Work extraction from long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level system

arXiv:2508.02614 · quant-ph · Submitted 2025-08-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Work extraction from long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level system".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Work extraction from long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level system analyzes protocols to convert persistent quantum coherence into practical work, demonstrating that this resource can be harnessed for energy extraction in quantum thermal machines The paper proposes two innovative thermodynamic protocols that transform quantum coherence into population asymmetry, serving as a quantum resource for work extraction.

Kai: System Model and Coherence Generation The analysis focuses on a three-level open quantum system, specifically the V-type atom configuration where two excited states are degenerate.

Mira: Long-lived quantum coherence is generated in this degenerate system due to environmentally induced quantum interference effects when two excited states are degenerate and have aligned transition dipoles.

Kai: The dynamics of the system are governed by a GoriniKossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad (GKSL) master equation, where the non-diagonal terms in the dissipator capture coherent dynamics induced by degeneracy and indistinguishability of decay pathways.

Paper summary: Kai: To summarize this paper, they focus on a three-level open quantum system, specifically a V-type atom configuration where two excited states are degenerate. The main point is analyzing protocols to convert this persistent quantum coherence into practical work, demonstrating that this resource can be harnessed for energy extraction in quantum thermal machines.

Mira: They propose two innovative thermodynamic protocols that transform this long-lived quantum coherence into population asymmetry, which they call a quantum resource for work extraction.

Lev: Protocol one is repeatable; it consumes some of the quantum coherence in each cycle and eventually turns the system into a thermal state, while protocol two is a single-shot thermal process that converts all the coherence into work in one cycle.

Kai: The paper quantifies this maximum extractable work by looking at the free energy difference, which they say is bounded by the difference between a non-equilibrium state and a Gibbs state.

Mira: And interestingly, quantum coherence helps here because it reduces the von Neumann entropy term, which allows for a larger potential maximum extractable work, or what they call the free energy difference.

Lev: Protocol two is shown to saturate this upper bound imposed by the free energy difference and extracts the maximum extractable work of that three-level system in just one cycle.

Conclusion: Kai: So, when we look at the title, "Work extraction from long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level system," it really captures the essence of what they're doing. They show how that specific type of coherence isn't just some theoretical quirk; it’s a physical resource that gets gradually consumed during the work extraction process.

Mira: And the protocols they designed give us a concrete way to design future quantum thermal machines, showing how this coherence can be used as fuel in these systems.

Lev: What's interesting is that Protocol one shows how you can repeat this process until no more quantum coherence is left, which eventually drives the system towards a Gibbs state.

Kai: They also found that even if you start with the system prepared on the ground level, the final measurement of the quantum coherence still has a non-zero l1-norm, determined by the KMS temperature of that bath and those excited states.

Mira: And they showed that both protocol extracted work and this free energy difference degrade as beta increases, which means less work can be extracted from a thermal bath at lower temperatures.

Lev: So the main implication for me on hardware is understanding where the overhead lands when you try to run these protocols on real hardware, especially since we're dealing with these quantum error-correction challenges.

Kai: Right, so this paper lays out a blueprint for designing machines that use coherence as an active resource, not just something we observe passively.

School of Physics, Xi’an Jiaotong University · MOE Key Laboratory for Non-equilibrium Synthesis and Modulation of Condensed Matter · Hefei National Laboratory

quant-ph

Submitted: 2025-08-04

Updated: 2026-10-31

Comments: 15 pages, 8 figures. Major revisions have been made, and more numerical results have been added

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 72/100

The gist: Work extraction from long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level system analyzes protocols to convert persistent quantum coherence into practical work…

Key concepts

Long-lived Quantum Coherence
This is a persistent quantum correlation within the system that lasts longer than typical decay times. In this specific three-level atom setup, it arises because two excited states are degenerate and have aligned transition dipoles, causing the decay pathways to interfere constructively.
Work Extraction Protocols
These are specific sequences of operations designed to transform quantum coherence into measurable work. Protocol-1 is repeatable, consuming some coherence each time until the system thermalizes. Protocol-2 is a single cycle that converts all available coherence into work.
Free Energy Difference (FED)
The FED represents the maximum theoretical amount of useful work that can be extracted from the initial non-equilibrium state down to a final thermal state. Quantum coherence helps reduce the entropy term, potentially allowing for more extractable work than classical thermodynamics would suggest.

Terminology

Summary

Work extraction from long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level system analyzes protocols to convert persistent quantum coherence into practical work, demonstrating that this resource can be harnessed for energy extraction in quantum thermal machines The paper proposes two innovative thermodynamic protocols that transform quantum coherence into population asymmetry, serving as a quantum resource for work extraction. p. 0

Where the paper says it

By designing two innovative thermodynamic protocols involving energy-preserving unitary operations, we show that quantum coherence can be transformed into population asymmetry, serving as a quantum resource for work extraction. As the system approaches final thermal equilibrium, the initial quantum coherence effectively acts as fuel, being progressively consumed.

System Model and Coherence Generation

The analysis focuses on a three-level open quantum system, specifically the V-type atom configuration where two excited states are degenerate. Long-lived quantum coherence is generated in this degenerate system due to environmentally induced quantum interference effects when two excited states are degenerate and have aligned transition dipoles. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Surprisingly, specific multilevel configurations, such as degenerate three-level quantum systems with a V-type configuration, permit longlived quantum coherence to persist through environmentinduced quantum interference effects [3]. Particularly, suppose two excited states are degenerate and have aligned transition dipoles, the degeneracy allows interference between decay pathways, creating environmentally induced coherence (EIC), which can persist even under continuous thermalization [4–6].

The dynamics of the system are governed by a GoriniKossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad (GKSL) master equation, where the non-diagonal terms in the dissipator capture coherent dynamics induced by degeneracy and indistinguishability of decay pathways. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The structure of the dissipator Eq. (6) of the master equation, particularly the non-diagonal terms Γ± (ij) with i ̸= j, captures the coherent dynamics induced by degeneracy and indistinguishability of decay pathways.

For perfectly aligned dipoles, this coherent cross-coupling is a hallmark of V-type systems. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the case of perfectly aligned dipoles, we have cos Θij = 1 for all i, j, leading to maximal coherence between decay channels. This coherent cross-coupling, induced by interference, is a hallmark of V-type systems [3] and would play a central role in coherence-enhanced thermodynamic processes [27, 28].

Work Extraction Protocols

The paper introduces two distinct protocols for extracting work from the long-lived quantum coherence in the steady state.

  1. Protocol-1 is a repeatable protocol that consumes part of quantum coherence in each cycle, eventually transforming the system into a thermal state. p. 9

    Where the paper says it

    Through a designed thermodynamic cycle involving thermalization and controlled level shifts, this asymmetry is used to extract practical work. Protocol-1 is repeatable and consumes part of quantum coherence in each cycle, eventually transforming the system into a thermal state.

  2. Protocol-2 is a single-shot thermal process capable of converting all the quantum coherence of the system into work in one cycle. p. 9

    Where the paper says it

    Protocol-1 is repeatable and consumes part of quantum coherence in each cycle, eventually transforming the system into a thermal state. Protocol-2 is a single-shot thermal process capable of converting all the quantum coherence of the system into work in one cycle.

Free Energy Difference and Efficiency

The maximum extractable work (MEW) is quantified by the free energy difference (FED), which is bounded by the difference between a non-equilibrium state and a Gibbs state. Quantum coherence, via the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix, reduces the von Neumann entropy term, thereby allowing for more MEW (indicated by a larger FED) to be potentially utilized. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(32) With the degenerate system Hamiltonian (2), the related FED can be directly calculated as: ⟨W⟩ρ = ω(ρ11 + ρ22) + kT   X i=0,± λi log λi + log ZS   , (33) where ZS = 1 + 2e −βω. The interesting point is that quantum coherence (via ρ12) reduces the von Neumann entropy term, thereby allowing for more MEW (indicated by the larger FED (33)) to be potentially utilized.

The single-shot Protocol-2 is shown to saturate the upper bound imposed by FED and extract the MEW of the three-level system. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(63) The total extracted work after the cycle is Wprotocol-2 = W1 + W2 − W′ 1 − W′ 2 , (64) which can be confirmed as equal to the FED between the initial state ρS of the three-level system and its final thermal state γeS after completing the cycle: ⟨W⟩ρS = ω(1 − b) + 1 β log 1 + 2e −βω 1 + e−βω1 + e−βω2 − (1 − b) 2 [(1 + |n|)ω1 + (1 − |n|)ω2] (65) under the matching condition (57). In this sense, the single-shot Protocol-2 saturates the upper bound imposed by FED and extracts the MEW of the three-level system.

Resource Consumption and Optimization

The decrement of quantum coherence is a trade-off for the work extracted by Protocol-1, as it can be repeated until no more quantum coherence can be utilized, i.e., the final state after the protocol is thermal. p. 5

Where the paper says it

with temperature 𝑇 Final state with less quantum coherence |0ۧ |1ۧ |2ۧ Energy-preserving 𝝆final 𝝆𝟐 FIG. Schematic about the work extraction Protocol-1 from a degenerate three-level quantum system interacting with a thermal bath.

The optimal work extraction in Protocol-1(i) is determined by a recurrence relation for the optimal energy shift, which asymptotically leads to zero as the system relaxes to a Gibbs state. p. 7
Where the paper says it

(48) To guarantee the positive work extraction during each round of the protocol, a chain of constraints ω˜ (i) < 1 β log " 2 + e −βω + e −βΩ (i−1) (1 + e−βω)(1 + e−βω˜ (i−1) ) # < ω˜ (i−1) , (49) should be satisfied, which means asymptotically limn→∞ ω˜ (n) → 0. This implies that the amount of work extracted in subsequent cycles decreases progressively until it approaches zero when the system relaxes to the pure Gibbs state γS.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The work confirms that the quantum coherence arising from degeneracy serves as a kind of physical resource that is gradually consumed during the work extraction process. The protocols provide a basis for designing future coherence-driven quantum thermal machines. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Besides deepening the understanding of the thermodynamic resource role of quantum coherence, our analysis also opens the possibility of utilizing other quantum resources, such as quantum discord [16]. The protocols also provide a basis for designing future coherence-driven quantum thermal machines [35] by the three-level quantum system.

The analysis can be extended to nearly degenerate systems, opening the possibility of utilizing other quantum resources such as quantum discord. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The same analysis can be extended to the nearly degenerate system, although with more involved dynamics obtained in C4. Besides deepening the understanding of the thermodynamic resource role of quantum coherence, our analysis also opens the possibility of utilizing other quantum resources, such as quantum discord [16].

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper analyzes open dynamics of a three-level system interacting with a thermal bath through dipole-monopole coupling. The authors explore the conditions that generate long-lived quantum coherence in the steady state of the system and design efficient thermodynamic protocols to convert this coherence into practical work. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this paper, we address this gap by examining the open dynamics of a three-level quantum system interacting with a thermal bath through dipole-monopole coupling. We explore the conditions that generate long-lived quantum coherence in the steady state of the system, and design efficient thermodynamic protocols to convert this coherence into practical work.

How the training signal is built

The dynamics of a three-level open quantum system are described by a set of first-order differential equations for the components of the Bloch vector, which can be rewritten as a Schrödinger-like equation for the coherence vector. The matrix M in this equation is invertible when p! p. 2

Where the paper says it

(18) For |p| ̸= 1, the coefficient matrix M in Eq. (16) is invertible.

= 1, leading to eventual relaxation to the Gibbs state [30]. p. 1
Where the paper says it

For simplicity, we assume the dipole moments d(1) and d(2) have unit magnitude, and denoting Θij as the angle between them, the rates can be expressed as: Γ ± (ij) = γ± cos Θij , (7) where γ± are the total downward (emission) and upward (absorption) rates, respectively. In the case of perfectly aligned dipoles, we have cos Θij = 1 for all i, j, leading to maximal coherence between decay channels.

When p = 1, the matrix M becomes irreversible, and an explicit solution for the time evolution of relevant density matrix components is obtained analytically. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(16) can be obtained analytically. Setting the initial conditions by ρ22(0) = a, ρ00(0) = b, ρ+(0) = c, ρ−(0) = id, with a, b, c, d ∈ R and denoting x := e −βω, the time evolution of the relevant density matrix components reads from Eq.

Where the gains come from

The work extraction protocol (Protocol-1) involves applying an energy-preserving unitary transformation U to convert coherence into population asymmetry between degenerate states. This asymmetry is then used in a series of adiabatic level shifts and thermalizations to extract work from the asymmetrically populated states. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The protocol starts with a coherent steady state induced by environmental interaction, then applies an energypreserving unitary transformation that converts coherence into population asymmetry. Next, a series of adiabatic level shifts and thermalizations is used to extract work from the asymmetrically populated states.

The single-shot Protocol-2 extracts the full free energy difference, which is equal to the FED between the initial state and its final thermal state. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(63) The total extracted work after the cycle is Wprotocol-2 = W1 + W2 − W′ 1 − W′ 2 , (64) which can be confirmed as equal to the FED between the initial state ρS of the three-level system and its final thermal state γeS after completing the cycle: ⟨W⟩ρS = ω(1 − b) + 1 β log 1 + 2e −βω 1 + e−βω1 + e−βω2 − (1 − b) 2 [(1 + |n|)ω1 + (1 − |n|)ω2] (65) under the matching condition (57). In this sense, the single-shot Protocol-2 saturates the upper bound imposed by FED and extracts the MEW of the three-level system.

The paper proposes a concrete work-extraction protocol (Protocol-1) to convert the long-lived quantum coherence in a steady state into practical work that can be utilized during the thermodynamic process. The single-shot protocol (Protocol-2) allows the MEW to be extracted as practical work in a single process. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The single-shot protocol (Protocol-2) in Section III. 3 allows the MEW to be extracted as practical work in a single process.

The scheme of Protocol-2 involves an energy-preserving rotation, population reshuffling by lifting/lowering excited levels in isolation, then coupling to a thermal bath while adiabatically lowering one excited level. The total extracted work after the cycle is expressed as Wprotocol-2 = W1 + W2 − W′1 − W′2, which can be confirmed as equal to the FED between the initial state and its final thermal state. p. 9

Where the paper says it

This step leads the system to the final Gibbs state as γeS = 1 1 + 2e−βω   e −βω 0 0 0 e −βω 0 0 0 1   (62) and consumes energy: W′ 2 = Z ω ω1 2e −βω′ dω′ 1 + 2e−βω′ = − 1 β ln 1 + 2e −βω 1 + 2e−βω1 . (63) The total extracted work after the cycle is Wprotocol-2 = W1 + W2 − W′ 1 − W′ 2 , (64) which can be confirmed as equal to the FED between the initial state ρS of the three-level system and its final thermal state γeS after completing the cycle: ⟨W⟩ρS = ω(1 − b) + 1 β log 1 + 2e −βω 1 + e−βω1 + e−βω2 − (1 − b) 2 [(1 + |n|)ω1 + (1 − |n|)ω2] (65) under the matching condition (57).

The key resource is the quantum coherence exhausted after Step 1, resulting in an asymmetry in the populations of the excited state. p. 9

Where the paper says it

In this sense, the single-shot Protocol-2 saturates the upper bound imposed by FED and extracts the MEW of the three-level system. As we have presented, the key resource is the quantum coherence exhausted after Step 1, resulting in an asymmetry in the populations of the excited state.

The decrement of quantum coherence is a trade-off for the work extracted by Protocol-1. p. 6
Where the paper says it

, Cl1 (ρ0) = (1 + e βω) −1 , to the quantum coherence of the final state (D2): Cl1 (ρ (1) final) = Cl1 (ρ0) 1 − e −βω˜ (1) 2Z(1) < Cl1 (ρ0). (41) The decrement of quantum coherence is a trade-off for the work extracted by the protocol.

The final state after Protocol-1(n) approaches a Gibbs state as asymptotically limn→∞ ω˜(n) → 0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

(48) To guarantee the positive work extraction during each round of the protocol, a chain of constraints ω˜ (i) < 1 β log " 2 + e −βω + e −βΩ (i−1) (1 + e−βω)(1 + e−βω˜ (i−1) ) # < ω˜ (i−1) , (49) should be satisfied, which means asymptotically limn→∞ ω˜ (n) → 0. This implies that the amount of work extracted in subsequent cycles decreases progressively until it approaches zero when the system relaxes to the pure Gibbs state γS.

The concrete protocols designed for a degenerate threelevel quantum system illustrate how long-lived quantum coherence can serve as a resource convertible into practical work. The same analysis can be extended to the nearly degenerate system, although with more involved dynamics obtained in C4. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The concrete protocols designed for a degenerate threelevel quantum system illustrate how long-lived quantum coherence can serve as a resource convertible into practical work. The same analysis can be extended to the nearly degenerate system, although with more involved dynamics obtained in C4.

The paper analyzes a (nearly) degenerate three-level quantum system interacting with a thermal bath via dipole-monopole coupling. The authors identify situations where persistent quantum coherence arises, i. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Work extraction from long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level system Wenjing Chen,1 Si-Wei Han,1 Xiaoshan Feng,1 and Jun Feng1, 2, 3, ∗ 1School of Physics, Xi’an Jiaotong University, Xi’an, Shaanxi 710049, China 2MOE Key Laboratory for Non-equilibrium Synthesis and Modulation of Condensed Matter, Xi’an 710049, Shaanxi, China 3Hefei National Laboratory, Hefei 230088, Anhui, China (Dated: July 2025) We analyze work extraction protocols using the long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level quantum system, which is coupled to a thermal bath through dipole-monopole interactions. We identify situations where persistent quantum coherence arises, i.

e., for systems with degenerate excited states with aligned transition dipoles or nearly degenerate systems with small energy splittings. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We identify situations where persistent quantum coherence arises, i. , for systems with degenerate excited states with aligned transition dipoles or nearly degenerate systems with small energy splittings.

The analysis highlights the thermodynamic advantages of long-lived coherence in a three-level quantum system and could influence future designs of coherence-driven quantum thermal machines. The results show that the optimal work Wprotocol-1 is generally less than the FED between the initial state ρ0 and the final γS, indicating Protocol-1 is not fully efficient. p. 7

Where the paper says it

It is evident that the optimal work Wprotocol-1 is generally less than the FED between the initial state ρ0 of the protocol and the final γS. From the perspective of resource conversion, this indicates that Protocol-1 is not fully efficient, as the extracted work is smaller than the MEW of the three-level system.

The paper discusses how quantum coherence can be quantified using certain monotone measures, specifically the so-called l1-norm measure of coherence. The final l1-norm of quantum coherence for the asymptotic steady-state ρ∞ is nonzero even when prepared on the ground level. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Here, we utilize the so-called ℓ1-norm measure of coherence [31], defined as Cℓ1 (ρ) = X i,j;i̸=j |ρi,j | , (22) For the asymptotic steady-state ρ∞ given by Eq. (21), it inherits quantum coherence Cℓ1 (ρ∞) = (1 + 2e −βω)(b + 2c) − 1 2(1 + e−βω) (23) Notably, even if the three-level system is prepared on the ground level (i.

The paper uses energy-preserving unitary operations that coherently manipulate populations and coherences, transforming quantum informational resources into thermodynamically accessible energy. The optimized protocol capable of extracting the maximal extractable work (MEW), measured by the free energy difference (FED), from quantum coherence in a single-shot thermodynamic cycle is proposed. p. 0

Where the paper says it

As the system approaches final thermal equilibrium, the initial quantum coherence effectively acts as fuel, being progressively consumed. Specifically, we propose an optimized protocol capable of extracting the maximal extractable work (MEW), measured by the free energy difference (FED), from quantum coherence in a single-shot thermodynamic cycle.

The paper demonstrates that practical thermodynamic protocols may apply to future quantum device design by showing how quantum coherence is gradually consumed in each step, highlighting its role as a finite thermodynamic resource. The results show that both protocol-extracted work and FED monotonically degrade as β increases, meaning less work can be extracted from a thermal bath at lower temperatures. p. 7

Where the paper says it

From the perspective of resource conversion, this indicates that Protocol-1 is not fully efficient, as the extracted work is smaller than the MEW of the three-level system. On the other hand, we also note that both protocol-extracted work and FED monotonically degrade as β increases, which means less work can be extracted from a thermal bath at lower temperatures.

p. 7
Where the paper says it

From the perspective of resource conversion, this indicates that Protocol-1 is not fully efficient, as the extracted work is smaller than the MEW of the three-level system. On the other hand, we also note that both protocol-extracted work and FED monotonically degrade as β increases, which means less work can be extracted from a thermal bath at lower temperatures.

The paper concludes that when there is dipole alignment (p = 1), as well as for dipole anti-alignment (p = -1), the perfect degenerate three-level system maintains long-lived quantum coherence induced by the atombath interaction. This phenomenon occurs because the two decay channels become indistinguishable, resulting in quantum coherence generation between 1⟩ and 2⟩ even without external driving. p. 3

Where the paper says it

This phenomenon occurs because the two decay channels (from excited states to ground state in Fig. 1) become indistinguishable, resulting in quantum coherence generation between |1⟩ and |2⟩, even without external driving.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

This phenomenon occurs because the two decay channels (from excited states to ground state in Fig. 1) become indistinguishable, resulting in quantum coherence generation between |1⟩ and |2⟩, even without external driving.

The paper proposes a single-shot protocol (Protocol-2) using an idealized thermodynamic cycle in which the quantum coherence of the system is exhausted, and the MEW is fully achieved in a single process. This protocol saturates the upper bound imposed by FED and extracts the MEW of the three-level system. p. 9

Where the paper says it

(63) The total extracted work after the cycle is Wprotocol-2 = W1 + W2 − W′ 1 − W′ 2 , (64) which can be confirmed as equal to the FED between the initial state ρS of the three-level system and its final thermal state γeS after completing the cycle: ⟨W⟩ρS = ω(1 − b) + 1 β log 1 + 2e −βω 1 + e−βω1 + e−βω2 − (1 − b) 2 [(1 + |n|)ω1 + (1 − |n|)ω2] (65) under the matching condition (57). In this sense, the single-shot Protocol-2 saturates the upper bound imposed by FED and extracts the MEW of the three-level system.

The key resource is the quantum coherence exhausted after Step 1, resulting in an asymmetry in the populations of the excited state.

The single-shot Protocol-2 extracts practical work equal to the FED between the initial state and its final thermal state. The protocol demonstrates that quantum coherence can be converted into population asymmetry, serving as a quantum resource for work extraction. p. 0

Where the paper says it

, for systems with degenerate excited states with aligned transition dipoles or nearly degenerate systems with small energy splittings. By designing two innovative thermodynamic protocols involving energy-preserving unitary operations, we show that quantum coherence can be transformed into population asymmetry, serving as a quantum resource for work extraction.

The energy-preserving unitary operator U is used to transfer the quantum coherence between degenerate energy levels into the asymmetry between the populations of energy levels. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The operation of U is a rotation in the frame of the excited state subspace, diagonalizing it without costing any energy. Using this energy-preserving operator, we can transfer the quantum coherence between degenerate energy levels into the asymmetry between the populations of energy levels.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The operation of U is a rotation in the frame of the excited state subspace, diagonalizing it without costing any energy. Using this energy-preserving operator, we can transfer the quantum coherence between degenerate energy levels into the asymmetry between the populations of energy levels.

The paper aims to identify the conditions under which the maximum total work extraction can be achieved after completing all rounds of protocols. The recurrence relation for optimal energy shifts provides a method to determine the optimal work extraction in subsequent cycles. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Since the protocols are conducted sequentially, we only need to determine the optimal ˜ω (i) optimal for each cycle. From (48), we solve dW(i) protocol-1/dω˜ (i) = 0, which gives a recurrence relation for ˜ω (i) optimal (i ⩾ 2) as: h Z (i) i2 − Z (i) e βΩ(i) R(i−1) + ω˜ (i) e βΩ(i) β 1 + e −βω R(i−1) = 0, (50) where the function R(i−1) determined by (i−1)-th cycle: R(i−1) := 2 1 + e βω 1 + e −βω˜ (i−1) optimal !

The paper presents an optimized protocol capable of extracting the maximal extractable work (MEW), measured by the free energy difference (FED), from quantum coherence in a single-shot thermodynamic cycle. The results highlight the thermodynamic advantages of long-lived coherence in a three-level quantum system and could influence future designs of coherence-driven quantum thermal machines. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Specifically, we propose an optimized protocol capable of extracting the maximal extractable work (MEW), measured by the free energy difference (FED), from quantum coherence in a single-shot thermodynamic cycle. Our results highlight the thermodynamic advantages of long-lived coherence in a three-level quantum system and could influence future designs of coherence-driven quantum thermal machines.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Specifically, we propose an optimized protocol capable of extracting the maximal extractable work (MEW), measured by the free energy difference (FED), from quantum coherence in a single-shot thermodynamic cycle. Our results highlight the thermodynamic advantages of long-lived coherence in a three-level quantum system and could influence future designs of coherence-driven quantum thermal machines.

The paper concludes that the net work extracted from conducting Protocol-1 is expressed as W(1) protocol-1 = ∆W(1) − W(1) = ∆W(1), which reaches its maximum when the optimal ˜ω(1) is obtained from dW(i) protocol-1/dω˜ (i) = 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

(D2) in Appendix. We conclude that the net extracted work from conducting Protocol-1 is expressed as: W (1) protocol-1 = ∆W(1) − W(1) = ∆W(1), which reaches its maximum when the optimal ˜ω (1) is obtained from dW(1) protocol-1/dω˜ (1) = 0, as: ω˜ (1) optimal = 1 β 1 + Wp 1 (1 + e βω) e .

The paper shows that quantum coherence still remains in ρ(1)final after completing Protocol-1, suggesting that we can continue extracting work by repeating the protocol until no more quantum coherence can be utilized. The final state after the protocol is thermal γS. p. 6

Where the paper says it

This suggests that we can continue extracting work by repeating the protocol until no more quantum coherence can be utilized, i. , the final state after the protocol is thermal γS.

The decrement of quantum coherence is a trade-off for the work extracted by the protocol. p. 6
Where the paper says it

, Cl1 (ρ0) = (1 + e βω) −1 , to the quantum coherence of the final state (D2): Cl1 (ρ (1) final) = Cl1 (ρ0) 1 − e −βω˜ (1) 2Z(1) < Cl1 (ρ0). (41) The decrement of quantum coherence is a trade-off for the work extracted by the protocol.

The paper confirms that even if the three-level system is prepared on the ground level, the final l1-norm of quantum coherence is nonzero. The analysis shows that both protocol-extracted work and FED monotonically degrade as β increases, meaning less work can be extracted from a thermal bath at lower temperatures. p. 7

Where the paper says it

From the perspective of resource conversion, this indicates that Protocol-1 is not fully efficient, as the extracted work is smaller than the MEW of the three-level system. On the other hand, we also note that both protocol-extracted work and FED monotonically degrade as β increases, which means less work can be extracted from a thermal bath at lower temperatures.

The paper demonstrates that quantum coherence can be converted into population asymmetry, serving as a quantum resource for work extraction. The energy-preserving unitary operator U is used to transfer the quantum coherence between degenerate energy levels into the asymmetry between the populations of energy levels. The results show that both protocol-extracted work and FED monotonically degrade as β increases, meaning less work can be extracted from a thermal bath at lower temperatures.

The paper confirms that when there is dipole alignment (p = 1), as well as for dipole anti-alignment (p = -1), the perfect degenerate three-level system maintains long-lived quantum coherence induced by the atombath interaction. This phenomenon occurs because the two decay channels become indistinguishable, resulting in quantum coherence generation between 1⟩ and 2⟩ even without external driving.

The paper presents an optimized protocol capable of extracting the maximal extractable work (MEW), measured by the free energy difference (FED), from quantum coherence in a single-shot thermodynamic cycle. The results highlight the thermodynamic advantages of long-lived coherence in a three-level quantum system and could influence future designs of coherence-driven quantum thermal machines.

The paper confirms that even if the three-level system is prepared on the ground level, the final l1-norm of quantum coherence is nonzero determined by the KMS temperature of the bath and the energy level of the excited states.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Quantum resource utilization for energy extraction: The AI system can be designed to function as a quantum heat engine by utilizing long-lived quantum coherence as fuel, specifically by implementing Protocol 1 or Protocol 2 to convert this coherence into practical work.

  2. Coherence-to-asymmetry conversion: The system can perform energy-preserving unitary operations, such as the unitary operator U described in Section III.2, to transform persistent quantum coherence between degenerate levels into population asymmetry, which is a required step for work extraction.

  3. Single-shot maximal work extraction: The AI can execute Protocol 2 to extract the maximal extractable work (MEW) in a single thermodynamic cycle by exhaustively converting the available free energy difference, including quantum coherence, into practical work.

  4. Adaptive level shifting for optimization: The system can dynamically adjust excited state energies, as described in Protocol 2 Step 2 and Step 3, to fine-tune the final state and maximize extracted work according to the condition on optimal omega 1 and omega 2.

Abstract

We analyze work-extraction protocols using the long-lived quantum coherence of a three-level quantum system coupled to a thermal bath. We identify conditions under which persistent quantum coherence can arise, i.e., for systems with degenerate excited states and aligned transition dipoles, or for nearly degenerate systems with small energy splittings. By proposing two thermodynamic protocols that employ energy-preserving unitary operations, we show that quantum coherence can be converted into population asymmetry, thereby serving as a quantum resource for work extraction. Specifically, we propose an optimized protocol to extract the maximum extractable work (MEW), measured by the free energy difference (FED), from quantum coherence in a single-shot thermodynamic cycle. Our results highlight the thermodynamic advantages of long-lived coherence in a three-level quantum system and could influence future designs of coherence-driven quantum thermal machines.

Sources

Related papers