

Future work may explore coupling between adjacent traps, the role of substrate-induced disorder and decoherence, and the feasibility of entangling operations mediated by shared photonic modes. The paper suggests a scalable platform for quantum information processing where individual qubit sites are periodically patterned on the substrate. p. 4 The authors also discuss shaping the bump elliptically can confine the electron’s lateral motion along a preferred axis, reducing the spatial footprint of each qubit and enabling higher qubit density. p. 4

Derivation of Trapping Potential

The perpendicular trapping potential V⊥(L, z) is derived from the Poisson equation and approximated by an integral involving the reflection coefficient ΛL(k). The total potential V (z) enters the one-dimensional Schrödinger equation along the z-direction. p. 2 The ground-state energy WG decreases markedly for thinner layers, such as WG = −44. p. 26 meV for L = 10 nm, which is nearly three times lower than the bulk solid Ne value of −15. p. 27 meV. The lateral trapping potential V∥(ρ, Eex) is described using a local-thickness approximation (LTA). p. 3 The resulting excitation energy ∆U increases as R decreases since it corresponds to the rotational motion of the electron. p. 3 The lateral trapping potential deepens with increasing ∆L or decreasing L0, as shown in Fig. p. 3 p. 3 4(a).

Tuning via Field Dependence

The nonlinear field dependence of ∆U is reproduced by a harmonic approximation V∥(ρ) ≈ 1/2meω20ρ2. The corresponding excitation energy is ∆U = ħω = ħ p ω20 + β1Eex/me, naturally reproducing the asymmetric behavior. p. 3 This nonlinear response is more prominent for sharper thickness transitions (smaller b) or shallower potentials. p. 3 The authors conclude that increasing the Ne layer thickness suppresses the lateral trapping effect, enabling gatedefined qubits. p. 4

Substrate Influence on Thickness

The non-uniform neon layer thickness is induced by substrate inhomogeneity through the Gibbs–Thomson effect. The shift in melting temperature, denoted ∆TR, is governed by the Gibbs–Thomson relation. p. 1 This leads to an approximate relation ∆TR ≈ −9. p. 112 [K · nm]/rc. The sign of ∆TR is determined by the curvature direction, causing solidification to initiate preferentially at the bottom of surface depressions. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 The gravitational potential difference associated with height variations on silicon substrates is on the order of 5×10−11 meV, which is negligible compared to other energies. p. 1 The combined effects of partial solidification and rapid thermal diffusion lead to preferential accumulation of Ne atoms in surface depressions. p. 1 p. 1

Experimental Realization

The authors discuss the feasibility of constructing multiqubit architectures based on this mechanism using lithography and etching techniques. By forming a similar bump and surrounding it with superconducting electrodes, one can create a locally thinner Ne region above the bump to trap an electron. p. 4 p. 4 The electrode height should be slightly lower than that of the central bump to maintain proper field confinement. p. 4 This correspondence suggests a scalable platform for quantum information processing where individual qubit sites are periodically patterned on the substrate. p. 4 p. 4 The paper is supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research under Grant No. p. 4 FA9550-20-1- 0220 and the National Science Foundation under Grant No. p. 4 p. 4 PHY-2409943, OSI-2228725. p. 4 p. 4 The authors thank Kaiwen Zhang, Kater Murch, and Wei Guo for fruitful discussions and comments. p. 4 p. 4

Key References

[1] A. Chatterjee, P. p. 4 p. 4 Stevenson, S. p. 4 p. 4 De Franceschi, A. p. 4 p. 4 Morello, N. p. 4 p. 4 P. De Leon, and F. p. 4 Kuemmeth

[6] X. Zhou, G. Koolstra, X. p. 4 Zhang, G Yang, X Han B Dizdar X Li R Divan W Guo K W Murch D I Schuster and D Jin

[9] X. Li S Zou Q Chen and D Jin

[28] Supplementary materials

--- Page 7 ---

The perpendicular trapping potential V⊥(L, z) is well approximated by an integral involving the reflection coefficient ΛL(k). By subtracting the self-interaction term, we obtain V⊥(r) = e2 / 8πε0 ∫0∞ dk ΛL(k)e−2kzdk. p. 6

--- Page 1 ---

Electron lateral trapping induced by non-uniform thickness in solid neon layers is a theoretical investigation into how finite thickness and non-uniformity of solid neon layers shape the trapping potential of an excess electron. The main findings are that the binding energy for the electron above a 10 nmthick solid Ne layer reaches 44.6 meV on a superconducting substrate and 40.0 meV on a silicon substrate, both markedly exceeding the bulk value of 15.7 meV. Thickness variations on the order of ∆L ∼ 3 nm can induce ground-state energy shifts of approximately 10 meV for the excess electron, revealing a fundamental lateral trapping mechanism arising from thickness nonuniformity. p. 1 p. 1

Derivation Details

The system consists of a vacuum in the upper half-space (z > 0), a solid Ne layer of thickness L occupying the region −L < z < 0, and a substrate below (z < −L). The spatially dependent dielectric permittivity is defined as ε(L, z) = ε0 for 0

Potential Limits

For a superconducting substrate (εB → ∞), this expression simplifies to ΛL(k) = ε0 tanh(kL) − εNe / (ε0 + εNe) tanh(kL). In the bulk limit (L → ∞), the potential reduces to the well-known image charge potential above bulk solid Ne. p. 2 In the limit of vanishing thickness (L → 0), the potential reduces to that produced by a mirror charge e. p. 2

Excitation Energy Analysis

The total potential V (z) enters the one-dimensional Schrödinger equation along the z-direction. Figure 2(b) shows that WG decreases markedly for thinner layers, with WG = −44. p. 26 meV for L = 10 nm. p. 1 The perpendicular excitation energy from the ground to the first excited state is approximately 21. p. 21 meV, substantially higher than both typical experimental temperatures and characteristic lateral excitation energies. p. 2

Lateral Trapping Potential Modeling

The lateral trapping potential V∥(ρ, Eex) is modeled using a local-thickness approximation (LTA). This smoothly interpolates between a potential depth of −V0(Eex) = WG(L0 − ∆L, Eex) − WG(L0, Eex) near the center (ρ ≪ R) and zero at large distances. p. 3 p. 3 The lateral trapping potential deepens with increasing ∆L or decreasing L0, as shown in Fig. 4(a).

Field Tuning Asymmetry

The external electric field Vex(z) introduces a shift to the potential depth of approximately eEex∆L ε0/εNe. A positive field (Eex > 0) increases the potential depth, leading to modest changes in ∆U, whereas a negative field (Eex < 0) reduces the depth and leads to a more pronounced shift. p. 3 p. 3 The corresponding excitation energy is tuned by ∆U = ħω = ħ p ω20 + β1Eex/me. p. 3 p. 3

Substrate Roughness Influence

The substrate roughness can strongly influence the solidification process near the triple point via the Gibbs–Thomson effect. This effect introduces thickness nonuniformity in the solid layer by shifting the melting temperature via ∆TR = −2γSLVm / rc∆HfTbulk (1). p. 1 p. 1 The sign of ∆TR is determined by the curvature direction, causing solidification to initiate preferentially at the bottom of surface depressions. The combined effects of partial solidification and rapid thermal diffusion lead to preferential accumulation of Ne atoms in surface depressions.

Scalability and Qubit Design

Nanopillar arrays have been routinely fabricated using lithography and etching techniques, such as in GaAs [29, 30]. By forming a similar bump and surrounding it with superconducting electrodes, one can create a locally thinner Ne region above the bump to trap an electron. The resulting lateral excitation energy is comparable to the typical microwave photon energy used in qubit operations. This correspondence suggests a scalable platform for quantum information processing where individual qubit sites are periodically patterned on the substrate. Shaping the bump elliptically can confine the electron’s lateral motion along a preferred axis, reducing the spatial footprint of each qubit and enabling higher qubit density. p. 4

Final Conclusion

The authors conclude that finite thickness of a solid Ne layer has a profound effect on the quantum state and binding energy of an electron floating above its surface. The paper paves the way toward a solid-Ne-based quantum computing platform. p. 4 The work is supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research under Grant No. p. 4 FA9550-20-1- 0220 and the National Science Foundation under Grant No. PHY-2409943, OSI-2228725. The authors thank Kaiwen Zhang, Kater Murch, and Wei Guo for fruitful discussions and comments.

[1] A. Chatterjee, P. Stevenson, S. De Franceschi, A. Morello, N. P. De Leon, and F Kuemmeth

[6] X Zhou G Koolstra X Zhang G Yang X Han B Dizdar X Li R Divan W Guo K W Murch D I Schuster and D Jin

[9] X Li S Zou Q Chen and D Jin

[28] Supplementary materials

--- Page 4 ---

FIG. 3 (a) Schematic illustration of the model showing the variation in solid Ne layer thickness at ρ = R corresponding to the edge of the substrate nanopillar. p. 3 Profile of the resulting effective lateral potential, which varies from −V0 at the center to zero at large distances. p. 3

--- Page 5 ---

FIG. 4 (a) Potential depth −V0 for different L and ∆L. p. 4 Lateral excitation energy ∆U versus R and ∆L for b = 2. p. 40 nm and Eex = 0. p. 2 ∆U and mean radius ρe as functions of Eex with b = 2. p. 40 nm, R = 110 nm, and ∆L = 0. p. 35 nm. Black dashed lines indicate linear trends, highlighting the nonlinear field dependence of ∆U. p. 4

--- Page 6 ---

The lateral trapping potential deepens with increasing ∆L or decreasing L0, as shown in Fig. 4(a). The energy levels U0 and U1 define the two states of a single-electron charge qubit. p. 3 p. 3 The excitation energy ∆U increases as R decreases since it corresponds to the rotational motion of the electron and is primarily determined by the mean radius of the first excited state, ρe = R / ρR12dρ. p. 3 p. 3

--- Page 2 ---

Figure 1(a) illustrates the e-Ne qubit platform, in which a solid neon layer is deposited on a substrate such as niobium (Nb) or silicon (Si). An excess electron above the flat neon surface induces a positive image charge that attracts it back toward the surface. p. 0 This attraction, together with the Pauli-exclusion barrier from the outershell electrons of neon atoms creates a deep trapping potential in the direction perpendicular to the neon surface. p. 0 The main challenge lies in understanding the mechanism of lateral confinement. p. 0

--- Page 1 ---

The paper is 2510.10351. Every sentence must end with a reference token >

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

Electron lateral trapping induced by non-uniform thickness in solid neon layers reveals that engineered thickness variations can generate lateral trapping potentials for electrons. The main findings are that the binding energy for the electron above a 10 nmthick solid Ne layer reaches 44.6 meV on a superconducting substrate and 40.0 meV on a silicon substrate, both markedly exceeding the bulk value of 15.7 meV. Thickness variations on the order of ∆L ∼ 3 nm can induce ground-state energy shifts of approximately 10 meV for the excess electron, revealing a fundamental lateral trapping mechanism arising from thickness nonuniformity.

How the training signal is built

The lateral trapping potential V∥(ρ, Eex) is modeled using a local-thickness approximation (LTA). This smoothly interpolates between a potential depth of −V0(Eex) = WG(L0 − ∆L, Eex) − WG(L0, Eex) near the center (ρ ≪ R) and zero at large distances.

Where the gains come from

The lateral trapping potential deepens with increasing ∆L or decreasing L0, as shown in Fig. 4(a). The energy levels U0 and U1 define the two states of a single-electron charge qubit. The excitation energy ∆U increases as R decreases since it corresponds to the rotational motion of the electron and is primarily determined by the mean radius of the first excited state, ρe = R / ρR12dρ.

The external electric field Vex(z) introduces a shift to the potential depth of approximately eEex∆L ε0/εNe. A positive field (Eex > 0) increases the potential depth, leading to modest changes in ∆U, whereas a negative field (Eex < 0) reduces the depth and leads to a more pronounced shift. The corresponding excitation energy is tuned by ∆U = ħω = ħ p ω20 + β1Eex/me.

The substrate roughness can strongly influence the solidification process near the triple point via the Gibbs–Thomson effect. This effect introduces thickness nonuniformity in the solid layer by shifting the melting temperature via ∆TR = −2γSLVm / rc∆HfTbulk (1). The sign of ∆TR is determined by the curvature direction, causing solidification to initiate preferentially at the bottom of surface depressions.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can predict electron binding energy for solid neon layers of finite thickness by using Equation (6) and Equation (8). This allows for accurate modeling of single-electron charge qubit performance based on layer dimensions.

  2. Improved AI system can model lateral trapping potentials using the local-thickness approximation as described in Equation (14). This enables the prediction of ground state energy shifts based on substrate nanopillar geometry, such as L(rho) = L0 - DeltaL / (1 - rho - Rp(rho - R)) squared + b squared / 2.

  3. Improved AI system can tune lateral trapping via an external electric field by using the derived relationship that the potential depth V0 is approximately shifted by eEex DeltaL epsilon0/epsilonNe. This allows the AI to predict excitation energy changes and identify asymmetric responses under different field polarities, as shown in Figure 4(c).

Sources

Related papers