Integration of Silica in G4CMP for Phonon Simulations: Framework and Tools for Material Integration

arXiv:2510.06595 · physics.comp-ph · Submitted 2025-10-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Integration of Silica in G4CMP for Phonon Simulations".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Superconducting detectors with sub-eV energy resolution have demonstrated success setting limits on Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics due to their unique sensitivity to low-energy events.

Kai: G4CMP, a Geant4-based extension for condensed matter physics, provides a comprehensive toolkit for modeling phonon and charge dynamics in cryogenic materials.

Mira: Framework Introduction The paper introduces a technical formalism to support the superconducting qubit and low-threshold detector community in implementing phonon simulations in custom materials into the G4CMP.

Kai: As a case study, they present results from a detailed analysis of silica phonon transport properties relevant for simulating substrate backgrounds in Beryllium Electron capture in Superconducting Tunnel junctions (BeEST)-style experiments using G4CMP.

Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper, "Integration of Silica in G4CMP for Phonon Simulations: Framework and Tools for Material Integration." Basically, they developed a way to plug silica into G4CMP so you can model the phonon transport through that thermal oxide layer.

Mira: They are setting this up as an example because it relates directly to experiments like Beryllium Electron capture in Superconducting Tunnel junctions, or BeEST experiments seven <ref:2510.06595#pg2,Beryllium Electron capture in Superconducting Tunnel junctions>. The point here is reducing systematic uncertainties when reconstructing those nuclear recoil spectra.

Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, modeling that substrate layer sounds crucial for getting the fidelity right on real hardware four <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: The core claim of this paper is providing a technical formalism to support the superconducting qubit and low-threshold detector community in implementing phonon simulations in custom materials within G4CMP. They also developed Python tools for users to implement their own materials, which they put on the G4CMP repository.

Mira: It moves beyond just using existing models; it gives people the tools to model specific material dynamics, including phonon and charge transport in cryogenic materials four <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Lev: If you're building real hardware, having a framework for custom material modeling is essential because standard libraries often don't handle these specific physics interactions well thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: They use elastic constants as the starting point. These are material-dependent parameters that describe how stress relates to strain in a given medium. They include second-order and third-order elastic constants, which represent linear and nonlinear relationships, respectively.

Mira: That nonlinearity is key because it’s what you need to calculate the Lame parameters for anharmonic downconversion, which is necessary for accurately modeling certain phonon decay modes <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Lev: Calculating those Lame parameters requires knowing both the second-order and third-order elastic constants, which are typically obtained from experimental measurements of bulk materials at room temperature <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Kai: They then use a general formalism to express those Lame parameters as functions of the second-order and third-order elastic constants. Then they apply symmetry to derive expressions specific to alpha quartz, showing calculated Lame parameters for alpha quartz and amorphous silicon dioxide in Table I <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Mira: The paper then dives into anharmonic downconversion, which is about how a longitudinal phonon's energy gets redistributed into two lower energy phonons because the interatomic potential isn't perfectly quadratic <ref:2510.06595#pg4>.

Paper summary: Lev: To model that decay, you need the decay rates for both modes, which means you need those Lame parameters we just discussed to calculate the anharmonic decay rate coefficient A <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: They also mention isotopic scattering, which is when phonons scatter off natural isotopic impurities in a crystal. They treat these mass fluctuations as a small perturbation to the ideal harmonic lattice Hamiltonian <ref:2510.06595#pg4>.

Mira: And they use time-dependent perturbation theory to derive the phonon scattering rate associated with that mechanism <ref:2510.06595#pg4>.

Lev: That perturbation theory approach sounds computationally intensive, and I wonder how much overhead that adds when you try to run it on actual hardware thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: For the phonon density of states, they use specific parameters for implementation into G4CMP. They use relative DOS contributions at one terahertz as zero point five four three for transverse slow, zero point three nine seven for transverse fast, and zero point zero five nine five for longitudinal <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Mira: And they set the maximum acoustic phonon energy at four point two terahertz <ref:2510.06595#pg2>, which is what you need to predict the relative probability of exciting those acoustic modes <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Lev: If you're doing a thermal oxide simulation, calculating that density of states for it sounds like it will be extremely computationally expensive thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: Because of that high computation cost for the thermal oxide, they approximate the DOS values as being equivalent to alpha quartz for the amorphous silica implementation <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Mira: That approximation is what lets them proceed with the amorphous implementation, but it means you're assuming a certain material behavior based on quartz <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Lev: If that approximation impacts your simulation results significantly, that’s a major caveat we need to keep in mind when moving from theory to hardware thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: Then they validate their phonon propagation using what's called phonon caustics. This involves simulating the phonon energy for different crystal orientations and comparing those simulations directly to corresponding bolometer images <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Mira: For alpha quartz, their simulated caustic pattern successfully reproduced bolometer images of two different crystal orientations, specifically the one with crystal direction one bar ten zero zero <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Lev: And for the amorphous case, they found that the intensity only depends on the path length from the phonon source <ref:2510.06595#pg3>. That’s a simpler dependency, which is good for modeling things at scale thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Paper summary: Kai: The result of this validation is that their amorphous implementation allows for modeling background events in the thermal oxide layer, as well as phonon propagation across that layer from events in the silicon substrate <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Mira: So, they've successfully integrated silica into G4CMP to model these complex interactions within a realistic experimental context <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Lev: The implication for hardware is that if you can accurately model the substrate noise using this framework, it helps reduce those systematic uncertainties mentioned earlier <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Kai: So, to wrap up, the paper presents a comprehensive toolkit and framework for simulating phonon dynamics in custom materials like silica inside G4CMP <ref:2510.06595#pg1>.

Mira: And they make that material modeling available on the G4CMP github repository, along with a tutorial for calculating the phonon density of states using QE and phonopy <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Lev: It’s a useful resource for anyone looking to simulate new materials with G4CMP, which is exactly what we need when pushing experimental boundaries thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: The authors also provided their results for alpha quartz and amorphous silicon dioxide, showing the calculated Lame parameters in Table I <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Mira: And they showed that isotopic scattering rates are calculated at one point two four times ten to the negative forty-three seconds cubed for amorphous and nine point six zero times ten to the negative forty-four seconds cubed for alpha quartz <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Lev: Those scattering rates are quite specific, which is good because it gives you concrete numbers to compare against when you try to model real material imperfections thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: The paper shows that the amorphous case demonstrates intensity only dependent on the path length from the phonon source <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Mira: So, even though they had to approximate the density of states for amorphous silica with alpha quartz, they still got a result that allows modeling background events in that layer <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Lev: The main limitation I see is that the DOS approximation means you're not getting the full physics for the thermal oxide, only an equivalent one thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Kai: And they did state that their method doesn't cover everything, but it provides a way to model propagation from events in the silicon substrate across this layer <ref:2510.06595#pg2>.

Mira: So the paper gives us a framework and tools for integrating silica into G4CMP for phonon simulations <ref:2510.06595#pg1>.

Lev: It's a valuable contribution to making these simulations more accessible and repeatable for the community thirty <ref:2510.06595#pg3>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about taking silica and putting it into G4CMP to model how phonons move through that stuff inside a cryogenic setup.

Mira: Exactly. They introduce a new technical framework for the qubit and detector communities so they can actually plug in their custom materials like silica into G4CMP.

Lev: So, it’s building these tools so people can simulate complex phonon dynamics in real materials instead of just using standard models that don't fit the specific physics.

Kai: They did show how to model silica transport for substrate backgrounds in experiments like BeEST using G4CMP as a case study.

Mira: It also developed Python tools that users can use to implement their own materials, which are now on the G4CMP repository.

Lev: The implication here is that researchers can start simulating new material noise sources more realistically, which is important for the error correction side of things.

Kai: The authors used alpha quartz and amorphous silica as examples to show how they handled things like elastic constants and downconversion physics.

Mira: They showed that you have to deal with anharmonic downconversion when you look at how phonons lose energy into two lower energy ones, which requires those specific material parameters.

Lev: And they did tackle isotopic scattering too, using time-dependent perturbation theory to figure out the scattering rates from natural impurities in the crystal.

Kai: The validation part was interesting too; they used phonon caustics to compare their simulated results with actual bolometer images for alpha quartz and amorphous silica orientations.

Mira: For alpha quartz, the simulation matched two different crystal orientations perfectly, but for the amorphous case, it just depended on how far the phonon traveled from where it started.

Lev: So what this means practically is that if you want to model noise in a thermal oxide layer or substrate between your qubits and detectors, this framework gives you a concrete way to do that.

Kai: It provides a pathway for people who are building hardware to simulate those background events more accurately.

Mira: It opens up the door for modeling new materials in cryogenic experiments by giving them the necessary tools and formulas right there.

Lev: We need to see how robust these calculations are when you try to push them beyond the quartz or amorphous silica examples they used.

Colorado School of Mines · Illinois Institute of Technology · Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory · Massachusetts Institute of Technology · Facility for Rare Isotope Beams, Michigan State University

physics.comp-ph

Submitted: 2025-10-08

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures, LTD25 conference proceeding submission, replaced with erratum removed from title since it is the complete updated document, erratum describing changes is on IEEE

DOI: 10.1109/TASC.2026.3651428; 10.1109/TASC.2026.3677456

Code: https://github.com/kelseymh/G4CMP

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 88/100

The gist: Superconducting detectors with sub-eV energy resolution have demonstrated success setting limits on Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics due to their unique sensitivity to low-energy events.

Key concepts

Elastic Constants
These are material-dependent parameters describing how a medium responds to stress and strain. They include second-order constants (linear relationship) and third-order constants (nonlinear relationship), which are crucial for modeling the mechanical behavior of crystals like silica.
Lame Parameters
These parameters ($\mu$, $\lambda$) parameterize the second-order elastic constants. The authors developed a formalism to express these Lame parameters based on third-order constants and symmetries, allowing them to derive specific values for materials like $\alpha$-Quartz.
Anharmonic Downconversion
This process describes how energy from a single longitudinal phonon is redistributed into two lower-energy phonons because the interatomic potential deviates from a simple quadratic form. Modeling the decay rates of these modes is necessary to accurately simulate this energy redistribution.
Phonon Density of States (DOS)
The DOS predicts the probability of exciting different acoustic phonon modes. The authors used specific values for transverse and longitudinal contributions at 1 THz, approximating them with $\alpha$-Quartz data for amorphous silica due to computational constraints.

Terminology

Summary

Superconducting detectors with sub-eV energy resolution have demonstrated success setting limits on Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics due to their unique sensitivity to low-energy events. p. 0

Where the paper says it

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON APPLIED SUPERCONDUCTIVITY, VOL. 8, AUGUST 2021 1 Erratum for Integration of Silica in G4CMP for Phonon Simulations: Framework and Tools for Material Integration Caitlyn Stone-Whitehead1 , Israel Hernandez2,3 , Connor Bray1 , Allison Davenport1 , Spencer Fretwell1 , Abigail Gillespie1 , Joren Husic1 , Mingyu Li4 , Andrew Marino1 , Kyle Leach1,5 , Bismah Rizwan1 , Wouter Van De Pontseele1 , Grace Wagner1 Colorado School of Mines, Department of Physics, CO 80401, USA1 Illinois Institute of Technology, Department of Physics, Chicago, IL 60616, USA2 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, Batavia, IL 60510, USA3 Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Department of Physics, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA4 Facility for Rare Isotope Beams, Michigan State University, 640 S Shaw Lane, East Lansing, 48824, MI, USA5 Abstract—Superconducting detectors with sub-eV energy resolution have demonstrated success setting limits on Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics due to their unique sensitivity to low-energy events.

G4CMP, a Geant4-based extension for condensed matter physics, provides a comprehensive toolkit for modeling phonon and charge dynamics in cryogenic materials. p. 0
Where the paper says it

8, AUGUST 2021 1 Erratum for Integration of Silica in G4CMP for Phonon Simulations: Framework and Tools for Material Integration Caitlyn Stone-Whitehead1 , Israel Hernandez2,3 , Connor Bray1 , Allison Davenport1 , Spencer Fretwell1 , Abigail Gillespie1 , Joren Husic1 , Mingyu Li4 , Andrew Marino1 , Kyle Leach1,5 , Bismah Rizwan1 , Wouter Van De Pontseele1 , Grace Wagner1 Colorado School of Mines, Department of Physics, CO 80401, USA1 Illinois Institute of Technology, Department of Physics, Chicago, IL 60616, USA2 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, Batavia, IL 60510, USA3 Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Department of Physics, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA4 Facility for Rare Isotope Beams, Michigan State University, 640 S Shaw Lane, East Lansing, 48824, MI, USA5 Abstract—Superconducting detectors with sub-eV energy resolution have demonstrated success setting limits on Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics due to their unique sensitivity to low-energy events. G4CMP, a Geant4-based extension for condensed matter physics, provides a comprehensive toolkit for modeling phonon and charge dynamics in cryogenic materials.

Framework Introduction

The paper introduces a technical formalism to support the superconducting qubit and low-threshold detector community in implementing phonon simulations in custom materials into the G4CMP. As a case study, they present results from a detailed analysis of silica phonon transport properties relevant for simulating substrate backgrounds in Beryllium Electron capture in Superconducting Tunnel junctions (BeEST)-style experiments using G4CMP. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This paper introduces a technical formalism to support the superconducting qubit and low-threshold detector community in implementing phonon simulations in custom materials into the G4CMP. As a case study, we present the results of a detailed analysis of silica phonon transport properties relevant for simulating substrate backgrounds in Beryllium Electron capture in Superconducting Tunnel junctions (BeEST)-style experiments using G4CMP.

Additionally, Python-based tools were developed to aid users in implementing their own materials and are available on the G4CMP repository. p. 0
Where the paper says it

As a case study, we present the results of a detailed analysis of silica phonon transport properties relevant for simulating substrate backgrounds in Beryllium Electron capture in Superconducting Tunnel junctions (BeEST)-style experiments using G4CMP. Additionally, Python-based tools were developed to aid users in implementing their own materials and are available on the G4CMP repository.

Elastic Constants and Mode Dependence

Elastic constants are material-dependent parameters that describe the stress-strain relationship in a given medium. They include the second-order elastic constants (SOECs), which represent the linear relationship between stress and strain, and the third-order elastic constants (TOECs), which represent the nonlinear relationship between them. p. 1

Where the paper says it

ELASTIC CONSTANTS AND MODE DEPENDENT SPEED OF SOUND Elastic constants are material-dependent parameters that describe the stress-strain relationship in a given medium. They include the second-order elastic constants (SOECs), which represent the linear relationship between stress and strain, and the thirdorder elastic constants (TOECs), which represent the nonlinear relationship between them.

These values are commonly obtained experimentally from measurements of bulk materials at room temperature. p. 1
Where the paper says it

SOECs and TOECs are of key importance for computing Lame parameters for anharmonic downconversion ´ as well as reproducing phonon caustics. These values are commonly obtained experimentally from measurements of bulk materials at room temperature [8].

The mode-dependent speeds of sound are implemented from experimental results using bulk materials. p. 1
Where the paper says it

For our modeling of silicon dioxide, the SOECs and TOECs are included in [9] and [10]. The mode-dependent speeds of sound are implemented from experimental results using bulk materials [11], [12].

Lame Parameters Derivation

The Lame parameters offer a parameterization of the SOECs (µ, λ). They have developed a general formalism to express the Lame parameters as functions of the SOECs and TOECs (µ, λ, α, β, γ). p. 1

Where the paper says it

LAME´ PARAMETERS The Lame parameters offer a parameterization ´ of the SOECs (µ, λ). We have developed a general formalism to express the Lame parameters as ´ functions of the SOECs and TOECs (µ, λ, α, β, γ).

By subsequently applying the symmetries present in these elastic constants they derive the expressions for the Lame parameters specific to α-Quartz. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We have developed a general formalism to express the Lame parameters as ´ functions of the SOECs and TOECs (µ, λ, α, β, γ). By subsequently applying the symmetries present in these elastic constants [13], we derive the expressions for the Lame parameters, which are ´ specific to α-Quartz.

The calculated Lame parameters for α-Quartz and amorphous silicon dioxide are shown in Table I. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Using the symmetry group to reduce the expression for the Lame constants, the resulting equations ´ are: λ = 1 15 (2C11 + 4C12 + 8C13 − 4C44 + C33 − 2C66) µ = 1 15 (2C11 − C12 − 2C13 + C33 + 6C44 + 3C66) (8) α = (−17C111 + 30C112 + 33C113 + 78C123 − 57C133 − 156C144 + 84C155 − 17C222 + C333 − 12C344)/105 β = (71C111 + 4C112 − 11C113 − 68C123 + 103C133 + 220C144 − 140C155 − 55C222 + 2C333 + 4C344)/210 γ = (−34C111 − 24C112 + 3C113 + 30C123 − 51C133 − 144C144 + 126C155 + 92C222 + 2C333 + 18C344)/210. (9) The calculated Lame parameters for ´ α-Quartz and amorphous silicon dioxide are shown in Table I.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

Using the symmetry group to reduce the expression for the Lame constants, the resulting equations ´ are: λ = 1 15 (2C11 + 4C12 + 8C13 − 4C44 + C33 − 2C66) µ = 1 15 (2C11 − C12 − 2C13 + C33 + 6C44 + 3C66) (8) α = (−17C111 + 30C112 + 33C113 + 78C123 − 57C133 − 156C144 + 84C155 − 17C222 + C333 − 12C344)/105 β = (71C111 + 4C112 − 11C113 − 68C123 + 103C133 + 220C144 − 140C155 − 55C222 + 2C333 + 4C344)/210 γ = (−34C111 − 24C112 + 3C113 + 30C123 − 51C133 − 144C144 + 126C155 + 92C222 + 2C333 + 18C344)/210. (9) The calculated Lame parameters for ´ α-Quartz and amorphous silicon dioxide are shown in Table I.

Anharmonic Downconversion and Scattering

Anharmonic downconversion refers to the redistribution of a longitudinal phonon’s energy into two lower energy phonons due to deviations from the quadratic form of the interatomic potential. The decay rates for both decay modes are required to model this process. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The initial longitudinal phonon’s energy can be redistributed into two transverse phonons or into a longitudinal and a transverse phonon. The decay rates for both decay modes are required to model this process.

Isotopic scattering refers to the scattering of phonons from naturally occurring isotopic impurities in a crystal. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The results of this computation for silicon dioxide are shown in Table I. ISOTOPIC SCATTERING Isotopic scattering refers to the scattering of phonons from naturally occurring isotopic impurities in a crystal.

Treating these mass fluctuations as a perturbation to the ideal harmonic lattice Hamiltonian one can employ time-dependent perturbation theory to derive the phonon scattering rate associated with this mechanism. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Isotopic disorder introduces local mass fluctuations that disrupt the periodicity of the lattice, thereby enabling phonon scattering. Treating these mass fluctuations as a perturbation to the ideal harmonic lattice Hamiltonian, one can employ time-dependent perturbation theory to derive the phonon scattering rate associated with this mechanism [16].

Phonon Density of States

The phonon density of states is necessary for predicting the relative probability of exciting acoustic phonon modes. For implementation into G4CMP the necessary parameters are the relative DOS contributions at 1 THz (transverse slow = 0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

After validation of the DFPT results, the contributions from individual acoustic phonon modes are extracted (Figure 2). For implementation into G4CMP, the necessary parameters are the relative DOS contributions at 1 THz (transverse slow = 0.

543, transverse fast = 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

For implementation into G4CMP, the necessary parameters are the relative DOS contributions at 1 THz (transverse slow = 0. 543, transverse fast = 0.

397, longitudinal = 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

543, transverse fast = 0. 397, longitudinal = 0.

0595) and maximum acoustic phonon energy (ωa = 4. p. 3
Where the paper says it

397, longitudinal = 0. 0595) and maximum acoustic phonon energy (ωa = 4.

2 THz). Due to the extreme computation cost required to calculate the DOS for a thermal oxide and the projected small impact on simulation results the DOS values have been approximated as equivalent to α-Quartz for the amorphous implementation of silica. p. 3
Where the paper says it

0595) and maximum acoustic phonon energy (ωa = 4. Due to the extreme computation cost required to calculate the DOS for a thermal oxide and the projected small impact on simulation results, the DOS values have been approximated as equivalent to α-Quartz for the amorphous implementation of silica.

Validation by Phonon Caustics

Following the standard introduced in [6] a validation of accurate phonon propagation for a given crystal can be performed by simulating phonon energy. Performing the simulation for different crystal orientations we can then directly compare the results to corresponding bolometer images. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Phonon caustics refer to the intensity pattern created on the top of a sample from an isotropic point source of phonons generated at the bottom. Performing the simulation for different crystal orientations, we can then directly compare the results to corresponding bolometer images.

For α-Quartz our simulated caustic pattern was able to reproduce bolometer images [27] of two different crystal orientations (crystal direction [1¯100] shown in Figure 3 and [0001] shown in Figure 4). p. 4
Where the paper says it

The prebuilt example for generating phonon caustics for this validation step can be found on the G4CMP GitHub repository [28]. For α-Quartz, our simulated caustic pattern was able to reproduce bolometer images [27] of two different crystal orientations (crystal direction [1¯100] shown in Figure 3 and [0001] shown in Figure 4).

The amorphous case demonstrates intensity only dependent on the path length from the phonon source. p. 4
Where the paper says it

For α-Quartz, our simulated caustic pattern was able to reproduce bolometer images [27] of two different crystal orientations (crystal direction [1¯100] shown in Figure 3 and [0001] shown in Figure 4). The amorphous case demonstrates intensity only dependent on the path length from the phonon source.

Conclusion and Availability

The resulting amorphous implementation allows for modeling of background events in the thermal oxide layer (amorphous silica) as well as phonon propagation across this layer from events in the Si substrate. Following the analysis and validation reported in this paper the silica materials are now available on the G4CMP github repository for use. p. 4

Where the paper says it

CONCLUSIONS The resulting amorphous implementation allows for modeling of background events in the thermal oxide layer (amorphous silica) as well as phonon propagation across this layer from events in the Si substrate. Following the analysis and validation reported in this paper, the silica materials are now available on the G4CMP github repository for use [29].

Additionally tools are provided from this work for members of the community looking to simulate new materials with G4CMP. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Following the analysis and validation reported in this paper, the silica materials are now available on the G4CMP github repository for use [29]. Additionally, tools are provided from this work for members of the community looking to simulate new materials with G4CMP.

The phonon DOS tutorial using QE and phonopy is located on the G4CMP github repository. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Additionally, tools are provided from this work for members of the community looking to simulate new materials with G4CMP. The phonon DOS tutorial using QE and phonopy is located on the G4CMP github repository.

The G4CMP consortium can aid in supporting this work and providing community access. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The phonon DOS tutorial using QE and phonopy is located on the G4CMP github repository. For those repeating this analysis, the G4CMP consortium can aid in supporting this work and providing community access [30].

Acknowledgements

We thank Ryan Linehan and Mike Kelsey for organizing a community effort to support this work through the G4CMP consortium. We thank the rest of the G4CMP consortium for guiding this work. p. 4

Where the paper says it

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank Ryan Linehan and Mike Kelsey for organizing a community effort to support this work through the G4CMP consortium. We thank the rest of the G4CMP consortium for guiding this work.

CS developed the silica modeling work presented in this paper and IH provided supporting checks. p. 5
Where the paper says it

[27], where the crystal direction [1¯100] is out of page and scan range is ±68. CS developed the silica modeling work presented in this paper and IH provided supporting checks.

CS developed the tutorial for calculating the phonon DOS and ML revised. p. 5
Where the paper says it

CS developed the silica modeling work presented in this paper and IH provided supporting checks. CS developed the tutorial for calculating the phonon DOS and ML revised.

IH led the development of a general formalism for this work. p. 5
Where the paper says it

CS developed the tutorial for calculating the phonon DOS and ML revised. IH led the development of a general formalism for this work.

IH derived a complete formalism for extracting Lame parameters for a given crystal symmetry group and developed the Python implementation. p. 5
Where the paper says it

IH led the development of a general formalism for this work. IH derived a complete formalism for extracting Lame parameters ´ for a given crystal symmetry group and developed the Python implementation.

CS and IH drafted the manuscript. p. 5
Where the paper says it

IH derived a complete formalism for extracting Lame parameters ´ for a given crystal symmetry group and developed the Python implementation. CS and IH drafted the manuscript.

The remaining authors provided feedback that shaped the manuscript. p. 5
Where the paper says it

CS and IH drafted the manuscript. The remaining authors provided feedback that shaped the manuscript.

This work was supported by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation (10. p. 5
Where the paper says it

[27], where the crystal direction [0001] is out of page and scan range is ±68. Betty Moore Foundation (10.

37807/GBMF11571) and the US Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics under award nos. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Betty Moore Foundation (10. 37807/GBMF11571) and the US Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, under award nos.

DE-SC0021245 and DE-SC0023540. p. 5
Where the paper says it

37807/GBMF11571) and the US Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, under award nos. DE-SC0021245 and DE-SC0023540.

This manuscript has been authored by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC under Contract No. p. 5
Where the paper says it

DE-SC0021245 and DE-SC0023540. This manuscript has been authored by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC under Contract No.

DE-AC02-CH11359 with the U. p. 5
Where the paper says it

This manuscript has been authored by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC under Contract No. DE-AC02- 07CH11359 with the U.

S. Department of Energy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON APPLIED SUPERCONDUCTIVITY, VOL. 8, AUGUST 2021 1 Erratum for Integration of Silica in G4CMP for Phonon Simulations: Framework and Tools for Material Integration Caitlyn Stone-Whitehead1 , Israel Hernandez2,3 , Connor Bray1 , Allison Davenport1 , Spencer Fretwell1 , Abigail Gillespie1 , Joren Husic1 , Mingyu Li4 , Andrew Marino1 , Kyle Leach1,5 , Bismah Rizwan1 , Wouter Van De Pontseele1 , Grace Wagner1 Colorado School of Mines, Department of Physics, CO 80401, USA1 Illinois Institute of Technology, Department of Physics, Chicago, IL 60616, USA2 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, Batavia, IL 60510, USA3 Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Department of Physics, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA4 Facility for Rare Isotope Beams, Michigan State University, 640 S Shaw Lane, East Lansing, 48824, MI, USA5 Abstract—Superconducting detectors with sub-eV energy resolution have demonstrated success setting limits on Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics due to their unique sensitivity to low-energy events.

This work was supported by the National Quantum Information Science Research Centers, Quantum Science Center and Illinois Institute of Technology Department of Physics. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Department of Energy. This work was supported by the National Quantum Information Science Research Centers, Quantum Science Center and Illinois Institute of Technology Department of Physics.

References

[1] S. Agostinelli et al. p. 6

Where the paper says it

8, AUGUST 2021 7 REFERENCES [1] S. Agostinelli et al.

, “GEANT4—a simulation toolkit,” Nucl. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Agostinelli et al. , “GEANT4—a simulation toolkit,” Nucl.

Instrum. Methods Phys. p. 6
Where the paper says it

, “GEANT4—a simulation toolkit,” Nucl. Methods Phys.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

, “GEANT4—a simulation toolkit,” Nucl. Methods Phys.

Res. A, vol. 506, no. 3, pp. 250–303, Jul. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Methods Phys. 250–303, Jul.

2003.

[4] M Kelsey et al. p. 4

Where the paper says it

For those repeating this analysis, the G4CMP consortium can aid in supporting this work and providing community access [30]. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank Ryan Linehan and Mike Kelsey for organizing a community effort to support this work through the G4CMP consortium.

, “G4CMP: A Geant4 extension for phonon and charge transport in cryogenic crystals,” Nucl. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Kelsey et al. , “G4CMP: A Geant4 extension for phonon and charge transport in cryogenic crystals,” Nucl.

Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A, vol. 1050, p. 168473, 2023 [Online]. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Methods Phys. 168473, 2023.

Available: https://doi. p. 6
Where the paper says it

168473, 2023. Available: https://doi.

org/10.1016/j.nima-23-168473. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Methods Phys. 168473, 2023.

[29] C Stone-Whitehead, “G4cmp crystalmaps: Silica elastic constants and sound velocities,” https://github. p. 7

Where the paper says it

com/kelseymh/G4CMP/tree/master/ examples/caustics, 2023, accessed: 2025-05-25. Stone-Whitehead, “G4cmp crystalmaps: Silica elastic constants and sound velocities,” https://github.

com/kelseymh/G4CMP/tree/master/CrystalMaps, 2025, includes silica-related material property data files for use with G4CMP. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Stone-Whitehead, “G4cmp crystalmaps: Silica elastic constants and sound velocities,” https://github. com/ kelseymh/G4CMP/tree/master/CrystalMaps, 2025, includes silica-related material property data files for use with G4CMP.

[30] G4CMP Consortium, “G4cmp consortium: Cryogenic phonon modeling toolkit,” https://confluence. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Accessed: 2025-05-25. [30] G4CMP Consortium, “G4cmp consortium: Cryogenic phonon modeling toolkit,” https://confluence.

slac.stanford.edu/x/Qk6fDQ, 2024, sLAC Confluence portal for G4CMP documentation and collaboration. p. 7
Where the paper says it

[30] G4CMP Consortium, “G4cmp consortium: Cryogenic phonon modeling toolkit,” https://confluence. edu/x/Qk6fDQ, 2024, sLAC Confluence portal for G4CMP documentation and collaboration.

Table I Data Summary

The Lame parameters (µ, λ) and TOEC coefficients (α, β, γ) are used to compute the anharmonic decay rate coefficient A. The isotopic scattering rates are calculated for amorphous and α-Quartz silica to be 1. p. 3

Where the paper says it

55 A˚ 3 and 15. Using the above formalism, the isotopic scattering rates are calculated for amorphous and α-Quartz silica to be 1.

24 · 10−43 s3 and 9.60 · 10−44 s3 respectively. p. 3
Where the paper says it

24 · 10−43 s 3 and 9. 60 · 10−44 s 3 respectively.

The volumes per atom were obtained for both α-Quartz and amorphous silica to be 12. p. 3
Where the paper says it

65×10−5 ). The volumes per atom were obtained for both α-Quartz and amorphous silica to be 12.

55 A˚3 and 15.12 A˚3. The calculated Lame parameters for α-Quartz and amorphous silicon dioxide are shown in Table I.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved material simulation capability for superconducting detectors by integrating silica phonon transport modeling into G4CMP, allowing researchers to model the time-dependent propagation of phonons across the substrate’s thermal oxide layer to reduce systematic uncertainties in the reconstruction of nuclear recoil spectra.

  2. Development of custom Python-based tools available on the G4CMP repository that aid users in implementing their own materials, enabling a broader community to simulate new materials and utilize the phonon DOS tutorial using QE and phonopy.

  3. Enhanced analysis of material properties by providing a general formalism to derive Lame parameters from second-order and third-order elastic constants, which allows for the calculation of parameters specific to crystal symmetries such as alpha-Quartz.

  4. Capability to calculate anharmonic downconversion rates for phonons using the Tamura formalism, which requires only the Lame parameters (GPa), speeds of sound (m/s), and density (kg/m3) via a developed Python program.

  5. Accurate prediction of phonon scattering rates due to isotopic impurities by employing time-dependent perturbation theory to derive a rate that exhibits a quartic dependence on phonon energy.

Abstract

Superconducting detectors with sub-eV energy resolution have demonstrated success setting limits on Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics due to their unique sensitivity to low-energy events. G4CMP, a Geant4-based extension for condensed matter physics, provides a comprehensive toolkit for modeling phonon and charge dynamics in cryogenic materials. This paper introduces a technical formalism to support the superconducting qubit and low-threshold detector community in implementing phonon simulations in custom materials into the G4CMP. As a case study, we present the results of a detailed analysis of silica phonon transport properties relevant for simulating substrate backgrounds in Beryllium Electron capture in Superconducting Tunnel junctions (BeEST)-style experiments using G4CMP. Additionally, Python-based tools were developed to aid users in implementing their own materials and are available on the G4CMP repository.

Related papers