Trigonal warping enables linear optical spectroscopy in single-valley superconductors
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Trigonal warping enables linear optical spectroscopy in single-valley superconductors".
Title and authors: Kai: This paper's title is "Trigonal warping enables linear optical spectroscopy in single-valley superconductors," and the authors are Benjamin A. Levitan and Etienne Lantagne-Hurtubise.
Mira: So what does that title really mean? It’s telling us that the specific geometric feature of trigonal warping allows us to use linear optics to look at superconductivity in materials with only one valley involved.
Lev: That sounds like a significant leap because typically, crystal symmetries are what impose selection rules that keep these collective modes optically dark.
Kai: Right, and the paper is focusing on how this warping breaks those rules for specific modes like Bardasis-Schrieffer and clapping modes.
The paper's summary: Mira: They summarize it by saying that when multiple pairing channels compete for the title of the superconducting ground state, collective orderparameter modes generically emerge, like the BaSch or clapping modes.
Kai: And the point is that these fluctuations carry valuable information about those uncondensed pairing channels, which is what we want to know.
Lev: So they are using these optical couplings as a way to signal the presence of pairing channels that aren't dominating the ground state.
Mira: They show that trigonal warping enables this visibility in both longitudinal and Hall optical responses when pairing is around a single Fermi surface.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The improvement they suggest is using kinetic inductance measurements as a probe, predicting a kinetic inductance on the order of tens of nanohenries at characteristic frequencies of a few gigahertz for rhombohedral graphene.
Mira: They also highlight that if you lift the degeneracy between pairing channels—if g1 and g2 are different—the clapping mode frequency is shifted up from sqrt(two Delta mf) <ref:2508.09387#pg1>.
Lev: And they predict that by analyzing the frequency dependence of the longitudinal and transverse conductivity near resonance, you get a real part with a square-root onset.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up on this paper, the main implication is that trigonal warping opens up new windows into studying exotic superconducting collective modes using linear optical spectroscopy.
Mira: It confirms that these modes are not optically dark because of crystal symmetry; trigonal warping can fix that and make them visible.
Lev: For us in error correction research, it suggests that if we can engineer a system with this specific symmetry breaking—the trigonal warping—we might be able to use optical probes to detect the presence of uncondensed pairing channels.
Department de physique · Institut quantique, Universite de Sherbrooke
cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.str-el
Submitted: 2025-08-12
Updated: 2026-01-30
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 114, L080507 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/1bmy-6yp4
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 69/100
The gist: Trigonal warping enables linear optical spectroscopy in single-valley superconductors The results suggest that rhombohedral graphene multilayers…
Key concepts
- Collective Orderparameter Modes
- These are emergent states that appear when multiple pairing channels compete to define the superconducting ground state. They signal the presence of uncondensed pairing channels and carry information about the host superconductor's nature.
- Trigonal Warping
- This specific crystal symmetry in materials like rhombohedral graphene breaks the antisymmetry in electron velocity between Cooper pairs. This breaking is key because it enables optical couplings between collective modes and light, a process that doesn't require an external field or supercurrent.
- Clapping Mode vs. BaSch Mode
- These are specific collective modes arising from different pairing channel interactions. The clapping mode reverses the pair's angular momentum, while the BaSch mode changes it by two units without changing its direction, allowing distinction through magnetic field coupling.
Terminology
Summary
Trigonal warping enables linear optical spectroscopy in single-valley superconductors The results suggest that rhombohedral graphene multilayers, which are believed to host the required ingredients, might offer an ideal setting for the study of exotic superconducting collective modes
Introduction to Collective Modes
When multiple pairing channels compete for the title of superconducting ground state, collective orderparameter modes generically emerge For example, in an s-wave superconductor, subdominant attraction in a d-wave channel can bind an in-gap mode corresponding to d-wave pair fluctuations, known as a Bardasis-Schrieffer (BaSch) mode [1] Similarly, when a superconductor breaks time-reversal symmetry (T), fluctuations in the time-reversed partner to the condensed channel manifest as generalizations of the clapping mode found in superfluid 3He [2] By signaling the presence of uncondensed pairing channels, collective modes carry valuable information about their host superconductor [3–36]. However, BaSch and clapping modes are often invisible to linear optical response in the long-wavelength limit q → 0 due to crystal symmetries [37]. p. 0
Mechanism of Optical Activation
The key mechanism enabling optical couplings is that trigonal warping enables a similar effect for BaSch and clapping modes when pairing occurs around a single Fermi surface These modes then become visible to any probe sensitive to the frequency-dependent superfluid stiffness, including longitudinal and Hall conductivity, polar Kerr effect [44], microwave reflectometry and related circuit-QED techniques [45–51]. Crucially, the optical couplings enabled by trigonal warping do not require any background field or supercurrent. p. 0 This effect is due to the fact that trigonal warping breaks the antisymmetry in velocity between the two electrons forming a Cooper pair, activating couplings between order-parameter collective modes and light. p. 4
Mode Character and Symmetry Dependence
The paper discusses how different pairing channels manifest as specific collective modes; for instance, if χ(1)k = χ(2)k, i.e., if the two pairing channels are time-reversed partners, then a and b are clapping modes. p. 1 If instead χ(1)k and χ(2)k come from unrelated irreps, e. p. 1g., p+ip and f +if (or s-wave and d-wave in a spin-singlet model), then a and b would instead constitute BaSch modes. p. 1 The paper notes that the clapping mode reverses the pair angular momentum, while the BaSch mode changes pair angular momentum by two units while preserving its direction. p. 4
Experimental Probes and Predictions
The results extend the zoo of collective modes detectable in linear optical spectroscopy. p. 4 The paper predicts that kinetic inductance measurements could detect the clapping mode in trigonally-warped single-valley superconductors. p. 3 Specifically, for RnG, it predicts a kinetic inductance on the order of tens of nH at characteristic frequencies of a few GHz. p. 3 The analysis shows that the clapping mode frequency is shifted up in energy from √2∆mf when breaking degeneracy between pairing channels. p. 3
Conclusion on Superfluid Response
The collective-mode propagator diverges at the clapping mode resonance, D−1(omegac) = 0, while all other quantities remain finite. p. 4 The result simplifies drastically when f = 0, i. p. 3 p. 3e., g1 = g2, in which case the clapping mode energy is found to be shifted away from √2∆mf. p. 0 The longitudinal (transverse) conductivity is then purely imaginary (real); recall that σ = iK/(omega+i0+), and the longitudinal (transverse) conductivity develops a real (imaginary) part with a square-root onset. p. 3 p. 3
Numerical Estimates for RnG
In numerical estimates for RnG, the effective trigonal warping term is estimated to be approximately η = -20 meV nm3. This parameter is derived by projecting the non-interacting, continuum-model description of rhombohedral L-layer graphene to the two sublattices where the low-energy wavefunctions are predominantly polarized. The resulting dispersion relation shows that the trigonal warping parameter is extracted as η = 3γ1γ2γ2/3γ20uk30 ≈ -20 meV nm3. p. 2 p. 2 The kinetic inductance on a square sample is predicted to be on the order of tens of nH at characteristic frequencies of a few GHz. p. 3 p. 3
Inductance Measurements
Inductance measurements could detect the clapping mode in trigonally-warped single-valley superconductors. The supercurrent density is related to the superfluid stiffness by J = 2Kijq for q=0. p. 0 Assuming a square sample, the frequency-dependent inductance matrix is L(omega) = 1/2K−1(omega). p. 3
Limits of Interest
At DC, the longitudinal response is given by Kijf,q=0(omega → 0) = δij e2ν (µm − 2(ηmµ)2 / (1 − ∆mfµ2 + log 2Λ∆mf)). The collective-mode propagator diverges at the clapping mode resonance, D−1(omegac) = 0, while all other quantities remain finite. Near resonance, the collective-mode propagator is expanded as z 2(tan z − cot z) − f log 2Λ∆mf ≈ −omega − Ωc + i0+ / (1 - 1/2 sec 2zc (1 + zc sec zc csc zc). p. 2 The result simplifies drastically when f = 0, i.e., g1 = g2, in which case the clapping mode frequency is found to be shifted away from √2∆mf. p. 0 The gap-edge feature involves a subtle cancellation between the bare bubble and collective-mode contributions; both diverge separately, but their divergences cancel one another. p. 6 The longitudinal (transverse) conductivity is then purely imaginary (real); recall that σ = iK/(omega+i0+), and the longitudinal (transverse) conductivity develops a real (imaginary) part with a square-root onset.
Inductance Results
The inductance measurement results demonstrate that inductance measurements could detect the clapping mode in trigonally-warped single-valley superconductors. The free energy of an inductor is U = 1/2LI2, with frequency-dependent inductance matrix L(omega) = 1/2K−1(omega). p. 0 Assuming a square sample, we have simply L(omega) = 1/2K−1(omega). p. 3
Numerical Estimates for Parameters
In numerical estimates for RnG, the effective trigonal warping term is estimated to be approximately η = -20 meV nm3. This parameter is derived by projecting the non-interacting, continuum-model description of rhombohedral L-layer graphene to the two sublattices where the low-energy wavefunctions are predominantly polarized. The resulting dispersion relation shows that the trigonal warping parameter is extracted as η = 3γ1γ2γ2/3γ20uk30 ≈ -20 meV nm3. The kinetic inductance on a square sample is predicted to be on the order of tens of nH at characteristic frequencies of a few GHz.
Final Conclusion
We have demonstrated that the clapping modes of a chiral p-wave superconductor are optically active when the parent normal state hosts a single Fermi surface with trigonal warping. The same is true for the subset of Bardasis-Schrieffer modes which change Cooper pair angular momentum by two units. p. 4 The physical origin of this effect is that trigonal warping breaks the antisymmetry in velocity between the two electrons forming a Cooper pair, activating couplings between order-parameter collective modes and light. p. 4 The results extend the zoo of collective modes detectable in linear optical spectroscopy. Valley-polarized superconductors in RnG are a promising platform to test our ideas. p. 4 Future work will consider more realistic models of RnG and investigate how experimental tuning parameters affect their collective mode spectra. p. 4
Acknowledgments
We thank Erez Berg for fruitful discussions and collaborations on related topics BAL gratefully acknowledges support from the Canada First Research Excellence Fund (CFREF). ELH is grateful for support from the National Sciences and Engineering Council of Canada (NSERC), grant RGPIN-2025-06136, and start-up funds from the Faculté des Sciences at Université de Sherbrooke. p. 4
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform linear optical spectroscopy on single-valley superconductors by using trigonal warping to make modes like Bardasis-Schrieffer (BaSch) and clapping modes visible in longitudinal and Hall optical responses. This enables detection of uncondensed pairing channels which carry valuable information about the host superconductor.
-
Improved AI can design microwave impedance spectroscopy as an ideal probe for studying collective modes in rhombohedral graphene by predicting kinetic inductances on the order of tens of nanohenries at characteristic frequencies relevant to circuit-QED techniques.
-
Improved AI can distinguish between clapping modes and BaSch modes by analyzing their coupling to an out-of-plane magnetic field, as the optical responses are identical in the model but they couple differently due to changes in pair angular momentum.
-
Improved AI can predict the energy of the clapping mode resonance using Equation (71), which shows how lifting degeneracy between pairing channels raises the clapping mode energy from sqrt(2 Delta mf).
-
Improved AI can predict the longitudinal and transverse conductivity as a function of frequency by using Equation (81), which provides an explicit expression for Kij cm,q=0(Omega) near resonance.
Sources
- Collective mode spectroscopy in time-reversal symmetry breaking superconductors
- Current-Enabled Optical Conductivity of Collective Modes in Unconventional Superconductors
- Microwave Kerr/Faraday Resonance in Two-dimensional Chiral Superconductors
- Kinetic Inductance of Few-Layer NbSe$_2$ in the Two-Dimensional Limit
- Observing unconventional superconductivity via kinetic inductance in Weyl semimetal MoTe$_2$
- Stripe Order in the Metallic and Superconducting Phases of Rhombohedral Hexalayer Graphene
- A Hierarchy of Superconductivity and Topological Charge Density Wave States in Rhombohedral Graphene
- Chiral superconductivity from parent Chern band and its non-Abelian generalization
- Chiral and topological superconductivity in isospin polarized multilayer graphene
- Chiral finite-momentum superconductivity in the tetralayer graphene
- Topological incommensurate Fulde-Ferrell-Larkin-Ovchinnikov superconductor and Bogoliubov Fermi surface in rhombohedral tetra-layer graphene
- How pairing mechanism dictates topology in valley-polarized superconductors with Berry curvature
- Enhanced Kohn-Luttinger topological superconductivity in bands with nontrivial geometry
- Quarter Metal Superconductivity
- Band Renormalization, Quarter Metals, and Chiral Superconductivity in Rhombohedral Tetralayer Graphene
- Finite-momentum pairing and superlattice superconductivity in valley-imbalanced rhombohedral graphene
- Variational Monte Carlo Optimization of Topological Chiral Superconductors
- Family of multilayer graphene superconductors with tunable chirality: Momentum-space vortices nucleated by a ring of Berry curvature
- Intrinsic superconducting diode effect and nonreciprocal superconductivity in rhombohedral graphene multilayers
- Superconductivity from phonon-mediated retardation in a single-flavor metal
Related papers
- Microscopic Origin and Josephson Signatures of d-Wave Superconductivity in Monolayer FeSe
- Excitonic-Superconducting Coexistence and Emergent Nematic Superconductivity Driven by Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
- Quantum phase fluctuations quench chiral superconductivity in twisted overdoped cuprate bilayers
- Interface-Confined Superconductivity with Thickness-Independent Superfluid Stiffness in (Pb,Sn)Te/FeTe Bilayers
- Kinetic Lifshitz invariants and dynamics of nonreciprocal fluctuations in superconductors
- Steering and Local Tunneling Signatures of Majorana Corner Modes in Altermagnetic Josephson Junctions