Where Are the Rates? Derivative-Implied Interest Rates in Cryptocurrency Markets
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantitative Finance. The day in quantitative finance: models of markets, risk and prices.
Ruth: I'm Ruth.
Warren: And I'm Warren, here with Iris.
Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Where Are the Rates? Derivative-Implied Interest Rates in Cryptocurrency Markets".
Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. In this paper, mathematical tools are used to construct yield curves for cryptocurrencies by leveraging data from highly developed cryptocurrency derivatives markets because fixed-rate lending and bonds are almost nonexistent as of early 2025 Historical Context of Interest Rates Yield curves in traditional finance require access to market prices for an issuer’s bonds across a range of maturities, which is difficult to obtain in new currencies without a developed bond market The concept of the yield curve is modern, having evolved from ancient credit systems where interest rates were set by legal maxima such as those found in Sumerian and Babylonian documents In Rome, normal interest rates typically ranged from 4% to 6%, although they could rise to the legal maximum during times of crisis The medieval period saw the emergence of a term structure of interest rates, with short-term maturities reflecting trade fairs and long-term instruments like life annuities By the end of the 19th century, a British yield curve could be reconstructed, showing high volatility in short-term rates and structural decline in long-term rates The goal is to reverse classical reasoning by replicating the payoff of zero-coupon bonds using existing cryptocurrency derivatives, specifically inverse options and inverse futures with fixed maturities The approach involves turning the call–put parity relationship into a synthetic zero-coupon bond price equation (Eq.
Ruth: 1) and using an inverse futures contract to replicate a zero-coupon bond in the cryptocurrency The estimation procedure minimizes a weighted sum of squared Euclidean distances between option prices and the replicated payoffs to obtain estimators for zero-coupon bond prices The resulting interest rates are then computed using the formula rbT−t,Cet:= −1/T−t log ZCcCt(T) Empirical Results and Findings The study computes annualized implied yield curves for Deribit USD and BTC based on BTC inverse option data, showing a downward-sloping structure in the USD rates during volatile periods The implied rates for BTC remain close to zero across maturities, consistent with Bitcoin not intrinsically bearing interest In contrast, the implied rates for ETH fluctuate around zero throughout the observation period, which is surprising given its non-negligible staking yield of around 2% The differences between USD rates inferred from BTC and ETH inverse option data are frequently positive, with an average spread of approximately 1%, which decreases with the tenor Market Dynamics and Risk Proxies The analysis uses Random Sample Consensus (RANSAC) to remove outliers from the option data by fitting a regression model (Eq.
Title and authors: Ruth: Now let's talk about what this paper is actually trying to do, focusing on the title, "Where Are the Rates? Derivative-Implied Interest Rates in Cryptocurrency Markets." It’s a direct question about where these rates even exist when you don't have traditional bonds.
Warren: And the authors are Philippe Bergault, Sébastien Bieber, Olivier Guéant, and Wenkai Zhang <ref:2509.03964#pg1> They bring different expertise to this problem, which is always a good thing.
Iris: They are combining economic thinking on markets with quantitative methods from derivatives pricing <ref:2509.03964#pg1> It’s an attempt to build a new estimation framework for crypto yields.
Ruth: They propose using the payoffs of zero-coupon bonds, which you can't trade directly in crypto, by looking at derivative prices instead <ref:2509.03964#pg2> That's the main mechanism they are proposing to solve the bond market problem.
Warren: The implication is that even without a traditional bond market structure, we have enough data in derivatives to infer a structure for interest rates across different time horizons <ref:2509.03964#pg1> It suggests the concept of a yield curve isn't purely dependent on existing bond markets.
Iris: They are essentially building a synthetic bond price equation using call put parity and inverse futures, which is a clever way to create an estimate <ref:2509.03964#pg3> It's an identification strategy based on pricing relationships.
The paper's summary: Ruth: To summarize what they did, the paper takes the goal of constructing yield curves for cryptocurrencies and proposes an alternative method that relies on derivative prices <ref:2509.03964#pg2> They use inverse options and inverse futures with fixed maturities to replicate zero-coupon bonds <ref:2509.03964#pg3>
Warren: The core of their calculation is turning call put parity into a synthetic zero-coupon bond price equation, and then using an inverse futures contract to model a zero-coupon bond in crypto <ref:2509.03964#pg3> This is the quantitative heart of the work.
Iris: The estimation procedure involves minimizing a weighted sum of squared Euclidean distances between option prices and the payoffs of those replicated bonds to get their estimators for zero-coupon bond prices <ref:2509.03964#pg3> This is how they turn noisy market data into a usable yield curve estimate.
Ruth: The empirical findings show that when they apply this to Deribit USD and BTC, the implied rates exhibit a downward slope during volatile periods <ref:2509.03964#pg1> They also note that the BTC rates stay close to zero across maturities, while ETH rates fluctuate around zero despite its staking yield <ref:2509.03964#pg1>
Warren: The specific finding they highlight is the average spread between USD rates inferred from BTC and ETH inverse option data which is about one percent and shrinks with maturity <ref:2509.03964#pg1> This spread serves as a risk proxy for platform-specific differences.
The paper's improvements: Ruth: The authors suggest several ways to improve this approach, essentially suggesting how they could take their initial findings and make them more robust or applicable <ref:2509.03964#pg1> They mention using Random Sample Consensus to remove outliers from the option data by fitting a regression model <ref:2509.03964#pg1>
Warren: That RANSAC step is important because derivative data can be messy, so cleaning that noise should help stabilize the estimation of those zero-coupon bond prices <ref:2509.03964#pg1> It’s about making the input cleaner for the math.
Iris: They also suggest that they could use this methodology to identify distinct market regimes by analyzing how these implied yield curves shift over time <ref:2509.03964#pg1> This allows for regime-specific risk assessment, which is a big practical step forward.
Ruth: And they propose another improvement involves validating the consistency of these rates by comparing them against on-chain lending benchmarks like Aave v3 USDC lending rates <ref:2509.03964#pg1> This checks the economic relevance of what their model spits out.
Warren: That comparison to on-chain data is interesting because it grounds the theoretical derivative estimates in actual, observable crypto lending activity rather than just market prices <ref:2509.03964#pg1> It adds a layer of real-world validation.
Conclusion: Ruth: So wrapping up the "Where Are the Rates? Derivative-Implied Interest Rates in Cryptocurrency Markets" paper, they've shown that we can construct yield curves even in markets that lack traditional bonds by using derivative data <ref:2509.03964#pg1> The key is using call put parity to build synthetic bond prices and then estimating the rates from those prices.
Warren: They found that while Bitcoin doesn't seem to bear intrinsic interest, Ethereum's implied rates are still moving, and the spread between BTC and ETH USD rates provides a measure of risk divergence <ref:2509.03964#pg1> The one percent average spread is something to watch as it changes with maturity.
Iris: For me, the most important part is how they suggested using time series analysis on those implied yield curves to spot market shifts, like the volatility seen in November two thousand twenty-two <ref:2509.03964#pg1> This allows us to assess risk not just at a single point but across market cycles.
Ruth: It’s a practical tool that lets us look beyond just the asset itself and see how different parts of the ecosystem are pricing risk relative to each other <ref:2509.03964#pg1> The implication is that we can start using these derivative-based estimates to gauge market dynamics better.
Warren: It's a solid framework for when traditional bond data just isn't available, pushing us toward alternative risk measurement techniques in digital finance <ref:2509.03964#pg1> We'll keep an eye on how this method performs under different market conditions.
Iris: I think the paper sets a clear path for future work by showing exactly what kind of data and identification strategy is needed to make these derivative-implied rates reliable for broader use <ref:2509.03964#pg1>
Ruth: That's all we have time for on this paper today, "Where Are the Rates? Derivative-Implied Interest Rates in Cryptocurrency Markets." We've seen how they use derivatives to build yield curves where bonds don't exist.
Warren: Next up, we look at another paper that tackles a very different problem in the quantitative world.
Université Paris Dauphine-PSL · LCH SA
q-fin.GN
Submitted: 2025-09-04
Updated: 2026-11-17
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 58/100
The gist: In this paper, mathematical tools are used to construct yield curves for cryptocurrencies by leveraging data from highly developed cryptocurrency derivatives markets because fixed-rate lending and…
Key concepts
- Yield Curve
- A yield curve shows the relationship between different interest rates for a single asset across various time periods. In traditional finance, it helps determine the cost of borrowing or lending money over time. This paper adapts this concept to cryptocurrencies where traditional bonds are scarce.
- Inverse Options and Futures
- These are specific cryptocurrency derivatives used in the study. They allow researchers to mimic the payoff structure of a zero-coupon bond by using existing option prices and futures contracts. This technique is crucial because it allows for the estimation of bond prices without needing actual fixed-rate lending markets.
- Call-Put Parity
- This is a financial relationship that links the price of an option to the underlying asset's spot price and the risk-free interest rate. The paper uses this parity relationship to create a synthetic equation that helps convert derivative prices into estimates for zero-coupon bond prices in the crypto market.
Terminology
Summary
In this paper, mathematical tools are used to construct yield curves for cryptocurrencies by leveraging data from highly developed cryptocurrency derivatives markets because fixed-rate lending and bonds are almost nonexistent as of early 2025
Historical Context of Interest Rates
Yield curves in traditional finance require access to market prices for an issuer’s bonds across a range of maturities, which is difficult to obtain in new currencies without a developed bond market The concept of the yield curve is modern, having evolved from ancient credit systems where interest rates were set by legal maxima such as those found in Sumerian and Babylonian documents In Rome, normal interest rates typically ranged from 4% to 6%, although they could rise to the legal maximum during times of crisis The medieval period saw the emergence of a term structure of interest rates, with short-term maturities reflecting trade fairs and long-term instruments like life annuities By the end of the 19th century, a British yield curve could be reconstructed, showing high volatility in short-term rates and structural decline in long-term rates
Methodology for Rate Estimation
The goal is to reverse classical reasoning by replicating the payoff of zero-coupon bonds using existing cryptocurrency derivatives, specifically inverse options and inverse futures with fixed maturities The approach involves turning the call–put parity relationship into a synthetic zero-coupon bond price equation (Eq. 1) and using an inverse futures contract to replicate a zero-coupon bond in the cryptocurrency The estimation procedure minimizes a weighted sum of squared Euclidean distances between option prices and the replicated payoffs to obtain estimators for zero-coupon bond prices The resulting interest rates are then computed using the formula rbT−t,Cet:= −1/T−t log ZCcCt(T)
Empirical Results and Findings
The study computes annualized implied yield curves for Deribit USD and BTC based on BTC inverse option data, showing a downward-sloping structure in the USD rates during volatile periods The implied rates for BTC remain close to zero across maturities, consistent with Bitcoin not intrinsically bearing interest In contrast, the implied rates for ETH fluctuate around zero throughout the observation period, which is surprising given its non-negligible staking yield of around 2% The differences between USD rates inferred from BTC and ETH inverse option data are frequently positive, with an average spread of approximately 1%, which decreases with the tenor
Market Dynamics and Risk Proxies
The analysis uses Random Sample Consensus (RANSAC) to remove outliers from the option data by fitting a regression model (Eq.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Data-driven Yield Curve Construction: The AI system can construct synthetic zero-coupon curves for cryptocurrencies by leveraging existing derivative prices using a minimization problem involving call put parity and inverse futures, as described in Section 3.
-
Risk Proxy Calibration: The system can infer platform-specific risk by calculating the spread between implied USD rates inferred from BTC and ETH data, which serves as a proxy for platform-specific risk, based on the finding that
the differences between USD rates inferred from BTC and ETH inverse option data do not average to zero.
-
Market Regime Identification: The AI can identify distinct market regimes by analyzing the time series of implied yield curves, recognizing shifts such as those observed in
November 2022 – a highly volatile period marked by the collapses of FTX and Terra LUNA,
allowing for regime-specific risk assessment. -
Yield Consistency Validation: The system can validate the consistency between different asset types by comparing derived interest rates with on-chain lending benchmarks, such as Aave v3 USDC lending rates, to assess
the economic relevance of the implied rates extracted through our methodology.
Abstract
In traditional finance, liquid markets for bonds, interest rate swaps, and other interest rate derivatives provide a basis for constructing yield curves. In the cryptocurrency ecosystem, lending and staking yields are predominantly variable and adjust over short timescales, whereas fixed-rate instruments remain scarce and, as of early 2026, widely accepted benchmark yield curves were still lacking. We jointly infer USD and cryptocurrency discount factors from inverse options and futures by combining put-call parity with the futures basis in a closed-form estimator. We introduce a novel RANSAC-based quote filter tailored to cryptocurrency market microstructure. We apply the method to hourly BTC and ETH derivatives data from Deribit between February 2023 and February 2026. The two underlying assets imply broadly similar USD term structures, with rates averaging approximately 8% per year and rising during the 2024 cryptocurrency rallies. Implied BTC and ETH rates are typically close to zero across the maturities considered, despite positive Aave lending yields and ETH staking yields. Implied USD rates co-move with Aave USDC rates but exhibit persistent differences. These findings suggest limited integration between derivatives markets and decentralized lending and staking.
Sources
- Optimal risk-aware interest rates for decentralized lending protocols
- SoK: Liquid Staking Tokens (LSTs) and Emerging Trends in Restaking
- DeFi Protocols for Loanable Funds: Interest Rates, Liquidity and Market Efficiency
Related papers
- Amortized Neural Filtering for Calibrated Posteriors in Statistical Arbitrage
- Multi-Jurisdictional Legal Identity Assurance for Capability Gating: A Design-Science Proposal for Tiered, Reusable Identity Assurance of Natural, Juridical, and Machine Entities
- A Financial Brain Scan of the LLM
- Decomposable Reward Modeling and Realistic Environment Design for Reinforcement Learning-Based Forex Trading
- Stablecoin Integration and Stress Transmission Through Crypto-Asset Service Providers: Evidence from Austria
- Tempting the Agent: The Economics of Reputation without Persistent Identity in AI Agent Markets