Two-loop renormalisation of quark and gluon fields in the SMEFT in the on-shell scheme

arXiv:2508.04500 · hep-ph · Submitted 2025-08-06 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Two-loop renormalisation of quark and gluon fields in the SMEFT in the on-shell scheme".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We compute the contributions of CP-conserving dimension-six SMEFT operators to the two-loop renormalisation constants of quark and gluon fields in the on-shell scheme Specifically, we consider the top-quark chromomagnetic operator and the triple gluon operator.

Kai: Collider experiments scrutinising the predictions of the Standard Model (SM) and searching for new particles have not found any evidence for new light degrees of freedom This has motivated the use of the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) framework

1–4: to parametrise new physics effects through higher-dimensional operators modifying the interactions of the SM particles in a model-independent manner.

Mira: Significant effort has been devoted to both interpreting experimental data within the context of the SMEFT in global fits

5–8: , and to improving theoretical predictions to maximise our sensitivity to new physics through these interpretations.

Kai: A campaign of higherorder SMEFT computations have appeared in the literature, with one-loop corrections in the QCD coupling automated with SMEFT@NLO

9: .

Paper summary: Kai: So, looking at the whole paper, "Two-loop renormalisation of quark and gluon fields in the SMEFT in the on-shell scheme", what's the main point they are driving home?

Mira: The main thing is that they’ve established these two-loop results for field renormalisation constants and masses using these specific dimension-six operators. They show how to do this in the on-shell scheme, which is different from the MS scheme.

Lev: It means we have better tools for calculating physical observables, like top pair production cross sections, because they can use these on-shell results flexibly.

Kai: So, in simple terms for someone just listening to the show, what’s the real implication of this work?

Mira: The implication is that we now have more solid mathematical ingredients available for any two-loop calculation within the SMEFT framework for QCD. They've also shown something important about those four-fermion operators not affecting the running of alpha sub s because there’s no single pole contribution.

Lev: It’s a validation check, essentially confirming that those four-fermion operators don't contribute to the strong coupling constant running at this level.

Kai: So, it’s about building up the theoretical machinery for precision work in this area. Where does this leave things for future research?

Mira: Future work will need to use these results as essential ingredients when performing two-loop computations in the QCD sector of SMEFT. It sets a standard for how we handle these kinds of corrections.

Lev: And they’ve also proposed a decoupling scheme for the SMEFT to define an effective coupling constant that mimics the running of alpha sub s in a theory with five massless quark flavours, where the effective quark is decoupled from the running. That's a new way to think about it.

Kai: It sounds like they are giving us more precise ways to model how new physics operators modify known particle interactions. That’s what this paper is doing for us right now.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at "Two-loop renormalisation of quark and gluon fields in the SMEFT in the on-shell scheme". What are we actually talking about here?

Mira: Basically, they’ve done these two-loop calculations for how quarks and gluons get their field renormalisation constants using those dimension six operators. They did this in the on-shell scheme.

Lev: The main thing I see is that they’re getting a more direct way to connect the theory to actual measurements because it uses the on-shell scheme, which is different from what we usually do in the MS scheme.

Kai: It means we have better tools for calculating those physical observables, like cross sections for top quark stuff, because we can use these on-shell results flexibly.

Mira: Exactly. And they also checked something important about those four-fermion operators—they showed there’s no single pole contribution that affects the running of the strong coupling constant alpha sub s.

Lev: That absence of a single pole is a good check for their work on the gluon renormalisation constant, but it means those four-fermion operators don't affect how the strong coupling runs at this level.

Kai: So, to sum it up, they’ve built up some essential mathematical ingredients for any future two-loop calculations in SMEFT for QCD. These results are key building blocks.

Mira: They are definitely ingredients. But they also put forward a new idea with that decoupling scheme for the SMEFT itself—defining an effective coupling constant that mimics the strong coupling running in a theory with five massless quark flavours, where one of those quarks is effectively decoupled from the running.

Lev: That decoupling scheme is interesting because it gives us a way to handle the strong coupling more cleanly when thinking about how these operators actually run. It moves us toward a clearer framework for real hardware calculations.

Kai: It sounds like this paper isn't just a calculation; it’s setting up the foundation for how we model these corrections precisely in the future. So, what does this mean for where we go next?

Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester

hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-08-06

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 28 pages

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: We compute the contributions of CP-conserving dimension-six SMEFT operators to the two-loop renormalisation constants of quark and gluon fields in the on-shell scheme Specifically…

Key concepts

SMEFT
Standard Model Effective Field Theory is a framework used to parametrize new physics effects by adding higher-dimensional operators to the Standard Model. This allows physicists to study potential new particles without needing a specific theory, making it model-independent for interpreting experimental data.
On-Shell Scheme
This scheme is a method used to define renormalization constants for fields and masses based on physical, on-shell values (like the pole mass of a particle). The paper computes these constants at two loops in this specific scheme to compare with results obtained in other schemes like MS.
Four-Quark Operators
These are operators involving four quarks, which are extended beyond the initial focus on dimension-six operators. Including them complicates calculations due to chirality-dependent terms, requiring careful treatment of gamma5 matrices and addressing issues in different renormalization schemes like BMHV.
Running of $\alpha_s$
The running of the strong coupling constant ($\alpha_s$) describes how its value changes with the energy scale. The paper checks if four-quark operators affect this running at two loops. The absence of a single pole in the gluon renormalization constant suggests these operators do not contribute to $\alpha_s$ running.

Terminology

Summary

We compute the contributions of CP-conserving dimension-six SMEFT operators to the two-loop renormalisation constants of quark and gluon fields in the on-shell scheme Specifically, we consider the top-quark chromomagnetic operator and the triple gluon operator. p. 0

Introduction to SMEFT Corrections

Collider experiments scrutinising the predictions of the Standard Model (SM) and searching for new particles have not found any evidence for new light degrees of freedom This has motivated the use of the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) framework [1–4] to parametrise new physics effects through higher-dimensional operators modifying the interactions of the SM particles in a model-independent manner. Significant effort has been devoted to both interpreting experimental data within the context of the SMEFT in global fits [5–8], and to improving theoretical predictions to maximise our sensitivity to new physics through these interpretations. p. 1 A campaign of higherorder SMEFT computations have appeared in the literature, with one-loop corrections in the QCD coupling automated with SMEFT@NLO [9]. p. 1

On-Shell Field and Mass Renormalisation

The work performs the computation of the field renormalisation constants in the on-shell scheme In particular, we extract the renormalisation constants for the quark and gluon fields within the on-shell scheme and the relation between the pole and MS top masses. The computation of these renormalisation constants at two loops for the top quark field in the on-shell scheme in the presence of dimension-six chromomagnetic dipole moment and triple gluon operators complements previous computations in the MS scheme. p. 2

Inclusion of Four-Quark Operators

The second direction we pursue is the extension of our operator basis to include four-quark operators. The presence of chirality-dependent operators introduces a significant complication into the calculation, due to the treatment of γ5 matrix beyond four dimensions. p. 2 We focus on the renormalisation of the gluon field in the BMHV scheme, addressing all issues arising in the presence of four-fermion operators. p. 2

Gluon Self-Energy and Running Coupling

We compute contributions from four-quark operators to the gluon field renormalisation constant in both MS and on-shell schemes. The lack of a single pole implies that none of the four-quark operators contribute to the two-loop running of αs. p. 1 This absence of a single pole is a non-trivial check for our result for the gluon renormalisation constant. p. 9

Conclusion and Implications

In this work we took another step towards the two-loop renormalisation of fields and masses in the QCD sector of the SMEFT. Our results are essential ingredients for any two-loop computation in the QCD sector of the SMEFT. p. 3 We find that there is no single pole contribution From the renormalisation constant for the gluon we can extract also the renormalisation of the strong coupling constant. p. 0 The absence of a single pole means that the four-fermion operators do not contribute to the running of the strong coupling constant. p. 2

Acknowledgements

GV thanks Victor Miralles and Hesham El Faham for useful discussions We also thank Andres Vasquez for collaboration during the early stages of this project. GV and EV are supported by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 949451) and by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship through grant URF/R1/201553. p. 0 The work of CD is supported by the DFG project 499573813 “EFTools”. p. 2

A Penguin Diagram in BMHV

We focus here on the renormalisation of the quark-gluon vertex at one loop with fourfermion operators in the BMHV scheme. Focusing on the divergent four-dimensional structures, the results of the renomalisation procedure are in table 1. p. 6

Evanescent Operators Generated at One-Loop Counterterm

Table 2 shows that the second set of operators is only generated in the latter. The first set of operators is generated in both the four- and D-dimensional schemes for the gauge-fermion vertex. p. 2

SMEFT Decoupling Scheme for Strong Coupling

We propose a similar decoupling scheme for the SMEFT. More precisely, we define an effective coupling constant that has the same running as the strong coupling constant in a theory with nf - 1 = 5 massless quark flavours, and the effective quark has effectively been decoupled form the running of the strong coupling. p. 2

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved calculation of two-loop renormalization constants for quark and gluon fields in both on-shell and MS schemes, including contributions from dimension-six operators like OtG and OG. The improved system can now provide explicit results for delta Z(2) terms, which are essential ingredients for any two-loop computation in the QCD sector of SMEFT.

  2. Enhanced handling of chiral fermions in dimensional regularization by consistently employing the Breitenlohner-Maison-’t Hooft-Veltman (BMHV) scheme. The improved system can now correctly identify and manage evanescent operators that arise from Fierz transformations, ensuring mathematical consistency at all loop orders.

  3. Accurate derivation of the two-loop relation between the pole mass and the MS mass for the top quark by combining on-shell and MS renormalization results. This allows for a consistent running of physical observables with respect to different renormalization scales in SMEFT calculations.

  4. Calculation of four-quark operator contributions to gluon self-energy in both MS and on-shell schemes, including the identification that there is no single pole contribution for these operators. The improved system can correctly predict the absence of a single pole, which serves as a non-trivial check for its results regarding the running of the strong coupling constant.

  5. Implementation of an effective coupling constant decoupling scheme that mimics SM running for massless quarks when only the top quark is massive. This capability allows the system to remedy mismatches between SMEFT running and automated tools that restrict running to the Standard Model.

Sources

Related papers