Type I + II Seesaw Model in light of the New Neutrino Oscillation Measurements

arXiv:2509.23508 · hep-ph · Submitted 2025-09-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Type I + II Seesaw Model in light of the New Neutrino Oscillation Measurements".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Global analysis of neutrino oscillation data slightly favors normal mass ordering In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking and explore the interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation, adopting normal ordering The study focuses on rare muon decays µ → eγ and µ → 3e and the same-sign dilepton searches at LHC, a canonical signature of a doubly charged scalar Neither the precise value of the sum of the neutrino masses nor alternative cosmological fits significantly changes the theoretical prediction for these rare decays The authors observe an interesting interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation depending on the choices of the vacuum expectation value of the triplet scalar Specifically, they find that µ → 3e is more constraining than µ → eγ, and the µ → 3e decay can yield a lower mass limit of 3 TeV on the doubly charged scalar, surpassing current LHC constraint.

Kai: Model Framework The investigation is conducted within an extended scalar sector that naturally generates a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking.

Mira: The model under consideration is the SU(3)C ⊗ SU(3)L ⊗ U(1)N gauge symmetry, abbreviated as 3-3-1 for short.

Kai: This model can explain the number of fermion generations by having left-handed leptons as SU(3)L triplets and right-handed leptons as SU(3)L singlets.

Title and authors: Kai: We're diving into the title and authors of "Type I + II Seesaw Model in light of the New Neutrino Oscillation Measurements." It’s a very direct way to frame what they are doing—using oscillation data to guide this specific model.

Mira: The authors are Aguilar, Helo, Ota, Queiroz, Suarez, and Rodríguez. They've built on previous work in this area and are providing a fresh look at how the new neutrino oscillation results fit into their proposed structure.

Lev: From my side of things, I’m interested in how they connect the structure of the mass matrices derived from this model to observable rates for these decays and collider signatures.

Kai: Yeah, so what they are doing is taking a specific set of neutrino oscillation parameters—they conservatively adopt Pmν equals zero point zero six eV to be consistent with Planck and DESI measurements—and seeing how that value impacts their conclusions about the scalar masses.

Mira: They are extending previous studies by providing this fresh perspective on the three-three-one model, which brings together the type I and type II seesaw mechanisms using an SU(three)L sextet scalar <ref:2509.23508#pg1>.

Lev: The key thing for me is how they treat the bounds of lepton flavor violation processes, which differs from what was discussed in older literature.

Kai: So we’re talking about how this model, when you plug in those neutrino mass constraints, dictates the allowed regions for new physics signals in both rare decays and at the LHC.

The paper's summary: Mira: The paper summarizes its investigation by showing that when they adopt the neutrino mass constraint of zero point zero six eV, they get a specific picture for the masses of those doubly and singly charged scalars that come from this scalar sextet.

Kai: They report their results in terms of these masses, and they are running parallel to that by studying the doubly charged Higgs bosons that decay promptly into same-sign charged leptons in the context of LHC searches.

Lev: So the summary is basically mapping out how the structure of this model dictates what those physical masses should be based on those neutrino constraints, and then checking if those predicted masses fit within current LHC limits.

Mira: They explicitly state that their goal is to investigate the interplay between lepton flavor violation and collider physics when you use this specific framework.

Kai: It’s not just about calculating a number; it’s about seeing how different parts of the theory—the neutrino sector, the scalar sector, and the collider signals—all influence each other under one set of assumptions.

Lev: And they point out that these results differ from some existing literature, which is important because it means we need to re-evaluate those previous findings in light of this new analysis.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Now for the improvements the paper suggests. They are trying to tighten up their predictions by incorporating more recent neutrino oscillation parameters from global fits, which leads to more reliable branching ratio estimates for muon decays.

Mira: They've also enhanced the constraint analysis by explicitly linking those lepton flavor violation bounds to the vacuum expectation value of that scalar triplet, denoted as versus eleven.

Lev: That means they can determine whether the constraints coming from lepton flavor violation can actually be stronger than what comes from the colliders, depending on that specific value of versus eleven.

Kai: It’s a lot of work to tie those LFV bounds directly to that vacuum expectation value because it changes the entire parameter space we have to consider.

Mira: They also provide a way to plot the branching ratios for both muon decay modes as functions of the doubly charged scalar mass, denoted as MS plus plus.

Lev: That’s useful for us because it lets us visually assess which decay mode provides a stronger constraint than mu to e gamma or if one is better for constraining versus eleven.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up the paper "Type I + II Seesaw Model in light of the New Neutrino Oscillation Measurements," they show that muon decay to three electrons, which is mu to three e, ends up being the best lepton flavor violating probe for this specific model.

Mira: They emphasize that the size of those lepton flavor violation decays is strongly tied to the neutrino mass spectrum and parameters, as shown by their equations.

Lev: I’d add that they show how mu to e gamma provides a stronger constraint than the LHC when versus eleven equals one electron volt. That’s a concrete comparison for our experimentalists.

Kai: So essentially, this paper solidifies that we need to keep looking at these rare decays, especially mu to three e, because they are really constraining this type of seesaw model.

Mira: It gives us a clearer picture of how the neutrino sector parameters directly dictate the observable signals in both flavor violation and direct collider searches.

Lev: And it leaves us with a lot to think about regarding how these theoretical predictions compare against what we might actually measure at a future experiment.

Maria Aguilar, Juan Carlos Helo, Toshihiko Ota, Farinaldo S. Queiroz, David Suarez, Amanda Rodríguez

Departamento de Fósica teorica e Experimental, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte · International Institute of Physics, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Campus Universitario · Millennium Institute for Subatomic Physics at High-Energy Frontier (SAPHIR) · Departamento de Fósica, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de La Serena · Departamento de Fósica, Universidad Tecnica Federico Santa Mar ía

hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-09-27

Updated: 2026-11-03

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 74/100

The gist: Global analysis of neutrino oscillation data slightly favors normal mass ordering In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism…

Key concepts

Type I + II Seesaw Mechanism
This mechanism combines two ways to generate neutrino masses. Type I involves heavy right-handed neutrinos and Type II involves scalar triplets. In this model, a combination of these mechanisms arises after spontaneous symmetry breaking, providing a natural way to explain why active neutrinos have mass.
Extended Scalar Sector (3-3-1)
The model uses an extended gauge symmetry (SU(3)C $\otimes$ SU(3)L $\otimes$ U(1)N). This structure is used to naturally account for the three generations of fermions. The masses of charged particles are generated through three specific scalar triplets ($\chi$, $\eta$, and $\rho$) within this framework.
Lepton Flavor Violation (LFV)
LFV refers to processes where leptons change their flavor, such as a muon decaying into an electron and a photon. These decays are forbidden in the Standard Model but are possible in extensions like this one. They serve as crucial probes for physics beyond the Standard Model.
Doubly Charged Scalar
This is a specific particle predicted by the model that carries two units of electric charge. Searches for its production and decay, particularly into same-sign dileptons at the LHC, provide strong constraints on its mass. The study uses these collider signatures to limit the possible parameter space of the theory.

Terminology

Summary

Global analysis of neutrino oscillation data slightly favors normal mass ordering In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking and explore the interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation, adopting normal ordering The study focuses on rare muon decays µ → eγ and µ → 3e and the same-sign dilepton searches at LHC, a canonical signature of a doubly charged scalar Neither the precise value of the sum of the neutrino masses nor alternative cosmological fits significantly changes the theoretical prediction for these rare decays The authors observe an interesting interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation depending on the choices of the vacuum expectation value of the triplet scalar Specifically, they find that µ → 3e is more constraining than µ → eγ, and the µ → 3e decay can yield a lower mass limit of 3 TeV on the doubly charged scalar, surpassing current LHC constraint. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking and explore the interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation, adopting normal ordering. In particular, we focus on the rare muon decays µ → eγ and µ → 3e and the same-sign dilepton searches at LHC, a canonical signature of a doubly charged scalar.

Model Framework

The investigation is conducted within an extended scalar sector that naturally generates a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking. The model under consideration is the SU(3)C ⊗ SU(3)L ⊗ U(1)N gauge symmetry, abbreviated as 3-3-1 for short. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We are particularly interested in the model with the SU(3)C ⊗ SU(3)L ⊗ U(1)N gauge symmetry [31– 36], 3-3-1 for short. The model can nicely explain the reason why the number of fermion generations is three; The gauge anomalies are absent only if there is a multiple of three families in their fermion spectrum, and there is no room for more than three fermion generations with the consideration of the asymptotic freedom [37, 38].

This model can explain the number of fermion generations by having left-handed leptons as SU(3)L triplets and right-handed leptons as SU(3)L singlets. p. 1
Where the paper says it

MODEL OVERVIEW In the SU(3)C ⊗ SU(3)L ⊗ U(1)N model, 3-3-1 for short, the left-handed chiral fermions in this model are triplets in a fundamental representation of SU(3)L, while the righthanded fermions remain as singlets. For example, left-handed leptons are SU(3)L triplets ψaL =   νa ea Nc a   L ∼ (1, 3, −1/3), (1) where a = 1, 2, 3.

The mass spectrum for charged fermions is generated via three scalar triplets, denoted by χ, η, and ρ. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Left-handed quarks of the first two families are SU(3)L anti-triplets QαL =   dα −uα Dα   L ∼ (3, 3 ∗ , 0), (3) where α = 1, 2, while the third generation of left-handed quarks is a SU(3)L triplet Q3L =   u3 d3 U   L ∼ (3, 3, 1/3), (4) The right-handed quarks transform as uαR ∼(3, 1, 2/3), (5) dαR ∼(3, 1, −1/3), (6) DαR ∼(3, 1, −1/3), (7) u3R ∼(3, 1, 2/3), (8) d3R ∼(3, 1, −1/3), (9) UR ∼(3, 1, −1/3). (10) The mass spectrum for the charged fermions in the model is generated via the following three scalar triplets χ =   χ 0 1 χ − 2 χ 0 3   ∼ (1, 3, −1/3), (11) η =   η 0 1 η − 2 η 0 3   ∼ (1, 3, −1/3), (12) ρ =   ρ + 1 ρ 0 2 ρ + 3   ∼ (1, 3, 2/3).

Seesaw Mechanism Details

The introduction of a scalar sextet leads to a combination of the type I and type II seesaw mechanisms. After spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB), the scalar sextet breaks down into a scalar triplet, a scalar doublet, and a singlet. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this study, we show that the introduction of a scalar sextet interestingly gives rise to a combination of the type I and type II seesaw mechanisms. After spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB), the scalar sextet breaks down to a scalar triplet and a scalar doublet, which yield the type I + II seesaw mechanism together with the right-handed neutrinos in the SU(3)L triplet fermions.

This setup yields a Majorana mass term for active neutrinos via the Yukawa Lagrangian L = fνab(ψaL)m(ψc bL)nSmn + h. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(32) After S 0 33 gets a vev, Λ, the scalar sextet breaks into a SU(2)L triplet, a SU(2)L doublet and a SU(2)L singlet S → S1(1, 3, −2) + S2(1, 2, 1) + S3(1, 1, 0), (33) where S1 = S 0 11 S − 12 S − 12 S −− 22 , (34) S2 = S 0 13 S − 23 , (35) S3 =S 0 33 . (36) gives a Majorana mass term for active neutrinos via the Yukawa Lagrangian L = f ν ab(ψaL)m(ψ c bL)nSmn + h.

c. Assuming v2s13Λ ≪ vs11, a type II seesaw dominance setup is found, where the mass matrix for active neutrinos reduces to (mν)ab = √2vs11(fν)ab. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Assuming v 2 s13 Λ ≪ vs11 we find a type II seesaw dominance setup. Then the mass matrix for active neutrinos reduces to (mν )ab = √ 2vs11(f ν )ab .

Collider and LFV Constraints

The constraints from collider physics are derived from the same-sign dilepton searches at the LHC, which are a clear signature of a doubly charged scalar. The most updated limit imposes MS±± > 856 GeV for a doubly charged scalar decaying mainly into muon pairs. p. 3

Where the paper says it

As electrons, muons, and taus are subject to different detector efficiencies, the limit changes a bit according to the final leptons. In our work, we will adopt the limit MS±± > 856 GeV [64] found for a doubly charged scalar decaying mainly into muon pairs (53%), and only (1%) into electrons, which is our case.

In contrast, the LFV processes µ → eγ and µ → 3e are powerful probes of physics beyond the Standard Model. p. 3
Where the paper says it

LEPTON FLAVOR VIOLATION The LFV processes are one of the most powerful probes for physics beyond the SM, because they are strictly prohibited in the SM and also strongly suppressed in the SM extended with neutrino masses. In this study, we focus on µ → eγ and µ → 3e processes.

The branching ratio for µ → 3e is found to be BR(µ → 3e) = (fν†fν)eµ/2G2FM4S±±. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Both the singly and the doubly charged scalars contribute to the µ → eγ process, and the ratio of those two contributions is determined with their masses as shown in Eq. Differing from µ → eγ, only the doubly charged scalar field mediates the µ → 3e process, and its branching ratio is found to be BR(µ → 3e) = (f ν†f ν )eµ 2 G2 FM4 S±± .

Conclusion on Probes

The study concludes that µ → 3e is and will be the best lepton flavor violating probe for this model. The size of the LFV decays is strongly tied to the neutrino mass spectrum and parameters, as shown by Eq. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The upper (lower) plot corresponds to the benchmark #1 (#2) for the neutrino oscillation parameters, which is found at Tab. Therefore, the size of the LFV decays is strongly tied to the neutrino mass spectrum and parameters.

(44). The branching ratios for both LFV processes are plotted as functions of MS±± in FIGs. p. 5
Where the paper says it

depend on vs11 as a direct result of Eq. The branching ratios for both the LFV processes are plotted as functions of MS±± in FIGs.

1-2. The results show that µ → eγ provides a stronger constraint than the LHC when vs11 = 1 eV. p. 5
Where the paper says it

In all the plots, the blue and red lines correspond to the theoretical predictions for vs11 = {1, 100} eV. Assuming vs11 = 1 eV, we can conclude that µ → eγ provides a stronger constraint than the LHC, as seen in FIG.

Acknowledgments

The work acknowledges several funding sources including the Simons Foundation, FAPESP Grants, CNPQ Grants, and ANID-Millennium Science Initiative Program. The work of J. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Global analysis of neutrino oscillation data slightly favors normal mass ordering. In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking and explore the interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation, adopting normal ordering.

C.H. is supported by ANID FONDECYT regular No. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The work of J. is supported by ANID FONDECYT regular No.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The work of J. is supported by ANID FONDECYT regular No.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The work of J. is supported by ANID FONDECYT regular No.

1241685. The work of T. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Global analysis of neutrino oscillation data slightly favors normal mass ordering. In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking and explore the interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation, adopting normal ordering.

O. is supported by ANID FONDECYT regular No.1250343. The work of A. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Global analysis of neutrino oscillation data slightly favors normal mass ordering. In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking and explore the interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation, adopting normal ordering.

R. is supported by ANID FONDECYT regular No.1230110.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved LFV prediction calculation accuracy by incorporating updated neutrino oscillation parameters from recent global fits, as shown in Table I, leading to more reliable branching ratio estimates for muon decays. The system can now calculate BR(mu -> eγ) and BR(mu -> 3e) based on the two benchmark sets provided.

  2. Enhanced constraint analysis by explicitly linking LFV bounds to the vacuum expectation value of the scalar triplet, vs11, allowing the AI to determine whether the constraints on the parameter space that come from LFV can be stronger than the ones from colliders depending on the vacuum expectation value of the neutral field in the scalar triplet, vs11.

  3. Optimized comparison between theoretical predictions and experimental limits by plotting branching ratios as functions of the doubly charged scalar mass (MS++), enabling direct visual assessment of which decay mode provides a stronger constraint than µ → eγ or the best lepton flavor violating probe for this model.

  4. Improved ability to assess model sensitivity by quantifying how branching ratios change under different neutrino mass parameters, specifically noting that The branching ratios for both the LFV processes are plotted as functions of MS±± in FIGs. 1-2.

  5. Refined understanding of parameter dependence by identifying that the size of the LFV decays is strongly tied to the neutrino mass spectrum and parameters, allowing for more nuanced interpretation when comparing results across different benchmark sets.

Abstract

Global analysis of neutrino oscillation data slightly favors normal mass ordering. In this work, we investigate an extended scalar sector that naturally gives rise to a type I + II seesaw mechanism after spontaneous symmetry breaking and explore the interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation, adopting normal ordering. In particular, we focus on the rare muon decays μ to e γ and μ to 3e and the same-sign dilepton searches at LHC, a canonical signature of a doubly charged scalar. We conclude that neither the precise value of the sum of the neutrino masses, taken from DESI data that favors sum m ν=0.07 eV, nor alternative cosmological fits which prefer a more relaxed limit sum m ν=0.1 eV, significantly changes the theoretical prediction for these rare decays. However, we observe an interesting interplay between collider physics and lepton flavor violation. In particular, we find that μ to 3e is more constraining than μ to eγ. The μ to 3e decay can yield a lower mass limit of 3 TeV on the doubly charged scalar, surpassing current LHC constraints in a dominant type II seesaw or in a mixed type I+II scenario. Nevertheless, LFV does not strongly constrain the dominant type I seesaw scenario.

Sources

Related papers